Combined modality treatment for poor prognosis stages I and II Hodgkin's disease

Long-term Events in Adult Patients with Clinical Stage IA-IIA Nonbulky Hodgkin's Lymphoma Treated with Four Cycles of Doxorubicin, Bleomycin, Vinblastine, and Dacarbazine and Adjuvant Radiotherapy: A Single-Institution 15-Year Follow-up

PURPOSE

To report on long-term events after short doxorubicin, bleomycin, vinblastine, and dacarbazine (ABVD) chemotherapy and adjuvant radiotherapy in favorable early-stage Hodgkin's lymphoma.

EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN

We monitored late events and causes of death over 15 years (median follow-up, 120 months) in 120 patients with nonbulky stage IA-IIA Hodgkin's lymphoma, treated with four cycles of ABVD and limited radiotherapy. Pulmonary and cardiac function tests were done throughout the follow-up. Outcome measures included cause-specific mortality, standardized mortality ratio, and standardized incidence ratio for secondary neoplasia.

RESULTS

Projected 15-year event-free and overall survival were 78% and 86%, and tumor mortality was 3%. Standardized mortality ratio was significantly higher than 1 for both males (2.8; P=0.029) and females (9.4; P=0.003). The risk of cardiovascular events at 5 and 12 years was 5.5% and 14%, with a median latent time of 67 months (range: 23-179 months) from the end of radiotherapy. Pulmonary toxicity developed in 8% of patients; all had received mediastinal irradiation and the median time from radiotherapy to pulmonary sequelae was 76 weeks (range: 50-123 weeks). The risk of secondary neoplasia at 5 and 12 years was 4% and 8%, respectively, with no cases of leukemia. Fertility was preserved.

CONCLUSIONS

Long-term events were mostly related to radiotherapy; the role of short ABVD chemotherapy was very limited, as documented by fertility preservation and lack of secondary myelodysplasia/leukemia. A proportion of patients died from causes unrelated to disease progression and the excess mortality risk was mostly due to the occurrence of secondary neoplasms and cardiovascular diseases. A moderate dose reduction of radiotherapy from 40-44 Gy to 30-36 Gy did not decrease the risk of late complications; abolishing radiotherapy in nonbulky early-stage Hodgkin's lymphoma is being evaluated.

A population-based cohort study on early-stage Hodgkin lymphoma treated with radiotherapy alone: with special reference to older patients

BACKGROUND

Combined modality treatment has reduced the risk of relapse among younger early-stage Hodgkin lymphoma (HL) patients. Older HL patients may not tolerate chemotherapy and their prognosis is less favorable. We conducted a population-based study to evaluate long-term follow-up outcome in older early-stage HL patients initially treated with radiotherapy (RT) alone.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

We included 308 consecutive patients (22% were >or=60 years) diagnosed 1972-1999 (median follow-up 20 years; range 1-28). Using Cox regression models we defined risk of relapse and survival in relation to clinical factors.

RESULTS

272/308 (88%) patients obtained complete remission following first-line RT alone. Among these, 42% relapsed within a median of 21 months. The relapse rate was independent of gender and age at diagnosis (median age 32 years, range 14-85); however, lymphocyte-predominant HL was associated with borderline (P=0.049) 56% decreased risk of relapse. Among patients<60 years and >or=60 years, we observed 29 (median latency 10 years, range 2-25) and 11 (median latency 3 years, range 1-10) second tumors, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Older age (>or=60 years) was not associated with an increased risk of relapse following RT alone. Given the risks of iatrogenic morbidity/mortality of chemotherapy in older patients, RT alone could be an alternative first-line therapy in early-stage older HL patients.

ABVD Plus Subtotal Nodal Versus Involved-Field Radiotherapy in Early-Stage Hodgkin's Disease: Long-Term Results

Purpose

Radiation therapy (RT) alone can cure more than 80% of all patients with pathologic stage IA, IB, and IIA Hodgkin's disease, but some prognostic factors unfavorably affect treatment outcome. Combined-modality approaches improved results compared with RT, but the optimal extent of RT fields when combined with chemotherapy warranted additional evaluation.

Patients and Methods

In February 1990, we activated a prospective trial in patients with early, clinically staged Hodgkin's disease to assess efficacy and tolerability of four cycles of doxorubicin, bleomycin, vinblastine, and dacarbazine (ABVD) followed by either subtotal nodal plus spleen irradiation (STNI) or involved-field radiotherapy (IFRT).

Results

Main patient characteristics were fairly well balanced between the two arms. Complete remission was achieved in 100% and in 97% of patients, respectively. The 12-year freedom from progression rates were 93% (95% CI, 83% to 100%) after ABVD and STNI, and 94% (95% CI, 88% to 100%) after ABVD and IFRT, whereas the figures for overall survival were 96% (95% CI, 91% to 100%) and 94% (95% CI, 89% to 100%), respectively. Apart from three patients who developed second malignancies in the STNI arm, treatment-related morbidities were mild.

Conclusion

Present long-term findings suggest that, after four cycles of ABVD, IFRT can achieve a worthwhile outcome. The limited size of our patient sample, however, had no adequate statistical power to test for noninferiority of IFRT versus STNI. Despite this, ABVD followed by IFRT can be considered an effective and safe modality in early Hodgkin's disease with both favorable and unfavorable presentation.

Current treatment strategies in early stage Hodgkin's disease

Treatment of Hodgkin's disease (HD) is strictly dependent on stage. Historically, early stage HD included the limited stages I, II, and IIIA (according to the Cotsworth modification of the Ann Arbor classification), whereas advanced HD included stage III with B symptoms and stage IV. It was observed that early stage HD with certain clinical risk factors had a significantly worse outcome. As a consequence, several studies defined these patients as suffering from early stage unfavorable (or intermediate stage) HD, demanding a more aggressive treatment.

Analysis of in-field control and late toxicity for adults with early-stage Hodgkin's disease treated with chemotherapy followed by radiotherapy

PURPOSE

We analyzed in-field (IF) control in adults with early-stage Hodgkin's disease who received chemotherapy followed by radiotherapy (RT) in terms of the (1) chemotherapeutic regimen used and number of cycles delivered, (2) response to chemotherapy, and (3) initial tumor size. Cardiac toxicity and second malignancies, particularly the incidence of solid tumors in terms of the RT field size treated, were also examined.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

From 1980 to 1995, 286 patients ranging in age from 16 to 88 years (median: 28 years) with Ann Arbor clinical Stage I or II Hodgkin's disease underwent chemotherapy followed 3 to 4 weeks later by RT. There were 516 nodal sites measuring 0.5 to 19.0 cm at the start of chemotherapy, including 134 cases of bulky mediastinal disease. NOVP, MOPP, ABVD, CVPP/ABDIC, and other chemotherapeutic regimens were given to 161, 67, 19, 18, and 21 patients, respectively. Patients received 1-8 (median: 3) cycles of induction chemotherapy. All 533 gross nodal and extranodal sites of disease were included in the RT fields. The median prescribed RT dose for gross disease was 40.0 Gy given in 20 daily 2.0-Gy fractions. There was little variation in the RT dose. Eighty-five patients were treated with involved-field or regional RT (to one side of the diaphragm), and 201 patients were treated with extended-field RT (to both sides of the diaphragm), based on the protocol on which they were enrolled.

RESULTS

Follow-up of surviving patients ranged from 1.3 to 19.9 years (median: 7.4 years). Based on a review of simulation films, there were 16 IF, 8 marginal, and 15 out-of-field recurrences. The chemotherapeutic regimen used and the number of cycles of chemotherapy delivered did not significantly affect IF control. IF control also did not significantly depend on the response to induction chemotherapy. In cases where there was a confirmed or unconfirmed complete response as opposed to a partial response or stable disease in response to induction chemotherapy for bulky nodal disease, the 5-year IF control rates were 99% and 92%, respectively (p = 0.0006). The 15-year actuarial risks of coronary artery disease requiring surgical intervention and of solid tumors were 4.1% and 16.8%, respectively. There was a trend toward a greater risk of solid tumors in patients who received extended-field RT rather than involved-field or regional RT (p = 0.08).

CONCLUSIONS

In patients with nonbulky disease, induction chemotherapy followed by RT to a median dose of 40.0 Gy resulted in excellent IF control, regardless of the chemotherapeutic regimen used, the fact that only 1-2 cycles of chemotherapy were delivered, and the response to chemotherapy. There was a trend toward a higher incidence of solid tumors in patients who received consolidation RT to both sides rather than only one side of the diaphragm. Ongoing Phase III trials will help clarify whether lower RT doses and smaller RT fields after chemotherapy can maintain the IF control seen in our study, but with a lower incidence of late complications in patients with Stage I or II Hodgkin's disease.

Rapidly alternating COPP/ABV/IMEP is not superior to conventional alternating COPP/ABVD in combination with extended-field radiotherapy in intermediate-stage Hodgkin's lymphoma: final results of the German Hodgkin's Lymphoma Study Group Trial HD5

PURPOSE

To investigate whether treatment results in intermediate-stage Hodgkin's lymphoma can be improved by rapid application of non-cross-resistant drugs, the 10-drug regimen cyclophosphamide, vincristine, procarbazine, and prednisone (COPP), doxorubicin, bleomycin, and vinblastine (ABV), and ifosfamide, methotrexate, etoposide, and prednisone (IMEP), repeated every 6 weeks, was compared with conventional alternating COPP/doxorubicin, bleomycin, vinblastine, and dacarbazine (ABVD) administered every 8 weeks.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

From January 1988 to January 1993, 996 patients in stage I or II Hodgkin's lymphoma with at least one risk factor (massive mediastinal tumor, massive spleen involvement, extranodal disease, elevated ESR, or more than two lymph node areas involved) and all patients in stage IIIA Hodgkin's lymphoma were randomized to receive two cycles of COPP/ABVD or COPP/ABV/IMEP followed by extended-field radiotherapy.

RESULTS

Both regimens produced similar rates for treatment responses (complete remission, 93% v 94%), freedom from treatment failure (80% v 79%), and overall survival (88% for both regimens) at a median follow-up time of 7 years. Most serious toxicities during chemotherapy were similar in both regimens. However, World Health Organization grade 3 and 4 leukocytopenia occurred significantly more frequently in the COPP/ABV/IMEP arm (53% v 44% of patients; P =.010). There were no differences in the number of serious infections and toxic deaths during therapy. The number of second malignancies was also the same in both arms (22 each).

CONCLUSION

Alternating COPP/ABVD and rapid alternating COPP/ABV/IMEP in combination with extended-field radiotherapy are equally effective in intermediate-stage Hodgkin's lymphoma and produce excellent long-term treatment results.

[Hodgkin's disease: from gross tumor volume to clinical target volume, firm data and unresolved problems]

The purpose of this article is to specify the target volumes, using ICRU criteria in the treatment of Hodgkin's disease. Because of the complexity of irradiation fields, the literature was carefully reviewed. However, with the variations of the recommendations and in the absence of large-scale studies, usual criteria can still be used. A consensus about the precise specification of the target volumes on CAT scan is still urgently awaited.

Early-stage Hodgkin's disease

Treatment of Hodgkin's disease (HD) is strictly dependent on stage. Historically, early-stage HD included the limited stages I, II, and IIIA (according to the Cotswolds modification of the Ann Arbor classsification), whereas advanced HD included stage III with B symptoms and stage IV. It was then observed that early-stage HD with certain clinical risk factors had a significantly worse outcome. As a consequence, several studies defined these patients as suffering from early-stage unfavorable (or intermediate-stage) HD, demanding a more aggressive treatment. The treatment of early-stage HD is changing strikingly. Until recently, extended-field (EF) irradiation has been considered the standard treatment. However, because of the recognition of its high relapse rate and fatal long-term effects, EF radiotherapy is now being abandoned by most study groups. Instead, for favorable early-stage HD, mild chemotherapy for control of occult disease is combined with involved-field (IF) irradiation. In early-stage unfavorable (intermediate) HD, four cycles of chemotherapy plus IF irradiation is accepted as standard treatment.

Radiation dose selection in Hodgkin's disease patients with large mediastinal adenopathy treated with combined modality therapy

PURPOSE

To determine the effective dose of consolidation radiation in Hodgkin's disease (HD) patients with large mediastinal adenopathy (LMA) treated with combined modality therapy (CMT).

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Eighty-three HD patients with LMA receiving CMT between 1983 and 1997 at Duke University and Yale University were identified. Patients underwent complete clinical staging. The staging breakdown was: IA, 4 patients; IB, 1 patient; IIA, 25 patients; IIB, 33 patients; IIIA, 3 patients; IIIB-6 patients; IVA, 2 patients; and IVB, 9 patients. All patients received induction chemotherapy (CT) as follows: MOPP/ABV(D), 31 patients; BCVPP, 15 patients; ABVD, 24 patients; MOPP, 3 patients; and other regimens, 10 patients. Following 6 cycles of CT, patients were restaged and classified as having either complete response (CR) or induction failure (IF). Post-CT gallium scans were obtained in 52 patients. Patients with residual radiographic abnormalities were classified as having CR if they were gallium-negative and clinically well otherwise. Following induction CT, 78 patients had a CR. There were 5 IFs. Consolidation irradiation was administered to all sites of initial involvement in patients who had achieved CR. RT dose varied. Patients were grouped into the following dose ranges: < or = 20 Gy, 12 patients; 20-25 Gy, 24 patients; 25-30 Gy, 30 patients; > or = 30 Gy, 12 patients.

RESULTS

Overall survival and failure-free survival were both 76% at 10 years. Of the 78 CR patients, 15 failed. Patterns of failure were in-field alone, 8 patients; out of field alone, 2 patients; and combined, 5 patients. Failure patterns by RT dose were: < or = 20 Gy, 0/12; 20-25 Gy, 7/24; 25-30 Gy, 5/30; > or = 30 Gy, 3/11. There was no apparent correlation between RT dose and subsequent failure. Post chemotherapy gallium scans were helpful in predicting for failure. Of 48 patients in whom the gallium was negative after chemotherapy, there were 6 failures, compared with 9 failures among 30 patients in whom gallium was not done after chemotherapy (p = 0.066). Additionally, patients receiving adriamycin-based chemotherapy regimens had improved outcomes compared to those not receiving adriamycin (p = 0.03.)

CONCLUSIONS

These retrospective data suggest that low-dose radiotherapy following CR achieved with induction chemotherapy (particularly when documented with gallium scanning) may be as effective as higher doses for bulky HD at presentation. Phase III trials are necessary for confirmation of this hypothesis.

[the role of radiotherapy for limited stage Hodgkin's disease in 1999: limitations and perspectives]

The role of radiotherapy in limited stage Hodgkin's disease (HD) has been gradually changing in the past few decades, resulting in the almost complete disappearance of exclusive irradiation treatment. In reality, exclusive radiotherapy yielded satisfactory results in terms of long-term survival, but in 1999 it was becoming impossible not to take into account the late mortality rates observed in all large cohorts of HD patients. This increased mortality rate has been shown to be related to 1) cardiac toxicity of irradiation, and 2) secondary radiation-induced solid tumors. Thus, the search for efficient but less toxic new strategies can no longer be avoided. For clinically staged, limited HD, precisely defined according to specific prognostic factors, the association of chemotherapy and radiotherapy appears more and more as a standard, and with this therapeutic burden comes parallel efforts for its alleviation. The Previous Radiotherapy experience has shown that, after a chemotherapy-induced complete remission, irradiation of only the initially involved areas was enough. Ongoing trials are now exploring the possibility of a dose de-escalation, from the conventional 36 Gy to 20 Gy (as for children HD), and to maybe 0 Gy (no radiotherapy at all). In parallel, deescalation in the number of chemotherapy cycles is also being investigated. For unfavorable cases, the problem is slightly different, as a higher percentage of cases still appears to be refractory to treatment in this subgroup. Thus, while chemo-radiotherapy has clearly became the standard strategy, efforts are essentially being devoted to identify new--and hopefully more efficient--chemotherapy schemes. In Europe, most of these pending questions will be addressed in the recently initiated trials of the EORTC/GELA and of the GHSG (German Hodgkin Study Group), with the aim of offering to patients treatment which could be at least as efficient as the present schedules, and less toxic in the long term.

The role of radiotherapy for early stage Hodgkin's disease: limitations and perspectives

For limited stage Hodgkin's disease (HD), the role of radiotherapy has been changing during the last decades, the main point being the (almost) complete disappearance of irradiation used alone. Actually, exclusive radiotherapy yielded satisfactory results in terms of long-term survival, but in 1998, it was becoming impossible not to take into account the late overmortality observed in all large cohorts of HD patients. This overmortality has been shown to be related (1) to cardiac toxicity of irradiation and (2) to secondary radiation-induced solid tumors. So the search for new strategies, as efficient, but less toxic, could not be avoided any more. For surgically staged patients (pathological stages I and II), irradiation alone (i.e., mantle field radiotherapy) can still be proposed to patients without unfavourable prognostic factors after a negative surgical infra-diaphragmatic exploration. For clinically staged patients with limited disease and favourable prognostic indicators, the association of chemotherapy and radiotherapy appears more and more as a standard. In parallel, efforts are being made to alleviate the therapeutic burden. For radiotherapy, previous experience showed that, after a chemotherapy-induced complete remission, irradiation of the initially involved areas only was enough treatment. Ongoing trials are now exploring the possibility of a dose desescalation from the conventional 36 Gy to 20 Gy (as for children HD), and maybe to ... 0 Gy (no radiotherapy at all). Desescalation in the number of chemotherapy cycles is also being investigated. For clinically staged patients with unfavourable prognostic indicators, a higher percentage of cases still appears to be refractory to treatment. So, while chemo-radiotherapy clearly became the standard strategy, efforts are essentially being devoted to identify new--and hopefully more efficient--chemotherapy schemes. In parallel, irradiation dose desescalation is being investigated. Most of these pending questions are addressed in a number of ongoing trials, as well in the US as in Europe, with the aim of offering to patients treatments at least as efficient as the presently used schedules, and less toxic in the long term.

Treatment of relapsed Hodgkin's disease: strategies and prognostic factors

The major points in salvage therapy of patients in relapse following combination chemotherapy for advanced disease are: (1) success of any second-line approach is determined by prognostic factors which include age, duration of the initial remission, and quantity of disease at relapse; (2) induction failures (progression without remission or incomplete remission and short initial remission) require innovative therapy which currently entails high-dose chemotherapy with peripheral or bone marrow autologous support; (3) late relapse still retains an order to sensitivity to chemotherapy and can be treated with conventional dose combination with complementary radiation therapy to previously unirradiated bulky sites. The choice of regimen is empiric and can include a repeat of the regimen used for the original remission or induction. The relative advantage of HDC in this favorable group is uncertain.