Early histopathologic changes in experimentally replanted extremities

Scoring of skin rejection in a swine composite tissue allograft model

BACKGROUND

For the first time, we define and correlate visual and histologic grading systems of composite tissue allograft (CTA) skin rejection in a large-animal model and determine the utility of these grading systems for early diagnosis and monitoring of rejection.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Sixteen pairs of outbred swine underwent transplant of a forelimb osteomyocutaneous free flap. Group I (n = 6) did not receive immunosuppressive therapy. Group II (n = 10) received oral cyclosporin A, mycophenolate mofetil, and prednisone. The flap was visually inspected and protocol skin biopsies were taken at frequent intervals over a 90-day period. Visual Grades 0 (no rejection) to 4 (severe rejection) were assigned based on skin color, bleeding from biopsy site, and blister formation. Histologic Grades 0 to 4 were assigned based on the degree of vasculitis, folliculitis, dermal inflammation, and epidermal degeneration present.

RESULTS

All Group I animals progressively rejected their graft by Day 7. Group II grafts survived from 19 and 90 days; 93% of 115 biopsy specimens were read to be within +/-1 histologic score of their assigned flap visual grade. Visual assessment carried an 8% false positive and 39% false negative rate with regard to biopsy-proven rejection. However, 81% of missed rejection specimens were histologic Grade 1. Biopsy, when visually indicated, would detect all rejection episodes when histologically Grade 1 or 2 and still potentially reversible.

CONCLUSIONS

Visual scoring of CTA skin serves as a useful tool for initially detecting rejection, but repeated histologic evaluation is necessary for monitoring the subsequent course of the graft.

Rejection of the component tissues of limb allografts in rats immunosuppressed with FK-506 and cyclosporine

One-hundred and fourteen limb transplantations have been performed across a major histoincompatibility barrier between donor ACI (RT1a) and recipient Lewis (RT1l) rats immunosuppressed with various dosages of FK-506 and cyclosporine. Three-hundred and thirty biopsy specimens from 64 animals have been evaluated histologically for signs of rejection. A new histologic grading system is introduced to classify the process of rejection in the component tissues (skin, muscle, bone, and articular cartilage) of a limb allograft. The results indicate that FK-506 is a more potent immunosuppressive agent than cyclosporine in preventing the rejection of the skin component of a limb transplant. With twice-weekly intermittent immunosuppression with FK-506, the rejection of muscle, bone, and cartilage can be prevented for an indefinite time, although all long-term surviving animals died at around 300 days, probably of graft-versus-host disease. Based on the histologic stages of rejection in the different tissues at the same point in time, it is evident that each component tissue of a limb transplant rejects over a different time period. This probably reflects a hierarchy of antigenicity, with skin being most antigenic, muscle being intermediate in antigenicity, and bone and cartilage being least antigenic. Although this grading system is not the ultimate solution, it may allow a more objective comparison of experimental limb transplantation in the future.