Pronuclear morphology predicts embryo development and chromosome constitution

Common dysmorphic oocytes and embryos in assisted reproductive technology laboratory in association with gene alternations

Amorphic or defected oocytes and embryos are commonly observed in assisted reproductive technology (ART) laboratories. It is believed that a proper gene expression at each stage of embryo development contributes to the possibility of a decent-quality embryo leading to successful implantation. Many studies reported that several defects in embryo morphology are associated with gene expressions during in vitro fertilization (IVF) treatment. There is lacking literature review on summarizing common morphological defects about gene alternations. In this review, we summarized the current literature. We selected 64 genes that have been reported to be involved in embryo morphological abnormalities in animals and humans, 30 of which were identified in humans and might be the causes of embryonic changes. Five papers focusing on associations of multiple gene expressions and embryo abnormalities using RNA transcriptomes were also included during the search. We have also reviewed our time-lapse image database with over 3000 oocytes/embryos to show morphological defects possibly related to gene alternations reported previously in the literature. This holistic review can better understand the associations between gene alternations and morphological changes. It is also beneficial to select important biomarkers with strong evidence in IVF practice and reveal their potential application in embryo selection. Also, identifying genes may help patients with genetic disorders avoid unnecessary treatments by providing preimplantation genetic testing for monogenic/single gene defects (PGT-M), reduce embryo replacements by less potential, and help scientists develop new methods for oocyte/embryo research in the near future.

Pronuclear and blastocyst morphology are associated age-dependently with embryo ploidy in in vitro fertilization cycles

This retrospective study aimed to assess the relationship between standard markers of embryo morphology, maternal age and blastocyst ploidy determined by trophectoderm (TE) biopsy and Next-generation Sequencing (NGS). A total of 774 oocytes and embryos from 288 PGT-A cycles were scored for pronuclear, cleavage stage and blastocyst morphology. Pronuclear oocytes aligned between the nuclei and presenting equal number of nucleolus precursor bodies (NPBs) were designated Z1, oocytes showing equal number of NPBs, but not aligned, as Z2 while Z3 oocytes had an unequal number of NBPs between the nuclei or NPBs aligned in one nucleus and non-aligned in the other. Pronuclear oocytes with unequal-sized or non-aligned nuclei were designated Z4. Blastocysts were graded as BL1 (AA, AB or BA), BL2 (BB or CB) and BL3 (BC or CC) based on the combination of inner cell mass (ICM) and TE scores. Pronuclear and blastocyst morphology were correlated with aneuploidy in a < 40-year-old group (p < 0.01 and p < 0.05, respectively), but not in those ≥40 years. Interestingly, BL3 blastocysts classified as Z1 or Z3-Z4 on day-1 had different aneuploidy rates (BL3/Z1 = 46.7% vs. BL3/Z3-Z4 = 90.0%, p < 0.05). In summary, our data showed that pronuclear and blastocyst morphology are associated with blastocyst ploidy in younger patients. This may help embryo selection for embryo transfer and decision-making on which blastocysts should be biopsied in PGT-A cycles.

The Effect of GH Administration on Oocyte and Zygote Quality in Young Women With Repeated Implantation Failure After IVF

Growth hormone (GH) has been shown to improve implantation and live birth rates in women of >40 years of age treated by in vitro fertilization (IVF). This effect was initially attributed to a GH effect on oocyte quality, but later studies showed that GH can also improve uterine receptivity for embryo implantation. As to younger women with previous failures of embryo implantation after IVF, data reported in the literature are ambiguous. This retrospective study focused on this latter category of women, comparing the numbers and morphological appearance of oocytes recovered from women with two previous IVF failures, aged between 30 and 39 years and treated with GH, with a comparable group of women without GH treatment. These results were complemented with the analysis of morphological markers of zygote and embryo quality and IVF clinical outcomes in both groups. The oocytes, zygotes and embryos from women treated with GH showed better morphological scores, and their uterine transfer resulted in more implantations, pregnancies and live births, as compared with the untreated group. It is concluded that the improvement of IVF outcomes in women with previous repeated IVF failures by exogenous GH administration is, at least partly, related to an increase in oocyte developmental potential. The statistically evident improvement of oocyte and embryo quality is the main finding of this study. Its weakness is its retrospective nature.

Acquired Sperm DNA Modifications: Causes, Consequences, and Potential Solutions

DNA of human spermatozoa can be subject to various kinds of modifications acquired throughout life. Put simply, two basic types of acquired sperm DNA modifications can be distinguished: genetic and epigenetic. Genetic modifications cause alterations of the DNA sequence and mainly result from the formation of breakpoints leading to sperm DNA fragmentation. Epigenetic modifications include a vast spectrum of events that influence the expression of different genes without altering their DNA sequence. Both the genetic and the epigenetic modifications of sperm DNA can negatively influence embryonic development, cause miscarriages, and be the origin of different health problems for the offspring. As to sperm DNA fragmentation, reliable diagnostic methods are currently available. On the other hand, the detection of potentially harmful epigenetic modifications in spermatozoa is a much more complicated issue. Different treatment options can be chosen to solve problems associated with sperm DNA fragmentation. Some are relatively simple and noninvasive, based on oral treatments with antioxidants and other agents, depending on the underlying cause. In other cases, the recourse to different micromanipulation-assisted in vitro fertilisation techniques is necessary to select spermatozoa with minimal DNA damage to be injected into oocytes. The treatment of cases with epigenetic DNA modifications is still under investigation. Preliminary data suggest that some of the techniques used in cases of extensive DNA fragmentation can also be of help in those of epigenetic modifications; however, further progress will depend on the availability of more reliable diagnostic methods with which it will be possible to evaluate the effects of different therapeutic interventions.

Pronuclear pattern does not predict morphokinetics behavior in human embryos

The purpose was to investigate the correlation between pronuclei (PN) morphology and morphokinetic behaviors of derived embryos with time lapse monitoring (TLM) in assisted reproduction setting. Over time, PN morphology from PN appearance (PNA) to PN fading (PNF), PNF according to size, contact, number and position of nuclear precursor bodies (NPBs) within each PN and morphokinetics variables, including absolute time points, relative timing parameters, cleavage patterns and arrest rate, were evaluated using TLM. There were insignificant relationship between morphokinetics variables including tBP2, tPNA, tPNF, t2, t3, t4, t5, t6, t7, t8, S1, CC2, S2 and Z scoring according Z1 to Z4 (p > .05). Also, an insignificant relationship was noticed between uneven blastomeres, reverse cleavage embryos and Z scoring (p > .05). However, there were significant correlations between the rates of direct and arbitrary cleavage as well as arrested embryos and Z scores. Combined PN morphology and embryo kinetic evaluation were suggested in assisted reproduction programs.

Assessment of human embryo development using morphological criteria in an era of time-lapse, algorithms and 'OMICS': is looking good still important?

With the worldwide move towards single embryo transfer there has been a renewed focus on the requirement for reliable means of assessing embryo viability. In an era of 'OMICS' technologies, and algorithms created through the use of time-lapse microscopy, the actual appearance of the human embryo as it progresses through each successive developmental stage to the blastocyst appears to have been somewhat neglected in recent years. Here we review the key features of the human preimplantation embryo and consider the relationship between morphological characteristics and developmental potential. Further, the impact of the culture environment on morphological traits, how key morphological qualities reflect aspects of embryo physiology, and how computer-assisted analysis of embryo morphology may facilitate a more quantitative approach to selection are discussed. The clinical introduction of time-lapse systems has reopened our eyes and given us a new vantage point from which to view the beauty of the initial stages of human life. Rather than a future in which the morphology of the embryo is deemed irrelevant, we propose that key features, such as multinucleation, cell size and blastocyst differentiation should be included in future iterations of selection/deselection algorithms.

Endometrial pattern, but not endometrial thickness, affects implantation rates in euploid embryo transfers

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the relationship of endometrial thickness (EnT) and endometrial pattern (EnP) to euploid embryo transfer (ET) outcomes.

DESIGN

Retrospective cohort.

SETTING

Private academic clinic.

PATIENT(S)

Patients (n = 277; age 36.1 ± 4.0 years) whose embryos (n = 476) underwent aneuploidy screening with fresh (n = 176) or frozen (n = 180) ET from July 2010 to March 2014.

INTERVENTION(S)

The EnT and EnP were measured on trigger day and at ET. Patients were stratified by age and cycle type (fresh or frozen). Cycle data were combined at trigger day, but separated at ET day.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S)

Outcome measures were implantation rate, pregnancy rate, and clinical pregnancy rate. Analysis was conducted using χ(2) analysis and Fisher's exact test.

RESULT(S)

A total of 234 gestational sacs, 251 pregnancies, and 202 clinical pregnancies resulted from 356 cycles. The EnT (9.6 ± 1.8 mm; range: 5-15 mm) at trigger day (n = 241 cycles), as a continuous or categorical variable (≤8 vs. >8 mm), was not associated with implantation rate, pregnancy rate, or clinical pregnancy rate. The EnT at day of fresh ET (9.7 ± 2.2 mm; range: 4.4-17.9 mm) (n = 176 cycles) or frozen ET (9.1 ± 2.1 mm; range: 4.2-17.7 mm) (n = 180 cycles) was not associated with implantation rate, pregnancy rate, or clinical pregnancy rate. Type 3 EnP at trigger day was associated with increased serum progesterone at trigger and a decreased implantation rate, compared with type 2 EnP. The EnP at fresh or frozen ET was not associated with implantation rate, pregnancy rate, or clinical pregnancy rate.

CONCLUSION(S)

Within the study population, EnT was not significantly associated with clinical outcomes of euploid ETs. A type 3 EnP at trigger day suggests a prematurely closed window of implantation.

Blastocyst Morphology Holds Clues Concerning The Chromosomal Status of The Embryo

Background

Embryo morphology has been proposed as an alternative marker of chro- mosomal status. The objective of this retrospective cohort study was to investigate the association between the chromosomal status on day 3 of embryo development and blas- tocyst morphology.

Materials and Methods

A total of 596 embryos obtained from 106 cycles of intra- cytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) followed by preimplantation genetic aneuploidy screening (PGS) were included in this retrospective study. We evaluated the relation- ship between blastocyst morphological features and embryonic chromosomal altera- tion.

Results

Of the 564 embryos with fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH) results, 200 reached the blastocyst stage on day 5 of development. There was a significantly high- er proportion of euploid embryos in those that achieved the blastocyst stage (59.0%) compared to embryos that did not develop to blastocysts (41.2%) on day 5 (P<0.001). Regarding blastocyst morphology, we observed that all embryos that had an abnormal inner cell mass (ICM) were aneuploid. Embryos with morphologically normal ICM had a significantly higher euploidy rate (62.1%, P<0.001). As regards to the trophectoderm (TE) morphology, an increased rate of euploidy was observed in embryos that had nor- mal TE (65.8%) compared to embryos with abnormal TE (37.5%, P<0.001). Finally, we observed a two-fold increase in the euploidy rate in high-quality blastocysts with both high-quality ICM and TE (70.4%) compared to that found in low-quality blastocysts (31.0%, P<0.001).

Conclusion

Chromosomal abnormalities do not impair embryo development as ane- uploidy is frequently observed in embryos that reach the blastocyst stage. A high-quality blastocyst does not represent euploidy of chromosomes 13, 14, 15, 16, 18, 21, 22, X and Y. However, aneuploidy is associated with abnormalities in the ICM morphology. Further studies are necessary to confirm whether or not the transfer of blastocysts with low-quality ICM should be avoided.

The strategy of group embryo culture based on pronuclear pattern on blastocyst development: a two center analysis

PURPOSE

To compare two embryo grouping strategies.

METHODS

Retrospective time-course analysis in two different centres. Two culture protocols were used at the zygote stage: "Random Group" in which zygotes were randomly grouped and "Definite Group" in which zygotes were grouped based on pronuclear pattern. Embryo culture was extended to blastocyst stage. Primary and secondary outcomes were respectively the blastulation rate and the cumulative clinical pregnancy and implantation rates.

RESULT(S)

A similar blastulation rate [42 and 41% day (5 + 6) blastocysts] was obtained in the two groups. Conversely, after adjusting for baseline and cycle variables, cumulative pregnancy [adjusted Odds Ratio = 2.10 (95%CI: 1.08-4.07)] and implantation [adjusted Odds Ratio = 1.78 (95%CI: 1.06-2.97)] rates were significantly higher in the "Random Group" compared to the "Definite Group".

CONCLUSION(S)

Two strategies of group culture gave similar results in terms of blastulation rate but the random grouping of zygotes improves pregnancy and implantation rates in IVF-cycles.

Embryo culture and selection: morphological criteria

In this chapter, we have outlined the various morphological criteria for selection of the best embryo at each important milestone encountered in the progress from the oocyte to the blastocyst. As Gerris et al. stated, a combination of one, two, or even three selection points should lead to a more accurate selection of the best embryo, as no one criterion is better than the other. An embryo that fails to meet the entire set of selection criteria must be avoided as culture cannot correct an impaired embryo.

Embryo quality but not pronuclear score is associated with clinical pregnancy following IVF

PURPOSE

The association between pronuclear (PN) scoring of embryos from assisted reproductive technology (ART) and clinical pregnancy remains controversial. We hypothesized that embryos with PNs scored on the day of fertilization check offer better embryo selection on day 3 and higher CPR compared to non-PN scored embryos.

METHODS

Patients (19-46 years) undergoing IVF/ICSI cycles at Montefiore's Institute for Reproductive Medicine and Health between January 2006 and December 2009 were included in our study. We analyzed fresh day 3 cycles only with autologous oocytes and partner's fresh sperm (n = 344). A total of 1,899 embryos were included. We compared CPR from non-PN scored embryos (Group 1, n = 835) with PN scored embryos (Group 2, n = 1,064). Composite scores by patient were developed based on embryo disposition. We also assessed traditional embryo grading derived from cell number, fragmentation and cell symmetry. Data analysis included chi square and t test to determine if PN scoring was associated with improved CPR, and to compare the additional variables.

RESULTS

CPR between Group 1 and Group 2 were not different (p = 0.91). CPR was significantly associated with female age, number of mature oocytes retrieved, number of day 3 embryos and grade of embryos transferred on day 3 (p < 0.05).

CONCLUSION

PN scoring was not associated with improved CPR in day 3 embryo transfers. Mean grade of transferred embryos continues to be a well-established, independent predictor of CPR. We conclude that further refinement of embryo grading by PN scoring is not beneficial.

Pronuclear morphology evaluation for fresh in vitro fertilization (IVF) and intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) cycles: a systematic review

The current systematic review was aimed to assess the effectiveness of the zygote morphology evaluation in fresh in vitro fertilization (IVF) and intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) cycles. All available studies reporting on zygote morphology and clinical and/or biological outcomes were analyzed. Forty studies were included in the final analysis. Fourteen different zygote scoring systems were employed. Zygote morphology correlated significantly with embryo quality and cleavage, blastocyst stage, embryonic chromosome status, in a high proportion of the studies which assessed the specific outcome [15/25 (60%), 15/20 (75%), 7/8 (87.5%), 6/6 (100%), respectively]. On the other hand, only a reduced proportion of papers showed a statistically significant relationship between implantation, pregnancy and delivery/live-birth rates and zygote morphology score [12/23 (52.2%), 12/25 (48%), 1/4 (25%), respectively]. In conclusion, our findings demonstrate the lack of conclusive data on the clinical efficacy of the zygote morphology evaluation in fresh IVF/ICSI cycles, even if biological results showing a good relationship with embryo viability suggest a role in cycles in which the transfer/freezing is performed at day 1.

Could time-lapse embryo imaging reduce the need for biopsy and PGS?

PURPOSE

To review relevant studies examining the relationship between embryo morpho-kinetics and aneuploidy.

METHODS

Search of Pubmed and Medline using relevant keywords pertaining to morphology, morphokinetics and embryonic aneuploidy, as well as examination of various reference lists and conference proceedings.

RESULTS

An abundance of publications, both preliminary and peer-reviewed, have emerged regarding the usefulness of time-lapse imaging in tracking embryo development and improving embryo selection. Recently, these publications have explored ability to not only predict blastocyst formation and implantation, but also the ability to detect embryonic chromosomal aneuploidy. Of the two peer-reviewed retrospective studies on morpho-kinetics and embryonic aneuploidy, one demonstrates that early cleavage timings can indicate chromosomal complement, while the other demonstrates that key events following the maternal-zygotic transition can be markers of aneuploidy. A recent paper also demonstrates improved outcomes following IVF using a selection algorithm to identify embryos at "low risk" of chromosomal abnormalities. However, the predictive nature of these events and timings is far from ideal. Additionally, results may be dependent upon the day of biopsy and method utilized for chromosomal assessment.

CONCLUSION

With continued effort, the combination of multiple morphologic endpoint assessments and developmental timings and refinement of modeling systems may improve the predictive ability to determine embryonic aneuploidy. This may help select a subset of embryos that are less likely to carry chromosomal abnormalities and improve assisted reproductive outcomes. However, embryo biopsy, followed by preimplantation genetic screening/comprehensive chromosomal screening still remains the most reliable method to assess chromosomal complement of preimplantation embryos.

Oocyte morphology on day 0 correlates with aneuploidy as detected by polar body biopsy and FISH

PURPOSE

For better selection of oocytes and embryos, preimplantation genetic screening (PGS) was introduced. As from the beginning of IVF, morphology was used as selection criteria; we investigated the combination of both. If there was a correlation between phenotype and genotype, invasive PGS might be replaced.

METHOD

Therefore, 104 cycles with PGS were done by biopsy of the first polar body and FISH with five chromosomes. Morphology of the oocyte was recorded digitally and noted for 12 categories in 4-13 values; evaluation of the chromosomes was noted for five chromosomes in five values. Morphology and genetics were correlated to each other.

RESULT

Correlations between morphology and genetics for day 0 were found: oocytes with an irregular or dark zona are less probable to have a normal chromosome 13 (80 vs. 53 %, p = 0.001). A medium amount of detritus in the perivitelline space makes it more probable to have a normal chromosome 18 (94 vs. 78 %, p = 0.001). A halo in the cytoplasm makes it less probable to be euploid for chromosome 22 (56 vs. 75 %, p = 0.018). For day 1, pattern "1, 2, 3 and fine" in the pronuclei makes it more probable to be euploid for chromosome 22 (78 vs. 63 %, p = 0.002).

CONCLUSION

There are correlations between the oocyte genome and its morphology also on day 0. These correlations are not sufficient to replace PGS.

Preimplantation genetic screening: does it help or hinder IVF treatment and what is the role of the embryo?

Despite an ongoing debate over its efficacy, preimplantation genetic screening (PGS) is increasingly being used to detect numerical chromosomal abnormalities in embryos to improve implantation rates after IVF. The main indications for the use of PGS in IVF treatments include advanced maternal age, repeated implantation failure, and recurrent pregnancy loss. The success of PGS is highly dependent on technical competence, embryo culture quality, and the presence of mosaicism in preimplantation embryos. Today, cleavage stage biopsy is the most commonly used method for screening preimplantation embryos for aneuploidy. However, blastocyst biopsy is rapidly becoming the more preferred method due to a decreased likelihood of mosaicism and an increase in the amount of DNA available for testing. Instead of using 9 to 12 chromosome FISH, a 24 chromosome detection by aCGH or SNP microarray will be used. Thus, it is advised that before attempting to perform PGS and expecting any benefit, extended embryo culture towards day 5/6 should be established and proven and the clinical staff should demonstrate competence with routine competency assessments. A properly designed randomized control trial is needed to test the potential benefits of these new developments.

Severe teratozoospermia and its influence on pronuclear morphology, embryonic cleavage and compaction

BACKGROUND

Fertilization, cell division and embryo development depend on genomic contributions from male and female gametes. We hypothesize that teratozoospermic sperm influences early embryo development and embryo compaction.

METHODS

We conducted a retrospective analysis of embryos derived from intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) cycles. Two hundred thirty-five consecutive ICSI cycles were included in the study; all treatment was provided at the Cleveland Clinic Fertility Center. Patient cycles were divided by sperm morphology based on Kruger's strict criteria: Group A, embryos where teratozoospermic sperm (0-2% normal) were used for ICSI and Group B, embryos where dysmorphic sperm (5-13% normal) were used for ICSI. All cycles analyzed were of patients doing day 3 embryo transfers. Outcome measures assessed included pronuclear (PN) pattern, syngamy, early cleavage, cell number, rate of compaction and blastulation of embryos left in culture and not transferred on day 3.

RESULTS

A total of 1762 embryos were analyzed. PN patterns were similar in Group A and Group B embryos. No differences were noted in syngamy, cleavage, cell number or blastulation rate. Studying the development of embryos in culture after day 3 transfer revealed a difference in the timeline for compaction. By day 4, 25% of Group A embryos had compacted compared to 36% in Group B (P = 0.0007). There was no difference found between Group A and Group B embryos in regards to blastulation.

CONCLUSIONS

We did not find an association between sperm morphology and clinical outcomes. The impact of teratozoospermia may be masked in ICSI cycles where fertilization, implantation rate and clinical pregnancy rate are the primary outcome measures. However, by examining the timeline of development, we were better able to discern a potential paternal effect at critical transition points from fertilization through activation.

Analysis of pronuclear zygote configurations in 459 clinical pregnancies obtained with assisted reproductive technique procedures

BACKGROUND

Embryos selection is crucial to maintain high performance in terms of pregnancy rate, reducing the risk of multiple pregnancy during IVF. Pronuclear and nucleolar characteristics have been proposed as an indicator of embryo development and chromosomal complement in humans, providing information about embryo viability.

METHODS

To correlate the zygote-score with the maternal age and the outcome of pregnancy, we analyzed the pronuclear and nucleolar morphology, the polar body alignment and the zygote configuration in 459 clinical pregnancies obtained by IVF and ICSI in our public clinic in Reggio Emilia, Italy. We derived odds ratios (OR) and Corenfield's 95% confidence intervals (CI). Continuous variables were compared with Student's t-test; P lower than .05 was considered statistically significant.

RESULTS

We observed a significant increase of "A" pronuclear morphology configuration in 38-41 years old patients in comparison to that lower than or equal to 32 years old and a significant decrease of "B" configuration in 38-41 years old patients in comparison to that lower than or equal to 32 and in comparison to that of 33-37 years old. Related to maternal age we found no significant differences in P1 and in P2 configuration. We found no correlation between zygote-score, embryo cleavage and embryo quality.

CONCLUSIONS

Our results confirm the limited clinical significance of zygote-score suggesting that it can not be associated with maternal age, embryo cleavage and embryo quality. The evaluation of embryo quality based on morphological parameters is probably more predictive than zygote-score.

Pronuclear zygote score following intracytoplasmic injection of hyaluronan-bound spermatozoa: a prospective randomized study

The aim of this study was to determine whether the early stages of embryo development, as assessed by the zygote score (Z-score), could be influenced by the injection of spermatozoa that had been preselected on the basis of their binding to hyaluronic acid (HA). A total of 407 sibling metaphase II oocytes, belonging to 44 different patients, were injected in a prospective randomized way, with either hyaluronic acid bound (HA(+) ) or non-bound (HA(-)) spermatozoa. The fertilization rate (75-70%), the percentage of the different Z-scores (Z 1: 22-24%, Z 2: 22-22.5%, Z 3: 44- 45%, Z 4: 12-8.5%), the mean score of the transferred embryos (3.76 +/- 1.29, 3.78 +/- 1.1) and the number of embryos at the 4-cell stage 45 h after injection (77-76%) were not different between the two groups. The ongoing pregnancy rate in this study (>20 weeks of gestation) was 36.4% per replacement, the implantation rate 28% and the twin pregnancy rate 44% (7/16). Although binding to HA did not apparently influence the Z-score, this agent continues to be used for the immobilization of spermatozoa prior to injection, on the basis that it is a natural product that can easily be metabolized by the oocyte via normal biological mechanisms.

Pronuclear morphology, embryo development and chromosome constitution

The aim of the present study was to evaluate the usefulness of pronuclear patterns, according to the classifications of Tesarik and Scott, as predictors of embryo chromosome constitution. Up to 73 preimplantation genetic diagnosis/preimplantation genetic screening (PGD/PGS) cycles were analysed in this retrospective study including 17 cycles of translocation carriers and 56 PGS cycles. A total of 331 biopsied embryos were studied assessing pronuclear (PN) pattern, embryo quality and chromosome constitution. As regards to the relationship between PN pattern and embryo quality, the data obtained in this study show no correlation between both parameters. Although there were no significant differences when comparing the distribution of chromosomally normal and abnormal embryos with respect to embryo quality, such differences were observed when distinguishing between normal, aneuploid and polyploid embryos. The results show that the PN pattern using Tesarik's and Scott's classification systems is not related to the embryo developmental potential or its chromosome constitution. Therefore, in the context of a PGD/PGS programme, the PN pattern cannot be used as a tool to predict embryo quality or chromosome status.

First polar body and nucleolar precursor body morphology is related to the ovarian reserve of infertile women

This study was undertaken in order to gain insight into the morphology of the first polar body (PB1) and the two pronuclei (2PN) in ICSI patients, specifically the nucleolar precursor bodies (NPB). Whether early abnormalities in these structures are related to the ovarian reserve of infertile women was also studied. Eighty consecutive infertile women were prospectively investigated throughout their first ICSI cycles. Basal ovarian reserve studies were performed in all women. Cycles were evaluated with respect to PB1 and 2PN morphology of the transferred embryos. Cycles that had at least one transferred embryo with normal PB1 and 2PN morphology had significantly better basal ovarian reserve parameters compared with cycles in which all transferred embryos had abnormal PB1 and 2PN morphology. Moreover, the normal morphology group performed significantly better throughout the ovarian stimulation, compared with the abnormal morphology group. Furthermore, the clinical implantation and pregnancy rates were significantly higher in the normal compared with the abnormal morphology group, corresponding to 20.7% versus 10.6% and 42.4% versus 18.2%, respectively. The study concluded that the morphology of the PB1 in metaphase II oocytes as well as that of the NPB within the 2PN zygotes seems to be related to the ovarian reserve in infertile women.

Aneuploidy and early human embryo development

Human embryo development occurs through a process that encompasses reprogramming, sequential cleavage divisions and mitotic chromosome segregation and embryonic genome activation. Chromosomal abnormalities may arise during germ cell and/or pre-implantation embryo development, and are a major cause of spontaneous miscarriage or birth defects. Nonetheless, model systems suitable for the study of human germ cell and embryo development have been limited until recently. We suggest that human embryonic stem cells may provide a valuable human cell-based model for genetic studies of human pre-implantation pluripotent cells. Here, we review the current literature on diagnosing chromosomal abnormalities in the pre-implantation embryo, and the importance of provisions from the human oocyte in establishing and maintaining the human embryonic genome during the first 3 days post-conception. We focus on transcriptional analysis of human oocytes and embryos and the unique cell cycle and checkpoint requirements in the early embryo. Taken together, data suggest that the unique programs of the early human embryo, including management of aneuploid cells, may paradoxically promote embryo development but contribute to the high rate of spontaneous miscarriages in human pregnancies.

Limited importance of pre-embryo pronuclear morphology (zygote score) in assisted reproduction outcome in the absence of embryo cryopreservation

OBJECTIVE

To investigate the hypothesis that Z-score criteria represent a reliable predictor of implantation rate and pregnancy outcome in in vitro fertilization (IVF) and intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) cycles, excluding the possibility of embryo selection before the embryo transfer.

DESIGN

Retrospective clinical study.

SETTING

Centre of Reproductive Medicine, Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Arcispedale S. Maria Nuova (ASMN), Reggio Emilia, Italy.

PATIENT(S)

We analyzed 393 pregnancies obtained by IVF or ICSI cycles.

INTERVENTION(S)

Morphologic evaluations of Z-score in pre-embryos obtained from IVF or ICSI cycles.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S)

Evaluations of Z-scores, implantation rate, and clinical pregnancy outcome.

RESULT(S)

We did not find any statistically significant correlation between the Z-score of 1032 embryos transferred in 393 embryo transfers and the implantation rate or the pregnancy outcome. In particular, the best Z-score identified (Z1, 7.2%) did not seem to correlate with embryo implantation rate or pregnancy outcomes any better than those with worse scores (Z2, 6.9% and Z3, 85.9%).

CONCLUSION(S)

Our results seem to confirm that Z-score alone cannot be considered a better tool than standard morphologic criteria for identifying, controlling, or selecting embryos with a better chance of successful ongoing pregnancy.

Developmental prognosis for zygotes based on pronuclear pattern: usefulness of pronuclear scoring

PURPOSE

To relate pronuclear patterns (PN) and zygote cytoplasmic appearance and embryo morphology.

METHODS

The usefulness of PN classification described by Tesarik et al. 1999 (patterns p0-5) and Scott et al. 2000 (Z1-4), for embryo selection is assessed.

RESULTS

Sinchrony on polarization and number of nucleolar precursor bodies (NPB) were associated with good quality embryos (p0 60.9% and p3 67.3%, and Z1 62.5% and Z2 64.7%; p<0.01). Pattern 4 zygotes were associated with small number of NPB developed into multinucleated embryos (14.3%) and poor quality embryos (61.9%). No significant differences were found in the pregnancy rate between transfer of at least one good prognosis PN pattern and transfer of poor prognosis PN patterns, although 75% of the transfers included at least one embryo derived from a pattern 0 zygote, and 55% included embryos from categories Z1 or Z2.

CONCLUSIONS

Sequential assessment involving the evaluation of oocyte quality, the classification of PN patterns and embryo morphology allows a more accurate evaluation of embryos to be selected for transfer.

Embryo morphology and development are dependent on the chromosomal complement

OBJECTIVE

To analyze embryo morphology in relation to the corresponding chromosomal status, in order to evaluate the effects of aneuploidy over fragmentation, delayed cleavage, and arrested cleavage.

DESIGN

Retrospective study.

SETTING

Reproductive Medicine Unit, Società Italiana di Studi di Medicina della Riproduzione, Bologna, Italy.

PATIENT(S)

A total of 662 patients with a poor prognosis for pregnancy underwent 916 cycles of preimplantation genetic diagnosis for aneuploidy.

INTERVENTION(S)

The chromosomes XY, 13, 15, 16, 18, 21, and 22 were analyzed in blastomeres biopsied from day 3 embryos.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S)

Embryo morphology, chromosomal status of the analyzed blastomeres, and spreading and reanalysis of nontransferred embryos.

RESULT(S)

The incidence of chromosomal abnormalities was significantly higher in arrested or slow-cleaving embryos, and in embryos cleaving too fast, compared to embryos with eight cells at 62 hours after insemination. The presence of an uneven number of blastomeres or fragments scattered in the perivitelline space was associated with an increased incidence of chromosomal abnormalities.

CONCLUSION(S)

A correlation between embryo development and chromosomal complement makes the incidence of chromosomal abnormalities significantly higher in embryos dividing according to a time frame and a symmetry plan which are different from what are expected. The type of fragmentation is also related to chromosomal status, which explains why the extrusion of fragments might severely affect embryo viability.

Light retardance by human oocyte spindle is positively related to pronuclear score after ICSI

Disturbed spindle assembly increases risks of chromosome mal-segregation. Non-invasive polarization microscopy (PolScope) was employed in two centres to assess spindle integrity for the first time quantitatively in human oocytes from consenting patients undergoing intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) with respect to pronuclear (PN) score after fertilization. In one centre oocytes were selected before ICSI, in another selection was after ICSI according to PN score. In both centres, mean retardance of light by birefringent spindles in oocytes forming a pre-embryo with good PN score after ICSI was significantly higher compared with spindles in oocytes developing into a lower PN score pre-embryo with limited developmental potential (P < 0.001). Transfers involving oocytes with high retardance and at least one good PN score embryo resulted more frequently in a conception than transfers from oocytes with spindles of lower mean retardance and lower PN score embryos. There was a trend for an inverse relationship between age and magnitude of retardance in a small oocyte cohort. The study suggests that quantitative evaluation of mean retardance of light by the oocyte spindle predicts oocyte health, is related to PN score of the embryo and may be especially useful to assess oocyte quality in countries with legal restrictions to select after fertilization.

Oocyte euploidy, pronuclear zygote morphology and embryo chromosomal complement

BACKGROUND

Pronuclear morphology has been proposed as an indicator of embryo development and chromosomal complement. In this study, the morphology of pronuclear zygotes generated from euploid oocytes [diagnosed by first polar body (PB1) analysis] was evaluated and compared with the configurations observed in chromosomally normal embryos (diagnosed by blastomere analysis).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Group 1--238 patients underwent 273 assisted conception cycles in combination with the screening of aneuploidy on PB1 for the chromosomes 13, 15, 16, 18, 21 and 22. Only normal oocytes were inseminated. Group 2--218 patients underwent 318 assisted conception cycles with aneuploidy screening on day 3 embryos. In both groups, oocytes were checked for fertilization and pronuclear morphology at 16 h after insemination.

RESULTS

Seventy-three percent of zygotes from Group 1 had the configurations with centralized and juxtaposed pronuclei, large-size aligned or scattered nucleoli and PB located in the longitudinal or perpendicular axis of pronuclei. In Group 2, these configurations corresponded to those with the highest proportion of chromosomally normal embryos. Accordingly, in both groups, these configurations had a higher implantation rate than all the others.

CONCLUSIONS

These observations confirm that some patterns of pronuclear morphology are associated with a higher proportion of euploidy and implantation reaffirming the relevance of this scoring system for the prediction of zygote viability.

Changing genetic world of IVF, stem cells and PGD. A. Early methods in research

Genetics proved essential to introduce IVF, preimplantation diagnosis (PGD) and embryo stem cells in the 1960s. Its small input in early years was confined to aspects such as timing follicle growth and ovulation. Modest understanding in the mid- to late 1980s, mostly on studies in mice, involved the actions of single genes and the balance between maternal and zygotic transcripts in preimplantation stages. Human IVF began after human oocytes were matured in vitro, and their meiotic chromosomes analysed. Their fertilization in vitro led to PGD and embryo stem cells. Unlike mouse embryos, most human embryos failed to implant, so the best had to be selected to improve IVF pregnancy rates. Initially, faster-growing embryos proved superior. Later, patterns of polarized nucleoli in pronuclei, the degree of blastomere fragmentation and growth of embryos in vitro to blastocysts provided excellent markers. Single cells could be isolated from embryos using micromanipulation. Stem cells from inner cell mass, a branch of IVF, differentiated into immortal stem cell lines in vitro if disaggregated. They formed virtually all body tissues in blastocysts cultured intact or when injected singly into recipient blastocysts. Later, the genetic controls of ES cell differentiation were assessed, together with factors switching them along specific differentiation pathways. Marker genes identified ES cells differentiating into various tissues.

Effect of culture environment on gene expression and developmental characteristics in IVF-derived embryos

It is generally accepted that mammalian preimplantation embryos are sensitive to their environment and that conditions of culture can affect future growth and developmental potential both pre- and postnatally. Evidence suggests that while culture conditions during bovine in vitro embryo production can impact somewhat on the developmental potential of the early embryo, the intrinsic quality of the oocyte is the key factor determining the proportion of oocytes developing to the blastocyst stage. In addition, evidence suggests that the period of post fertilization embryo culture is the most critical period affecting blastocyst quality assessed in terms of cryotolerance, gene expression pattern and ability to establish a pregnancy. This paper reviews the current literature, with emphasis on the bovine model, demonstrating evidence for an effect of post fertilization culture environment on embryo gene expression and quality.

Embryo aneuploidy screening for repeated implantation failure and unexplained recurrent miscarriage

Among other factors, chromosomal abnormalities that originate from gametogenesis and preimplantation embryonic development are thought to be one of the major contributing factors for early embryonic death and failure of pregnancy. However, so far, no non-invasive technique exists that allows the detection of the chromosomal complement of an oocyte or a developing embryo as a whole. Rather, by removing polar bodies/blastomeres, recent developments on preimplantation genetic diagnosis for aneuploidy screening (PGD-AS) have paved the way to detect and possibly eliminate the majority of chromosomally abnormal embryos, thereby increasing the chance of a healthy pregnancy. This article summarizes the origin and impact of chromosomal abnormalities on human reproduction in cases with repeated implantation failure (RIF) and unexplained recurrent miscarriage. It also discusses recent advances regarding the possible benefits of PGD-AS in such cases.

Secretion of soluble HLA-G by day 3 human embryos associated with higher pregnancy and implantation rates: assay of culture media using a new ELISA kit

Identification of chemical markers in human embryo culture media that relate to embryo quality and implantation potential could be an invaluable tool in embryo selection for transfer. Embryonic secretion of soluble human leukocyte antigen G (sHLA-G) has been postulated to be a marker for 'embryonic competence'. This study examines sHLA-G concentrations in day 3 culture media droplets of embryos that were selected for transfer, as well as those being cryopreserved. A total of 712 embryo culture supernatants from 83 patients were assayed. Soluble HLA-G was detected in 306 of the 712 samples tested. In the 58 transfers in which at least one embryo selected for embryo transfer was positive for sHLA-G, the pregnancy rate was 64% (37/58) and the implantation rate per embryo transferred was 38%. In contrast, patients receiving only embryos that were negative for sHLA-G had both a lower pregnancy rate of 36% (9/25; P < 0.05) and a decreased implantation rate (19%; P < 0.05). Expression of sHLA-G was also related to increasing cell stage. Concentration of sHLA-G in embryo culture media was variable and in the low range (3-10 ng/ml). These data suggest an association between implantation potential and embryonic secretion of sHLA-G. The commercial assay kit utilized allowed for same day assessment of sHLA-G secretion. Addition of sHLA-G status to traditional morphological criteria may be useful as a clinical tool for embryo selection.

Initial differentiation of blastomeres in 4-cell human embryos and its significance for early embryogenesis and implantation

This brief review is devoted to the nature of early blastomere differentiation in human 4-cell embryos and its consequences for embryonic development. Precursor cells of inner cell mass, germline, and trophectoderm may be formed at this stage, the clearest evidence being available for trophectoderm. The sites of these precursor cells in the embryo could be ascertained using markers for animal and vegetal poles, observing specific cleavage planes, and assessing gene and protein expression. This opens new opportunities for studying 4-cell embryos and removing or replacing specific cells. Knowledge of the properties of individual blastomeres should help in improving assisted human reproduction, performing preimplantation genetic diagnosis, and perhaps establishing specific stem cell lines. Special attention is paid to well-characterized trophectoderm, the trophectoderm stem cell, and possible new forms of clinical application.

Relationship between pre-embryo pronuclear morphology (zygote score) and standard day 2 or 3 embryo morphology with regard to assisted reproductive technique outcomes

OBJECTIVE

To test the hypothesis that pregnancy rates are low if grade Z1 pre-embryos are not available for transfer and to determine if pronuclear morphology is a better predictor of pregnancy than traditional embryo morphology.

DESIGN

Prospective clinical study.

SETTING

Academic human reproduction laboratory.

PATIENT(S)

One hundred couples undergoing IVF with conventional insemination or ICSI.

INTERVENTION(S)

Embryo quality was assessed using both pre-embryo pronuclear morphology (zygote scoring or Z-scoring) at the time of fertilization evaluation and standard day 2 and day 3 embryo morphology (number of blastomeres and grading based on degree of fragmentation and blastomere size).

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S)

We tested two decision models, one based on Z-scores and another on morphology, to determine which grading system better predicted pregnancy outcomes in assisted reproductive technique. Zygote score and embryo morphology were measured for all embryos and the transferred embryo pool. Implantation and pregnancy rates resulting from the embryo transfers of all cycles were calculated.

RESULT(S)

The Z-score distribution of 552 embryos was 27% Z1, 8% Z2, 50% Z3, and 15% Z4. Z1 and Z3 embryos had significantly (P approximately .03) higher quality over Z2 and Z4 embryos. Using the Z-score decision model with Z1 embryos having highest priority for transfer, pregnancy rates were similar between Z1 and Z3 embryos. Using embryo morphology as a decision model, pregnancy rates were highest in transfers containing one or two "best"-quality embryos.

CONCLUSION(S)

Z1 and Z3 embryos had similar morphology and pregnancy rates. The decision model based on the Z-score model was not better than standard embryo morphology in predicting pregnancy outcome.

Significance of morphological attributes of the early embryo

There are many morphological transformations during development of human embryos that mainly involve phenomena that can be easily assessed in living embryos by simple non-invasive microscopical observation. A clear correlation between pronuclear morphology and the ability of the resulting embryo to continue developing and to implant has been described. There is also general agreement that a positive relationship exists between early embryo morphology and implantation rate. The parameters classically involved in embryo evaluation are: cleavage rate, blastomere symmetry, cytoplasmic appearance, extent of fragmentation and blastomere nuclear status. In this paper, morphological features that have been related to embryo developmental potential are described. Furthermore, the ability of a cumulative classification scheme developed in the laboratory to predict blastocyst formation and implantation is analysed.

Predictive factors for embryo implantation potential

In spite of recent improvements in IVF, pregnancy rates have not increased significantly and one of the major problems remains the high multiple pregnancy rate. Better criteria are therefore necessary to establish the viability of a transferable embryo. Early prognosis of the developmental fate of the oocyte would help in selecting the best embryos to transfer, but non-invasive selection at the oocyte stage (extracytoplasmic and intracytoplasmic morphology) has proved to be of little prognostic value. Recently, it has been shown that follicular vascularization appears to be predictive of oocyte developmental fate, making it a good first-step approach for selection. Observation of pronuclei patterns at the zygote stage appears to offer an additional prognostic tool, correlating well with IVF outcome. Morphological evaluation of the embryo at days 2-3 remains the most used and valid method of selection, even though it is not sufficient to select embryos with the higher implantation potential. Blastocyst culture is another possible strategy for selecting the best embryos with reduced risk of aneuploidies, though not all major chromosomal aberrations are excluded by prolonged in-vitro culture. In summary, selecting the best embryo for transfer is a decision that should be based on choices made during the different stages of assisted reproductive technologies.

Preimplantation genetic diagnosis for aneuploidy screening in repeated implantation failure

Chromosomal abnormalities are thought to be responsible for implantation failure, and among chromosomal abnormalities in normally developing embryos, aneuploidy is the most frequent. Genetic testing of preimplantation embryos for chromosomal aneuploidy allows selection of chromosomally normal embryos, and early detection of chromosomal aberration will increase the chance of conceiving. Preimplantation genetic diagnosis for aneuploidy screening (PGD-AS), performed by polar body or blastomere analysis, is used in infertile patients treated with assisted reproduction technologies, especially in those with a poor prognosis, e.g. repeated IVF failure, advanced maternal age, or recurrent spontaneous abortion. The aim of this paper is to clarify the impact of PGD-AS in repeated implantation failure. In this review, the data collected so far regarding PGD-AS in this patient group will be discussed in depth.

High magnitude of light retardation by the zona pellucida is associated with conception cycles

BACKGROUND

Failures in expression of zona proteins correlate to subfertility in animals. Low expression of the zona proteins by the growing human oocyte may indicate reduced developmental potential. Therefore, we non-invasively analysed the thickness and the structure of the zona pellucida (ZP) of human oocytes with respect to embryo fate after ICSI.

METHODS

Retardance magnitude and thickness of the inner, middle and outer layers of the ZP were quantitatively analysed by a Polscope in 166 oocytes selected for transfer after ICSI (63 patients; 32.8 +/- 4.4 years) on the basis of pronuclear score at day 1. Blastomere number was determined at day 2. Data were compared between conception cycles (CC; 65 oocytes/23 patients) and non-conception cycles (NCC; 101 oocytes/40 patients) and with respect to maternal age.

RESULTS

The thickness was slightly elevated (P < 0.001), and the mean magnitude of light retardance was nearly 30% higher (P < 0.001) in the inner layer of the zona pellucida of oocytes contributing to CC compared to NCC. Embryos in the CC group tended to develop faster.

CONCLUSIONS

The magnitude of light retardance by the zona pellucida inner layer appears to present a unique non-invasive marker for oocyte developmental potential.

Predicting embryo quality: mRNA expression and the preimplantation embryo

To overcome the low implantation rate (10-20%) following IVF in humans, more than two embryos are commonly replaced, potentially leading to high order multiple pregnancies with associated significantly elevated risks. Selecting the most viable embryos and transferring fewer of them could reduce this risk. Prolonged culture of embryos in vitro to the blastocyst stage may expose the embryo to hazards not normally encountered in the female reproductive tract. Recent studies comparing bovine oocyte maturation, fertilization and embryo culture in vivo and in vitro have demonstrated that the origin of the oocyte is the main factor affecting blastocyst yield, while the post-fertilization culture environment is crucial in determining blastocyst quality, measured in terms of cryotolerance and relative transcript abundance, irrespective of the origin of the oocyte. Production of embryos in vitro, particularly when using an extended period of in-vitro culture may predispose the embryo to phenomena such as 'large offspring syndrome', which is probably linked to altered gene expression, particularly of imprinted genes. Post-fertilization culture environment clearly has a profound effect on the relative abundance of gene transcripts within the embryo. Culture under sub-optimal conditions for even one day can lead to perturbations in the pattern of expression.

Paternal effects on cell division in the preimplantation embryo

Cell divisions in the human preimplantation embryo can be compromised by deficiencies in sperm nuclear genome or sperm-derived developmentally relevant cytoplasmic factors, oocyte activating substance and centriole. Sperm nuclear deficiencies are usually not detected before the 8-cell stage of embryo development, when a major expression of sperm-derived genes has begun. Sperm cytoplasmic deficiencies can be detected as early as the 1-cell zygote and then throughout the preimplantation development. The terms 'late paternal effect' and 'early paternal effect' have been suggested to denote these two pathological conditions. The late paternal effect is associated with an increased incidence of sperm DNA fragmentation. No association with sperm DNA damage has been found for the early paternal effect. The diagnosis of the late paternal effect is thus based on the examination of sperm DNA integrity, which should be performed in cases of repeated assisted reproduction failure even if morphologically normal embryos result from fertilization with the patient's spermatozoa. The only element leading to the diagnosis of the early paternal effect is poor zygote and embryo morphology and low cleavage speed. The absence of increased sperm DNA damage does not exclude the presence of this pathology. ICSI with testicular spermatozoa has recently been shown to be an efficient treatment for the late paternal effect. The use of oral antioxidant treatment in this indication has also given promising results.