Hábito y actitud respecto al tabaco en enfermería de atención primaria de Bilbao

Prevalence of tobacco use in healthcare workers: A systematic review and meta-analysis

Objectives

To estimate tobacco use prevalence in healthcare workers (HCW) by country income level, occupation and sex, and compare the estimates with the prevalence in the general population.

Methods

We systematically searched five databases; Medline, EMBASE, CINHAL Plus, CAB Abstracts, and LILACS for original studies published between 2000 and March 2016 without language restriction. All primary studies that reported tobacco use in any category of HCW were included. Study extraction and quality assessment were conducted independently by three reviewers, using a standardised data extraction and quality appraisal form. We performed random effect meta-analyses to obtain prevalence estimates by World Bank (WB) country income level, sex, and occupation. Data on prevalence of tobacco use in the general population were obtained from the World Health Organisation (WHO) Global Health Observatory website. The review protocol registration number on PROSPERO is CRD42016041231.

Results

229 studies met our inclusion criteria, representing 457,415 HCW and 63 countries: 29 high-income countries (HIC), 21 upper-middle-income countries (UMIC), and 13 lower-middle-and-low-income countries (LMLIC). The overall pooled prevalence of tobacco use in HCW was 21%, 31% in males and 17% in females. Highest estimates were in male doctors in UMIC and LMLIC, 35% and 45%, and female nurses in HIC and UMIC, 21% and 25%. Heterogeneity was high (I² > 90%). Country level comparison suggest that in HIC male HCW tend to have lower prevalence compared with males in the general population while in females the estimates were similar. Male and female HCW in UMIC and LMLIC tend to have similar or higher prevalence rates relative to their counterparts in the general population.

Conclusions

HCW continue to use tobacco at high rates. Tackling HCW tobacco use requires urgent action as they are at the front line for tackling tobacco use in their patients.

Nurses' smoking habits and their professional smoking cessation practices. A systematic review and meta-analysis

BACKGROUND

A better understanding of whether nurses' own smoking behaviours influence their engagement with smoking cessation interventions is needed.

AIM

To establish whether the smoking status of nurses is associated with their professional smoking cessation practices.

METHODS

Twelve electronic databases covering English and Spanish language publications from 01 Jan, 1996 to 25 Mar, 2015 were systematically searched. Studies were included if they reported nurses' smoking cessation practices in relation to their personal smoking habits. Proportions of nurses' smoking status and smoking cessation practices were pooled across studies using random effects meta-analysis.

RESULTS

Fifteen studies were included in this systematic review. Levels of reportedsmoking cessation interventions were generally low across the studies. The meta-analyses suggested that nurses' personal smoking status was not associated significantly with nurses always asking patients about their smoking, but nurses who smoked were 13% less likely to advise their patients to quit and 25% less likely to arrange smoking cessation follow-up. More intense interventions (assessing motivation and assisting) were not significantly associated with the smoking status of the nurse.

CONCLUSIONS

The smoking status of nurses appears to have a negative impact in the delivery of smoking cessation practices. The overall level of nurses' engagement with the delivery of smoking cessation interventions requires attention if nurses are to be effective agents of smoking cessation.

[Assessment of effectiveness of a plan against tobacco in a universitary hospital]

AIMS

Assessment of effectiveness of a plan entitled «Smoke-free hospitals», specifically the reduction in the number of smoking staff and an increase in smoke-free areas.

METHOD

Interventional, non-controlled, populational study. A baseline study was conducted in 2004 to find out the situation as regards the prevalence of smokers in our hospital and the support of health workers for the smoke-free hospital plan. We used the questionnaire validated for the European smoke free hospital network in a sample of 483 workers randomly selected and stratified by gender, age and establishment. In 2007 we repeated the study with the same methodology to ascertain the progress of the project, in this case a sample of 425 workers was collected.

RESULTS

The number of smoking workers had decreased from 35.2% to 27.4 (P<.05). This reduction was seen in virtually all sectors, but was less so in nursing staff. In 2007 we had achieved that people only smoke in smoking areas (P<.0001). The plan was supported by smokers and non-smokers.

CONCLUSIONS

The «Smoke-free hospital» plan has achieved the objectives proposed. The actions carried out helped to enforce the law and respect that hospital areas should not be for smoking, together with strong support to help workers who want to quit smoking are shown to be effective.

Spanish primary health care nurses who are smokers: this influence on the therapeutic relationship

AIM

To identify the perception of Primary Health Care (PHC) female nurses in the Balearic Islands in Spain who are smokers, regarding the suitability of their anti-smoking therapeutic relationships with their clients. Also, to identify what factors they consider may determine why nurses smoke less in PHC than in specialized care (SC).

BACKGROUND

Backed by the signing of the WHO Framework Convention on Tobacco Control (WHO FCTC), a new Anti-Smoking law has been in force in Spain since 2006. This legislation limits the places where tobacco may be consumed. PHC nurses, because of their professional abilities, their number and their direct contact with society on all accounts - both health- and illness-wise - and also because of the proven efficacy of their interventions in the fight against the smoking habit, are called upon to play an important role against the smoking habit in the 21st century.

METHOD

A qualitative study using a semi-structured interview with 15 PHC female nurses who are smokers.

FINDINGS

Regarding the therapeutic relationship, basically two attitudes are adopted: first, blaming themselves and feeling uncomfortable and inadequate to be able to help someone to give up smoking or, second, considering themselves to be in an optimum situation in which to be able to help by sharing their addiction and thereby understanding and empathizing much more with clients. PHC nurses believe they smoke less than SC nurses as a result of a greater degree of awareness.

CONCLUSION

We would suggest that SC nurses should acquire a more relevant role in the fight against the smoking habit. In light of their capacity, commitment and efficacy, we believe there is a case for total autonomy as far as their role as therapists in breaking smoking habits is concerned.