Femoral expansion in total hip arthroplasty

Long-term survival of the cemented Müller CDH stem: a minimum follow-up of 10 years

INTRODUCTION

Total hip arthroplasty in patients with altered anatomy of the hip and femur, such as in congenital dysplasia of the hip, is challenging and often requires specially designed stems. Müller straight stems have shown excellent long-term results; however, long-term data on the analogous cemented Müller CDH stem are still missing. The aim of this study was to analyze long-term survival, identify potential risk factors for aseptic loosening, and analyze radiological outcome of the cemented Müller CDH stems.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Between 01/1985 and 06/2005, 95 Müller CDH stems (Zimmer, Winterthur, Switzerland) made up of 3 different materials were cemented using 2 different bone cements: 38 of stainless steel/high-viscosity cement, 31 of a cobalt-chrome-based alloy (CoCr)/low-viscosity cement, and 26 of a titanium-based alloy (Ti)/low-viscosity cement. All patients had a prospective clinical and radiological follow-up according to the standards of our institution. The cumulative incidence for revision of the stem was calculated using a competing risk model. To identify demographic and implant-related risk factors for aseptic loosening of the stem, a multivariate regression model for competing risks was performed.

RESULTS

The cumulative risk of revision at 15 years was 12.5% (95% CI 6.6-20.5%) for aseptic loosening of the stem as endpoint, with marked differences for the various stem materials used: stainless steel 2.7% (0.2-12.3%), CoCr 12.9% (4.0-27.3%), and Ti 24.5% (9.6-43.1%). Regression modeling revealed that Ti stems in combination with low-viscosity cement (HR 10.2) and implantation with an axis deviation greater than 3° (HR 3.8) are risk factors for aseptic loosening.

CONCLUSIONS

Long-term survival of the cemented Müller CDH stem is comparable to other Müller-type straight stems and uncemented implants. Similar to the original Ti Müller straight stem, the Ti Müller CDH stem also showed an increased risk for aseptic loosening and should, therefore, no longer be used.

Dynamics of femoral bone remodelling in well fixed total hip arthroplasty. A 20-year follow-up of 20 hips

The aim of our study was to investigate the dynamics of cortical thinning around well fixed cemented Muller straight stems without osteolysis at different time periods during long term follow-up. We investigated patients operated on for osteoarthritis with a cemented Muller straight stem, all with more than 15 years follow-up and no radiological signs of osteolysis. Cortical thinning in 20 THA hips (19 patients) followed for a mean of 20 (16 to 22) years was measured medially and laterally at six levels from the first postoperative, five, 10 years and the last follow-up x-rays. Sixty percent of observed cortical thinning occurred during the first five postoperative years, which was more evident proximally. We conclude that significantly greater cortical bone loss occurs around cemented Muller straight stems during the first five years, than is seen subsequently. We feel that this is a non-pathological process mainly related to the Muller straight stem.

Effect of bone type on clinical and radiographic outcomes of a proximally-coated cementless stem in primary total hip arthroplasties

We determined the effect of pre-operative bone structure upon the temporal effects of remodeling after total hip arthroplasty (THA) in a series of uncemented implants. We evaluated 345 patients (375 hips), who had either Dorr Type-A (238 hips) or Type-B (137 hips) bone, and who received a proximally-coated cementless THA and were followed for a mean of 6 years. Outcomes evaluated included aseptic survivorship, Harris hip scores, and radiographic evaluation for patterns of remodeling. The aseptic survivorship (97.5% vs. 98%) and the mean final Harris hip scores (92 vs. 94 points) were similar between Types-A and -B bone, respectively. Bone remodeling was seen significantly earlier and over a longer duration for patients who had Type-B bone. At 5-years, periprosthetic condensation (78% vs. 54%) and cortical hypertrophy (53% vs. 37%) were significantly higher and radiolucencies at any zone were lower (53% vs. 37%) in Type-B compared to Type-A bone. There was increased condensation in men and higher cortical hypertrophy in women. Various radiographic remodeling differences may not negatively impact clinical outcome at mid-term follow-up. Morphologic bone type appears to be predictive of physiologic response to loading.

Is the length of the femoral component important in primary total hip replacement?

Many different lengths of stem are available for use in primary total hip replacement, and the morphology of the proximal femur varies greatly. The more recently developed shortened stems provide a distribution of stress which closely mimics that of the native femur. Shortening the femoral component potentially comes at the cost of decreased initial stability. Clinical studies on the performance of shortened cemented and cementless stems are promising, although long-term follow-up studies are lacking. We provide an overview of the current literature on the anatomical features of the proximal femur and the biomechanical aspects and clinical outcomes associated with the length of the femoral component in primary hip replacement, and suggest a classification system for the length of femoral stems.

Cemented Müller straight stem total hip replacement: 18 year survival, clinical and radiological outcomes

AIM: To present the 18 year survival and the clinical and radiological outcomes of the Müller straight stem, cemented, total hip arthroplasty (THA).

METHODS: Between 1989 and 2007, 176 primary total hip arthroplasties in 164 consecutive patients were performed in our institution by the senior author. All patients received a Müller cemented straight stem and a cemented polyethylene liner. The mean age of the patients was 62 years (45-78). The diagnosis was primary osteoarthritis in 151 hips, dysplasia of the hip in 12 and subcapital fracture of the femur in 13. Following discharge, serial follow-up consisted of clinical evaluation based on the Harris Hip Score and radiological assessment. The survival of the prosthesis using revision for any reason as an end-point was calculated by Kaplan-Meier analysis.

RESULTS: Twenty-four (15%) patients died during the follow-up study, 6 (4%) patients were lost, while the remaining 134 patients (141 hips) were followed-up for a mean of 10 years (3-18 years). HSS score at the latest follow-up revealed that 84 hips (59.5%) had excellent results, 30 (22.2%) good, 11 (7.8%) fair and 9 (6.3%) poor. There were 3 acetabular revisions due to aseptic loosening. Six (4.2%) stems were diagnosed as having radiographic definitive loosening; however, only 1 was revised. 30% of the surviving stems showed no radiological changes of radiolucency, while 70% showed some changes. Survival of the prosthesis for any reason was 96% at 10 years and 81% at 18 years.

CONCLUSION: The 18 year survival of the Müller straight stem, cemented THA is comparable to those of other successful cemented systems.

Long-term femoral bone remodeling after cemented hip arthroplasty with the Müller straight stem in the operated and nonoperated femora

We investigated the cortical bone changes in 35 patients with total hip arthroplasty operated on only for osteoarthritis with more than 10 years of follow-up and with nonrevised femoral components and without radiologic signs of loosening. The mean follow-up was 16 ± 5 years. The thicknesses of femoral cortices were measured medially and laterally at 6 levels from the first postoperative and the last follow-up x-rays. A comparison with 10 patients who had a nonoperated contralateral hip was performed. We found a significant decrease in cortical thicknesses in total hip arthroplasty. The cortical thinning was significant at all periprosthetic levels but less expressed distally. Prosthetic femora were associated with greater cortical thinning as compared with the contralateral nonoperated femora, exceeding that caused by natural aging.

First-time revision using impacted morsellised allograft bone with a cemented Exeter stem

Previously, radiostereometric analysis following hip revision performed using impacted morsellised allograft bone and a cemented Exeter stem has shown continuous subsidence of the stem for up to five years. It is not known whether the subsidence continues thereafter. In our study, 17 of 25 consecutive osteo-arthritic patients with aseptically loose stems who underwent first-time revision using impacted morsellised allograft bone and a cemented Exeter stem were followed by yearly radiostereometric examinations for nine years. The mean subsidence at six weeks was 1.1 mm (0.1 to 2.3), from six weeks to one year 1.3 mm (0 to 2.6), from one to five years 0.7 mm (0 to 2.0), and from five to nine years 0.7 mm (0.1 to 3.1). That from six weeks to nine years was 2.7 mm (0 to 6.4) (95% confidence interval 2.0 to 3.5). The Charnley pain score significantly improved after revision, and was maintained at nine years, but walking ability deteriorated slightly as follow-up extended. Of the eight patients who were not followed for nine years, two had early subsidence exceeding 11 mm.

Our findings show that in osteo-arthritic patients who undergo revision for aseptic loosening of the stem using impacted morsellised allograft bone and a cemented Exeter stem, migration of the stem continues over nine years at a slower rate after the first year, but without clinical deterioration or radiological loosening.

Fixation and loosening of the cemented Muller straight stem: a long-term clinical and radiological review

The original forged Müller straight stem (CoNiCr) has shown excellent ten- to 15-year results. We undertook a long-term survival analysis with special emphasis on radiological changes within a 20-year period of follow-up. In all, 165 primary total hip replacements, undertaken between July 1984 and June 1987 were followed prospectively. Clinical follow-up included a standardised clinical examination, and radiological assessment was based on a standardised anteroposterior radiograph of the pelvis, which was studied for the presence of osteolysis, debonding and cortical atrophy. Survival of the stem with revision for any reason was 81% (95% confidence interval (CI), 76 to 86) at 20 years and for aseptic loosening 87% (95% CI, 82 to 90). At the 20-year follow-up, 15 of the surviving 36 stems showed no radiological changes. Debonding (p = 0.005), osteolysis (p = 0.003) and linear polyethylene wear (p = 0.016) were associated with aseptic loosening, whereas cortical atrophy was not associated with failure (p = 0.008). The 20-year results of the Müller straight stem are comparable to those of other successful cemented systems with similar follow-up. Radiological changes are frequently observed, but with a low incidence of progression, and rarely result in revision. Cortical atrophy appears to be an effect of ageing and not a sign of loosening of the femoral component.

Mechanical properties of femoral cortical bone following cemented hip replacement

Femoral bone remodeling following total hip replacement is a big concern and has never been examined mechanically. In this study, six goats underwent unilateral cemented hip hemiarthroplasty with polymethyl methacrylate (PMMA) bone cement. Nine months later animals were sacrificed, and the femoral cortical bone slices at different levels were analysed using microhardness testing and microcomputed tomography (micro-CT) scanning. Implanted femurs were compared to contralateral nonimplanted femurs. Extensive bone remodeling was demonstrated at both the proximal and middle levels, but not at the distal level. Compared with the nonimplanted side, significant decreases were found in the implanted femur in cortical bone area, bone mineral density, and cortical bone hardness at the proximal level, as well as in bone mineral density and bone hardness at the middle level. However, no significant difference was observed in either variable for the distal level. In addition, similar proximal-to-distal gradient changes were revealed both in cortical bone microhardness and bone mineral density. From the mechanical point of view, the results of the present study suggested that stress shielding is an important mechanical factor associated with bone adaptation following total hip replacement.

Increasing sex difference in bone strength in old age: The Age, Gene/Environment Susceptibility-Reykjavik study (AGES-REYKJAVIK)

INTRODUCTION

It is important to identify possible pathological mechanisms that underlie the known sexual dimorphism in bone fragility in old age. In this cross-sectional population-based study, we use data from three different skeletal sites to examine sex differences in volumetric bone density, geometry and strength indices and determine whether sex differences in these bone strength measures continue to increase into very old age.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A total of 1715 elderly individuals (807 men and 908 women) age 67-93 years, participants in a population-based study, the Age, Gene/Environment Susceptibility-Reykjavik Study (AGES-REYKJAVIK) and not taking medications affecting bone metabolism, were studied. Quantitative computed tomography (QCT) was performed in the lumbar spine, hip and mid-femoral shaft to estimate volumetric trabecular, cortical and integral BMD, bone geometry and bone strength indices. Regression models were used to assess the effects of age and gender-adjustment for standing midlife height and current weight.

RESULTS

At age 67-69 years, men had 24.9-31.7% larger cross-sectional bone size at measured sites than women. At all bone sites, women had two- to fivefold diminution in net bone mass with age compared to men but had comparable increments in bone size (1.8-6.0% per 10 years). This was reflected in significantly worse (more than twofold) bone strength measures with age in women, including compressive strength indices at the spine, femoral neck and trochanter and bending strength indices at the femoral neck.

CONCLUSION

With the limitations of a cross-sectional study, our data support the hypothesis that sex differences in bone strength continue into old age. These sex differences appear to be due to greater net bone loss in women rather than due to greater bone gain in men.

Analysis of long-term cemented total hip arthroplasty retrievals

A detailed biomechanical, histologic, and histomorphometric analysis of autopsy specimens from patients who previously had cemented total hip arthroplasty has helped to elucidate the skeletal response to cemented components. Bone cement has the capacity to provide long-term implant stability. The biologic response to polyethylene wear debris has a more critical effect on destabilization of cemented sockets compared with the femoral side. In contrast, mechanical events tended to predominate the early mode of destabilization of cemented femoral components with debonding at the metal-cement interface and fracture in the cement. Fractures predominate in cement mantles less than 1 mm thick and are associated with mantle defects, debonded interfaces, and sharp corners of the implants. Correlation of the histologic findings at the cement-bone interface with radiolucencies seen on clinical radiographs show that on the acetabular side radiolucencies represent a soft tissue membrane that is the biologic response to polyethylene debris. In contrast, on the femoral side, most radiolucencies were as a result of skeletal remodeling. Femoral adaptive bone remodeling is a diffuse process that occurs over the entire fixation surface. The most profound disuse osteoporosis occurred proximally in the proximal medial quadrant; however, when one takes into account all four quadrants, anterior, posterior, medial, and lateral, the most severe osteoporosis occurred at the midpoint of the stem.

Comparison of human, primate, and canine femora: implications for biomaterials testing in total hip replacement

The canine model remains an animal of choice for determining the efficacy and safety of various materials and designs used in human total hip replacement (THR). The primate also is used in orthopedic-related research for studying limb anatomy, gait, and age-related bone loss. In order to better understand the appropriateness of these animal models for human THR, external morphologies of thirty-three adult Caucasian human, sixteen adult chimpanzee, and forty-two adult greyhound femora were compared using osteometric methods. Measured parameters included anteversion angle, cervico-diaphyseal angle, femoral head offset in the frontal plane, and anterior bow profiles along the femoral diaphysis. Although some of the measured parameters were approximately similar between species (e.g., mean cervico-diaphyseal angle of humans and chimpanzees), the majority demonstrated morphologic differences that may be biomechanically significant for interpreting stress transfer across the hip (e.g., mean anteversion angle and mean normalized femoral head offset between species). Additionally, age-related changes in proximal femoral morphology and gait pattern, as well as species-related differences in local muscle and inertial forces, may result in notably different loading conditions across the hip joint of each species. Therefore, discretion must be exercised when evaluating canine or primate THR materials and designs for potential use in the human hip.

High failure rate of soft-interface stem coating for fixation of femoral endoprostheses

Twenty-five total hip arthroplasties were performed in 25 patients using a femoral stem with a soft-interface coating of Proplast (Vitek, Houston, TX). Follow-up periods for 24 of the hips ranged from 82 to 104 months (median, 96 months). Fourteen (58%) of the hips were judged to be failures, and nine of the failures were revised. The prostheses were thought to have failed because the coating was not strong enough to withstand normal weight-bearing loads. This inner-substance failure of the coating was seen in all revision operations. During these revisions, parts of the coating remained in the shaft as well as on the prosthesis stem. The combination of clinically manifest midthigh pain and radiologic scalloping and/or the pedestal sign seem to justify a strong suspicion of looseness of this type of cementless femoral endoprosthesis.

Long term bone remodeling around the Charnley femoral prostheses

Femoral bone remodeling after total hip replacement was studied by following patients who received 326 Charnley femoral prostheses for 10 to 20 years (mean, 13.3 years). The radiographic state of the bone remodeling was visually assessed and measured with a digitizer. Demineralization that started proximally and then progressed distally caused cortical thinning, which correlated with widening of the intramedullary canal, not with changes that developed in the periosteal width, and occurred in the medial femoral neck, around the proximal half of the stem, and around the distal half in 87%, 33%, and 10%, respectively. Cortical thinning around the distal half of the stem was always accompanied by proximal thinning, and extensive cortical thinning (both proximal and distal) correlated with both lower clinical scores and radiologic loosening of the femoral prosthesis. A low canal flare index of Noble, a large canal width, and a patient age of 60 years or more were risk factors for extensive cortical thinning. Accelerated polyethylene wear was related to resorption of the medial femoral neck but not to cortical thinning or radiological loosening. Cortical thickening occurred only around the distal half of the stem in 29%. These findings establish a basis for the performance of cemented femoral prostheses, and allow comparison of bone remodeling when evaluating other femoral prostheses.

Comparison of human and canine external femoral morphologies in the context of total hip replacement

The canine is frequently used as a model for human hip arthroplasty research. In order to better understand the appropriateness of the canine as a model for human total hip replacement studies, the external morphology of canine and human femurs were examined and compared. Several differences were found between canine and human femora, including angular measurements, anterior bow, and femoral head position relative to the femoral diaphysis. In addition, the human femur was noted to undergo age-related changes in several of the measured parameters. The canine femur did not exhibit any age-related changes in the measured parameters. This study suggests that there are limitations to the use of the canine model in human hip arthroplasty research, and that discretion must be exercised when attempting to extrapolate results from a canine study to the human clinical condition.

Clinical and radiographic results of the Muller straight stem used as a press-fit

Prior to the introduction of porous coating, 21 patients had 24 ME Muller straight-stem femoral prostheses inserted as a press fit for the treatment of osteoarthrosis. Five hips have been revised for aseptic loosening; the remaining 19 prostheses are still in situ after a mean of 7.3 years (range, 6.2-8.3 years). A prospective clinical assessment has been undertaken using a modified Harris hip score, with scores increasing on average from a preoperative 43 to a postoperative 79. Eighteen of the 19 remaining hips are functioning well. Variable distances of subsidence are evident in 10 hips. Despite the use of a prosthesis that was not designed for cementless proximal wedge fitting, the results indicate an exceptionally low incidence of bone resorption and lysis. Unlike cemented and some porous-coated prostheses, stress shielding and osteopenia were not a feature in this series.

Alterations in femoral and acetabular bone strains immediately following cementless total hip arthroplasty: an in vitro canine study

Alterations in strain patterns in both the femur and acetabulum of the dog, due to cementless total hip arthroplasty (THA), were evaluated by monitoring cortical bone strains before and immediately following implantation of components, using an accurate in vitro jig, simulating the loading of the canine hip in vivo. Femoral arthroplasty with straight stem, canal-filling, femoral components, made of titanium-based alloy, led to a statistically significant reduction of proximal femoral bone strains, with proximal medical compressive strains reduced, on average, to only 22% of intact strain magnitude (p less than 0.01), even though the prostheses contained collars and were not fixed with cement. Strain alterations on the acetabulum, following cementless THA, were more complex and variable. Laterally, a significant decrease (p less than 0.01) in periacetabular strains to between 20 and 60% of the intact state was observed, while medial wall strains varied inconsistently after arthroplasty. These strain alterations reflect major changes in mechanical loading of both the femur and acetabulum immediately following cementless THA, using components similar to those used clinically in humans. Major reductions in strains on the proximal femur occurred with cementless femoral components, while the change in strains on the acetabulum were variable, and could be a result of variations in fit and placement of components inherent even in well-controlled implantation techniques. The physiologic in vitro loading of the canine femur with the pelvis, used to obtain these data, can be applied to future investigations exploring stress transfer around uncemented components and the relationship of stress transfer to morphological changes of bone, in the canine model.

Age-related changes in the human femoral cortex

Bone undergoes structural changes with aging, but the nature of qualitative changes remains to be established. Blocks of midshaft femur were taken at autopsy from men of four different age groups: 20-25 years, 40-45 years, 60-65 years, and 80-85 years. Each femoral specimen was analyzed by density fractionation, a technique that allows the separation of bone by extent of mineralization and maturity. In the 20-25 group, lower density bone predominates. The 40-45 group is characterized by more highly mineralized bone with an increase in the 2.1-2.2 g/cc fraction. At 60-65 years, an increase in the lower density fraction was found, indicating an increase in new bone formation. At 80-85 years, there is an increase in the highest density bone (2.2-2.3 g/cc), which may represent regions of interstitial bone not properly removed through remodeling processes. Chemical studies did not reveal any change in Ca, P, Ca + PO4, or Ca/P molar ratio with respect to age. X-ray diffraction studies show no changes in apatite crystal size with respect to age or degree of mineralization. Morphological studies documented increased remodeling activity and endosteal trabecularization in the older age groups, as well as increased intracortical porosity. An increase in the highest density fraction with aging may represent a pool of bone mineral that is less accessible to remodeling, which may be the interstitial bone.