p53 latency--out of the blind alley

APE1/Ref-1 enhances DNA binding activity of mutant p53 in a redox-dependent manner

Apurinic/apyrimidinic endonuclease 1/redox factor-1 (APE1/Ref-1) is a dual function protein; in addition to its DNA repair activity, it can stimulate DNA binding activity of numerous transcription factors as a reduction-oxidation (redox) factor. APE1/Ref-1 has been found to be a potent activator of wild-type p53 (wtp53) DNA binding in vitro and in vivo. Although p53 is mutated in most types of human cancer including hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC), little is known about whether APE1/Ref-1 can regulate mutant p53 (mutp53). Herein, we reported the increased APE1/Ref-1 protein and accumulation of mutp53 in HCC by immunohistochemistry. Of note, it was observed that APE1/Ref-1 high-expression and mutp53 expression were associated with carcinogenesis and progression of HCC. To determine whether APE1/Ref-1 regulates DNA binding of mutp53, we performed electromobility shift assays (EMSAs) and quantitative chromatin immunoprecipitation (ChIP) assays in HCC cell lines. In contrast to sequence-specific and DNA structure-dependent binding of wtp53, reduced mutp53 efficiently bound to nonlinear DNA, but not to linear DNA. Notably, overexpression of APE1/Ref-1 resulted in increased DNA binding activity of mutp53, while downregulation of APE1/Ref-1 caused a marked decrease of mutp53 DNA binding. In addition, APE1/Ref-1 could not potentiate the accumulation of p21 mRNA and protein in mutp53 cells. These data indicate that APE1/Ref-1 can stimulate mutp53 DNA binding in a redox-dependent manner.

Structural biology of the p53 tumour suppressor

The p53 tumour suppressor protein has presented a challenge for structural biology for more than two decades. The complete p53 molecule has eluded numerous attempts to determine its structure, presumably owing to the intrinsic conformational flexibility that is essential to the protein's function. Recent data obtained by X-ray crystallography, NMR spectroscopy and electron microscopy provide new insight into the quaternary architecture of the whole molecule and new strategies for examining how these structures correlate with the cell and molecular biology of the 'Guardian of the Genome'.

Analysis of p53 dependent damage response in sperm-irradiated mouse embryos

Ionizing radiation activates a series of DNA damage response, cell cycle checkpoints to arrest cells at G1/S, S and G2/M, DNA repair, and apoptosis. The DNA damage response is thought to be the major determinant of cellular radiosensitivity and thought to operate in all higher eukaryotic cells. However, the radiosensitivity is known to differ considerably during ontogeny of mammals and early embryos of mouse for example are much more sensitive to radiation than adults. We have focused on the radiation-induced damage response during pre-implantation stage of mouse embryo. Our study demonstrates a hierarchy of damage responses to assure the genomic integrity in early embryonic development. In the sperm-irradiated zygotes, p53 dependent S-phase checkpoint functions to suppress erroneous replication of damaged DNA. The transcription-dependent function is not required and the DNA-binging domain of the protein is essential for this p53 dependent S-phase checkpoint. p21 mediated cleavage arrest comes next during early embryogenesis to prevent delayed chromosome damage at morula/ blastocyst stages. Apoptosis operates even later only in the cells of ICM at the blastocyst stage to eliminate deleterious cells. Thus, early development of sperm-irradiated embryos is protected at least by three mechanisms regulated by p53 and by p21.

RNA−p53 Interactions in Vitro

The tumor suppressor protein p53 is mutated in over half of human cancers. Despite 25 years of study, the complex regulation of this protein remains unclear. After serendipitously detecting RNA binding by p53 in the yeast three-hybrid system (Y3H), we are exploring the specificity and function of this interaction. Electrophoretic mobility shift assays show that full-length p53 binds equally to RNAs that are strongly distinguished in the Y3H. RNA binding blocks sequence-specific DNA binding by p53. The C-terminus of p53 is necessary and sufficient for strong RNA interaction in vitro. Mouse and human C-terminal p53 peptides have different affinities for RNA, and an acetylated human p53 C-terminal peptide does not bind RNA. Circular dichroism spectroscopy of p53 peptides shows that RNA binding does not induce a structural change in the p53 C-terminal peptide, and C-terminal peptides do not detectably affect the structure of RNA. These results demonstrate that p53 binds RNA with little sequence specificity, RNA binding has the potential to regulate DNA binding, and RNA-p53 interactions can be regulated by acetylation of the p53 C-terminus.

The structure of p53 tumour suppressor protein reveals the basis for its functional plasticity

p53 major tumour suppressor protein has presented a challenge for structural biology for two decades. The intact and complete p53 molecule has eluded previous attempts to obtain its structure, largely due to the intrinsic flexibility of the protein. Using ATP-stabilised p53, we have employed cryoelectron microscopy and single particle analysis to solve the first three-dimensional structure of the full-length p53 tetramer (resolution 13.7 A). The p53 molecule is a D2 tetramer, resembling a hollow skewed cube with node-like vertices of two sizes. Four larger nodes accommodate central core domains, as was demonstrated by fitting of its X-ray structure. The p53 monomers are connected via their juxtaposed N- and C-termini within smaller N/C nodes to form dimers. The dimers form tetramers through the contacts between core nodes and N/C nodes. This structure revolutionises existing concepts of p53's molecular organisation and resolves conflicting data relating to its biochemical properties. This architecture of p53 in toto suggests novel mechanisms for structural plasticity, which enables the protein to bind variably spaced DNA target sequences, essential for p53 transactivation and tumour suppressor functions.

DNA modification with cisplatin affects sequence-specific DNA binding of p53 and p73 proteins in a target site-dependent manner

Proteins p53 and p73 act as transcription factors in cell cycle control, regulation of cell development and/or in apoptotic pathways. Both proteins bind to response elements (p53 DNA-binding sites), typically consisting of two copies of a motif RRRCWWGYYY. It has been demonstrated previously that DNA modification with the antitumor drug cisplatin inhibits p53 binding to a synthetic p53 DNA-binding site. Here we demonstrate that the effects of global DNA modification with cisplatin on binding of the p53 or p73 proteins to various p53 DNA-binding sites differed significantly, depending on the nucleotide sequence of the given target site. The relative sensitivities of protein-DNA binding to cisplatin DNA treatment correlated with the occurrence of sequence motifs forming stable bifunctional adducts with the drug (namely, GG and AG doublets) within the target sites. Binding of both proteins to mutated p53 DNA-binding sites from which these motifs had been eliminated was only negligibly affected by cisplatin treatment, suggesting that formation of the cisplatin adducts within the target sites was primarily responsible for inhibition of the p53 or p73 sequence-specific DNA binding. Distinct effects of cisplatin DNA modification on the recognition of different response elements by the p53 family proteins may have impacts on regulation pathways in cisplatin-treated cells.

Recognition of RNA by the p53 tumor suppressor protein in the yeast three-hybrid system

The p53 tumor suppressor protein is a homotetrameric transcription factor whose gene is mutated in nearly half of all human cancers. In an unrelated screen of RNA/protein interactions using the yeast three-hybrid system, we inadvertently detected p53 interactions with several different RNAs. A literature review revealed previous reports of both sequence-specific and -non-specific interactions between p53 and RNA. Using yeast three-hybrid selections to identify preferred RNA partners for p53, we failed to identify primary RNA sequences or obvious secondary structures required for p53 binding. The cationic p53 C-terminus was shown to be required for RNA binding in yeast. We show that while p53 strongly discriminates between certain RNAs in the yeast three-hybrid assay, the same RNAs are bound equally by p53 in vitro. We further show that the p53 RNA-binding preferences in yeast are mirrored almost exactly by a recombinant tetrameric form of the HIV-1 nucleocapsid (NC) protein thought to be a sequence-nonspecific RNA-binding protein. However, the possibility of specific RNA binding by p53 could not be ruled out because p53 and HIV-1 NC displayed certain differences in RNA-binding preference. We conclude that (1) p53 binds RNA in vivo, (2) RNA binding by p53 is largely sequence-nonspecific in the yeast nucleus, (3) some structure-specific RNA binding by p53 cannot be ruled out, and (4) caution is required when interpreting results of RNA screens in the yeast three-hybrid system because sequence-dependent differences in RNA folding and display can masquerade as sequence-dependent differences in protein recognition.

Recognition of cisplatin-damaged DNA by p53 protein: Critical role of the p53 C-terminal domain

It was shown previously that the p53 protein can recognize DNA modified with antitumor agent cisplatin (cisPt-DNA). Here, we studied p53 binding to the cisPt-DNA using p53 deletion mutants and via modulation of the p53-DNA binding by changes of the protein redox state. Isolated p53 C-terminal domain (CTD) bound to the cisPt-DNA with a significantly higher affinity than to the unmodified DNA. On the other hand, p53 constructs involving the core domain but lacking the C-terminal DNA binding site (CTDBS) exhibited only small binding preference for the cisPt-DNA. Oxidation of cysteine residues within the CD of posttranslationally unmodified full length p53 did not affect its ability to recognize cisPt-DNA. Blocking of the p53 CTDBS by a monoclonal antibody Bp53-10.1 resulted in abolishment of the isolated CTD binding to the cisPt-DNA. Our results demonstrate a crucial role of the basic region of the p53 CTD (aa 363-382) in the cisPt-DNA recognition.

Transcriptional activities of mutant p53: when mutations are more than a loss

The dominant oncogenic properties of mutant p53 have been recognized as a phenomenon associated with tumor progression a long time ago, even before it was realized that the major function of wild type p53 is that of a tumor suppressor. Recent advances in this fascinating area in tumor cell biology reveal that the community of mutant p53 proteins is comprised of proteins that are extremely diverse both structurally and functionally, and elicit a multitude of cellular responses that not only are entirely distinct from those mediated by wild type p53, but also vary among different mutant p53 proteins. Aberrant regulation of transcription is one of the mechanisms underlying the ability of some mutant p53 proteins to act as oncogenic factors. Systematic analyses of the transcriptional activities of mutant p53 suggest that not the loss of transcriptional activity as such, but alterations of target DNA selectivity may be the driving force of mutant p53 specific transcription underlying the growth-promoting effects of mutant p53. This article focuses on mechanistic aspects of mutp53 "gain-of-function" with the emphasis on possible mechanisms underlying transcriptional activation by mutp53.

Redox factor 1 (Ref-1) enhances specific DNA binding of p53 by promoting p53 tetramerization

Sequence-specific DNA binding is a major activity of the tumor suppressor p53 and a prerequisite for the transactivating potential of the protein. p53 interaction with target DNA is tightly regulated by various mechanisms, including binding of different components of the transcription machinery, post-translational modifications, and interactions with other factors that modulate p53 transactivation in a cell context- and promoter-specific manner. The bi-functional redox factor 1 (Ref-1/APE1) has been identified as one of the factors, which can stimulate p53 DNA binding by redox-dependent as well as redox-independent mechanisms. Whereas stimulation of p53 DNA binding by the redox activities of Ref-1 is understood quite well, little is known about mechanisms that underlie the redox-independent effects of Ref-1. We report in this study a previously unknown activity of Ref-1 as a factor promoting tetramerization of p53. We demonstrate that Ref-1 promotes association of dimers into tetramers, and de-stacking of higher oligomeric forms into the tetrameric form in vitro, thereby enhancing p53 binding to target DNA.

Mutant p53 proteins bind DNA in a DNA structure-selective mode

Despite the loss of sequence-specific DNA binding, mutant p53 (mutp53) proteins can induce or repress transcription of mutp53-specific target genes. To date, the molecular basis for transcriptional modulation by mutp53 is not understood, but increasing evidence points to the possibility that specific interactions of mutp53 with DNA play an important role. So far, the lack of a common denominator for mutp53 DNA binding, i.e. the existence of common sequence elements, has hampered further characterization of mutp53 DNA binding. Emanating from our previous discovery that DNA structure is an important determinant of wild-type p53 (wtp53) DNA binding, we analyzed the binding of various mutp53 proteins to oligonucleotides mimicking non-B DNA structures. Using various DNA-binding assays we show that mutp53 proteins bind selectively and with high affinity to non-B DNA. In contrast to sequence-specific and DNA structure-dependent binding of wtp53, mutp53 DNA binding to non-B DNA is solely dependent on the stereo-specific configuration of the DNA, and not on DNA sequence. We propose that DNA structure-selective binding of mutp53 proteins is the basis for the well-documented interaction of mutp53 with MAR elements and for transcriptional activities mediates by mutp53.

Transcription-independent suppression of DNA synthesis by p53 in sperm-irradiated mouse zygotes

Cell cycle arrest in response to DNA damage is important for the maintenance of genomic integrity in higher eukaryotes. We have previously reported the novel p53-dependent S-phase checkpoint operating in mouse zygotes fertilized with irradiated sperm. In the present study, we analysed the detail of the p53 function required for this S-phase checkpoint in mouse zygotes. The results indicate that ATM kinase is likely to be indispensable for the p53-dependent S-phase checkpoint since the suppression was abrogated by inhibitors such as caffeine and wortmannin. However, ATM phosphorylation site mutant proteins were still capable of suppressing DNA synthesis when microinjected into sperm-irradiated zygotes lacking the functional p53, suggesting that the target of the phosphorylation is not p53. In addition, the suppression was not affected by alpha-amanitin, and p53 protein mutated at the transcriptional activation domain was also functional in the suppression of DNA synthesis. However, p53 proteins mutated at the DNA-binding domain were devoid of the suppressing activity. Taken together, the transcription-independent function of p53 associated with the DNA-binding domain is involved in the S-phase checkpoint in collaboration with yet another unidentified target protein(s).

Regulation of DNA binding of p53 by its C-terminal domain

The tumor suppressor p53 is a tetrameric multi-domain transcription factor. Its C-terminal domain is thought to regulate the binding of its core domain to specific recognition sequences in promoters. The mechanism of regulation by the C-terminal domain and the role of its post-translational modification are controversial. We have examined the binding of DNA in solution to a series of unmodified p53 constructs that lack various domains. The specific DNA sequences bind tightly to the core domain, irrespective of whether or not the C-terminal domain is part of the construct. Unmodified p53 is accordingly an active DNA binding protein. Non-specific DNA sequences do not inhibit directly the binding of the specific sequences to the core but bind to the C terminus and inhibit p53 via that binding mode. Using NMR, we identified the residues of the C terminus that interact with the non-specific DNA. They include residues that are known to be modified post-translationally. Our data provide direct support for the regulatory role of the C terminus in the activity of p53 and show that p53 containing the unmodified C terminus actively binds to short double-stranded DNA.

Investigations of the supercoil-selective DNA binding of wild type p53 suggest a novel mechanism for controlling p53 function

The tumor suppressor protein, p53, selectively binds to supercoiled (sc) DNA lacking the specific p53 consensus binding sequence (p53CON). Using p53 deletion mutants, we have previously shown that the p53 C-terminal DNA-binding site (CTDBS) is critical for this binding. Here we studied supercoil-selective binding of bacterially expressed full-length p53 using modulation of activity of the p53 DNA-binding domains by oxidation of cysteine residues (to preclude binding within the p53 core domain) and/or by antibodies mapping to epitopes at the protein C-terminus (to block binding within the CTDBS). In the absence of antibody, reduced p53 preferentially bound scDNA lacking p53CON in the presence of 3 kb linear plasmid DNAs or 20 mer oligonucleotides, both containing and lacking the p53CON. Blocking the CTDBS with antibody caused reduced p53 to bind equally to sc and linear or relaxed circular DNA lacking p53CON, but with a high preference for the p53CON. The same immune complex of oxidized p53 failed to bind DNA, while oxidized p53 in the absence of antibody restored selective scDNA binding. Antibodies mapping outside the CTDBS did not prevent p53 supercoil-selective (SCS) binding. These data indicate that the CTDBS is primarily responsible for p53 SCS binding. In the absence of the SCS binding, p53 binds sc or linear (relaxed) DNA via the p53 core domain and exhibits strong sequence-specific binding. Our results support a hypothesis that alterations to DNA topology may be a component of the complex cellular regulatory mechanisms that control the switch between latent and active p53 following cellular stress.

High-affinity binding of tumor-suppressor protein p53 and HMGB1 to hemicatenated DNA loops

We have recently observed that chromatin architectural protein HMGB1 (previously reported to be involved in numerous biological processes such as DNA replication, recombination, repair, tumor growth, and metastasis) could bind with extremely high affinity (K(d) < 1 pM) to a novel DNA structure that forms a DNA loop maintained at its base by a hemicatenane (hcDNA). The loop of hcDNA contains a track of repetitive sequences derived from CA-microsatellites. Here, we report using a gel-retardation assay that tumor-suppressor protein p53 can also bind to hcDNA. p53 is a crucial molecule protecting cells from malignant transformation by regulating cell-cycle progression, apoptosis, and DNA repair by activation or repression of transcription of its target genes by binding to specific p53 DNA-binding sites and/or certain types of DNA lesions or alternative DNA structures. The affinity of p53 for hcDNA (containing sequences with no resemblance to the p53 DNA consensus sequence) is >40-fold higher (K(d) approximately 0.5 nM) than that for its natural specific binding sites within its target genes (Mdm2 promoter). Binding of p53 to hcDNA remains detectable in the presence of up to approximately 4 orders of magnitude of mass excess of competitor linear DNA, suggesting a high specificity of the interaction. p53 displays a higher affinity for hcDNA than for DNA minicircles (lacking functional p53-specific binding sequence) with a size similar to that of the loop within the hcDNA, indicating that the extreme affinity of p53 for hcDNA is likely due to the binding of the protein to the hemicatenane. Although binding of p53 to hcDNA occurs in the absence of the nonspecific DNA-binding extreme carboxy-terminal regulatory domain (30-C, residues 363-393), the isolated 30-C domain (but not the sequence-specific p53 "core domain", residues 94-312) can also bind hcDNA. Only the full-length p53 can form stable ternary complexes with hcDNA and HMGB1. The possible biological relevance of p53 and HMGB1 binding to hemicatenanes is discussed.

Binding of RNA to p53 regulates its oligomerization and DNA-binding activity

The C-terminus of p53 is responsible for maintaining the latent, non-DNA-binding form of p53. However, the mechanism by which the C-terminus regulates DNA binding is not yet fully understood. We show here that p53 interacts with RNA via its C-terminal domain and that disruption of this interaction, by RNase A treatment, truncation or phosphorylation of the C-terminus, restores DNA-binding activity. Furthermore, the oligomerization of p53 is significantly enhanced by disrupting the interaction between p53 and RNA. These findings suggest that binding of RNA to p53 is involved in the mechanism of p53 latency.

YY1 binding to a subset of p53 DNA-target sites regulates p53-dependent transcription

The tumor suppressor protein p53 regulates gene transcription through binding to specific DNA-target sites. We here demonstrate that a subset of these sites is targeted by another DNA-binding factor. Binding specificity, reactivity with specific antibodies, and experiments with purified protein identified the factor as the multifunctional transcription regulator YY1. The YY1 core binding sequence ACAT is present in the center of p53-half-binding sites in the p21 and GADD45 genes regulating growth arrest and DNA repair, respectively, but is absent in those of the Bax gene critical for apoptosis. In transfection experiments YY1 inhibits p53-activated transcription from the p53-binding site that contains the ACAT sequence. YY1 and p53 are colocalized around the nucleoli and in discrete nuclear domains in PC12 cells undergoing apoptosis. YY1 might attenuate p53-dependent transcription from a subset of p53-target genes and this may be relevant for directing cells either to growth arrest or apoptosis upon p53 activation.

Denaturation of dsDNA by p53: fluorescence correlation spectroscopy study

p53 activates transcription through interaction with specific DNA sequences in gene promoters. It also regulates DNA replication, recombination, and repair apparently through interactions with DNA intermediates of these reactions. Biochemical activities relevant for these functions of p53 include binding to the ends and internal segments of single-stranded DNA molecules, catalysis of DNA renaturation, and strand exchange. We report a novel activity of p53, its ability to denature double-stranded DNA molecules aggregated by basic peptides. Stable complexes of coiled single-stranded DNA molecules with basic peptides are formed in this reaction. Thus, complementary to the ability to catalyze DNA renaturation, p53 denatures double-stranded DNA when the latter reaction is thermodynamically favorable. This p53 activity, along with its ability to interact physically with DNA helicases, may be relevant for resolving double-stranded DNA intermediates and inhibition of DNA recombination, which is critical for guarding of the genome.

In vitro folding and characterization of the p53 DNA binding domain

The transcription factor p53 acts as major tumor suppressor and is inactivated by mutation in more than 50% of all human tumors. We have established an efficient procedure for the in vitro folding and purification of the p53 DNA binding domain (p53DBD) using a modified factorial matrix approach that supplies large amounts of homogeneous (isotope-labeled) p53DBD for application in biochemical, crystallographic and NMR spectroscopic studies. We further show with biophysical methods that in vitro folded p53DBD is fully functional and that its conformation is identical to that obtained from the soluble fraction.

Drug discovery and p53

In the past two decades, the identification of commonly mutated oncogenes and tumour suppressor genes has driven an unprecedented growth in our understanding of the genetic basis of human cancer. Although oncogenes can clearly serve as classically defined drug targets whose inactivation by small molecules could place a brake on cancer cell proliferation, the restoration of mutated tumour suppressor gene activity by small molecules might appear on the surface to be unrealistic. However, there is a growing realization that many eukaryotic regulatory proteins are partially unfolded and such intrinsically disordered proteins acquire a folded structure after binding to their biological target. Molecular characterization of the p53 protein has shown that its conformational flexibility and intrinsic thermodynamic instability provide a foundation from which its conformation can be quickly post-translationally modified.