Comparison of miniature multileaf collimation (MMLC) with circular collimation for stereotactic treatment

Effects of cone versus multi-leaf collimation on dosimetry and neurotoxicity in patients with small arteriovenous malformations treated by stereotactic radiosurgery

PURPOSE/OBJECTIVE

Linear accelerator (LINAC) based stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS) for arteriovenous malformations (AVMs) is delivered with cone or multileaf collimators (MLCs), and favorable dosimetry is associated with reduced radionecrosis in normal brain tissue. This study aims to determine whether cones or MLCs has better dosimetric characteristics, to predict differences in toxicity.

METHODS

All patients treated for AVMs using LINAC SRS from 2003-2017 were examined retrospectively. Demographic data, volumes of normal tissue exposed to 12Gy (V12Gy[cc]) and 4Gy (V4Gy[cc]), maximal dose, and dose gradient were analyzed. Univariate and multivariate analyses were used to evaluate relationships between collimator type, dosimetric parameters, and toxicity. Propensity score matching was used to adjust for AVM size.

RESULTS

Compared to MLC, cones were independently associated with reduced V12Gy[cc] after propensity score matching (p=0.008) and reduced neurotoxicity (p=0.016). Higher V12Gy[cc] (p=0.0008) and V4Gy[cc] (p=0.002) were associated with increased neurotoxicity.

CONCLUSIONS

Treating AVMs with cone-based SRS over MLC-based SRS may improve dosimetry and reduce toxicities.

LINAC radiosurgery for glomus jugulare tumors: retrospective - cohort study of 23 patients

BACKGROUND

Glomus jugulare tumors (GJTs) are uncommon and locally disruptive tumors that usually arise within the jugular foramen of the temporal bone. Surgery was the treatment of choice up until recently. In the last decades, however, radiosurgery has surfaced as a promising alternative treatment by providing excellent tumor control with low risk of cranial nerve injuries. Our aim was to examine the results of radiosurgery specifically, linear accelerator stereotactic radiosurgery (LINAC SRS) for GJT treatment. We hypothesized that radiosurgery will reduce the size of the tumor and improve neurological symptoms.

DESIGN AND METHOD

Between January 1, 1994 and December 31, 2013, 30 patients with GJTs were treated in Sheba Medical Center using LINAC SRS treatment. Comprehensive clinical follow-up was available for 23 patients. Sixteen patients were female and seven males with a median age of 64 years, with a range of 18-87 years. In 19 of the patients, LINAC SRS was the primary treatment, whereas in the remaining four cases, surgery or embolization preceded radiosurgery. The median treated dose to tumor margin was 14 Gy (range 12-27 Gy), and the median tumor volume before treatment was 5 ml (range 0.5-15 ml).

RESULTS

Following the LINAC SRS treatment, 14 of 23 patients (60%) showed improvement of previous neurological deficits, nine patients (40%) remained unchanged. At the end of a follow-up, tumor reduction was seen in 13 patients and a stable volume in eight (91% tumor control rate). Two cases of tumor progression were noted. Three patients (13%) had post- SRS complications during the follow-up, two of which achieved tumor control, while in one the tumor advanced.

CONCLUSIONS

LINAC SRS is a practical treatment option for GJTs, with a high rate of tumor control and satisfactory neurological improvement.

Circular collimator arc versus dynamic conformal arc treatment planning for linac-based stereotactic radiosurgery of an intracranial small single lesion: a perspective of lesion asymmetry

BACKGROUND

Although circular collimator arcs (CCA) and dynamic conformal arcs (DCA) are commonly used linear accelerator-based treatment planning techniques for intracranial stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS) of a small single lesion, these two techniques have not been rigorously compared in terms of tumor shape. Therefore, this study compared clinical CCA plans with re-planned DCA plans using conformity index (CI) and V12Gy (volume of normal brain tissue receiving 12 Gy or higher) from a perspective of asymmetry (Asym) of planning target volume (PTV).

METHODS

Ninety-five clinical CCA plans delivered for a small single lesion with PTV size < 1.4 cm³ were selected and re-planned using DCA. PTV Asym (%) was defined and calculated from three dimensions of PTV. A pair of the 95 plans was first considered as one group without grouping and then categorized into two groups with respective to either PTV size or PTV Asym, and four groups with respect to PTV size and PTV Asym. For grouping, median values of PTV size and PTV Asym were used. A non-parametric paired test was performed for CI and V12Gy to compare CCA and DCA plans in each group.

RESULTS

Median values of PTV size and PTV Asym were 0.415 cm³ (range: 0.076 cm³-1.369 cm³) and 6.12% (range: 0.52-25.74%), respectively. DCA plans had a lower average CI value than CCA plans for all groups. CCA plans had a smaller average V12Gy value than DCA plans for lesions with PTV Asym ≤6.12%, while CCA and DCA plans had similar average V12Gy values for lesions with PTV Asym > 6.12%.

CONCLUSIONS

The DCA technique is recommended when a lesion has PTV Asym > 6.12% regardless of PTV size. For lesions with PTV Asym ≤6.12%, a technique choice would depend on the preference of CI or V12Gy.

The virtual cone: A novel technique to generate spherical dose distributions using a multileaf collimator and standardized control-point sequence for small target radiation surgery

Purpose

The study aimed to develop and demonstrate a standardized linear accelerator multileaf collimator-based method of delivering small, spherical dose distributions suitable for radiosurgical treatment of small targets such as the trigeminal nerve.

Methods and materials

The virtual cone is composed of a multileaf collimator–defined field with the central 2 leaves set to a small gap. For 5 table positions, clockwise and counter-clockwise arcs were used with collimator angles of 45 and 135 degrees, respectively. The dose per degree was proportional to the sine of the gantry angle. The dose distribution was calculated by the treatment planning system and measured using radiochromic film in a skull phantom for leaf gaps of 1.6, 2.1, and 2.6 mm. Cones with a diameter of 4 mm and 5 mm were measured for comparison. Output factor constancy was investigated using a parallel-plate chamber.

Results

The mean ratio of the measured-to-calculated dose was 0.99, 1.03, and 1.05 for 1.6, 2.1, and 2.6 mm leaf gaps, respectively. The diameter of the measured (calculated) 50% isodose line was 4.9 (4.6) mm, 5.2 (5.1) mm, and 5.5 (5.5) mm for the 1.6, 2.1, and 2.6 mm leaf gap, respectively. The measured diameter of the 50% isodose line was 4.5 and 5.7 mm for the 4 mm and 5 mm cones, respectively. The standard deviation of the parallel-plate chamber signal relative to a 10 cm × 10 cm field was less than 0.4%. The relative signal changed 32% per millimeter change in leaf gap, indicating that the parallel-plate chamber is sensitive to changes in gap width.

Conclusions

The virtual cone is an efficient technique for treatment of small spherical targets. Patient-specific quality assurance measurements will not be necessary in routine clinical use. Integration directly into the treatment planning system will make planning using this technique extremely efficient.

Dosimetric characterization of Elekta stereotactic cones

Purpose

Dosimetry of small fields defined by stereotactic cones remains a challenging task. In this work, we report the results of commissioning measurements for the new Elekta stereotactic conical collimator system attached to the Elekta VersaHD linac and present the comparison between the measured and Monte Carlo (MC) calculated data for the 6 MV FFF beam. In addition, relative output factor (ROF) dependence on the stereotactic cone aperture variation was studied and penumbra comparison for small MLC‐based and cone‐based fields was performed.

Methods

Cones with nominal diameters of 15 mm, 12.5 mm, 10 mm, 7.5 mm, and 5 mm were employed in our study. Percentage depth dose (PDD), off‐axis ratios (OAR), and ROF were measured using a stereotactic field diode (SFD). BEAMnrc code was used for MC simulations.

Results

MC calculated and measured PDDs for all cones agreed within 1%/0.5 mm, and OAR profiles agreed within 1%/0.5 mm. ROF obtained from the measurements and MC calculations agreed within 2% for all cone sizes. Small‐field correction factors for the SFD detector K_{field,3 × 3}(SFD) were derived using MC calculations as a baseline and were found to be 0.982, 0.992, 0.997, 1.015, and 1.017 for the 5, 7.5, 10, 12.5, and 15‐mm cones respectively. The difference in ROF was about 10%, 6%, 3.5%, 3%, 2.5%, and 2% for ±0.3 mm variations in 5, 7.5, 10, 12.5, and 15‐mm cone aperture respectively. In case of single static field, cone‐based collimation produced a sharper penumbra compared to the MLC‐based.

Conclusions

Accurate MC simulation can be an effective tool for verification of dosimetric measurements of small fields. Due to the very high sensitivity of output factors on the cone diameter, manufacture‐related variations in cone size may lead to considerable variations in dosimetric characteristics of stereotactic cones.

Dynamic contrast-enhanced magnetic resonance imaging of osseous spine metastasis before and 1 hour after high-dose image-guided radiation therapy

OBJECTIVE High-dose image-guided radiation therapy (HD IGRT) has been instrumental in mitigating some limitations of conventional RT. The recent emergence of dynamic contrast-enhanced (DCE) MRI to investigate tumor physiology can be used to verify the response of human tumors to HD IGRT. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the near-immediate effects of HD IGRT on spine metastases through the use of DCE MRI perfusion studies. METHODS Six patients with spine metastases from prostate, thyroid, and renal cell carcinoma who underwent HD IGRT were studied using DCE MRI prior to and 1 hour after HD IGRT. The DCE perfusion parameters plasma volume (V_p) and vascular permeability (K_trans) were measured to assess the near-immediate and long-term tumor response. A Mann-Whitney U-test was performed to compare significant changes (at p ≤ 0.05) in perfusion parameters before and after RT. RESULTS The authors observed a precipitous drop in V_p within 1 hour of HD IGRT, with a mean decrease of 65.2%. A significant difference was found between V_p values for before and 1 hour after RT (p ≤ 0.05). No significant change was seen in V_p (p = 0.31) and K_trans (p = 0.1) from 1 hour after RT to the first follow-up. CONCLUSIONS The data suggest that there is an immediate effect of HD IGRT on the vascularity of spine metastases, as demonstrated by a precipitous decrease in V_p. The DCE MRI studies can detect such changes within 1 hour after RT, and findings are concordant with existing animal models.

Stereotactic radiosurgery for intradural spine tumors using cone-beam CT image guidance

OBJECTIVE

Cone-beam CT (CBCT) image guidance technology has been widely adopted for spine radiosurgery delivery. There is relatively little experience with spine radiosurgery for intradural tumors using CBCT image guidance. This study prospectively evaluated a series of intradural spine tumors treated with radiosurgery. Patient setup accuracy for spine radiosurgery delivery using CBCT image guidance for intradural spine tumors was determined.

METHODS

Eighty-two patients with intradural tumors were treated and prospectively evaluated. The positioning deviations of the spine radiosurgery treatments in patients were recorded. Radiosurgery was delivered using a linear accelerator with a beam modulator and CBCT image guidance combined with a robotic couch that allows positioning correction in 3 translational and 3 rotational directions. To measure patient movement, 3 quality assurance CBCTs were performed and recorded in 30 patients: before, halfway, and after the radiosurgery treatment. The positioning data and fused images of planning CT and CBCT from the treatments were analyzed to determine intrafraction patient movements. From each of 3 CBCTs, 3 translational and 3 rotational coordinates were obtained.

RESULTS

The radiosurgery procedure was successfully completed for all patients. Lesion locations included cervical (22), thoracic (17), lumbar (38), and sacral (5). Tumor histologies included schwannoma (27), neurofibromas (18), meningioma (16), hemangioblastoma (8), and ependymoma (5). The mean prescription dose was 17 Gy (range 12–27 Gy) delivered in 1–3 fractions. At the halfway point of the radiation, the translational variations and standard deviations were 0.4 ± 0.5, 0.5 ± 0.8, and 0.4 ± 0.5 mm in the lateral (x), longitudinal (y), and anteroposterior (z) directions, respectively. Similarly, the variations immediately after treatment were 0.5 ± 0.4, 0.5 ± 0.6, and 0.6 ± 0.5 mm along x, y, and z directions, respectively. The mean rotational angles were 0.3° ± 0.4°, 0.3° ± 0.4°, and 0.3° ± 0.4° along yaw, roll, and pitch, respectively, at the halfway point and 0.5° ± 0.5°, 0.4° ± 0.5°, and 0.2° ± 0.3° immediately after treatment.

CONCLUSIONS

Radiosurgery offers an alternative treatment option for intradural spine tumors in patients who may not be optimal candidates for open surgery. CBCT image guidance for patient setup for spine radiosurgery is accurate and successful in patients with intradural tumors.

Evaluation of results of linac-based radiosurgery for brain metastases from primary lung cancer

AIM

The purpose of our review was to evaluate results of radiosurgery for patients with brain metastases from lung cancer.

BACKGROUND

Lung cancer is the leading cause of death from cancer and the most common source of brain metastases. Radiosurgery allows the precise focal delivery of a high single radiation dose to brain metastases and results in high rates of local control.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

83 patients were treated between 2006 and 2008. We evaluated local control and outcome after radiosurgery and identified prognostic factors.

RESULTS

Median survival in the whole group was 7.8 months from radiosurgery and 11 months from diagnosis. Median survival in classes I, II and III was 13.2, 8.2 and 2.2 months. For 94% of patients symptoms improved or stabilised at the first follow-up visit and this status did not change during 7.1 months. According to the univariate analysis, factors associated with improved survival included: RPA class 1 compared with RPA 2 and 3, RPA class 2 compared with RPA 3, KPS > 70, control of the primary disease, radiosurgery performed more than once, level of haemoglobin >7 mmol/1, absence of extracranial metastases, volume of the biggest lesion <11 cm(3). The multivariate analysis confirmed a significant influence on survival for the following factors: RPA class 1 as compared with RPA 3, KPS > 70, absence of extracranial metastases, multiplicity of radiosurgery.

CONCLUSIONS

Stereotactic radiosurgery is a safe and effective treatment. It proved to be effective and safe in older patients. Selection of patients who are likely to benefit most should be based on prognostic factors. KPS proved to be the most important prognostic factor. In the RPA III group (patients with KPS < 70) survival time was similar to that achieved after symptomatic medical management.

High resolution 2D dose measurement device based on a few long scintillating fibers and tomographic reconstruction

PURPOSE

Patient-specific QA of highly conformal radiotherapy treatments are usually conducted using 2D or 3D dosimetry of the incident dose distribution in a water-equivalent phantom. However, dosimeters typically used for this task usually lack in either spatial resolution or dose accuracy. The purpose of this work is to develop and validate a novel type of high resolution 2D dosimeter based on the tomographic reconstruction of the dose projections obtained using long scintillating fibers for the quality assurance of modern radiotherapy techniques such as IMRT.

METHODS

Fifty parallel scintillating fibers were aligned in a 30 cm diameter cylindrical masonite phantom with a 95 cm source-to-surface distance and a 100 cm source-to-fibers distance. The fibers were disposed so that the effective detection area of the scintillating fibers was a 20 cm diameter disk. Both ends of each scintillating fiber were coupled to clear optical fibers to enable light collection by a single CCD camera. Seven IMRT segments and two square fields were acquired using 18 projections over a 170° rotation of the device. Computation of the dose integrals was made for each scintillating fiber using the irradiation of known rectangular reference fields. Dose reconstructions were conducted using a total-variation minimization iterative reconstruction algorithm. Eight monitor units were programmed for each projection and the reconstructed dose grid pixel resolution was set to 1 × 1 mm(2).

RESULTS

3%∕3 mm gamma tests conducted between the reconstructed IMRT dose distributions and the dose calculated with the treatment planning system Pinnacle(3) were on average successful for 99.6% of the dose pixels with a predicted dose of at least 10% of the maximum dose. The dose profiles for both square fields and IMRT segments agreed within 2% to the dose calculated with Pinnacle(3) except in high dose gradient regions, and were comparable to the dose measured using an ionization chamber array (IBA MatriXX) and radiographic films (Kodak XV2).

CONCLUSIONS

Using tomographic reconstruction on the projections acquired with rotating scintillating fibers, we were able to perform water-equivalent 2D dosimetry of square fields and IMRT segments with acceptable accuracy and high spatial resolution. The underlying concept of tomographic dosimetry and the small number of fibers needed to reconstruct a given 2D dose distribution offer new dosimetric possibilities, both applicable to 2D and 3D dosimetry.

Potential of discrete Gaussian edge feathering method for improving abutment dosimetry in eMLC-delivered segmented-field electron conformal therapy

PURPOSE

The purpose of this work was to investigate the potential of discrete Gaussian edge feathering of the higher energy electron fields for improving abutment dosimetry in the planning volume when using an electron multileaf collimator (eMLC) to deliver segmented-field electron conformal therapy (ECT).

METHODS

A discrete (five-step) Gaussian edge spread function was used to match dose penumbras of differing beam energies (6-20 MeV) at a specified depth in a water phantom. Software was developed to define the leaf eMLC positions of an eMLC that most closely fit each electron field shape. The effect of 1D edge feathering of the higher energy field on dose homogeneity was computed and measured for segmented-field ECT treatment plans for three 2D PTVs in a water phantom, i.e., depth from the water surface to the distal PTV surface varied as a function of the x-axis (parallel to leaf motion) and remained constant along the y-axis (perpendicular to leaf motion). Additionally, the effect of 2D edge feathering was computed and measured for one radially symmetric, 3D PTV in a water phantom, i.e., depth from the water surface to the distal PTV surface varied as a function of both axes. For the 3D PTV, the feathering scheme was evaluated for 0.1-1.0-cm leaf widths. Dose calculations were performed using the pencil beam dose algorithm in the Pinnacle(3) treatment planning system. Dose verification measurements were made using a prototype eMLC (1-cm leaf width).

RESULTS

1D discrete Gaussian edge feathering reduced the standard deviation of dose in the 2D PTVs by 34, 34, and 39%. In the 3D PTV, the broad leaf width (1 cm) of the eMLC hindered the 2D application of the feathering solution to the 3D PTV, and the standard deviation of dose increased by 10%. However, 2D discrete Gaussian edge feathering with simulated eMLC leaf widths of 0.1-0.5 cm reduced the standard deviation of dose in the 3D PTV by 33-28%, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

A five-step discrete Gaussian edge spread function applied in 2D improves the abutment dosimetry but requires an eMLC leaf resolution better than 1 cm.

A contemporary review of stereotactic radiotherapy: inherent dosimetric complexities and the potential for detriment

OBJECTIVE

The advantages of highly localised, conformal treatments achievable with stereotactic radiotherapy (SRT) are increasingly being extended to extracranial sites as stereotactic body radiotherapy with advancements in imaging and beam collimation. One of the challenges in stereotactic treatment lies in the significant complexities associated with small field dosimetry and dose calculation. This review provides a comprehensive overview of the complexities associated with stereotactic radiotherapy and the potential for detriment.

METHODS

This study is based on a comprehensive review of literature accessible via PubMed and other sources, covering stereotactic radiotherapy, small-field dosimetry and dose calculation.

FINDINGS

Several key issues were identified in the literature. They pertain to dose prescription, dose measurement and dose calculation within and beyond the treatment field. Field-edge regions and penumbrae occupy a significant portion of the total field size. Spectral and dosimetric characteristics are difficult to determine and are compounded by effects of tissue inhomogeneity. Measurement of small-fields is made difficult by detector volume averaging and energy response. Available dosimeters are compared, and emphasis is given to gel dosimetry which offers the greatest potential for three-dimensional small-field dosimetry. The limitations of treatment planning system algorithms as applied to small-fields (particularly in the presence of heterogeneities) is explained, and a review of Monte Carlo dose calculation is provided, including simplified treatment planning implementations. Not incorporated into treatment planning, there is evidence that far from the primary field, doses to patients (and corresponding risks of radiocarcinogenesis) from leakage/scatter in SRT are similar to large fields.

CONCLUSIONS

Improved knowledge of dosimetric issues is essential to the accurate measurement and calculation of dose as well as the interpretation and assessment of planned and delivered treatments. This review highlights such issues and the potential benefit that may be gained from Monte Carlo dose calculation and verification via three-dimensional dosimetric methods (such as gel dosimetry) being introduced into routine clinical practice.

[Mechanical accuracy of a stereotactic irradiation system using a micro multi-leaf collimator]

Mechanical accuracy of a stereotactic irradiation system using a micro multi-leaf collimator (mMLC), Elekta DMLC, has been evaluated. Measurements were made to obtain transmission, leakage, penumbra, and positioning accuracy of the DMLC leaf for a 6 MV photon beam. Mechanical accuracy and long term stability of a linac isocenter was also evaluated. The resulting transmission, along a line perpendicular to the leaf movement, was 0.31±0.01%, and the leakage from the closed opposing leaf pairs was 0.39±0.01%. The measured penumbra, at a depth incurring maximum dose, was 2.37±0.16 mm toward the leaf end and 2.14±0.18 mm toward the leaf side for various field sizes. The leaf gap width error, of 0.10±0.08 mm, was obtained by analyzing picket fence test results. The maximum leaf positioning error, of 0.14±0.06 mm, was obtained by analyzing the log file for a various gantry angles during an arc delivery. The isocenter accuracy was within a radius of 1 mm, without any recalibration for two years. In conclusion, our stereotactic irradiation system using DMLC was capable of providing accurate stereotactic treatment.

The 2009 devaluation of radiosurgery and its impact on the neurosurgery-radiation oncology partnership

Neurosurgeons, radiation oncologists, and, increasingly, other surgical specialists recognize that radiosurgery is an important tool for managing selected disorders throughout the body. The partnership between neurosurgeons and radiation oncologists has resulted in collaborative studies that have established the clinical benefits of radiosurgery. Today, however, a range of political and financial issues is straining this relationship and thereby undermining the practice of radiosurgery. Neurosurgeons and radiation oncologists recently restricted the definition of radiosurgery to include only cranial- and spine-focused radiation treatments. Meanwhile, organized radiation oncology decided unilaterally that radiosurgery administered to other parts of the body would be termed stereotactic body radiation therapy. Finally, neurosurgical and radiation oncology coding experts developed new Current Procedural Terminology codes for cranial vault and spine radiosurgery, which were approved for use by the Relative Value Scale Update Committee as of 2009. The authors suggest that the neurosurgery strategy-which included 1) reasserting that all of the tasks of a radiosurgery procedure remain bundled, and 2) agreeing to limit the definition of radiosurgery to cranial vault and spine-has failed neurosurgeons who perform radiosurgery, and it may jeopardize patient access to this procedure in the future. The authors propose that all of the involved medical specialties recognize that the application of image-guided, focused radiation therapy throughout the body requires a partnership between radiation and surgical disciplines. They also urge surgeons to reexamine their coding methods, and they maintain that Current Procedural Terminology codes should be consistent across all of the different specialties involved in these procedures. Finally, surgeons should consider appropriate training in medical physics and radiobiology to perform the tasks involved in these specific procedures; ultimately all parties should receive equivalent reimbursement for similar assigned tasks, whether performed individually or jointly.

Setup accuracy of spine radiosurgery using cone beam computed tomography image guidance in patients with spinal implants

OBJECT

Cone beam computed tomography (CBCT) image guidance technology has been adopted for use in spine radiosurgery. There is concern regarding the ability to safely and accurately perform spine radiosurgery without the use of implanted fiducials for image guidance in postsurgical cases in which titanium instrumentation and/or methylmethacrylate (MMA) has been implanted. In this study the authors prospectively evaluated the accuracy of the patient setup for spine radiosurgery by using CBCT image guidance in the context of orthopedic hardware at the site of disease.

METHODS

The positioning deviations of 31 single-fraction spine radiosurgery treatments in patients with spinal implants were prospectively evaluated using the Elekta Synergy S 6-MV linear accelerator with a beam modulator and CBCT image guidance combined with a robotic couch that allows positioning correction in 3 translational and 3 rotational directions. To measure patient movement, 3 quality-assurance CBCT studies were performed and recorded: before, halfway through, and after radiosurgical treatment. The positioning data and fused images of planning CTs and CBCTs from the treatments were analyzed to determine intrafractional patient movements. From each of 3 CBCTs, 3 translational and 3 rotational coordinates were obtained.

RESULTS

The prescribed dose to the gross tumor volume for the cohort was 12-18 Gy (mean 14 Gy) utilizing 9-14 coplanar intensity-modulated radiation therapy (IMRT) beams (mean 10 beams). At the halfway point of the radiosurgery, the translational variations and standard deviations were 0.6 +/- 0.6, 0.4 +/- 0.4, and 0.5 +/- 0.5 mm in the lateral (X), longitudinal (Y), and anteroposterior (Z) directions, respectively. The magnitude of the 3D vector (X,Y,Z) was 1.1 +/- 0.7 mm. Similarly, the variations immediately after treatment were 0.5 +/- 0.3, 0.4 +/- 0.4, and 0.5 +/- 0.6 mm along the X, Y, and Z directions, respectively. The 3D vector was 1.0 +/- 0.6 mm. The mean rotational angles were 0.3 +/- 0.4, 0.5 +/- 0.6, and 0.3 +/- 0.4 degrees along yaw, roll, and pitch, respectively, at the halfway point and 0.3 +/- 0.4, 0.6 +/- 0.6, and 0.4 +/- 0.5 degrees immediately after treatment.

CONCLUSIONS

Cone beam CT image guidance used for patient setup for spine radiosurgery was highly accurate despite the presence of spinal instrumentation and/or MMA at the level of the target volume. The presence of such spinal implants does not preclude safe treatment via spine radiosurgery in these patients.

Control of brain metastases using frameless image-guided radiosurgery

Object

Radiosurgery is an important and well-accepted method in the management of brain metastases. Using conventional frame-based techniques, high lesional control rates are expected. The introduction of image-guided techniques allows for improved patient comfort and workflow. Some controversy exists as to the accuracy of imageguided techniques and consequently the impact they might have on control of brain metastases (as opposed to the level of control achieved with frame-based methods). The authors describe their initial 15-month experience with image-guided radiosurgery (IGRS) using Novalis with ExacTrac for management of brain metastases.

Methods

The authors reviewed the cases of brain metastasis treated by means of IGRS in their tertiary regional radiation oncology service over a 15-month period. During the study period 54 patients (median age 57.9 years) harboring 108 metastases were treated with IGRS. The median time from cancer diagnosis to development of brain metastasis was 12 months (range 0–144 months). The median tumor volume was 0.98 cm3 (range 0.03–19.07 cm3). The median prescribed dose was 18 Gy to the 80% isodose line (range 14–20 Gy). Lesions were followed with postradiosurgery MR imaging every 2–3 months following treatment.

Results

The median follow-up period was 9 months (range 0–20 months). Median actuarial survival was 8.6 months following IGRS. Eight patients with 18 lesions died within the first 2 months after the procedure, before scheduled follow-up imaging. Thus 90 lesions (in 46 patients) were followed up with imaging studies. Lesions that were unchanged or reduced in size were considered to be under control. The 6-month actuarial lesion control rate was 88%. Smaller lesions (< 1 cm3) had a statistically improved likelihood of complete imaging response (loss of all contrast-enhancement p = 0.01).

Conclusions

Image-guided radiosurgical treatment of brain metastases resulted in high rates of tumor control comparable to control rates reported for frame-based methods. High control rates were seen for small lesions in which spatial precision in dose delivery is critical. These data suggests that in regard to lesion control, IGRS using Novalis with ExacTrac is equivalent to frame-based radiosurgery methods.

Does intensity-modulated stereotactic radiotherapy achieve superior target conformity than conventional stereotactic radiotherapy in different intracranial tumours?

AIMS

To compare the dosimetric outcome of various conventional stereotactic radiotherapy (SRT) techniques with intensity-modulated stereotactic radiotherapy (IMSRT) in brain tumours of varying shape, size, location and proximity to organs at risk (OARs).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Fused computed tomography and magnetic resonance imaging datasets of four patients with different brain tumours previously treated with non-coplanar static conformal fields (SCF) were re-planned on the BrainScan treatment planning system using non-coplanar conformal arcs (CA), dynamic conformal arcs (DCA) and IMSRT with coplanar (IMSRT_CP) or non-coplanar (IMSRT_NCP) beam arrangement. Beam shaping and intensity modulation were carried out using a BrainLab micromultileaf collimator. The primary objective for each plan was to encompass >or=99% of the planning target volume (PTV) by >95% of the prescribed dose while minimising the dose to OARs.

RESULTS

The mean PTV coverage in SCF, CA, DCA, IMSRT_NCP and IMSRT_CP was 99.2, 99.5, 99.4, 99.2 and 99.2%, respectively. The highest dose within the target was <107% of the prescribed dose in all plans. Conformity was found to vary depending on the shape and location of the target. The best mean conformity index, ranging from 0.74 (CA) to 0.84 (IMSRT_NCP) was observed in spherical tumours. Among the three conventional SRT techniques, DCA and SCF appeared comparable (mean conformity index 0.72 and 0.71, respectively) and more conformal than CA (mean conformity index 0.67). In all cases, IMSRT showed better target conformity than conventional SRT techniques with a mean conformity index of 0.83 for non-coplanar and 0.81 for coplanar beam arrangement. The maximum improvement in conformity index was observed for IMSRT_NCP in complex, concave and irregularly shaped targets. The volume of normal brain and other OARs irradiated to high (>or=80%) and low (>or=30%) dose varied depending on the tumour shape, size, and location, but was essentially comparable in all three conventional SRT techniques. IMSRT (both coplanar as well as non-coplanar) reduced the volume of normal brain being irradiated to moderate to high doses compared with conventional SRT techniques, more so for large and irregular targets.

CONCLUSIONS

DCA and SCF are preferred conventional SRT techniques in terms of target conformity and reduction of doses to OARs. The use of IMSRT_NCP further improves conformity and reduces doses to OARs in a range of brain tumours commonly considered for stereotactic irradiation.

Dosimetric verification of micro-MLC based intensity modulated radiation therapy

A methodology for the dosimetric verification of micro-multileaf collimator MMLC) based intensity modulated radiation therapy (IMRT) plans intended for stereotactic applications is described. The procedure is similar to that of conventional IMRT patient-specific quality assurance with some notable exceptions. Relative dosimetry measurements are performed with radiographic film, a commercial film-scanning system and a dose-image registration program. Film dosimetry results are within +/- 3.0% of calculated distributions or within 2.0 mm distance to agreement. Absolute dosimetry measurements are performed with a small volume ion-chamber and a commercially available stereotactic phantom. The cumulative dose from all beams is within +/- 2.0 % of the prescribed dose. Large deviations may be observed from individual beams since the smaller IMRT fields tend to have very few high-dose and low-gradient regions. An independent program that examines the treatment MLC file is used to estimate the central axis dose from each beam and provide a dose image that can be assessed alongside the intended fluence distribution prior to treatment. Tolerances for relative and absolute dosimetry of MMLC-based IMRT treatments are tighter than what is typically reported for conventional MLC-based IMRT. Also, the time commitment for the IMRT QA is slightly longer than of conventional MLC-based IMRT due to QA processes which check the mechanical alignment of the MMLC device with the laser and radiation isocentre.

High-dose, single-fraction image-guided intensity-modulated radiotherapy for metastatic spinal lesions

PURPOSE

To report tumor control and toxicity for patients treated with image-guided intensity-modulated radiotherapy (RT) for spinal metastases with high-dose single-fraction RT.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

A total of 103 consecutive spinal metastases in 93 patients without high-grade epidural spinal cord compression were treated with image-guided intensity-modulated RT to doses of 18-24 Gy (median, 24 Gy) in a single fraction between 2003 and 2006. The spinal cord dose was limited to a 14-Gy maximal dose. The patients were prospectively examined every 3-4 months with clinical assessment and cross-sectional imaging.

RESULTS

The overall actuarial local control rate was 90% (local failure developed in 7 patients) at a median follow-up of 15 months (range, 2-45 months). The median time to local failure was 9 months (range, 2-15 months) from the time of treatment. Of the 93 patients, 37 died. The median overall survival was 15 months. In all cases, death was from progression of systemic disease and not local failure. The histologic type was not a statistically significant predictor of survival or local control. The radiation dose was a significant predictor of local control (p = 0.03). All patients without local failure also reported durable symptom palliation. Acute toxicity was mild (Grade 1-2). No case of radiculopathy or myelopathy has developed.

CONCLUSION

High-dose, single-fraction image-guided intensity-modulated RT is a noninvasive intervention that appears to be safe and very effective palliation for patients with spinal metastases, with minimal negative effects on quality of life and a high probability of tumor control.

Trilogy Image-Guided Stereotactic Radiosurgery

Full integration of advanced imaging, noninvasive immobilization, positioning, and motion-management methods into radiosurgery have resulted in fundamental changes in therapeutic strategies and approaches that are leading us to the treatment room of the future. With the introduction of image-guided radiosurgery (IGRS) systems, such as Trilogy, physicians have for the first time a practical means of routinely identifying and treating very small lesions throughout the body. Using new imaging processes such as positron emission tomography/computed tomography (PET/CT) scans, clinics may be able to detect these lesions and then eradicate them with image-guided stereotactic radiosurgery treatments. Thus, there is promise that cancer could be turned into a chronic disease, managed through a series of checkups, and Trilogy treatments when metastatic lesions reappear.

TG-69: Radiographic film for megavoltage beam dosimetry

TG-69 is a task group report of the AAPM on the use of radiographic film for dosimetry. Radiographic films have been used for radiation dosimetry since the discovery of x-rays and have become an integral part of dose verification for both routine quality assurance and for complex treatments such as soft wedges (dynamic and virtual), intensity modulated radiation therapy (IMRT), image guided radiation therapy (IGRT), and small field dosimetry like stereotactic radiosurgery. Film is convenient to use, spatially accurate, and provides a permanent record of the integrated two dimensional dose distributions. However, there are several challenges to obtaining high quality dosimetric results with film, namely, the dependence of optical density on photon energy, field size, depth, film batch sensitivity differences, film orientation, processing conditions, and scanner performance. Prior to the clinical implementation of a film dosimetry program, the film, processor, and scanner need to be tested to characterize them with respect to these variables. Also, the physicist must understand the basic characteristics of all components of film dosimetry systems. The primary mission of this task group report is to provide guidelines for film selection, irradiation, processing, scanning, and interpretation to allow the physicist to accurately and precisely measure dose with film. Additionally, we present the basic principles and characteristics of film, processors, and scanners. Procedural recommendations are made for each of the steps required for film dosimetry and guidance is given regarding expected levels of accuracy. Finally, some clinical applications of film dosimetry are discussed.

Advantages of mini-multileaf in stereotactic radiotherapy

Over the past few decades, cones of different diameter (12.5 mm to 40 mm) were used for treatment of intracranial lesions. These give very focused dose delivery to the target with minimum dose to outside normal brain tissues. This study is intended to compare the older method of arc-based stereotactic treatments using cones with the new mini-multileaf collimator (mMLC). Treatment plans are made for various sites of intracranial lesions with the cones and mMLC. In case of nonspherical lesions, more than one isocenter is used to get an optimum dose distribution with cones, while a single isocenter is sufficient with mMLC. Treatment plans are compared for irregular lesions using cones with multiple isocenters and mMLC. It is observed that conformity index and dose heterogeneity are better for mMLC based treatments.

Radiosurgery in Metastatic Brain Cancer

Radiosurgery offers patients with brain metastases an effective and minimally invasive treatment modality. Radiosurgery provides local tumor control and prolongs survival in select patients with brain metastases. This review will discuss numerous aspects of radiosurgery, including the various delivery techniques and radiobiology. Treatment recommendations will be outlined in view of the available clinical data. Although surgery or radiosurgery with whole-brain radiotherapy remains an important option for patients with a solitary brain metastasis, radiosurgery with or without whole-brain radiotherapy should be considered in patients with a limited number of small tumors and a good prognosis.

Stereotactic arc therapy for small elongated tumors using cones and collimator jaws; dosimetric and planning aspects

Stereotactic arc treatment of small intracranial tumors is usually performed with arcs collimated by circular cones, resulting in treatment volumes which are basically spherical. For nonspherical lesions this results in a suboptimal dose distribution. Multiple isocenters may improve the dose conformity for these lesions, at the cost of large overdosages in the target volume. To achieve improved dose conformity as well as dose homogeneity, the linac jaws (with a minimum distance of 1.0 cm to the central beam axis) can routinely be used to block part of the circular beams. The purpose of this study was to investigate the feasibility of blocking cones with diameters as small as 1.0 cm and a minimum distance between the jaw and the central beam axis of 0.3 cm. First, the reproducibility in jaw positioning and resulting dose delivery on the treatment unit were assessed. Second, the accuracy of the TPS dose calculation for these small fields was established. Finally, clinically applied treatment plans using nonblocked cones were compared with plans using the partially blocked cones for several treatment sites. The reproducibility in dose delivery on our Varian Clinac 2300 C/D machines on the central beam axis is 0.8% (1 SD). The accuracy of the treatment planning system dose calculation algorithm is critically dependent on the used fits for the penumbra and the phantom scatter. The average deviation of calculated from measured dose on the central beam axis is -1.0%+/-1.4% (1 SD), which is clinically acceptable. Partial cone blocking results in improved dose distributions for elongated tumors, such as vestibular schwannoma and uveal melanoma. Multiple isocenters may be avoided. The technique is easy to implement and requires no additional workload.

Stereotactic radiotherapy for treatment of cavernous sinus meningiomas

PURPOSE

To assess the safety and efficacy of stereotactic radiotherapy (SRT) using a linear accelerator equipped with a micromultileaf collimator for cavernous sinus meningiomas.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Forty-five patients with benign cavernous sinus meningiomas were treated with SRT between November 1997 and April 2002. Sixteen patients received definitive treatment on the basis of imaging characteristics of the cavernous sinus tumor. Twenty-nine patients received SRT either as immediate adjuvant treatment after incomplete resection or at documented recurrence. Treatment planning in all patients included CT-MRI image fusion and beam shaping using a micromultileaf collimator. The primary tumor volume varied from 1.41 to 65.66 cm(3) (median, 14.5 cm(3)). The tumor diameter varied from 1.4 to 7.4 cm (median, 3.8 cm). Tumor compressed the optic chiasm or optic nerve in 30 patients. All tumors were treated with a single isocenter plus a margin of normal parenchyma varying from 1 to 5 mm (median, 2.5 mm). The prescribed dose varied from 4250 to 5400 cGy (median, 5040 cGy). The prescription isodose varied from 87% to 95% (median, 90%). The maximal tumor dose varied from 5000 to 6000 cGy (median, 5600 cGy). The follow-up varied from 12 to 53 months (median, 36 months).

RESULTS

The actuarial 3-year overall and progression-free survival rate was 100% and 97.4%, respectively. One patient (2%) developed local relapsed at 18 months. A partial imaging response occurred in 18% of patients, and the tumor was stable in the remaining 80%. Preexisting neurologic complaints improved in 20% of patients and were stable in the remainder. No patient, tumor, or treatment factors were found to be predictive of imaging or clinical response. Transient acute morbidities included headache responsive to nonnarcotic analgesics in 4 patients, fatigue in 3 patients, and retroorbital pain in 1 patient. No treatment-induced peritumoral edema, cranial neuropathy, endocrine dysfunction, cognitive decline, or second malignancy occurred. One patient had an ipsilateral cerebrovascular accident 6 months after SRT.

CONCLUSION

Stereotactic radiotherapy is both safe and effective for patients with cavernous sinus meningiomas. Field shaping using a micromultileaf collimator allows conformal and homogeneous radiation of cavernous sinus meningiomas that may not be amenable to single-fraction stereotactic radiosurgery because of tumor size or location. Additional clinical experience is necessary to determine the position of SRT among the available innovative fractionated RT options for challenging skull base meningiomas.

An integrated treatment delivery system for CSRS and CSRT and clinical applications

An integrated treatment delivery system for conformal stereotactic radiosurgery (CSRS) and radiotherapy (CSRT) has been developed through a collaboration involving Siemens Medical Systems, Inc., Tyco/Radionics, Inc., and The University of Texas M. D. Anderson Cancer Center. The system consists of a 6-MV linear accelerator (LINAC) equipped with a Tyco/Radionics miniature multileaf collimator (mMLC). For the conventional SRS treatment, the circular collimator housing can be attached to the opening window of the mMLC. The treatment delivery system is integrated with a radiotherapy treatment planning system and a record-and-verify system. The purpose of this study is to report the characteristics, performance, benefits, and the clinical applications of this delivery system. The technical specifications of the LINAC and mMLC were tested, and all the specifications were met. The 80% to 20% penumbral width for each mMLC leaf is approximately 3 mm and is nearly independent of the off-axis positions of a leaf. The maximum interleaf leakage is 1.4% (1.1% on average) and the maximum intra-leaf leakage is 1.0% (0.9% on average). The leaf position precision is better than 0.5 mm for all the leaves. The integration of the SRS/SRT treatment planning system, mMLC, and LINAC has been evaluated successfully for transferring the patient treatment data file through radiotherapy treatment planning system to the patient information and treatment record-and-verify server and the mMLC controller. Subsequently, the auto-sequential treatment delivery for SRS, CSRS/CSRT, and the step-and-shoot intensity-modulated radiotherapy has also been tested successfully. The accuracy of dose delivery was evaluated for a 2-cm spherical target in a Radiological Physics Center SRS head phantom with GAFChromic films and TLD. Five non-coplanar arcs, using a 2-cm diameter circular collimator, were used for this simulation treatment. The accuracy to aim the center of the spherical target was within 0.5 mm and the deviation of dose delivery to the isocenter of the target was within 2% of the calculated dose. For the irregularly shaped tumor, a tissue-equivalent head phantom was used to evaluate the accuracy of dose delivery for using either geometric conformal treatment or IMRT. The accuracy of dose delivery to the isocenter was within 2% and 3% of the calculated dose, respectively. From October 26, 1999 to September 30, 2002, we treated over 400 SRS patients and 70 SRT patients. Four representative cases are presented to illustrate the capabilities of this dedicated unit in performing conventional SRS, CSRS, and CSRT. For all the cases, the geometric conformal-plan dose distributions showed a high degree of conformity to the target shape. The degree of conformity can be evaluated using the target-volume-ratio (TVR). Our preferred TVR values for highly conformed dose distributions range from 1.6 to 2.0. The patient setup reproducibility for the Gill-Thomas-Cosman (GTC) noninvasive head frame ranges from 0.5 to 1 mm, and the head and neck noninvasive frame is within 2 mm. The integrated treatment delivery system offers excellent conformation for complicated planning target volumes with the stereotactic setup approach, ensuring that dose delivery can be achieved within the specified accuracy. In addition, the treatment time is comparable with that of single isocenter multiple-arc treatments.

Measurement of beam-axis displacement from the isocenter during three-dimensional conformal radiosurgery with a micro-multileaf collimator

We describe the displacement of the beam-axis from the planning isocenter in clinical situations during three-dimensional conformal radiosurgery using an Acculeaf bi-directional micro-multileaf collimator. The displacements were recorded for 64 ports using a video imaging system and a stereotactic arc. The mean displacement was 0.41+/-0.25 mm.

Intensity-modulated stereotactic radiotherapy vs. stereotactic conformal radiotherapy for the treatment of meningioma located predominantly in the skull base

PURPOSE

This study evaluates a possible advantage of intensity-modulated stereotactic radiotherapy (IMSRT) over stereotactic conformal radiotherapy (SCRT) in the treatment of lesions in the base of the skull.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Ten patients (7 with a skull base meningioma) planned for routine SCRT were replanned for IMSRT. The criteria for comparison were the same for both methods: optimal dose to the planning target volume (PTV) and optimal sparing of the organs at risk (OAR). For SCRT, sparing of OAR was achieved by conformal avoidance using 5-6 fields. The IMSRT inverse planning process used optimized OAR sparing through user-defined dose constraints. Dose to the PTV and OAR were assessed by dose-volume histograms, maximum dose, 2 conformity indices, and volumes of relevant isodoses.

RESULTS

The conformity index is consistently higher for IMSRT, the largest improvement being for the multifocal and irregular cases. Volumes of the 90% and 80% isodoses were smaller for IMSRT, whereas the volume of the 30% isodose was larger for IMSRT in 6 cases. The maximum dose was consistently higher for IMSRT (mean values 102% and 108% for SCRT and IMSRT, respectively). Sparing of OAR was better with IMSRT, especially for those OARs situated in or near a concave PTV.

CONCLUSIONS

In terms of PTV coverage, there is an advantage in using IMSRT for all target shapes, but especially for irregular and concave targets. The dose to OAR is lower with IMSRT, although the volume of normal tissue receiving a low dose can be larger than for SCRT.

Multivariate analysis of clinical prognostic factors in patients with glioblastoma multiforme treated with a combined modality approach

We investigated the influence of various clinical prognostic factors in patients with glioblastoma multiforme (GBM) treated with a combined modality approach. A total of 175 patients with GBM was treated in four consecutive prospective phase II studies using surgery, hyperfractionated or accelerated hyperfractionated radiotherapy (RT) and either adjuvant or concurrent or pre-irradiation chemotherapy (CHT) between January 1988 and December 1993. The median survival time for all 175 patients was 14 months and 1-3-year survival (OS) rates were 57%, 34% and 24%, respectively. The median time to tumour progression was 12 months, and 1-3-year progression-free survival (PFS) rates were 43%, 11% and 7%, respectively. Survival analysis showed that of all investigated prognostic factors, only gender did not influence survival. Patients </=55 years did better than those >55 years; patients with KPS 80-100 did better than those with KPS 50-70; patients with frontal tumours did better than those with tumours in other locations; patients with tumours up to 4 cm did better than those with larger tumours, as did patients with either subtotal or gross total tumour resection when compared to those undergoing biopsy only. Multivariate analysis showed that gender and tumour location did not independently influence survival. When PFS was used as the endpoint, only gender did not influence PFS, as confirmed by multivariate analysis.

Dynamic conical conformal radiotherapy using a C-arm-mounted accelerator: dose distribution and clinical application

PURPOSE

The aim of this study was to solve anisotropy in the dose distributions from rotational conformal radiotherapy (RCRT) by using a C-arm-mounted accelerator.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The linac head was designed to move along the C-arm with a maximum angle of 60 degrees (from a vertical position toward the gantry). Simultaneous rotation of the gantry creates a dynamic conical irradiation technique. Dynamic conical conformal radiation therapy (Dyconic CRT) was developed by combining the technique with continuous motion of a multileaf collimator. Dose distributions were measured in phantoms using film densitometry and compared with conventional RCRT. Dose distributions in actual radiation therapy patients are also presented.

RESULTS

Dyconic CRT enabled the precise delivery of noncoplanar beams without rotating the table. The measurements showed that three-dimensionally isotropic dose falloff was achieved with Dyconic CRT. Dose inhomogeneity in the sagittal direction with Dyconic CRT was compensated for by use of wedge filters.

CONCLUSIONS

The drawbacks of the dose distributions produced by RCRT were overcome with the use of Dyconic CRT.

Treatment planning for stereotactic radiosurgery with photon beams

Stereotactic Radiosurgery (SRS) has evolved as a unique discipline that combines aspects of both surgery and radiation oncology. Technological developments in the past few decades have provided a wide array of treatment techniques, including (i) the Gamma Knife; (ii) Linac-based stereotactic techniques using circular collimators or using micro multileaf collimators (mMLCs); (iii) the Cyber Knife, using an x-band linac mounted on a robotic arm; and (iv) serial and spiral tomotherapy. This paper provides a review of the treatment planning methods for stereotactic radiosurgery. Because of the differences in planning strategies used for each SRS technique, this paper will provide both a general review of the pre-requisites and common features of SRS treatment planning and the planning techniques specific to each of the SRS techniques.

Gentlemen (and ladies), choose your weapons: Gamma knife vs. linear accelerator radiosurgery

This article compares and contrasts Gamma Knife radiosurgery with linear accelerator-based radiosurgery; where appropriate, Cyberknife technology is discussed. Topics covered are: positioning of the head (invasive versus non-invasive positioning systems); collimator construction; beam properties; beam arrangements; treatment planning; and issues regarding manpower (including a discussion of patient repositioning during treatment), machine availability, and financial considerations.

Impact of a micromultileaf collimator on stereotactic radiotherapy of uveal melanoma

PURPOSE

To evaluate the impact of a micro multileaf collimator (mMLC) on Linac-based stereotactic radiotherapy (SRT) of uveal melanoma by comparing circular arc with static conformal, dynamic arc, and intensity-modulated SRT.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Forty uveal melanoma patients were selected from approximately 100 patients treated with SRT since 1996. For each patient, four treatment plans (BrainSCAN XL, V5.0) were made: conventional arc, static conformal, dynamic arc plan, and intensity-modulated radiotherapy (IMRT). The goal of treatment planning was to fully encompass the planning target volume (PTV) by the 80% isodose while minimizing doses to the optic nerve and lens. The following parameters were evaluated: target conformity; target homogeneity; ratio of the target volume and 50% isodose volume; normal tissue receiving doses >/=80%, >/=50%, and >/=20%; central nervous system volume irradiated to >/=20%; optical nerve volume irradiated >/=50%, D(max) of the lens; lens volume receiving >/=20%; and monitor units.

RESULTS

PTVs ranged from 0.68 to 4.90 cm(3) (mean 1.97 +/- 0.97 cm(3)). The average reduction of the prescription isodose volume was 1-1.5 cm(3) for conformal (range 2.6-0.3 cm(3)), dynamic arc (range 2.5-0.3 cm(3)), and IMRT plans (range 3.9-0.1 cm(3)), compared with conventional arc therapy. Central nervous system volumes irradiated to doses >/=20% were smallest for conventional or dynamic arc treatments. Average target dose homogeneity values were 1.74 +/- 0.50 for arc, 1.27 +/- 0.02 for static mMLC, 1.26 +/- 0.01 for dynamic arc, and 1.15 +/- 0.03 for IMRT plans. IMRT helped to reduce doses to the lens but did not provide an advantage for optical nerve sparing. When applying IMRT, the monitor units increased by approximately one-third compared with static mMLC-based SRT.

CONCLUSIONS

Conformal mMLC and dynamic arc SRT are the treatment options of choice for Linac-based SRT of uveal melanoma. They present dosimetric advantages, while being highly efficient in treatment planning and delivery.

Comparison of intensity-modulated radiosurgery with gamma knife radiosurgery for challenging skull base lesions

PURPOSE

To quantitatively compare intensity-modulated radiosurgery (IMRS) using 3-mm mini-multileaf collimation with gamma knife radiosurgery (GKRS) plans for irregularly shaped skull base lesions in direct proximity to organs at risk (OAR).

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Ten challenging skull base lesions originally treated with GKRS were selected for comparison with IMRS using inverse treatment planning and 3-mm mini-multileaf collimation operating in step-and-shoot delivery mode. The lesions ranged in volume from 1.6 to 32.2 cm(3) and were treated with 9-20 GK isocenters (mean 13.2). The IMRS plans were designed with the intent to, at minimum, match the GKRS plans with regard to OAR sparing and target coverage. For each case, IMRS plans were generated using 9 coplanar, 11 equally spaced noncoplanar, and 11 OAR-avoidant noncoplanar beams; the best of these approaches with respect to target conformality, sparing of OAR, and maintaining coverage was selected for comparison with the original GKRS plan.

RESULTS

Assuming no patient motion or setup error, IMRS provided comparable target coverage and sparing of OAR and an improved conformity index at the prescription isodose contour but sometimes less conformity at lower isodose contours compared with the actual GKRS plan. All IMRS plans produced less target dose heterogeneity and shorter estimated treatment times compared with the GKRS plans.

CONCLUSION

Compared with GKRS for complex skull base lesions, IMRS plans using a 3-mm mini-multileaf collimator achieved comparable or sometimes improved target coverage, conformity, and critical structure sparing with shorter estimated treatment times.

Gamma knife radiosurgery and its possible relationship to malignancy: a review

✓ The question has been raised recently whether gamma knife radiosurgery (GKS) can induce secondary neoplasia. Because there is little or no detailed knowledge about this potential complication, background information culled from the radiotherapy literature is reviewed as a guide to the clinical situations in which radiotherapy may induce secondary neoplastic change. Available case reports are then reviewed and discussed against the background of the current knowledge. On the basis of the review, the following suggestions are proposed on how to limiting the extent of this complication, document its frequency, and inform patients. It should be remembered that: the benefits of GKS are great; its alternatives also have risks; there often are no alternatives to GKS; follow-up documentation should be pursued more actively so that, if possible, no patient falls through the net; practitioners should be proactive in defining the problem, and genetic analysis of tumor biopsy specimens obtained in patients who will undergo or have undergone GKS should become routine; the extent of secondary neoplasia is not known; and patient information should be guided by what is known rather than by what is feared.

Dosimetric characteristics of Novalis shaped beam surgery unit

The dosimetric characteristics of a new dedicated radiosurgical treatment unit are systematically measured in terms of its percent depth dose, beam profile, and relative scatter factor. High-resolution diode detector, mini-ion-chamber detector, and conventional Kodak XV films are used to measure dosimetric data for a range of field sizes from 6x6 mm to 100x100 mm. The effects of collimator size, micro-multileaf collimator shape, and detector type on the dosimetric data are investigated. Results indicate that, with careful design, accurate dosimetric data could be acquired using either a dedicated diode detector or a mini-ion-chamber detector, and film detector. Special attention is required when measuring dosimetric data for small field sizes such as 6x6 mm.