Incorrect aminoacylations catalysed by E. coli valyl-tRNA synthetase

Identification in archaea of a novel D-Tyr-tRNATyr deacylase

Most bacteria and eukarya contain an enzyme capable of specifically hydrolyzing D-aminoacyl-tRNA. Here, the archaea Sulfolobus solfataricus is shown to also contain an enzyme activity capable of recycling misaminoacylated D-Tyr-tRNATyr. N-terminal sequencing of this enzyme identifies open reading frame SS02234 (dtd2), the product of which does not present any sequence homology with the known D-Tyr-tRNATyr deacylases of bacteria or eukaryotes. On the other hand, homologs of dtd2 occur in archaea and plants. The Pyrococcus abyssi dtd2 ortholog (PAB2349) was isolated. It rescues the sensitivity to D-tyrosine of a mutant Escherichia coli strain lacking dtd, the gene of its endogeneous D-Tyr-tRNATyr deacylase. Moreover, in vitro, the PAB2349 product, which behaves as a monomer and carries 2 mol of zinc/mol of protein, catalyzes the cleavage of D-Tyr-tRNATyr. The three-dimensional structure of the product of the Archaeoglobus fulgidus dtd2 ortholog has been recently solved by others through a structural genomics approach (Protein Data Bank code 1YQE). This structure does not resemble that of Escherichia coli D-Tyr-tRNATyr deacylase. Instead, it displays homology with that of a bacterial peptidyl-tRNA hydrolase. We show, however, that the archaeal PAB2349 enzyme does not act against diacetyl-Lys-tRNALys, a model substrate of peptidyl-tRNA hydrolase. Based on the Protein Data Bank 1YQE structure, site-directed mutagenesis experiments were undertaken to remove zinc from the PAB2349 enzyme. Several residues involved in zinc binding and supporting the activity of the deacylase were identified. Taken together, these observations suggest evolutionary links between the various hydrolases in charge of the recycling of metabolically inactive tRNAs during translation.

Specific tyrosylation of the bulky tRNA-like structure of brome mosaic virus RNA relies solely on identity nucleotides present in its amino acid-accepting domain

Residues specifying aminoacylation by yeast tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase (TyrRS) of the tRNA-like structure present at the 3'-end of brome mosaic virus (BMV) RNA were determined by the in vitro approach using phage T7 transcripts. They correspond to nucleotides equivalent to base-pair C1-G72 and discriminator base A73 in the amino acid-acceptor branch of the molecule. No functional equivalents of the tyrosine anticodon residues, shown to be weakly involved in tyrosine identity of canonical tRNA(Tyr), were found in the BMV tRNA-like structure. This indicates a behaviour of this large and intricate molecule reminiscent of that of a minihelix derived from an amino acid-acceptor branch. Furthermore, iodine footprinting experiments performed on a tyrosylable BMV RNA transcript of 196 nt complexed to yeast TyrRS indicate that the amino acid-acceptor branch of the viral RNA is protected against cleavages as well as a hairpin domain, which is possibly located perpendicularly to its accepting branch. This domain without the canonical anticodon loop or the tyrosine anticodon acts as an anchor for TyrRS interaction leading to a better efficiency of tyrosylation.

Transfer RNA identity rules and conformation of the tyrosine tRNA-like domain of BMV RNA imply additional charging by histidine and valine

This paper reports the first example of a triple aminoacylation specificity of a viral tRNA-like domain. These findings were based on structural studies on the brome mosaic virus (BMV) tRNA-like domain (Felden et al., 1994, J. Mol. Biol. 235, 508-531) together with knowledge on tRNA aminoacylation identity rules suggesting potential histidinylation and valylation capacities of the viral RNA in addition to its already known tyrosylation ability. Here, both predictions are demonstrated by in vitro aminoacylation assays. Kinetic parameters of histidinylation and valylation of BMV tRNA-like structure have been determined and compared to those of the corresponding tRNA transcripts and to the tyrosylation capacity of the molecule. The influence of experimental conditions on aminoacylation reactions was also studied. The novel aminoacylation capacities of BMV tRNA-like domain support its already reported three-dimensional fold and illustrate the predictive potential of modeling data. Biological necessity of specific or non specific aminoacylation will be discussed.

Efficient mischarging of a viral tRNA-like structure and aminoacylation of a minihelix containing a pseudoknot: histidinylation of turnip yellow mosaic virus RNA

Mischarging of the valine specific tRNA-like structure of turnip yellow mosaic virus (TYMV) RNA has been tested in the presence of purified arginyl-, aspartyl-, histidinyl-, and phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetases from bakers' yeast. Important mischarging of a 264 nucleotide-long transcript was found with histidinyl-tRNA synthetase which can acylate this fragment up to a level of 25% with a loss of specificity (expressed as Vmax/KM ratios) of only 100 fold as compared to a yeast tRNA(His) transcript. Experiments on transcripts of various lengths indicate that the minimal valylatable fragment (n = 88) is the most efficient substrate for histidinyl-tRNA synthetase, with kinetic characteristics similar to those found for the control tRNA(His) transcript. Mutations in the anticodon or adjacent to the 3' CCA that severely affect the valylation capacity of the 264 nucleotide long TYMV fragment are without negative effect on its mischarging, and for some cases even improve its efficiency. A short fragment (n = 42) of the viral RNA containing the pseudoknot and corresponding to the amino acid accepting branch of the molecule is an efficient histidine acceptor.

Conformation in solution of yeast tRNA(Asp) transcripts deprived of modified nucleotides

A synthetic gene of yeast aspartic acid tRNA with a promoter for phage T7 RNA polymerase was cloned in Escherichia coli. The in vitro transcribed tRNA(Asp) molecules are deprived of modified nucleotides and retain their aspartylation capacity. The solution conformation of these molecules was mapped with chemical structural probes and compared to that of fully modified molecules. Significant differences in reactivities were observed in Pb2+ cleavage of the RNAs and in modification of the bases with dimethyl sulphate. The most striking result concerns C56, which becomes reactive in unmodified tRNA(Asp), indicating the disruption of the C56-G19 base pair involved in the D- and T-loop interaction. The chemical data indicate that unmodified tRNA(Asp) transcripts possess a relaxed conformation compared to that of the native tRNA. This conclusion is confirmed by thermal melting experiments. Thus it can be proposed that post-transcriptional modifications of nucleotides in tRNA stabilize the biologically active conformations in these molecules.

Exploring the aminoacylation function of transfer RNA by macromolecular engineering approaches. Involvement of conformational features in the charging process of yeast tRNA(Asp)

This report presents the conceptual and methodological framework that presently underlies the experiments designed to decipher the structural features in tRNA important for its aminoacylation by aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases. It emphasizes the importance of conformational features in tRNA for an optimized aminoacylation. This is illustrated by selected examples on yeast tRNA(Asp). Using the phage T7 transcriptional system, a series of tRNA(Asp) variants were created in which conformational elements were modified. It is shown that aspartyl-tRNA synthetase tolerates conformational variability in tRNA(Asp) at the level of the D-loop and variable region, of the tertiary Levitt base-pair 15-48 which can be inverted and in the T-arm in which residue 49 can be excised. However, changing the anticodon region completely abolishes the aspartylation capacity of the variants. Transplanting the phenylalanine identity elements into a different tRNA(Asp) variant presenting conformational characteristics of tRNA(Phe) converts this molecule into a phenylalanine acceptor but is less efficient than wild-type tRNA(Phe). This engineered tRNA completely loses its aspartylation capacity, showing that some aspartic acid and phenylalanine identity determinants overlap. The fact that chimeric tRNA(Asp) molecules with altered anticodon regions lose their aspartylation capacity demonstrates that this region is part of the aspartic acid identity of tRNA(Asp).

tRNA anticodon replacement experiments show that ribosomal frameshifting can be caused by doublet decoding

The expression of certain normal genes requires a specific ribosomal frameshift event because the mRNA has the coding information for one protein in two different reading frames. One of several possible mechanisms for this involves recognition of a nontriplet codon by a noncognate tRNA. The AGUC-decoding Escherichia coli tRNASer3 reads a GCA alanine codon to cause a -1 frameshift. Replacement of the anticodon of tRNAPhe with the anticodon of tRNASer3 allows the constructed tRNA to cause this frameshifting. By altering the anticodon loop nucleotides at positions 33-36 in the constructed tRNAPhe molecules, the tRNA was found to recognize a 2-base codon. Instead of the usual anticodon, positions 34-36, the nucleotides in positions 34 and 35 form essential base pairs with the first two positions of the alanine codon. The uridine in position 36 is also required but not for base pairing.

Isoleucyl-tRNA synthetase from bakers' yeast: multistep proofreading in discrimination between isoleucine and valine with modulated accuracy, a scheme for molecular recognition by energy dissipation

For discrimination between isoleucine and valine by isoleucyl-tRNA synthetase from yeast, a multistep sequence is established. The initial discrimination of the substrates is followed by a pretransfer and a posttransfer hydrolytic proofreading process. The overall discrimination factor D was determined from kcat and Km values observed in aminoacylation of tRNAIle-C-C-A with isoleucine and valine. From aminoacylation of the modified tRNA species tRNAIle-C-C-3'dA and tRNAIle-C-C-A (3'NH2), the initial discrimination factor I (valid for the reversible substrate binding) and the proofreading factor P1 (valid for the aminoacyl adenylate formation) could be determined. Factor I was computed from ATP consumption and D1, the overall discrimination factor for this partial reaction which can be obtained from kinetic constants, and P1 was calculated from AMP formation rates. Proofreading factor P2 (valid for aminoacyl transfer reaction) was determined from AMP formation rates observed in aminoacylation of tRNAIle-C-C-A and tRNAIle-C-C-3'dA. From the initial discrimination factor I and the AMP formation rates, discrimination factor DAMP in aminoacylation of tRNAIle-C-C-A can be calculated. These values deviate by a factor II from factor D obtained by kinetics which may be due to the fact that for acylation of tRNAIle-C-C-A an initial discrimination factor I' = III is valid. The observed overall discrimination varies up to a factor of 16 according to conditions. Under optimal conditions, 38 000 correct aminoacyl-tRNAs are produced per 1 error while the energy of 5.5 ATPs is dissipated. With the determined energetic and molecular flows for the various steps of the enzymatic reaction, a coherent picture of this new type of "far away from equilibrium enzyme" emerges.

Isoleucyl-tRNA synthetase from bakers' yeast: variable discrimination between tRNAIle and tRNAVal and different pathways of cognate and noncognate aminoacylation under standard conditions, in the presence of pyrophosphatase, elongation factor Tu-GTP complex, and spermine

Error rates in discrimination between cognate tRNAIle and noncognate tRNAVal in the aminoacylation reaction with isoleucine catalyzed by isoleucyl-tRNA synthetase from yeast have been investigated in three sets of experiments under different assay conditions. The overall discrimination factor was first determined by isoleucylation of tRNAVal/tRNAIle mixtures. In the second set of experiments, the number of AMP molecules formed per Ile-tRNA in the cognate and noncognate reactions was measured. The higher AMP formation in the noncognate aminoacylation is assigned to a proofreading reaction step. The calculated proofreading factors and an estimated initial discrimination factor yield overall discriminations that are consistent with those obtained from the first set of experiments. In the third series of studies, the orders of substrate addition and product release of cognate and noncognate isoleucylation reactions were investigated by initial rate kinetic methods. From kcat and Km values, the overall discrimination factors were calculated and showed again a good coincidence with those observed in the preceding sets of experiments. Besides under standard assay conditions, aminoacylation reactions were studied in the presence of pyrophosphatase or elongation factor Tu-GTP complex, under addition of both these proteins, in presence of these two additional proteins and spermine at high and low magnesium concentrations, and under special conditions that favor misacylations. Furthermore, isoleucylation of tRNAIle was tested at increased and decreased pH in the standard enzyme assay. Variation of the assay conditions results in changing discrimination factors, which differ by a factor of about 10. Substitution of tRNAIle by tRNAVal in the isoleucylation reaction causes changes in substrate addition and product release orders and thus of the whole catalytic cycle. For aminoacylation of tRNAIle, four different orders of substrate addition and product release appear: the sequential ordered ter-ter, the rapid equilibrium sequential random ter-ter, the random bi-uni uni-bi ping-pong, and a bi-bi uni-uni ping-pong mechanism with a rapid equilibrium segment. tRNAVal is aminoacylated in rapid equilibrium random ter-ter order, in a bi-bi uni-uni ping-pong mechanism with a rapid equilibrium segment, and in two bi-uni uni-bi ping-pong mechanisms. It is assumed that the different assay conditions can be regarded as a stepwise approximation to physiological conditions and that considerable changes in error rates may be also possible in vivo up to 1 order of magnitude.

Structure of phenylalanine-accepting transfer ribonucleic acid and of its environment in aqueous solvents with different salts

Thermodynamic and structural parameters were measured for brewers' yeast tRNAPhe in solution in the range of 0.1-0.9 M monovalent salt (with and without 1 mM MgCl2), pH 7.0, by small-angle neutron scattering. Partial specific volumes and preferential interaction parameters were found to be similar to corresponding values measured by more conventional means in DNA [Eisenberg, H. (1981) Q. Rev. Biophys. 14, 141-172]. There is no evidence of a large conformational change in tRNAPhe in this range, and the molecule has a radius of gyration that is the same as that calculated from the crystal-structure coordinates (23 A). Transfer RNA in solution is made up of polyion tRNA76- and 76 positive monovalent ions (in absence of Mg2+). The data show the polyion to be surrounded by a shell of solvent that is significantly denser than bulk, whose structure depends on salt conditions. In 0.1 M NaCl, it has an excess mass of approximately 85 molecules of water. This would be accounted for, for example, by approximately 850 molecules of water if their density were 10% higher than that for bulk. The radius of gyration of the dense shell is approximately 30 A for NatRNA and approximately 35 A for KtRNA. The present study shows that the solvent around tRNA is a component of its structure that must be taken into account in understanding its function.

The complex formation between Escherichia coli aminoacyl-tRNA, elongation factor Tu and GTP. The effect of the side-chain of the amino acid linked to tRNA

The interaction between Escherichia coli aminoacyl-tRNAs and elongation factor Tu (EF-Tu) x GTP was examined. Ternary complex formation with Phe-tRNAPhe and Lys-tRNALys was compared to that with the respective misaminoacylated Tyr-tRNAPhe and Phe-tRNALys. There was no pronounced difference in the efficiency of aminoacyl-tRNA x EF-Tu x GTP complex formation between Phe-tRNAPhe and Tyr-tRNAPhe. However, Phe-tRNALys was bound preferentially to EF-Tu x GTP as compared to Lys-tRNALys. This was shown by the ability of EF-Tu x GTP to prevent the hydrolysis of the aminoacyl ester linkage of the aminoacyl-tRNA species. Furthermore, gel filtration of ternary complexes revealed that the complex formed with the misaminoacylated tRNALys was also more stable than the one formed with the correctly aminoacylated tRNALys. Both misaminoacylated aminoacyl-tRNA species could participate in the ribosomal peptide elongation reaction. Poly(U)-directed synthesis of poly(Tyr) using Tyr-tRNAPhe occurred to a comparable extent as the synthesis of poly(Phe) with Phe-tRNAPhe. In the translation of poly(A) using native Lys-tRNALys, poly(Lys) reached a lower level than poly(Phe) when Phe-tRNALys was used. It was concluded that the side-chain of the amino acid linked to a tRNA affects the efficiency of the aminoacyl-tRNA x EF-Tu x GTP ternary complex formation.

Aminoacylation of undermethylated mammalian transfer RNA

To study the role of 5-methylcytidine in the aminoacylation of mammalian tRNA, bulk tRNA specifically deficient in 5-methylcytidine was isolated from the livers of mice treated with 5-azacytidine (18 mg/kg) for 4 days. For comparison, more extensively altered tRNA was isolated from the livers of mice treated with DL-ethionine (100 mg/kg) plus adenine (48 mg/kg) for 3 days. The amino acid acceptor capacity of these tRNAs was determined by measuring the incorporation of one of eight different 14C-labeled amino acids or a mixture of 14C-labeled amino acids in homologous assays using a crude synthetase preparation isolated from untreated mice. The 5-methylcytidine-deficient tRNA incorporated each amino acid to the same extent as fully methylated tRNA. The tRNA from DL-ethionine-treated livers showed an overall decreased amino-acylation capacity for all amino acids tested. The 5-methylcytidine-deficient tRNA from DL-ethionine-treated mice were further characterized as substrates in homologous rate assays designed to determine the Km and V of the aminoacylation reaction using four individual 14C-labeled amino acids and a mixture of 14C-labeled amino acids. The Km and V of the reactions for all amino acids tested using 5-methylcytidine-deficient tRNA as substrate were essentially the same as for fully methylated tRNA. However, the Km and V were increased when liver tRNA from mice treated with DL-ethionine plus adenine was used as substrate in the rate reaction with [14C]lysine as label. Our results suggest that although extensively altered tRNA is a poorer substrate than control tRNA in both extent and rate of aminoacylation, 5-methylcytidine in mammalian tRNA is not involved in the recognition of the tRNA by the synthetase as measured by aminoacylation activity.

Interpretation of tRNA-mischarging kinetics

Incorrect tRNA aminoacylation reactions are characterized by very slow reaction rates and by the fact that in most cases they are incomplete. In a previous study some of us explained the incompleteness of the correct aminoacylation reactions of tRNA, which can be encountered under certain experimental conditions (for instance low enzyme concentration or high ionic strength) by an equilibrium between the aminoacylation and the deacylation reactions [J. Bonnet and J.P. Ebel (1972) Eur. J.Biochem. 31, 335-344]. In the present report we bring evidence that the incorrect valylation of yeast tRNAfMet by yeast valyl-tRNA synthetase studied under standard experimental conditions, can also be described by a kinetic rate law including the rate equations of the aminoacylation and of the various deacylation reactions. In particular we show that the incomplete mischarging plateaus reflect the existence of an equilibrium between the valylation reaction on the one hand and the spontaneous and enzymic deacylation of valyl-tRNAfMet and the reverse of the valylation reaction on the other hand. However, when the valyl-tRNA synthetase concentration is not very high the reverse reaction of the amino-acylation does not play a predominant part in the establishment of the plateau. These interpretations have been extended to other mischarging systems: valylation of yeast tRNAPhE by yeast valyl-tRNA synthetase and mischarging of tRNAfMet and tRNA2Val from yeast by yeast phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase. Unusual mischarging kinetics have been discussed. Furthermore, and as in correct systems, we found that during the mischarging of tRNAfMet one ATP is hydrolyzed per tRNA charged with valine. We conclude that the correct and the incorrect amino-acylation of tRNA behave kinetically in a similar way.

Phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase from baker's yeast. Salt dependence of steady-state kinetics indicates two molecular forms of the enzyme

Steady-state kinetic data of aminoacylation of tRNAPhe by phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase depend on salt concentration. At 5 mM KCl and 20 mM MgSO4 a non-linear curve is found in the double-reciprocal plot for ATP and phenylalanine, while at 200 mM KCl and 50 mM MgSO4 a linear curve is observed. KCl and MgSO4 dependence of the reaction also show biphasic curves with intersection points of the two extrapolated linear parts at 50 mM and 10 mM, respectively. A biphasic curve is also found if the concentration of CTP is varied at constant low ATP concentration. Extrapolations of the linear parts of the curves for ATP as well as for CTP at 5 mM KCl and 20 mM MgSO4 intersected the 1/[NTP] axis at 1.2 +/- 0.1 mM. Hence the existence of a non-linear curve for ATP as well as phenylalanine does not necessarily indicate two non-equivalent binding sites for these substrates. A more likely explanation is the existence of two different molecular forms of phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase which are interconvertible by salt. This explanation is substantiated by the observation that proteolytic digestion of phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase is more easily achieved at low than at medium ionic strength. In addition mischarging of tRNAIle with phenylalanine by phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase occurs at a moderate rate at 5 mM KCl and 20 mM MgSO4 whereas it is largely depressed by addition of either 5 mM CTP or 150 mM KCl.