Endometrial carcinoma: does the addition of intracavitary vault caesium to external beam therapy postoperatively result in improved control or increased morbidity?

Câncer do Endométrio: Tratamento Adjuvante Pélvico apenas com Radioterapia Externa após Cirurgia sem Linfadenectomia

A incidência mediana de câncer endometrial no Brasil é de 6 casos novos/cem mil mulheres/ ano. A radioterapia tem sido usada como tratamento adjuvante pré ou pós cirurgia, com ou sem braquiterapia. Há consenso de que os casos estadiados como II e III pela FIGO recebam irradiação pélvica, com ou sem braquiterapia. Entretanto, 75% dos casos são estádios I. Por isso há subgrupos prognósticos que dependem da profundidade de invasão do miométrio e do grau histológico do tumor. Tumores em estádio I com invasão profunda do miométrio e/ou alto grau têm também sido tratados com irradiação. A adição de braquiterapia vaginal após a radioterapia externa resulta em melhor controle de falha pélvica? Esta é uma pergunta não resolvida. Desde 1990 temos feito apenas radioterapia externa nos casos de câncer do endométrio que têm indicação de irradiação adjuvante, sem braquiterapia. A cirurgia básica destes casos têm sido histerectomia abdominal total + salpingo-ooforectomia bilateral sem dissecção de rotina dos linfonodos pélvicos. Foram revistas retrospectivamente 61 destes casos tratados no nosso serviço, com 4 campos pélvicos. Cobalto, dose total entre 45Gy-50,4Gy em 25 a 28 frações. Seguimento mediano de 33 meses mostrou um único caso de falha em vagina, 6/61 casos de pacientes que morreram e apenas um caso de complicação intestinal moderada. Estes resultados se assemelham com outros da literatura que não usam a braquiterapia de rotina após a irradiação externa na pelve.

[Evidence based medicine and high performance irradiation techniques: endometrial cancer]

Radiation oncology is a field in which many technologic improvements have been made over the past decades. External beam radiotherapy has evolved from treatment fields planned on X-rays to 3-dimensional planning with fusion with MRI's and PET images. Recently, intensity-modulated radiotherapy has been tested for many cancer localizations, and its role in the treatment of gynecologic cancers is still under evaluation. Potential benefits are well known: decrease of treatment toxicity, improvement of efficacy through better dose delivery. But the implementation of this technique requires a careful target and organs at risk delineation. The goal of this review is to evaluate the use of intensity-modulated radiotherapy in endometrial cancers with respect of dosimetric and clinical studies to date. In addition, challenges and perspectives of intensity-modulated radiotherapy integration are discussed.

Survival rate of early stage endometrioid adenocarcinoma of endometrium treated at Srinagarind Hospital

PURPOSE

To evaluate the survival outcome of early stage endometrioid adenocarcinoma of the endometrium with risk factors for locoregional recurrence treated with combined pelvic external beam radiotherapy (EBRT) and vaginal brachytherapy (VBT) after comprehensive surgery.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Post-operative radiotherapy by pelvic EBRT and VBT for early stage endometrioid endometrial carcinoma resulted in excellent pelvic control with acceptable complications. This study showed no significant relationships between age, stage, histologic grade and LVSI and overall survival rate.

RESULTS

The 5-year overall survival rate (OS) of early stage endometrioid type of endometrial carcinoma was 85.7%. Acute toxicity occurred in 38.1% of the patients, all of whom were grade 1 or 2. Total late toxicity developed in 42.9% of study group, in which 36.99% of them were grade 1-2 and 4.76% were grade 3-4.

CONCLUSIONS

Post-operative radiotherapy by pelvic EBRT and VBT is acceptable for early stage endometrioid endometrial carcinoma, independent of age, stage, histologic grade and LVSI.

Image-based 3D treatment planning for vaginal cylinder brachytherapy: dosimetric effects of bladder filling on organs at risk

PURPOSE

To investigate the dosimetric effects of bladder filling on organs at risk (OARs) using three-dimensional image-based treatment planning for vaginal cylinder brachytherapy.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Twelve patients with endometrial or cervical cancer underwent postoperative high-dose rate vaginal cylinder brachytherapy. For three-dimensional planning, patients were simulated by computed tomography with an indwelling catheter in place (empty bladder) and with 180 mL of sterile water instilled into the bladder (full bladder). The bladder, rectum, sigmoid, and small bowel (OARs) were contoured, and a prescription dose was generated for 10 to 35 Gy in 2 to 5 fractions at the surface or at 5 mm depth. For each OAR, the volume dose was defined by use of two different criteria: the minimum dose value in a 2.0-cc volume receiving the highest dose (D(2cc)) and the dose received by 50% of the OAR volume (D(50%)). International Commission on Radiation Units & Measurements (ICRU) bladder and rectum point doses were calculated for comparison. The cylinder-to-bowel distance was measured using the shortest distance from the cylinder apex to the contoured sigmoid or small bowel. Statistical analyses were performed with paired t tests.

RESULTS

Mean bladder and rectum D(2cc) values were lower than their respective ICRU doses. However, differences between D(2cc) and ICRU doses were small. Empty vs. full bladder did not significantly affect the mean cylinder-to-bowel distance (0.72 vs. 0.92 cm, p = 0.08). In contrast, bladder distention had appreciable effects on bladder and small bowel volume dosimetry. With a full bladder, the mean small bowel D(2cc) significantly decreased from 677 to 408 cGy (p = 0.004); the mean bladder D(2cc) did not increase significantly (1,179 cGy vs. 1,246 cGy, p = 0.11). Bladder distention decreased the mean D(50%) for both the bladder (441 vs. 279 cGy, p = 0.001) and the small bowel (168 vs. 132 cGy, p = 0.001). Rectum and sigmoid volume doses were not affected by bladder filling.

CONCLUSIONS

In high-dose rate vaginal cylinder brachytherapy, treatment with a distended bladder preferentially reduces high dose to the small bowel around the vaginal cuff without a significant change in dose to the bladder, rectum, or sigmoid.

Postoperative Accelerated Radiotherapy with Cytoprotection Followed by Three-Dimensional Conformal Boost in Patients with Early Endometrial/Cervical Cancer

Aims and background

Adjuvant external beam radiotherapy is highly recommended for uterine carcinomas invading beyond the inner half of the myometrium or cervical stage IIa carcinomas. The addition of a booster intracavitary dose is widely used.

Methods

We assessed the feasibility and toxicity of a hypofractionated accelerated conformal radiotherapy scheme (2.7 Gy per fraction, for 14 consecutive fractions to the pelvis) supported with the cytoprotective agent amifostine (HypoARC). The amifostine dose was individualized (500–1000 mg daily subcutaneously). A booster dose of radiation was given to the vagina and stump using a 6-field 3D-conformal technique (3 × 4 Gy or 4 × 3 Gy) instead of intracavitary radiotherapy.

Results

Grade 2 diarrhea appeared in 9/25 (36%) and grade 1 cystitis in 7/25 (28%) cases. Analysis according to the amifostine dose level clearly showed reduced toxicity in patients receiving a daily dose of 750–1000 mg (P <0.009). Within a median follow-up of 31 months (range, 11–52), there was only one case with grade 2 colitis (the patient had received no amifostine). None of the patients treated has relapsed locally or to distant organs within a median of 31 months of follow-up.

Conclusions

It is concluded that HypoARC followed by 3D-conformal booster dose to the vagina is feasible and convenient for patients and for busy radiotherapy departments, as it reduces the overall time by 50%. When supported by high-dose daily amifostine, it has an impressively low rate of early and late radiation toxicity.

Patterns of failure after postoperative radiation therapy for endometrial carcinoma

PURPOSE

We tried to investigate the outcome and patterns of failure of endometrial cancer patients who were treated with surgery and postoperative radiation therapy (RT).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Eighty-three patients with endometrial cancer who received postoperative RT between May 1979 and August 2000 were included in this retrospective study. Forty-one patients received total abdominal hysterectomy, 41 patients received Wertheim's operation and 1 underwent vaginal hysterectomy. Pelvic lymph node dissection or pelvic lymph node sampling was done in 56 patients and peritoneal cytology was done in 35. All the patients were staged according to 1988 FIGO (International Federation of Gynecology and Obstetrics) staging system; 2 were stage IA, 23 were stage IB, 20 were stage IC, 4 were stage IIA, 5 were stage IIB, 9 were stage IIIA, 2 were stage IIIB and 18 were stage IIIC. The histologic diagnoses were adenocarcinoma in seventy-four patients (89%). The histologic grades were Grade 1, 2 and 3 in 21 (25%), 43 (52%) and 10 (12%) patients, respectively. All the patients received external beam RT (EBRT) with a median dose of 5,040 cGy (range: 4,500 approximately 5,075 cGy) to the whole pelvis. Five patients with pathologically confirmed paraaortic lymph node metastasis received 4500 cGy to the paraaortic lymph nodes. Fifteen patients received low-dose intracavitary brachytherapy after their EBRT. A total dose of 7,500 approximately 9,540 cGy (median dose: 8511) was prescribed to the vaginal surface.

RESULTS

Overall, 11 patients (13%) experienced disease relapse: 4 with initial stage I or II disease and 7 with initial stage III disease. Among the 54 stage I or II patients, 1 (2%) relapsed in the pelvis only, 2 (4%) relapsed in the vagina and distant organs, and 1 (2%) relapsed in the paraaortic lymph nodes (PANs). Among the 29 stage III patients, 1 (3%) relapsed in the vagina. The most common sites of failure for the stage III patients were the peritoneum (3 patients, 10%), PANs (2 patients, 7%), and lung (2 patients, 7%). With a median follow-up period of 86 months, the overall survival (OS) and disease-free survival (DFS) rates at 5 years were 87% for both. The five-year DFS rate was 93%, 100% and 74% for the stage I, II and III patients, respectively. Three patients experienced severe radiation-related late complications: RTOG (Radiation Therapy Oncology Group) grade 3 radiation cystitis was seen in one patient, and grade 3 bowel obstruction was seen in two patients.

CONCLUSIONS

Postoperative RT was useful for controlling pelvic disease. The major patterns of failure for stage III patients were peritoneal seeding and distant metastasis. Selective use of whole abdominal radiotherapy or adjuvant chemotherapy may improve the therapeutic outcome of these patients.

Predictors of vaginal relapse in stage I endometrial cancer

OBJECTIVE

To identify factors predictive of vaginal relapse in stage I endometrial cancer, thereby potentially facilitating the selection of patients who may benefit from vaginal brachytherapy.

METHODS

The study population included 632 patients with stage I endometrial cancer managed with hysterectomy at our institution between 1984 and 1996. Median follow-up was 73 months; 122 patients (19%) received adjuvant radiotherapy.

RESULTS

Overall, 2.9% of the stage I cohort developed vaginal relapse at 5 years. Vaginal relapse was observed in 1.7% of patients who received radiotherapy and in 3.0% of those whose treatment did not include radiotherapy (P = 0.36). Cox regression analysis (including radiotherapy) identified only grade 3 differentiation (hazard ratio = 3.83, P = 0.007) as an independent predictor of vaginal relapse. Patients with a low-grade tumor had a 5-year vaginal relapse rate of 2%, compared with 7% for those with a grade 3 tumor. When only patients who did not receive adjuvant radiotherapy were considered, both grade 3 tumor and lymphovascular invasion were significant predictors of vaginal relapse (P < 0.05). When neither variable was present, 2% of patients experienced vaginal relapse at 5 years, compared with 11% when either 1 was present (P < 0.001). Depth of myometrial invasion was not a significant predictor of vaginal recurrence.

CONCLUSION

Histologic grade 3 tumor and lymphovascular invasion were the cogent predictors of vaginal relapse in our population. The cost and morbidity of vaginal brachytherapy should be balanced against the potential risk of vaginal relapse in this group of patients.

Geometric and dosimetric variations of ICRU bladder and rectum reference points in vaginal cuff brachytherapy using ovoids

PURPOSE

To investigate the interfractional geometric and dose variations of rectal reference point (R) and bladder reference point (BL) doses in patients receiving vaginal cuff irradiation using high-dose-rate brachytherapy with 2 ovoids and the change in calculated radiobiologic-equivalent dose of R and BL.

METHODS

ICRU-38 R and BL reference doses were calculated. The variation in positions of ovoids, R, and BL were determined. Whether the magnitude of displacement shows a time trend and has an effect on calculated R and BL doses was evaluated. The relation between the ovoid diameter and both the magnitude of displacement and changes in R and BL doses was studied. Changes in radiobiologic-equivalent dose of rectum and bladder were determined.

RESULTS

The average magnitude of displacements was 3.2 and 12.1 mm, showed no time trend, and no tendency to displacement in a certain direction. Mean changes in BL and R doses were 64-75 cGy and 47-58 cGy, respectively. There was a relation between neither ovoid size and displacement nor R and BL dose change. Dose and geometric variation showed no correlation (p > 0.05). The differences in radiobiologic-equivalent dose of R and B were not significant.

CONCLUSION

Although there were significant differences in R and B position and doses among the fractions, the magnitudes of dose changes were relatively small, and total calculated radiobiologic-equivalent doses of R and B did not change significantly. According to the results of this study, the benefit of treatment planning is limited to supporting treatment planning in each fraction.

Conventional 3D conformal versus intensity-modulated radiotherapy for the adjuvant treatment of gynecologic malignancies: a comparative dosimetric study of dose–volume histograms☆

OBJECTIVE

The goals of this study were to evaluate the feasibility of pelvic intensity-modulated radiotherapy (IMRT) in the adjuvant treatment of gynecologic malignancies and to compare the dose-volume histograms (DVHs) and determine the potential impact on acute and long-term toxicity based on the dose to target and nontarget tissues for both planning techniques.

METHODS

Ten consecutive patients referred for adjuvant radiotherapy for gynecologic malignancies at the University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine and Magee-Womens Hospital were selected for CT-based treatment planning using the ADAC 3D version 4.2g and the NOMOS Corvus IMRT version 4.0. Normal tissues and critical structures were contoured on axial CT slices by both systems in conjunction with a gynecologic radiologist. These regions included internal, external, and common iliac nodal groups, rectum, upper 4 cm of vagina, bladder, and small bowel. Conventional treatment planning included 3D four-field box using 18-MV photons designed to treat a volume from the L(5)/S(1) border superiorly to the bottom of the ischial tuberosity on the AP/PA field and shaped blocks on the lateral fields to minimize the dose to the rectum and small bowel. A seven-field technique using 6-MV photons was used for IMRT. Restraints on small bowel for IMRT were set at 23.0 Gy +/- 5% and 35.0 Gy+/- 5% for the rectum and 37.5 Gy +/- 5% for the bladder while simultaneously delivering full dose (45.0 Gy) to the intrapelvic nodal groups in 1.8-Gy daily fractions. The dose-volume histograms where then compared for both treatment delivery systems.

RESULTS

The volume of each organ of interest (small bowel, bladder, and rectum) receiving doses in excess of 30 Gy was compared in the 3D and IMRT treatment plans. The mean volume of small bowel receiving doses in excess of 30 Gy was reduced by 52% with IMRT compared with 3D. A similar advantage was noted for the rectum (66% reduction) and the bladder (36% reduction). The nodal regions at risk and the upper vagina all received the prescribed dose of 45.0 Gy.

CONCLUSIONS

Intensity-modulated radiotherapy appears to offer several advantages over conventional 3D radiotherapy (3D CRT) planning for adjuvant radiotherapy for gynecologic malignancies. These include a significant reduction in treatment volume for bladder, rectum, and small bowel. It is anticipated that this reduction in volume of normal tissue irradiated would translate into overall reduction in acute and potentially late treatment-related toxicity. Prospective trials are necessary to better evaluate the advantages in a larger group of patients.

Toxicity, recurrence and survival after adjuvant radiotherapy treatment for FIGO stage I cancer of the endometrium

We conducted a retrospective observational study to determine the rate of toxicity, pattern of tumour recurrence and survival associated with radiotherapy treatment for FIGO stage I cancer of the endometrium. All patients had undergone definitive surgery and had been referred to the oncology department of the University Hospital Birmingham, U.K. Two hundred and forty-five women were included in the study; 228 patients were treated with radiotherapy; 160 had external beam radiation alone; 32 had vaginal vault brachytherapy alone; 36 patients had both modalities; and 17 patients were not given radiotherapy. There were nine cases of Grade 3 and 4 radiation reactions, of which four were acute, four were late and one was acute and late toxicity. The severity of both acute and late radiation effects was significantly associated with the delivery of vault brachytherapy (external beam radiotherapy alone compared with brachytherapy alone (1/158 vs 3/32; P = 0.02). Thirty-four patients were diagnosed with tumour recurrence (11 distant, 14 local, 4 patients had both distant and local disease and 5 patients had recurrence diagnosed at the time of death). Patients who received no radiotherapy were at greater risk of local pelvic tumour recurrence (P < 0.0001; hazard ratio [HR] 9.6, 95% confidence interval (CI) 3.5-26.3). Vaginal vault brachytherapy had no discernible effect on the pattern of tumour recurrence. Forty-six patients died during the follow-up period, 28 of these were attributable to carcinoma of the endometrium. There was no difference in survival between the four treatment groups (P = 0.68). The overall 5-year survival rate in our study group was 89.6% (85.4-93.8%). In a proportional hazards model, tumour grade (HR 2.0 per level [1.25, 3.17]; P = 0.004]) and age (HR 1.74 per 10 years [1.12, 2.69]; P = 0.01) were the only factors found to have an independent influence on survival. This study suggests that, although pelvic radiation may not alter overall survival, it does reduce the risk of local disease recurrence. In this study population, vaginal vault brachytherapy using a vaginal stock/dobbie showed no additional benefits compared with external beam radiotherapy; it was, however, associated with a higher rate of both acute and late radiation effects.

The influence of applicator angle on dosimetry in vaginal vault brachytherapy

In vaginal vault brachytherapy, the critical normal tissues are bladder and rectum; doses to these tissues may be affected by the position of a single line applicator placed in the vagina. Dosimetry with the applicator lying at its "natural" angle in the vagina with the patient in the lithotomy position has been compared with the applicator held horizontal as defined by a spirit level in 30 consecutive patients. A mean change in angle of 19.7 degrees was found. This resulted in a mean decrease in ICRU (International Commission of Radiation Units and Measurements) rectal point dose when the applicator is horizontal of 12.9%, equivalent to a mean absolute dose reduction of 1.3 Gy for a prescription dose of 5.5 Gy at 5 mm depth. An increase in mean dose to the ICRU bladder point when the applicator is horizontal of 13.3%, equivalent to an absolute mean dose increase of 0.5 Gy per fraction for the same prescription dose, was also found. On the basis of these findings, it is recommended that vaginal vault brachytherapy is performed with a single line source held in the "corrected" horizontal position to reduce bowel dose as this is the most sensitive critical normal tissue.

Relationship between acute and late normal tissue injury after postoperative radiotherapy in endometrial cancer

PURPOSE

To evaluate the relationship between acute and late normal tissue reactions in 317 consecutive endometrial cancer patients treated with surgery and adjuvant radiotherapy (RT).

METHODS

The data of 317 patients (staging according to the International Federation of Gynecology and Obstetrics) treated with postoperative RT were analyzed. Both low-dose-rate brachytherapy and external beam RT were applied in 247 patients (78%); brachytherapy only in 49 (15%) and external beam irradiation only in 21 (7%). The median follow-up was 7.3 years (range 4-21). The European Organization for Research and Treatment of Cancer, Radiation Therapy Oncology Group system with elements of the late effects of normal tissue, subjective, objective, management, analytic (LENT/SOMA) scale was used to score the RT reactions. The correlation between the occurrence and severity of acute and late bowel and bladder toxicity, as well as the relationship between the severity of acute effects and time to occurrence of late reactions, were assessed using linear and logistic regression analyses.

RESULTS

Of the 317 patients, 268 (85%) experienced acute RT reactions of any grade. Severe acute bowel reactions were observed in 15 patients (5%), urinary bladder complications in 1 patient (0.5%), cutaneous in 1 patient (0.5%), and vaginal in 1 patient (0.5%). Severe acute hematologic toxicity was seen in 3 patients (1%). A total of 158 patients (51%) experienced late RT reactions of any grade. Severe late bowel reactions were observed in 19 patients (6%), urinary bladder in 5 (2%), vaginal in 3 (1%), and bone in 10 (4%). When all toxic events were considered, there was a highly significant correlation between the acute and late bowel reactions (p <0.001), but the acute and late urinary bladder reactions did not correlate (p = 0.64). The grade of acute toxicity was found to predict the grade of late toxicity for the bowel but not for the bladder (p <0.001 and p = 0.47, respectively). The severity of acute bowel and bladder toxicity did not correlate with the time to occurrence of late toxicity in these locations (p = 0.34 and p = 0.47, respectively).

CONCLUSION

Patients with increased acute bowel toxicity during postoperative RT for endometrial cancer have an increased risk of late bowel injury. A higher grade of acute bowel complications correlated with more severe late events, but was not predictive for its latency time. These findings suggest the possibility of an early indication of patients with an increased risk of late toxicity in whom preventive measures might be attempted.

Carcinoma of the endometrium

The incidence of endometrial cancer is highest among relatively affluent Caucasians. Although it has a comparatively low mortality rate compared with other gynaecological cancers, it is capable of aggressive behaviour. Endometrial cancer is uncommon in premenopausal women. The incidence rises with age and is significantly increased when there is exposure to unopposed estrogen, including hormone replacement therapy (HRT). Even when HRT is given in the form of estrogen and cyclical progesterone there is probably some increased risk. The long term use of tamoxifen for breast cancer is also associated with an increased incidence of endometrial cancer. Transvaginal ultrasound and pipelle or hysteroscopy endometrial biopsies are tending to replace the traditional dilation and curettage in establishing a diagnosis. 90% of endometrial tumours are surgically resectable on presentation. This remains the first line management--minimally, a total abdominal hysterectomy and bi-lateral salpingo oophorectomy. Prognostic factors include the histological grade, the depth of invasion of the myometrium, the presence or absence of lymph-vascular space invasion and involved regional nodes, tumour volume, and the presence or absence of involvement of the cervix. The pelvis is a major anatomical site at risk of recurrence, and since cytotoxic chemotherapy and hormone therapies have limited effectiveness, radiotherapy is the adjuvant therapy of choice where adverse prognostic factors are present. A move towards more radical surgery--the addition of lymphadenectomy with a total abdominal hysterectomy and bi-lateral salpingo oophorectomy, may modify the value of adjuvant therapy and has highlighted the need to demonstrate the exact place of post operative radiotherapy in the management of endometrial cancer. The ASTEC trial in the UK, run by the Medical Research Council, has the dual aims of determining the benefit of lymphadenectomy and of post operative adjuvant radiotherapy in patients with endometrial cancer confined to the corpus. Patients who are not medically fit for surgery or who have inoperable disease are managed with radical radiotherapy but the results in both these groups are inferior to those obtained with radical surgery. Spread outside the pelvis to para-aortic nodes may still be salvaged with local irradiation, but systemic disease is incurable and treatment is largely palliative including consideration of local irradiation, hormone therapy or chemotherapy for symptomatic relief. As reliable techniques for diagnosis are refined an even larger proportion of patients will be diagnosed with early disease. This, together with the development of new cytotoxic agents and sophisticated radiotherapy techniques to reduce normal tissue morbidity, will require the establishment of further clinical trials to refine optimal management.

Gynecologic brachytherapy-II: Intravaginal brachytherapy for carcinoma of the endometrium

Brachytherapy plays a significant role in the management of endometrial cancer. In the adjuvant setting, based on pathologic risk factors, intravaginal brachytherapy alone, external radiation therapy alone, or a combination of the two is recommended. For patients who are medically inoperable, brachytherapy with or without external beam therapy is the mainstay of treatment. In recurrent disease, to achieve improved local regional control interstitial and/or intravaginal brachytherapy is used as a boost. This article will highlight the indications and technical aspects of postoperative intravaginal brachytherapy, which is the most common application of brachytherapy in endometrial cancer.

Adenocarcinoma of the endometrium treated with combined irradiation and surgery: study of 437 patients

PURPOSE

To identify prognostic factors and treatment toxicity in a series of operable endometrial adenocarcinomas.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Between November 1971 and October 1992, 437 patients (pts) with endometrial carcinoma, staged according to the 1988 FIGO staging system (225 Stage IB, 107 Stage IC, 4 Stage IIA, 35 Stage IIB, 30 Stage IIIA, 6 Stage IIIB, and 30 Stage IIIC), underwent total abdominal hysterectomy and bilateral salpingo-oophorectomy without (n = 140) or with (n = 297) pelvic lymph node dissection. The chronology of adjuvant RT was not randomized and depended on the usual practices of the surgical teams. Seventy-nine pts (Group I) received preoperative low-dose-rate uterovaginal brachytherapy (mean dose [MD]: 57 Gy). Three hundred fifty-eight pts (Group II) received postoperative RT. One hundred ninety-six pts received low-dose-rate vaginal brachytherapy alone (MD: 50 Gy). One hundred fifty-eight pts had external beam pelvic RT (MD: 46 Gy) followed by low-dose-rate vaginal brachytherapy (MD: 17 Gy). Four pts had external beam pelvic RT alone (MD: 47 Gy). The mean follow-up from the beginning of treatment was 128 months.

RESULTS

The 10-year disease-free survival rate was 86%. From 57 recurrences, only 12 were isolated locoregional recurrences. The independent factors decreasing the probability of disease-free survival were as follows: histologic type (clear-cell carcinoma, p = 0.038), largest histologic tumor diameter >3 cm (p = 0.015), histologic grade (p = 0.008), myometrial invasion > 1/2 (p = 0.005), and 1988 FIGO staging system (p = 9.10(-8)). In Group II, the addition of external beam pelvic RT did not seem to independently improve vaginal or pelvic control. The postoperative complication rate was 7%. The independent factors increasing the risk of postoperative complications were stage FIGO (p = 0.02) and pelvic lymph node dissection (p = 0.011). The 10-year rate for Grade 3 and 4 late radiation complications according to the LENT-SOMA scoring system was 3.1%. External beam pelvic RT independently increased the rate for Grade 3 and 4 late complication (RR: 5.6, p = 0.0096).

CONCLUSION

Postoperative external beam pelvic RT increases the risk of late radiation complications. After surgical and histopathologic staging with pelvic lymph node dissection, in subgroup of "intermediate-risk" patients (Stage IA Grade 3, IB-C and II), postoperative vaginal brachytherapy alone is probably sufficient to obtain a good therapeutic index. Results for patients with Stage III tumor are not satisfactory.

Postoperative irradiation in endometrial cancer: still a matter of controversy

Although endometrial cancer is the most common female malignancy, evidence-based uniform guidelines for postoperative therapy have not been established. The most logical management is adjuvant irradiation tailored to the extent of surgery, the tumour grade, depth of myometrial invasion, degree of lymph node involvement and age of the patient. Currently, the only widely accepted treatment recommendations are no further therapy in low-risk patients who underwent extensive surgical staging, and external beam radiotherapy (EBRT) in high-risk patients. Most authors recommend postoperative application of only one radiotherapy modality: either brachytherapy (BRT) or EBRT, as their routine combination does not clearly improve the outcome but does increase the risk of late complications. A combination of BRT and EBRT should however be considered in patients with stage II disease, for infiltration of the lower uterine segment, vaginal involvement, positive or close surgical margins, capillary space involvement or unfavourable histology. Two recent randomized studies including mostly intermediate-risk patients managed with either extensive surgical staging or total abdominal hysterectomy and bilateral salpingo-oophorectomy (TAH&BSO) with or without postoperative EBRT, showed better local control but no survival benefit from adjuvant irradiation. Two ongoing Gynecologic Oncology Group (GOG) studies compare adjuvant chemotherapy with pelvic or abdominal irradiation in patients with high risk of local relapse. The role of adjuvant radiotherapy (EBRT with or without BRT) in high-risk patients as well as the value of lymphadenectomy in patients fit for such surgery is being addressed in a trial co-ordinated by the Medical Research Council. Future studies are warranted to define whether any irradiation should be employed in intermediate-risk patients and which radiotherapy modality should be used in high-risk node-negative patients with stage I tumours (stage Ib grade 3 and all stage Ic). Other issues which should be addressed in future studies include the extent of surgery, the role of systemic therapies, the relevance of novel biologic prognostic factors, salvage therapies after recurrence, cost-benefit analysis and quality of life.

Recurrent endometrial cancer after surgery alone: results of salvage radiotherapy

PURPOSE

Postoperative irradiation of endometrial cancer patients decreases the risk of local recurrence but is associated with a number of long-term sequelae. In a proportion of patients, no immediate postoperative radiotherapy is applied and this treatment is introduced only at relapse. The aim of our study was to assess the long-term results of salvage radiotherapy in previously nonirradiated endometrial cancer patients who developed local recurrence, and to evaluate the impact of patient- and treatment-related factors on treatment efficacy.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

We performed a detailed retrospective analysis of 73 endometrial cancer patients given radiotherapy for local recurrence after the initial surgery only. The mean age at diagnosis of the recurrence was 63 years (range, 39-78 years). Median time to recurrence was 11 months (range, 1-19 months). All recurrences were staged with the use of Perez modification of the International Federation of Gynecology and Obstetrics (FIGO) staging system for primary vaginal carcinoma. There were five (7%) Stage I patients, 43 (59%) Stage II patients, and 25 (34%) Stage III patients. Forty-four patients (60%) received both external beam irradiation (EBRT) and endovaginal brachytherapy (BRT), 17 (23%) received only BRT, and 12 (17%) received only EBRT. The mean total physical radiation dose was 75.9 Gy (range, 8-130 Gy), and the mean normalized total dose (NTD) calculated on the base of the linear-quadratic model was 86.6 Gy (range, 8.5-171.9 Gy). Median follow-up for alive patients was 8.8 years (range, 3-21 years). The impact of patient-, tumor-, and therapy-related factors on the treatment outcome was evaluated with the use of uni- and multivariate analyses.

RESULTS

Three- and 5-year overall survival rates were 33% and 25%, respectively. In the univariate analysis, lower stage of recurrent disease (p < 0.0005), combined EBRT and BRT (p = 0.027), higher total radiation dose (p = 0.031), and higher NTD (p = 0.006) were significantly correlated with better survival. In the multivariate analysis, only stage of recurrent disease (p < 0.005) and high total dose (p = 0.047) were independently correlated with better survival. Lower FIGO stage of recurrence (p = 0.023) and higher total dose (p = 0.005) were also independently correlated with longer time to progression, whereas higher radiotherapy dose was the only factor correlated with better local control (p = 0.029).

CONCLUSIONS

The efficacy of salvage radiotherapy in endometrial cancer patients with local failure after previous surgery is limited. Factors determining treatment outcome include advancement of the tumor at relapse and radiotherapy dose.

Vaginal vault brachytherapy: the effect of varying bladder volumes on normal tissue dosimetry

This study was designed to assess the impact of bladder volume on dosimetry to critical normal structures in vaginal vault brachytherapy using a single line source vaginal applicator. 30 consecutive patients undergoing vaginal vault brachytherapy were studied by CT scanning with the applicator in situ and the bladder empty and then with the bladder containing either 35 ml of water (10 patients), 70 ml of water (10 patients) or 100 ml of water (10 patients). The scans were then analysed with isodose distributions overlayed to determine changes in dosimetry. No effect on bladder dose was seen with increasing volume compared with the empty bladder; however, there was a reduction in amount of small bowel within the high dose treatment region as bladder volume increased. With 100 ml bladder volume, the reduction reached 57.5% compared with the empty bladder. We conclude that vaginal vault brachytherapy should be undertaken with a bladder volume of at least 100 ml, which will considerably reduce the amount of small bowel in the irradiation volume with no increase in bladder dose.

Surgery followed by radiotherapy in endometrial cancer: analysis of survival and patterns of failure

We performed a retrospective evaluation of survival and patterns of failure in 317 consecutive endometrial cancer patients treated between 1974 and 1991 with surgery and adjuvant radiotherapy. Two hundred and forty seven patients (78%) had FIGO stage I disease, 30 (9%) - stage II, 35 (11%) - stage III and 5 (2%) - stage IV. Both low dose rate brachytherapy (BRT) and external beam radiation (EBRT) were applied in 247 patients (78%), only BRT in 49 (15%), and only EBRT in 21 (7%). Median follow-up was 7.3 years. Five-year overall survival was 75%, and five-year disease free survival was 81%. Both overall and disease free survival rates were correlated with stage (P = 0.001 and P = 0.000, respectively). Recurrence occurred in 70 patients (22%): 11 (3.5%) in the pelvis, 51 (16%) outside the pelvis and 6 (2%) both in- and outside the pelvis. Independent risk factors for local recurrence included older age (P = 0.03) and variant histologic subtypes (P = 0.039), whereas independent risk factors for distant spread were stage (P = 0.000) and older age (P = 0.011). Normalized Total Dose (the sum of EBRT and BRT doses, based on linear-quadratic equation), type of radiotherapy regimen, overall radiotherapy time and surgery-to-radiotherapy interval did not correlate with the risk of relapse. Severe early and late radiotherapy complications were observed in 21 (7%) and 35 patients (11%), respectively. In view of the relatively low risk of exclusive pelvic recurrences and the high rate of severe late radiotherapy complications, indications for postoperative radiotherapy and its scheme should be verified. A relatively high rate of extrapelvic recurrences calls for effective systemic adjuvants to surgery. Further definition of high risk patients is warranted in order to tailor postoperative therapy to the prognostic factors and to increase the therapeutic index of management of endometrial cancer.

The role of adjuvant radiotherapy in carcinoma of the endometrium-results in 550 patients with pathologic stage I disease

OBJECTIVES

A retrospective analysis of 550 women with pathological stage I carcinoma of the endometrium who were seen between January 1984 and December 1988 was performed in order to assess the value of adjuvant radiation therapy.

METHODS

Two-hundred twenty-eight patients were treated with surgery alone (S); 97 received adjuvant external beam radiotherapy (S + EXT); 217 received external beam radiotherapy and colpostats (S + EXT + IC); and 8 patients received only colpostats (S + IC). Pelvic radiation therapy, usually 40 Gy in 20 fractions, was administered to 94% of patients whose tumors showed greater than 50% myometrial invasion and to 89% of patients with FIGO grade 3 tumors. Colpostats were used in 40% of patients, the majority of whom had lower uterine segment involvement.

RESULTS

The overall survival rate for the whole group using Kaplan-Meier estimates was 84% at 5 years. The 5-year overall survival rates for each treatment group, excluding the S + IC group, were 90% for S alone, 79% for S + EXT, and 82% for S + EXT + IC. The 5-year disease-free survival rates were 84, 77, and 77%, respectively. Local control rates at 5 years were 93, 94, and 95% in the three treatment groups, but the patterns of relapse were different. Distant metastases occurred more frequently among the patients who received adjuvant radiation therapy (36/49, 73%) than among those who did not (4/19, 21%). Late toxicity was documented in 66 patients. Twelve patients had EORTC/RTOG grade 3 and 4 complications; all had been treated with S + EXT + IC. FIGO grade (P = 0.009), lower uterine segment involvement (P = 0.009), and age (P = 0.03) were significant predictors of worse disease-free survival in a multiple regression analysis.

CONCLUSIONS

The addition of vaginal vault brachytherapy to external beam radiotherapy did not appear to improve local cure rates nor survival, but increased the incidence of late radiation toxicity.

Late complications after postoperative radiotherapy in endometrial cancer: analysis of 317 consecutive cases with application of linear-quadratic model

PURPOSE

To evaluate the incidence and risk factors for late complications after postoperative radiotherapy in endometrial cancer patients.

METHODS AND MATERIAL

We performed a detailed retrospective analysis of 317 endometrial cancer patients given postoperative radiotherapy. A total of 247 patients (78%) received both intracavitary (BRT) and external beam irradiation (XRT); 49 patients (15%) received only BRT, and 21 (7%) only XRT. BRT included radium (Ra) and cesium (Cs). The mean dose rate for both isotopes at 0.5 cm from the applicator surface was 0.47 +/- 0.06 and 1.42 +/- 0.41 Gy/h, and the mean total dose was 50.5 +/- 10.3 and 48.4 +/- 15.0 Gy, respectively. Mean BRT dose at 0.5 cm was 50.1 +/- 11.7 Gy (range 14.5-71.0). Mean XRT dose in the International Commission on Radiation Units and Measurements (ICRU) reference point was 49.0 +/- 3.7 Gy (range 22.0-66.0) given in fractions of 1.54-2.49 Gy (mean 2.0 +/- 0.17) with a two- or four-field technique. Follow-up ranged from 4 to 21 years (median 7.3). Normalized total dose (NTD) including XRT and BRT doses was calculated based on a linear quadratic equation.

RESULTS

Five-year overall survival rate was 75%, and 5-year disease-free survival (censored for noncancer deaths) was 81%. Late radiotherapy complications of any grade occurred in 158 patients (51%), including bowel complications in 41% and urinary bladder complications in 21%. A total of 37 grade 3 or 4 complications were observed in 33 patients (11%), of whom 32 were treated with both XRT and BRT. Severe bowel and/or urinary bladder complications occurred in 24 patients: in 14 of 72 patients (19.4%) who received XRT and Cs BRT, and in 10 of 172 patients (6.0%) applied XRT and Ra BRT. The higher proportion of severe bowel and/or bladder complications in the former group was due to the particularly frequent rate of these events (30.0%) in a subset of 47 patients who received XRT combined with Cs BRT at the dose rate of 1.7 Gy/h and the total BRT dose of 60 Gy. Higher NTD, XRT fraction dose, BRT dose rate, Cs BRT, two-field XRT technique, short overall radiotherapy time, and older age were correlated with increased late-event risk in univariate analysis. Multivariate Cox analysis demonstrated that the independent risk factors for late bowel complications were NTD (p = 0.000) and BRT dose rate (p = 0.036), whereas for bladder complications they were BRT dose rate (p = 0.005) and XRT fraction dose (p = 0.041). Neither clinical factor (age, parity, prior abdominal surgery, FIGO stage, diabetes mellitus, or hypertension) nor the surgery-to-radiotherapy interval, nor overall radiotherapy time was independently associated with the risk of late bladder or bowel complications.

CONCLUSIONS

The risk of late complications after postoperative radiotherapy in endometrial cancer depends mainly on treatment-related factors: NTD, BRT dose rate, and XRT fraction dose. The use of combined XRT and BRT increases the risk of late effects. NTD calculations including BRT dose rate and XRT fraction dose enable estimation of radiobiologically equivalent dose and can decrease the risk of mistakes when the radiotherapy regimen is changed.

Uterine cancer (corpus uteri)

This synthesis of the literature on radiotherapy for cancer originating in the endometrium of the uterus (corpus uteri) is based on 55 scientific articles, including 2 randomized studies, 1 prospective study, and 48 retrospective studies. These studies involve 13597 patients. Endometrial cancer is a radiosensitive cancer. Research findings compiled for the period 1948 to 1954 showed that 69% of the patients could be cured by radiotherapy alone. During the 1970s it was shown that combined radiotherapy and surgery yielded better results. There is agreement that patients at stage I should receive primary surgery. According to the literature, there is controversy about whether patients with poorly differentiated tumors should be given preoperative radiotherapy. Radiotherapy alone can be used successfully in patients who are inoperable because of age, general condition, or advanced spread of cancer. Vaginal postoperative radiotherapy is used in most patients and reduces the percentage of patients who develop vaginal metastases from 7%-20% to less than 1%. Patients with good prognostic factors have such a low risk for metastasis that withholding radiotherapy may be considered in this group. Postoperative external radiotherapy improves survival in patients with unfavorable prognostic factors, such as deep myometrium invasion or signs of node metastasis. Radiotherapy is delivered, in principle, to all patients with poorly differentiated disease. It can be expected that most cases of endometrial cancer will continue to be referred for some form of radiotherapy.

Uterine sarcomas: a review of the Edinburgh experience from 1974 to 1992

A retrospective review of patients treated for a uterine sarcoma in Edinburgh from 1974 to 1992 has been performed. Clinical details at presentation, tumour pathology, treatment and the outcome of treatment were all recorded. 82 patients' case notes were reviewed. 54 patients had died and 28 were alive (mean follow-up period 80.3 months). 39 patients had a malignant mixed mesodermal tumour, 12 patients had an endometrial stromal sarcoma, and 27 had a leiomyosarcoma. Using a modified FIGO staging retrospectively, 41 patients had Stage 1 disease, two patients had Stage 2, 16 patients had Stage 3, and 13 patients had Stage 4 disease. Definitive treatment of total abdominal hysterectomy and bilateral salpingo-oophorectomy was used in 69 patients, with 35 of these patients also receiving post-operative radiotherapy to the pelvis. 13 patients did not undergo surgery. Five of these patients received radical radiotherapy, three patients received palliative radiotherapy, and five patients were not treated. The overall median survival is 15 months and the 5-year actuarial survival is 31%. 25 of the 26 surviving patients had Stage 1 disease at presentation. Post-operative pelvic radiotherapy did not influence either survival or local tumour control. 51 of the 54 patients who relapsed had evidence of distant metastases. We conclude that total abdominal hysterectomy and bilateral salpingo-oophorectomy remains the treatment of choice for uterine sarcomas.