Tumor hypoxia--a confounding or exploitable factor in interstitial brachytherapy? Effects of tissue trauma in an experimental rat tumor model

Dose Rate Effects from the 1950s through to the Era of FLASH

Numerous dose rate effects have been described over the past 6-7 decades in the radiation biology and radiation oncology literature depending on the dose rate range being discussed. This review focuses on the impact and understanding of altering dose rates in the context of radiation therapy, but does not discuss dose rate effects as relevant to radiation protection. The review starts with a short historic review of early studies on dose rate effects, considers mechanisms thought to underlie dose rate dependencies, then discusses some current issues in clinical findings with altered dose rates, the importance of dose rate in brachytherapy, and the current timely topic of the use of very high dose rates, so-called FLASH radiotherapy. The discussion includes dose rate effects in vitro in cultured cells, in in vivo experimental systems and in the clinic, including both tumors and normal tissues. Gaps in understanding dose rate effects are identified, as are opportunities for improving clinical use of dose rate modulation.

Radiobiology of brachytherapy: The historical view based on linear quadratic model and perspectives for optimization

Most preclinical studies examining the radiobiology of brachytherapy have focused on dose rate effects. Scarcer data are available on other major parameters of therapeutic index, such as cell cycle distribution, repopulation or reoxygenation. The linear quadratic model describes the effect of radiotherapy in terms of normal tissue or tumour response. It allows some comparisons between various irradiation schemes. This model should be applied cautiously for brachytherapy, because it relies on cell death analysis only, and therefore partially reflects the biological effects of an irradiation. Moreover, the linear quadratic model validity has not been demonstrated for very high doses per fraction. A more thorough analysis of mechanisms involved in radiation response is required to better understand the true effect of brachytherapy on normal tissue. The modulation of immune response is one promising strategy to be tested with brachytherapy. A translational approach applied to brachytherapy should lead to design trials testing pharmacological agents modulating radiation response, in order to improve not only local control, but also decrease the risk of distant failure. Here we review the radiobiology of brachytherapy, from the historical view based on linear quadratic model to recent perspectives for biological optimization.

Changes in the tumor microenvironment during low-dose-rate permanent seed implantation iodine-125 brachytherapy

PURPOSE

There is a lack of data regarding how the tumor microenvironment (e.g., perfusion and oxygen partial pressure [pO2]) changes in response to low-dose-rate (LDR) brachytherapy. This may be why some clinical issues remain unresolved, such as the appropriate use of adjuvant external beam radiation therapy (EBRT). The purpose of this work was to obtain some basic preclinical data on how the tumor microenvironment evolves in response to LDR brachytherapy.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

In an experimental mouse tumor, pO2 (measured by electron paramagnetic resonance) and perfusion (measured by dynamic contrast-enhanced magnetic resonance imaging) were monitored as a function of time (0-6 days) and distance (0-2 mm and 2-4 mm) from an implanted 0.5 mCi iodine-125 brachytherapy seed.

RESULTS

For most of the experiments, including controls, tumors remained hypoxic at all times. At distances of 2-4 mm from radioactive seeds ( approximately 1.5 Gy/day), however, there was an early, significant increase in pO2 within 24 h. The pO2 in that region remained elevated through Day 3. Additionally, the perfusion in that region was significantly higher than for controls starting at Day 3.

CONCLUSION

It may be advantageous to give adjuvant EBRT shortly (approximately 1 to 2 days) after commencement of clinical LDR brachytherapy, when the pO2 in the spatial regions between seeds should be elevated. If chemotherapy is given adjuvantly, it may best be administered just a little later (approximately 3 or 4 days) after the start of LDR brachytherapy, when perfusion should be elevated.

Effects of hyperbaric oxygen and normobaric carbogen on the radiation response of the rat rhabdomyosarcoma R1H

PURPOSE

Hypoxic tumor cells are an important factor of radioresistance. Hyperbaric oxygen (HBO) and normobaric carbogen (95% oxygen, 5% carbon dioxide) increase the oxygen delivery to tumors. This study was performed to explore changes of tumor oxygenation during a course of fractionated irradiation and to determine the effectiveness of normobaric carbogen and HBO during the final phase of the radiation treatment.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Experiments were performed on the rhabdomyosarcoma R1H growing on WAG/Rij rats. After 20 X-ray fractions of 2 Gy within 4 weeks, oxygen partial pressure (pO2) was measured using the Eppendorf oxygen electrode under ambient conditions, with normobaric carbogen or HBO at a pressure of 240 kPa. Following the 4-week radiation course, a top-up dose of 10-50 Gy was applied in 2-10 fractions of 5 Gy with or without hyperoxygenation.

RESULTS

HBO but not carbogen significantly increased the median pO2 in irradiated tumors. The radiation doses to control 50% of tumors were 38.0 Gy, 29.5 Gy, and 25.0 Gy for air, carbogen, and HBO, respectively. Both high oxygen content gas inspirations led to significantly improved tumor responses with oxygen enhancement ratios (OERs) of 1.3 for normobaric carbogen and 1.5 for HBO (air vs. carbogen: p = 0.044; air vs. HBO: p = 0.02; carbogen vs. HBO: p = 0.048).

CONCLUSION

Both normobaric carbogen and HBO significantly improved the radiation response of R1H tumors. HBO appeared to be more effective than normobaric carbogen, both with regard to tumor oxygenation and response to irradiation.

Equivalence of hyperfractionated and continuous brachytherapy in a rat tumor model and remarkable effectiveness when preceded by external irradiation

PURPOSE

In clinical brachytherapy, there is a tendency to replace continuous low-dose-rate (LDR) irradiation by either single-dose or fractionated high-dose-rate (HDR) irradiation. In this study, the equivalence of LDR treatments and fractionated HDR (2 fractions/day) or pulsed-dose-rate (PDR, 4 fractions/day) schedules in terms of tumor cure was investigated in an experimental tumor model.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Tumors (rat rhabdomyosarcoma R1M) were grown s.c. in the flank of rats and implanted with 4 catheters guided by a template. All interstitial radiation treatment (IRT) schedules were given in the same geometry. HDR was given using an (192)Ir single-stepping source. To investigate small fraction sizes, part of the fractionated HDR and PDR schedules were applied after an external irradiation (ERT) top-up dose. The endpoint was the probability of tumor control at 150 days after treatment. Cell survival was estimated by excision assay.

RESULTS

Although there was no fractionation effect for fractionated HDR given in 1 or 2 fractions per day, TCD(50)-values were substantially lower than that for LDR. A PDR schedule with an interfraction interval of 3 h (4 fractions/day), however, was equivalent to LDR. The combination of ERT and IRT resulted in a remarkably increased tumor control probability in all top-up regimens, but no difference was found between 2 or 4 fractions/day. Catheter implantation alone decreased the TCD(50) for single-dose ERT already by 17.4 Gy. Cell viability assessed at 24 h after treatment demonstrated an increased effectiveness of interstitial treatment, but, after 10 Gy ERT followed by 10 Gy IRT (24-h interval), it was not less than that calculated for the combined effect of these treatments given separately.

CONCLUSION

In full fractionation schedules employing large fractions and long intervals, the sparing effect of sublethal damage repair may be significantly counteracted by reoxygenation. During 3-h intervals, however, repair may be largely completed with only partial reoxygenation causing PDR schedules to be less effective than fractionated HDR, and equivalent to LDR. Brachytherapy with clinically sized fractions after a large external top-up dose showed a remarkable increase in tumor control rate with no effect of fractionation (up to 4 fractions/day), which could not be fully explained by differences in dose distribution or in the cell viability assessed after treatment. This suggests a longer lasting effect on cell survival or radiosensitivity associated with catheter implantation shortly after the top-up dose.