Radiation Therapy: Results and Future Possibilities

Impact of extended lymphadenectomy on morbidity, mortality, recurrence and 5-year survival after gastrectomy for cancer. Meta-analysis of randomized clinical trials

PURPOSE

To compare morbidity, mortality, recurrence and 5-year survival between D1 and D2 or D3 for treatment of gastric cancer.

METHODS

Systematic review and meta-analysis of RCTs. Metaview in RevMan 4.2.8 for analysis; statistical heterogeneity by Cochran's Q test (P<0.1) and I(2) test (P>50%). Estimates of effect were calculated using random effects model.

RESULTS

D2 or D3 was associated with higher in-hospital mortality, with RR = 2.13, p=0.0004, 95% CI, 1.40 to 3.25, I(2)=0%, P=0.63; overall morbidity showed higher incidence in D2 or D3, RR = 1.98, p<0.00001, 95% CI, 1.64 to 2.38, I(2) = 33.9%, P=0.20; operating time showed longer duration in D2 or D3, weighted mean difference of 1.05, p<0.00001, 95% CI, 0.71 to 1.38, I(2) = 78.7%, P=0.03, with significant statistical heterogeneity; reoperation showed higher rate in D2 or D3, with RR = 2.33, p<0.0001, 95% CI, 1.58 to 3.44, I(2) = 0%, P=0.99; hospital stay showed longer duration in the D2 or D3, with weighted mean difference of 4.72, p<0.00001, 95% CI, 3.80 to 5.65, I(2) = 89.9%, P<0.00001; recurrence was analyzed showed lower rate in D2 or D3, with RR = 0.89, p=0.02, 95% CI, 0.80 to 0.98, I(2) = 71.0%, P = 0.03, with significant statistical heterogeneity; mortality with recurrent disease showed higher incidence in D1, with RR = 0.88, p=0.04, 95% CI, 0.78 to 0.99, I(2) =51.8%, P=0.10; 5-year survival showed no significant difference, with RR = 1.05, p=0.40, 95% CI, 0.93 to 1.19, I(2) = 49.1% and P=0.12.

CONCLUSIONS

D2 or D3 lymphadenectomy procedure is followed by higher overall morbidity and higher in-hospital mortality; D2 or D3 lymphadenectomy shows lower incidence of recurrence and lower mortality with recurrent disease, when analysed altogether with statistical heterogeneity; D2 or D3 lymphadenectomy has no significant impact on 5-year survival.

Surgical treatment of gastric cancer. Proximal, mid, and distal stomach

At present, only radical surgical resection of gastric cancer offers a chance for cure. The objective of an operation for patients with disease that is confined locally is to maximize the potential for cure. The objective for patients with advanced incurable disease, obstruction, hemorrhage, and intractable pain is to provide the best palliation. The evaluation, staging, and surgical management of gastric cancer are described.

Postoperative adjuvant radiotherapy for adenocarcinoma of the rectum and rectosigmoid

One hundred five patients treated with potentially curative surgery and adjuvant postoperative radiotherapy for adenocarcinoma of the rectum and rectosigmoid from 1973 through 1981 were reviewed. Radiation therapy was given with 18-25 MeV X rays in doses of 40-50 Gy in 5 weeks (midline dose) using AP-PA fields in 97 patients. A boost of 6 to 10 Gy was directed to the area of maximum risk by anterior-posterior or perineal fields in 71 patients. Local failure occurred in 15 patients and was documented pathologically in 8 patients, or clinically or radiologically in 7 patients. The local recurrences according to the Modified Astler-Coller staging criteria were: B1: 0% (0/3); B2: 4% (1/24); B3: 31% (4/13); C1: 8% (1/12); C2: 18% (8/45); C3: 20% (1/5). Local failure after adjuvant radiotherapy versus surgery alone was compared. The comparison of local failure of combined treatment versus surgery alone, from our institution, is as follows: B2-4% vs 13%, B3-31% vs 26%, C2-18% vs 30%, and C3-20% vs 49%. Sixty-one patients (58.1%) have been followed for 5 years, with a median of 73 months and a minimum of 24 months. The actuarial 5-year survival (disease-free) for the entire group is 55% and is not statistically different for the groups with negative or positive nodes. Fourteen patients (13%) required surgery for small bowel complications; four others (4%) had symptomatic small bowel obstruction treated with conservative therapy only. Small bowel obstruction occurred in 4 of 16 (25%) treated with radiation fields above L5, whereas those treated below L5 had an 11% incidence. Postoperative adjuvant radiotherapy can increase local tumor control compared to surgery alone. The small bowel complication rate in this series most likely reflects AP-PA treatment technique and can be decreased by the use of multiple fields with maximum shielding of the small intestine.

R2/3 gastrectomy for gastric carcinoma: an audited experience of a consecutive series

A consecutive series of 27 patients with gastric neoplasm (24 carcinoma, 3 lymphoma) have been staged at laparotomy using the Japanese criteria for macroscopic staging. In 20 patients the radical R2/3 resection was considered potentially curative as defined by the Japanese Society for Research in Gastric Cancer. The operative mortality in this subgroup was 1/20 (5 per cent) and 3/27 (11 per cent) in the entire series. Locoregional recurrence was not observed in the potentially curative group. Follow-up has varied from 6 months to 7 years. An overall survival of 12/27 (48 per cent) has been observed to date. Death from cancer dissemination is maximal in the first and second year after resection. The R2/3 resection was considered non-curative in seven patients. In this subgroup there were two postoperative deaths and four have died of metastatic disease within 12 months of the resection. The only 5 year survivor in this group had a gastric lymphoma.

Adjuvant treatment of colorectal cancer. Current status and concepts

Colorectal cancer is the second leading cause of cancer mortality in the United States, causing approximately 50,000 deaths per year. The overall prognosis and results of treatment have not changed impressively over the last three decades. Half of all the patients who undergo curative surgery finally succumb to locoregional or metastatic recurrence of their disease. Recent clinical research has been aimed at adjuvant therapeutic measures to improve survival after curative surgical resection. For rectal cancer, combined postoperative chemotherapy and radiation therapy have been shown to reduce the overall relapse rate and improve disease-free survival. Further studies of adjuvant treatment for rectal cancer are needed to evaluate the optimal radiation schedule and limit the side-effects of the treatment. Adjuvant treatment of colon cancer must still be regarded as unsettled. Since liver metastases are the most common unfavorable outcome of colon cancer, ongoing trials using liver-directed treatment (perfusion, irradiation) should be followed with interest. The lack of proven efficacy and the side-effects of these treatments strongly favor the inclusion of an observation-only control group in trials for adjuvant treatment of colon cancer. Unfortunately, there is as yet no proven significant benefit from immunotherapy as an adjuvant therapy for colorectal cancer, but further basic and clinical studies will be of great interest in this field.

Dose-response relationship for radiation therapy of recurrent, residual, and primarily inoperable colorectal cancer

One hundred and thirteen patients with advanced locoregional recurrent (77), residual (18) or primarily inoperable (18) colorectal carcinoma were treated with radiotherapy. Eighty-five patients had locoregional disease only and 28 had both local disease and distant metastases. The treatment was given with varying dose levels (23-73 Gy) in daily fractions of approximately 2 Gy in 3-8 weeks. This dose variation allowed an evaluation of the dose-response relationship for radiation treatment of this tumour. A good subjective response was obtained in 63%. This effect showed no dose-response relationship except for doses greater than or equal to 56 Gy, where all patients received relief of symptoms. Eighty-two per cent of evaluable patients achieved an objective response (PR 53%, CR 29%). The frequency and duration of the complete responses showed a marked dose-response relationship. Thus, at doses greater than or equal to 56 Gy, a 2-year actuarial complete response rate of 40% was found compared with 7, 4 and 0% at doses of 46-55 Gy, 36-45 Gy and less than or equal to 35 Gy, respectively. The dose-response relationship for local control also influenced the survival rate, although a number of patients died from distant metastases even when local control was obtained. However, with regard to locoregional disease, the 2-year survival was 53% for patients with complete tumour regression but only 8% for patients without complete tumour regression.

Adjuvant postoperative radiation therapy for colorectal carcinoma above the peritoneal reflection. II. Antimesenteric wall ascending and descending colon and cecum

From 1970 to 1981, 50 patients had curative surgery for carcinoma of the cecum, ascending, or descending colon and were Stage greater than or equal to B2. In 15 cases, the lesion originated on the antimesenteric (posterolateral) bowel wall. Of seven cases (with minimum three-year follow-up) not receiving adjuvant postoperative regional irradiation, four recurred in the tumor bed/abdominal wall versus 0/3 irradiated patients. Similarly, the five-year survival was improved in the irradiated group (2/3) versus only 2/9 in the unirradiated group. Patients with transmural extension of right or left colon cancers originating on the anti mesenteric (posterolateral) bowel wall may have a high incidence of postoperative regional failure which may be decreased by adjuvant postoperative regional irradiation.

Oesophogeal squamous cell carcinoms: II. A critical view of radiotherapy

There has been no controlled trial of radiotherapy versus surgery for squamous cell carcinoma of the oesophagus. Radiotherapy is generally used for those patients with extensive disease or those who are unfit for surgery. In spite of this, the 1-year survival of 18 per cent is similar to that for surgically treated patients and there is no equivalent operative mortality. The 5-year survival is 6 per cent compared with that for surgery of 4 per cent. There are no results available to suggest what would happen if a patient with a localized tumour, technically suitable for surgical resection, were treated instead by radiotherapy.

Prospective randomized trial of combined oncological therapy for gastric carcinoma

One hundred forty-two patients with all stages of gastric carcinoma were prospectively stratified into two divisions according to T.N.M. stage following, but irrespective of the type of surgical procedure. Division I (T1-3, N1-2, M0) was randomized into a control group, and a treatment group who received 2000 rad in 8 fractions over 10 days with intravenous 5 Fluorouracil (5 F.U.) at a dose of 500 mg daily x 4 days preirradiation and then 12.5 mg/kg daily for 5 days every 28 days for six courses. Division II (T4 or M1) was randomized into three groups; a control group, a group who received radiotherapy and 5 F.U. in the same schedule as division one and a group who received Thiotepa 45 mg intravenously daily for three days and then every 28 days for 6 months. Four and one-half years after commencement of the trial 86% of the patients had died. There was no difference in survival rate between the treatment and control groups, (p greater than 0.5) in Division I or II. Survival appeared to correlate with the T.N.M. stage of disease and not therapy. Blind assessment of the quality of life showed no difference between the treatment groups and the controls. In the dose schedules used, this form of oncological therapy had no effect on survival or quality of life in patients with gastric carcinoma.