Perfusion safety: past, present, and future

A Small Scale Oxygenator for Cardiopulmonary Bypass in Rats

Cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB) devices replace transiently the function of both heart and lungs, allowing the investigator to work safely on a stopped heart. Although this technology has greatly improved since its first applications in the early 1950's there is still no definitive rat CPB model, various experiments reporting drawbacks like pulmonary edema, large priming volumes, etc. We present a new oxygenator that can be used in cardiopulmonary bypass experiments in rats, simple in design and efficient in function, in which the process of blood oxygenation takes place in a vertical cylinder filled up with air or oxygen, with blood being spread onto the wall and then trickling down in a thin layer that facilitates the oxygen transfer. The oxygenation is efficient, the pO2 reaches levels of almost 150 mmHg (physiological level is around 100 mmHg) in conditions of oxygen saturation of over 99% (normal levels 95%-98%).

Departmental use of perfusion crisis management drills: 2002 survey results

Serious complications during the performance of cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB) are an infrequent event. However, when potentially fatal technical complications, such as oxygenator or pump failure, do occur, it necessitates a swift and well-co-ordinated response. Periodic performances of drills that simulate various CPB crises are a way to improve individual perfusionist proficiency during disaster situations. The purpose of this study is to determine the utilization of crisis management drills in perfusion departments. Every open-heart program listed by the American Hospital Association in the New England states (Maine, Massachusetts, Rhode Island, Vermont, New Hampshire, Connecticut) and New York were contacted by telephone. Of the 61 contacted, 59 participated for a response rate of 97%. Demographically, the survey represents 312 perfusionists and 47 227 cases annually. While 97% of the perfusion departments believed that regular practice and performance of crisis management drills would improve individual proficiency, only 17% of the programs mandated that their perfusionists perform crisis management drills as a matter of departmental policy. Reasons expressed for not having a formal written policy regarding performance crisis management drills were as follows: left up to the individuals to maintain proficiency 19 (39%), not motivated 11 (22%), confident of proficiency 9 (19%), no time 8 (17%), dubious value 1 (2%), and cost prohibitive 1 (2%). While it is nearly universally accepted that periodically practicing perfusion crisis management drills in a `wet lab' environment would improve proficiency, only a minority of perfusion teams deem this a high enough priority to make it a matter of formal departmental policy.

Perfusion safety: defining the problem

Perfusion safety is not an isolated component of cardiac surgery, but encompasses many facets, including equipment, safety devices, conduct of perfusion, surgical technique, vigilance, and communication within the operating room. Over the last 25 years, several surveys have provided an estimation of the occurrence of perfusion-related incidents and documented the frequency with which they affected patient morbidity and mortality. As the focus of attention turned to correcting these problem areas, each subsequent survey demonstrated changes, but also pointed out new areas needing improvement. As technology and education improved, so did results. With refinements in perfusion equipment and techniques, and increasing use of computer assistance and automation, cardiopulmonary bypass should become even safer. The key ingredient, though, will remain the knowledge and expertise of the perfusionist.

Comparison of current practices of cardiopulmonary perfusion technology in Iran with American Society of Extracorporeal Technology's standards

INTRODUCTION

Standards have a significant role in showing the minimum level of optimal optimum and the expected performance. Since the perfusion technology staffs play an the leading role in providing the quality services to the patients undergoing open heart surgery with cardiopulmonary bypass machine, this study aimed to assess the standards on how Iranian perfusion technology staffs evaluate and manage the patients during the cardiopulmonary bypass process and compare their practice with the recommended standards by American Society of Extracorporeal Technology.

METHODS

In this descriptive study, data was collected from 48 Iranian public hospitals and educational health centers through a researcher-created questionnaire. The data collection questionnaire assessed the standards which are recommended by American Society of Extracorporeal Technology.

RESULTS

Findings showed that appropriate measurements were carried out by the perfusion technology staffs to prevent the hemodilution and avoid the blood transfusion and unnecessary blood products, determine the initial dose of heparin based on one of the proposed methods, monitor the anticoagulants based on ACT measurement, and determine the additional doses of heparin during the cardiopulmonary bypass based on ACT or protamine titration. It was done only in 4.2% of hospitals and health centers.

CONCLUSION

Current practices of cardiopulmonary perfusion technology in Iran are inappropriate based on the standards of American Society of Cardiovascular Perfusion. This represents the necessity of authorities' attention to the validation programs and development of the caring standards on one hand and continuous assessment of using these standards on the other hand.

Real-time data acquisition and alerts may reduce reaction time and improve perfusionist performance during cardiopulmonary bypass

Delayed perfusionist identification and reaction to abnormal clinical situations has been reported to contribute to increased mortality and morbidity. The use of automated data acquisition and compliance safety alerts has been widely accepted in many industries and its use may improve operator performance. A study was conducted to evaluate the reaction time of perfusionists with and without the use of compliance alert. A compliance alert is a computer-generated pop-up banner on a pump-mounted computer screen to notify the user of clinical parameters outside of a predetermined range. A proctor monitored and recorded the time from an alert until the perfusionist recognized the parameter was outside the desired range. Group one included 10 cases utilizing compliance alerts. Group 2 included 10 cases with the primary perfusionist blinded to the compliance alerts. In Group 1, 97 compliance alerts were identified and, in group two, 86 alerts were identified. The average reaction time in the group using compliance alerts was 3.6 seconds. The average reaction time in the group not using the alerts was nearly ten times longer than the group using computer-assisted, real-time data feedback. Some believe that real-time computer data acquisition and feedback improves perfusionist performance and may allow clinicians to identify and rectify potentially dangerous situations.

Perfusion safety: new initiatives and enduring principles

Perfusion safety has been studied and discussed extensively for decades. Many initiatives occurred through efforts of professional organizations to achieve recognition, establish accreditation and certification, promote consensus practice guidelines, and develop peer-reviewed journals as sources for dissemination of clinical information. Newer initiatives have their basis in other disciplines and include systems approach, Quality Assurance/Quality Improvement processes, error recognition, evidence-based methodologies, registries, equipment automation, simulation, and the Internet. Use of previously established resources such as written protocols, checklists, safety devices, and enhanced communication skills has persisted to the present in promoting perfusion safety and has reduced current complication rates to negligible levels.

Establishment of rat model of cardiopulmonary bypass in pulmonary hypertension

An experimental model of cardiopulmonary bypass in rats with pulmonary hypertension is necessary to understand underlying mechanisms and develop protective strategies. Male Sprague-Dawley rats were randomly divided into a sham group, cardiopulmonary bypass group, pulmonary hypertension group, and pulmonary hypertension with cardiopulmonary bypass group. Both groups with pulmonary hypertension received a subcutaneous injection of monocrotaline 60 mg x kg(-1) on day 0. Cardiopulmonary bypass was instituted in one of them 21 days later. The sham and pulmonary hypertension control groups underwent cannulation only. Cardiopulmonary bypass was conducted for 60 min at a flow rate of 100 mL x kg(-1) x min(-1). Hemodynamic investigations, blood gas analysis, interleukin-6, tumor necrosis factor-alpha, and survival studies were performed subsequently. Time-dependent increases of serum interleukin-6 and tumor necrosis factor-alpha were found after cardiopulmonary bypass in both groups. This model allows the study of multiple organ pathophysiological processes after cardiopulmonary bypass in rats with pulmonary hypertension, as well as the evaluation of possible protective strategies.

Artificial device for extracorporeal blood oxygenation in rats

Blood oxygenation devices are an essential component of any cardiopulomonary bypass circuit in various species of laboratory animals. When using larger animals like dogs or pigs, the human and pediatric blood oxygenators could be easily used, but the disadvantage of these species is the scarcity of biochemical and genetic assays for experimental follow-up. However, small rodents like rats have plenty of biochemical assays, but their size requires special oxygenators adapted for their small blood volume and often primed with blood of another animal or other physiological solution. We showed the new design of a blood oxygenator with direct blood-gas contact in an open circuit, specially designed for rats in which the blood oxygenation takes place in a slowly rotating plastic tube with blood spread onto its inner walls in a thin layer. The oxygenator is simple and efficient, does not require priming with the blood of another rat, has a small dead volume, is reusable, and easy to clean and sterilize.

Good Recovery after Nontransthoracic Cardiopulmonary Bypass in Rats

BACKGROUND

Cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB) has been shown to be associated with systemic inflammatory response leading to postoperative organ dysfunction. Unwanted side effects of CPB are well known but poorly understood due to the absence of a stable recovery animal model that is easy to handle and reduces experiment cost and time. The purpose of this study was to establish a good recoverable rat model of CPB to study the pathophysiology of these potential complications.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Twenty adult male Sprague-Dawley rats weighing 480 +/- 20 g were randomly divided into either the CPB group (n = 10) or the sham group (n = 10). All rats were anesthetized, intubated, and ventilated. The carotid artery and jugular vein were cannulated. The blood was drained from the right atrium via the right jugular and further transferred by a miniaturized roller pump to a hollow fiber oxygenator and back to the rat via the left carotid artery. Priming consisted of 8 mL of homologous blood and 6 mL of colloid. The surface of the hollow fiber oxgenator was 0.075 m2. Rats were catheterized and brought on bypass for 120 minutes at a flow rate of 100-120 mL/kg per minute. Oxygen flow/perfusion flow was 0.8 to 1.0, and the mean arterial pressure remained 60 to 80 mmHg. Blood gas analysis, lactate dehydrogenase, and survival rate were examined subsequently.

RESULTS

All CPB rats recovered from the operative process without incident and recovery remained uneventful in follow-up at 1 week. Normal cardiac function after successful weaning was confirmed by electrocardiography and blood pressure measurements. Mean arterial pressure remained stable. The results of blood gas analysis at different times were within normal range. No significant hemolysis could be detected with the use of lactate dehydrogenase during bypass.

CONCLUSIONS

The rat model of CPB can in principle simulate the clinical setting of human CPB. The non-transthoracic model is easy to establish and is associated with excellent recovery. This reproducible model may open the field for various studies on the pathophysiological process of CPB and systemic ischemia-reperfusion injury in vivo.

A recovery model of minimally invasive cardiopulmonary bypass in the rat

This study was undertaken to develop a rodent (rat) model of cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB) that has been designed to mimic functionally the minimally invasive clinical setting. The circuit is similar to the clinical model in terms of its construction, configuration, material surface area to blood volume ratio, and priming volume to blood ratio. The overall priming volume was 10 mL. Thirty-six male Sprague-Dawley rats (422 +/- 32 g) were anaesthetized while maintaining spontaneous ventilation. Anticoagulation was achieved with heparin (500 IU/kg). Blood arterial pressure was monitored continuously. Normal central temperature was maintained throughout. Intermittent arterial blood gas levels also were monitored. All animals were cannulated in preparation for CPB; however, CPB, utilizing a double roller pump and a flow rate of 100 mL/kg/minute for 60 min, was initiated in only 18 animals, the remaining 18 animals acting as non-CPB controls (Sham). The animals were haemodynamically stable. After the operative procedure, the animals were allowed to recover from the anaesthesia and, after transfer to a recovery facility, were monitored for a period of 1 week. There were no differences between the groups in terms of blood gas analysis and blood pressure data; all animals survived the procedure and had an uneventful follow-up. Differences were found between the CPB animals and the Sham group in terms of TNFalpha used as a marker of inflammatory processes. This trend tends to support this model as an analogue for the clinical scenario for future studies of CPB-related inflammation. Overall, the CPB procedure was easy to perform and was associated with excellent survival. This recovery model is an effective tool to perform pathophysiological studies associated with minimally invasive CPB.

A rat model of cardiopulmonary bypass with excellent survival

BACKGROUND

Elucidating the underlying mechanisms and developing protective strategies for the pathophysiological consequences of cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB) have been hampered due to the absence of a satisfactory long-term recovery animal model. The objective of this study was to establish a survival experimental model of CPB in rats to meet the requirement of these studies.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Male SD rats (450-550 g) were randomly divided into CPB (n = 10) group and Sham group (n = 10). All rats were anaesthetized and mechanically ventilated. The femoral artery and vein were cannulated for continuous blood pressure recordings and fluid replacement, respectively. The CPB circuit comprised a venous reservoir, a membrane oxygenator, and a roller pump. Blood was drained from the right atrium via a jugular vein catheter and returned to the right carotid artery. Priming consisted of 8 ml of homologous blood and 8 ml of colloid. CPB was conducted for 60 min at a flow rate of 100-150 ml/kg/min in the CPB group. Haemodynamic investigations, blood gas analysis, and survival studies were performed subsequently.

RESULTS

Our data show that the rat model principally simulated the clinical setting of CPB in terms of its construction, configuration, performance, material surface area, and priming volume to blood volume ratio. All CPB rats survived and the 2-week follow-up period remained uneventful.

CONCLUSIONS

The rat model of CPB was easy to establish and was associated with excellent survival. This model should facilitate the investigation of the pathophysiological processes concerning CPB-related multiple organ dysfunction and possible protective interventions.

Is roller pump induced tubing rupture a clinical possibility?

We analyzed the effects of variations in the diameter of silicone rubber and polyvinyl chloride (PVC) tubings on the likelihood of tubing rupture during modeling of accidental arterial line clamping in cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB) with a roller pump. A closed CPB circuit constructed with a roller pump was tested with both PVC and silicone rubber tubings of 1/2, 3/8, and 1/4 inch internal diameter. Arterial line pressure was monitored, and an occlusive clamp was placed across the tubing distal to the pressure monitor site to model an accidental arterial line occlusion. A charge coupled device camera with 512 (horizontal) x 492 (vertical) pixels was installed above the roller pump to measure tubing diameters at pump outlet where the maximum deformations (distension) of the tubings occurred. Quantitative measurement of the changes of tubing diameters with the change of arterial line pressure was performed using computerized image processing techniques. A visible change of tubing diameter was generally noticeable by around 250 psi of arterial line pressure, which was already very high. By 1,500 psi, the PVC tubings showed an increase of diameter between 5% to 10% while the silicone rubber tubings showed an increase between 20% to 25%. Silicone rubber tubings of all sizes showed greater distensibility than PVC tubings of equivalent size. In conclusion, although roller pump induced tubing rupture remains a theoretical problem during CPB in terms of the inherent mechanism of the pump, in reality such an occurrence is impossible in real clinical conditions.

Alterations to haemostasis following cardiopulmonary bypass and the relationship of these changes to neurocognitive morbidity

Cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB) is routinely utilized to provide circulatory support during cardiac surgical procedures. The morbidity of CPB has been significantly reduced since its introduction 50 years ago; however, cerebral injury remains a potentially serious consequence of otherwise successful surgery. The risk of stroke postoperatively is approximately 1-5%. Incidence rates for neurocognitive deficit, however, vary markedly depending on the detection method, although typically it is reported in at least 50% of patients. The aetiology of this cerebral injury remains open to debate, although evidence shows that ischaemia secondary to microembolism may be the principal factor. Emboli originate from bubbles of air, atheroemboli released on aortic manipulation and thromboemboli generated as a result of haemostatic activation. Significant generation of thrombin occurs during CPB resulting in fibrin formation, although the trigger of this activation is not fully understood. Rather than originating from contact activation as previously thought, the primary trigger may be via the activated factor VII/tissue factor pathway of coagulation, with an additional role of contact activation in amplification of coagulation as well as the fibrinolytic response to CPB. Haemostatic activation is inhibited with systemic heparin therapy. The relationship between haemostatic activation and emboli formation during CPB is not known. Interventions to reduce cerebral injury in the context of cardiac surgery depend, in large part, on the minimization of emboli. This review investigates cerebral injury after cardiac surgery and evidence showing that microembolism is the principal causative agent. Fibrin emboli are postulated to be an important source of cerebral embolism. The mechanism of haemostatic activation during CPB is therefore also discussed.

An update on perfusion safety: does the type of perfusion practice affect the rate of incidents related to cardiopulmonary bypass?

Cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB) techniques vary among adult and pediatric patients undergoing cardiac surgery. This may result in a differential conduct of CPB between various aged patients. The present study reports on perfusion incidents occurring in hospitals using extracorporeal circulation. An 80 question survey was mailed to chief perfusionists at all 1030 US cardiac surgical centers. Respondents were asked to report on device use and incidents occurring during a 2-year period from July 1996 to June 1998. Five hundred and twenty-four completed surveys were returned with the age of surgical patients operated on at each hospital defined as either an adult (n=407), pediatric (n=17), or combined-adult and pediatric (n=100). Centrifugal pumps were used as the primary systemic pumps in 54% of adult, 12% of pediatric, and 36% of combined centers. In-line blood gas monitoring was used in 76% of all pediatric hospitals, but in only 30% of adult facilities. Incident rates occurred once per every 120.9, 83.9, and 220.2 cases in adult, pediatric, and combined centers, respectively. Mortality rates related to CPB occurred 2.7 times higher in adult and pediatric centers as compared to combined hospitals. Arterial dissection was the number one cause of death in both pediatric and combined hospitals, while coagulation disturbances resulted in the highest mortality for adult procedures. Results of this study show that the lowest incident rates occur at hospitals performing combined adult and pediatric CPB.

A retrospective study on perfusion incidents and safety devices

Despite the acceptance of extracorporeal circulation as an effective modality to facilitate cardiac surgery, patient outcomes can be negatively influenced by the occurrence of perfusion incidents. A perfusion survey was conducted to identify safety techniques and incidents related to cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB). An 80-question survey was mailed to chief perfusionists of all 1030 USA cardiac surgical centers using CPB. The survey was designed to examine practices and incidents that occurred during a 2-year period (July 1996 to July 1998). Five-hundred-and-fifty-two (54% response rate) surveys were returned, which accounted for 797 hospitals (79% of all cardiac centers) and 653,621 surgical procedures. Of the 27 identified CPB safety devices, the highest utilization was arterial line filters (98.5%) and the lowest arterial line bubble traps (3.4%). Of the reported cases, a CPB incident occurred once every 138 cases. The most common occurring incidents were protamine reactions (1:783), coagulation problems (1:771), and heater/cooler failures 11:1809). The rate of occurrence of an incident resulting in a serious injury or death was one for every 1453 procedures. Although techniques and safety devices create a relatively secure environment for CPB, lower incident rates may be achieved with further improvements in coagulation monitoring and incident reporting.

A literature review of cardiopulmonary bypass models for rats

Cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB) has improved a great deal since its first applications in the early 1950s. If improvements are to be continued, a preclinical model of CPB for small animals is desirable, mainly because of convenience of equipment and low costs. We review the different models of CPB for rats that have been designed, discuss their characteristics and points where improvements may be made. We give suggestions and requirements for a new up-to-date model that could be a useful tool in continued research on the pathophysiology and therapeutic strategies of CPB.

Quality assurance in clinical perfusion

OBJECTIVE

To investigate the properties and usefulness of prospective routine registration of incidents related to cardiopulmonary bypass and its clinical significance as a quality assurance instrument.

METHODS

Incidents or deviations from the normal course observed during cardiopulmonary bypass procedures were registered in a computer database. Each incident was classified according to 14 pre-defined categories. The cause of each incident was evaluated, as well as patient outcome. Incidents leading to permanent or temporary injury were denoted accidents. The general- and category-related incidence rate was calculated for the observation period 1989-1997 encompassing 6918 cardiopulmonary bypass procedures.

RESULTS

The general incidence rate varied between 4.5-7.6% per year during the registration period. Most incidents (57%) occurred during established, or start of, cardiopulmonary bypass, whereas the remaining proportion of incidents were detected either before (27%) or when terminating (16%). The most common category of incidents was oxygenator failure (1.6%), followed by mechanical (1.4%) and surgical (1.2%) incidents. Accidents and fatal outcomes occurred in 0.03% of the cases.

CONCLUSIONS

Routine registration of incidents yields a clinically attractive instrument of controlling safety aspects and quality measures in cardiopulmonary bypass. The observed incidence rates are somewhat higher than previously reported, probably primarily related to the methodology implemented in this study.