Biochemistry of bacterial type I DNA topoisomerases

PPEF: A bisbenzimdazole potent antimicrobial agent interacts at acidic triad of catalytic domain of E. coli topoisomerase IA

BACKGROUND

Topoisomerase is a well known target to develop effective antibacterial agents. In pursuance of searching novel antibacterial agents, we have established a novel bisbenzimidazole (PPEF) as potent E. coli topoisomerase IA poison inhibitor.

METHODS

In order to gain insights into the mechanism of action of PPEF and understanding protein-ligand interactions, we have produced wild type EcTopo 67 N-terminal domain (catalytic domain) and its six mutant proteins at acidic triad (D111, D113, E115). The DDE motif is replaced by alanine (A) to create three single mutants: D111A, D113A, E115A and three double mutants: D111A-D113A, D113A-E115A and D111A-E115A.

RESULTS

Calorimetric study of PPEF with single mutants showed 10 fold lower affinity than that of wild type EcTopo 67 (7.32 × 10⁶ M^-1for wild type, 0.89 × 10⁶ M^-1for D111A) and 100 fold lower binding with double mutant D113A-E115A (0.02 × 10⁶ M^-1) was observed. The mutated proteins showed different CD signature as compared to wild type protein. CD and fluorescence titrations were done to study the interaction between EcTopo 67 and ligands. Molecular docking study validated that PPEF has decreased binding affinity towards mutated enzymes as compared to wild type.

CONCLUSION

The overall study reveals that PPEF binds to D113 and E115 of acidic triad of EcTopo 67. Point mutations decrease binding affinity of PPEF towards DDE motif of topoisomerase.

GENERAL SIGNIFICANCE

This study concludes PPEF as poison inhibitor of E. coli Topoisomerase IA, which binds to acidic triad of topoisomerase IA, responsible for its function. PPEF can be considered as therapeutic agent against bacteria.

Direct observation of topoisomerase IA gate dynamics

Type IA topoisomerases cleave single-stranded DNA and relieve negative supercoils in discrete steps corresponding to the passage of the intact DNA strand through the cleaved strand. Although type IA topoisomerases are assumed to accomplish this strand passage via a protein-mediated DNA gate, opening of this gate has never been observed. We developed a single-molecule assay to directly measure gate opening of the Escherichia coli type IA topoisomerases I and III. We found that after cleavage of single-stranded DNA, the protein gate opens by as much as 6.6 nm and can close against forces in excess of 16 pN. Key differences in the cleavage, ligation, and gate dynamics of these two enzymes provide insights into their different cellular functions. The single-molecule results are broadly consistent with conformational changes obtained from molecular dynamics simulations. These results allowed us to develop a mechanistic model of interactions between type IA topoisomerases and single-stranded DNA.

Kinetic insights into the temperature dependence of DNA strand cleavage and religation by topoisomerase III from the hyperthermophile Sulfolobus solfataricus

All cellular organisms encode type IA topoisomerases which catalyze DNA topological changes essential for DNA transactions. However, the kinetics of the reaction catalyzed by these enzymes remains poorly characterized. Here we measured the rapid kinetics of template binding, cleavage and religation by Sso topo III, a type IA topoisomerase from the hyperthermophilic archaeon Sulfolobus solfataricus, by using a novel FRET/PIFE-based method in a stopped-flow spectrometer. We show that Sso topo III bound the template rapidly, and the rate of binding was 2–3 orders of magnitudes higher than that of template cleavage at 25 °C. The rate of template cleavage was favored over that of template religation by the enzyme, and was more so at lower temperatures (25–55 °C). Significant template cleavage [(2.23 ± 0.11) × 10⁻³ s⁻¹] was observed while little religation was detectable at 25 °C. This is consistent with the presence of a higher activation energy for template religation (41 ± 5 kcal·mol⁻¹) than that for template cleavage (32 ± 1 kcal·mol⁻¹). Our results provide a kinetic interpretation for the ability of Sso topo III to relax negatively supercoiled DNA only at higher temperature and offer clues to the adaptation of the reaction mechanisms of thermophilic enzymes to high temperature.

The interplay between DNA topology and accessory factors in site-specific recombination in bacteria and their bacteriophages

Site-specific recombination is employed widely in bacteria and bacteriophage as a basis for genetic switching events that control phenotypic variation. It plays a vital role in the life cycles of phages and in the replication cycles of chromosomes and plasmids in bacteria. Site-specific recombinases drive these processes using very short segments of identical (or nearly identical) DNA sequences. In some cases, the efficiencies of the recombination reactions are modulated by the topological state of the participating DNA sequences and by the availability of accessory proteins that shape the DNA. These dependencies link the molecular machines that conduct the recombination reactions to the physiological state of the cell. This is because the topological state of bacterial DNA varies constantly during the growth cycle and so does the availability of the accessory factors. In addition, some accessory factors are under allosteric control by metabolic products or second messengers that report the physiological status of the cell. The interplay between DNA topology, accessory factors and site-specific recombination provides a powerful illustration of the connectedness and integration of molecular events in bacterial cells and in viruses that parasitise bacterial cells.

High Throughput Screen for Inhibitors of Bacterial DNA Topoisomerase I Using the Scintillation Proximity Assay

We report the development of a rapid method to detect binding of supercoiled DNA to Escherichia coli topoisomerase I using the scintillation proximity assay (SPA). Streptavidin-SPA beads were coated with biotinylated topoisomerase I produced in vivo as a chimeric fusion protein. The hybrid biotinyl-fusion protein was overproduced in E. coli and purified in a single step by monomeric avidin affinity chromatography. The assay signal originates from both covalent and noncovalent binding of [3H]DNA to the SPA bead-immobilized enzyme. About 20-30% of the total [3H]DNA bound to the bead-immobilized enzyme remains associated with the bead in the presence of 0.5% SDS. The residual signal arises from the trapping of covalent [3H]DNA-enzyme complexes. The assay was employed in a high throughput screen that identified two general classes of topoisomerase inhibitors: agents that (1) inhibit DNA binding or (2) stabilize a covalent enzyme-DNA intermediate.

Design and synthesis of heterobimetallic topoisomerase I and II inhibitor complexes: in vitro DNA binding, interaction with 5'-GMP and 5'-TMP and cleavage studies

New potential cancer chemotherapeutic complexes Cu-Sn(2)/Zn-Sn(2) 3 and 4 were designed and prepared as topoisomerases inhibitors; their in vitro DNA binding studies were carried out which reveal strong electrostatic binding via phosphate backbone of DNA helix, in addition to other binding modes viz. coordinate covalent and partial intercalation. To throw insight to molecular binding event at the target site, UV-vis titrations of 3 and 4 with mononucleotides of interest, viz, 5'-GMP and 5'-TMP were carried out, (in case of 4) by (1)H and (31)P NMR. Cleavage studies employing gel electrophoresis demonstrate both the complexes 3 and 4 are efficient cleavage agents and are specific groove binders (complex 3 binds to both major and minor groove while complex 4 is specifically minor groove binder only). In addition, the complexes show high inhibition activity against topoisomerase I and II. However, complex 4 exhibits significant inhibitory effects on the Topo I activity at a very low concentration approximately 2.5 microM.

The role of the Zn(II) binding domain in the mechanism of E. coli DNA topoisomerase I

BACKGROUND

Escherichia coli DNA topoisomerase I binds three Zn(II) with three tetracysteine motifs which, together with the 14 kDa C-terminal region, form a 30 kDa DNA binding domain (ZD domain). The 67 kDa N-terminal domain (Top67) has the active site tyrosine for DNA cleavage but cannot relax negatively supercoiled DNA. We analyzed the role of the ZD domain in the enzyme mechanism.

RESULTS

Addition of purified ZD domain to Top67 partially restored the relaxation activity, demonstrating that covalent linkage between the two domains is not necessary for removal of negative supercoils from DNA. The two domains had similar affinities to ssDNA. However, only Top67 could bind dsDNA with high affinity. DNA cleavage assays showed that the Top67 had the same sequence and structure selectivity for DNA cleavage as the intact enzyme. DNA rejoining also did not require the presence of the ZD domain.

CONCLUSIONS

We propose that during relaxation of negatively supercoiled DNA, Top67 by itself can position the active site tyrosine near the junction of double-stranded and single-stranded DNA for cleavage. However, the interaction of the ZD domain with the passing single-strand of DNA, coupled with enzyme conformational change, is needed for removal of negative supercoils.

Biochemical characterization of an invariant histidine involved in Escherichia coli DNA topoisomerase I catalysis

An invariant histidine residue, His-365 in Escherichia coli DNA topoisomerase I, is located at the active site of type IA DNA topoisomerases and near the active site tyrosine. Its ability to participate in the multistep catalytic process of DNA relaxation was investigated. His-365 was mutated to alanine, arginine, asparagine, aspartate, glutamate, and glutamine to study its ability to participate in general acid/base catalysis and bind DNA. The mutants were examined for pH-dependent DNA relaxation and cleavage, salt-dependent DNA relaxation, and salt-dependent DNA binding affinity. The mutants relax DNA in a pH-dependent manner and at low salt concentrations. The pH dependence of all mutants is different from the wild type, suggesting that His-365 is responsible for the pH dependence of the enzyme. Additionally, whereas the wild type enzyme shows pH-dependent oligonucleotide cleavage, cleavage by both H365Q and H365A is pH-independent. H365Q cleaves DNA with rates similar to the wild type enzyme, whereas H365A has a slower rate of DNA cleavage than the wild type but can cleave more substrate overall. H365A also has a lower DNA binding affinity than the wild type enzyme. The binding affinity was determined at different salt concentrations, showing that the alanine mutant displaces half a charge less upon binding DNA than an inactive form of topoisomerase I. These observations indicate that His-365 participates in DNA binding and is responsible for optimal catalysis at physiological pH.

Effect of phosphorothioate substitutions on DNA cleavage by Escherichia coli DNA topoisomerase I

To evaluate the structural influence of the DNA phosphate backbone on the activity of Escherichia coli DNA topoisomerase I, modified forms of oligonucleotide dA(7) were synthesized with a chiral phosphorothioate replacing the non-bridging oxygens at each position along the backbone. A deoxy-iodo-uracil replaced the 5'-base to crosslink the oligonucleotides by ultraviolet (UV) and assess binding affinity. At the scissile phosphate there was little effect on the cleavage rate. At the +1 phosphate, the rectus phosphorus (Rp)-thio-substitution reduced the rate of cleavage by a factor of 10. At the +3 and -2 positions from the scissile bond, the Rp-isomer was cleaved at a faster rate than the sinister phosphorus (Sp)-isomer. The results demonstrate the importance of backbone contacts between DNA substrate and E. coli topoisomerase I.

C-terminal domains of Escherichia coli topoisomerase I belong to the zinc-ribbon superfamily

Detection of remote evolutionary connections is increasingly difficult with sequence and structural divergence. A combination of sequence and structural analysis, in which statistically supported sequence similarity had a crucial impact, revealed that Escherichia coli topoisomerase I C-terminal fragment is evolutionarily related to the three tetracysteine zinc-binding domains of the enzyme. Spatial structure analysis of this C-terminal fragment indicates that it consists of two structurally similar domains and suggests homology between them. Sequence similarity between the zinc-binding domains of type Ia topoisomerases and transcription regulators of known spatial structure helps to conclude that E. coli topo I contains five copies of a zinc ribbon domain at the C terminus. Two of these domains, corresponding to the C-terminal fragment, lost their cysteine residues and are probably not able to bind zinc. Present analyses lead to the classification of the C-terminal fragment of E. coli topoisomerase I as a member of zinc ribbon superfamily, despite the absence of zinc-binding sites.

Step-wise DNA relaxation and decatenation by NaeI-43K

Nae I protein was originally isolated for its restriction endonuclease properties. Nae I was later discovered to either relax or cleave supercoiled DNA, depending upon whether Nae I position 43 contains a lysine (43K) or leucine (43L) respectively. Nae I-43K DNA relaxation activity appears to be the product of coupling separate endonuclease and ligase domains within the same polypeptide. Whereas Nae I relaxes supercoiled DNA like a topoisomerase, even forming a transient covalent intermediate with the substrate DNA, Nae I shows no obvious sequence similarity to the topoisomerases. To further characterize the topoisomerase activity of Nae I, we report here that Nae I-43K changes the linking number of a single negatively supercoiled topoisomer of pBR322 by units of one and therefore is a type I topoisomerase. Positively supercoiled pBR322 was resistant to Nae I-43K. At low salt concentration Nae I-43K was processive; non-saturating amounts of enzyme relaxed a fraction of the DNA. At high salt concentration the same non-saturating amounts of Nae I-43K partially relaxed all the DNA in a step-wise fashion to give a Gaussian distribution of topoisomers, demonstrating a switch from a processive to a distributive mode of action. Nae I-43K decatenated kinetoplast DNA containing nicked circles, implying that Nae I-43K can cleave opposite a nick. The products of the reaction are decatenated nicked circles under both processive and distributive conditions. The behavior of Nae I-43K is consistent with that of a prokaryotic type I topoisomerase.

Identification of active site residues in Escherichia coli DNA topoisomerase I

Alanine substitution mutagenesis of Escherichia coli DNA topoisomerase I, a member of the type IA subfamily of DNA topoisomerases, was carried out to identify amino acid side chains that are involved in transesterification between DNA and the active site tyrosine Tyr-319 of the enzyme. Twelve polar residues that are highly conserved among the type IA enzymes, Glu-9, His-33, Asp-111, Glu-115, Gln-309, Glu-313, Thr-318, Arg-321, Thr-322, Asp-323, His-365, and Thr-496, were selected for alanine substitution. Each of the mutant enzymes was overexpressed, purified, and characterized. Surprisingly, only substitution at Glu-9 and Arg-321 was found to reduce the DNA relaxation activity of the enzyme to an insignificant level. The R321A mutant enzyme, but not the E9A mutant enzyme, was found to retain a reduced level of DNA cleavage activity. Two additional mutant enzymes R321K and E9Q were also constructed and purified. Replacing Arg-321 by lysine has little effect on enzymatic activities; replacing Glu-9 by glutamine greatly reduces the supercoil removal activity but not the DNA cleavage and rejoining activities. From these results and the locations of the amino acids in the crystal structure of the enzyme, it appears that Glu-9 has a critical role in DNA breakage and rejoining, probably through its interaction with the 3' deoxyribosyl oxygen. The positively charged Arg-321 may also participate in these reactions by interacting with the scissile DNA phosphate as a monodentate. Because of the strict conservation of these residues, the findings for the E. coli enzyme are likely to apply to all type IA DNA topoisomerases.

Effect of Mg(II) binding on the structure and activity of Escherichia coli DNA topoisomerase I

Escherichia coli DNA topoisomerase I requires Mg(II) as a cofactor for the relaxation of negatively supercoiled DNA. Mg(II) binding to the enzyme was shown by fluorescence spectroscopy to affect the tertiary structure of the enzyme. Addition of 2 mM MgCl2 resulted in a 30% decrease in the maximum emission of tryptophan fluorescence of the enzyme. These Mg(II)-induced changes in fluorescence properties were reversible by the addition of EDTA and not obtained with other divalent cations. After incubation with Mg(II) and dialysis, inductively coupled plasma (ICP) analysis showed that each enzyme molecule could form a complex with 1-2 Mg(II) bound to each enzyme molecule. Such Mg(II).enzyme complexes were found to be active in the relaxation of negatively supercoiled DNA in the absence of additional Mg(II). Results from ICP analysis after equilibrium dialysis and relaxation assays with limiting Mg(II) concentrations indicated that both Mg(II) binding sites had to be occupied for the enzyme to catalyze relaxation of negatively supercoiled DNA.

Contrasting enzymatic activities of topoisomerase IV and DNA gyrase from Escherichia coli

DNA gyrase and topoisomerase IV (Topo IV) have distinct roles as unlinking enzymes during DNA replication despite 40% sequence identity between them. DNA gyrase unlinks replicating DNA by introducing negative supercoils while Topo IV decatenates the two daughter molecules. For this study, we measured the rates of unlinking of various topoisomers of DNA by DNA gyrase and Topo IV. Each enzyme has marked preferences for certain strand-passage reactions. DNA gyrase is a relatively poor decatenase, catalyzing strand-passage events that result in supercoiling at rates several orders of magnitude faster than those causing decatenation. Topo IV, in contrast, decatenates linked circles 10-40 times more quickly than it removes the intramolecular crossings from supercoiled DNA. Supercoiled catenanes are unlinked at an even more increased rate by Topo IV. Thus, the supercoils augment decatenation rather than compete with catenane crossings for their removal. Knot crossings and the crossings of multiply interlinked catenanes are also preferentially removed by Topo IV. This ability of Topo IV to selectively unlink catenated molecules mirrors its key role in decatenation of replicating chromosomes in vivo.