Adequacy of information and acceptability of pain relief as assessed by a postpartum questionnaire

What mothers know, and want to know, about the complications of general anaesthesia

BACKGROUND

Informed consent should be sought when performing anaesthesia on pregnant patients. There is no standard for consent for general anaesthesia on the delivery suite. This study was designed to assess post-partum women's awareness of the complications of general anaesthesia and the level of risk at which they felt these risks should be discussed.

METHODS

One hundred and fifty parturients from two London hospitals who had undergone uncomplicated vaginal deliveries were asked on the first post-partum day about their knowledge of the potential complications of general anaesthesia for obstetrics. They were also asked about the level of risk at which they would wish to be informed before consenting to a general anaesthetic procedure.

RESULTS

The knowledge of the risks of general anaesthesia among the parturients was poor, with awareness, allergy, nausea and vomiting being known by over 50%. Knowledge of difficult intubation and its consequences, dental damage, malignant hyperpyrexia and suxamethonium apnoea was known by less than 30% of the respondents. The level of risk at which mothers felt they should be informed was variable, with 50% wishing to know all risks up to 1 : 1000, and 19% wishing to know risks of greater than 1 : 1,000,000. All known risks were wished by nearly 30% of those questioned.

CONCLUSIONS

Anaesthetists must be flexible when providing information to mothers about general anaesthesia and should provide more information to mothers if they wish it.

Complications of obstetric regional analgesia: how much information is enough?

Two hundred parturients who had received epidural analgesia during labour (100 in Melbourne, Australia and 100 in London, UK) were asked on the first postnatal day about their sources of antenatal information on pain relief in labour, their awareness of potential complications of epidural analgesia and the level of risk at which they would wish to be informed before consenting to a procedure. Sources of antenatal information were similar in the two countries although more women in Australia received information from an anaesthetist or obstetrician than in the UK, whilst more women in the UK received information from the media than in Australia. Knowledge of risks was also similar although the Australian subjects were more aware of infective complications while those in the UK were more aware of intravascular injection of local anaesthetic; these differences may reflect recent high-profile cases in the two countries. The preferred level of risk at which women wanted to be informed about a complication varied from 1:1 to 1:1,000,000,000 in all three centres. The majority of women considered that the benefits of epidural analgesia outweighed each of the potential complications. Women differ in their requirements for antenatal information about regional analgesia and its complications, with some wanting to know every complication, however rare. Anaesthetists should be flexible in their disclosure of information when obtaining consent for regional analgesia and consider the particular wishes of each patient rather than follow rigid centralised guidelines.

Maternal satisfaction with labour analgesia

Satisfaction with childbirth is a multidimensional issue, of which analgesia is but one component. The importance of analgesia as a contribution to overall satisfaction has been recognized increasingly in the last 50 years, but improvement in quality of available analgesia has not always resulted in commensurate improvement in satisfaction. Satisfaction by its very nature has proved to be difficult both to define and to quantify, and no reliable standards of measurement have been accepted. Pain relief in childbirth is subject to many social and cultural modifiers, which continue to change. Control of pain rather than absolute amelioration is seen by many to provide greater satisfaction. Analgesia issues still do not figure prominently in the overall satisfaction of the birthing process for the vast majority of women, despite the availability of and demand for improved methods of relief. The interpersonal relationships established between patient and healthcare providers may ultimately be of more importance in the determination of satisfaction with management.