XX germ cells: the difference between an ovary and a testis

Sex Maintenance in Mammals

The crucial event in mammalian sexual differentiation occurs at the embryonic stage of sex determination, when the bipotential gonads differentiate as either testes or ovaries, according to the sex chromosome constitution of the embryo, XY or XX, respectively. Once differentiated, testes produce sexual hormones that induce the subsequent differentiation of the male reproductive tract. On the other hand, the lack of masculinizing hormones in XX embryos permits the formation of the female reproductive tract. It was long assumed that once the gonad is differentiated, this developmental decision is irreversible. However, several findings in the last decade have shown that this is not the case and that a continuous sex maintenance is needed. Deletion of Foxl2 in the adult ovary lead to ovary-to-testis transdifferentiation and deletion of either Dmrt1 or Sox9/Sox8 in the adult testis induces the opposite process. In both cases, mutant gonads were genetically reprogrammed, showing that both the male program in ovaries and the female program in testes must be actively repressed throughout the individual's life. In addition to these transcription factors, other genes and molecular pathways have also been shown to be involved in this antagonism. The aim of this review is to provide an overview of the genetic basis of sex maintenance once the gonad is already differentiated.

Systemic compensatory response to neonatal estradiol exposure does not prevent depletion of the oocyte pool in the rat

The formation of ovarian follicles is a finely tuned process that takes place within a narrow time-window in rodents. Multiple factors and pathways have been proposed to contribute to the mechanisms triggering this process but the role of endocrine factors, especially estrogens, remains elusive. It is currently hypothesized that removal from the maternal hormonal environment permits follicle formation at birth. However, experimentally-induced maintenance of high 17β-estradiol (E2) levels leads to subtle, distinct, immediate effects on follicle formation and oocyte survival depending on the species and dose. In this study, we examined the immediate effects of neonatal E2 exposure from post-natal day (PND) 0 to PND2 on the whole organism and on ovarian follicle formation in rats. Measurements of plasma E2, estrone and their sulfate conjugates after E2 exposure showed that neonatal female rats rapidly acquire the capability to metabolize and clear excessive E2 levels. Concomitant modifications to the mRNA content of genes encoding selected E2 metabolism enzymes in the liver and the ovary in response to E2 exposure indicate that E2 may modify the neonatal maturation of these organs. In the liver, E2 treatment was associated with lower acquisition of the capability to metabolize E2. In the ovary, E2 depleted the oocyte pool in a dose dependent manner by PND3. In 10 µg/day E2-treated ovaries, apoptotic oocytes were observed in newly formed follicles in addition to areas of ovarian cord remodeling. At PND6, follicles without any visible oocyte were present and multi-oocyte follicles were not observed. Our study reveals a major species-difference. Indeed, neonatal exposure to E2 depletes the oocyte pool in the rat ovary, whereas in the mouse it is well known to increase oocyte survival.

Germ cells are not required to establish the female pathway in mouse fetal gonads

The fetal gonad is composed of a mixture of somatic cell lineages and germ cells. The fate of the gonad, male or female, is determined by a population of somatic cells that differentiate into Sertoli or granulosa cells and direct testis or ovary development. It is well established that germ cells are not required for the establishment or maintenance of Sertoli cells or testis cords in the male gonad. However, in the agametic ovary, follicles do not form suggesting that germ cells may influence granulosa cell development. Prior investigations of ovaries in which pre-meiotic germ cells were ablated during fetal life reported no histological changes during stages prior to birth. However, whether granulosa cells underwent normal molecular differentiation was not investigated. In cases where germ cell loss occurred secondary to other mutations, transdifferentiation of granulosa cells towards a Sertoli cell fate was observed, raising questions about whether germ cells play an active role in establishing or maintaining the fate of granulosa cells. We developed a group of molecular markers associated with ovarian development, and show here that the loss of pre-meiotic germ cells does not disrupt the somatic ovarian differentiation program during fetal life, or cause transdifferentiation as defined by expression of Sertoli markers. Since we do not find defects in the ovarian somatic program, the subsequent failure to form follicles at perinatal stages is likely attributable to the absence of germ cells rather than to defects in the somatic cells.

Instructing an embryonic stem cell-derived oocyte fate: lessons from endogenous oogenesis

Female reproductive potential is limited in the majority of species due to oocyte depletion. Because functional human oocytes are restricted in number and accessibility, a robust system to differentiate oocytes from stem cells would enable a thorough investigation of the genetic, epigenetic, and environmental factors affecting human oocyte development. Also, the differentiation of functional oocytes from stem cells may permit the success of human somatic cell nuclear transfer for reprogramming studies and for the production of patient-specific embryonic stem cells (ESCs). Thus, ESC-derived oocytes could ultimately help to restore fertility in women. Here, we review endogenous and ESC-derived oocyte development, and we discuss the potential and challenges for differentiating functional oocytes from ESCs.

Society for Reproductive Biology Founders' Lecture 2006 - life in the pouch: womb with a view

Marsupials give birth to an undeveloped altricial young after a relatively short gestation period, but have a long and sophisticated lactation with the young usually developing in a pouch. Their viviparous mode of reproduction trades placentation for lactation, exchanging the umbilical cord for the teat. The special adaptations that marsupials have developed provide us with unique insights into the evolution of all mammalian reproduction. Marsupials hold many mammalian reproductive 'records', for example they have the shortest known gestation but the longest embryonic diapause, the smallest neonate but the longest sperm. They have contributed to our knowledge of many mammalian reproductive events including embryonic diapause and development, birth behaviour, sex determination, sexual differentiation, lactation and seasonal breeding. Because marsupials have been genetically isolated from eutherian mammals for over 125 million years, sequencing of the genome of two marsupial species has made comparative genomic biology an exciting and important new area of investigation. This review will show how the study of marsupials has widened our understanding of mammalian reproduction and development, highlighting some mechanisms that are so fundamental that they are shared by all today's marsupial and eutherian mammals.

Consequences of Fetal Irradiation on Follicle Histogenesis and Early Follicle Development in Rat Ovaries1

Follicle histogenesis, in which follicles arise from fragmenting ovigerous cords, is a poorly understood mechanism that is strictly dependent upon the presence of germ cells. Our previous studies have shown that severely germ cell-depleted rat ovaries after fetal gamma-irradiation display modifications of follicular endowment and dynamics during the immature period. The primordial follicle stock was absent and the follicles with primary appearance remained quiescent longer than in control ovaries during the neonatal period. The aim of the present work was to analyze the initial steps of follicle histogenesis, and to investigate the etiology of the alterations observed in the development of irradiated ovaries. Just after birth, we observed, in addition to sterile ovigerous cords, the emergence of the first follicles which exhibited several abnormal features as compared to those of control ovaries. Most of the follicles appeared as primary follicles, as they were composed of a layer of cuboidal-shaped granulosa cells surrounding an enlarged oocyte. Interestingly, the granulosa cells of these primary-like follicles did not proliferate and did not express the genes for anti-Müllerian hormone (Amh) or bone morphogenetic protein receptor type II (Bmpr2), both of which are normally expressed from the primary stage onwards. In contrast, the oocytes strongly expressed the gene for growth and differentiation factor 9 (Gdf9), which is normally upregulated from the primary follicle stage onwards, which suggests an uncoupling of granulosa cell development from oocyte development. In addition, irradiated ovaries displayed a higher frequency of follicles that contained 2 or 3 oocytes, which are also referred to as multi-oocyte follicles (MOFs). Examination at the time of follicle histogenesis indicated that MOFs arise from incomplete ovigerous cord breakdown. Taken together, the results of this study indicate that severe perturbations of follicular histogenesis take place following irradiation and massive germ cell depletion during fetal life. In addition to the classically described sterile cords, we have pointed out the differentiation of MOFs and primary-like quiescent follicles, which finally evolve into growing follicles and participate in ovarian function. We propose that these phenotypes are closely correlated to the proportion of granulosa cells to oocytes at the time of neonatal follicle histogenesis.

Contribution of Germ Cells to the Differentiation and Maturation of the Ovary: Insights from Models of Germ Cell Depletion

In mammals, the role played by germ cells in ovarian differentiation and folliculogenesis has been the focus of an increasing number of studies over the last decades. From these studies, it has emerged that bidirectional communication between germ cells and surrounding companion cells is required as soon as the initial assembly of follicles. Models of germ cell depletion that arise from both spontaneous and experimentally induced mutations as well as irradiation or chemical treatments have been helpful in deciphering the role played by germ cells from the onset of ovarian differentiation onward. This review reports current knowledge and proposes novel hypotheses that can be formulated from these models about the contribution of germ cells to ovarian differentiation and folliculogenesis. In particular, it promotes the idea that the influence of germ cells on companion somatic cells varies within both ovarian differentiation and folliculogenesis.

Determination and stability of sex

How is the embryonic bipotential gonad regulated to produce either an ovary or a testis? In males, transient early activation of the Y chromosome Sry gene makes both germ cells and soma male. However, in females, available evidence suggests that the process of ovary sex determination may take place independently in the germline and somatic lineages. In addition, in contrast to testis, in ovary somatic cells, female-to-male gonadal sex reversal can occur at times throughout ovary development and maturation. We suggest that a single gene pathway, likely hinging on the Foxl2 transcription factor, both initiates and maintains sex differentiation in somatic cells of the mammalian ovary.

Sexual development of a model marsupial male

In eutherian mammals sexual differentiation occurs during fetal development, making experimental manipulation difficult, unlike in marsupials. We are investigating the roles of several key genes and hormones whose exact role in gonadal differentiation is still unclear using the tammar wallaby (Macropus eugenii) as a model. As in humans, unlike in mice, the testis-determining gene SRY is expressed in male tammar fetuses in many tissues over an extended period. Not all sexual differentiation depends on testicular hormones. Scrotum and mammary glands are under the control of X-linked gene(s). Our demonstration of DMRT1 expression in tammar and mouse ovaries suggests it has a wider role than previously thought. The Y-borne copy of ATRX (ATRY) is coexpressed with DMRT1 in developing testis. Gonadal sex reversal can be induced in males by neonatal oestrogen treatment and in females by grafting developing ovaries to males or culturing them in minimal medium. Treatments of developing young with various androgens, and studies of steroid metabolism have shown that the steroid androstenediol may have a previously unrecognised role in virilisation. Our studies using a marsupial model have given some surprising insights into the evolution and control of sexual development in all mammals.

Follicular cells acquire sertoli cell characteristics after oocyte loss

Although it has been suggested that in mammals the loss of female germ cells may induce the masculinization of the ovarian compartment, there has been as yet no conclusive demonstration. To directly address that question, the present study has been designed to determine the fate of follicular cells after oocyte loss. Using gamma-irradiation to selectively deplete oocytes in nongrowing follicles in female rats, we show that follicular cells in oocyte-depleted follicles survive, proliferate, and subsequently acquire morphological characteristics of Sertoli cells: elongated cytoplasm, basal location of the nucleus, and specific Sertoli cell junctions, the ectoplasmic specializations. These Sertoli-like cells express, however, the female-specific marker FOXL2 (Forkhead L2) but not the male sex-specific marker SOX-9 (Sry-type high-mobility-group box transcription factor-9) underlying the maintenance of molecular characteristics of granulosa cells. Before transdifferentiating into Sertoli-like cells, follicular cells of oocyte-depleted follicles initiate the expression of anti-Mullerian hormone and inhibin alpha-subunit that are typically synthesized by granulosa cells from the onset of follicular growth. Experimental modifications of the endocrine balance of the irradiated females show that there is a close relationship between plasma FSH levels and the occurrence of Sertoli-like cells. In addition to providing experimental evidence for the crucial role of the oocyte in granulosa cell phenotype maintenance, these results emphasize that the transdifferentiation of granulosa cells into Sertoli cells occurs in a multistep fashion, requiring the maturation of granulosa cells and depending on the endocrine milieu.

Estrogen regulates development of the somatic cell phenotype in the eutherian ovary

Steroids play a critical role in gonadal differentiation in birds, reptiles, and amphibia whereas gonadal differentiation in mammals is thought to be determined by genetic mechanisms. The gonads of female mice incapable of synthesizing estrogens due to disruption of the aromatase gene (ArKO) provide a unique model to test the role of estrogen in regulating the gonadal phenotype. We have shown that in the absence of estrogen, genetically female mice develop testicular tissue within their ovaries. The ovaries develop cells that possess structural and functional characteristics of testicular interstitial cells and of seminiferous tubule-like structures lined with Sertoli cells. Moreover, the ovaries express mRNA for the testis-specific Sertoli cell transcription factor Sox 9 and espin protein, which is specific for inter-Sertoli cell junctions. The development of the testicular tissue in this model can be reverted/postponed by replacing estrogen. When ArKO female mice were fed a diet containing phytoestrogens, the appearance of Leydig and Sertoli cells was postponed and reduced. Furthermore, administration of estradiol-17beta decreased the number of Sertoli and Leydig cells in the ovaries. These findings constitute definitive evidence that estrogen plays a critical role in maintaining female somatic interstitial and granulosa cells in the eutherian ovary.

Contrasting phenotypes in reproductive tissues of female estrogen receptor null mice

The estrogen receptor (ER) exists in two known forms, ERalpha and ERbeta, and acts as a ligand-inducible transcription factor to fulfill critical roles in reproductive physiology. Although in vitro studies suggest the ERs may play redundant roles, a dissimilar tissue distribution indicates otherwise. Therefore, to gain insight into the role of each ER form, individual lines of mice lacking each respective receptor, as well as mice lacking both ER forms, were generated. alphaERKO and betaERKO female mice possess a normally developed reproductive tract and maintain expression of the opposite ER. The alphaERKO female is infertile and exhibits a hypoplastic uterus that is refractory to estrogens. The ovaries of the alphaERKO female are consistently polycystic and lack indications of spontaneous ovulation. In contrast, the betaERKO female exhibits a hormonally responsive uterus and grossly normal ovaries, but is subfertile in terms of the frequency and size of litters. Immature females of both ERKO lines successfully ovulate viable ova when superovulated with exogenous gonadotropins, yet the average yield of ooctyes is reduced. Mice lacking both known ER forms (alphabetaERKO) are infertile, possess the expected reproductive tract structures, but exhibit a remarkably distinct ovarian phenotype characterized by postnatal loss of oocytes and redifferentiation of the remaining somatic cells to Sertoli-like cells. This "sex-reversal" in the alphabetaERKO ovary is accompanied by the ectopic expression of testis-specific genes, for example, Sox9 and sulfatedglycoprotein-2.

Sex determining genes and sexual differentiation in a marsupial

The role of genes in the differentiation of the testis and ovary has been extensively studied in the human and the mouse. Despite over a decade of investigations, the precise roles of genes and their interactions in the pathway of sex determination are still unclear. We have chosen to take a comparative look at sex determination and differentiation to gain insights into the evolution and the conserved functions of these genes. To achieve this, we have examined a wide variety of eutherian sex determining genes in a marsupial, the tammar wallaby, to determine which genes have a conserved and fundamental mammalian sex determining role. These investigations have provided many unique insights. Here, we review the recent molecular and endocrine investigations into sexual development in marsupials, and highlight how these studies have shed light on the roles of genes and hormones in mammalian sex determination and differentiation.

Postnatal sex reversal of the ovaries in mice lacking estrogen receptors alpha and beta

Mice lacking estrogen receptors alpha and beta were generated to clarify the roles of each receptor in the physiology of estrogen target tissues. Both sexes of alphabeta estrogen receptor knockout (alphabetaERKO) mutants exhibit normal reproductive tract development but are infertile. Ovaries of adult alphabetaERKO females exhibit follicle transdifferentiation to structures resembling seminiferous tubules of the testis, including Sertoli-like cells and expression of Müllerian inhibiting substance, sulfated glycoprotein-2, and Sox9. Therefore, loss of both receptors leads to an ovarian phenotype that is distinct from that of the individual ERKO mutants, which indicates that both receptors are required for the maintenance of germ and somatic cells in the postnatal ovary.

TGF-beta Family Members and Gonadal Development

Several members of the transforming growth factor beta (TGF-beta) family are involved in gonadal development; namely, TGF-beta itself, inhibins, activins, anti-Müllerian hormone (AMH) and GDF-9. These proteins do not affect initial gonadal organogenesis but play either a stimulatory or inhibitory role in the division and differentiation of gonadal cells and in meiotic maturation in the female. Furthermore, as shown by transgenic mouse technology, both AMH and inhibin act as tumor suppressors.

High specificity of Müllerian-inhibiting substance signaling in vivo

Female transgenic mice that ectopically express high levels of human Müllerian-inhibiting substance (hMIS) under the control of the mouse metallothionein (MT) promoter lack a uterus, oviducts, and ovaries. The loss of the uterus and oviducts is consistent with the known activities for MIS. However, it is not clear if the loss of the ovaries in these transgenic females is caused by interactions of MIS with its normal receptor signaling pathway or by abnormal interactions with other transforming growth factor-beta (TGF-beta) super family receptor signaling pathways. To address this question, female mice carrying the MT-hMIS transgene that were also homozygous for a targeted deletion of the MIS type II receptor gene were generated. Although these females had high levels of circulating hMIS, they had normal reproductive tracts and ovaries with germ cells. In addition, these females were able to become pregnant and gave birth to pups. These findings demonstrate that all of the abnormalities of the reproductive system that are found in female transgenic mice that ectopically express high levels of hMIS are caused by signaling through the MIS type II receptor. These in vivo data demonstrate a high specificity for MIS and its receptor.