Hollows, voids, gaps and tunnels in the ribosome

Abortive translation caused by peptidyl-tRNA drop-off at NGG codons in the early coding region of mRNA

In Escherichia coli the codons CGG, AGG, UGG or GGG (NGG codons) but not GGN or GNG (where N is non-G) are associated with low expression of a reporter gene, if located at positions +2 to +5. Induction of a lacZ reporter gene with any one of the NGG codons at position +2 to +5 does not influence growth of a normal strain, but growth of a strain with a defective peptidyl-tRNA hydrolase (Pth) enzyme is inhibited. The same codons, if placed at position +7, did not give this effect. Other codons, such as CGU and AGA, at location +2 to +5, did not give any growth inhibition of either the wild-type or the mutant strain. The inhibitory effect on the pth mutant strain by NGG codons at location +5 was suppressed by overexpression of the Pth enzyme from a plasmid. However, the overexpression of cognate tRNAs for AGG or GGG did not rescue from the growth inhibition associated with these codons early in the induced model gene. The data suggest that the NGG codons trigger peptidyl-tRNA drop-off if located at early coding positions in mRNA, thereby strongly reducing gene expression. This does not happen if these codons are located further down in the mRNA at position +7, or later.

The bacterial ribosome at atomic resolution

X-ray crystallographic structures have just been published for the 30S ribosomal subunit of Thermus thermophilus at 3.4 A resolution and for the 50S subunit of Haloarcula marismortui at 2.4 A. These eagerly awaited structures will provide an enormous boost to research into the mechanisms involved in protein biosynthesis.

A map of protein-rRNA distribution in the 70 S Escherichia coli ribosome

Neutron scattering exploits the enormous scattering difference between protons and deuterons. A set of 42 x-ray and neutron solution scattering curves from hybrid Escherichia coli ribosomes was obtained, where the proteins and rRNA moieties in the subunits were either protonated or deuterated in all possible combinations. This extensive data set is analyzed using a novel method. The volume defined by the cryoelectron microscopic model of Frank and co-workers (Frank, J., Zhu, J., Penczek, P., Li, Y. H., Srivastava, S., Verschoor, A., Radermacher, M., Grassucci, R., Lata, R. K., and Agrawal, R. K. (1995) Nature 376, 441-444) is divided into 7890 densely packed spheres of radius 0.5 nm. Simulated annealing is employed to assign each sphere to solvent, protein, or rRNA moieties to simultaneously fit all scattering curves. Twelve independent reconstructions starting from random approximations yielded reproducible results. The resulting model at a resolution of 3 nm represents the volumes occupied by rRNA and protein moieties at 95% probability threshold and displays 15 and 20 protein subvolumes in the 30 S and 50 S, respectively, connected by rRNA. 17 proteins with known atomic structure can be tentatively positioned into the protein subvolumes within the ribosome in agreement with the results from other methods. The protein-rRNA map enlarges the basis for the models of the rRNA folding and can further help to localize proteins in high-resolution crystallographic density maps.

The Escherichia coli large ribosomal subunit at 7.5 A resolution

BACKGROUND

In recent years, the three-dimensional structure of the ribosome has been visualised in different functional states by single-particle cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM) at 13-25 A resolution. Even more recently, X-ray crystallography has achieved resolution levels better than 10 A for the ribosomal structures of thermophilic and halophilic organisms. We present here the 7.5 A solution structure of the 50S large subunit of the Escherichia coli ribosome, as determined by cryo-EM and angular reconstitution.

RESULTS

The reconstruction reveals a host of new details including the long alpha helix connecting the N- and C-terminal domains of the L9 protein, which is found wrapped like a collar around the base of the L1 stalk. A second L7/L12 dimer is now visible below the classical L7/L12 'stalk', thus revealing the position of the entire L8 complex. Extensive conformational changes occur in the 50S subunit upon 30S binding; for example, the L9 protein moves by some 50 A. Various rRNA stem-loops are found to be involved in subunit binding: helix h38, located in the A-site finger; h69, on the rim of the peptidyl transferase centre cleft; and h34, in the principal interface protrusion.

CONCLUSIONS

Single-particle cryo-EM is rapidly evolving towards the resolution levels required for the direct atomic interpretation of the structure of the ribosome. Structural details such as the minor and major grooves in rRNA double helices and alpha helices of the ribosomal proteins can already be visualised directly in cryo-EM reconstructions of ribosomes frozen in different functional states.

Elucidating the medium-resolution structure of ribosomal particles: an interplay between electron cryo-microscopy and X-ray crystallograhy

BACKGROUND

Ribosomes are the universal cellular organelles that accomplish the translation of the genetic code into proteins. Electron cryo-microscopy (cryo-EM) has yielded fairly detailed three-dimensional reconstructions of ribosomes. These were used to assist in the determination of higher resolution structures by X-ray crystallography.

RESULTS

Molecular replacement studies using cryo-EM reconstructions provided feasible packing schemes for crystals of ribosomes and their two subunits from Thermus thermophilus, and of the large subunits from Haloarcula marismortui. For the large subunits, these studies also confirmed the major heavy-atom sites obtained by single isomorphous replacement combined with anomalous diffraction (SIRAS) and by multiple isomorphous replacement combined with anomalous diffraction (MIRAS) at approximately 10 A. Although adequate starting phases could not be obtained for the small subunits, the crystals of which diffract to 3.0 A, cryo-EM reconstructions were indispensable for analyzing their 7.2 A multiple isomorphous replacement (MIR) map. This work indicated that the conformation of the crystallized small subunits resembles that seen within the 70S ribosomes. Subsequently, crystals of particles trapped in their functionally active state were grown.

CONCLUSIONS

Single-particle cryo-EM can contribute to the progress of crystallography of non-symmetrical, large and flexible macromolecular assemblies. Besides confirming heavy-atom sites, obtained from flat or overcrowded difference Patterson maps, the cryo-EM reconstructions assisted in elucidating packing arrangements. They also provided tools for the identification of the conformation within the crystals and for the estimation of the level of inherent non-isomorphism.

An unspliced group I intron in 23S rRNA links Chlamydiales, chloroplasts, and mitochondria

Chlamydia was the only genus in the order Chlamydiales until the recent characterization of Simkania negevensis Z(T) and Parachlamydia acanthamoebae strains. The present study of Chlamydiales 23S ribosomal DNA (rDNA) focuses on a naturally occurring group I intron in the I-CpaI target site of 23S rDNA from S. negevensis. The intron, SnLSU. 1, belonged to the IB4 structural subgroup and was most closely related to large ribosomal subunit introns that express single-motif, LAGLIDADG endonucleases in chloroplasts of algae and in mitochondria of amoebae. RT-PCR and electrophoresis of in vivo rRNA indicated that the intron was not spliced out of the 23S rRNA. The unspliced 658-nt intron is the first group I intron to be found in bacterial rDNA or rRNA, and it may delay the S. negevensis developmental replication cycle by affecting ribosomal function.

Initiation factors IF1 and IF2 synergistically remove peptidyl-tRNAs with short polypeptides from the P-site of translating Escherichia coli ribosomes

A novel function of initiation factors IF1 and IF2 in Escherichia coli translation has been identified. It is shown that these factors efficiently catalyse dissociation of peptidyl-tRNAs with polypeptides of different length from the P-site of E. coli ribosomes, and that the simultaneous presence of both factors is required for induction of drop-off. The factor-induced drop-off occurs with both sense and stop codons in the A-site and competes with peptide elongation or termination. The efficiency with which IF1 and IF2 catalyse drop-off decreases with increasing length of the nascent polypeptide, but is quite significant for hepta-peptidyl-tRNAs, the longest polypeptide chains studied. In the absence of IF1 and IF2 the rate of drop-off varies considerably for different peptidyl-tRNAs, and depends both on the length and sequence of the nascent peptide. Efficient factor-catalysed drop-off requires GTP but not GTP hydrolysis, as shown in experiments without guanine nucleotides, with GDP or with the non-cleavable analogue GMP-PNP.Simultaneous overexpression of IF1 and IF2 in vivo inhibits cell growth specifically in some peptidyl-tRNA hydrolase deficient mutants, suggesting that initiation factor-catalysed drop-off of peptidyl-tRNA can occur on a significant scale in the bacterial cell. Consequences for the bacterial physiology of this previously unknown function of IF1 and IF2 are discussed.

Functional universality and evolutionary diversity: insights from the structure of the ribosome

The structure of the mammalian ribosome, reconstructed at 25 A resolution, has added a new dimension to our current knowledge, as it manifests the conservation and universality of the ribosome in respect to its primary tasks in protein biosynthesis. A combined approach to study of the ribosome, using X-ray crystallography and electron microscopy, may further improve our understanding of ribosome function in the future.

The 80S rat liver ribosome at 25 A resolution by electron cryomicroscopy and angular reconstitution

BACKGROUND

The ribosome is central to protein synthesis in all living organisms. Single-particle electron cryomicroscopy has recently led to the determination of three-dimensional structures of bacterial ribosomes to approximately 20 A, which have since revolutionised our understanding of ribosomal function. The structure we present here of the 80S rat liver ribosome leads the way to similar progress for mammalian ribosomes.

RESULTS

Among the new details revealed by our 25 A structure of the 80S rat liver ribosome are channels within the subunits, a large 'flat ribosomal surface' (FRS) on the outer surface of the large subunit and structural extensions of the mammalian compared to the bacterial ribosome. The main large subunit channel in both the bacterial and the mammalian species starts at the peptidyl transferase centre, below the central protuberance, and ends in the FRS, at the lower back of the large subunit. Structurally, the channels of both species can be directly superimposed.

CONCLUSIONS

The mammalian structural extensions--none of which trespass the FRS--can be interpreted in terms of rRNA inserts and additional protein content over that of bacterial ribosomes. The main large subunit channel, which ends at the FRS, is the best candidate for the exit channel for proteins targeted for the endoplasmic reticulum.

Physiologically dependent appearance of a low density region that corresponds to the tunnel through the 50S part of the 70S ribosome

Ribosomes have different conformations in cells that are starved for a required amino acid (giving aminoacyl.tRNA starvation), or treated with kirromycin (blocking EF-Tu.GDP release), or are in exponential growth. A tunnel spans the 50S ribosome from a location facing the 70S ribosomal intersubunit space to the back side of the subunit in Escherichia coli cells. Here we have analyzed the internal low density region that corresponds to this tunnel in ribosomes in vivo. The data suggest that the tunnel is opened in connection with spatial separation of the subunits in ribosomes that have an empty A-site due to starvation for aminoacyl.tRNA. A region that corresponds to this tunnel can be found in the more compact structure of ribosomes in kirromycin-treated cells only after a substantial removal of low density material. This region is even less prominent in ribosomes in undefined working modes in growing bacteria. The data suggest that appearance of the tunnel through the 50S ribosomal subunit is working-mode dependent and it is not a characteristic feature of the major fraction of the ribosomal population in growing cells.

Visualization of a large conformation change of ribosomes in Escherichia coli cells starved for tryptophan or treated with kirromycin

Computer-aided electron tomography has been used to visualize ribosomes in Escherichia coli cells treated with kirromycin. This antibiotic stops bacterial growth by blocking the release of EF-Tu. GDP from the ribosome after GTP cleavage. Ribosomes in the kirromycin-treated cells are very compact, with the two subunits in close contact with each other. This closed structure is different from the open structure with spatially separated subunits that characterizes ribosomes in tryptophan-starved cells, giving deficiency for tryptophanyl.tRNA. A comparison of ribosomes in exponentially growing bacteria suggests that most ribosomes in an undefined working mode are in the closed conformation.

Solution scattering structural analysis of the 70 S Escherichia coli ribosome by contrast variation. I. Invariants and validation of electron microscopy models

Solutions of selectively deuterated 70 S Escherichia coli ribosomes and of free 30 S and 50 S subunits were studied by neutron scattering using contrast variation. The integrity of the partially deuterated particles was controlled by parallel X-ray measurements. Integral parameters of the entire ribosome, of its subunits and of the protein and rRNA moieties were evaluated. The data allow an experimental validation of the two most recent electron microscopy reconstructions of the 70 S ribosome presented by the groups of J. Frank (Albany) and of M. van Heel & R. Brimacombe (Berlin). For each reconstruction, integral parameters and theoretical scattering curves from the 70 S and its subunits were calculated and compared with the experimental data. Although neither of the two models yields a comprehensive agreement with the experimental data, Frank's model provides a better fit. For the 50 S subunit of van Heel & Brimacombe's model the fit with the experimental data improves significantly when the internal channels and tunnels are filled up. The poorer fit of the latter model is thus caused by its "sponge"-like structure which may partly be due to an enhancement of high frequency contributions in some of the steps of the three-dimensional image reconstruction. It seems therefore unlikely that the ribosome has a "sponge"-like structure with a pronounced network of channels.

The ribosome at higher resolution--the donut takes shape

Major new results in the 3D cryoimaging of ribosomes have advanced our understanding of ribosomal structure and function. For the first time, 3D difference maps have been used to image tRNA molecules in situ. With this new technology, the stage is set for detailed ligand-binding experiments that explore the binding states of elongation factors and tRNA, and that pinpoint locations of proteins and RNA on the surface of the ribosome.

Incorporation of dinitrophenyl protein L23 into totally reconstituted Escherichia coli 50 S ribosomal subunits and its localization at two sites by immune electron microscopy

Escherichia coli ribosomal protein L23 was derivatized with [3H]2, 4-dinitrofluorobenzene both at the N terminus and at internal lysines. Dinitrophenyl-L23 (DNP-L23) was taken up into 50 S subunits from a reconstitution mixture containing rRNA and total 50 S protein depleted in L23. Unmodified L23 competed with DNP-L23 for uptake, indicating that each protein form bound in an identical or similar position within the subunit. Modified L23, incorporated at a level of 0.7 or 0.4 DNP groups per 50 S, was localized by electron microscopy of subunits complexed with antibodies to dinitrophenol. Antibodies were seen at two major sites with almost equal frequency. One site is beside the central protuberance, in a region previously identified as the peptidyltransferase center. The second location is at the base of the subunit, in the area of the exit site from which the growing peptide leaves the ribosome. Models derived from image reconstruction show hollows or canyons in the subunit and a tunnel that links the transferase and exit sites. Our results indicate that L23 is at the subunit interior, with separate elements of the protein at the subunit surface at or near both ends of this tunnel.

Arrangement of tRNAs in pre- and posttranslocational ribosomes revealed by electron cryomicroscopy

The three-dimensional structure of the translating 70S E. coli ribosome is presented in its two main conformations: the pretranslocational and the posttranslocational states. Using electron cryomicroscopy and angular reconstitution, structures at 20 A resolution were obtained, which, when compared with our earlier reconstruction of "empty" ribosomes, showed densities corresponding to tRNA molecules--at the P and E sites for posttranslocational ribosomes and at the A and P sites for pretranslocational ribosomes. The P-site tRNA lies directly above the bridge connecting the two ribosomal subunits, with the A-site tRNA fitted snugly against it at an angle of approximately 50 degrees, toward the L7/L12 side of the ribosome. The E-site tRNA appears to lie between the side lobe of the 30S subunit and the L1 protuberance.

Structural model of the 50S subunit of E. coli ribosomes from solution scattering

The application of new methods of small-angle scattering data interpretation to a contrast variation study of the 50S ribosomal subunit of Escherichia coli in solution is described. The X-ray data from contrast variation with sucrose are analyzed in terms of the basic scattering curves from the volume inaccessible to sucrose and from the regions inside this volume occupied mainly by RNA and by proteins. From these curves models of the shape of the 50S and its RNA-rich core are evaluated and positioned so that their difference produces a scattering curve which is in good agreement with the scattering from the protein moiety. Based on this preliminary model, the X-ray and neutron contrast variation data of the 50S subunit in aqueous solutions are interpreted in the frame of the advanced two-phase model described by the shapes of the 50S subunit and its RNA-rich core taking into account density fluctuations inside the RNA and the protein moiety. The shape of the envelope of the 50S subunit and of the RNA-rich core are evaluated with a resolution of about 40 A. The shape of the envelope is in good agreement with the models of the 50S subunit obtained from electron microscopy on isolated particles. The shape of the RNA-rich core correlates well with the model of the entire particle determined by the image reconstruction from ordered sheets indicating that the latter model which is based on the subjective contouring of density maps is heavily biased towards the RNA.

Tetracyclines induce changes in accessibility of ribosomal proteins to proteases

Limited proteolysis was used to test the interaction of tetracyclines and some of their derivatives with ribosomes. Proteolysis of the free ribosomes was compared with that of the ligand-bound ribosomes. The interaction of different tetracyclines with ribosomes depends on their chemical structure and produces both a protective effect and an increased susceptibility to proteases of some ribosomal proteins in the 30S and 50S subparticles. Most of the proteins affected by tetracycline action are located on the head of the 30S and interface side of the 50S subunits. On the grounds of the obtained data one of the antibiotic-binding regions can be located near the ribosomal peptidyl transferase center. The effect of possible conformational changes induced by tetracyclines on the translation process is discussed.

A milestone in ribosomal crystallography: the construction of preliminary electron density maps at intermediate resolution

Preliminary electron density maps of the large and the small ribosomal particles from halophilic and thermophilic sources, phased by the isomorphous replacement method, have been constructed at intermediate resolution. These maps contain features comparable in size with what is expected for the corresponding particles, and their packing arrangements are in accord with the schemes obtained by ab-initio procedures as well as with the motifs observed in thin sections of the crystals by electron microscopy. To phase higher resolution data, procedures are being developed for derivatization by specific labeling of the ribosomal particles at selected locations with rather small and dense clusters. Potential binding sites are being inserted either by site directed mutagenesis or by chemical modifications to facilitate cluster binding on the surface of the halophilic large and the thermophilic small ribosomal particles, which yield the crystals diffracting to highest resolution (2.9 and 7.3 A (1 A = 0.1 nm), respectively). For this purpose, the surface of these ribosomal particles is being characterized and procedures are being developed for quantitative detachment of selected ribosomal proteins and for their incorporation into core particles. The genes of these proteins are being cloned, sequenced, mutated to introduce reactive side groups, mainly cysteines, and overexpressed. In parallel, two in situ small and stable complexes were isolated from the halophilic ribosome. Procedures for their crystal production in large quantities are currently being developed. Models, reconstructed at low resolution from crystalline arrays of ribosomes and their large subunits, are being used for initial low-resolution phasing of the X-ray amplitudes. The interpretation of these models stimulated the design and the crystallization of complexes mimicking defined functional states of a higher quality than those obtained for isolated ribosomes. These models also inspired modelling experiments according to results of functional studies, performed elsewhere, focusing on the progression of nascent proteins.

The 70S Escherichia coli ribosome at 23 A resolution: fitting the ribosomal RNA

BACKGROUND

The ribosome--essential for protein synthesis in all organisms--has been an evasive target for structural studies. The best available structures for the 70S Escherichia coli ribosome or its 30S and 50S subunits are based on electron microscopical tilt experiments and are limited in resolution to 28-55 A. The angular reconstitution approach, which exploits the random orientations of particles within a vitreous ice matrix, can be used in conjunction with cryo-electron microscopy to yield a higher-resolution structure.

RESULTS

Our 23 A resolution map of the 70S ribosome elucidates many structural details, such as an extensive system of channels within the 50S subunit and an intersubunit gap ideally shaped to accommodate two transfer RNA molecules. The resolution achieved is sufficient to allow the preliminary fitting of double-helical regions of an earlier three-dimensional ribosomal RNA model.

CONCLUSIONS

Although we are still a long way from attaining an atomic-resolution structure of the ribosome, cryo-electron microscopy, in combination with angular reconstitution, is likely to yield three-dimensional maps with gradually increasing resolution. As exemplified by our current 23 A reconstruction, these maps will lead to progressive refinement of models of the ribosomal RNA.

Structures of small subunit ribosomal RNAs in situ from Escherichia coli and Thermomyces lanuginosus

Small ribosomal subunits from the prokaryote Escherichia coli and the eukaryote Thermomyces lanuginosus were imaged electron spectroscopically, and single particle analysis used to yield three-dimensional reconstructions of the net phosphorus distribution representing the nucleic acid (RNA) backbone. This direct approach showed both ribosomal RNAs to have a three domain structure and other characteristic morphological features. The eukaryotic small ribosomal subunit had a prominent bill present in the head domain, while the prokaryotic subunit had a small vestigial bill. Both ribosomal subunits contained a thick 'collar' central domain which correlates to the site of the evolutionarily conserved ribosomal RNA core, and the location of the majority of ribosomal RNA bases that have been implicated in translation. The reconstruction of the prokaryotic subunit had a prominent protrusion extending from the collar, forming a channel approximately 1.5 nm wide and potentially representing a 'bridge' to the large subunit in the intact monosome. The basal domain of the prokaryotic ribosomal subunit was protein free. In this region of the eukaryotic subunit, there were two basal lobes composed of ribosomal RNA, consistent with previous hypotheses that this is a site for the 'non-conserved core' ribosomal RNA.

Crystallography of ribosomes: attempts at decorating the ribosomal surface

Crystals of various ribosomal particles, diffracting best to 2.9 A resolution were grown. Crystallographic data were collected from shock frozen crystals with intense synchrotron radiation at cryo temperature. For obtaining phase information, monofunctional reagents were prepared from an undecagold and a tetrairidium cluster, by attaching to them chemically reactive handles, specific for sulfhydryl moieties. Heavy-atom derivatives were prepared by a specific and quantitative binding of the undecagold cluster to an exposed sulfhydryl prior to the crystallization. To create potential binding sites on the halophilic and thermophilic ribosomal particles, which yield our best and most interesting crystals, exposed reactive moieties were inserted, using genetic and chemical procedures. In order to choose the appropriate locations for these insertions, the surfaces of the ribosomal particles were mapped by direct chemical determination of exposed amino and sulfhydryl groups.

Starvation in vivo for aminoacyl-tRNA increases the spatial separation between the two ribosomal subunits

Structures in situ of individual ribosomes in E. coli have been determined by computer-aided electron microscope tomography using a tilt series of positively stained embedded cellular sections. Amino acid starvation of a bacterial culture, causing a deficiency for aminoacyl-tRNA, induces a spatial separation between the ribosomal subunits compared with ribosomes in exponentially growing cells. Eight ribosomes from each growth condition were aligned to each other, and the two average structures were determined. Comparison of these suggests that the distance between the two subunits increases by approximately 3 nm upon starvation for aminoacyl-tRNA during protein synthesis. Ribosomes in most other states of the translational elongation cycle in exponentially growing cells show a more compact structure than previously realized.

Electron crystallography of macromolecules

Numerous technical advances in electron crystallography have facilitated determination of the three-dimensional structures of macromolecules, especially those that form two-dimensional or helical periodic arrays. Several recent studies have demonstrated the utility of this technique for visualizing secondary structure such as alpha-helices and beta-sheets of membrane proteins and, in one case, the entire polypeptide backbone. Electron crystallography, therefore, has great potential as a tool for studying structural problems that are relevant to both molecular biology and biotechnology.