Three-dimensional conformal radiation therapy in bronchogenic carcinoma

A Randomized Phase 2 Trial of Prophylactic Manuka Honey for the Reduction of Chemoradiation Therapy-Induced Esophagitis During the Treatment of Lung Cancer: Results of NRG Oncology RTOG 1012

PURPOSE

Randomized trials have shown that honey is effective for the prevention of radiation-induced mucositis in head and neck cancer patients. Because there is no efficacious preventative for radiation esophagitis in lung cancer patients, this trial compared liquid honey, honey lozenges, and standard supportive care for radiation esophagitis.

METHODS

The patients were stratified by percentage of esophagus receiving specific radiation dose (V60 Gy esophagus <30% or ≥30%) and were then randomized between supportive care, 10 mL of liquid manuka honey 4 times a day, and 2 lozenges (10 mL of dehydrated manuka honey) 4 times a day during concurrent chemotherapy and radiation therapy. The primary endpoint was patient-reported pain on swallowing, with the use of an 11-point (0-10) scale at 4 weeks (Numerical Rating Pain Scale, NRPS). The study was designed to detect a 15% relative reduction of change in NRPS score. The secondary endpoints were trend of pain over time, opioid use, clinically graded and patient-reported adverse events, weight loss, dysphagia, nutritional status, and quality of life.

RESULTS

53 patients were randomized to supportive care, 54 were randomized to liquid honey, and 56 were randomized to lozenge honey. There was no significant difference in the primary endpoint of change in the NRPS at 4 weeks between arms. There were no differences in any of the secondary endpoints except for opioid use at 4 weeks during treatment between the supportive care and liquid honey arms, which was found to be significant (P=.03), with more patients on the supportive care arm taking opioids.

CONCLUSION

Honey as prescribed within this protocol was not superior to best supportive care in preventing radiation esophagitis. Further testing of other types of honey and research into the mechanisms of action are needed.

Personalized dose selection in radiation therapy using statistical models for toxicity and efficacy with dose and biomarkers as covariates

Selection of dose for cancer patients treated with radiation therapy (RT) must balance the increased efficacy with the increased toxicity associated with higher dose. Historically, a single dose has been selected for a population of patients (e.g., all stage III non-small cell lung cancer). However, the availability of new biologic markers for toxicity and efficacy allows the possibility of selecting a more personalized dose. We consider the use of statistical models for toxicity and efficacy as a function of RT dose and biomarkers to select an optimal dose for an individual patient, defined as the dose that maximizes the probability of efficacy minus the sum of weighted toxicity probabilities. This function can be shown to be equal to the expected value of the utility derived from a particular family of bivariate outcome utility matrices. We show that if dose is linearly related to the probability of toxicity and efficacy, then any marker that only acts additively with dose cannot improve efficacy, without also increasing toxicity. Using a dataset of lung cancer patients treated with RT, we illustrate this approach and compare it to non-marker-based dose selection. Because typical metrics used in evaluating new markers (e.g., area under the ROC curve) do not directly address the ability of a marker to improve efficacy at a fixed probability of toxicity, we utilize a simulation study to assess the effects of marker-based dose selection on toxicity and efficacy outcomes.

Lung abnormalities at multimodality imaging after radiation therapy for non-small cell lung cancer

Three-dimensional (3D) conformal radiation therapy (CRT) and stereotactic body radiation therapy (SBRT) are designed to deliver the maximum therapeutic radiation dose to the tumor, allowing improved local disease control, while minimizing irradiation of surrounding normal structures. The complex configuration of the multiple beams that deliver the radiation dose to the tumor in 3D CRT and SBRT produces patterns of lung injury that differ in location and extent from those seen after conventional radiation therapy. Radiation-induced changes in lung tissue after 3D CRT and SBRT occur within the radiation portals. The imaging appearance of irradiated tissues varies according to the time elapsed after the completion of therapy, with acute-phase changes of radiation pneumonitis represented by ground-glass opacities and consolidation and with late-phase changes of radiation fibrosis manifesting as volume loss, consolidation, and traction bronchiectasis. Knowledge of treatment timelines and radiation field locations, as well as familiarity with the full spectrum of possible radiation-induced lung injuries after 3D CRT and SBRT, is important to correctly interpret the abnormalities that may be seen at computed tomography (CT). Differential diagnoses in this context might include infections, lymphangitic carcinomatosis, local recurrence of malignancy, and radiation-induced tumors. The integration of morphologic information obtained at CT with metabolic information obtained at positron emission tomography is helpful in distinguishing radiation-induced parenchymal abnormalities from residual, recurrent, and new cancers. Thus, multimodality follow-up imaging may lead to substantial changes in disease management.

Conformal radiotherapy for lung cancer: interobservers' variability in the definition of gross tumor volume between radiologists and radiotherapists

Background

Conformal external radiotherapy aims to improve tumor control by boosting tumor dose, reducing morbidity and sparing healthy tissues. To meet this objective careful visualization of the tumor and adjacent areas is required. However, one of the major issues to be solved in this context is the volumetric definition of the targets. This study proposes to compare the gross volume of lung tumors as delineated by specialized radiologists and radiotherapists of a cancer center.

Methods

Chest CT scans of a total of 23 patients all with non-small cell lung cancer, not submitted to surgery, eligible and referred to conformal radiotherapy on the Hospital A. C. Camargo (São Paulo, Brazil), during the year 2004 were analyzed. All cases were delineated by 2 radiologists and 2 radiotherapists. Only the gross tumor volume and the enlarged lymph nodes were delineated. As such, four gross tumor volumes were achieved for each one of the 23 patients.

Results

There was a significant positive correlation between the 2 measurements (among the radiotherapists, radiologists and intra-class) and there was randomness in the distribution of data within the constructed confidence interval.

Conclusion

There were no significant differences in the definition of gross tumor volume between radiologists and radiotherapists.

Thoracic radiation therapy for limited-stage small-cell lung cancer: unanswered questions

The role of thoracic radiation therapy (RT; TRT) is now established in the management of limited-stage small-cell lung cancer (SCLC). There is increasing evidence in the literature in favor of early concurrent chemoradiation therapy, and a gold standard of care for patients with a good performance status is twice-daily TRT (45 Gy in 3 weeks) with concurrent cisplatin/etoposide. Five-year survival rates > 20% can be expected with this combined-modality approach. Although current clinical trials are exploring the efficacy of new chemotherapeutic strategies for the disease, essential questions related to the optimization of TRT remain unanswered. In particular, the optimal RT dose, fractionation, and treatment volume have not been defined. This review highlights the need for well-designed multinational trials aimed at the optimization and standardization of RT for limited-stage SCLC. These trials should integrate translational research studies to investigate the molecular basis of RT resistance and to develop biomarker profiles of prognosis.

Imaging of the Patient with Non–Small Cell Lung Cancer

Lung cancer is the most common type of cancer and is the leading cause of cancer deaths in the United States for both men and women. Even though the 5-year survival rate of patients with lung cancer remains dismal at 14% for all cancer stages, treatments are improving and newer agents for lung cancer appear promising. Therefore, an accurate assessment of the extent of disease is critical to determine whether the patient is treated with surgical resection, radiation therapy, chemotherapy, or a combination of these modalities. Radiologic imaging plays an important role in the staging evaluation of the patient; however, radiologists need to be aware that there are also important differences in what each specialist needs from imaging to provide appropriate treatment. This article reviews the role of imaging in patients with non-small cell lung cancer, with an emphasis on the radiologic imaging findings relevant for each specialty.

Combination of longitudinal and circumferential three-dimensional esophageal dose distribution predicts acute esophagitis in hypofractionated reirradiation of patients with non-small-cell lung cancer treated in stereotactic body frame

PURPOSE

To evaluate dosimetric predictors of acute esophagitis (AE) and clinical outcome of patients with non-small-cell lung cancer (NSCLC) receiving reirradiation.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Seventeen patients with NSCLC received reirradiation to the lung tumors/mediastinum, while immobilized in stereotactic body frame (SBF). CT simulation and hypofractionated three-dimensional radiotherapy were used. Two axial segments of esophagus contours merged together were defined as esophagus disc (ED). For each ED, the percentage (%) of the volume of esophageal circumference treated to % of prescribed dose (PD) was assessed. Number of EDs with 50% or any % of volume (V) of esophageal circumference receiving more than or equal to (>/=) 50%, 80%, and 100% of PD (50% V >/=50% PD; 50% V >/=80% PD; any % V >/=100% PD) were calculated. These dosimetric variables and the length of the esophagus within the radiation therapy (RT) port were correlated with AE using exact Wilcoxon test.

RESULTS

A median RT dose was 32 Gy with a median fraction size of 4 Gy. Eleven of 13 patients presenting with pain and/or shortness of breath had complete or partial resolution of symptoms. Median survival time from the start of reirradiation in SBF until death was 5.5 months. AE was observed in 7 patients and resolved within 3 months of RT completion. No Grade 3 or higher events were noticed. The length of the esophagus within RT port did not predict for AE (p = 0.71). However, an increased number of EDs predicted for AE for the following dosimetric variables: 50% V >/=50% PD (p = 0.023), 50% V >/=80% PD (p = 0.047), and any % V >/=100% PD (p = 0.004). Patients with at least 2 EDs receiving >/=100% PD to any % V of circumference had AE compared to those with zero EDs.

CONCLUSIONS

Reirradiation using hypofractionated three-dimensional radiotherapy and SBF immobilization is an effective strategy for palliation of symptoms in selected patients with recurrent NSCLC. The length of the esophagus in the RT field does not predict for AE. However, an increasing number of EDs displaying the combination of longitudinal and circumferential three-dimensional dose distribution along the esophagus is a valuable predictor for AE.

Results of a phase I dose-escalation study using three-dimensional conformal radiotherapy in the treatment of inoperable nonsmall cell lung carcinoma

BACKGROUND

The objective of this study was to report the results of a Phase I dose-escalation study using three-dimensional conformal radiation therapy (3D-CRT) for the treatment of patients with nonsmall cell lung carcinoma (NSCLC).

METHODS

Between 1991 and 2003, 104 patients were enrolled for 3D-CRT at Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center. The median patient age was 69 years. Twenty-eight percent of patients had Stage I-II NSCLC, 33% of patients had Stage IIIA NSCLC, 32% of patients had Stage IIIB NSCLC, and 6% of patients had recurrent NSCLC. Induction chemotherapy was received by 16% of patients. Radiation was delivered in daily fractions of 1.8 grays (Gy) for doses < or = 81.0 Gy and in daily fractions of 2.0 Gy for higher doses. Accrual at a dose level was complete when 10 patients received the intended dose without unacceptable acute morbidity.

RESULTS

After an incident of fatal acute radiation pneumonitis at the starting dose of 70.2 Gy, the protocol was modified to limit normal tissue complication probabilities (NTCP) to < 25%. The dose was then escalated from 70.2 Gy, to 75.6 Gy, 81.0 Gy, and 84.0 Gy, with at least 10 patients treated at each dose level. Unacceptable pulmonary toxicity occurred at 90.0 Gy. Subsequently, another 10 patients were accrued at the 84.0 Gy level with acceptable toxicity. Thus, 84.0 Gy was the maximum tolerated dose (MTD). The crude late pulmonary toxicity rate was 7%, the 2-year local control rate was 52%, the disease-free survival rate was 33%, and the overall survival rate was 40%. The median survival was 21.1 months. Overall survival was improved significantly in patients who received > or = 80.0 Gy.

CONCLUSIONS

The MTD of 3D-CRT for NSCLC with an NTCP constraint of 25% was 84.0 Gy in the current study. There was a suggestion of improved survival in patients who received 80.0 Gy.

Imaging of non-small cell lung cancer

Radiologic evaluation is an important component of the clinical staging evaluation of lung cancer and can greatly influence whether the patient is treated with surgical resection, radiation therapy, chemotherapy, or a combination of these modalities. In addition to staging, the radiologic evaluation of the patient undergoing treatment and subsequent follow-up is important to the clinician for assessing treatment effects and complications. This article discusses the imaging of patients with non-small cell lung cancer and its use in management of these patients.

Comparison of three IMRT inverse planning techniques that allow for partial esophagus sparing in patients receiving thoracic radiation therapy for lung cancer

The purpose of this study is to compare 3 intensity-modulated radiation therapy (IMRT) inverse treatment planning techniques as applied to locally-advanced lung cancer. This study evaluates whether sufficient radiotherapy (RT) dose is given for durable control of tumors while sparing a portion of the esophagus, and whether large number of segments and monitor units are required. We selected 5 cases of locally-advanced lung cancer with large central tumor, abutting the esophagus. To ensure that no more than half of the esophagus circumference at any level received the specified dose limit, it was divided into disk-like sections and dose limits were imposed on each. Two sets of dose objectives were specified for tumor and other critical structures for standard dose RT and for dose escalation RT. Plans were generated using an aperture-based inverse planning (ABIP) technique with the Cimmino algorithm for optimization. Beamlet-based inverse treatment planning was carried out with a commercial simulated annealing package (CORVUS) and with an in-house system that used the Cimmino projection algorithm (CIMM). For 3 of the 5 cases, results met all of the constraints from the 3 techniques for the 2 sets of dose objectives. The CORVUS system without delivery efficiency consideration required the most segments and monitor units. The CIMM system reduced the number while the ABIP techniques showed a further reduction, although for one of the cases, a solution was not readily obtained using the ABIP technique for dose escalation objectives.

Improved local control with higher doses of radiation in large-volume stage III non-small-cell lung cancer

PURPOSE

It has been suggested that larger tumor volume is associated with poor survival in patients with non-small-cell lung cancer (NSCLC). We investigated whether high-dose radiation improved local control in patients with large-volume Stage III NSCLC.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Seventy-two patients with Stage III NSCLC and gross tumor volumes (GTV) of greater than 100 cc were treated with three-dimensional conformal radiotherapy (3D-CRT). Patients were divided into two groups: those treated to less than 64 Gy (37 patients) and those treated to 64 Gy or higher (35 patients).

RESULTS

The 1-year and 2-year local failure rates were 27% and 47%, respectively, for Stage III patients treated to 64 Gy or higher, and 61% and 76%, respectively, for those treated to less than 64 Gy (p = 0.024). The median survival time for patients treated to 64 Gy or higher was 20 months vs. 15 months for those treated to less than 64 Gy (p = 0.068). Multivariate analysis revealed that dose and GTV are predictors of local failure-free survival. A 10 Gy increase in dose resulted in a 36.4% decreased risk of local failure.

CONCLUSIONS

Our data suggest that administration of higher doses using 3D-CRT improves local control in Stage III NSCLC patients with large GTVs.

[New radiotherapy techniques for non-small-cell lung cancer]

Lung cancer is one of the most difficult challenges for radiotherapy. Problems include ballistic targeting compromised by respiratory movements, poor tolerance of neighboring healthy tissues and difficult dosimetry due to the heterogeneous nature of the thoracic tIssues. New perspectives are offered by recent developments allowing a more comprehensive approach to thoracic radiotherapy integrating new advances in imaging techniques, contention, dosimetry, and treatment devices. Two techniques are particularly promising: conformal radiotherapy and respiration-gated radiotherapy. Conformal radiotherapy, a three-dimensional conformal mode of irradiation with or without intensity modulation, is designed to achieve high-precision dose delivery by integrating advanced imaging techniques into the irradiation protocol. These tools are used to optimize irradiation of target Volumes and avoid recurrence while sparing as much as possible healthy tissues. If healthy tissue can be correctly protected, increased doses can be delivered to the target tumor. Respiration-gated techniques offer promising prospects for the treatment of tumors which are displaced by respiratory movements. These techniques allow better adaptation of the irradiation fields to the target tumor and better protection of healthy tissues (lung, heart...). These new approaches are now routine practices in many centers. Early results have been very promising. We describe here the currently available techniques for thoracic radiotherapy.

Normal-tissue toxicities of thoracic radiation therapy: esophagus, lung, and spinal cord as organs at risk

The evolution of therapeutic approaches for lung cancer illustrates the trend for treatment intensification, with hopes that dose-intense chemotherapy regimens, higher radiation therapy (RT) doses, or novel fractionation schemes will result in prolongation of survival. Current chemotherapy- and RT-intense regimens may not be intensified further without addressing dose-limiting toxicities such as esophagitis. It is important to understand factors pre-disposing to esophagitis so that strategies to minimize its severity can be investigated. Pulmonary complications such as pneumonitis and fibrosis from RT (with or without chemotherapy) are dose and volume dependent. Methods to better identify the target tissues and improved RT-delivery systems may facilitate increasing target doses or reducing doses to adjacent normal tissues. Biologic predictors may allow clinicians in the future to individualize RT treatment based on a patient's toxicity risk profile. Radiation myelopathy is still the most feared radiation complication of lung cancer treatment. The authors address the known parameters that influence the incidence of thoracic radiation myelopathy and the putative factors that could be considered when a clinician may be required to push the spinal cord dose in favor of tumor control.

Three-dimensional conformal radiotherapy in the radical treatment of non-small cell lung cancer

Patients with locally advanced, inoperable, non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) have a poor prognosis mainly due to failure of local control after treatment with radical radiotherapy. This overview addresses the role of three-dimensional conformal radiotherapy (3D CRT) in trying to improve survival and reduce toxicity for patients with NSCLC. Current techniques of 3D CRT are analysed and discussed. They include imaging, target volume definition, optimisation of the delivery of radiotherapy through improvement of set-up inaccuracy and reduction of organ motion, dosimetry and implementation and verification issues; the overview concludes with the clinical results of 3D CRT.

New radiotherapy technologies

Conventional radiation therapy has had limited success in curing inoperable lung cancer due to poor local control. There is evidence to suggest that higher doses of radiation will improve local control. In order to safely deliver higher doses of thoracic radiation, advanced treatment techniques are required. Different biologic indices have been utilized to determine whether dose escalation can be safely accomplished, and the results have been reported from many institutions. Tumor motion control aids in treatment since it allows radiation oncologists to more accurately target tumors and therefore to spare more normal tissue from the radiation field. The imaging information from 18-FDG-PET scans also improves target delineation. Advanced treatment delivery techniques, such as three-dimensional conformal radiation therapy, intensity modulated radiation therapy, and stereotactic radiosurgery are also being used to safely escalate the radiation dose. This article explores the current literature on these issues and other advanced radiation therapy techniques.

[Non-small-cell bronchial cancers: improvement of survival probability by conformal radiotherapy]

The conformal radiotherapy approach, three-dimensional conformal radiotherapy (3DCRT) and intensity-modulated radiotherapy (IMRT), is based on modern imaging modalities, efficient 3D treatment planning systems, sophisticated immobilization devices and demanding quality assurance and treatment verification. The main goal of conformal radiotherapy is to ensure a high dose distribution tailored to the limits of the target volume while reducing exposure of healthy tissues. These techniques would then allow a further dose escalation increasing local control and survival. Non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) is one of the most difficult malignant tumors to be treated. It combines geometrical difficulties due to respiratory motion, and number of low tolerance neighboring organs, and dosimetric difficulties because of the presence of huge inhomogeneities. This localization is an attractive and ambitious example for the evaluation of new techniques. However, the published clinical reports in the last years described very heterogeneous techniques and, in the absence of prospective randomized trials, it is somewhat difficult at present to evaluate the real benefits drawn from those conformal radiotherapy techniques. After reviewing the rationale for 3DCRT for NSCLC, this paper will describe the main studies of 3DCRT, in order to evaluate its impact on lung cancer treatment. Then, the current state-of-the-art of IMRT and the last technical and therapeutic innovations in NSCLC will be discussed.

Dose-volume factors contributing to the incidence of radiation pneumonitis in non-small-cell lung cancer patients treated with three-dimensional conformal radiation therapy

PURPOSE

To analyze acute lung toxicity data of non-small-cell lung cancer patients treated with three-dimensional conformal radiation therapy in terms of dosimetric variables, location of dose within subvolumes of the lungs, and models of normal-tissue complication probability (NTCP).

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Dose distributions of 49 non-small-cell lung cancer patients treated in a dose escalation protocol between 1992 and 1999 were analyzed (dose range: 57.6-81 Gy). Nine patients had RTOG Grade 3 or higher acute lung toxicity. Correlation with dosimetric and physical variables, as well as Lyman and parallel NTCP models, was assessed. Lungs were evaluated as a single structure, as superior and inferior halves (to assess significance of dose to upper and lower lungs), and as ipsilateral and contralateral lungs.

RESULTS

For the whole lung, Grade 3 or higher pneumonitis was significantly correlated (p <or= 0.05) with mean dose and Lyman and parallel model indices (d(eff) and f(dam)). It was significantly correlated with these indices and with V20 for the ipsilateral lung and with mean dose and d(eff) for the inferior half of the lungs. Dosimetric and NTCP model quantities for the superior half of the lungs and contralateral lung were not significantly correlated (p > 0.5 for superior lung indices, and >0.1 for contralateral lung indices studied).

CONCLUSIONS

For these patients, commonly used dosimetric and NTCP models are significantly correlated with >or= Grade 3 pneumonitis. Equivalently strong correlations are found in the lower portion of the lungs and the ipsilateral lung, but not in the upper portion or contralateral lung.

Radiation injury of the lung after three-dimensional conformal radiation therapy

OBJECTIVE

The objective of this study is to describe the CT patterns of radiation injury in the lungs of patients who have undergone three-dimensional (3D) conformal radiation therapy (CRT).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Over a 36-month period, the chest CT scans of 19 patients with non-small cell lung cancer who were treated with 3D CRT were reviewed. CT scans were evaluated for findings of radiation injury (ground-glass opacities, consolidation, bronchiectasis, and volume loss). The presence, extent, and distribution of these findings were reached by consensus.

RESULTS

Radiation pneumonitis limited to a small area immediately around the tumor was present in all patients who were imaged within 3 months after completion of the treatment (n = 7). Radiation-induced fibrosis occurred in all patients (n = 19). Three distinct patterns of fibrosis were consistently present, and these were classified as modified conventional, masslike, and scarlike. Modified conventional fibrosis (consolidation, volume loss, and bronchiectasis similar to, but less extensive than, conventional radiation fibrosis) was seen in five patients. Masslike fibrosis (focal consolidation with traction bronchiectasis limited to the site of the original tumor) was seen in eight patients. Scarlike fibrosis (linear opacity in the region of the original tumor associated with moderate to severe volume loss) was seen in six patients.

CONCLUSION

Three-dimensional conformal radiation therapy results in three patterns of radiation fibrosis that differ from the conventional radiation-induced lung injury. Knowledge of the full spectrum of these manifestations is useful in the correct interpretation of CT scans after 3D CRT.

Has 3-D conformal radiotherapy (3D CRT) improved the local tumour control for stage I non-small cell lung cancer?

AIMS AND BACKGROUND

The high local failure rates observed after radiotherapy in stage I non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) may be improved by the use of 3-dimensional conformal radiotherapy (3D CRT).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The case-records of 113 patients who were treated with curative 3D CRT between 1991 and 1999 were analysed. No elective nodal irradiation was performed, and doses of 60Gy or more, in once-daily fractions of between 2 and 3Gy, were prescribed.

RESULTS

The median actuarial survival of patients was 20 months, with 1-, 3- and 5-year survival of 71, 25 and 12%, respectively. Local disease progression was the cause of death in 30% of patients, and 22% patients died from distant metastases. Grade 2-3 acute radiation pneumonitis (SWOG) was observed in 6.2% of patients. The median actuarial local progression-free survival (LPFS) was 27 months, with 85 and 43% of patients free from local progression at 1 and 3 years, respectively. Endobronchial tumour extension significantly influenced LPFS, both on univariate (P=0.023) and multivariate analysis (P=0.023). The median actuarial cause-specific survival (CSS) was 19 months, and the respective 1- and 3-year rates were 72 and 30%. Multivariate analysis showed T2 classification (P=0.017) and the presence of endobronchial tumour extension (P=0.029) to be adverse prognostic factors for CSS. On multivariate analysis, T-stage significantly correlated with distant failure (P=0.005).

CONCLUSIONS

Local failure rates remain substantial despite the use of 3D CRT for stage I NSCLC. Additional improvements in local control can come about with the use of radiation dose escalation and approaches to address the problem of tumour mobility.

Intensity-modulated radiotherapy

Intensity-modulated radiotherapy represents a recent advancement in conformal radiotherapy. It employs specialized computer-driven technology to generate dose distributions that conform to tumor targets with extremely high precision. Treatment planning is based on inverse planning algorithms and iterative computer-driven optimization to generate treatment fields with varying intensities across the beam section. Combinations of intensity-modulated fields produce custom-tailored conformal dose distributions around the tumor, with steep dose gradients at the transition to adjacent normal tissues. Thus far, data have demonstrated improved precision of tumor targeting in carcinomas of the prostate, head and neck, thyroid, breast, and lung, as well as in gynecologic, brain, and paraspinal tumors and soft tissue sarcomas. In prostate cancer, intensity-modulated radiotherapy has resulted in reduced rectal toxicity and has permitted tumor dose escalation to previously unattainable levels. This experience indicates that intensity-modulated radiotherapy represents a significant advancement in the ability to deliver the high radiation doses that appear to be required to improve the local cure of several types of tumors. The integration of new methods of biologically based imaging into treatment planning is being explored to identify tumor foci with phenotypic expressions of radiation resistance, which would likely require high-dose treatments. Intensity-modulated radiotherapy provides an approach for differential dose painting to selectively increase the dose to specific tumor-bearing regions. The implementation of biologic evaluation of tumor sensitivity, in addition to methods that improve target delineation and dose delivery, represents a new dimension in intensity-modulated radiotherapy research.

Inoperable localized stage I and stage II non-small-cell lung cancer

Early stage, medically inoperable non-small-cell lung cancer is a treatable disease. A thorough clinical work-up is necessary to optimize management for this group of patients. Thoracic radiation therapy has been used for such patients with achievement of durable local control and prolonged survival. To improve upon the results of standard fractionation radiation therapy, novel approaches are needed. Dose escalation may further enhance local tumor control and survival rates. Efforts to minimize irradiation to normal lung parenchyma are necessary. Multiple strategies to optimize the therapeutic ratio are being investigated. Elimination of elective nodal irradiation may reduce late toxicity of treatment but may compromise locoregional control. Other strategies, such as intensity-modulated radiation therapy with dose volume histograms will help minimize lung parenchyma irradiation, which will reduce the probability of radiation pneumonitis. Chemotherapy appears to play a minimal role in the treatment of inoperable limited disease, but researchers continue to conduct investigational trials with active chemotherapeutic agents in the hopes of reducing local and distant tumor failures.

Conformal radiotherapy for lung cancer: different delineation of the gross tumor volume (GTV) by radiologists and radiation oncologists

PURPOSE

Delineation of the gross tumor volume (GTV) and organs at risk constitutes one of the most important phases of conformal radiotherapy (CRT) procedures. In the absence of a clear redefinition of the GTV, for a given pathology, complemented by detailed contouring procedures, the GTV are likely to be estimated rather arbitrarily with the risk of tumor underdosage or detriment to the surrounding healthy tissues. The objective of this study was to compare the delineation of the GTV of intrathoracic tumors by radiologists and radiation oncologists with experience in the field in various centers.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The computed tomography images of ten patients with nonoperated non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) eligible for CRT were reviewed. Nine radiologists and eight radiation oncologists working in five different centers, classified as either 'junior' or 'senior' according to their professional experience, had to delineate the GTV (primary tumor and involved lymph nodes) with predefined visualization parameters. A dedicated software was used to compare the delineated volumes in terms of intersection and union volumes and to calculate the 'concordance index' for each patient and each subgroup of physicians.

RESULTS

Significant differences between physicians and between centers were observed. Compared to radiation oncologists, radiologists tended to delineate smaller volumes and encountered fewer difficulties to delineate 'difficult' cases. Junior physicians, regardless of their specialty, also tended to delineate smaller and more homogeneous volumes than senior physicians, especially for 'difficult' cases.

CONCLUSIONS

Major discordances were observed between the radiation oncologists' and the radiologists' delineations, indicating that this step needs to be improved. A better training of radiation oncologists in thoracic imaging and collaboration between radiation oncologists and radiologists should decrease this variability. New imaging techniques (image fusion, positron emission tomography, magnetic resonance imaging spectroscopy, etc.) may also provide a useful contribution to this difficult delineation.

Computed tomographic-pathologic correlation of gross tumor volume and clinical target volume in non-small cell lung cancer: a pilot experience

CONTEXT

Computed tomographic (CT) scan data are used regularly in radiation treatment planning for patients with lung cancer. To our knowledge, the relationship of the CT images of tumors and their corresponding microscopic extent has not yet been studied in detail.

OBJECTIVE

To correlate tumor sizes on CT with tumor sizes measured microscopically (ie, the gross tumor volume [GTV]-clinical target volume margin) in non-small cell lung cancers.

DESIGN

Prospective pilot study.

SETTING

Single institution.

PATIENTS

Patients with operable non-small cell lung cancer were identified preoperatively.

INTERVENTIONS

Once the surgical specimen was available, it was oriented with the surgeon and the pathologist. Seven whole-mount, cross-sectional histologic glass slides were made from 5 tumors using formalin fixation and hematoxylin-eosin staining. The pathologist then outlined the cancer-containing area under the microscope (Micro-GTV) and the area of surrounding inflammatory response (Micro-GTV + inflammation). Preoperative CT scans were used for outlining tumor on the corresponding slice (CT-GTV).

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Correlation of the areas of Micro-GTV, Micro-GTV + inflammation, and CT-GTV was performed.

RESULTS

There was an obvious trend that the CT-GTV was bigger than the Micro-GTV, except in specimen 1, in which the 2 areas were about equal. However, on comparing the values for the CT-GTV and the Micro-GTV + inflammation, the difference between the 2 areas became smaller.

CONCLUSIONS

Modern CT scans might overestimate the GTV in non-small cell lung cancer. The GTV-clinical target volume margin could actually be zero or even a negative value. The findings in this small study are interesting and provoking. Further study with a larger number of patients and more rigid quality control is warranted to confirm our findings.

Computed tomography-guided frameless stereotactic radiotherapy for stage I non-small cell lung cancer: a 5-year experience

PURPOSE

Stereotactic radiotherapy (SRT) is highly effective for brain metastases from non-small-cell lung cancers (NSCLCs). As such, primary lesions of NSCLC may also be treated effectively by similar focal high-dose SRT.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Between October 1994 and June 1999, 50 patients with pathologically proven T1-2N0 M0 NSCLC were treated by CT-guided frameless SRT. Of these, 21 patients were medically inoperable and the remainder were medically operable but refused surgery. In most patients, SRT was 50-60 Gy in 5-10 fractions for 1-2 weeks. Eighteen patients also received conventional radiotherapy of 40-60 Gy in 20-33 fractions before SRT.

RESULTS

With a median follow-up period of 36 months (range 22-66), 30 patients were alive and disease free, 3 were alive with disease, 6 had died of disease, and 11 had died intercurrently. Local progression was not observed on follow-up CT scans in 47 (94%) of 50 patients. The 3-year overall survival rate was 66% in all 50 patients and 86% in the 29 medically operable patients. The 3-year cause-specific survival rate of all 50 patients was 88%. No definite adverse effects related to SRT were noted, except for 2 patients with a minor bone fracture and 6 patients with temporary pleural pain.

CONCLUSIONS

SRT is a very safe and effective treatment for Stage I NSCLC. Additional studies involving a larger patient population and longer follow-up periods are warranted to assess this new treatment for early-stage lung cancer.

Three-Dimensional Conformal Radiation Therapy (3D-CRT) for Early-Stage Non–Small-Cell Lung Cancer

The standard treatment for early-stage non-small-cell lung cancer is surgical resection. However, many patients are inoperable due to medical comorbidities. Thirty-two medically inoperable patients with early-stage non-small-cell lung cancer were treated with 3-dimensional conformal radiation therapy between January 1991 and December 2000. The median dose was 70.2 Gy, and the median follow-up time in survivors was 30 months. The 2-year actuarial local control, overall survival, and cancer-specific survival rates were 43%, 54%, and 57%, respectively. The 5-year actuarial local control, overall survival, and cancer-specific survival rates were 43%, 33%, and 39%, respectively. This report suggests that local control is improved with high-dose conformal radiation therapy when compared to other institutions' retrospective experiences.

Dose and fractionation concepts in the primary radiotherapy of non-small cell lung cancer

At present, radiotherapy alone or in combination with chemotherapy offers the only chance of cure of medically inoperable or locally advanced unresectable non-small cell lung cancer. The radiobiological basis and clinical results of current dose and fractionation concepts in the primary radiotherapy of NSCLC are briefly reviewed. Whenever possible, focus is given to the results of randomized phase III trials. With the exception of early disease treated to doses higher than 60 Gy, the prognosis of inoperable localized NSCLC is very poor. Local recurrence is the major cause of failure after radiation therapy calling for intensified local treatment. Dose-escalation using conventional fractionation or moderate hypofractionation is promising but randomized trials are presently not available. Dose-escalated hyperfractionation theoretically offers advantages, however, there appears currently no strong evidence from randomized trials supporting this approach in NSCLC. The highly accelerated CHART regimen significantly improved survival by 9% compared to standard radiotherapy. Nevertheless, even when treated with CHART, about 80% of all patients will eventually develop local recurrence and 60% distant metastases. Many trials on combined radiochemotherapy have used radiotherapy regimens that are not optimal from a current perspective. Because of the high rate of both, local recurrence and distant metastases, future research should be directed to further intensify radiotherapy as well as to integrate such protocols with systemic treatment in carefully selected patients. Since toxicity is expected to increase, state-of-the-art 3D conformal radiation techniques need to be part of clinical trials testing such strategies.

NONSURGICAL MANAGEMENT OF NON-SMALL-CELL LUNG CANCER

Aggressively applied radiotherapy can cure approximately 15% to 20% of medically inoperable patients. It is hoped that with more sophisticated treatment planning and more dose-intensive radiation, the results in these tumors can be improved. No good clinical evidence to date suggests that including areas of subclinical involvement will result in higher cure rates. In patients who have regionally advanced disease, combination therapy consisting of concurrent chemotherapy and irradiation seems to have yielded an improvement in short-term and median survival. Patients selected for this type of aggressive treatment must have a good performance status and should be less than 70 years of age. Refinements in chemotherapeutic agents, in the delivery of radiotherapy, and in the interdigitation of these modalities are areas of intense clinical research.

Evaluation of microscopic tumor extension in non-small-cell lung cancer for three-dimensional conformal radiotherapy planning

PURPOSE

One of the most difficult steps of the three-dimensional conformal radiotherapy (3DCRT) is to define the clinical target volume (CTV) according to the degree of local microscopic extension (ME). In this study, we tried to quantify this ME in non-small-cell lung cancer (NSCLC).

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Seventy NSCLC surgical resection specimens for which the border between tumor and adjacent lung parenchyma were examined on routine sections. This border was identified with the naked eye, outlined with a marker pen, and the value of the local ME outside of this border was measured with an eyepiece micrometer. The pattern of histologic spread was also determined.

RESULTS

A total of 354 slides were examined, corresponding to 176 slides for adenocarcinoma (ADC) and 178 slides for squamous cell carcinoma (SCC). The mean value of ME was 2.69 mm for ADC and 1.48 mm for SCC (p = 0.01). The usual 5-mm margin covers 80% of the ME for ADC and 91% for SCC. To take into account 95% of the ME, a margin of 8 mm and 6 mm must be chosen for ADC and SCC, respectively. Aerogenous dissemination was the most frequent pattern observed for all groups, followed by lymphatic invasion for ADC and interstitial extension for SCC.

CONCLUSION

The ME was different between ADC and SCC. The usual CTV margin of 5 mm appears inadequate to cover the ME for either group, and it must be increased to 8 mm and 6 mm for ADC and SCC, respectively, to cover 95% of the ME. This approach is obviously integrated into the overall 3DCRT procedure and with other margins.

The deep inspiration breath-hold technique in the treatment of inoperable non-small-cell lung cancer

PURPOSE

Conventional radiotherapeutic techniques are associated with lung toxicity that limits the treatment dose. Motion of the tumor during treatment requires the use of large safety margins that affect the feasibility of treatment. To address the control of tumor motion and decrease the volume of normal lung irradiated, we investigated the use of three-dimensional conformal radiation therapy (3D-CRT) in conjunction with the deep inspiration breath-hold (DIBH) technique.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

In the DIBH technique, the patient is initially maintained at quiet tidal breathing, followed by a deep inspiration, a deep expiration, a second deep inspiration, and breath-hold. At this point the patient is at approximately 100% vital capacity, and simulation, verification, and treatment take place during this phase of breath-holding.

RESULTS

Seven patients have received a total of 164 treatment sessions and have tolerated the technique well. The estimated normal tissue complication probabilities decreased in all patients at their prescribed dose when compared to free breathing. The dose to which patients could be treated with DIBH increased on average from 69.4 Gy to 87.9 Gy, without increasing the risk of toxicity.

CONCLUSIONS

The DIBH technique provides an advantage to conventional free-breathing treatment by decreasing lung density, reducing normal safety margins, and enabling more accurate treatment. These improvements contribute to the effective exclusion of normal lung tissue from the high-dose region and permit the use of higher treatment doses without increased risks of toxicity.

Limited field irradiation for medically inoperable patients with peripheral stage I non-small cell lung cancer

The outcome of limited field irradiation for medically inoperable patients with peripheral stage I non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) was analyzed to discuss the elective irradiation of regional lymph nodes. From 1976 through 1994, 36 patients with peripheral stage I NSCLC were treated with definitive radiation therapy (RT) alone at Gunma University hospital. The total dose ranged from 60 to 81 Gy with a 2 Gy-daily standard fractionation, although only one patient received 48 Gy. Ten patients received elective irradiation of the regional lymph nodes with a total dose of 40 Gy or more. The overall response rate was 97% with 31% complete responses. The overall survival rates at 3 and 5 years were 42 and 23%, and disease-specific survival rates were 56 and 39% at 3 and 5 years, respectively. In 26 patients without the elective regional irradiation, disease-specific survival rates at 3 and 5 years were 53 and 40%, respectively, whereas they were 64 and 39% in 10 patients with the regional nodal irradiation. The cumulative 5-year local progression rate was 28%, and the overall progression rate was 60% at 5 years. Four patients had a local recurrence as the only site of initial tumor progression. Combined local and regional progression was seen in two patients, and one patient had a local recurrence in combination with distant metastasis. Twelve patients had distant failure without evidence of local or regional progression. Only one patient without regional nodal irradiation developed an isolated regional failure. No patient had serious complications related to RT. High-dose limited field RT is justified for medically inoperable patients with peripheral stage I NSCLC. The regional nodal irradiation can be omitted in these pulmonary compromised patients because of the low regional relapse rate. Dose-escalation by a conformal RT with a small target volume can be expected to provide a better local control rate and better survival.

Radiotherapy for lung cancer: target splitting by asymmetric collimation enables reduction of radiation doses to normal tissues and dose escalation

PURPOSE

This study was performed to develop a method of reducing the radiation doses to normal thoracic tissues, increasing the target dose, especially in the primary radiotherapy of non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC), and to evaluate acute/subacute toxicity of dose escalation.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

From December 1195 to March 1998, the technique of target splitting has been applied to 58 patients. In this period, 30 patients were treated with doses > 80 Gy (ICRU-specification, mean 85.1 Gy, range 80. 1-90.2 Gy). The target volume is split into a cranial part (e.g., upper mediastinum) and a caudal part (e.g., primary tumor and middle mediastinum). Both volumes are planned and treated independently, using conformal irradiation techniques for both parts with half-collimated fields to prevent over- or underdosage in the junction plane. After fine-adjustment of the jaws, a verification film, exposed in a polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA) phantom, demonstrates the homogeneity of dose in the entire target volume. For comparison with conventional techniques, planning to identical doses is performed for 5 patients. Dose-volume histograms (DHVs) for normal lung tissue are presented for both methods.

RESULTS

The irradiated volume of normal tissue of the ipsilateral lung can be lowered at dose levels > or = 65, > or =45 Gy, and > or = 20 Gy to values of 37% (range 25-54%), 49% (range 46-54%), and 86% (range 55-117%), respectively. Other organs at risk, such as heart or esophagus, can also be spared significantly. Only 1 patient showed a transient grade 3 toxicity (pneumonitis), and there where no grade 4 acute/subacute side-effects. Two patients with Stage III A central tumors in close proximity to the large vessels died due to a pulmonary hemorrhage 2 and 4 months after therapy, respectively. No patient developed esophagitis. Antimycotic prophylaxis for esophagitis and posttherapeutic steroid prophylaxis for pneumonitis for several weeks were routinely used.

CONCLUSION

The technique of target splitting by asymmetric collimation helps to increase conformation, and thus enhances the sparing of normal tissues. It can be used whenever there is a marked difference in the shape of the planning target volume (PTV) in a cranio-caudal direction. This technique can principally be handled with 2D-planning systems, because it is coplanar. We consider target splitting as an important tool for dose escalation in the primary radiotherapy of NSCLC, that should also be used for other lung cancer patients necessitating moderate doses only.

High-dose radiation therapy alone for inoperable non-small cell lung cancer--experience with prolonged overall treatment times

The purpose of this study as to determine the impact of overall treatment time on long-term survival after high-dose radiation therapy alone for inoperable non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC). Between 1978 and 1990, 229 patients with stage I-III disease and Karnofsky Performance Scores of 80-100 received a conventionally fractionated total dose of 70 Gy through a split-course technique. After a first treatment course of 40 or 50 Gy, a restaging was performed and only patients without any contraindications, such as newly diagnosed distant metastases or serious deterioration of performance status, were given a second course. In 83% of patients this break lasted for 4-6 weeks. Overall treatment time ranged between 7 and 24 weeks (median 12 weeks). Median follow-up time was 6.6 years (range 4.0-9.3 years). Actuarial overall survival rates at 2 and 5 years were 28% and 7% respectively. Complete radiological tumor response was observed in 31% of patients, and was found to be the strongest positive predictor of survival with 2- and 5-year rates of 50% and 12% respectively compared with 17% and 4% for patients without complete response. Treatment duration was not found to be a significant prognostic factor in univariate or multivariate analysis. For overall treatment times of 7-11 weeks (n = 50), 12 weeks (n = 79) and > 12 weeks (n = 100), 5-year survival was 4%, 6%, and 8%, respectively (p = 0.6). To conclude, in our experience and in contrast to other studies, prolonged overall treatment times in radiation therapy alone for inoperable NSCLC had no negative impact on long-term survival. It is hypothesized that accelerated tumor cell repopulation is absent in a significant number of these patients with the time-factor playing no apparent role for outcome of treatment.

Focal, high dose, and fractionated modified stereotactic radiation therapy for lung carcinoma patients: a preliminary experience

BACKGROUND

Stereotactic radiation therapy is highly effective in the treatment of small brain metastases, regardless of the histology. This suggests that small extracranial malignancies may be curable with similar radiation therapy. The authors developed a novel treatment unit for administering such therapy.

METHODS

The unit consisted of a linear accelerator (linac), an X-ray simulator (X-S), computed tomography (CT), and a table. The gantry axes of the three machines were coaxial and could be matched by rotating the table. Patients were instructed to perform shallow respiration with oxygen. The motion of the tumor was monitored with the X-S. When the motion was slight enough, the table was rotated to the CT. To include all geometric movement on the CT images, each scan was made while the patient was performing shallow respiration. After the CT positioning, the table was rotated to the linac, and non-coplanar treatment was given. Beginning in October 1994, 45 patients with 23 primary or 43 metastatic lung carcinomas were treated. Radiation doses at the 80% isodose line were 30-75 gray in 5-15 fractions over 1-3 weeks with or without conventional radiation therapy.

RESULTS

The treatment was performed with no or minimal adverse acute symptoms. The daily treatment time was short. During a median follow-up of 11 months, local progression occurred in 2 of 66 lesions. Interstitial changes in the lung were limited.

CONCLUSIONS

With this unit and procedure, focal radiation therapy similar to stereotactic radiation therapy is possible for extracranial sites. The preliminary experience appeared safe and promising, and further exploration of this approach is warranted.