Hypoalgesia to pressure pain in referred pain areas triggered by spatial summation of experimental muscle pain from unilateral or bilateral trapezius muscles

Experimental cervical interspinous ligament pain altered cervical joint motion during dynamic extension movement

BACKGROUND

Although the cervical interspinous ligament is a potential source of neck pain, the effects on cervical joint motion and pressure pain sensitivity has never been investigated. The understanding of the relationship will broaden our understanding of cervical biomechanics and improve diagnosis and treatment of neck pain.

METHODS

Fluoroscopy videos of cervical flexion and extension movements and pressure pain thresholds over bilateral C2/C3 and C5/C6 facet joints were collected in fifteen healthy subjects before and after injections of hypertonic and isotonic saline in C4/C5 ISL. The videos were divided into 10 even epochs and the motion of individual joints during each epoch was extracted. Joint motion parameters including anti-directional motion, pro-directional motion, total joint motion and joint motion variability were extracted across epochs. Joint motion parameters and PPTs were compared before and after injection of hypertonic and isotonic saline separately.

FINDINGS

Compared with baselines: hypertonic saline injection 1) decreased anti-directional motion and joint motion variability at C4/C5 (P < 0.05) and increased at C2/C3 (P < 0.05) during extension; 2) increased total joint motion of C0/C1 during first half range (P < 0.05) and decreased during second half range of extension, and total joint motion of C2/C3 increased during second half range of extension (P < 0.05) and; 3) increased pressure pain thresholds over left C2/C3 facet joint (P < 0.01).

INTERPRETATION

The cervical interspinous ligament pain redistributed anti-directional motion between C4/C5 and C2/C3 during dynamic extension and decreased pressure pain sensitivity over the left C2/C3 facet joint.

Origin of neck pain and direction of movement influence dynamic cervical joint motion and pressure pain sensitivity

BACKGROUND

Patients with neck pain normally showed alterations in cervical motion and pressure pain sensitivity. Cervical joints show scattered motions opposite to (anti-directional) the primary motion direction (pro-directional) during dynamic cervical flexion and extension. This study aimed to assess dynamic cervical joint motion and pressure pain sensitivity when pain originated from different cervical muscles which may have clinical relevance in diagnosis of impairments related with neck pain.

METHODS

Fluoroscopic video recordings of cervical flexion and extension were collected from fifteen healthy subjects before and during hypertonic saline-induced pain in right multifidus and trapezius muscles. Cervical flexion and extension motions were divided into 10 epochs with respect to time. Pro-directional, anti-directional, and total joint motion were extracted across epochs as well as joint motion variability. Pressure pain thresholds (PPTs) were assessed bilaterally over C2/C3 and C5/C6 facet joints.

FINDINGS

Compared with baseline: 1) Multifidus muscle pain increased the C3/C4 anti-directional motion (P < 0.01), decreased the C6/C7 anti-directional motion (P < 0.05) during extension, and redistributed total joint motion between joints and between half ranges during flexion (P < 0.05). 2) Trapezius muscle pain decreased pro-directional motion (P < 0.05), anti-directional motion (P < 0.05), and joint motion variability (P < 0.05) during extension. 3) Trapezius and multifidus muscle pain increased the PPTs bilaterally over C2/C3 and on the left side of C5/C6 facet joints (P < 0.05).

INTERPRETATION

The direction of motion influenced the effects of experimental muscle pain on dynamic cervical joint kinematics, and deep muscle pain showed local effects on individual joints while superficial muscle pain showed global effects spread to all joints.

Alterations in the trapezius muscle in young patients with migraine--a pilot case series with MRI

BACKGROUND/PURPOSE

Migraine is frequent in young adults and adolescents and often associated with neck muscle tension and pain. Common pathophysiological pathways, such as reciprocal cervico-trigeminal activation, are assumed. Tense areas within the neck muscles can be clinically observed many patients with migraine. The aim of this pilot case study was to visualize these tense areas via magnet resonance imaging (MRI).

METHODS

Three young patients with migraine were examined by an experienced investigator. In all three patients tense areas in the trapezius muscles were palpated. These areas were marked by nitroglycerin capsules on the adjacent skin surface.

RESULTS

The MRI showed focal signal alterations at the marked locations within the trapezius muscles.

CONCLUSION

Visualization of palpable tense areas by MRI may be usefully applied in the future to help elucidate the underlying pathophysiological processes of migraine.

Experimental pelvic pain facilitates pain provocation tests and causes regional hyperalgesia

The extra-articular sacroiliac joint (SIJ) structure is a potential source for low back and pelvic pain. This study hypothesised that experimental pain induced in a superficial pelvic ligament causes (1) hyperalgesia to pressure, (2) distinct pain referral, and (3) an increased frequency of positive pain provocation tests of the SIJ complex. Thirty healthy subjects (15 females) participated in this study designed as a randomised crossover trial. Pain was induced in the long posterior sacroiliac ligament by injection of hypertonic saline, with the contralateral ligament injected with isotonic saline as control. Pain intensity was assessed on an electronic visual analogue scale (VAS). Pressure pain thresholds (PPTs) and pain provocation tests were assessed on 3 occasions: at baseline, after injection, and when pain had subsided. PPT sites were located bilaterally at the injection site, lateral to spinous processes of S2 and L5, and at the gluteus medius and gastrocnemius muscles. Hypertonic saline caused significantly higher VAS scores and more extended pain referral than isotonic saline (P<0.001). PPTs at the injection site and lateral to S2 were significantly reduced after hypertonic saline compared with baseline and isotonic saline (P<0.002). Significantly more subjects had positive pain provocation tests after hypertonic (67% of subjects) compared with isotonic saline (20%; P<0.001). These data demonstrate that the extra-articular SIJ structure accommodates nociceptors that are capable of inducing pain referral and regional hyperalgesia sensitive to manual pain provocation tests similar to what previously have been found in pelvic girdle pain patients.

Referred pain from trapezius muscle trigger points shares similar characteristics with chronic tension type headache

Referred pain and pain characteristics evoked from the upper trapezius muscle was investigated in 20 patients with chronic tension-type headache (CTTH) and 20 age- and gender-matched controls. A headache diary was kept for 4 weeks in order to confirm the diagnosis and record the pain history. Both upper trapezius muscles were examined for the presence of myofascial trigger points (TrPs) in a blinded fashion. The local and referred pain intensities, referred pain pattern, and pressure pain threshold (PPT) were recorded. The results show that referred pain was evoked in 85% and 50% on the dominant and non-dominant sides in CTTH patients, much higher than 55% and 25% in controls (P<0.01). Referred pain spread to the posterior-lateral aspect of the neck ipsi-lateral to the stimulated muscle in both patients and controls, with additional referral to the temple in most patients, but none in controls. Nearly half of the CTTH patients (45%) recognized the referred pain as their usual headache sensation, i.e. active TrPs. CTTH patients with active TrPs in the right upper trapezius muscle showed greater headache intensity and frequency, and longer headache duration than those with latent TrPs. CTTH patients with bilateral TrPs reported significantly decreased PPT than those with unilateral TrP (P<0.01). Our results showed that manual exploration of TrPs in the upper trapezius muscle elicited referred pain patterns in both CTTH patients and healthy subjects. In CTTH patients, the evoked referred pain and its sensory characteristics shared similar patterns as their habitual headache pain, consistent with active TrPs. Our results suggest that spatial summation of perceived pain and mechanical pain sensitivity exists in CTTH patients.

Sensory characteristics of tender points in the lower back

Palpation of tender points in superficial tissue is commonly undertaken in the management of musculoskeletal pain. The sensory characteristics of digitally tender points (DTPs) have not been defined. This study had two major aims: 1) to characterise 'Strain-Counterstrain' DTPs, using quantitative sensory testing (QST) in participants with low back pain (LBP); 2) to compare corresponding points at lumbar sites in participants with LBP to those without LBP. Fifteen participants with LBP (9 females), mean (SD) Oswestry scores 20.8 (10.1)) and 15 participants without LBP (6 females) were included. QST was undertaken by a single examiner blind to the location of DTPs and included measurement of electrical detection and electrical pain threshold, thermal (hot/cold) detection and thermal pain threshold, vibration detection threshold and pressure-pain threshold. In participants with LBP, DTPs demonstrated significantly lower electrical detection and electrical pain thresholds compared to contralateral non-tender points (p < 0.0001). These findings may be indicative of altered central processing of Abeta afferents with terminal receptors at DTPs. Participants with LBP demonstrated elevated cold pain thresholds at lower back sites and at the peripheral shoulder site compared to participants without LBP (p < 0.001). This may also indicate augmented central pain processing in participants with LBP.

On functional motor adaptations: from the quantification of motor strategies to the prevention of musculoskeletal disorders in the neck-shoulder region

BACKGROUND

Occupations characterized by a static low load and by repetitive actions show a high prevalence of work-related musculoskeletal disorders (WMSD) in the neck-shoulder region. Moreover, muscle fatigue and discomfort are reported to play a relevant initiating role in WMSD.

AIMS

To investigate relationships between altered sensory information, i.e. localized muscle fatigue, discomfort and pain and their associations to changes in motor control patterns.

MATERIALS & METHODS

In total 101 subjects participated. Questionnaires, subjective assessments of perceived exertion and pain intensity as well as surface electromyography (SEMG), mechanomyography (MMG), force and kinematics recordings were performed.

RESULTS

Multi-channel SEMG and MMG revealed that the degree of heterogeneity of the trapezius muscle activation increased with fatigue. Further, the spatial organization of trapezius muscle activity changed in a dynamic manner during sustained contraction with acute experimental pain. A graduation of the motor changes in relation to the pain stage (acute, subchronic and chronic) and work experience were also found. The duration of the work task was shorter in presence of acute and chronic pain. Acute pain resulted in decreased activity of the painful muscle while in subchronic and chronic pain, a more static muscle activation was found. Posture and movement changed in the presence of neck-shoulder pain. Larger and smaller sizes of arm and trunk movement variability were respectively found in acute pain and subchronic/chronic pain. The size and structure of kinematics variability decreased also in the region of discomfort. Motor variability was higher in workers with high experience. Moreover, the pattern of activation of the upper trapezius muscle changed when receiving SEMG/MMG biofeedback during computer work.

DISCUSSION

SEMG and MMG changes underlie functional mechanisms for the maintenance of force during fatiguing contraction and acute pain that may lead to the widespread pain seen in WMSD. A lack of harmonious muscle recruitment/derecruitment may play a role in pain transition. Motor behavior changed in shoulder pain conditions underlining that motor variability may play a role in the WMSD development as corroborated by the changes in kinematics variability seen with discomfort. This prognostic hypothesis was further, supported by the increased motor variability among workers with high experience.

CONCLUSION

Quantitative assessments of the functional motor adaptations can be a way to benchmark the pain status and help to indentify signs indicating WMSD development. Motor variability is an important characteristic in ergonomic situations. Future studies will investigate the potential benefit of inducing motor variability in occupational settings.

Generalized Neck-Shoulder Hyperalgesia in Chronic Tension-Type Headache and Unilateral Migraine Assessed by Pressure Pain Sensitivity Topographical Maps of the Trapezius Muscle

Spatial changes in pressure pain hypersensitivity are present throughout the cephalic region (temporalis muscle) in both chronic tension-type headache (CTTH) and unilateral migraine. The aim of this study was to assess pressure pain sensitivity topographical maps on the trapezius muscle in 20 patients with CTTH and 20 with unilateral migraine in comparison with 20 healthy controls in a blind design. For this purpose, a pressure algometer was used to assess pressure pain thresholds (PPT) over 11 points of the trapezius muscle: four points in the upper part of the muscle, two over the levator scapulae muscle, two in the middle part, and the remaining three points in the lower part of the muscle. Pressure pain sensitivity maps of both sides (dominant/non-dominant; symptomatic/non-symptomatic) were depicted for patients and controls. CTTH patients showed generalized lower PPT levels compared with both migraine patients ( P = 0.03) and controls ( P < 0.001). The migraine group had also lower PPT than healthy controls ( P < 0.001). The most sensitive location for the assessment of PPT was the neck portion of the upper trapezius muscle in both patient groups and healthy controls ( P < 0.001). PPT was negatively related to some clinical pain features in both CTTH and unilateral migraine patients (all P < 0.05). Side-to-side differences were found in strictly unilateral migraine, but not in those subjects with bilateral pain, i.e. CTTH. These data support the influence of muscle hyperalgesia in both CTTH and unilateral migraine patients and point towards a general pressure pain hyperalgesia of neck-shoulder muscles in headache patients, particularly in CTTH.

Gender and site of injection do not influence intensity of hypertonic saline-induced muscle pain in healthy volunteers

The aim of the study was to determine whether the same stimulus to different muscles results in comparable pain and whether gender has any influence on the pain. We compared the quality and intensity of muscle pain induced by a hypertonic saline injection into the tibialis anterior (leg) muscle to that after an injection into the lumbar erector spinae (back) muscle in both male (n=10) and female (n=10) volunteers. Hypertonic or isotonic saline was injected into the leg and back muscles and pain intensity (visual analogue scale, VAS) and pain quality (McGill Pain Questionnaire) were measured. Pressure pain tolerance around the site of injection and on the contralateral side was measured. Hypertonic saline injection induced significant muscle pain in the back and leg compared to isotonic saline (P<0.05, ANOVA). The site of injection did not influence the quality of pain but there was a gender bias in the descriptive words chosen (chi(2) test, P<0.05) and female subjects were more sensitive to pressure than male subjects. Experimentally induced muscle pain is equivalent in intensity and quality in the leg and back muscle. Gender does not influence muscle pain intensity but does influence sensitivity to pressure and the description of pain.

Depression of the human nociceptive withdrawal reflex by segmental and heterosegmental intramuscular electrical stimulation

OBJECTIVE

To investigate the effects of intramuscular electrical conditioning in the modulation of nociceptive withdrawal reflex (NWR) and further to determine what muscle afferents are involved in the modulation of the nociceptive withdrawal reflex and the sites along the reflex pathway where the NWR modulation occurs in healthy humans.

METHODS

The NWR elicited by a cutaneous test stimulus to the dorsal foot was modulated by a short (21 ms) intramuscular conditioning electrical stimulus at two times the pain threshold. At varying conditioning-test stimulus intervals, segmental conditioning stimulus was applied in the tibialis anterior muscle ipsilateral and contralateral to the test stimulus, and heterosegmental conditioning stimulus was applied in the contralateral trapezius muscle to modulate the NWR. Non-painful and painful intramuscular conditioning stimuli were also used to modulate the NWR and the soleus H-reflex.

RESULTS

The NWR was depressed by preceding intramuscular conditioning stimuli, with a degree that depended on the conditioning-test stimulus intervals and on the conditioning site. Segmental conditioning depressed the NWR more quickly and gave a longer duration (15-1500 ms), and larger magnitude than heterosegmental conditioning, which depressed the NWR in a short temporal window (80-100 ms). No difference was seen in the magnitude of the NWR depression between the painful and non-painful intramuscular stimuli, and the soleus H-reflex was not affected.

CONCLUSIONS

Our results suggest that segmental and heterosegmental conditionings of NWR are mediated by myelinated muscle afferents engaging central inhibitory mechanisms rather than direct changes in the excitability of motor neurons.

SIGNIFICANCE

The therapeutic effects of electrotherapy could involve these mechanisms in the treatment of muscle pain syndromes.

Myofascial trigger points and sensitization: an updated pain model for tension-type headache

Present pain models for tension-type headache suggest that nociceptive inputs from peripheral tender muscles can lead to central sensitization and chronic tension-type headache (CTTH) conditions. Such models support that possible peripheral mechanisms leading to pericranial tenderness include activation or sensitization of nociceptive nerve endings by liberation of chemical mediators (bradikinin, serotonin, substance P). However, a study has found that non-specific tender points in CTTH subjects were not responsible for liberation of algogenic substances in the periphery. Assuming that liberation of algogenic substances is important, the question arising is: if tender muscle points are not the primary sites of on-going neurogenic inflammation, which structure can be responsible for liberation of chemical mediators in the periphery? A recent study has found higher levels of algogenic substances, and lower pH levels, in active myofascial trigger point (TrPs) compared with control tender points. Clinical studies have demonstrated that referred pain elicited by head and neck muscles contribute to head pain patterns in CTTH. Based on available data, an updated pain model for CTTH is proposed in which headache can at least partly be explained by referred pain from TrPs in the posterior cervical, head and shoulder muscles. In this updated pain model, TrPs would be the primary hyperalgesic zones responsible for the development of central sensitization in CTTH.

Referred pain and hyperalgesia in human tendon and muscle belly tissue

The sensitivity of tendon and tendon-bone junction is not fully described although these tissues have high clinical impacts. This study assessed (1) pain intensity and referred pain caused by hypertonic saline injection to the proximal tendon-bone junction (PTBJ), tendon and muscle belly sites of tibialis anterior muscle and (2) pressure pain sensitivity, pre, during and post hypertonic saline injections. Eighteen subjects (14 males and 4 females) participated. Subjects also had constant mechanical stimulation for 120s at 130% of baseline pressure pain threshold (PPT) during which VAS parameters were recorded. VAS parameters after hypertonic saline for PTBJ (VAS area, VAS peak), and tendon sites (VAS area, duration and time to maximum VAS) were significantly (P < 0.05) higher than muscle belly. During hypertonic saline pain all three sites displayed local and frequently enlarged and referred pain areas. Hypertonic saline pain at the PTBJ and tendon transiently increased pressure sensitivity at these sites (P < 0.05). When referred pain was caused by mechanical stimulation it occurred predominantly at the PTBJ and tendon sites (86% cases). Constant mechanical stimulation caused steadily increasing pain (summation of pain) at all sites. Hypertonic saline pain at the tendon and PTBJ caused significantly higher (P < 0.001) final VAS scores compared to the muscle belly site. The results indicate the PTBJ and tendon sites are more sensitive and susceptible to sensitisation by hypertonic saline than muscle belly. Furthermore, there may be site specific central changes reflected by the differences in the results regarding sensitivity and summation over time.

Gender differences in pain modulation evoked by repeated injections of glutamate into the human trapezius muscle

Gender differences in pain habituation, temporal summation, and pressure hyperalgesia evoked by repeated injections of glutamate into the dominant trapezius muscle were investigated. The glutamate-evoked muscle pain intensity and pressure pain threshold (PPT) were assessed. The PPTs were measured bilaterally in the trapezius muscles (local pain area) and posterolateral neck muscles (referred pain area) after glutamate injection in healthy and age-matched males and females (each n=14). Two glutamate injections (0.4 ml, 2M each) were injected with an interval of 5 min. One injection of glutamate (0.4 ml, 2M) served as a control. Males, but not females, rated the second injection (maximal pain intensity) significantly less painful than the first injection. The area under the visual analogue scale pain curve of the second injection was significantly larger than the first injection in females. Repeated glutamate injections, but not one-glutamate injection, significantly decreased PPTs in the local pain area, with no significant gender differences. No PPTs changes were observed either in the contralateral trapezius muscle or bilaterally in the referred pain areas in either sex. These results suggest that a less efficient pain habituation and a greater susceptibility to the development of temporal summation of muscle pain in females, but not in males, might be one of the contributing factors to the higher incidence of neck shoulder pain in females. In addition, the reduction of PPTs in the local pain area evoked by intramuscular glutamate injection may represent an early process of peripheral pressure hyperalgesia, which is most likely gender independent.

Visceral pain: gender differences in response to experimental and clinical pain

Gender differences in response to visceral pain have important implications for experimental studies and when evaluating clinical pain. Few studies have in details explored specific gender differences in response to experimental stimulation of selected visceral organs or specific visceral diseases. Lower pain threshold to e.g. oesophageal distension has however been shown in females. The effect of female sex hormones on visceral function and pain is studied in greater details in both experimental and clinical studies. Pronounced differences in pain sensitivity are found across the menstrual phases. This may also interact with pharmacological interventions. For clinicians assessing the pain level of female patients in the reproductive age group should take into consideration the physiological and clinical effects of the menstrual cycle and the somatic segmental sites related to the uterus and cervix when clinically evaluating the pain and assessing for disease activity.

Sex differences in temporal characteristics of descending inhibitory control: an evaluation using repeated bilateral experimental induction of muscle pain

Little is known about sex differences in the temporal pattern of descending inhibitory mechanisms, such as descending noxious inhibitory control (DNIC). Sex differences in temporal characteristics of DNIC were investigated by measuring pressure pain thresholds (PPTs) over time in the trapezius muscles (local pain areas) and the posterolateral neck muscles (referred pain areas) following repeated bilateral injection of hypertonic versus isotonic saline into both trapezius muscles. Ten females and 11 males received two consecutive bilateral injections, with 15 min interval, of either 5.8% hypertonic saline (0.5 ml in each side for each bilateral injection) or isotonic saline as a control in a randomized manner. Following hypertonic saline injection, the maximal pain intensities of the first and second bilateral injections were significantly higher in females than in males. The PPTs in the trapezius muscles were significantly lower in females than in males. Significantly higher PPTs (hypoalgesia) in men than in women were shown 15 min after the first bilateral injection, and 7.5 and 15 min after the second bilateral injection in the referred pain areas. Importantly, the second bilateral injection failed to further increase the PPTs for both sexes. These results showed that there were sex differences in temporal characteristics of descending inhibition with long-lasting hypoalgesia in men than in women. Repeated noxious muscular stimuli may inhibit further build-up of DNIC, which may reflect a mechanism of plasticity of the descending inhibitory systems following recurrent nociceptive barrage for both sexes.

Simultaneous modulation of the exteroceptive suppression periods in the trapezius and temporalis muscles by experimental muscle pain

OBJECTIVE

To investigate whether the exteroceptive suppression (ES) periods in the trapezius and temporalis muscles could be simultaneously modulated by either experimental trapezius muscle pain or temporalis muscle pain.

METHODS

Fourteen healthy volunteers participated in two sessions with randomised injections of either hypertonic or isotonic saline into the right trapezius muscle or right temporalis muscle. The pain intensity was continuously scored on a 10 cm electronic visual analogue scale. During muscle contraction, the early (ES1) and late (ES2) reflex in the temporalis and late (ES2) reflex in the trapezius elicited by electrical stimulation of the right infraorbital nerve were recorded pre-, during-, and post-injection.

RESULTS

Hypertonic saline injection induced local muscle pain and referred pain with the maximal pain intensity of 6.3+/-0.5 cm in the right trapezius and 6.7+/-0.6 cm in the right temporalis muscles. Injection of either hypertonic or isotonic saline into the right trapezius muscle was associated with significantly shortened ES2 duration and offset time in the injected right trapezius muscle. Only injection of hypertonic saline into the right trapezius muscle could significantly reduce the ES2 offset time and decrease the degree of suppression of ES2 in the right temporalis and left trapezius muscles. Injection of either hypertonic or isotonic saline into the right trapezius muscle evoked no changes in ES2 parameters in the left temporalis muscle. Injection of hypertonic saline, but not isotonic saline, into the right temporalis muscle caused a significantly shorter ES2 offset time and shorter ES2 duration bilaterally in the temporalis and trapezius muscles.

CONCLUSIONS

The findings of the present study provide evidence for a bi-directional effects reflecting convergence of muscle afferents from the trigeminal and upper cervical neural systems in humans, which may partly underlie the manifestations of pain referral between these two areas.