First experiences with superfractionated skin irradiations using large afterloading molds

High dose rate brachytherapy with customized applicators for malignant facial skin lesions

PURPOSE

Brachytherapy is a well-known treatment in the management of skin tumors. For facial or scalp lesions, applicators have been developed to deliver non-invasive treatment. We present cases treated with customized applicators with high dose rate system.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Patients with poor performance status treated for malignant skin lesions of the scalp or the facial skin between 2011 and 2014 were studied. Afterloading devices were chosen between Freiburg(®) Flap, silicone-mold or wax applicators. The clinical target volume (CTV) was created by adding margins to lesions (10mm to 20mm). The dose schedules were 25Gy in five fractions for postoperative lesions, 30Gy in six fractions for exclusive treatments and a single session of 8Gy could be considered for palliative treatments.

RESULTS

In 30 months, 11 patients received a treatment for a total of 12 lesions. The median age was 80 years. The median follow-up was 17 months and the 2-year local control rate was 91%. The mean CTV surface was 41.1cm(2) with a mean thickness of 6.1mm. We conceived three wax applicators, used our silicone-mold eight times and the Freiburg(®) Flap one time. We observed only low-grade radiodermitis (grade I: 50%, grade II: 33%), and no high-grade skin toxicity.

CONCLUSION

High dose rate brachytherapy with customized applicators for facial skin and scalp lesions is efficient and safe. It is a good modality to treat complex lesions in patients unfit for invasive treatment.

Optimising treatment distance and treatment area for HDR surface mould brachytherapy

The purpose of this study was to quantify the effect of treatment area and treatment distance on dose distributions for geometrically optimised surface mould plans in order to provide guidance in choosing treatment parameters and constructing moulds for individual patients. Geometrically optimised plans were generated with a typical brachytherapy planning system and measurements were taken with radiochromic film over depths of 5-32 mm with an (192)Ir high dose rate source. Films were calibrated with a cylindrical geometry technique utilising the (192)Ir source and readout was performed with a flatbed scanner. The rate of dose fall-off about the prescription plane, as well as the magnitude and extent of local dose maxima superficial to the prescription plane, increased with decreasing treatment areas when inter-catheter spacing and treatment distance were kept constant. The dose fall-off was highly dependent on treatment distance, with a 16 % reduction in dose 4 mm superficial to the treatment depth occurring when the distance was increased from 10 to 20 mm while maintaining a 10 mm inter-catheter spacing. The table generated using the measured planar geometry data, can be used as an initial guide for mould construction and planning. The properties of high dose regions near to the catheter plane are highly dependent on the treatment area, which must be considered when normal tissue dose tolerances are a concern. Treatment distance is a key variable influencing the overall dose distribution and should be adjusted as a function of the desired tumour to skin dose ratio, controlled by mould thickness.

High-dose-rate (HDR) plesiotherapy with custom-made moulds for the treatment of non-melanoma skin cancer

BACKGROUND

Non-melanoma skin tumours (NMSC) are one of the most frequent types of cancer, accounting for nearly one third of newly diagnosed tumours. NMSC are frequently diagnosed in elderly patients and while mortality rates are low, NMSC can be associated with significant morbidity in terms of cosmetic and functional impairment.

OBJECTIVE

Surgical excision is nowadays considered the standard treatment for NMSC, although this approach might not be suitable for all the patients. Good rates of local control and cosmetic outcome are achieved by using high-dose-rate (HDR) plesiotherapy.

METHODS

Nine consecutive patients with 11 NMSC were treated with custom-made moulds and HDR plesiotherapy reaching a fi nal dose of 44-48 Gy in 11-12 fractions of 4 Gy over 4 weeks.

RESULTS

No local or distant relapses have been observed after a mean follow-up of 15 months (range 4-36 months). Acute toxicity was acceptable and cosmetic result was considered as excellent/good in 7 patients.

CONCLUSIONS

This modality of treatment offers an alternative for those patients not candidates for surgical procedures because of medical contraindications or risk of disfigurement or functional impairment.

Safety aspects of pulsed dose rate brachytherapy: analysis of errors in 1,300 treatment sessions

PURPOSE

To determine the safety of pulsed-dose-rate (PDR) brachytherapy by analyzing errors and technical failures during treatment.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

More than 1,300 patients underwent treatment with PDR brachytherapy, using five PDR remote afterloaders. Most patients were treated with consecutive pulse schemes, also outside regular office hours. Tumors were located in the breast, esophagus, prostate, bladder, gynecology, anus/rectum, orbit, head/neck, with a miscellaneous group of small numbers, such as the lip, nose, and bile duct. Errors and technical failures were analyzed for 1,300 treatment sessions, for which nearly 20,000 pulses were delivered. For each tumor localization, the number and type of occurring errors were determined, as were which localizations were more error prone than others.

RESULTS

By routinely using the built-in dummy check source, only 0.2% of all pulses showed an error during the phase of the pulse when the active source was outside the afterloader. Localizations treated using flexible catheters had greater error frequencies than those treated with straight needles or rigid applicators. Disturbed pulse frequencies were in the range of 0.6% for the anus/rectum on a classic version 1 afterloader to 14.9% for orbital tumors using a version 2 afterloader. Exceeding the planned overall treatment time by >10% was observed in only 1% of all treatments. Patients received their dose as originally planned in 98% of all treatments.

CONCLUSIONS

According to the experience in our institute with 1,300 PDR treatments, we found that PDR is a safe brachytherapy treatment modality, both during and outside of office hours.

CT computer-optimized high-dose-rate brachytherapy with surface applicator technique for scar boost radiation after breast reconstruction surgery

PURPOSE

Immediate breast reconstruction has become increasingly prevalent after mastectomy for breast cancer. Postoperative scar boost radiation for the reconstructed breast presents many planning challenges due to the shape, size, and curvature of the scar. High-dose-rate (HDR) surface applicator brachytherapy is a novel and effective method of delivering scar boost radiation. Two cases, one with a saline implant and one with a transverse rectus abdominis musculocutaneous flap reconstruction, illustrate the method and advantages of HDR optimization of surface applicators.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

For 2 patients a mold of the breast was made with Aquaplast sheets. A reproducible system was used for arm positioning. Skin fiducials, including tattoos from external beam planning, were matched to fiducials on the mold. HDR catheters were sited on the mold at 1cm intervals, with the central catheter situated along the scar. Topographically, both scars demonstrated extreme curvature in both craniocaudal and mediolateral directions. A CT computer-optimized HDR plan was developed, with the reference dose prescribed at the skin surface. The dosimetry was compared to single-field and matched-field electron plans.

RESULTS

This surface applicator technique provided a uniform skin dose of 100% to the entire clinical target volume (CTV) without hot spots in both patients. The patient position and surface applicator setup were consistently reproducible. The patients tolerated the treatment well with minimal skin erythema. In the single-field electron plan, skin dose was decreased to 50% at the periphery of the scar. Matching fields addressed this depth dose decrement, but resulted in large localized hot spots of more than 200% centrally in each field.

CONCLUSION

CT computer-optimized HDR surface applicator brachytherapy provided a reproducible homogeneous method of treating highly curved scars on the reconstructed breast. Electron beam treatment would result in longer and more complex treatments yet still provide a less homogeneous dose than this surface applicator technique.

Homogeneous Ir-192 afterloading-flab-irradiation of plane surfaces

Homogeneous irradiation of plane targets by Ir-192 afterloading flabs made by a parallel series of linear applicators can be time-consuming even with modern planning systems. The aim of the present study was to develop an algorithm that supplies homogeneous dose distributions in an arbitrary given plane in parallel to the equipped plane of a flab. The edge and corner positions of the flab are of particular importance. The identity of the dose in the optimisation distance above the flab centre, corners, and middle of the flab edges, leads to a strict relation of the respective dwell weights. Formulas can be derived that allow the calculation of the dwell times. The dimensioning of the flab can be rapidly adapted to new conditions. A comparison with the results of Nucletron PLATO-BPS for applicator-applicator distances and step sizes of 1 cm at optimisation distances of 10, 20, 30, and 40 mm and various flab sizes (3 x 3, 9 x 9, and 15 x 15 cm2) shows the following results: The standard deviation of the proposed algorithm is sometimes slightly higher than the results of the commercial planning system, whereas the underdosage at the flab edges is usually smaller. The effort for planning and preparation of the irradiation, for example using a Nucletron HDR, is below 5 minutes--a considerable reduction of planning time.

Office hours pulsed brachytherapy boost in breast cancer

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Radiobiological studies suggest equivalent biological effects between continuous low dose rate brachytherapy (CLDR) and pulsed brachytherapy (PB) when pulses are applied without interruption every hour. However, radiation protection and institute-specific demands requested the design of a practical PB protocol substituting the CLDR boost in breast cancer patients. An office hours scheme was designed, considering the CLDR dose rate, the overall treatment time, pulse frequency and tissue repair characteristics. Radiobiological details are presented as well as the logistics and technical feasibility of the scheme after treatment of the first 100 patients.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Biologically effective doses (BEDs) were calculated according to the linear quadratic model for incomplete repair. Radiobiological parameters included an alpha/beta value of 3 Gy for normal tissue late effects and 10 Gy for early normal tissue or tumour effects. Tissue repair half-time ranged from 0.1 to 6 h. The reference CLDR dose rate of 0.80 Gy/h was obtained retrospectively from analysis of patients' data. The treatment procedure was evaluated with regard to variations in implant characteristics after treatment of 100 patients.

RESULTS

A PB protocol was designed consisting of two treatment blocks separated by a night break. Dose delivery in PB was 20 Gy in two 10 Gy blocks and, for application of the 15 Gy boost, one 10 Gy block plus one 5 Gy block. The dose per pulse was 1.67 Gy, applied with a period time of approximately 1.5 h. An inter-patient variation of 30% (1 SD) was observed in the instantaneous source strength. Taking also the spread in implant size into account, the net variation in pulse duration amounted to 38%.

CONCLUSION

An office hours PB boost regimen was designed for substitution of the CLDR boost in breast-conserving therapy on the basis of the BED. First treatment experience shows the office hour regimen to be convenient to the patients and no technical perturbations were encountered.

Interstitial brachytherapy for recurrent breast cancer using a high dose rate Ir-192 remote afterloading system: a report of two cases

We employed interstitial brachytherapy using a high dose rate Ir-192 remote afterloading unit in two breast cancer patients with locoregional recurrence. In the first case, skin metastasis was treated, with favorable control of the infield tumor but subsequent persistent sequelae and multiple outfield metastases. This experience caused us to be cautious when choosing brachytherapy for the second case, in whom a solitary metastasis to an axillary lymph node was successfully treated. Although this method is still investigational, it may play a critical role in the treatment of locoregional recurrence resistant to other treatment modalities.

Results of chest wall reirradiation using pulsed-dose-rate (PDR) brachytherapy molds for breast cancer local recurrences

PURPOSE

We report in a retrospective study on the effect and toxicity of chest wall reirradiation using pulsed-dose-rate (PDR) afterloading molds.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Between 1993 and 1999, a total of 58 patients were treated. All patients presented with locally recurrent breast cancer (31 patients had concomitant distant metastases) after mastectomy and a previously completed course of radiation therapy (median, 54 Gy; range, 36-70). Indication for reirradiation was a progressive macroscopic skin recurrence in 30 cases and an incomplete surgical resection in 28 patients. Standard treatment consisted of a split course with two fractions of 20 Gy (interval, 31 days). The reference dose was prescribed to the skin surface at 5 mm distance from the source. PDR brachytherapy (37 GBq, (192)Ir) was carried out after geometric distance optimization with 0.5-1 Gy/pulse/h. The irradiated median area was 423 cm(2) (range, 100-919). The median follow-up was 18 months (range, 7-84).

RESULTS

The actuarial 1-, 2- and 3-year local recurrence-free survival rates in patients treated for macroscopic disease (microscopic disease in parenthesis) were 89% (96%), 81% (85%), and 75% (71%). Local control was obtained in 24/30 (22/28) patients. Twenty-nine of the 34 patients (85%) who deceased during follow-up were locally controlled. 9/58 patients experienced Grade III acute toxicity, 35/58 patients Grade III (29/58 telangiectasia, 6/58 contracture), and 4/58 Grade IV late toxicity (RTOG/EORTC).

CONCLUSION

Reirradiation of the chest wall using PDR brachytherapy molds is effective and provides a high local control rate with acceptable toxicity.

[In vitro studies of PDR brachytherapy]

BACKGROUND

Calculations on the basis of the LQ-model have been focussed on the possible radiobiological equivalence between common continuous low dose rate irradiation (CLDR) and a superfractionated irradiation (PDR = pulsed dose rate) provided that the same total dose will be prescribed in the same overall time as with the low doserate. A clinically usable fractionation scheme for brachytherapy was recommended by Brenner and Hall and should replace the classical CLDR brachytherapy with line sources with an afterloading technique using a stepping source. The hypothes is that LDR equivalency can be achieved by superfractionation was tested by means of in vitro experiments on V79 cells in monolayer and spheroid cultures as well as on HeLa monolayers.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Simulating the clinical situation in PDR brachytherapy, fractionation experiments were carried out in the dose rate gradient of afterloading sources. Different dose levels were produced with the same number of fractions in the same overall incubation time. The fractionation schedules which were to be compared with a CLDR reference curve were: 40 x 0.47 Gy, 20 x 0.94 Gy, 10 x 1.88 Gy, 5 x 3.76 Gy, 2 x 9.4 Gy given in a period of 20 h and 1 x 18.8 Gy as a "single dose" exposition. As measured by flow cytometry, the influence of the dose rate in the pulse on cell survival and on cell cycle distribution under superfractionation was examined on V79 cells.

RESULTS

V79 spheroids as a model for a slowly growing tumor, reacted according to the radiobiological calculations, as a CLDR equivalency was achieved with increasing fractionation. Rapidly growing V79 monolayer cells showed an inverse fractionation effect. A superfractionated irradiation with pulses of 0.94 Gy/h respectively 0.47 Gy/0.5 h was significantly more effective than the CLDR irradiation. This inverse fractionation effect in log-phase V79 cells could be attributed to the accumulation of cycling cells in the radiosensitive G2/M phase (G2 block) during protected exposure which was drastically more pronounced for the pulsed scheme. HeLa cells were rather insensitive to changes of fractionation. Superfractionation as well as hypofractionation yielded CLDR equivalent survival curves.

CONCLUSIONS

The fractionation scheme, derived from the PDR theory to achieve CLDR equivalent effects, is valid for many cell lines, however not for all. Proliferation and dose rate dependend cell cycle effects modify predictions derived from the sublethal damage recovery model and can influence acute irradiation effects significantly. Dose rate sensitivity and rapid proliferation favour cell cycle effects and substantiate, applied to the clinical situation, the possibility of a higher effectiveness of the pulsed irradiation on rapidly growing tumors.

[Effects of fractionation and dose rate in PDR brachytherapy of B14 cells]

PURPOSE

Present radiobiological studies for different cell lines in vitro demonstrate the equivalence and efficacy of continuous low-dose-rate brachytherapy (LDR-BT) and pulsed dose rate brachytherapy (PDR-BT) when using small and frequent dose pulses. The aim of this study was to examine monolayer fibroblast cultures in vitro to examine the biological effects of different pulse doses and dose rates under clinically conditions.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

B14 cells, Hy B14 FAF 28, peritoneal fibroblasts, were cultured in multi-well plates and exposed to a PDR radiation source at a distance of 9 mm. The following PDR-schemes were compared: dose per pulse: 1 Gy, 2.5 Gy and 5 Gy to a total dose of 5 Gy/5 h (overall time), 10 Gy/10 h, 20 Gy/20 h and 30 Gy/30 h. The pulse duration for the examination of dose rate effects was 20 min, 30 min or 52 min corresponding by dye pulse dose rate of 300 cGy/h, 200 cGy/h or 115 cGy/h. Treatment endpoints were cell measured by dye exclusion test and clonogenic cell survival.

RESULTS

Cell survival decreased for pulse doses of 5 Gy compared to 2.5 Gy or 1 Gy per pulse (mean dose rate 200 to 300 cGy/h). No differences were observed with dose rates during irradiation of 300 cGy/h, 200 cGy/h or 115 cGy/h (20 Gy/1 Gy).

CONCLUSION

Radiobiological effects of PDR-RT are dependent on the dose per pulse, with differences in biological effects only with a dose per pulse of more than 2.5 Gy, considering the described in-vitro conditions. More examinations with a more pronounced difference in dose rate will be continued for evaluation of dose rate effects.

PDR brachytherapy with flexible implants for interstitial boost after breast-conserving surgery and external beam radiation therapy

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

For radiobiological reasons the new concept of pulsed dose rate (PDR) brachytherapy seems to be suitable to replace traditional CLDR brachytherapy with line sources. PDR brachytherapy using a stepping source seems to be particularly suitable for the interstitial boost of breast carcinoma after breast-conserving surgery and external beam irradiation since in these cases the exact adjustment of the active lengths is essential in order to prevent unwanted skin dose and consequential unfavorable cosmetic results. The purpose of this study was to assess the feasibility and morbidity of a PDR boost with flexible breast implants.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Sixty-five high risk patients were treated with an interstitial PDR boost. The criteria for an interstitial boost were positive margin or close margin, extensive intraductal component (EIC), intralymphatic extension, lobular carcinoma, T2 tumors and high nuclear grade (GIII). Dose calculation and specification were performed following the rules of the Paris system. The dose per pulse was 1 Gy. The pulse pauses were kept constant at 1 h. A geometrically optimized dose distribution was used for all patients. The treatment schedule was 50 Gy external beam to the whole breast and 20 Gy boost. PDR irradiations were carried out with a nominal 37 GBq 192-Ir source.

RESULTS

The median follow-up was 30 months (minimum 12 months, maximum 54 months). Sixty percent of the patients judged their cosmetic result as excellent, 27% judged it as good, 11% judged it as fair and 2% judged it as poor. Eighty-six percent of the patients had no radiogenous skin changes in the boost area. In 11% of patients minimal punctiform telangiectasia appeared at single puncture sites. In 3% (2/65) of patients planar telangiectasia appeared on the medial side of the implant. The rate of isolated local recurrence was 1.5%. In most cases geometrical volume optimization (GVO) yields improved dose distributions with respect to homogeneity and compensation of underdosage at the margins of the implant. Only in 9% of patients was the dose distribution impaired by GVO. However, GVO causes a number of substantial changes of the dose distribution which have consequences for its application.

CONCLUSIONS

The interstitial CLDR boost of the breast can be replaced by the PDR technique without severe acute and late complications and without deterioration of the cosmetic results.