The reproducibility and relationship between single and fractionated dose estimates of the surviving fraction at 2 Gy

Discrimination of human tumor radioresponsiveness using low-dose rate irradiation

PURPOSE

Evaluation of the theoretical and practical value of using low-dose rate (LDR) irradiation to increase the resolution of radiosensitivity testing of primary human tumors using clonogenic assays.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Fourteen human tumor cell lines were assessed for surviving fraction at 2-8 Gy (SF2-SF8) using low-dose rate irradiation and a clonogenic assay. Further data were collected from the literature for 64 low-dose rate irradiation survival curves from human tumor cell lines. The data were grouped into five different radioresponsiveness categories (A-E). An analysis was made of the ability of the graded survival levels to discriminate between the different radioresponse groups and compared with previous analyses for high-dose rate SF2. Fifteen human cervical carcinoma specimens were analysed for SF2 and SF3.5 following high- and low-dose rate irradiation.

RESULTS

Low-dose rate irradiation increased the spread of tumor cell line radiosensitivity data and the ability to discriminate between radioresponse groups was greater at low than at high-dose rates. Using low-dose rate irradiation on primary tumor specimens and a soft agar clonogenic assay decreased the success rate in obtaining data. The latter dropped from 70% for high-dose rate SF2 to 51% for low-dose rate SF3.5.

CONCLUSIONS

The work on cell lines illustrates that low-dose rate irradiation does improve the ability of clonogenic radiosensitivity measurements to discriminate between tumors of different radioresponsiveness groups. However, using low-dose rate irradiation on primary human tumors with a soft agar clonogenic assay was not practical because of reducing the success rate for obtaining data for radiosensitivity measurements.

Enhancement of fractionated-dose irradiation by retinoic acid plus interferon

PURPOSE

To evaluate the relative cytotoxicity of fractionated-dose radiation in the presence and absence of 13-cis-retinoic acid (RA) plus alpha-2a-interferon (IFN), as a function of overall treatment time.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Studies were performed with the human squamous cell carcinoma line FaDu, in vitro. Attached exponential phase cells were treated with RA + IFN for 8-10 h and then exposed to single graded doses of radiation, or 1 to 6 doses of radiation at 2 Gy per dose, or to 5 doses of radiation at 2 Gy/dose with a time interval of 4-24 h between treatments. Following irradiation, the cells were incubated with drugs present throughout colony formation, and the fraction of survivors in the presence and absence of the combined drugs was calculated.

RESULTS

For single graded-dose irradiation, the surviving fraction ratio at 2 Gy in the absence vs. presence of drugs was 1.27 +/- 0.19 in 3 repeat experiments. Following administration of 6 doses of radiation at 2 Gy/fraction with a 5-h time interval between treatments and, after correcting for cell proliferation between treatments, the surviving fractions differed by a factor of 3.25, again indicating an average difference in survival of 1.26 after each of the 6 2-Gy/fractions. Treatment with 5 2-Gy doses of irradiation with 24 vs. 4 h elapsing between doses, resulted in a 3-fold greater decrease in survival in the presence of drugs vs. no drug. The relatively greater cell kill due to 24 vs. 4 h between treatments was due to drug inhibition of cell proliferation between the more prolonged treatments.

CONCLUSIONS

The results of this study indicate that retinoic acid plus interferon both sensitizes and inhibits cell proliferation during treatment. These results suggest that this combination of radiation and drugs, when used concurrently, may be effective for inhibiting tumor cell proliferation or accelerated repopulation during clinical fractionated radiotherapy.