Is the nasopharynx warmer in children than in adults?

Correlation of Nasal Mucosal Temperature With Subjective Nasal Patency in Healthy Individuals

Importance

Historically, otolaryngologists have focused on nasal resistance to airflow and minimum airspace cross-sectional area as objective measures of nasal obstruction using methods such as rhinomanometry and acoustic rhinometry. However, subjective sensation of nasal patency may be more associated with activation of cold receptors by inspired air than with respiratory effort.

Objective

To investigate whether subjective nasal patency correlates with nasal mucosal temperature in healthy individuals.

Design, Setting, and Participants

Healthy adult volunteers first completed the Nasal Obstruction Symptom Evaluation (NOSE) and a unilateral visual analog scale to quantify subjective nasal patency. A miniaturized thermocouple sensor was then used to record nasal mucosal temperature bilaterally in 2 locations along the nasal septum: at the vestibule and across from the inferior turbinate head.

Main Outcomes and Measures

Nasal mucosal temperature and subjective patency scores in healthy individuals.

Results

The 22 healthy adult volunteers (12 [55%] male; mean [SD] age, 28.3 [7.0] years) had a mean (SD) NOSE score of 5.9 (8.4) (range, 0-30) and unilateral VAS score of 1.2 (1.4) (range, 0-5). The range of temperature oscillations during the breathing cycle, defined as the difference between end-expiratory and end-inspiratory temperatures, was greater during deep breaths (mean [SD] change in temperature, 6.2°C [2.6°C]) than during resting breathing (mean [SD] change in temperature, 4.2°C [2.3°C]) in both locations (P < .001). Mucosal temperature measured at the right vestibule had a statistically significant correlation with both right-side visual analog scale score (Pearson r = -0.55; 95% CI, -0.79 to -0.17; P = .008) and NOSE score (Pearson r = -0.47; 95% CI, -0.74 to -0.06; P = .03). No other statistically significant correlations were found between mucosal temperature and subjective nasal patency scores. Nasal mucosal temperature was lower (mean of 1.5°C lower) in the first cavity to be measured, which was the right cavity in all participants.

Conclusions and Relevance

The greater mucosal temperature oscillations during deep breathing are consistent with the common experience that airflow sensation is enhanced during deep breaths, thus supporting the hypothesis that mucosal cooling plays a central role in nasal airflow sensation. A possible correlation was found between subjective nasal patency scores and nasal mucosal temperature, but our results were inconsistent. The higher temperature in the left cavity suggests that the sensor irritated the nasal mucosa, affecting the correlation between patency scores and mucosal temperature. Future studies should consider noncontact temperature sensors to prevent mucosa irritation.

Level of Evidence

NA.

Ethnicity, infection and sudden infant death syndrome

Epidemiological studies found the incidence of SIDS among Indigenous groups such as Aboriginal Australians, New Zealand Maoris and Native Americans were significantly higher than those for non-Indigenous groups within the same countries. Among other groups such as Asian families in Britain, the incidence of SIDS has been lower than among groups of European origin. Cultural and childrearing practices as well as socio-economic factors have been proposed to explain the greater risk of SIDS among Indigenous peoples; however, there are no definitive data to account for the differences observed. We addressed the differences among ethnic groups in relation to susceptibility to infection because there is evidence from studies of populations of European origin that infectious agents, particularly toxigenic bacteria might trigger the events leading to SIDS. The risk factors for SIDS parallel those for susceptibility to infections in infants, particularly respiratory tract infections which are also major health problems among Indigenous groups. Many of the risk factors identified in epidemiological studies of SIDS could affect three stages in the infectious process: (1) frequency or density of colonisation by the toxigenic species implicated in SIDS; (2) induction of temperature-sensitive toxins; (3) modulation of the inflammatory responses to infection or toxins. In this review we compare genetic, developmental and environmental risk factors for SIDS in ethnic groups with different incidences of SIDS: low (Asians in Britain); moderate (European/Caucasian); high (Aboriginal Australian). Our findings indicate: (1) the major difference was high levels of exposure to cigarette smoke among infants in the high risk groups; (2) cigarette smoke significantly reduced the anti-inflammatory cytokine interleukin-10 responses which control pro-inflammatory responses implicated in SIDS; (3) the most significant effect of cigarette smoke on reduction of IL-10 responses was observed for donors with a single nucleotide polymorphism for the IL-10 gene that is predominant among both Asian and Aboriginal populations. If genetic makeup were a major factor for susceptibility to SIDS, the incidence of these deaths should be similar for both populations. They are, however, significantly different and most likely reflect differences in maternal smoking which could affect frequency and density of colonisation of infants by potentially pathogenic bacteria and induction and control of inflammatory responses.

Mucosal tolerance to a bacterial superantigen indicates a novel pathway to prevent toxic shock

Enterotoxins with superantigenic properties secreted during systemic Staphylococcus aureus infection are responsible for toxic shock. We show that intranasal administration of staphylococcal enterotoxin A (SEA), but not a recombinant SEA lacking superantigenic activity, protected mice against lethal systemic SEA challenge. Protection was superantigen specific since intranasal exposure to SEA would not protect against death caused by subsequent toxic shock syndrome toxin 1 systemic challenge. Protection was neither due to selective depletion of SEA-specific T-cell receptor Vbeta families nor due to production of neutralizing anti-SEA antibodies. Importantly, the production of interleukin 10 (IL-10) induced by "tolerization" (that is, by the induction of immunological tolerance) contributed to the observed protection against lethal superantigen-triggered disease. In support of this notion we found that (i) significantly increased levels of IL-10 in sera of "tolerized" animals (that is, animals rendered tolerant) and (ii) IL-10(-/-) mice could not be tolerized by mucosal SEA administration. Altogether, this is the first study to show that mucosal tolerance to a superantigen is readily triggered by means of immunodeviation.

The role of bacterial toxins in sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS)

There is increasing evidence for the involvement of bacterial toxins in some cases of sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS), particularly the pyrogenic toxins of Staphylococcus aureus. This had led to the hypothesis that some SIDS deaths are due to induction of inflammatory mediators by infectious agents or their products during a period in which the infant is unable to control these normally protective responses. The genetic, developmental and environmental risk factors identified for SIDS are assessed in relation to frequency or density of mucosal colonisation by toxigenic bacteria and their effects on induction and control of inflammatory responses to the toxins.

Review of risk factors for sudden infant death syndrome

Sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS) accounts for the largest number of deaths during the first year of life in developed countries. The possible causes of SIDS are numerous and, to date, there is no adequate unifying pathological explanation for SIDS. Epidemiological studies have played a key role in identifying risk factors, knowledge of which has underpinned successful preventive programmes. This review critically assesses information on the main risk factors and causal hypotheses put forward for SIDS, focusing on research published since 1994. The overall picture that emerges from this review is that affected infants are not completely normal in development, but possess some inherent weakness, which may only become obvious when the infant is subjected to stress. Initially there may be some minor impairment or delay in development of respiratory, cardiovascular or neuromuscular function. None of these is likely to be sufficient, in isolation, to cause death and, provided the infant survives the first year of life, may no longer be of any significance. However, when a compromised infant is confronted with one or more stressful situations, several of which are now clearly identified as risk factors, and from which the majority of infants would normally escape, the combination may prove fatal.

Toxigenic bacteria and sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS): nasopharyngeal flora during the first year of life

Many developmental and environmental risk factors for sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS) are similar to those for susceptibility to respiratory tract infection, and toxigenic bacteria have been implicated in some SIDS cases. We assessed nasopharyngeal flora of healthy infants in relation to risk factors to determine which species best lit the mathematical model proposed for the common bacterial toxin hypothesis and if these findings complemented results obtained from SIDS cases which occurred during the period of the survey. Longitudinal studies were carried out between April 1993 and March 1996 on 253 healthy infants and their mothers. 150 from a multiply deprived area, 103 from an affluent area. Concurrent SIDS infants (37) were screened for nasopharyngeal flora. Among healthy infants < or = 3 months of age, the predominant isolate was Staphylococcus aureus 57% compared with 86% for SIDS infants in that age range (P< 0.02). There were significant associations between isolation of different species from both mother and baby but no association between isolation of any species with: area of residence: parental smoking habits; breast or bottle feeding; symptoms of viral infection: seasonality. We conclude that S. aureus fits the mathematical model for SIDS. Both staphylococci and/or their toxins were identified in a significant proportion of SIDS cases. Isolation of staphylococci from healthy infants was associated with the 2-4-month age range, a risk factor consistently found in all epidemiological studies of SIDS. This might reflect the developmental stage in which 80-90% of infants express the Lewis(a) antigen which we have shown to be one of the receptors for S. aureus.

The effect of prone posture on nasal temperature in children in relation to induction of staphylococcal toxins implicated in sudden infant death syndrome

The incidence of sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS) has declined in response to campaigns discouraging the prone sleeping position. Recent work suggests some SIDS death may be in response to bacterial toxins produced in the upper airway. A minimal temperature of 37 degrees C is required for induction of the pyrogenic toxins of Staphylococcus aureus identified in many SIDS infants. This aim of this study was to test the hypothesis that the prone position raises the temperature of the upper airways in children. A pilot study of 10 children (aged 3-8) and a main study of 30 children were carried out. Nasal septal temperatures were measured with an infra-red thermometer with the subjects in upright and prone positions under controlled conditions of ambient temperature and humidity. In both the pilot study and main study, nasal temperatures in the prone position were significantly higher (P < 0.01) Five subjects' prone readings were 37 degrees C or higher. These findings suggest that lying prone raises the upper airway surface temperature towards that required for toxin production. This could be one means by which the prone sleeping position contributes to the risk of SIDS.

Detection of pyrogenic toxins of Staphylococcus aureus in sudden infant death syndrome

It has been suggested that pyrogenic toxins of Staphylococcus aureus are involved in the series of events leading to some cases of sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS). The objectives of the study were to screen tissues from SIDS infants for pyrogenic toxins and to compare incidence of identification of these toxins among these infants from different countries. An enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) and a flow cytometry method were used to screen body fluids and frozen or formalin-fixed tissues for pyrogenic toxins of S. aureus, toxic shock syndrome toxin 1 (TSST), staphylococcal enterotoxins A (SEA), B (SEB), and C1 (SEC). Toxins were identified in tissues of 33/62 (53%) SIDS infants from three different countries: Scotland (10/ 19, 56%); France (7/13, 55%); Australia (16/30, 53%). In the Australian series, toxins were identified in only 3/19 (16%) non-SIDS deaths (chi2 = 5.42, P < 0.02). The flow cytometry method was useful for toxin detection in both frozen and fixed tissues, but ELISA was suitable only for frozen tissues or those fixed for less than 12 months. Identification of pyrogenic toxins in > 50% of SIDS infants from three different countries indicated further investigation into the role the toxins play in cot deaths might result in development of additional measures to reduce further the incidence of these infant deaths.

Infection, inflammation and sleep: more pieces to the puzzle of sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS)

Risk factors for sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS) parallel those for respiratory tract infections; however, infectious agents suggested to be involved in SIDS do not fulfil Koch's postulates. No single agent has been identified in all cases and there is no suitable animal model for SIDS which could be used to test the candidate organisms. Based on epidemiological and experimental work by our group and others, we suggested some SIDS deaths are due to pathophysiological responses elicited by combinations of microbial products and/or cigarette smoke during a developmental stage when infants' endocrine responses are less able to "damp down" the effects of inflammatory mediators. Here we review evidence from studies on interactions between developmental and environmental risk factors that could affect 1) mucosal colonization of infants by potentially pathogenic bacteria, and 2) induction and control of infants', inflammatory responses to infectious agents. New evidence suggests that there are genetic factors involved in the induction of inflammatory responses to some bacterial antigens implicated in SIDS. Further investigation of the role of infection, exposure to cigarette smoke and inflammation in infants, particularly differences in ethnic groups at increased risk of SIDS, could lead to new insights into the events leading to a fatal outcome and perhaps to new intervention schemes to reduce further the incidence of these deaths.