Regulation of autoimmunity

The role of transforming growth factor beta in the generation of suppression: an interaction between CD8+ T and NK cells

CD8+ T cells have suppressor effector functions, but the mechanisms involved in the generation of this activity are poorly understood. We report that natural killer (NK) cells have an important role in the acquisition of this function. CD8+ cells induce NK cells to produce transforming growth factor-beta (TGF-beta) which, in turn, stimulates CD8+ T cells to become suppressors of antibody production. Using a monocyte-dependent and -independent method to induce antibody production, we first observed that the addition of NK cells to CD8+ cells was required for optimal suppression. Next, we determined that the interaction of CD8+ T cells with NK cells resulted in a striking increase NK cell TGF-beta mRNA and its production. This cytokine appeared to be involved in the induction of T suppressor cell activity since: (a) anti-TGF-beta 1 completely abrogated the suppression of immunoglobulin G synthesis; (b) TGF-beta 1 could substitute for NK cells in inducing CD8+ T cells to develop suppressor activity; and (c) a short exposure of T cells to TGF-beta 1 in the absence of B cells was sufficient for the generation of suppressor activity by CD8+ T cells. Interferon gamma did not have this property. These studies provide strong evidence that in addition to its suppressive properties, TGF-beta is involved in the generation of CD8+ T suppressor effector cells. Because NK cell function is decreased in many autoimmune diseases, these cells may fail to interact properly with these individuals' CD8+ cells in generating suppressors of aggressive anti-self responses.

Holes in the T cell repertoire to myelin basic protein owing to the absence of the D beta 2-J beta 2 gene cluster: implications for T cell receptor recognition and autoimmunity

Models of T cell recognition suggest that amino acid residues in the CDR3 region of the T cell receptor (TCR) alpha or beta chain directly contact the major histocompatibility complex-bound peptide, and thus are crucial for providing peptide specificity. T cells derived from B10.PL or PL/J mice of H-2u haplotype, use only D beta 2 and J beta 2 gene segments in the recognition of the dominant determinant, Ac1-9/Au, of myelin basic protein (MBP). New Zealand White (NZW) mice, with identical class II H-2u genes (I-A and I-E), carry an 8.8-kb deletion in their TCR beta chain locus encompassing D beta 2 and J beta 2 gene segments. How does this deletion of the crucial D beta 2-J beta 2 region in NZW mice influence specific responses to Ac1-9/Au as well as to other known Au or Eu determinants of MBP? We found that these mice respond very poorly to the dominant Ac1-9/Au and to the subdominant 31-50/Eu determinant in in vitro proliferation assays as well as in their in vivo capacity to induce experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis. This loss of response is apparently owing to the absence of high avidity TCRs with essential CDR3 residues contributed by D beta 2 or J beta 2 gene segments. These data reveal constraints in the recognition of certain antigenic structures, and further support a TCR-recognition model in which CDR3 residues of the TCR alpha and beta chains constitute the antigenic peptide-binding sites on the TCR molecule. Implications for autoimmune manifestations contributed by NZW genes in (NZB x NZW)F1 disease are also discussed.

Cellular immunity and retrobulbar fibroblasts in Graves' ophthalmopathy

In Graves' ophthalmopathy (GO), retrobulbar connective tissue is infiltrated by T cells whose role in the pathogenesis of the disease was investigated in the present work. The aims included firstly to characterize subsets of blood lymphocytes and of sessile lymphocytes cloned from a retroorbital tissue specimen. Second, in counterstimulation assays, the ability of patients' T cells to influence cultivated retrobulbar fibroblasts and in turn the enhancement of lymphocyte proliferation by retrobulbar fibroblasts was investigated. Blood lymphocytes of 16 GO patients and 12 controls isolated by density gradient centrifugation and retrobulbar fibroblasts obtained from orbital decompression were alternately exposed to irradiation of 4000 rad (to suppress proliferation of either cell type), then cocultivated for 48 h. Subsequently, the cells (250,000 lymphocytes, 5000 retrobulbar fibroblasts) were incubated with [3H]thymidine for 24 h. A stimulation index representing the degree of proliferation in comparison with a control was determined. Screening of 62 retrobulbar lymphocyte clones by cell-ELISA revealed a CD4/CD8 ratio of 8.2, contrasting with a normal ratio of 2.1 in peripheral lymphocytes (as obtained by FACS analysis). Incubation of patient's lymphocytes with autologous retrobulbar fibroblasts resulted in a markedly elevated stimulation index (9.7) compared to incubation of lymphocytes with retrobulbar fibroblasts from controls (2.5). In another assay, the degree of stimulation amounted to 2.2 vs. -0.8. Retrobulbar fibroblasts were stimulated twice as much by lymphocytes of the same patient compared to retrobulbar fibroblasts from controls. The autologous reactions demonstrated suggest the presence of autoreactive T lymphocytes in GO patients directed against retrobulbar fibroblasts, which, in addition, are stimulated by these lymphocytes.

Involution of the thymus revisited: immunological trade-offs as an adaptation to aging

An attempt was made, in previous theories, to find a unifying explanation for two phenomena of thymic involution: stress-induced reversible involution and age-related irreversible involution. It was postulated that in both cases involution is beneficial to the organism, as it serves to reduce the dangers of autoimmune reactions. The modified theory proposed here: (a) relates to the suggestions of I.R. Cohen and D.B. Young (Immunol. Today, 12 (1991) 105-109) and to those of S. Avrameas Immunol. Today, 12 (1991) 154-158) as to the usefulness of autoantibodies to the organism; (b) emphasizes the fact that self components undergo continuous changes throughout the life cycle of the organism, which in turn necessitates continuous adaptations to prevent autoimmune damage; (c) stresses the relevance of these adaptations to the process of natural selection; (d) brings experimental evidence to the effect that thymic involution will reduce the danger of autoimmune damage; and (e) suggests that the adaptations required to prevent autoimmune reactions with aging entail immunological compromises or trade-offs. These measures may by themselves cause autoimmune diseases, result in reduced resistance to neoplasia and to infectious diseases, particularly viral ones, and in accelerated aging.