Severe hypoglycemic coma due to insulin autoimmune syndrome

Safety of Antithyroid Drugs in Avoiding Hyperglycemia or Hypoglycemia in Patients With Graves' Disease and Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus: A Literature Review

Graves' disease (GD) may increase the difficulty of glucose control in patients with type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM). Therefore, selecting a drug with limited blood glucose side effects is an important issue in patients with T2DM and GD. Antithyroid drugs (ATDs) including propylthiouracil (PTU), methimazole, and carbimazole are commonly prescribed for the treatment of GD. Here, we review and summarize the literature from the last 10 years and discuss the effects of current ATDs used for GD for blood glucose control in patients with T2DM. A search of the literature published between January 1, 2012 and December 1, 2022 was conducted using three major medical databases: Google Scholar, Ovid Medline, and Scopus. An initial search was conducted on PubMed using the MeSH terms "propylthiouracil," "methimazole," "carbimazole," and "hyperglycemia" or "hypoglycemia" in academic databases. All articles included "Graves' disease" and "type 2 diabetes mellitus" in the title. Based on the results of previous studies, the hyperglycemic and hypoglycemic side effects of ATDs can be explained by several possible mechanisms. The most widely accepted hypothesis is that sulfhydryl group drugs (e.g., methimazole and carbimazole) cleave the disulfide bond of insulin and enhance its immunogenicity, resulting in hypoglycemia. Moreover, some reports have indicated that methimazole is associated with hypoglycemia; therefore, if the patient has a history of autoimmune diseases, it is necessary to consider whether to change drugs or actively track the production of autoimmune antibodies. In non-diabetic and diabetic patients with GD, the hyperglycemic and hypoglycemic side effects of PTU (on glycemic variation) were less than that of thiamazole. However, as relatively few reports have investigated the side effects of blood sugar changes, further research is necessary to confirm these effects. In addition to autoimmune diseases, drug side effects may need to be considered. These findings provide considerations for clinicians to select more appropriate ATDs for patients with GD and T2DM, and implement improved care guidelines.

Case report: hypoglycemia secondary to methimazole-induced insulin autoimmune syndrome in young Taiwanese woman with Graves' disease

RATIONALE

Hypoglycemia is an emergent condition with many causes, including underlying diabetes mellitus either with the use of insulin or oral anti-diabetic medications for glucose control, and organ (heart, hepatic, or renal) failure. Insulin autoimmune syndrome (IAS) can also cause hypoglycemia, however it is relatively difficult to diagnose as it is rare clinically. Although uncommon, IAS can be life threatening in patients with persistent hypoglycemia.

PATIENT CONCERN

We report the case of a 27-year-old female with underlying Graves' disease who was treated with methimazole (MTZ). After 6 weeks of treatment, she developed hypoglycemia symptoms accompanied by dizziness and cold sweating. We excluded underlying diabetes mellitus, the use of insulin or oral anti-diabetic medications, and organ failure.

DIAGNOSES

Laboratory data showed elevated insulin and C-peptide levels. Therefore, insulinoma and IAS were suspected. Abdominal computed tomography and magnetic resonance imaging ruled out insulinoma, and MTZ-induced IAS was finally diagnosed.

INTERVENTIONS AND OUTCOMES

The hypoglycemia symptoms resolved after MTZ was switched to propylthiouracil, confirming the diagnosis of IAS.

LESSONS

This case emphasizes the significance of life-threatening MTZ-induced IAS. IAS should be suspected in patients who develop spontaneous hypoglycemia, especially in those with underlying Graves' disease receiving MTZ who present with hyperinsulinism.

Insulin Autoimmune Syndrome (Hirata Disease): A Comprehensive Review Fifty Years After Its First Description

Insulin autoimmune syndrome (IAS), also named Hirata's disease, is a rare condition characterized by hypoglycemic episodes due to the presence of high titers of insulin autoantibodies (IAA). IAS is a form of immune-mediated hypoglycemia, which develops when a triggering factor (ie, a medication or a viral infection) acts on an underlying predisposing genetic background. IAS pathogenesis involves the formation of insulin-IAA complexes that induce glycemic alterations with a double-phase mechanism: IAA prevent insulin to bind its receptor in the postprandial phase, possibly resulting in mild hyperglycemia; thereafter, insulin is released from the complexes irrespective of blood glucose concentrations, thus inducing hypoglycemia. The diagnosis of IAS is challenging, requiring a careful workup aimed at excluding other causes of hyperinsulinemic hypoglycemia. The gold standard for the definitive diagnosis is the finding of IAA in a blood sample. Because IAS is frequently a self-remitting disease, its management mostly consists of supportive measures, such as dietary modifications, aimed at preventing the development of hypoglycemia. Pharmacological therapies may occasionally be necessary for patients presenting with severe manifestations of IAS. Available therapies may include drugs that reduce pancreatic insulin secretion (somatostatin analogues and diazoxide, for instance) and immunosuppressive agents (glucocorticoids, azathioprine and rituximab). The purpose of this review is to provide a comprehensive analysis of the disease, by describing the burden of knowledge that has been obtained in the 50 years following its first description, took in 1970, and by highlighting the points that are still unclear in its pathogenesis and management.

Insulin Autoimmune Syndrome Diagnosis and Therapy in a Single Chinese Center

PURPOSE

Insulin autoimmune syndrome (IAS) is a relatively rare cause of hypoglycemia characterized by endogenous hyperinsulinism and autoantibodies against endogenous insulin despite no prior exposure to exogenous insulin. We present a series of IAS cases and describe the clinical characteristics of these cases.

METHODS

The medical records of inpatients with the final diagnosis of IAS were collected from August 2007 to August 2017 in Peking Union Medical College Hospital. Clinical characteristics and laboratory test results were summarized. The results of serum glucose, insulin, true insulin, and C-peptide testing during 5-h oral glucose tolerance tests were also summarized. Circulating immune complexes were assessed qualitatively by precipitation with polyethylene glycol (PEG) in some patients.

FINDINGS

Sixteen patients were included in this study. Insulin autoimmune antibody test results were found positive in 12 patients and weakly positive in 1 patient. Nine patients had an insulin to C-peptide molar ratio >1, whereas 6 patients had an insulin to C-peptide molar ratio <1. Circulating immune complexes were verified in all 4 patients who had been assessed with PEG. During 5-h oral glucose tolerance tests, the C-peptide level responded earlier to the glucose tolerance and had a shorter peak value period compared with insulin, although C-peptide's fluctuation still lagged behind the glucose fluctuation. Three patients presented with self-limited disease courses or limited disease course after discontinuing use of the sulfhydryl group drugs. Some patients' symptoms were relieved after small frequent meals, and some were relieved after taking acarbose. Only 3 patients took glucocorticoids as the anti-immune therapy.

IMPLICATIONS

The insulin to C-peptide molar ratios were not consistently >1 in patients with confirmed diagnoses of IAS in our study, which suggested the low sensitivity of insulin to C-peptide molar ratio to detect IAS. The therapy in our study also revealed the self-limited disease course of IAS, and despite the effectiveness of anti-immunity therapy, convenient therapy, such as frequent small meals and adding acarbose, performed well in many patients.

Rare Cause of Recurrent Hypoglycemia: Insulin Autoimmune Syndrome

We report a case of insulin autoimmune syndrome associated with several autoantibodies, presenting with recurrent hypoglycemia, predominantly in the postprandial period, which improved by dietary management and spontaneously resolved within two months. Differentiation from other causes of hyperinsulinemic hypoglycemia, such as insulinoma, is important to avoid unnecessary invasive procedures or surgical interventions. The 75-gram oral glucose tolerance test (OGTT) and mixed meal test showed a typical pattern, which may be useful indirect evidence of insulin autoimmune syndrome.

The insulin autoimmune syndrome (IAS) as a cause of hypoglycaemia: an update on the pathophysiology, biochemical investigations and diagnosis

Insulin autoimmune syndrome (IAS) is considered to be very rare in Caucasians. Understanding its pathophysiology is paramount in (a) appreciating its potential impact on analyses of pancreatic hormones and (b) explaining its highly variable clinical manifestations in non-diabetic, non-acutely ill patients with indeterminate hypoglycaemia. The underlying aetiology of IAS is the presence of variable affinity/avidity endogenous insulin antibodies in significant amounts. The two types of insulin antibodies namely antibodies which bind insulin and/or proinsulin(s) and receptor antibodies (insulin mimetic) will be discussed. Their biochemical and immunological roles in causing hypoglycaemia will be highlighted. Clinical manifestations of IAS can vary from mild and transient to spontaneous, severe and protracted hypoglycaemia necessitating in extreme cases plasmapheresis for glycaemic control. Antibodies of IAS can interfere in pancreatic immunoassay tests causing erroneous and potentially misleading results. Thorough testing for endogenous insulin antibodies must be considered in the investigations of non-diabetic, non-acutely ill patients with indeterminate and/or unexplained hypoglycaemia.

Hyperinsulinemic hypoglycemia associated with insulin antibodies caused by exogenous insulin analog

Insulin antibodies (IA) associated with exogenous insulin administration seldom caused hypoglycemia and had different characteristics from insulin autoantibodies (IAA) found in insulin autoimmune syndrome (IAS), which was first described by Dr Hirata in 1970. The characteristic of IAS is the presence of insulin-binding autoantibodies and related fasting or late postprandial hypoglycemia. Here, we report a patient with type 1 diabetes mellitus under insulin glargine and insulin aspart treatment who developed recurrent spontaneous post-absorptive hyperinsulinemic hypoglycemia with the cause probably being insulin antibodies induced by exogenous injected insulin. Examinations of serial sera disclosed a high titre of insulin antibodies (33%, normal <5%), high insulin concentration (111.9 IU/mL) and undetectable C-peptide when hypoglycemia occurred. An oral glucose tolerance test revealed persistent high serum levels of total insulin and undetectable C-peptide. Image studies of the pancreas were unremarkable, which excluded the diagnosis of insulinoma. The patient does not take any of the medications containing sulfhydryl compounds, which had been reported to cause IAS. After administering oral prednisolone for 3 weeks, hypoglycemic episodes markedly improved, and he was discharged smoothly.

LEARNING POINTS

Insulin autoimmune syndrome (IAS) or IAS-like situation should be one of the differential diagnosis in patients with hyperinsulinemic hypoglycemia.Although less reported, insulin antibodies (IA) caused by exogenous insulin analog should be considered as the cause of hypoglycemia.Patients with suspected insulin autoimmune syndrome (IAS) should be screened for drugs related to autoimmunity to endogenous insulin.

Clinical features and causes of endogenous hyperinsulinemic hypoglycemia in Korea

BACKGROUND

Endogenous hyperinsulinemic hypoglycemia (EHH) is characterized by an inappropriately high plasma insulin level, despite a low plasma glucose level. Most of the EHH cases are caused by insulinoma, whereas nesidioblastosis and insulin autoimmune syndrome (IAS) are relatively rare.

METHODS

To evaluate the relative frequencies of various causes of EHH in Korea, we retrospectively analyzed 84 patients who were diagnosed with EHH from 1998 to 2012 in a university hospital.

RESULTS

Among the 84 EHH patients, 74 patients (88%), five (6%), and five (6%) were diagnosed with insulinoma, nesidioblastosis or IAS, respectively. The most common clinical manifestation of EHH was neuroglycopenic symptoms. Symptom duration before diagnosis was 14.5 months (range, 1 to 120 months) for insulinoma, 1.0 months (range, 6 days to 7 months) for nesidioblastosis, and 2.0 months (range, 1 to 12 months) for IAS. One patient, who was diagnosed with nesidioblastosis in 2006, underwent distal pancreatectomy but was later determined to be positive for insulin autoantibodies. Except for one patient who was diagnosed in 2007, the remaining three patients with nesidioblastosis demonstrated severe hyperinsulinemia (157 to 2,719 µIU/mL), which suggests that these patients might have had IAS, rather than nesidioblastosis.

CONCLUSION

The results of this study suggest that the prevalence of IAS may be higher in Korea than previously thought. Therefore, measurement of insulin autoantibody levels is warranted for EHH patients, especially in patients with very high plasma insulin levels.

Insulinoma in a young female patient with systemic lupus erythematosus: a case report

OBJECTIVE

Fasting hypoglycemia may occur in subjects with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) when accompanied with insulin-binding antibodies or insulin-receptor antibodies. However, insulinoma has not been reported in SLE subjects with hypoglycemia.

METHODS

We present a case report and review the relevant literature.

RESULTS

A 26-year-old female with underlying SLE experienced several episodes of neuropsychiatric symptoms in a fasting state. The steroid dosage was titrated up, but in vain. Timely imaging studies showed a pancreatic tumor, and insulinoma was proven by pathology. Hypoglycemia did not recur after surgery.

CONCLUSION

Physicians should distinguish insulinoma from autoimmunity-mediated hypoglycemia in SLE patients with fasting hypoglycemia.

[Endogenous hyperinsulinism: two diagnostic challenges]

Hypoglycemia in apparently healthy adults is a rare finding in clinical practice requiring a thorough investigation of the cause. During the investigation, identification of hypoglycemia associated with inappropriately high levels of insulin and C-peptide should prompt the exclusion of rare causes of hypoglycemia, including pancreatic islet-cells disease and autoimmune hypoglycemia. In this paper, we describe two cases of hypoglycemia associated with endogenous hyperinsulinism, whose causes are uncommon in clinical practice, and review important aspects of the diagnosis and treatment of hyperinsulinemic hypoglycemia.

Severe hypoglycemia secondary to methimazole-induced insulin autoimmune syndrome in a 16 year old African-American male

Insulin autoimmune syndrome (IAS) or Hirata's disease is a rare disorder characterized by hypoglycemia secondary to insulin autoantibodies (IAb). Over 200 patients have been described from Japan with significantly less numbers being reported from outside the Orient. IAS is more common in patients older than 40 yr of age with reports in the pediatric age group being notably rarer. Exposure to sulfhydryl group containing medications is implicated in the pathogenesis of this syndrome. In this report, we describe a case of IAS in an African-American adolescent. A 16-yr-old healthy African-American male was diagnosed with Graves' disease and started on Methimazole. Four weeks later, he was found unconscious and hypoglycemic (blood sugar 1.5 mmol/L). Evaluation was negative for insulinoma. Insulin antibodies were positive. Oral glucose tolerance test revealed elevated free insulin concentrations with disproportionately elevated total insulin levels. The patient was started on prednisone, diazoxide, and propranolol for management of IAS and hyperthyroidism. Thyroid radio-ablation was subsequently undertaken. The doses of prednisone and diazoxide were tapered and these medications discontinued after 9 months. The insulin antibody levels decreased gradually and became undetectable in 6 months with resolution of the hypoglycemia.

Clinical features and morphological characterization of 10 patients with noninsulinoma pancreatogenous hypoglycaemia syndrome (NIPHS)

OBJECTIVE

Noninsulinoma pancreatogenous hypoglycaemia syndrome (NIPHS), characterized by postprandial neuroglycopaenia, negative prolonged fasts and negative perioperative localization studies for insulinoma, but positive selective arterial calcium stimulation tests and nesidioblastosis in the gradient-guided resected pancreas, is a rare hypoglycaemic disorder of undetermined aetiology. We analysed the clinical, morphological and immunohistological features to further clarify the aetiology and pathogenesis of this rare disease.

PATIENTS

Ten consecutive patients with NIPHS (nine men and one woman, aged 29-78 years) were included in the study. Six of the 10 received a gradient-guided subtotal (70%) or distal (50%) pancreatectomy. In the remaining four patients, diazoxide treatment was initiated and the precise mechanism of its action was assessed by meal tests.

RESULTS

All of the patients showed a combination of postprandial neuroglycopaenia, negative prolonged fasts (except one patient) and negative localization studies for insulinoma, but positive calcium stimulation tests and nesidioblastosis in the gradient-guided resected pancreas. Immunohistological studies of the resected pancreatic tissues revealed neither an increased rate of proliferation of beta-cells nor an abnormal synthesis and/or processing of either proinsulin or amylin. Evidence of overexpression of the two pancreatic differentiation factors, PDX-1 and Nkx-6.1, as well as the calcium sensing receptor (CaSR) was absent. Nevertheless, abnormal expression of islet neogenesis-associated protein (INGAP), a human cytokine expressed only in the presence of islet neogenesis, in ducts and/or islets, was identified in three of the five patients studied. All of the six patients who received a surgical operation were relieved of further neuroglycopaenic attacks, but one patient who received a subtotal pancreatectomy developed diabetes. In the remaining four patients who received diazoxide treatment, hypoglycaemic episodes were satisfactorily controlled with an attenuated response of beta-cell peptides to meal stimulation.

CONCLUSIONS

Our results strengthen the existence of this unique clinical hypoglycaemic syndrome from beta-cell hyperfunction as well as the value of the selective arterial calcium stimulation test in its correct diagnosis and localization. The mechanisms underlying beta-cell hyperfunction and release of insulin to calcium, however, remain poorly characterized. Nevertheless, in a subset of patients with NIPHS, there exists some, as yet undefined, pancreatic humoral/paracrine factor(s) other than proinsulin, amylin, PDX-1, Nkx-6.1 and possibly glucagon-like peptide-1 (GLP-1) that are capable of inducing the INGAP gene and, if activated, will initiate ductal proliferation and islet neogenesis. As for the treatment, we recommend that diazoxide be tried first in each patient and, should it fail, a gradient-guided subtotal or distal pancreatectomy be attempted.