[Can US-guided vacuum-assisted biopsies be an alternative to diagnostic surgery in cases of non-diagnostic core needle biopsy?]

[Benign proliferative breast disease with and without atypia]

In the last few years, diagnostics of high-risk breast lesions (atypical ductal hyperplasia [ADH], flat epithelial atypia [FEA], lobular neoplasia: atypical lobular hyperplasia [ALH], lobular carcinoma in situ [LCIS], radial scar [RS], usual ductal hyperplasia [UDH], adenosis, sclerosing adenosis [SA], papillary breast lesions, mucocele-like lesion [MLL]) have increased with the growing number of breast percutaneous biopsies. The management of these lesions is highly conditioned by the enlarged risk of breast cancer combined with either an increased probability of finding cancer after surgery, either a possible malignant transformation (in situ or invasive cancer), or an increased probability of developing cancer on the long range. An overview of the literature reports grade C recommendations concerning the management and follow-up of these lesions: in case of ADH, FEA, ALH, LCIS, RS, MLL with atypia, diagnosed on percutaneous biopsies: surgical excision is recommended; in case of a diagnostic based on vacuum-assisted core biopsy with complete disappearance of radiological signal for FEA or RS without atypia: surgical abstention is a valid alternative approved by multidisciplinary meeting. In case of ALH (incidental finding) associated with benign lesion responsible of radiological signal: abstention may be proposed; in case of UDH, adenosis, MLL without atypia, diagnosed on percutaneous biopsies: the concordance of radiology and histopathology findings must be ensured. No data is available to recommend surgery; in case of non-in sano resection for ADH, FEA, ALH, LCIS (except pleomorphic type), RS, MLL: surgery does not seem to be necessary; in case of previous ADH, ALH, LCIS: a specific follow-up is recommended in accordance with HAS's recommendations. In case of FEA and RS or MLL combined with atypia, little data are yet available to differ the management from others lesions with atypia; in case of UDH, usual sclerosing adenosis, RS without atypia, fibro cystic disease: no specific follow-up is recommended in agreement with HAS's recommendations.

Malignancy rates after surgical excision of discordant breast biopsies

BACKGROUND

Vacuum-assisted core-needle biopsy (VAB) is increasingly used to perform breast biopsies instead of automated-gun core-needle biopsy (CNB). The significance of discordance between radiologic and pathologic findings has not been well established in the era of VAB predominance. This retrospective study was conducted to determine the rate of malignancy after surgical excisional biopsy (EXB) of these lesions at our two institutions.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We reviewed medical records from January 2008-June 2013 to identify female patients who underwent EXB for a Breast Imaging-Reporting and Data System (BI-RADS) 4 or 5 lesions found to be benign and discordant on CNB. Clinicopathologic data were gathered, and analysis was performed using descriptive statistics.

RESULTS

A total of 8081 core biopsies were performed in the study timeframe. Six of 81 (7.4%) patients who had an EXB for a benign discordant breast lesion were found to have malignant pathology (two invasive, four in situ). Four of 63 (6.3%) lesions originally biopsied by VAB were upgraded, compared with 2 of 17 (11.8%) originally biopsied by CNB. There were no statistically significant differences in the rates of upgrade to malignancy when data were stratified by BI-RADS score or method of biopsy.

CONCLUSIONS

The overall rate of malignancy after EXB of benign discordant lesions was 7.4%. Despite the widespread adoption of VAB, EXB is still warranted for clarification of discordant radiologic-pathologic findings.

Ultrasound-guided vacuum-assisted core biopsy in the diagnosis and treatment of focal lesions of the breast - own experience

Introduction

Vacuum-assisted core biopsy (VACB) guided by ultrasound is a minimally invasive method used in diagnosis and treatment of breast focal lesions. Vacuum-assisted core biopsy is an interesting minimally invasive alternative to open surgical biopsy.

Aim

To assess the value of ultrasound-guided vacuum-assisted core biopsy in the diagnosis and treatment of breast focal lesions.

Material and methods

In the period 2009-2010, 397 ultrasound-guided vacuum-assisted core biopsies were performed. Mean age of the patients was 41.7 years (18-92 years), and size of the lesions ranged from 3 mm to 65 mm, mean size being 12 mm. All women with diagnosed atypical ductal hyperplasia or cancer were qualified for surgery. The patients with histopathologically benign lesions were under follow-up.

Results

Samples sufficient for histopathological examination were obtained from 394 cases (99.2%). Of all 397 lesions, 293 (73.7%) were diagnosed as benign, there were 6 (1.6%) cases of atypical ductal hyperplasia and 98 (24.7%) malignant lesions. Three hundred and sixty-nine lesions were below 15 mm in diameter, of which 339 (91.9%) were totally removed during the VACB.

Conclusions

The results obtained confirm high efficiency of ultrasound-guided VACB in the differential diagnosis of breast focal lesions, including impalpable ones. It is a safe method with a low complication rate. In the case of benign lesions with a diameter not exceeding 15 mm, it allows one to excise the whole lesion and is a very good alternative to an open surgical biopsy. Vacuum-assisted core biopsy should be a standard and the method of choice in diagnosing breast lesions.

Ultrasound-guided diagnostic breast biopsy methodology: retrospective comparison of the 8-gauge vacuum-assisted biopsy approach versus the spring-loaded 14-gauge core biopsy approach

Background

Ultrasound-guided diagnostic breast biopsy technology represents the current standard of care for the evaluation of indeterminate and suspicious lesions seen on diagnostic breast ultrasound. Yet, there remains much debate as to which particular method of ultrasound-guided diagnostic breast biopsy provides the most accurate and optimal diagnostic information. The aim of the current study was to compare and contrast the 8-gauge vacuum-assisted biopsy approach and the spring-loaded 14-gauge core biopsy approach.

Methods

A retrospective analysis was done of all ultrasound-guided diagnostic breast biopsy procedures performed by either the 8-gauge vacuum-assisted biopsy approach or the spring-loaded 14-gauge core biopsy approach by a single surgeon from July 2001 through June 2009.

Results

Among 1443 ultrasound-guided diagnostic breast biopsy procedures performed, 724 (50.2%) were by the 8-gauge vacuum-assisted biopsy technique and 719 (49.8%) were by the spring-loaded 14-gauge core biopsy technique. The total number of false negative cases (i.e., benign findings instead of invasive breast carcinoma) was significantly greater (P = 0.008) in the spring-loaded 14-gauge core biopsy group (8/681, 1.2%) as compared to in the 8-gauge vacuum-assisted biopsy group (0/652, 0%), with an overall false negative rate of 2.1% (8/386) for the spring-loaded 14-gauge core biopsy group as compared to 0% (0/148) for the 8-gauge vacuum-assisted biopsy group. Significantly more (P < 0.001) patients in the spring-loaded 14-gauge core biopsy group (81/719, 11.3%) than in the 8-gauge vacuum-assisted biopsy group (18/724, 2.5%) were recommended for further diagnostic surgical removal of additional tissue from the same anatomical site of the affected breast in an immediate fashion for indeterminate/inconclusive findings seen on the original ultrasound-guided diagnostic breast biopsy procedure. Significantly more (P < 0.001) patients in the spring-loaded 14-gauge core biopsy group (54/719, 7.5%) than in the 8-gauge vacuum-assisted biopsy group (9/724, 1.2%) personally requested further diagnostic surgical removal of additional tissue from the same anatomical site of the affected breast in an immediate fashion for a benign finding seen on the original ultrasound-guided diagnostic breast biopsy procedure.

Conclusions

In appropriately selected cases, the 8-gauge vacuum-assisted biopsy approach appears to be advantageous to the spring-loaded 14-gauge core biopsy approach for providing the most accurate and optimal diagnostic information.

[Benign papilloma: is US-guided vacuum-assisted breast biopsy an alternative to surgical biopsy?]

The purpose of this study is to assess the value of US guided vacuum-assisted breast biopsy compared to surgery for management of intraductal papilloma. This retrospective study included 13 patients with hypoechoic nodular lesion corresponding to small benign intraductal papillomas on biopsy and visible by US. The lesions were removed using US-guided vacuum-assisted biopsy and all tissue material was reviewed at histology. The mean size of papillomas was 9.3 mm (5-16 mm). Vacuum-assisted tumor removal was considered total for all 13 lesions. Maximum follow-up was 57 months. Two patients had tumor recurrence at 22 and 28 months respectively. In one case, atypical ductal hyperplasia was present at the periphery of the papilloma, requiring complementary surgery. US-guided vacuum-assisted excision of small benign tumors such as solitary intraductal papillomas appears to be an alternative to surgical biopsy. Because of the large volume of tissue removed, total tumor excision is possible allowing detection of incidental associated lesions.

The utilization of an ultrasound-guided 8-gauge vacuum-assisted breast biopsy system as an innovative approach to accomplishing complete eradication of multiple bilateral breast fibroadenomas

Background

Ultrasound-guided vacuum-assisted breast biopsy technology is extremely useful for diagnostic biopsy of suspicious breast lesions and for attempted complete excision of appropriately selected presumed benign breast lesions.

Case presentation

A female patient presented with 16 breast lesions (eight within each breast), documented on ultrasound and all presumed to be fibroadenomas. Over a ten and one-half month period of time, 14 of these 16 breast lesions were removed under ultrasound guidance during a total of 11 separate 8-gauge Mammotome^® excision procedures performed during seven separate sessions. Additionally, two of these 16 breast lesions were removed by open surgical excision. A histopathologic diagnosis of fibroadenoma and/or fibroadenomatous changes was confirmed at all lesion excision sites. Interval follow-up ultrasound imaging revealed no evidence of a residual lesion at the site of any of the 16 original breast lesions.

Conclusion

This report describes an innovative approach of utilizing ultrasound-guided 8-gauge vacuum-assisted breast biopsy technology for assisting in achieving complete eradication of multiple bilateral fibroadenomas in a patient who presented with 16 documented breast lesions. As such, this innovative approach is highly recommended in similar appropriately selected patients.

A comprehensive evaluation of the 8-gauge vacuum-assisted Mammotome(R) system for ultrasound-guided diagnostic biopsy and selective excision of breast lesions

Background

Minimally invasive breast biopsy technology is now considered a standard of care for the diagnostic evaluation of suspicious breast lesions. The aim of the current study was to present a comprehensive evaluation of the 8-gauge vacuum-assisted Mammotome^® system for ultrasound-guided diagnostic biopsy and selective excision of breast lesions.

Methods

A retrospective analysis was conducted of a series of 304 consecutive 8-gauge Mammotome^® procedures that were performed under ultrasound guidance by a single surgeon from March 2004 to December 2006. Multiple variables, including patient demographics, characteristics of the breast lesion (based on ultrasound and mammography), procedural and histopathology variables, and interval follow-up variables (based on ultrasound and mammography), were evaluated.

Results

Among 304 procedures, 235 (77%) were performed with the presumption of complete excision of the ultrasound lesion during Mammotome^® core acquisition, while 69 (23%) were performed with only partial excision of the ultrasound lesion during Mammotome^® core acquisition (diagnostic tissue sampling only). 100% of all ultrasound lesions were accurately diagnosed, demonstrating no apparent false-negative results among the 256 patients that were compliant with follow-up at a median interval follow-up duration of 11 months (range 1 to 37). Likewise, 89% of all appropriately selected ultrasound lesions were completely excised, as demonstrated on interval follow-up ultrasound at a median time of 6 months (range, 3 to 16). There were no independent predictors of successful complete excision of any given appropriately selected ultrasound lesion by the ultrasound-guided 8-gauge Mammotome^® biopsy technique.

Conclusion

The 8-gauge vacuum-assisted Mammotome^® system is highly accurate for ultrasound-guided diagnostic biopsy of suspicious breast lesions and is highly successful for complete excision of appropriately selected presumed benign breast lesions. This particular technology should be routinely offered to all appropriately selected patients that are evaluated by physicians involved in breast-specific health care.

[Value of vacuum assisted biopsies under sonography guidance: results from a multicentric study of 650 lesions]

OBJECTIVE

With this retrospective, multi-centric study, the authors are showing the technique of Vacuum assisted biopsies under ultrasound guidance and comparing it with the other widely used diagnostic techniques. Material and method. Six hundred and fifty biopsies were performed between May 2000 and December 2004, on 644 patients, in 3 centres, following a unique protocol. Lesions were categorized, using the classification from Stavros, between "probably benign", "indeterminate", "probably malignant" and "malignant" Histology was validated only after review of the clinical and radiological data, as well as surgical data when available. All benign cases were included in an on-going follow-up protocol.

RESULTS

We have identified 471 benign lesions and 179 malignant lesions. The mean size of the lesions was 9 mm. Three cancers were diagnosed in the cases of "probably benign lesions" and in the cases of "probably malignant lesions" 18 (27%) were inflammatory disorders. In 5 cases vacuum biopsy underestimated the pathology with regard to surgery: 2 cases of atypical duct hyperplasia (HCA) were in situ ductal carcinoma (DCIS) at surgery and 3 cases of DCIS were infiltrative ductal carcinoma (DCI) at surgery. With this technique we have avoided surgery for 71% of all women who presented an "indeterminate" or "probably malignant" condition. Specificity is excellent with no cancer detected so far among the patients with benign findings, under follow-up.

CONCLUSION

Ultrasound guided Vacuum assisted biopsy is a fairly recent minimally invasive technique, with short learning curve. The ability to collect a larger volume of tissue overcomes the targeting issues on small lesions and avoids underestimation of heterogeneous and larger abnormalities and some specific at-risk lesions such as papilloma. This technique thus appears indicated in such cases because it overcomes some of the limitations of core needle biopsy and should be considered as an alternative to surgical biopsy.

Les tumeurs papillaires non malignes du sein : quelle prise en charge après diagnostic percutané ?

PURPOSE

To assess the reliability of percutaneous breast biopsies in diagnosing and managing non malignant papillary lesions and determine if subsequent excision must be systematic. MATERIALS AND METHODS. Retrospective review of 2233 breast biopsies over a 43 months period (September 2001 to March 2005): sonographically guided core biopsies (n = 836), ultrasound (n = 346) or stereotactic (n:1051) guided vacuum biopsies. 86 non malignant papillary tumors were diagnosed (core biopsy:28, US:38 and stereotactic guided vacuum biopsy:20). A larger sample was systematic after core biopsy: lumpectomy (n = 19) or vacuum biopsy (n = 9). Surgical excision followed vacuum biopsy (n = 18) in case of atypia or sampling excision. Alternatively, yearly follow-up was advised (n = 40). Correlation with surgical findings (n = 37) or mammographic follow-up (n = 49) is presented. The influence of various factors on the risk of underestimation was analysed.

RESULTS

Surgical resection revealed an underestimation of 5/37 (13.5%): 4/19 with core- and 1/18 with vacuum-assisted biopsy corresponding to 4 low grade ductal carcinoma in situ and a microinvasive ductal carcinoma in situ. It was higher for core biopsies and related to age and size: higher when women<50 years and when radiological image>1 cm. The influence of the other factors was not significant. Of the 9 non operated papillomas after core biopsy, vacuum biopsy revealed an additional underestimation (low-grade ductal carcinoma in situ). Of the 49 papillary lesions that were not surgically biopsied, 40 were monitored at 2-42 months (average: 19 months). No carcinoma was detected during this follow-up.

CONCLUSION

Percutaneous biopsy is an accurate technique in managing papillary tumors. A larger histologic specimen is necessary after core biopsy. Vacuum biopsy is an attractive alternative to surgery for smaller papillomas (<1 cm), but in spite of nonsignificant results we advise subsequent excision in case of multiple papillomas, atypia or residual tumor.

[Ultrasound-guided vacuum-assisted biopsy: review of 382 cases]

PURPOSE

To evaluate the use of US-guided vacuum biopsy for diagnosis and treatment of probably benign breast masses.

MATERIALS AND METHOD

Retrospective review of 382 US guided vacuum biopsies over a 44 months period (september 2001 to may 2005) with the 11-g handheld mammotome. A total of 308 benign tumors, 59 borderline lesions and 15 carcinomas were diagnosed. The average number of specimens is 13.1 (3-37). Surgical resection has been systematic for carcinomas and selective for papillomas. Surgical correlation (n:35) or mammographic follow-up (n:347) are presented.

RESULTS

Complete removal occurred in 371/382 (97.1%) immediately after biopsy and 337/382 (88.2%) after one month: 138/142 (93.7%) for fibroadenomas and 52/53 (98.1%) papillomas less than 15 mm. Open surgical biopsy was carried out for 35 patients on the basis of incomplete removal (3 cases) or histologic findings (8 invasive carcinomas, 7 ductal carcinoma in situ, 3 atypical ductal hyperplasia, 1 fibrocystic changes with atypia and 11 papillomas). No lesion was under-diagnosed and the rate of avoided surgery was 94.5%. Of the 347 lesions that were not surgically biopsied (42 borderline lesions and 305 benign lesions), 337 were monitored at 1-43 months (average: 20 months, > or =24 months: 57 patients). Ten underwent additional biopsy but no missed cancer was detected. Patients tolerance was good or very good in 83%, and the complication rate was 1.3%.

CONCLUSION

US-guided vacuum biopsy is an accurate and well tolerated technique. It is an alternative to surgery for masses less than 15 mm including fibroadenomas and papillomas or in patients with imaging-histologic discordance at core biopsy.