Mammalian artificial chromosomes as tools for gene therapy

Improving the efficiency of gene insertion in a human artificial chromosome vector and its transfer in human-induced pluripotent stem cells

A human artificial chromosome (HAC) vector has potential to overcome the problems of stable gene expression associated with plasmid, transposon, and virus-based vectors, such as insertional mutagenesis, position effect, uncontrollable copy number, unstable gene expression, and DNA size limitation. The main advantages of the HAC are its episomal nature and ability to accommodate DNA inserts of any size. However, HAC vectors have two disadvantages: low efficiency of gene insertion and lack of reports regarding the successful HAC transfer to human-induced pluripotent stem cells (iPSCs). We here provide the first report of a method for the efficient transfer of HAC to human iPSCs for obtaining reproducible experimental results. Moreover, we achieved a 10% increase in the gene insertion efficiency in the HAC vector using our new site-specific recombination systems VCre/VloxP and SCre/SloxP.

De novo generation of satellite DNA-based artificial chromosomes by induced large-scale amplification

Mammalian artificial chromosomes (MACs) are engineered chromosomes with defined genetic content that can function as non-integrating vectors with large carrying capacity and stability. The large carrying capacity allows the engineering of MACs with multiple copies of the same transgene, gene complexes, and to include regulatory elements necessary for the regulated expression of transgene(s). In recent years, different approaches have been explored to generate MACs (Vos Curr Opin Genet Dev 8:351-359, 1998; Danielle et al. Trends Biotech 23:573-583, 2005; Duncan and Hadlaczky Curr Opin Biotech 18:420-424, 2007): (1) the de novo formation by centromere seeding, the "bottom-up" approach, (2) the truncation of natural chromosomes or the modification of naturally occurring minichromosomes, the "top-down" approach, and (3) the in vivo "inductive" approach. Satellite DNA-based artificial chromosomes (SATACs) generated by the in vivo "inductive" method have the potential to become an efficient tool in diverse gene technology applications such as cellular protein manufacturing (Kennard et al. BioPharm Int 20:52-59, 2007; Kennard et al. Biotechnol Bioeng 104:526-539, 2009; Kennard et al. Biotechnol Bioeng 104:540-553, 2009), transgenic animal production (Telenius et al. Chromosome Res 7:3-7, 1999; Co et al. Chromosome Res 8:183-191, 2000; Monteith et al. Methods Mol Biol 240:227-242, 2003), and ultimately a safe vector for gene therapy (Vanderbyl et al. Stem Cells 22:324-333, 2004; Vanderbyl et al. Exp Hematol 33:1470-1476, 2005; Katona et al. Cell. Mol. Life Sci 65:3830-3838, 2008). A detailed protocol for the de novo generation of satellite DNA-based artificial chromosomes (SATACs) via induced large-scale amplification is presented.

Transgenic animals: current and alternative strategies

Transgenic animal technology is one of the most fascinating technologies developed in the last two decades. It allows us to address questions in life sciences that no other methods have achieved. The impact on biomedical and biological research, as well as commercial interests are overwhelming. The questions accompanying this fast growing technology and its diversified applications attract the attention from a variety of entities. Still, one of the most fundamental problems remaining is the search for an efficient and reliable gene delivery system for creating transgenic animals. The traditional method of pronuclear microinjection has displayed great variability in success among species. While an acceptable efficiency in the production of transgenic mice has been attained, the relative low efficiency (<1%) in creating transgenic livestock has become one of the barriers for its application. In the past decades, improvements in producing transgenic livestock have made a slow progression, however, the recent advancement in cloning technology and the ability to create transgenic livestock in a highly efficient manner, have opened the gate to a new era in transgenic technology. Discoveries of new gene delivery systems have created an enthusiastic atmosphere that has made this technology so unique. This review focuses on gene delivery strategies as well as various approaches that may assist the advancement of transgenic efficiency in large animals.

Chromosome-based vectors for gene therapy

Currently used vectors in human gene therapy suffer from a number of limitations with respect to safety and reproducibility. There is increasing agreement that the ideal vector for gene therapy should be completely based on chromosomal elements and behave as an independent functional unit after integration into the genome or when retained as an episome. In this review we will first discuss the chromosomal elements, such as enhancers, locus control regions, boundary elements, insulators and scaffold- or matrix-attachment regions, involved in the hierarchic regulation of mammalian gene expression and replication. These elements have been used to design vectors that behave as artificial domains when integrating into the genome. We then discuss recent progress in the use of mammalian artificial chromosomes and small circular non-viral vectors for their use as expression systems in mammalian cells.

Establishment of an oriP/EBNA1-based episomal vector transcribing human genomic beta-globin in cultured murine fibroblasts

A novel oriP/EBNA1-based episomal vector has been constructed that persists episomally in cultured murine fibroblasts. The vector, pBH148, is equipped with the entire 185-kb human beta-globin gene locus. After amplification in bacteria, column-purified episomal pBH148 was transfected into both cultured EBNA1-expressing human D98/Raji positive control fusion cells (DRpBH148) and cultured EBNA1-negative murine fibroblast cells (A9pBH148). Cell cultures were maintained concurrently with and without hygromycin selection for a period of 3 months. We show long-term stable episome maintenance of the full-size 200-kb circular double-stranded pBH148 in both the DRpBH148 cultures and the A9pBH148 cultures, regardless of selective pressure by agarose gel electrophoresis and Southern blot. EBNA1 transgene was detected by PCR in all transfected cultures. In addition, we were able to detect correctly spliced human beta-globin mRNA by RT-PCR in all transfected late-passage DRpBH148 and A9pBH148 cell cultures. These findings illustrate that this oriP/EBNA1-based episomal vector is stable in a previously nonpermissive murine cell line and is a potential vector for human gene therapy.

Genome medicine: gene therapy for the millennium, 30 September-3 October 2001, Rome, Italy

The recent surge of DNA sequence information resulting from the efforts of agencies interested in deciphering the human genetic code has facilitated technological developments that have been critical in the identification of genes associated with numerous disease pathologies. In addition, these efforts have opened the door to the opportunity to develop novel genetic therapies to treat a broad range of inherited disorders. Through a joint effort by the University of Vermont, the University of Rome, Tor Vergata, University of Rome, La Sapienza, and the CSS Mendel Institute, Rome, an international meeting, 'Genome Medicine: Gene Therapy for the Millennium' was organized. This meeting provided a forum for the discussion of scientific and clinical advances stimulated by the explosion of sequence information generated by the Human Genome Project and the implications these advances have for gene therapy. The meeting had six sessions that focused on the functional evaluation of specific genes via biochemical analysis and through animal models, the development of novel therapeutic strategies involving gene targeting, artificial chromsomes, DNA delivery systems and non-embryonic stem cells, and on the ethical and social implications of these advances.

Efficient in-vitro transfer of a 60-Mb mammalian artificial chromosome into murine and hamster cells using cationic lipids and dendrimers

Non-integrating artificial chromosomes represent a potentially promising approach to ex-vivo and in-vivo gene therapy applications. These large vectors require an efficient means for delivery to target cells. We have evaluated a panel of twenty-one commercially available transfection agents for their ability to mediate the in-vitro transfer of a 60-Mb murine artificial chromosome consisting of mouse major satellite DNA and a payload including a marker gene (hygromycin B) and a reporter gene (lacZ). A rapid screening procedure utilizing iododeoxyuridine-incorporated artificial chromosomes facilitated the assessment of different transfection conditions. The results were confirmed by cytogenetic analysis of positively transfected clones. By transfecting both hamster lung fibroblast cells (V79-4) and murine connective tissue cells [L-M(TK-)], the best results were obtained using either Superfect (cationic dendrimer) or LipofectAMINE 2000 (cationic lipid) with protocols adapted for metaphase chromosome preparation. Transfection efficiencies of 10(-4)-10(-2) (0.01-1%) were routinely observed, and recipient cells were able to maintain expression of the reporter gene over the total length of the experiment. This represents a significant advance over our previous attempts at mass-transfection of artificial chromosomes using microcell fusion, where we routinely achieved efficiencies at least two orders of magnitudes less than reported here. These data are particularly noteworthy given that lipid-mediated gene transfer typically involves transfecting millions of plasmids (1 microg of DNA from a 5 kb plasmid is approximately 1.2 x 10(11) copies) to each cell whereas the much larger artificial chromosomes comprise only a one-to-one ratio, yet achieve transfection efficiencies of (10(-2)-10(-1)), that is, comparable to our results. These data suggest that artificial chromosomes containing therapeutic genes can be successfully delivered to target cells in vitro using well-established transfection agents.

Expression of a reporter gene after microinjection of mammalian artificial chromosomes into pronuclei of bovine zygotes

The introduction of mammalian artificial chromosomes (ACs) into zygotes represents an alternative, more predictive technology for the production of recombinant proteins in transgenic animals. The aim of these experiments was to examine the effects of artificial chromosome microinjection into bovine pronuclei on embryo development and reporter gene expression. Bovine oocytes aspirated from 2-5 mm size follicles were matured in vitro for 22 hr. Mature oocytes were fertilized in vitro with frozen- thawed bull spermatozoa. Artificial chromosome carrying either beta-galactosidase (Lac-Z) gene or green fluorescence protein (GFP) gene were isolated by flow cytometry. A single chromosome was microinjected into one of the two pronuclei of bovine zygotes. Sham injected zygotes served as controls. Injected zygotes were cultured in G 1.2 medium for 7 days. Hatched blastocysts were cultured on blocked STO cell feeder layer for attachment and outgrowth of ICM and trophectoderm cells. The results showed a high zygote survival rate following LacZ-ACs microinjection (74%). However, the blastocyst development rate after 7 days of culture was significantly lower than that of sham injected zygotes (7.5 vs. 22%). Embryonic cells positive for Lac-Z gene were detected by PCR in three of nine outgrowth colonies. In addition, GFP gene expression was observed in 15 out of 85 (18%) embryos at the arrested 2-cell stage to blastocyst stage. Six blastocysts successfully outgrew, three outgrowths were GFP positive for up to 3 weeks in culture. We conclude that the methodology for artificial chromosome delivery into bovine zygotes could lead to viable blastocyst development, and reporter gene expression could be sustained during pre-implantation development.

Viral vectors as part of an integrated functional genomics program

Over the past decade, viral vectors have slowly gained mainstream acceptance in the neuroscience and genetics communities for the in vivo study of gene function [1]. Using stereotactic techniques, it is possible to characterize neuroanatomical relationships through the delivery of neurotropic viral vectors to specific brain regions. More sophisticated studies combine viral vectors with other methods of genetic manipulation such as germline transgenic mice. As more is learned about the properties of different viral vectors, it has become possible to use viral vectors to test hypotheses about the function of genes, through targeted in vivo delivery to the central nervous system (CNS). The effects of gene expression in the brain can be measured on the molecular, biochemical, electrophysiological, morphological, and behavioral levels. We propose that viral vectors should be considered as part of an integrated functional genomics platform in the CNS.

Genomics and gene therapy. Artificial chromosomes coming to life

One of the biggest obstacles to gene therapy is the delivery of the therapeutic gene to the target tissue so that it is appropriately expressed. In his Perspective, Willard looks at the potential advantages of using a human artificial chromosome to maintain expression of a therapeutic gene and discusses some of the hurdles yet to be overcome before this gene delivery system can be tried out in the clinic.

Generation of transgenic mice and germline transmission of a mammalian artificial chromosome introduced into embryos by pronuclear microinjection

We have generated transgenic mice by pronuclear microinjection of a murine satellite DNA-based artificial chromosome (SATAC). As 50% of the founder progeny were SATAC-positive, this demonstrates that SATAC transmission through the germline had occurred. FISH analyses of metaphase chromosomes from mitogen-activated peripheral blood lymphocytes from both the founder and progeny revealed that the SATAC was maintained as a discrete chromosome and that it had not integrated into an endogenous chromosome. To our knowledge, this is the first report of the germline transmission of a genetically engineered mammalian artificial chromosome within transgenic animals generated through pronuclear microinjection. We have also shown that murine SATACs can be similarly introduced into bovine embryos. The use of embryo microinjection to generate transgenic mammals carrying genetically engineered chromosomes provides a novel method by which the unique advantages of chromosome-based gene delivery systems can be exploited.

Novel generation of human satellite DNA-based artificial chromosomes in mammalian cells

An in vivo approach has been developed for generation of artificial chromosomes, based on the induction of intrinsic, large-scale amplification mechanisms of mammalian cells. Here, we describe the successful generation of prototype human satellite DNA-based artificial chromosomes via amplification-dependent de novo chromosome formations induced by integration of exogenous DNA sequences into the centromeric/rDNA regions of human acrocentric chromosomes. Subclones with mitotically stable de novo chromosomes were established, which allowed the initial characterization and purification of these artificial chromosomes. Because of the low complexity of their DNA content, they may serve as a useful tool to study the structure and function of higher eukaryotic chromosomes. Human satellite DNA-based artificial chromosomes containing amplified satellite DNA, rDNA, and exogenous DNA sequences were heterochromatic, however, they provided a suitable chromosomal environment for the expression of the integrated exogenous genetic material. We demonstrate that induced de novo chromosome formation is a reproducible and effective methodology in generating artificial chromosomes from predictable sequences of different mammalian species. Satellite DNA-based artificial chromosomes formed by induced large-scale amplifications on the short arm of human acrocentric chromosomes may become safe or low risk vectors in gene therapy.

Transgenic animal bioreactors

The production of recombinant proteins is one of the major successes of biotechnology. Animal cells are required to synthesize proteins with the appropriate post-translational modifications. Transgenic animals are being used for this purpose. Milk, egg white, blood, urine, seminal plasma and silk worm cocoon from transgenic animals are candidates to be the source of recombinant proteins at an industrial scale. Although the first recombinant protein produced by transgenic animals is expected to be in the market in 2000, a certain number of technical problems remain to be solved before the various systems are optimized. Although the generation of transgenic farm animals has become recently easier mainly with the technique of animal cloning using transfected somatic cells as nuclear donor, this point remains a limitation as far as cost is concerned. Numerous experiments carried out for the last 15 years have shown that the expression of the transgene is predictable only to a limited extent. This is clearly due to the fact that the expression vectors are not constructed in an appropriate manner. This undoubtedly comes from the fact that all the signals contained in genes have not yet been identified. Gene constructions thus result sometime in poorly functional expression vectors. One possibility consists in using long genomic DNA fragments contained in YAC or BAC vectors. The other relies on the identification of the major important elements required to obtain a satisfactory transgene expression. These elements include essentially gene insulators, chromatin openers, matrix attached regions, enhancers and introns. A certain number of proteins having complex structures (formed by several subunits, being glycosylated, cleaved, carboxylated...) have been obtained at levels sufficient for an industrial exploitation. In other cases, the mammary cellular machinery seems insufficient to promote all the post-translational modifications. The addition of genes coding for enzymes involved in protein maturation has been envisaged and successfully performed in one case. Furin gene expressed specifically in the mammary gland proved to able to cleave native human protein C with good efficiency. In a certain number of cases, the recombinant proteins produced in milk have deleterious effects on the mammary gland function or in the animals themselves. This comes independently from ectopic expression of the transgenes and from the transfer of the recombinant proteins from milk to blood. One possibility to eliminate or reduce these side-effects may be to use systems inducible by an exogenous molecule such as tetracycline allowing the transgene to be expressed only during lactation and strictly in the mammary gland. The purification of recombinant proteins from milk is generally not particularly difficult. This may not be the case, however, when the endogenous proteins such as serum albumin or antibodies are abundantly present in milk. This problem may be still more crucial if proteins are produced in blood. Among the biological contaminants potentially present in the recombinant proteins prepared from transgenic animals, prions are certainly those raising the major concern. The selection of animals chosen to generate transgenics on one hand and the elimination of the potentially contaminated animals, thanks to recently defined quite sensitive tests may reduce the risk to an extremely low level. The available techniques to produce pharmaceutical proteins in milk can be used as well to optimize milk composition of farm animals, to add nutriceuticals in milk and potentially to reduce or even eliminate some mammary infectious diseases.

Making CENs of mammalian artificial chromosomes

Mammalian artificial chromosomes (MACs) hold the promise of providing autonomous vectors for gene therapy in dividing cells. They would not require insertion into the genome and could include sufficient genomic sequences that surround the therapeutic gene to ensure proper tissue-specific and temporal regulation. Several groups have reported successful formation of MACs in human cells using transfection strategies that included alpha satellite DNA, the primary DNA found at normal human centromeres. These results, although extremely encouraging, have limitations such as unpredictable chromosome formation and success thus far in only one transformed human cell line. Examination of other cells where alpha satellite DNA has integrated into ectopic chromosomal locations, as well as naturally occurring dicentric and neocentromere-containing cell lines, suggests that alpha satellite DNA may not be necessary or sufficient for centromere formation. Overall, these results suggest that epigenetic modifications of centromeric DNA are required for efficient centromere formation. Models for this centromere-specific epigenetic modification include a specialized chromatin structure and differential replication timing of centromeric DNA. Thus, further investigation of these centromere-specific epigenetic modifications may suggest strategies for increasing the efficiency of generating human artificial chromosomes for use as gene therapy vectors.

Biopharmaceutical production in transgenic livestock

The production of recombinant human proteins in the milk of transgenic dairy animals offers a safe, renewable source of commercially important proteins that cannot be produced as efficiently in adequate quantities by other methods. A decade of success in expressing a variety of proteins in livestock has brought three human recombinant proteins to human clinical trials. Recent progress has drawn on molecular biology and reproductive physiology to improve the efficiency of producing and reproducing useful transgenic founder animals, and to improve the expression of heterologous proteins in their milk.

Stability of a functional murine satellite DNA-based artificial chromosome across mammalian species

A 60-Mb murine chromosome consisting of murine pericentric satellite DNA and two bands of integrated marker and reporter genes has been generated de novo in a rodent/human hybrid cell line (mM2C1). This prototype mammalian artificial chromosome platform carries a normal centromere, and the expression of its beta-galactosidase reporter gene has remained stable under selection for over 25 months. The novel chromosome was transferred by a modified microcell fusion method to mouse [L-M(TK-)], bovine (P46) and human (EJ30) cell lines. In all cases, the chromosome remained structurally and functionally intact under selection for periods exceeding 3 months from the time of transfer into the new host. In addition, the chromosome was retained in three first-generation tumours when L-M(TK-) cells containing the chromosome were xenografted in severe combined immunodeficiency mice. These data support that a murine satellite DNA-based artificial chromosome can be used as a functional mammalian artificial chromosome and can be maintained in vivo and in cells of heterologous species in vitro.

A system for shuttling 200-kb BAC/PAC clones into human cells: stable extrachromosomal persistence and long-term ectopic gene activation

A novel shuttle vector, pBH140, has been constructed that allows stable maintenance of large genomic inserts as human artificial episomal chromosomes (HAECs) in mammalian cells. The vector, essentially a hybrid BAC-HAEC, contains an F-based replication system as in a bacterial artificial chromosome (BAC) and the Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) latent origin of replication system, oriP, for replication in human cells. A 185-kb DNA insert containing the entire human beta-globin locus, including its locus control region (LCR), was retrofitted into this vector. The resulting beta-globin BAC-HAEC clone, p148BH, was transfected into human cells and analyzed for episomal maintenance and expression of the beta-globin gene. FISH revealed an association of the vector with different human chromosomes but no integration. The beta-globin BAC-HAECs were present at an average copy number of 11-15 per nucleus in the stably transformed human cells. After 1 year of continuous in vitro cultivation, the HAECs persisted as structurally intact 200-kb episomes. While no beta-globin transcription could be detected in the parental D98/Raji cells, correctly spliced RT-PCR products were produced at significant levels in long-term cultures of the BAC-HAEC-transduced cells. The wide availability of BAC and PAC libraries, the ease in manipulating cloned DNA in bacteria, and the episomal stability of the pBH140 vector make this system ideal for studies on gene expression and other genomic functions in human cells. The potential significance of large, functionally active episomes for gene therapy is discussed.

Epstein-Barr-based episomal chromosomes shuttle 100 kb of self-replicating circular human DNA in mouse cells

We describe the microcell fusion transfer of 100-200 kb self-replicating circular human minichromosomes from human into mouse cells. This experimental approach is illustrated through the shutting of the latent 170 kb double-stranded DNA genome from the human herpesvirus, Epstein-Barr virus, into nonpermissive rodent cells. Using this interspecies transfer strategy, circular episomes carrying 95-105 kb of human DNA were successfully established at low copy number in mouse A9 cells. Selected episomes were stably maintained for 6 months, and unselected episomes were characterized by a 95% episomal retention per cell division. The establishment of a mouse artificial episomal chromosome system should facilitate evolutionary and therapeutic studies of large human DNA in rodent genetic backgrounds.