Patients' and nurses' constructions of death and dying in a hospice setting

Open awareness and dying: The use of denial and acceptance as coping strategies by hospice patients

This paper examines the use of denial and acceptance as interdependent and fluctuating coping strategies by dying patients in a hospice, and discusses some of the reasons why denial and acceptance operate for these patients. 'Open awareness' of dying is now accepted as a central feature of palliative care, and full disclosure of prognosis and diagnosis is seen as a desirable element of care for patients who are dying. However, such openness is not without its tensions and conflicts. The study was conducted in a hospice where patients and nurses interact within an 'open awareness' context and where most patients live in the knowledge of 'certain death but at an unknown time'. The paper examines use of denial and acceptance by hospice patients at various times during their dying.

The data are derived from the findings of a prospective qualitative study on the experiences of 12 hospice patients and those of their nurses. Unstructured interviews and participant observation were used as the primary methods of collecting data. Data from interviews were coded and comparative analyses between cases were performed.

Denial and acceptance of dying among patients fluctuated during the period of dying and appeared to form an important aspect of their coping process. Denial and acceptance appeared to be used to avoid threats as well as to preserve existing relationships within the context of open awareness.

In contrast to some commonly held beliefs, which tend to view denial and acceptance as 'singular, either/or entities', denial and acceptance are best seen as interdependent and fluctuating strategies, used continually by dying patients.

The Decision-Making Process when Starting Terminal Care as Assessed by Nursing Staff

This article deals with making decisions about starting terminal care. The results are part of a larger survey on nurses’ conceptions of terminal care in community health centres in Finland. The importance, frequency and timing of decision making as well as communication and the number of investigations and procedures carried out are examined. The relationship between decision making and the size of a health centre’s catchment population is also discussed. The results make it possible to compare the current situation in Finland with the national law on patients’ rights. The sample consisted of 328 nurses who worked on the wards of 32 community health centres. The data were collected by means of a structured questionnaire and processed with the Statistical Package for Social Sciences software. The nurses agreed that explicit decision making and documentation about starting terminal care were necessary, but it was highlighted that the practice had many shortcomings. Decisions were often made too late and the patients were not always aware of their situation; family members and the nursing staff were mostly better informed. It was noted that many investigations and other procedures were carried out on terminally ill patients, often at the request of family members. Decision making was found to have some relationship to the size of a health centre’s catchment area.

Death awareness, feelings of uncertainty, and hope in advanced lung cancer patients: can they coexist?

Patients diagnosed with stage-IV lung cancer are forced to quickly transition from a cancer-free and perhaps healthy life to one of serious illness, uncertainty, and anticipation of a premature death. Health professionals may be too quick to label the patient as being in denial if they hope for healing. Hope may not be lost when reality is accepted. Studies have investigated what it is like to live with awareness of impending death. Using a patient case study this paper discusses the concepts of death awareness, uncertainty, and hope. The aim is to provide a deeper understanding of how these seemingly antithetical emotions can coexist to the benefit of the patient, and to provide clinicians with practical considerations for supporting patients' hope throughout their terminal illness.

The constraints of the ordinary: 'being with' in the context of end-of-life nursing care

The concept of 'being with' was an essential part of the hospice philosophy developed by Cicely Saunders, and one that she believed was a key element in the care of the dying. In Saunders' philosophy, 'being with' is a specific moment of engagement between a health professional and a patient whereby the patient has the opportunity to examine and express their thoughts and feelings relating to their imminent death. This study examined how 'being with' was implemented as a part of ordinary day-to-day practice in a hospice in Scotland. The study was based on the principles of ethnomethodology, which aims to reveal embedded and taken-for-granted rules and behaviours that determine practice. The data collection and analysis revealed that the nursing practice was constructed in such a way that 'being with', as Saunders understood it, could not be initiated either by a member of the nursing staff or by the patients. By adopting the philosophical framework of Heidegger, the study offers an understanding of how the nursing staff had developed 'being with' as provision of comfort in order to protect both themselves and the patients from engaging with painful emotions associated with facing death.

Measuring End-of-Life Care Outcomes Prospectively

This paper discusses the state of the science in prospective measurement in end-of-life research and identifies particular areas for focused attention. Topics include defining the scope of inquiry, evaluating experiences of patients too ill to communicate, the role of proxy and family response, measurement sensitivity to change, the role of theory in guiding measurement efforts, evaluating relationships between domains of end-of-life experience, and measurement of cultural comprehensiveness. The state of the sciences calls for future research to (1) conduct longitudinal studies to capture transitions in end-of-life trajectories; (2) evaluate the quality of proxy reporting as it varies by rater relationship, domain, and over time; (3) use state-of-the art psychometric and longitudinal techniques to validate measures and to assess sensitivity to change; (4) develop further and test conceptual models of the experience of dying; (5) study the inter-relatedness of multiple dimensions of end-of-life trajectories; (6) compile updated information evaluating available measurement tools; and (7) conduct population- based research with attention to ethnic and age diversity.

Terminal patients' awareness of impending death: the impact upon requesting adequate care

In this qualitative study, 19 Dutch terminal patients and 23 relatives of deceased patients were interviewed. The interviews revealed that a timely request for care and anticipation of "what was going to happen" was determined by the degree to which patients and their relatives realize that the end of life was close, that the symptoms would get worse, and that the family would have to bear an increasing burden. When awareness of the severity of the situation dawns late, shortly before death, the patient and family may not receive the right sort of care, nor have access to the appropriate facilities. In the concluding part of this article, there is a plea for adopting a proactive approach. Nurses and other caregivers must try to prepare patients and relatives early for the care that will become necessary in the later stages.

Pain management problems in patients' terminal phase as assessed by nurses in Finland

BACKGROUND

This study is part of a larger questionnaire survey concerned with the views of nursing staff on physical, emotional and spiritual support for terminally ill patients and decision making on the transition to the terminal phase of treatment.

AIM

This article discusses the results concerning the prevalence of physical pain in patients and with problems in pain management.

METHODS

A total of 328 nurses working on the inpatient wards of 32 municipal health centres in finland took part. Data were collected with multiple-choice items and one open-ended question, which were part of a larger structured questionnaire. The data were analysed by means of the SPSS statistical software and content analysis.

FINDINGS

Dying patients often suffered from pain, which was most commonly because of cancer. Intractable pain was common. The problems of pain management concerned attitudes and qualifications related to treating pain, the assessment of the pain, pain management per se and the organization of pain management.

CONCLUSION

The study highlights the need to increase pain education, discussion and agreement on the principles of pain management in municipal health centres in Finland.

Health promotion in palliative care: the patients' perception of therapeutic interaction with the palliative nurse in the primary care setting

AIMS

To identify and describe palliative patients' perception of factors within the interaction with the community palliative care nurse that enhance feelings of health and well-being, and to begin to define health promotion in relation to palliative nursing in the primary care setting.

BACKGROUND

Health promotion may seem to be of little relevance in palliative care and for patients within its remit, and there is no definition of health promotion in relation to palliative care, yet therapeutic 'new' nursing, and its core elements of holism, egalitarianism and a humanistic approach accord with the philosophy of palliative care and are recognised as health promoting nursing practice.

DESIGN/METHODS

A qualitative methodology was used. Information was obtained from 12 patients by a qualitative semi-structured interview. Data were organised and analysed using recognised guidelines for phenomenological analysis.

FINDINGS

The patients identified two types of therapeutic interaction with the nurse, which enhanced feelings of health and well-being in different ways. Psychological well-being was enhanced by the humanistic and egalitarian personal interaction with the nurse, and the professional interaction focused on the disease and addressed physical problems. Although recognizing the nurses' role in the relief of physical symptoms, the patients' perception of 'feeling better' generally focussed on enhancement of psychological health and well-being.

CONCLUSION

For the patients, a combination of 'new' (therapeutic) nursing and a more traditional expert-led approach resulted in the promotion of an enhanced sense of physical and psychological health and well-being, and was an integral part of community palliative care nursing. Based on the study findings, the researcher offers a definition of health promotion relevant to palliative nursing in the primary care setting, which identifies that for the patients (but with caveats related to generalizability), the practice of holistically therapeutic palliative nursing is the ideal.

Research design in end-of-life research: state of science

PURPOSE

The volume of research on end-of-life care, death, and dying has exploded during the past decade. This article reviews the conceptual and methodological adequacy of end-of-life research to date, focusing on limitations of research to date and ways of improving future research.

DESIGN AND METHODS

A systematic search was conducted to identify the base of end-of-life research. Approximately 400 empirical articles were identified and are the basis of this review.

RESULTS

Although much has been learned from research to date, limitations in the knowledge base are substantial. The most fundamental problems identified are conceptual and include failure to define dying; neglect of the distinctions among quality of life, quality of death, and quality of end-of-life care. Methodologically, the single greatest problem is the lack of longitudinal studies that cover more than the time period immediately before death.

IMPLICATIONS

Gaps in the research base include insufficient attention to psychological and spiritual issues, the prevalence of psychiatric disorder and the effectiveness of the treatment of such disorders among dying persons, provider and health system variables, social and cultural diversity, and the effects of comorbidity on trajectories of dying.

Managing awareness: negotiating and coping with a terminal prognosis

This study examined the way in which a terminal cancer prognosis was negotiated by patients and their lay carers, and the complexities involved in managing a context of awareness. Individual semi-structured interviews were undertaken with 16 patients and 14 lay carers. These were transcribed verbatim and analysed using a grounded theory approach. The process started with being given bad news, when the concept of life was no longer open-ended. The need to maintain hope influenced the amount of information sought by patients and their families and was an important strategy in helping patients cope with the knowledge of their disease. Levels of awareness appeared to be influenced less by setting, than by the way the prognosis was managed within individual families. Difficulties facing patients and carers in knowing how to communicate with each other within a context of open awareness suggest that they need help in learning how to do this. Achieving an environment to enable this requires private space and staff skilled in enabling and facilitating the complexities of communication between patients and their carers.

Cancer patients', family members' and professional helpers' conceptions and beliefs concerning death

The purpose of this study was to examine the attitudes of different groups of people towards death, as well as their opinions and beliefs concerning life after death. The study is part of a larger research project in which cancer patients' suffering and coping were under examination. Data were collected in semi-structured focused interviews with 32 patients with incurable cancer, 13 family members, 13 nurses and 13 doctors from two central hospitals and four community health centres. The interviews were tape-recorded and transcribed verbatim. Data were analysed by content analysis. Most of the interviewees were not afraid of death. The professionals were slightly more often afraid of death than the patients and the family members. The participants gave many reasons for their opinions. The interviewees were not very interested in reading death-related literature. Only nurses had read a great deal of literature on death. Most of the participants believed in the existence of God and in life after death. The participants had different kinds of conceptions of the events after death. The doctors differed from the other groups in that they read less literature on death and had less faith in God and in life after death.

Communication and awareness about dying in the 1990s

Since the 1960s communication and awareness about dying in modern western societies have been topics for debate, with a considerable amount of literature on the need for open communication and the strategies which can be used by health professionals to improve their communication with patients facing a terminal prognosis. Despite the difficulties of comparing studies using different methodologies and the additional problems of ascertaining patients' knowledge and awareness about their impending deaths, the trend is clear. In advanced industrial societies there is increasing evidence that doctors have shifted from a policy of 'withholding' to a policy of 'revealing' to the patient his or her terminal prognosis. This change in medical practice is further supported by other data which show an increase in the percentage of those patients who were aware they were dying from chronic diseases, especially cancer. However, despite the perceived trend towards open disclosure of the patient's terminal illness, recent studies have suggested that in their daily encounters with dying patients health workers employ 'conditional' rather than 'full open disclosure'. Such moderating strategies in discussing the patient's prognosis may be employed despite open awareness of a patient's prognosis. This paper examines this apparent paradox by analysing the complex tensions and conflicts of such communication through a discussion of existing literature on modes of communication and patient awareness.

A review of current theories of death and dying

Recently, attention has been focused on the care of dying individuals and their families. Although this area of care remains topical for health care professionals, there have been few attempts undertaken to explore critically both the seminal and more recent theories of death and dying in order to extend and develop the theoretical scope and orientation of this field further. The purpose of this paper is therefore twofold: first, to provide a general overview of the current theories of death and dying, and second, to discuss some specific and general contributions and limitations of the current theories. To this end, a review of seminal and more recent theoretical frameworks is presented in this paper. Implications for future research in theory development in the field of death and dying are highlighted.