Induction of tolerance across major barriers using a two-step method with genetic analysis of tolerance induction

A Review of Cyclophosphamide-Induced Transplantation Tolerance in Mice and Its Relationship With the HLA-Haploidentical Bone Marrow Transplantation/Post-Transplantation Cyclophosphamide Platform

The bone marrow transplantation (BMT) between haplo-identical combinations (haploBMT) could cause unacceptable bone marrow graft rejection and graft-versus-host disease (GVHD). To cross such barriers, Johns Hopkins platform consisting of haploBMT followed by post-transplantation (PT) cyclophosphamide (Cy) has been used. Although the central mechanism of the Johns Hopkins regimen is Cy-induced tolerance with bone marrow cells (BMC) followed by Cy on days 3 and 4, the mechanisms of Cy-induced tolerance may not be well understood. Here, I review our studies in pursuing skin-tolerance from minor histocompatibility (H) antigen disparity to xenogeneic antigen disparity through fully allogeneic antigen disparity. To overcome fully allogeneic antigen barriers or xenogeneic barriers for skin grafting, pretreatment of the recipients with monoclonal antibodies (mAb) against T cells before cell injection was required. In the cells-followed-by-Cy system providing successful skin tolerance, five mechanisms were identified using the correlation between super-antigens and T-cell receptor (TCR) Vβ segments mainly in the H-2-identical murine combinations. Those consist of: 1) clonal destruction of antigen-stimulated-thus-proliferating mature T cells with Cy; 2) peripheral clonal deletion associated with immediate peripheral chimerism; 3) intrathymic clonal deletion associated with intrathymic chimerism; 4) delayed generation of suppressor T (Ts) cells; and 5) delayed generation of clonal anergy. These five mechanisms are insufficient to induce tolerance when the donor-recipient combinations are disparate in MHC antigens plus minor H antigens as is seen in haploBMT. Clonal destruction is incomplete when the antigenic disparity is too strong to establish intrathymic mixed chimerism. Although this incomplete clonal destruction leaves the less-proliferative, antigen-stimulated T cells behind, these cells may confer graft-versus-leukemia (GVL) effects after haploBMT/PTCy.

Mechanisms of Graft-versus-Host Disease Prevention by Post-transplantation Cyclophosphamide: An Evolving Understanding

Post-transplantation cyclophosphamide (PTCy) has been highly successful at preventing severe acute and chronic graft-versus-host disease (GVHD) after allogeneic hematopoietic cell transplantation (HCT). The clinical application of this approach was based on extensive studies in major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-matched murine skin allografting models, in which cyclophosphamide was believed to act via three main mechanisms: (1) selective elimination of alloreactive T cells; (2) intrathymic clonal deletion of alloreactive T-cell precursors; and (3) induction of suppressor T cells. In these models, cyclophosphamide was only effective in very specific contexts, requiring particular cell dose, cell source, PTCy dose, and recipient age. Achievement of transient mixed chimerism also was required. Furthermore, these studies showed differences in the impact of cyclophosphamide on transplanted cells (tumor) versus tissue (skin grafts), including the ability of cyclophosphamide to prevent rejection of the former but not the latter after MHC-mismatched transplants. Yet, clinically PTCy has demonstrated efficacy in MHC-matched or partially-MHC-mismatched HCT across a wide array of patients and HCT platforms. Importantly, clinically significant acute GVHD occurs frequently after PTCy, inconsistent with alloreactive T-cell elimination, whereas PTCy is most active against severe acute GVHD and chronic GVHD. These differences between murine skin allografting and clinical HCT suggest that the above-mentioned mechanisms may not be responsible for GVHD prevention by PTCy. Indeed, recent work by our group in murine HCT has shown that PTCy does not eliminate alloreactive T cells nor is the thymus necessary for PTCy's efficacy. Instead, other mechanisms appear to be playing important roles, including: (1) reduction of alloreactive CD4⁺ effector T-cell proliferation; (2) induced functional impairment of surviving alloreactive CD4⁺ and CD8⁺ effector T cells; and (3) preferential recovery of CD4⁺ regulatory T cells. Herein, we review the history of cyclophosphamide's use in preventing murine skin allograft rejection and our evolving new understanding of the mechanisms underlying its efficacy in preventing GVHD after HCT. Efforts are ongoing to more fully refine and elaborate this proposed new working model. The completion of this effort will provide critical insight relevant for the rational design of novel approaches to improve outcomes for PTCy-treated patients and for the induction of tolerance in other clinical contexts.

Post-transplantation cyclophosphamide prevents graft-versus-host disease by inducing alloreactive T cell dysfunction and suppression

Post-transplantation cyclophosphamide (PTCy) recently has had a marked impact on human allogeneic hematopoietic cell transplantation (HCT). Yet, our understanding of how PTCy prevents graft-versus-host disease (GVHD) largely has been extrapolated from major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-matched murine skin allografting models that were highly contextual in their efficacy. Herein, we developed a T-cell-replete, MHC-haploidentical, murine HCT model (B6C3F1→B6D2F1) to test the putative underlying mechanisms: alloreactive T-cell elimination, alloreactive T-cell intrathymic clonal deletion, and suppressor T-cell induction. In this model and confirmed in four others, PTCy did not eliminate alloreactive T cells identified using either specific Vβs or the 2C or 4C T-cell receptors. Furthermore, the thymus was not necessary for PTCy's efficacy. Rather, PTCy induced alloreactive T-cell functional impairment which was supported by highly active suppressive mechanisms established within one day after PTCy that were sufficient to prevent new donor T cells from causing GVHD. These suppressive mechanisms included the rapid, preferential recovery of CD4+CD25+Foxp3+ regulatory T cells, including those that were alloantigen-specific, which served an increasingly critical function over time. Our results prompt a paradigm-shift in our mechanistic understanding of PTCy. These results have direct clinical implications for understanding tolerance induction and for rationally developing novel strategies to improve patient outcomes.

Induction of Major Histocompatibility Complex-mismatched Mouse Lung Allograft Acceptance With Combined Donor Bone Marrow: Lung Transplant Using a 12-Hour Nonmyeloablative Conditioning Regimen

BACKGROUND

Despite broad and intense conventional immunosuppression, long-term survival after lung transplantation lags behind that for other solid organ transplants, primarily because of allograft rejection. Therefore, new strategies to promote lung allograft acceptance are urgently needed. The purpose of the present study was to induce allograft tolerance with a protocol compatible with deceased donor organ utilization.

METHODS

Using the major histocompatibility complex-mismatched mouse orthotopic lung transplant model, we investigated a conditioning regimen consisting of pretransplant T cell depletion, low-dose total body irradiation and posttransplant (donor) bone marrow, and splenocyte infusion followed by posttransplantation cyclophosphamide.

RESULTS

Our results show that C57BL/6 recipients of BALB/c lung allografts undergoing this complete short-duration nonmyeloablative conditioning regimen had durable lung allograft acceptance. Mice that lacked 1 or more components of this regimen exhibited significant graft loss. Mechanistically, animals with lung allograft acceptance had established higher levels of donor chimerism, lymphocyte responses which were attenuated to donor antigens but maintained to third-party antigens, and clonal deletion of donor-reactive host Vβ T cells. Frequencies of Foxp3 T regulatory cells were comparable in both surviving and rejected allografts implying that their perturbation was not a dominant cell-regulatory mechanism. Donor chimerism was indispensable for sustained tolerance, as evidenced by acute rejection of allografts in established chimeric recipients of posttransplantation cyclophosphamide after a chimerism-ablating secondary recipient lymphocyte infusion.

CONCLUSIONS

Together, these data provide proof-of-concept for establishing lung allograft tolerance with tandem donor bone marrow transplantation using a short-duration nonmyeloablative conditioning regimen and posttransplant cyclophosphamide.

Targeted bone marrow radioablation with 153Samarium-lexidronam promotes allogeneic hematopoietic chimerism and donor-specific immunologic hyporesponsiveness

BACKGROUND

Transplantation tolerance, defined as acceptance of a graft by an otherwise fully immunocompetent host, has been an elusive goal. Although robust tolerance has been achieved by the induction of stable hematopoietic chimerism after bone marrow transplantation, lethal or sublethal radiation conditioning used to induce long-term chimerism precludes its clinical use. We studied whether targeted delivery of radiation to bone marrow could allow for bone marrow cell (BMC) engraftment, chimerism, and donor-specific tolerance in the absence of the side effects associated with external irradiation.

METHODS

We administered a radioactive bone-seeking compound (Samarium-Lexidronam, Quadramet, Berlex Laboratories, Wayne, NJ) together with transient T-cell costimulatory blockade to recipient mice. Allogeneic BMCs were given 7 or 14 days after preconditioning. Costimulatory blockade was obtained by the use of an anti-CD154 antibody for 4 weeks. Chimerism was assessed by flow cytometry. Mice then received donor-specific and third-party skin grafts. Graft survival was analyzed with mechanisms of donor-specific hyporesponsiveness.

RESULTS

High levels of stable chimerism across an allogeneic barrier were achieved in mice by a single administration of Samarium-Lexidronam, transient T-cell costimulatory blockade, and BMC transplantation. A large percentage of chimeric animals retained donor-derived skin grafts for more than 120 days without requiring additional immunosuppression, suggesting that harsh cytotoxic preconditioning is not necessary to achieve stable chimerism and donor specific hyporesponsiveness. Analysis of the T-cell repertoire in chimeras indicates T-cell deletional mechanisms.

CONCLUSIONS

These data broaden the potential use of BMC transplantation for tolerance induction and argue for its potential in treating autoimmune diseases.

Fractionated dosing of cyclophosphamide for establishing long-lasting skin allograft survival, stable mixed chimerism, and intrathymic clonal deletion in mice primed with allogeneic spleen cells

BACKGROUND

Injection of allo-spleen cells (SC) followed by a single dose of cyclophosphamide (CP) can induce tolerance of tumor and/or skin allografts in mice. To minimize the damage caused by CP, fractionation of CP that can establish long-lasting skin graft survival, stable mixed chimerism, and intrathymic clonal deletion in the host was investigated in the present study.

METHODS

Allo-SC (10(8)) were given intravenously on day 0. CP at 200 mg/kg was given intraperitoneally on day 2 in a single dose (CP 200x1 group). CP at 100, 66, 50, 40, and 33 mg/kg was given daily from day 1 through days 2, 3, 4, 5 and 6, respectively, in the fractionated doses (CP 100x2, 66x3, 50x4, 40x5, and 33x6 groups; total dose=200 mg/kg). Allografting was performed on day 14.

RESULTS

In a fully allogeneic combination of C57BL/6 (H2b)-->AKR (H2k, Mls-1a), an EL-4 tumor (H2b) was specifically accepted to kill the AKR mice in all of the SC+CP 200x1, 100x2, 66x3, 50x4, 40x5, and 33x6 groups (n=6), but C57BL/6 skin graft survival was not prolonged in any of the tumor-tolerant groups. In an H2-identical combination of AKR-->C3H (H2k, Mls-1b), AKR skin graft survival was prolonged remarkably (80-90 days) in the SC+CP 200x1, 100x2, and 66x3 groups (n=5-11), but was prolonged moderately (20-60 days) in the SC+CP 50x4 and 40x5 groups. In both of the SC+CP 200x1 and 66x3 groups in the AKR-->C3H combination, mixed chimerism was maintained for as long as 100 days after tolerance induction in both the spleen and thymus, associated with intrathymic clonal deletion of Vbeta6+ T cells. The decreases in leukocyte count, hemoglobin level, spleen weight, SC count, and body weight were significantly smaller in the SC+CP 66x3 group than in the SC+CP 200x1 group.

CONCLUSIONS

Fractionated CP is effective in ameliorating the compromised state induced by a single dose of CP. To induce a long-lasting skin allograft survival associated with stable mixed chimerism and intrathymic clonal deletion in an H2-identical combination, 200 mg/kg of CP can be divided into three or fewer fractions.

Cyclophosphamide-induced immunological tolerance: an overview

A cyclophosphamide (CP)-induced tolerance system in mice that primarily consists of donor cell injection followed by CP-treatment was found useful for inducing a long-lasting allo- or xeno-tolerance to various solid organs. In the cells-followed-by-CP system, the sequential mechanisms of tolerance were clarified using the specific correlation between superantigens and certain T cell receptor (TCR) V beta segments. Those include the clonal destruction of antigen-stimulated mature T cells, the peripheral clonal deletion associated with peripheral chimerism, the intrathymic clonal deletion associated with intrathymic chimerism, and the clonal anergy. The generation of suppressor T cells was another important mechanism of tolerance in the late stage. Special care was taken to overcome the " hard" barriers of allo- or xeno-combinations by reducing the "split tolerance" produced through the clonal destruction mechanism. For this purpose, the tolerogen, antimitotic drugs, their doses, timing, route of administration, combined immunosuppressants, and supportive treatment were all crucial for successful induction of a long-lasting skin tolerance. This system may be applicable to human transplantation.

Donor-specific prolongation of rat skin graft survival induced by rat-donor cells and cyclophosphamide under coadministration of monoclonal antibodies against T cell receptor alpha beta and natural killer cells in mice

Because of the recent interest in human xenotransplantation, we investigated the possibility of inducing tolerance in a xenogeneic combination using cyclophosphamide (CP). Donor-specific prolongation of xenogeneic Fisher 344 (F344) rat skin graft survival for up to 60 days was induced in C57BL/6 (B6) mice by giving F344 bone marrow cells and spleen cells on day 0, CP on day 2, and monoclonal antibodies against murine TCR-alpha beta and NK1.1 on days--1 and 3. The inoculation of the xenogeneic cells brought accelerated repopulation of TCR-alpha beta+ T cells, even under the administration of anti-TCR-alpha beta mAb. The quick increase of the host TCR-alpha beta+ T cells caused by the xenogeneic cell injection was deeply suppressed by CP. Mixed lymphocyte reaction, CTL activity, and antibody production against donor F344 were profoundly suppressed for 50 days. Mixed xenogeneic chimerism was observed for 1 month after the inoculation of donor cells in the spleen and peripheral blood of the recipient B6 mice, but was never observed in the thymus. Moreover, when irradiated F344 cells were used in place of viable cells, chimerism was never detected and graft survival was only slightly prolonged. Clonal deletion of V beta 5- or V beta 11-bearing murine T cells was not observed on day 50 in the thymus or spleen of the recipient B6 mice. These results suggest that treatment with viable xenogeneic donor cells, CP, and mAbs against T and NK cells can induce a temporary peripheral mixed chimerism and donor-specific prolongation of xenogeneic skin graft survival. The destruction with CP of T and B cells that are xenoreactive and thus proliferating after antigen stimulation, followed by mechanism other than intrathymic clonal deletion, may be the mechanism of the hyporesponsiveness in the present system.

The requirement of intrathymic mixed chimerism and clonal deletion for a long-lasting skin allograft tolerance in cyclophosphamide-induced tolerance

Mechanisms of cyclophosphamide (CY)-induced tolerance were studied. When C3H/He Slc (C3H; H-2k, Mls-1b) mice were primed i.v. with 1 x 10(8) viable spleen cells from H-2-identical AKR/J Sea (AKR; H-2k, Mls-1a) mice and treated with 200 mg/kg of CY 2 days later, a long-lasting skin allograft tolerance to AKR was established. When [C57BL/6 Sea (B6; H-2b, Mls-1b) x AKR]F1 (B6AKF1) cells were used as the tolerogen, however, only a moderate, but not long-lasting, skin tolerance to AKR was observed. In the C3H mice treated with AKR cells and CY, the intrathymic clonal deletion of V beta 6+ T cells, which are strongly correlated with reactivity to Mls-1a antigens, was observed in the chimeric thymus on day 35, although neither the clonal deletion of V beta 6-bearing T cells nor the mixed chimerism was observed in the thymus on day 14. In the C3H mice treated with B6AFKF1 cells followed by CY, however, neither the clonal deletion of V beta 6+ T cells nor the mixed chimerism was observed in the thymus throughout the test period. In the lymph nodes of the C3H mice treated with AKR cells and CY, only CD4+ V beta 6+ T cells, bur not CD8+V beta 6+ T cells, had selectively decreased by day 14, and they were hardly detectable on day 35. The selective decrease of CD4+V beta 6+ T cells in the lymph nodes was also observed by day 14 when B6AKF1 cells were used as the tolerogen, although CD4+V beta 6+ T cells gradually increased on day 35, at which time almost all skin grafts from AKR had already been rejected. These results strongly support the necessity of the intrathymic mixed chimerism and clonal deletion of donor-reactive T cells for a long-lasting skin allograft tolerance in CY-induced tolerance.