Measured TG-60 dosimetric parameters of the Novoste Beta-Cath 90Sr/Y source trains for intravascular brachytherapy

A new delivery system to resolve dosimetric issues in intravascular brachytherapy

PURPOSE

Renewed interest is being expressed in intravascular brachytherapy (IVBT). A number of unresolved issues exist in the discipline. Providing a homogeneous and adequate dose to the target remains difficult in IVBT. The guidewire that delivers the device to the target, arterial plaques, and stent struts are all known to reduce the dose delivered to target. The viability and efficacy of a proposed IVBT delivery system designed to resolve the issue of guidewire attenuation is evaluated and compared to that of a popular and commercially available IVBT device.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Monte Carlo simulations are conducted to determine distributions of absorbed dose around an existing and proposed IVBT delivery system.

RESULTS

For the Novoste Beta-Cath 3.5F (TeamBest®), dose in water varies by 10% as a function of angle in the plane perpendicular to the delivery catheter due to off-centering of seeds in the catheter. Dose is reduced by 52% behind a stainless steel guidewire and 64% behind a guidewire, arterial plaque, and stent strut for the Novoste Beta-Cath 3.5F. Dose is not perturbed by the presence of a guidewire for the proposed device and is reduced by 46% by an arterial plaque and stent strut.

CONCLUSIONS

Dose attenuation by guidewire is likely the single greatest source of dose attenuation in IVBT in terms of absolute dose reduction and is greater than previously reported for the Novoste Beta-Cath 3.5F. The Novoste Beta-Cath 3.5F delivers an inhomogeneous dose to target. A delivery system is proposed, which resolves the issue of guidewire attenuation in IVBT and should reduce treatment times.

A retrospective analysis of catheter-based sources in intravascular brachytherapy

PURPOSE

Coronary artery disease involves the deposition of plaque along the walls of a coronary artery leading to narrowed or blocked vessels (stenosis) and is one of the main causes of death in developed countries. Percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty (PTCA) is used to reverse stenosis. Restenosis (renarrowing) of the treated vessel is a major complication of PTCA. A metal mesh tube (stent) can be placed inside the vessel to prevent restenosis. Tissue stress incurred during PTCA and stenting can provoke neointimal cell proliferation leading to in-stent restenosis (ISR). Intravascular brachytherapy (IVBT), a form of internal radiotherapy, is used to treat ISR. Renewed interest in IVBT is being expressed as a treatment for patients with ISR in drug-eluting stents. Current treatment planning (TP) of IVBT is extremely limited and assumes human tissue can be approximated by water. The interactions of arterial plaque, guidewires, and the stent have been shown to attenuate radiation significantly but are ignored in TP. Other models have determined the degree of attenuation by each factor in isolation. For the first time, we create a model with several inhomogenities present to determine whether attenuation by multiple inhomogenities combines linearly or if a larger dose reduction than anticipated is realized. We are also able to evaluate a spatial distribution of dose around the source and in arterial walls.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

A dosimetric analysis of two commercially available IVBT systems was performed in a Monte Carlo-based particle simulation (Geant4). Absorbed dose was calculated using a model of a human coronary artery with a calcified plaque and stent. Dose delivered in water was also calculated to evaluate the accuracy of a water approximation.

RESULTS

Dose as a function of θ shows significant variation around IVBT sources. For the Guidant Galileo, dose is reduced by 20% behind stent struts and as much as 66% in a region occluded by the guidewire, plaque, and stent. For the Novoste Beta Cath device, delivered dose is reduced by 19% and 58%, respectively, in the same regions.

CONCLUSIONS

Our findings show that the water approximation used in clinical practice to calculate dose is inaccurate when inhomogeneities are present. Methods proposed for calculating dose perturbations in IVBT may underestimate the magnitude of dose reduction. Increasing source dwell time seems unlikely to resolve dosimetric issues in IVBT. The effectiveness of currently existing β-emitting devices may be reduced in patients with complex lesions at the treatment site. Investigation of new radioisotopes and off-centering devices should be considered to improve dose outcomes.

Dose perturbation caused by stents: experiments with a model 90Sr/90Y source

PURPOSE

Biological effects of intravascular brachytherapy are very sensitive to discrepancies between the prescription and the applied dose. If brachytherapy is aimed at in-stent restenosis, shielding and shadowing effects of metallic stents may change the dose distribution relative to that produced by the bare source. The development of new generations of stents inspired us to a new experimental study in this field. The effect was studied for 14 stents which we have recently encountered in clinical practice.

METHODS

The model source was a continuous 20-mm column of (90)Sr/(90)Y solution sealed in a 1-mm-I.D. Plexiglas capillary. The dose distribution in the Plexiglas phantom was mapped using GafChromic MD-55-2 film. The stent masses varied from 2.5 to 25 mg; the strut thicknesses, from 0.075 to 0.15 mm; and the atomic numbers of stent materials, from 24 (Cr) to 79 (Au).

RESULTS

Dose perturbations depend on a variety of stent features. Local reduction of the mean dose rates near the reference distance (r(0) = 2 mm) varied from 11% to 47%. No simple correlation was found between these data and stent characteristics, but it seems that the atomic number of the stent material is less important than the strut thickness and mesh density.

CONCLUSION

The results provide a warning that clinical indications for in-stent radiation therapy must always be confronted with another aspect of the patient's history: the kind of implanted stent. Intravascular brachytherapy using pure beta sources may be recommended only for patients "wearing" light, thin-strut stents. The presence of thick-strut stents is a contraindication for this modality, due to excessive dose perturbation.

β-Radiation for the Creation of Linear Lesions in the Canine Atrium

Background— Creating linear lesions is important for the treatment of arrhythmias such as atrial flutter and fibrillation. Making these lesions with standard radiofrequency catheters can be difficult and may result in charring and thrombosis. The purpose of this study was to evaluate β-radiation as a novel energy source for creating linear myocardial lesions.

Methods and Results— Eight dogs with intact conduction across the cavotricuspid isthmus were studied. The isthmus was irradiated (25 to 50 Gy) with strontium/yttrium-90 delivered via a deflectable 7F catheter (Novoste Corporation). There were no immediate effects, but bidirectional conduction block developed during follow-up studies in 7 of 8 dogs. The dog without conduction block received 25 Gy. After the animals were euthanized, histology revealed transmural, linear areas of fibrosis without any thrombus.

Conclusions— β-Radiation can safely and effectively create linear lesions that are contiguous and nonthrombogenic. This energy source may become an interesting adjunct to radiofrequency for the treatment of atrial flutter and fibrillation.