Design of novel sequence-specific DNA-binding proteins

Refactoring transcription factors for metabolic engineering

Due to the ability to regulate target metabolic pathways globally and dynamically, metabolic regulation systems composed of transcription factors have been widely used in metabolic engineering and synthetic biology. This review introduced the categories, action principles, prediction strategies, and related databases of transcription factors. Then, the application of global transcription machinery engineering technology and the transcription factor-based biosensors and quorum sensing systems are overviewed. In addition, strategies for optimizing the transcriptional regulatory tools' performance by refactoring transcription factors are summarized. Finally, the current limitations and prospects of constructing various regulatory tools based on transcription factors are discussed. This review will provide theoretical guidance for the rational design and construction of transcription factor-based metabolic regulation systems.

Synergy of Two Highly Specific Biomolecular Recognition Events: Aligning an AT-Hook Peptide in DNA Minor Grooves via Covalent Conjugation to 2'-Amino-LNA

Two highly specific biomolecular recognition events, nucleic acid duplex hybridization and DNA-peptide recognition in the minor groove, were coalesced in a miniature ensemble for the first time by covalently attaching a natural AT-hook peptide motif to nucleic acid duplexes via a 2'-amino-LNA scaffold. A combination of molecular dynamics simulations and ultraviolet thermal denaturation studies revealed high sequence-specific affinity of the peptide-oligonucleotide conjugates (POCs) when binding to complementary DNA strands, leveraging the bioinformation encrypted in the minor groove of DNA duplexes. The significant cooperative DNA duplex stabilization may pave the way toward further development of POCs with enhanced affinity and selectivity toward target sequences carrying peptide-binding genetic islands.

Reprogramming cell fate with artificial transcription factors

Transcription factors (TFs) reprogram cell states by exerting control over gene regulatory networks and the epigenetic landscape of a cell. Artificial transcription factors (ATFs) are designer regulatory proteins comprised of modular units that can be customized to overcome challenges faced by natural TFs in establishing and maintaining desired cell states. Decades of research on DNA-binding proteins and synthetic molecules has provided a molecular toolkit for ATF design and the construction of genome-scale libraries of ATFs capable of phenotypic manipulation and reprogramming of cell states. Here, we compare the unique strengths and limitations of different ATF platforms, highlight the advantages of cooperative assembly, and present the potential of ATF libraries in revealing gene regulatory networks that govern cell fate choices.

A designed DNA binding motif that recognizes extended sites and spans two adjacent major grooves

We report the rational design of a DNA-binding peptide construct composed of the DNA-contacting regions of two transcription factors (GCN4 and GAGA) linked through an AT-hook DNA anchor. The resulting chimera, which represents a new, non-natural DNA binding motif, binds with high affinity and selectivity to a long composite sequence of 13 base pairs (TCAT-AATT-GAGAG).

Visualization of Genomic Loci in Living Cells with a Fluorescent CRISPR/Cas9 System

The discovery that the RNA guided bacterial endonuclease Cas9 can be harnessed to target and manipulate user-defined genomic sequences has greatly influenced the field of genome engineering. Interestingly, a catalytically dead Cas9 (dCas9) can be employed as a targeted DNA-binding platform to alter gene expression. By fusing this dCas9 to eGFP, we and others could show that the CRISPR/Cas9 system can be further expanded to label and trace genomic loci in living cells. We demonstrated that by exchanging the sgRNA, dCas9-eGFP could be specifically directed to various heterochromatic sequences within the nucleus. Here, we provide a basic protocol for this versatile tool and describe how to verify new dCas9-eGFP targets.

The AT-Hook motif as a versatile minor groove anchor for promoting DNA binding of transcription factor fragments

We report the development of chimeric DNA binding peptides comprising a DNA binding fragment of natural transcription factors (the basic region of a bZIP protein or a monomeric zinc finger module) and an AT-Hook peptide motif. The resulting peptide conjugates display high DNA affinity and excellent sequence selectivity. Furthermore, the AT-Hook motif also favors the cell internalization of the conjugates.

Sequence-selective DNA binding with cell-permeable oligoguanidinium–peptide conjugates

Conjugation of a short peptide fragment from a bZIP protein to an oligoguanidinium tail results in a DNA-binding miniprotein that selectively interacts with composite sequences containing the peptide-binding site next to an A/T-rich tract.

Analysis of an artificial zinc finger epigenetic modulator: widespread binding but limited regulation

Artificial transcription factors (ATFs) and genomic nucleases based on a DNA binding platform consisting of multiple zinc finger domains are currently being developed for clinical applications. However, no genome-wide investigations into their binding specificity have been performed. We have created six-finger ATFs to target two different 18 nt regions of the human SOX2 promoter; each ATF is constructed such that it contains or lacks a super KRAB domain (SKD) that interacts with a complex containing repressive histone methyltransferases. ChIP-seq analysis of the effector-free ATFs in MCF7 breast cancer cells identified thousands of binding sites, mostly in promoter regions; the addition of an SKD domain increased the number of binding sites ∼5-fold, with a majority of the new sites located outside of promoters. De novo motif analyses suggest that the lack of binding specificity is due to subsets of the finger domains being used for genomic interactions. Although the ATFs display widespread binding, few genes showed expression differences; genes repressed by the ATF-SKD have stronger binding sites and are more enriched for a 12 nt motif. Interestingly, epigenetic analyses indicate that the transcriptional repression caused by the ATF-SKD is not due to changes in active histone modifications.

Selective DNA-binding by designed bisbenzamidine-homeodomain chimeras

We report the construction of conjugates between three variants of the helix 3 region of a Q50K engrailed homeodomain and bisbenzamidine minor-groove DNA binders. The hybrid featuring the sequence of the native protein failed to bind to DNA; however, modifications that increased the α-helical folding propensity of the peptide allowed specific DNA binding by a bipartite (major/minor groove) interaction.

Visualization of specific DNA sequences in living mouse embryonic stem cells with a programmable fluorescent CRISPR/Cas system

Labeling and tracing of specific sequences in living cells has been a major challenge in studying the spatiotemporal dynamics of native chromatin. Here we repurposed the prokaryotic CRISPR/Cas adaptive immunity system to specifically detect endogenous genomic loci in mouse embryonic stem cells. We constructed a catalytically inactive version of the Cas9 endonuclease, fused it with eGFP (dCas9-eGFP) and co-expressed small guide RNAs (gRNAs) to target pericentric, centric, and telomeric repeats, which are enriched in distinct nuclear structures. With major satellite specific gRNAs we obtained a characteristic chromocenter (CC) pattern, while gRNAs targeting minor satellites and telomeres highlighted smaller foci coinciding with centromere protein B (CENP-B) and telomeric repeat-binding factor 2 (TRF2), respectively. DNA sequence specific labeling by gRNA/dCas9-eGFP complexes was directly shown with 3D-fluorescent in situ hybridization (3D-FISH). Structured illumination microscopy (3D-SIM) of gRNA/dCas9-eGFP expressing cells revealed chromatin ultrastructures and demonstrated the potential of this approach for chromatin conformation studies by super resolution microscopy. This programmable dCas9 labeling system opens new perspectives to study functional nuclear architecture.

Targeting and tracing of specific DNA sequences with dTALEs in living cells

Epigenetic regulation of gene expression involves, besides DNA and histone modifications, the relative positioning of DNA sequences within the nucleus. To trace specific DNA sequences in living cells, we used programmable sequence-specific DNA binding of designer transcription activator-like effectors (dTALEs). We designed a recombinant dTALE (msTALE) with variable repeat domains to specifically bind a 19-bp target sequence of major satellite DNA. The msTALE was fused with green fluorescent protein (GFP) and stably expressed in mouse embryonic stem cells. Hybridization with a major satellite probe (3D-fluorescent in situ hybridization) and co-staining for known cellular structures confirmed in vivo binding of the GFP-msTALE to major satellite DNA present at nuclear chromocenters. Dual tracing of major satellite DNA and the replication machinery throughout S-phase showed co-localization during mid to late S-phase, directly demonstrating the late replication timing of major satellite DNA. Fluorescence bleaching experiments indicated a relatively stable but still dynamic binding, with mean residence times in the range of minutes. Fluorescently labeled dTALEs open new perspectives to target and trace DNA sequences and to monitor dynamic changes in subnuclear positioning as well as interactions with functional nuclear structures during cell cycle progression and cellular differentiation.

Sequence-selective DNA recognition with peptide-bisbenzamidine conjugates

Transcription factors (TFs) are specialized proteins that play a key role in the regulation of genetic expression. Their mechanism of action involves the interaction with specific DNA sequences, which usually takes place through specialized domains of the protein. However, achieving an efficient binding usually requires the presence of the full protein. This is the case for bZIP and zinc finger TF families, which cannot interact with their target sites when the DNA binding fragments are presented as isolated monomers. Herein it is demonstrated that the DNA binding of these monomeric peptides can be restored when conjugated to aza-bisbenzamidines, which are readily accessible molecules that interact with A/T-rich sites by insertion into their minor groove. Importantly, the fluorogenic properties of the aza-benzamidine unit provide details of the DNA interaction that are eluded in electrophoresis mobility shift assays (EMSA). The hybrids based on the GCN4 bZIP protein preferentially bind to composite sequences containing tandem bisbenzamidine-GCN4 binding sites (TCAT⋅AAATT). Fluorescence reverse titrations show an interesting multiphasic profile consistent with the formation of competitive nonspecific complexes at low DNA/peptide ratios. On the other hand, the conjugate with the DNA binding domain of the zinc finger protein GAGA binds with high affinity (KD≈12 nM) and specificity to a composite AATTT⋅GAGA sequence containing both the bisbenzamidine and the TF consensus binding sites.

Binding and NMR structural studies on indoloquinoline-oligonucleotide conjugates targeting duplex DNA

An 11-phenyl-indolo[3,2-b]quinoline (PIQ) was tethered through an aminoalkyl linker to the 5'-end of four pyrimidine oligonucleotides with T/C scrambled sequences at their two 5'-terminal positions. Binding to different double-helical DNA targets formed parallel triple helices with a PIQ-mediated stabilization that strongly depends on pH and the terminal base triad at the 5'-triplex-duplex junction. The most effective stabilization was observed with a TAT triplet at the 5'-junction under low pH conditions, pointing to a protonated ligand with a high triplex binding affinity and unfavorable charge repulsions in the case of a terminal C(+)GC triplet at the junction. The latter preference of the PIQ ligand for TAT over CGC is alleviated yet still preserved at higher pH. Intercalation of PIQ at the 5'-triplex-duplex junction as suggested by the triplex melting experiments was confirmed by homonuclear and heteronuclear NMR structural studies on a specifically isotope-labeled triplex. The NMR analysis revealed two coexisting species that only differ by a 180° rotation of the indoloquinoline within the intercalation pocket. NOE-derived molecular models indicate extensive stacking interactions of the indoloquinoline moiety with the TAT base triplet and CG base pair at the junction and a phenyl substituent that is positioned in the major groove and oriented almost perpendicular to the plane of the indoloquinoline.

Mini review: protein-protein interactions in transcription: a fertile ground for helix mimetics

Designed ligands that inhibit protein-protein interactions involved in gene expression are valuable as reagents for genomics research and as leads for drug discovery efforts. Selective modulation of protein-protein interactions has proven to be a daunting task for synthetic ligands; however, the last decade has seen significant advances in inhibitor design, especially for helical protein interfaces. This review discusses examples of transcriptional complexes targeted by designer helices.

Bipartite selection of zinc fingers by phage display for any 9-bp DNA target site

Phage display has been used to engineer DNA-binding proteins with new sequence specificities, which has allowed applications in the blockage or enhancement of gene expression as well as targeting specific sites on DNA for methylation, recombination, and cleavage. To effectively and quickly conduct selections that consider the synergistic mode of DNA binding by zinc fingers, Isalan and Choo in Aaron Klug's lab devised a bipartite phage display approach that enables selection and recombination of variants of zinc finger DNA-binding domains from a pair of premade complementary phage libraries for any given 9-bp DNA sequence. The bipartite phage display has the advantage of rapid, high-throughput selection of sequence-specific zinc finger DNA-binding domains for use in diverse applications of expression control and gene targeting.

Acridine-N peptide conjugates display enhanced affinity and specificity for boxB RNA targets

Arginine-rich peptides and small-molecule intercalating agents utilize distinct molecular mechanisms for RNA recognition. Here, we combined these distinct binding modules in an effort to create conjugate ligands with enhanced affinity and specificity using the bacteriophage lambda N peptide-boxB interaction as a model system. We first designed and synthesized a series of peptide-acridine conjugates using portions of the RNA-binding domain of N protein (11- and 22- residue peptide segments) and then compared the binding affinity, specificity, salt dependence, and structural properties of the RNA-peptide and RNA-peptide-acridine conjugate complexes using steady-state fluorescence, CD spectroscopy, NMR, and native gel mobility shift assays (GMSAs). These analyses revealed that the full-length peptide-acridine conjugate displayed substantially improved RNA binding affinity ( approximately 80-fold; K(d) approximately 15 pM) relative to that of the peptide alone (K(d) approximately 1.2 nM). In accordance, we also observed specificity enhancement ( approximately 25-fold) as determined via comparison of the binding of the best conjugate to a cognate lambda boxB RNA with that to a noncognate P22 RNA hairpin (80-fold vs 3.2-fold enhancement). Furthermore, the observed binding enhancement was unique to the full-length conjugate with a flexible linker, implying that the structural context of the acridine presentation was critical. Taken together, our observations support the idea that peptide- and intercalation-based binding can be combined to create a new class of high-affinity, high-specificity RNA-binding ligands.

Using ChIP-seq technology to identify targets of zinc finger transcription factors

Half of all human transcription factors are zinc finger proteins and yet very little is known concerning the biological role of the majority of these factors. In particular, very few genome-wide studies of the in vivo binding of zinc finger factors have been performed. Based on in vitro studies and other methods that allow selection of high affinity-binding sites in artificial conditions, a zinc finger code has been developed that can be used to compose a putative recognition motif for a particular zinc finger factor (ZNF). Theoretically, a simple bioinformatics analysis could then predict the genomic locations of all the binding sites for that ZNF. However, it is unlikely that all of the sequences in the human genome having a good match to a predicted motif are in fact occupied in vivo (due to negative influences from repressive chromatin, nucleosomal positioning, overlap of binding sites with other factors, etc). A powerful method to identify in vivo binding sites for transcription factors on a genome-wide scale is the chromatin immunoprecipitation (ChIP) assay, followed by hybridization of the precipitated DNA to microarrays (ChIP-chip) or by high throughput DNA sequencing of the sample (ChIP-seq). Such comprehensive in vivo binding studies would not only identify target genes of a particular zinc finger factor, but also provide binding motif data that could be used to test the validity of the zinc finger code. This chapter describes in detail the steps needed to prepare ChIP samples and libraries for high throughput sequencing using the Illumina GA2 platform and includes descriptions of quality control steps necessary to ensure a successful ChIP-seq experiment.

Genomic targets of the KRAB and SCAN domain-containing zinc finger protein 263

Half of all human transcription factors use C2H2 zinc finger domains to specify site-specific DNA binding and yet very little is known about their role in gene regulation. Based on in vitro studies, a zinc finger code has been developed that predicts a binding motif for a particular zinc finger factor (ZNF). However, very few studies have performed genome-wide analyses of ZNF binding patterns, and thus, it is not clear if the binding code developed in vitro will be useful for identifying target genes of a particular ZNF. We performed genome-wide ChIP-seq for ZNF263, a C2H2 ZNF that contains 9 finger domains, a KRAB repression domain, and a SCAN domain and identified more than 5000 binding sites in K562 cells. Our results suggest that ZNF263 binds to a 24-nt site that differs from the motif predicted by the zinc finger code in several positions. Interestingly, many of the ZNF263 binding sites are located within the transcribed region of the target gene. Although ZNFs containing a KRAB domain are thought to function mainly as transcriptional repressors, many of the ZNF263 target genes are expressed at high levels. To address the biological role of ZNF263, we identified genes whose expression was altered by treatment of cells with ZNF263-specific small interfering RNAs. Our results suggest that ZNF263 can have both positive and negative effects on transcriptional regulation of its target genes.

Energy-based prediction of amino acid-nucleotide base recognition

Despite decades of investigations, it is not yet clear whether there are rules dictating the specificity of the interaction between amino acids and nucleotide bases. This issue was addressed by determining, in a dataset consisting of 100 high-resolution protein-DNA structures, the frequency and energy of interaction between each amino acid and base, and the energetics of water-mediated interactions. The analysis was carried out using HINT, a non-Newtonian force field encoding both enthalpic and entropic contributions, and Rank, a geometry-based tool for evaluating hydrogen bond interactions. A frequency- and energy-based preferential interaction of Arg and Lys with G, Asp and Glu with C, and Asn and Gln with A was found. Not only favorable, but also unfavorable contacts were found to be conserved. Water-mediated interactions strongly increase the probability of Thr-A, Lys-A, and Lys-C contacts. The frequency, interaction energy, and water enhancement factors associated with each amino acid-base pair were used to predict the base triplet recognized by the helix motif in 45 zinc fingers, which represents an ideal case study for the analysis of one-to-one amino acid-base pair contacts. The model correctly predicted 70.4% of 135 amino acid-base pairs, and, by weighting the energetic relevance of each amino acid-base pair to the overall recognition energy, it yielded a prediction rate of 89.7%.

Chiral introduction of positive charges to PNA for double-duplex invasion to versatile sequences

Invasion of two PNA strands to double-stranded DNA is one of the most promising methods to recognize a predetermined site in double-stranded DNA (PNA = peptide nucleic acid). In order to facilitate this 'double-duplex invasion', a new type of PNA was prepared by using chiral PNA monomers in which a nucleobase was bound to the alpha-nitrogen of N-(2-aminoethyl)-d-lysine. These positively charged monomer units, introduced to defined positions in Nielsen's PNAs (poly[N-(2-aminoethyl)glycine] derivatives), promoted the invasion without impairing mismatch-recognizing activity. When pseudo-complementary nucleobases 2,6-diaminopurine and 2-thiouracil were bound to N-(2-aminoethyl)-d-lysine, the invasion successfully occurred even at highly G-C-rich regions [e.g. (G/C)7(A/T)3 and (G/C)8(A/T)2] which were otherwise hardly targeted. Thus, the scope of sequences available as the target site has been greatly expanded. In contrast with the promotion by the chiral PNA monomers derived from N-(2-aminoethyl)-d-lysine, their l-isomers hardly invaded, showing crucial importance of the d-chirality. The promotion of double-duplex invasion by the chiral (d) PNA monomer units was ascribed to both destabilization of PNA/PNA duplex and stabilization of PNA/DNA duplexes.

A novel stable RNA pentaloop that interacts specifically with a motif peptide of lambda-N protein

To achieve a novel specific peptide-nucleic acid binding model, we designed an in vitro selection procedure to decrease the energetic contribution of the electrostatic interaction in the total binding energy and to increase the contribution of hydrogen bonding and pi-pi stacking. After the selection of hairpin-loop RNAs that specifically bound to a model peptide of lambda N protein (N peptide), a new thermostable pentaloop RNA motif (N binding thermostable RNA hairpin: NTS RNA) was revealed. The obtained NTS RNA was able to bind to the N peptide with superior specificity to the boxB RNA, which is the naturally occurring partner of the lambda N protein.

Exploring the recognition of quadruplex DNA by an engineered Cys2-His2 zinc finger protein

We have recently described an engineered zinc finger protein (Gq1) that binds with high specificity to the intramolecular G-quadruplex formed by the human telomeric sequence 5'-(GGTTAG)(5)-3', and that inhibits the activity of the enzyme telomerase in vitro. Here we report site-directed mutagenesis, biophysical, and molecular modeling studies that provide new insights into quadruplex recognition by the zinc finger scaffold. We show that any one finger of Gq1 can be replaced with the corresponding finger of Zif268, without significant loss of quadruplex affinity or quadruplex versus duplex discrimination. Replacement of two fingers, with one being finger 2, of Gq1 by Zif268 results in significant impairment of quadruplex recognition and loss of discrimination. Molecular modeling suggests that the zinc fingers of Gq1 can bind to the human parallel-stranded quadruplex structure in a stable arrangement, whereas Zif268-quadruplex models show significantly weaker binding energy. Modeling also suggests that an important role of the key protein finger residues in the Gq1-quadruplex complex is to maintain Gq1 in an optimum conformation for quadruplex recognition.

Designer zinc-finger proteins and their applications

The Cys(2)His(2) zinc finger is one of the most common DNA-binding motifs in Eukaryota. A simple mode of DNA recognition by the Cys(2)His(2) zinc finger domain provides an ideal scaffold for designing proteins with novel sequence specificities. The ability to bind specifically to virtually any DNA sequence combined with the potential of fusing them with effector domains has led to the technology of engineering of chimeric DNA-modifying enzymes and transcription factors. This in turn has opened the possibility of using the engineered zinc finger-based factors as novel human therapeutics. One such synthetic factor-designer zinc finger transcription activator of the vascular endothelial growth factor A gene-has recently entered clinical trials to evaluate the ability of stimulating the growth of blood vessels in treating the peripheral arterial obstructive disease. This review concentrates on the aspects of natural Cys(2)His(2) zinc fingers evolution and fundamental steps in design of engineered zinc finger proteins. The applications of engineered zinc finger proteins are discussed in a context of the mechanism mediating their effect on the targeted DNA. Furthermore, the regulation of the expression of zinc finger proteins and their targeting to various cellular compartments and to chromatin and non-chromatin target templates are described. Also possible future applications of designer zinc finger proteins are discussed.

Effects of linking 15-zinc finger domains on DNA binding specificity and multiple DNA binding modes

To assess the possibility of multi-connection of zinc finger domains for understanding of DNA binding mechanisms and gene regulation, the longest artificial zinc finger protein, Sp1ZF15, has been constructed. This zinc finger consists of 5 units of Sp1 zinc finger peptide connected by canonical short linker sequences (TGEKP). Recognition of the 50 base pairs of DNA and potential binding to shorter targets by Sp1ZF15 were determined. Sequence alterations of the GCG triplet to ATA at a target site clearly showed that Sp1ZF15 changes its DNA binding mode depending on the target sequences. Of special interest is the fact that Sp1ZF15 controls the number of finger domains active in DNA binding corresponding to the length and sequence of the target DNA. These results suggest that artificial transcription factors based upon these multi-zinc finger proteins have great potential for the regulation of a vast number of cellular processes.

Adding specificity to artificial transcription activators

In this issue, Mapp and colleagues describe a significant advance in the design of artificial transcription activators that function in a cell-type-specific manner. [1] The authors show that peptides selected for binding a component of the yeast transcription complex require its presence for effective transcriptional activation.

Artificial zinc finger fusions targeting Sp1-binding sites and the trans-activator-responsive element potently repress transcription and replication of HIV-1

Tat activates transcription by interacting with Sp1, NF-kappaB, positive transcription elongation factor b, and trans-activator-responsive element (TAR). Tat and Sp1 play major roles in transcription by protein-protein interactions at human immunodeficiency virus, type 1 (HIV-1) long terminal repeat. Sp1 activates transcription by interacting with cyclin T1 in the absence of Tat. To disrupt the transcription activation by Tat and Sp1, we fused Sp1-inhibiting polypeptides, zinc finger polypeptide, and the TAR-binding mutant Tat (TatdMt) together. A designed or natural zinc finger and Tat mutant fusion was used to target the fusion to the key regulatory sites (GC box and TAR) on the long terminal repeat and nascent short transcripts to disrupt the molecular interaction that normally result in robust transcription. The designed zinc finger and TatdMt fusions were targeted to the TAR, and they potently repressed both transcription and replication of HIV-1. The Sp1-inhibiting POZ domain, TatdMt, and zinc fingers are key functional domains important in repression of transcription and replication. The designed artificial zinc fingers were targeted to the high affinity Sp1-binding site, and by being fused with TatdMt and POZ domain, they strongly block both Sp1-cyclin T1-dependent transcription and Tat-dependent transcription, even in the presence of excess expressed Tat.

NMR Structure of Transcription Factor Sp1 DNA Binding Domain†,‡

To understand the DNA recognition mechanism of zinc finger motifs of transcription factor Sp1, we have determined the solution structure of DNA-binding domain of the Sp1 by solution NMR techniques. The DNA-binding domain of Sp1 consists of three Cys(2)His(2)-type zinc finger motifs. They have typical betabetaalpha zinc finger folds and relatively random orientations. From DNA-binding analysis performed by NMR and comparison between structures determined here and previously reported structures of other zinc fingers, it was assumed that DNA recognition modes of fingers 2 and 3 would be similar to those of fingers of Zif268, in which each finger recognizes four base pairs strictly by using residues at positions -1, 2, 3, and 6 of the recognition helix. On the contrary, finger 1 can use only two residues for DNA recognition, Lys550 and His553 at positions -1 and 3 of the helix, and has more relaxed sequence and site specificity than other Cys(2)His(2) zinc fingers. It is proposed that this relaxed property of finger 1 allows transcription factor Sp1 to bind various DNA sequences with high affinity.

Synthetic zinc finger peptides: old and novel applications

In the last decade, the efforts in clarifying the interaction between zinc finger proteins and DNA targets strongly stimulated the creativity of scientists in the field of protein engineering. In particular, the versatility and the modularity of zinc finger (ZF) motives make these domains optimal building blocks for generating artificial zinc finger peptides (ZFPs). ZFPs can act as transcription modulators potentially able to control the expression of any desired gene, when fused to an appropriate effector domain. Artificial ZFPs open the possibility to re-program the expression of specific genes at will and can represent a powerful tool in basic science, biotechnology and gene therapy. In this review we will focus on old, novel and possible future applications of artificial ZFPs.Key words: synthetic zinc finger, recognition code, artificial transcription factor, chromatin modification, gene therapy.

Exchange of Histidine Spacing between Sp1 and GLI Zinc Fingers: Distinct Effect of Histidine Spacing-Linker Region on DNA Binding

In the DNA recognition mode of C(2)H(2)-type zinc fingers, the finger-finger connection region, consisting of the histidine spacing (HX(3-5)H) and linker, would be important for determining the orientation of the zinc finger domains. To clarify the influence of spacing between two ligand histidines in the DNA binding, we exchanged the histidine spacing between Sp1 and GLI zinc fingers, which have an HX(3)H-TGEKK linker (typical) and an HX(4)H-SNEKP linker (atypical), respectively. A significant decrease in the DNA binding affinity and specificity is found in Sp1-type peptides, whereas GLI-type peptides show a mild reduction. To evaluate the effect of the linker characteristics, we further designed Sp1-type mutants with an SNEKP linker. As a result, the significant effect of the histidine spacing in Sp1-type peptides was reduced. These results demonstrate that (1) the histidine spacing significantly affects the DNA binding of zinc finger proteins and (2) the histidine spacing and the following linker regions are one effective target for regulating the DNA recognition mode of zinc finger proteins.

Effects of length and position of an extended linker on sequence-selective DNA recognition of zinc finger peptides

Engineered zinc finger proteins revealed that a linker sequence connecting zinc finger units has a significant effect on the DNA binding property of the protein. The recognition for a noncontiguous DNA target beyond the current recognition code of zinc finger proteins has never been determined because of the limitation of a zinc finger framework. DNA recognition of zinc finger proteins is limited only to a contiguous subset of three base pairs. We propose the recognition for a noncontiguous DNA target by inserting amino acids into the canonical linker between zinc finger units. The sequence selectivity of the new zinc finger peptides was evaluated by gel mobility shift assays. DNase I footprinting analyses clearly showed different DNA binding of various linker-extended zinc finger peptides. The application of a SPR measurement also revealed a DNA sequence selectivity of peptides. Insertion of three amino acids is enough for recognition of a noncontiguous DNA target with sequence selectivity. An extended linker will be useful for expansion of the recognition code of zinc finger proteins and for development of a new role for linker sequences in DNA binding of zinc finger proteins.

Assessing the plasticity of DNA target site recognition of the PI-SceI homing endonuclease using a bacterial two-hybrid selection system

The PI-SceI protein from Saccharomyces cerevisiae is a member of the LAGLIDADG family of homing endonucleases that have been used in genomic engineering. To assess the flexibility of the PI-SceI-binding interaction and to make progress towards the directed evolution of homing endonucleases that cleave specified DNA targets, we applied a two-hybrid method to select PI-SceI variants from a randomized expression library that bind to different DNA substrates. In particular, the codon for Arg94, which is located in the protein splicing domain and makes essential contacts to two adjacent base-pairs, and the codons for four proximal residues were randomized. There is little conservation of the wild-type amino acid residues at the five randomized positions in the variants that were selected to bind to the wild-type site, yet one of the purified derivatives displays DNA-binding specificity and DNA endonuclease activity that is similar to that of the wild-type enzyme. A spectrum of DNA-binding behaviors ranging from partial relaxation of specificity to marked shifts in target site recognition are present in variants selected to bind to sites containing mutations at the two base-pairs. Our results illustrate the inherent plasticity of the PI-SceI/DNA interface and demonstrate that selection based on DNA binding is an effective means of altering the DNA cleavage specificity of homing endonucleases. Furthermore, it is apparent that homing endonuclease target specificity derives, in part, from constraints on the flexibility of DNA contacts imposed by hydrogen bonds to proximal residues.

Differential Modes of Recognition in N Peptide−BoxB Complexes

N proteins from bacteriophages lambda, P22, and phi21 modulate transcription elongation by binding nascent "boxB" mRNA hairpins. This RNA recognition is mediated by N-terminal arginine-rich peptide sequences capable of interacting with their cognate boxB RNA targets. Here, we have analyzed the affinity and specificity of the peptide-RNA interactions that modulate this transcriptional switch. To do this, we constructed a series of peptides based on the wild-type lambda, P22, and phi21 N protein binding domains ranging from 11 to 22 residues and analyzed their interactions with the leftward and rightward boxB RNA hairpin targets for all three phage. Binding constant (K(d)) values were determined using RNA hairpins labeled with 2-aminopurine (2AP) and monitoring the fluorescence change as peptide was added. K(d)'s demonstrate that lambda and P22 N peptides bind to their cognate boxB targets with high specificity and show equal affinities for their leftward and rightward hairpins. Surprisingly, phi21 shows very little specificity for its cognate targets. Lambda and P22 N peptides exhibit differential modes of recognition with specificity conferred by their amino- and carboxy-terminal modules, respectively. We have generated a reciprocal matrix of substituted peptides to examine the contributions of individual residues to specificity. Amino acid coupling analysis supports a binding model where the Arg8 residue of lambda peptide acts as a conformational hot spot, anchoring the induced loop fold of its boxB hairpin target.

Recognition of double-stranded RNA by proteins and small molecules

Molecular recognition of double-stranded RNA (dsRNA) is a key event for numerous biological pathways including the trafficking, editing, and maturation of cellular RNA, the interferon antiviral response, and RNA interference. Over the past several years, our laboratory has studied proteins and small molecules that bind dsRNA with the goal of understanding and controlling the binding selectivity. In this review, we discuss members of the dsRBM class of proteins that bind dsRNA. The dsRBM is an approximately 70 amino acid sequence motif found in a variety of dsRNA-binding proteins. Recent results have led to a new appreciation of the ability of these proteins to bind selectivity to certain sites on dsRNA. This property is discussed in light of the RNA selectivity observed in the function of two proteins that contain dsRBMs, the RNA-dependent protein kinase (PKR) and an adenosine deaminase that acts on dsRNA (ADAR2). In addition, we introduce peptide-acridine conjugates (PACs), small molecules designed to control dsRBM-RNA interactions. These intercalating molecules bear variable peptide appendages at opposite edges of an acridine heterocycle. This design imparts the potential to exploit differences in groove characteristics and/or base-pair dynamics at binding sites to achieve selective binding.

Directional shape complementarity at the protein-DNA interface

Nature utilizes various styles of architecture for DNA-binding proteins to recognize diverse DNA sequences, a process facilitated by a complementary surface between protein and DNA. However, the extent and ways this 'shape complementarity' occurs at the protein-DNA interface have yet to be characterized. Here, by analyzing a set of diverse protein-DNA complexes of known three-dimensional structures, we investigated whether the normal vectors of a protein surface at the interface exhibited any relationship with DNA conformation. Generally, the normal vectors of a DNA-contacting protein surface distinctly preferred certain angles, enabling them to align with certain axes characterizing the conformation of DNA. Thus, a new geometric property of DNA-binding protein is demonstrated, i.e. the "shape complementarity" of protein-DNA recognition clearly bears the property of "directionality".

Assessment by molecular dynamics simulations of the structural determinants of DNA-binding specificity for transcription factor Sp1

The DNA-binding domain (DBD) of the ubiquituous transcription factor Sp1 consists of three consecutive zinc fingers that recognize a number of nucleotide sequences different from, but related to and sometimes overlapping, those recognized by the structurally better characterized early growth response protein 1 (EGR1, also known as Zif268, Krox-24, and NGFI-A). The accepted consensus binding sequence for Sp1 is usually defined by the asymmetric hexanucleotide core GGGCGG but this sequence does not include, among others, the GAG (=CTC) repeat that constitutes a high-affinity site for Sp1 binding to the wt1 promoter. Since no 3D structure of the whole DBD of Sp1 is available, either alone or in complex with DNA, a homology-based model was built and its interaction with two DNA 14-mers was studied using nanosecond molecular dynamics simulations in the presence of explicit water molecules. These oligonucleotides represent Sp1 target sites that are present in the promoters of the mdr1 and wt1 genes. For comparative purposes and validation of the protocol, the complex between the DBD of EGR1 and its DNA target site within the proximal mdr1 promoter was simulated under the same conditions. Some water molecules were seen to play an important role in recognition and stabilization of the protein-DNA complexes. Our results, which are supported by the available experimental evidence, suggest that the accuracy in the prediction of putative Sp1-binding sites can be improved by interpreting a set of rules, which are a blend of both stringency and tolerance, for the juxtaposed triplet subsites to which each zinc finger binds. Our approach can be extrapolated to WT1 and other related natural or artificial zinc-finger-containing DNA-binding proteins and may aid in the assignment of particular DNA stretches as allowed or disallowed-binding sites.

Zinc fingers and a green thumb: manipulating gene expression in plants

Artificial transcription factors can be rapidly constructed from predefined zinc-finger modules to regulate virtually any gene. Stable, heritable up- and downregulation of endogenous genes has been demonstrated in transgenic plants. These advances promise new approaches for creating functional knockouts and conditional overexpression, and for other gene discovery and manipulation applications in plants.

Evaluation of a modular strategy for the construction of novel polydactyl zinc finger DNA-binding proteins

In previous studies, we have developed a technology for the rapid construction of novel DNA-binding proteins with the potential to recognize any unique site in a given genome. This technology relies on the modular assembly of modified zinc finger DNA-binding domains, each of which recognizes a three bp subsite of DNA. A complete set of 64 domains would provide comprehensive recognition of any desired DNA sequence, and new proteins could be assembled by any laboratory in a matter of hours. However, a critical parameter for this approach is the extent to which each domain functions as an independent, modular unit, without influence or dependence on its neighboring domains. We therefore examined the detailed binding behavior of several modularly assembled polydactyl zinc finger proteins. We first demonstrated that 80 modularly assembled 3-finger proteins can recognize their DNA target with very high specificity using a multitarget ELISA-based specificity assay. A more detailed analysis of DNA binding specificity for eight 3-finger proteins and two 6-finger proteins was performed using a target site selection assay. Results showed that the specificity of these proteins was as good or better than that of zinc finger proteins constructed using methods that allow for interdependency. In some cases, near perfect specificity was achieved. Complications due to target site overlap were found to be restricted to only one particular amino acid interaction (involving an aspartate in position 2 of the alpha-helix) that occurs in a minority of cases. As this is the first report of target site selection for designed, well characterized 6-finger proteins, unique insights are discussed concerning the relationship of protein length and specificity. These results have important implications for the design of proteins that can recognize extended DNA sequences, as well as provide insights into the general rules of recognition for naturally occurring zinc finger proteins.

Selective dimerization of a C2H2 zinc finger subfamily

The C2H2 zinc finger is the most prevalent protein motif in the mammalian proteome. Two C2H2 fingers in Ikaros are dedicated to homotypic interactions between family members. We show here that these fingers comprise a bona fide dimerization domain. Dimerization is highly selective, however, as homologous domains from the TRPS-1 and Drosophila Hunchback proteins support homodimerization, but not heterodimerization with Ikaros. Ikaros-Hunchback selectivity is determined by 11 residues concentrated within the alpha-helical regions typically involved in base recognition. Preferential homodimerization of one chimeric protein predicts a parallel dimer interface and establishes the feasibility of creating novel dimer specificities. These results demonstrate that the C2H2 motif provides a versatile platform for both sequence-specific protein-nucleic acid interactions and highly specific dimerization.

Influence of TFIIIA-type linker at the N- or C-terminal of nine-zinc finger protein on DNA-binding site

The central three-zinc finger connection of the native nine-zinc finger protein transcription factor IIIA (TFIIIA) is composed of unique linker sequences, -NIKICV-, -TQQLP-, -AG-, and -QDL-. New artificial nine-zinc finger proteins, Sp1ZF9TC and Sp1ZF9TN, which use the TFIIIA-type linker for their C- and N-terminal three-zinc finger connections have been created. To investigate the influence of TFIIIA-type linker sequences by their different locations in the proteins, gel mobility shift assays (GMSA), DNase I footprinting assays, methylation interference analyses, and hydroxyl radical footprinting assays were performed. The GMSA revealed similar DNA-binding affinities of these two proteins. The footprinting analyses indicated that the two zinc finger proteins recognize the same part of GCII or GCIII DNA. Moreover, the specific base contacts were observed in the same sites of the substrate DNA. In the present proteins, Sp1ZF9TC and Sp1ZF9TN, the four zinc fingers (fingers 1-4 or 5-9) situated in the site opposite to the TFIIIA-type linker position participate in their DNA bindings. The position of the TFIIIA-type linker is important in DNA recognition by multi-zinc finger proteins.

Optimized regulation of gene expression using artificial transcription factors

A major focus in the basic science of gene therapy is the study of factors involved in target-specific regulation of gene expression. Optimization of artificial or "designer" transcription factors capable of specific regulation of target genes is a prerequisite to developing practical applications in human subjects. In this paper, we present a systematic and combinatorial approach to optimize engineered transcription factors using designed zinc-finger proteins fused to transcriptional effector domains derived from the naturally occurring activators (VP16 or P65) or repressor (KRAB) proteins. We also demonstrate effective targeting of artificial transcription factors to regulate gene expression from three different constitutive viral promoters (SV40, CMV, RSV). Achieving a desired level of gene expression from a targeted region depended on several variables, including target site affinities for various DNA-binding domains, the nature of the activator domain, the particular cell type used, and the position of the target site with respect to the core promoter. Hence, several aspects of the artificial transcription factors should be simultaneously evaluated to ensure the optimum level of gene expression from a given target site in a given cell type. Our observations and our optimization approach have substantial implications for designing safe and effective artificial transcription factors for cell-based and therapeutic uses.

Engineering polydactyl zinc-finger transcription factors

The availability of rapid and robust methods for controlling gene function is of prime importance not only for assigning functions to newly discovered genes, but also for therapeutic intervention. Traditionally, gene function has been probed by often-laborious methods that either increase the level of a gene product or decrease it. Advances now make it possible to rapidly produce zinc-finger proteins capable of recognizing virtually any 18 bp stretch of DNA--a sequence long enough to specify a unique address in any genome. The attachment of functional domains also allows the design of tailor-made transcription factors for specific genes. Recent studies demonstrate that artificial transcription factors are capable of controlling the expression of endogenous genes in their native chromosomal context with a high degree of specificity in both animals and plants. Dominant regulatory control of expression of any endogenous gene can be achieved rapidly and can be also placed under chemical control. A wide range of potential applications is now within reach.

The use of zinc finger peptides to study the role of specific factor binding sites in the chromatin environment

The once ambitious goal of creating custom DNA-binding factors has been achieved. Advances in construction methodology now enable any laboratory to create site-specific binding proteins to nearly any sequence. Using predefined zinc finger modules, new proteins can be constructed in days with minimal cost and using only standard polymerase chain reaction techniques. The existing spectrum of modules can be rearranged to produce more than one billion different proteins that bind with high affinity and specificity. Artificial transcription factors based on modified zinc finger domains have recently been shown by several groups to be capable of activating or repressing transcription of a handful of endogenous genes in the chromatin environment of plant and animal cells. These proteins can also be used in a number of ways to compete with endogenous factors for specific binding sites in vivo. Zinc finger peptides are therefore useful tools in the study of gene regulation and signal transduction. A detailed description of the construction method is presented, along with a full discussion of potential caveats and future expectations.

Custom DNA-binding proteins come of age: polydactyl zinc-finger proteins

Artificial transcription factors based on modified zinc-finger DNA-binding domains have been shown to activate or repress the transcription of endogenous genes in multiple organisms. Advances in both the construction of novel zinc-finger proteins and our understanding of the characteristics of a productive regulatory site have fueled these achievements.

Electrostatic control of half-site spacing preferences by the cyclic AMP response element-binding protein CREB

Basic region leucine zipper (bZIP) proteins represent a class of transcription factors that bind DNA using a simple, dimeric, alpha-helical recognition motif. The cAMP response element-binding protein (CREB) is a member of the CREB/ATF subfamily of bZIP proteins. CREB discriminates effectively in vivo and in vitro between the 10 bp cAMP response element (ATGACGTCAT, CRE) and the 9 bp activating protein 1 site (ATGACTCAT, AP-1). Here we describe an alanine scanning mutagenesis study designed to identify those residues within the CREB bZIP element that control CRE/AP-1 specificity. We find that the preference of CREB for the CRE site is controlled in a positive and negative way by acidic and basic residues in the basic, spacer and zipper segments. The CRE/AP-1 specificity of CREB is increased significantly by four glutamic acid residues located at positions 24, 28, 35 and 41; glutamic acid residues at positions 10 and 48 contribute in a more modest way. Specificity is decreased significantly by two basic residues located at positions 21 and 23; basic residues at positions 14, 18, 33 and 34 and V17 contribute in a more modest way. All of the residues that influence specificity significantly are located on the solvent-exposed face of the protein-DNA complex and likely participate in interactions between and among proteins, not between protein and DNA. The finding that the CRE/AP-1 specificity of CREB is dictated by the presence or absence of charged residues has interesting implications for how transcription factors seek and selectively bind sequences within genomic DNA.

Development of zinc finger domains for recognition of the 5'-ANN-3' family of DNA sequences and their use in the construction of artificial transcription factors

In previous studies we have developed Cys(2)-His(2) zinc finger domains that specifically recognized each of the 16 5'-GNN-3' DNA target sequences and could be used to assemble six-finger proteins that bind 18-base pair DNA sequences (Beerli, R. R., Dreier, B., and Barbas, C. F., III (2000) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 97, 1495--1500). Such proteins provide the basis for the construction of artificial transcription factors to study gene/function relationships in the post-genomic era. Central to the universal application of this approach is the development of zinc finger domains that specifically recognize each of the 64 possible DNA triplets. Here we describe the construction of a novel phage display library that enables the selection of zinc finger domains recognizing the 5'-ANN-3' family of DNA sequences. Library selections provided domains that in most cases showed binding specificity for the 3-base pair target site that they were selected to bind. These zinc finger domains were used to construct 6-finger proteins that specifically bound their 18-base pair target site with affinities in the pm to low nm range. When fused to regulatory domains, these proteins containing various numbers of 5'-ANN-3' domains were capable of specific transcriptional regulation of a reporter gene and the endogenous human ERBB-2 and ERBB-3 genes. These results suggest that modular DNA recognition by zinc finger domains is not limited to the 5'-GNN-3' family of DNA sequences and can be extended to the 5'-ANN-3' family. The domains characterized in this work provide for the rapid construction of artificial transcription factors, thereby greatly increasing the number of sequences and genes that can be targeted by DNA-binding proteins built from pre-defined zinc finger domains.

Structure-based design of a dimeric RNA-peptide complex

The arginine-rich RNA-binding domain of bovine immunodeficiency virus (BIV) Tat adopts a beta-hairpin conformation upon binding to the major groove of BIV TAR. Based on its NMR structure, we modeled dimeric arrangements in which two adjacent TAR sites might be recognized with high affinity by a dimeric peptide. Some dimeric RNAs efficiently bound two unlinked BIV Tat peptides in vitro, but could not bind even one monomeric peptide in vivo, as monitored by transcriptional activation of human immunodeficiency virus long terminal repeat reporters. Results with additional reporters suggest that extending the RNA helix in the dimeric arrangements inhibits peptide binding by decreasing major groove accessibility. In contrast, a dimeric peptide efficiently bound an optimally arranged dimeric TAR in vivo, and bound with an affinity at least 10-fold higher than the monomeric peptide in vitro. Mutating specific nucleotides in each RNA 'half-site' or specific amino acids in each beta-hairpin of the dimeric peptide substantially decreased binding affinity, providing evidence for the modeled dimer-dimer interaction. These studies provide a starting point for identifying dimeric RNA-protein interactions with even higher binding affinities and specificities.