Solvent effects within the CS INDO method. Geometrical distortion and solvatochromism of merocyanine dyes

Verdict: Time-Dependent Density Functional Theory "Not Guilty" of Large Errors for Cyanines

We assess the accuracy of eight Minnesota density functionals (M05 through M08-SO) and two others (PBE and PBE0) for the prediction of electronic excitation energies of a family of four cyanine dyes. We find that time-dependent density functional theory (TDDFT) with the five most recent of these functionals (from M06-HF through M08-SO) is able to predict excitation energies for cyanine dyes within 0.10-0.36 eV accuracy with respect to the most accurate available Quantum Monte Carlo calculations, providing a comparable accuracy to the latest generation of CASPT2 calculations, which have errors of 0.16-0.34 eV. Therefore previous conclusions that TDDFT cannot treat cyanine dyes reasonably accurately must be revised.

Solvent dependence of structure, charge distribution, and absorption spectrum in the photochromic merocyanine-spiropyran pair

We have studied the structures and absorption spectra of merocyanine, the photoresponsive isomer of the spiropyran (SP)-merocyanine (MC) pair, in chloroform and in water solvents using a combined hybrid QM/MM Car-Parrinello molecular dynamics (CP-QM/MM) and ZINDO approach. We report remarkable differences in the molecular structure and charge distribution of MC between the two solvents; the molecular structure of MC remains in neutral form in chloroform while it becomes charge-separated, zwitterionic, in water. The dipole moment of MC in water is about 50% larger than in chloroform, while the value for SP in water is in between, suggesting that the solvent is more influential than the conformation itself in deciding the dipole moment for the merocyanine-spiropyran pair. The calculations could reproduce the experimentally reported blue shift in the absorption spectra of MC when going from the nonpolar to the polar solvent, though the actual value of the absorption maximum is overestimated in chloroform solvent. We find that the CP-QM/MM approach is appropriate for structure modeling of solvatochromic and thermochromic molecules as this approach is able to capture the solvent and thermal-induced structural changes within the solute important for an accurate assessment of the properties.

Investigation of the UV/Visible Absorption Spectra of Merocyanine Dyes Using Time-Dependent Density Functional Theory

The visible spectral properties of a set of merocyanine dyes have been determined experimentally and compared to theoretical estimates calculated using time-dependent density functional theory. Three families of merocyanines have been investigated. The merocyanines of the first class contain the 4-thiazolidinone, 2-thioxo group in resonance with different donor groups. In the second family, they present a common pyrrolo[2,3-c]pyrazole-6-(2H)-acetic acid, the 4-[4-(dialkylamino)phenyl]-3,5-dihydro-3,5-dioxo-2-phenyl group with different substituents on the two phenyl rings, while in the third family, they are constituted of an isoxazolone group linked via a conjugated polyenic segment to an aminophenyl group. Two hybrid exchange-correlation functionals have been used, whereas solvent effects have been included using the integral equation formalism of the polarizable continuum model. Moreover, for one compound, the vibrational structure of the electronic transitions has been determined by calculating the Franck-Condon factors within the Born-Oppenheimer approximation. The calculations show that the dominant transitions present a pi-pi(*) character. This approach reproduces nicely the variations of excitation energies with the nature of the merocyanine so that least-squares fits can be used to correct for the major systematic errors of the computational scheme and to reach an accuracy of 0.09 eV or better. Part of these systematic errors is shown to originate from the description of the solvent effects, whereas vibronic effects can account for most of the remaining differences.