Proximal toe phalanx transplantation for bony stabilization and lengthening of partially aplastic digits

Non-vascularized toe phalanx transfer for correction of severe clinodactyly of the thumb in Rubinstein-Taybi syndrome

In Rubinstein-Taybi syndrome, patients may have a particularly severe clinodactyly of the thumb. We evaluated a new method for correction of these severe clinodactylies using non-vascularized toe phalanx transfer as a replacement for the abnormal delta phalanx. Results of the new technique are presented, together with those of an osteotomy technique. We retrospectively recorded the angle of the clinodactyly before and after surgery and at long-term follow-up of 11 osteotomies and five transfers in nine patients from 1990 to 2017. The pre-operative angle of clinodactyli was similar between the two groups with a mean of 59°. After surgery, the correction was equivalent (7° and 11°). At the last follow-up (7 and 18 years), the relapse of clinodactyly was 17° for osteotomies and 1° for phalanx transfers. We noticed growth of the transferred phalanx, resulting in an excellent thumb length. We conclude that non-vascularized toe transfer can be an effective correction of severe clinodactyly and may be more stable than osteotomy in the long-term.Level of evidence: IV.

Long-term donor site morbidity after free nonvascularized toe phalangeal transfer

PURPOSE

Free nonvascularized toe phalangeal transfer is an established surgical option for the reconstruction of hypoplastic digits. This study assessed long-term morbidity in the feet using this technique.

METHODS

We reviewed 40 children treated between 1991 and 2007 by free nonvascularized toe phalangeal transfer. The diagnosis was digital hypoplasia resulting from symbrachydactyly in 33 cases, constriction ring syndrome in 3 cases, thumb hypoplasia in 3 cases, and perinatal subclavian venous thrombosis in 1 case. The patients were followed up after surgery for a mean of 10 years (range, 3-19 y). The Oxford Ankle Foot Questionnaire was administered to patients and families to assess patient symptoms and patient and parental satisfaction. We assessed toe length ratio, the presence of visible deformity, and distal hypoplasia of the donor toes clinically and radiographically.

RESULTS

Emotional problems related to foot appearance were common. We also found functional problems with footwear in some patients. All patients had floppy unstable toes with visible deformity. Increasing foot deformity was seen with growth, which led to deterioration in foot aesthetics, particularly where multiple donor toes had been harvested. We identified distal and middle phalangeal and metatarsal hypoplasia in the donor toes.

CONCLUSIONS

Donor site morbidity for free toe phalangeal transfer is greater than previously documented. This should be considered during surgical decision making for reconstruction of hypoplastic digits. Preoperative counseling should include discussion regarding possible consequences of phalangeal harvest on donor toes and options for donor site reconstruction. Long-term follow-up of the donor site is essential to accurately assess results.

TYPE OF STUDY/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Therapeutic III.

Post-traumatic distal interphalangeal finger joint reconstruction using a free hemi-joint transfer from the fifth toe middle phalanx

We present three cases of finger distal interphalangeal joint reconstruction in children using a new donor site, the middle phalanx of the fifth toe, transferred as a non-vascularized graft. The patients were followed a minimum of 36 months with serial radiographs, magnetic resonance imaging and photographs. Alignment was improved and persisting growth was demonstrated in all cases. Postoperative magnetic resonance imaging of the grafted phalanx and control toe showed comparable signals. The absence of a proximal epiphysis of these toe phalanges may have an important role in their survival after free transplantation, and may promote continued growth.

[Classification and treatment of symbrachydactyly. A series of 117 cases]

In the present study, a modification has been proposed of the Blauth and Gekeler classification, aimed at a more accurate definition of appropriate surgical treatment. An analysis was made of a series of 120 cases of symbrachydactyly (117 patients); however, surgery was only performed in 86 cases (51 toe transfers in 49 patients; mean age at surgery 12 months). Type I included the separation of short and sometimes stiff fingers; type II, the 'pseudo-cleft', could be subdivided into three groups. Type IIA included those hands with more than two long and frequently hypoplastic digits, regarding which a decision had to be made between removal of rudimentary fingers or their stabilization. In type IIB, hand function was good and surgery was rarely needed. Type III (monodactylous) could also be subdivided into two categories, i.e., normal thumb in type IIIA and hypoplasia in IIIB. Finally, in type IVA, toe transfer surgery was performed on condition that wrist mobility was sufficient to compensate for the insufficient mobility of the artificial thumb on the anterior aspect of the radius. In all cases, a weak but useful pincer movement was obtained, with poor cosmetic results. In the case of toe transfers, surgery was advocated before the age of one year; and although mobility was disappointing (35 degrees active motion), good growth and excellent discrimination (5 mm on average) was observed. Symbrachydactyly is a fairly frequent congenital malformation; its diverse clinical features require a precise classification to better determine adequate treatment management.