Impedance index measurements of in vitro PTFE end-to-side anastomoses: effect of angle and Miller cuff

Randomized clinical trial of distal anastomotic interposition vein cuff in infrainguinal polytetrafluoroethylene bypass grafting

Background

The aim was to examine the effect of a Miller vein cuff at the distal anastomosis on the medium- to long-term patency and limb salvage rates of femoral to above-knee and femoral to below-knee popliteal artery polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) bypasses.

Methods

This study involved extended follow-up of the original cohort of patients included in a previously reported multicentre randomized clinical study. Outcome measures were bypass graft patency and limb salvage.

Results

Two hundred and sixty-one bypass operations were originally randomized. For this study, full data were available on 235 (120 with a Miller cuff, 115 without). The cumulative 5-year patency rate for above-knee bypasses with a Miller cuff was 40 per cent, compared with 42 per cent for non-cuffed bypasses (P = 0·702). The cumulative 3-year patency rate for below-knee bypasses with a Miller cuff was 45 per cent, compared with 19 per cent for non-cuffed bypasses (P = 0·018). A Miller cuff had no significant effect on limb salvage for above-knee or below-knee bypasses.

Conclusion

Three-year patency rates of femoral to below-knee popliteal PTFE bypasses were improved by a Miller cuff. Miller cuffs had no effect on patency rates for femoral to above-knee popliteal bypasses at 5 years and did not improve limb salvage in either group.

Improved patency of prosthetic arteriovenous grafts with an acute anastomotic angle and flow diffuser

OBJECTIVE

Conventional end-to-side anastomosis to establish venous outflow for prosthetic arteriovenous grafts often requires operative patch angioplasty within 1 year because of venous stenosis. Rather than conventional venous anastomosis, a modified end-to-side anastomosis at a 15-degree angle with a flow diffuser was constructed. Such diffusers allow decreased flow velocity and increased pressure, inhibiting boundary layer separation.

METHODS

Ten brachial artery to axillary vein 6 mm straight se-polytetrafluoroethylene prosthetic arteriovenous grafts were created with this technique. Patients included 6 men and 4 women (mean age, 66.4 years; range, 54-80 years), all with renal failure and a history of diabetes. The degree of stenosis at the venous anastomosis was determined with duplex scanning at intervals of 6 months. Analysis of survival and cumulative primary patency estimates were determined with the Kaplan-Meier method.

RESULTS

Primary cumulative patency estimate of 100% for the modified group at 18 and 24 months was significantly greater than that for age-matched historic control fistulas with the conventional end-to-side anastomosis (n = 20): 18 months, 32%; 24 months, 32% (P <.05). Although venous stenosis could not be quantitated for thrombosed conventional fistulas, modified anastomoses had minimal stenosis at 24 months: mean area reduction, 30% (range, 20%-45%).

CONCLUSION

Incorporation of a flow diffuser and a 15-degree anastomotic angle significantly increases patency of prosthetic brachial artery to axillary vein grafts.

Is there a haemodynamic advantage associated with cuffed arterial anastomoses?

The development of intimal hyperplasia at arterial bypass graft anastomoses is a major factor responsible for graft failure. A revised surgical technique, involving the incorporation of a small section of vein (vein cuff) into the distal anastomosis of PTFE grafts, results in an altered distribution of intimal hyperplasia and improved graft patency rates, especially for below-knee grafts. Numerical simulations have been conducted under physiological conditions to identify the flow behaviour in a typical cuffed bypass model and to determine whether the improved performance of the cuffed system can be accounted for by haemodynamic factors. The flow patterns at the cuffed anastomosis are significantly different to those at the conventional end-to-side anastomosis. In the former case, the flow is characterised by an expansive, low momentum recirculation within the cuff. Separation occurs at the graft heel, and at the cuff toe as the blood enters the recipient artery. Wall shear stresses in the vicinity of the cuff heel are low, but high shear stresses and large spatial gradients in the shearing force act on the artery floor during systole. In contrast, a less disturbed flow prevails and the floor shear stress distribution is less adverse in the conventional model. In conclusion, aspects of the anastomotic haemodynamics are worsened when the cuff is employed. The benefits associated with the cuffed grafts may be related primarily to the presence of venous material at the anastomosis. Therefore, caution is advised with regard to the use of PTFE grafts, pre-shaped to resemble a cuffed geometry.

Computational and experimental simulations of the haemodynamics at cuffed arterial bypass graft anastomoses

The development of intimal hyperplasia at arterial bypass graft anastomoses is a major factor responsible for graft failure. A revised surgical technique, involving the incorporation of a small section of vein (vein cuff) into the distal anastomosis of polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) grafts, alters the distribution of intimal hyperplasia and improves graft performance. Numerical and in vitro flow visualization experiments have been conducted to identify the flow behaviour in the cuffed bypass model and to determine whether the improved performance of the cuffed system can be accounted for by haemodynamic factors. The flowfield at the cuffed anastomosis is characterized by an expansive recirculation. Separation occurs at the graft heel, and at the cuff toe as the blood enters the recipient artery. Wall shear stresses in the vicinity of the cuff heel are low, but high shear stresses and large spatial gradients in the shearing force act for a time on the artery floor. In the conventional model, a less disturbed flow prevails while the gradients of shear stress on the floor are smaller. Aspects of the anastomotic haemodynamics are worsened when the cuff is employed. The superior patency rates of cuffed bypasses may not be explained purely on the basis of local haemodynamic factors.

Simulation of flow through a Miller cuff bypass graft

Unnatural temporal and spatial distributions of wall shear stress in the anastomosis of distal bypass grafts have been identified as possible factors in the development of anastomotic intimal hyperplasia in these grafts. Distal bypass graft anastomoses with an autologus vein cuff (a Miller cuff) interposed between the graft and artery have been shown to alleviate the effects of intimal hyperplasia. In this study, pulsatile flow through models of a standard end-to-side anastomosis and a Miller cuff anastomosis are computed and the resulting wall shear stress and pressure distributions analysed. The results are inconclusive, and could be taken to suggest that the unnatural distributions of shear stress that do occur along the anastomosis floor may not be particularly important in the development of intimal hyperplasia. However, it seems more likely that the positive effects of the biological and material properties of the vein cuff, which are not considered in this study, somehow outweigh the negative effects of the shear stress distributions predicted to occur on the floor of the Miller-cuff graft.

Compliance in Anastomoses With and Without Vein Cuff Interposition

OBJECTIVE

to compare anastomotic compliance in end-to-side anastomoses with and without vein cuff interposition. Materials polytetrafluoroethylene graft to bovine carotid artery without (standard) and with vein interposition (Linton-patch and Miller-cuff).

METHODS

zonewise compliance measurement of end-to-side anastomoses in an in-vitro circulation system. The zone most distal to the suture-line served as reference compliance.

RESULTS

directly distal to the suture-line the compliance of the Linton-patch (5.6+/-1.6%/100 mmHg) and Miller-cuff anastomosis (5.2+/-1.1%/100 mmHg) more closely approached reference compliance (standard: 5.0+/-1.2, Linton-patch: 4.5+/-1.5, Miller-cuff: 4.9+/-1.0%/100 mmHg) than that of the standard anastomosis (7.9+/-3.0%/100 mmHg). The maximal compliance values of the Linton-patch (9.5+/-2.3%/100 mmHg) and Miller-cuff anastomoses (9.8+/-2.7%/100 mmHg) were significantly higher than that of the standard end-to-side anastomosis (7.9+/-3.0%/100 mmHg). However, maximal compliance was shifted from the zone directly distal to the suture line in the standard end-to-side anastomosis, to the vein cuff interposition in the Linton-patch and Miller-cuff anastomoses.

CONCLUSION

the shift in maximal compliance to the wider portion of the anastomosis in the Miller-cuff and Linton-patch anastomoses may obviate reocclusion.

Optimising Miller Cuff Dimensions. The Influence of Geometry on Anastomotic Flow Patterns

OBJECTIVES

since cuff dimensions are variable, we studied the influence of cuff geometry on flow mechanics, in an attempt to identify the optimum configuration.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

bench studies involved the manufacture of anatomically accurate models of varying cuff dimensions, perfused in a specifically designed flow rig, simulating physiological conditions. Flow visualisation studies incorporating laser illumination of tracer particles enabled accurate analysis of flow patterns.

RESULTS

the vortex created within the proximal cuff of each model during the deceleration phase of the cardiac cycle was strongly influenced by the aspect ratio (AR=cuff height:length). The standard and high cuffs (AR=1.63 and 1.18, respectively) demonstrated cohesive vortices and stable flow patterns. Low and long cuffs (AR=2.6 and 2.25, respectively) created more complex vortices with large areas of flow separation and low velocities.

CONCLUSIONS

aspect ratio has an important influence on flow within the distal anastomosis, with cuff dimensions of 13 mm long and 8-11 mm high (standard and high cuffs) creating beneficial flow patterns anticipated to optimise wall shear stress and inhibit myointimal hyperplasia.

Axial flow fields in cuffed end-to-side anastomoses: effect of angle and disease progression

OBJECTIVE

to visualise the axial flow fields in standard and cuffed end-to-side anastomoses (ESA).

DESIGN

in vitro experiments using a flow rig, custom-built glass models and frame-by-frame video analysis of flow patterns in standard and cuffed ESA.

SUBJECTS

glass models of standard or cuffed (1 cm or 2 cm high) ESA of angles 15, 30, 45 and 60 degrees.

RESULTS

the cross-sectional area of standard ESA is much smaller than that of ESA between graft and cuff. The size of the vortex in the anastomotic zone of both standard and cuffed ESA increased with increasing ESA angle and cuff height, but did not change with flow rate. The presence of the vortex maintains a zone of flow separation and low shear at the heel of standard and graft/cuff anastomoses.

CONCLUSIONS

the observations explain the clinical findings of intimal hyperplasia (IH) at the heel of PTFE/cuff anastomoses. The improved patency rates of cuffed ESA may be due not to decreased IH, but to an increased ability of the cuff to accommodate IH before causing a significant stenosis.