Blunt pediatric head trauma requiring neurosurgical intervention: how subtle can it be?

The Relationship between Risk Factors of Head Trauma with CT Scan Findings in Children with Minor Head Trauma Admitted to Hospital

BACKGROUND:

In emergency medicine for determining the intracranial injury (ICI) in children with head trauma, usually brain CT scan is performed. Since brain CT scan, especially in children, has some disadvantages, it is better to find a procedure which could help to choose only the children with real head trauma injury for brain CT scan.

AIMS:

The aim of this study is to find such procedure. This study was descriptive, analytic and non-interventional.

METHODS:

We reviewed the archived files of children with head trauma injuries referred to the emergency department of Imam Hossein Hospital within two years. Patient’s CT scan findings and head trauma risk factors were evaluated in this study.

RESULTS:

Out of 368 patients, 326 patients had normal brain CT scan. 28 of them showed symptoms of ICI consisting intraventricular haemorrhage (IVH), contusion, subarachnoid haemorrhage (SAH), subdural haemorrhage (SDH), epidural hematoma (EDH), and pneumocephalus. Twenty-seven patients showed skull FX, which 14 of them had an Isolated fracture, and 13 of them also showed symptoms of ICI. Since patients with isolated FX usually discharge quickly from Emergency Department; their data did not include in results of the study. The patients have been divided into two groups: 1- ICI, 2- without ICI. RR (relative risk), CI (Confidence interval) and sensitivity, positive predictive value (PPV), negative predictive value (NPV) and association of these risk factors with ICI were assessed with the Chi-2 test. In the end to determine the indications of CT scan, the presence of one of these five risk factors is important including abnormal mental status, clinical symptoms of skull FX, history of vomiting, craniofacial soft tissue injury (including subgaleal hematomas or laceration) and headache.

CONCLUSIONS:

For all other patients without these risk factors, observation and Follow Up can be used which has more advantages and less cost.

Neurologically intact children with an isolated skull fracture may be safely discharged after brief observation

PURPOSE

The management of children presenting with an isolated skull fracture (ISF) posttrauma is highly variable. We sought to estimate the risk of neurologic deterioration in children with a Glasgow coma score (GCS) 15 and ISF to reduce unnecessary hospital admissions.

METHODS

A retrospective review at a level I pediatric trauma referral center was conducted for patients with ISF on head computed tomography from 2003 to 2008. Patients were excluded for injury greater than 24 hours prior, GCS less than 15, intracranial pathology, significant fracture depression, or complex fractures involving facial bones or skull base.

RESULTS

A total of 235 patients were identified with an ISF. The median age was 11 months, with falls accounting for 87% of the injuries. One hundred seventy-seven patients were admitted, and 58 patients were discharged from the emergency department after a period of observation (median, 3.3 hours). Median length of stay for those admitted to the hospital was 18.2 hours. One patient developed vomiting following overnight observation and a repeat computed tomography scan demonstrated a small extra-axial hematoma that required no intervention. The mean total costs for patients discharged from the emergency department were $291 vs $1447 for those admitted for observation (P < .001).

CONCLUSION

Patients with a presenting GCS of 15 and an ISF can be safely discharged from the emergency department after a short period of observation if they are asymptomatic and have a reliable social environment. This could result in significant savings by eliminating inpatient costs.

Age differences in brain injury characteristics

PURPOSE

Traumatic brain injury (TBI) is an important cause of morbidity and mortality in children. Despite the high incidence of head injury among children, the mortality rate is low. There is a lack of studies that describe children's age-specific symptoms in relation to outcome. The purpose is to investigate if other described symptoms could be used as a predictor of intracranial injury in children.

METHODS

Retrospective review of data from all children who during 1 year were admitted due to a brain injury.

RESULTS

During 1 year 724 children visited the ED due to a brain injury. A significant difference was found between age groups and other documented initial symptoms, but no single symptoms could be used as a predictor for intracranial injury.

CONCLUSION

Unconsciousness as a predictor for brain injury should be used with caution in children. Significant differences were found in other documented symptoms between age groups.

Population-based study of paediatric head injury

AIM

There is a paucity of population-based studies regarding the spectrum of paediatric head injury from mild through serious to fatal paediatric head injury. The aims of the present study were to determine the incidence, demographics and outcome of significant head injury in a state-wide population of children aged 0-15 years. A secondary aim was to determine if any serious head injuries were being missed under the current management protocols of the state-wide trauma system.

METHODS

A retrospective review of significant head injury in all paediatric patients over a period of 2 years was undertaken. Data were collected from the Victorian State Trauma Outcome Registry and Monitoring database, the Victorian Emergency Minimum Dataset and from the Victorian Institute of Forensic Medicine.

RESULTS

The incidence of paediatric head injury in Victoria over the 2-year period was 765 per 100000 per year. The incidence of admitted head injuries was 75 per 100000 per year and the incidence of significant head injury was seven per 100000 or 151 children. Forty-one per cent of these injuries required surgical intervention. Mortality was 1.6 children per 100000. All patients who died presented with a Glasgow Coma Score (GCS) of 3 and had multiple other risk factors. There were no deaths in patients discharged from hospital. Demographic and clinical factors associated with higher mortality and morbidity was determined.

CONCLUSION

The incidence of significant paediatric head injury was low. Deaths occurred early and were always associated with significant early clinical features of severe head injury. This highlights the importance of strategies for the prevention of head injuries. There appeared to be no serious head injuries missed during the study period.

Pediatric minor traumatic brain injury

The literature surrounding minor traumatic brain injury is complex, methodologically challenging, and controversial. Although we lack a consistent standardized definition, the annual rate is likely in excess of 200 per 100,000 children. The proportion of children with minor traumatic brain injury who will require neurosurgery is certainly <1%. Several studies are underway that have the potential to significantly advance our understanding of the specific risk factors for intracranial injury and more specifically neurosurgical injury. The mortality within children is very low, with estimates of 0% to 0.25%. Virtually all studies of the prognosis of minor brain injury in children have reported no long-term behavioral or cognitive sequelae as a specific result of the brain injury. Symptoms fall in 4 domains: somatic, cognitive, sleep/fatigue, and affective. Limited pediatric studies are available to assist clinicians in the prognosis or in optimizing recovery. Until further studies are available, a conservative approach is recommended. Children with suspected concussions should be removed from activity and observed. Children with symptomatic concussions must be limited to no physical activity. Adolescents and families need to self-monitor symptoms and limit environments or circumstances that exacerbate any symptoms. When symptoms resolve, a gradual progressive return to play is currently recommended. The recurrence risk for subsequent concussions is elevated, but there is limited documentation of the effectiveness of preventative efforts. Much remains to be learned.

Pediatric minor closed head injury

Many studies have found conflicting evidence over the use of clinical indicators to predict intracranial injury in pediatric mild head injury. Although altered mental status, loss of consciousness, and abnormal neurologic examination have all been found to be more prevalent among head-injured children, studies have observed inconsistent results over their specificity and predictive value. Children older than 2 years have been evaluated, managed, and studied differently than those less than 2 years old. Evidence strongly supports a lower threshold to perform a CT scan in younger children because they have a higher risk of significant brain injury after blunt head trauma.