The effect of enterocystoplasty on bone strength assessed at four different skeletal sites in a rat model

Animal models in urinary diversion

We set out to critically assess the value of animal experimentation in urinary diversion through intestinal segments, as some authors question the effectiveness of animal research, criticising the methodological quality, lack of standardization, inadequate reporting and the few systematic reviews in this field. Based on a comprehensive MEDLINE literature search (MeSH database; search terms: urinary diversion, urinary reservoirs, continent, rat, dog, animal models) we retrieved and evaluated all full-length papers published in English, German, French, and Spanish languages from 1966 to 2011 reporting the use of animal models in the setting of urinary diversion. Studies were stratified according to the addressed research question. Within each category species, gender, number of animals, age at procedure, type of diversion, mortality, length of follow-up, experimental procedure and outcome were recorded and tabulated. In all, 159 articles were judged to be relevant and while there are numerous animal models only a few have been used in more than one study. Animals were used for the systematic study of new surgical techniques (93 articles) or metabolic and functional consequences of urinary reconstruction (66 articles). For the latter purpose, the most often used animal is the rat, whereas the dog model is preferred for technical experimentation. In many studies, the validity of the model is at least questionable. Animal experiments have repeatedly been conducted addressing the same question, often with striking discrepancies in outcome. Animal studies were even performed after a surgical technique had been pioneered in humans. The use of animal models in urinary diversion is far from standardized rendering the results less than ideal for comparison across studies. Due to differences in anatomy and physiology, the applicability of findings in animal experiments to clinical urology is limited. Continued effort is needed to optimise the use of animal models in experimental urology.

Metabolic factors in the causation of urinary tract stones in patients with enterocystoplasties

Stones are a common complication of the storage of urine in intestinal reservoirs. Previous studies have identified predisposing physical characteristics in the reservoirs. Biochemical and dietary factors have been little investigated. Fifteen patients (6 males and 9 females) who had undergone various enterocystoplasty operations and who had subsequently formed either upper or lower urinary tract stones were investigated. The programme has been previously described and included stone, blood and urine analysis and dietary review. Comparison was made with 15 age- and sex-matched idiopathic stone formers with normal bladders. Stones were infective in origin in 86% of cases, and 14% were sterile. Metabolic screen showed that 80% of enterocystoplasty patients had risk factors for at least three different types of stone. All patients had raised pH (mean 6.93) and hypocitraturia. Five had a raised alkaline phosphatase. Raised serum and urinary calcium, hyperoxaluria and hyperuricosuria were found in 33% of patients. Five had a 24-h urine volume below 1.6 l/day. All patients had a high risk index (PSF) for phosphatic stones and 12 also for calcium oxalate stones. Compared to age-and sex-matched idiopathic stone-formers, the urine had a higher pH, sodium and protein excretion and a lower calcium and citrate excretion. Although the patients were already selected as stone-formers, the data show that metabolic and dietary factors are present. They may be as important in the aetiology of the stones, as the already recognised factors of infection and poor reservoir drainage. Investigation should include such factors, the presence of which may be taken into account in a prophylactic regime.

Experimental renal failure and iron overload: a histomorphometric study in rat tibia

Renal failure (RF) is a serious disease of relatively high incidence, known to cause bone alterations. RF patients frequently suffer anemia, which is usually treated with iron. Given that iron overload inhibits bone formation, the aim of the present study was to evaluate the effect of iron on the subchondral bone of rat tibiae, using a model of renal failure. Male Wistar rats were subjected to experimental nephrectomy in order to induce renal failure and to iron overload by daily intraperitoneal injections of 88 mg/kg body weight of iron-dextran for 16 days. Tetracyclines were injected intraperitoneally to evaluate dynamic parameters of bone. Undecalcified histological sections of the tibiae were obtained. Serum urea, creatinine, and paratohormone (PTH) levels were evaluated 30 days after the onset of the experiment. Static and dynamic histomorphometric measurements were performed. Iron overload modified the response of the animals with renal failure: a reduction in bone forming activity compatible with adynamic bone disease and a decrease in peritrabecular fibrosis were observed. Our results suggest that iron is yet one more factor involved in the imbalance in bone metabolism typically found in renal failure patients treated with iron, rendering diagnosis and treatment of bone disease in these patients more complex.

Changes in bone structure after augmentation cystoplasty in chronic uraemic rats

OBJECTIVE

To investigate the effect of urinary diversion using several types of intestinal segments on cortical and cancellous bone structure of growing rats with renal insufficiency.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

In all, 110 female Sprague-Dawley rats (8 weeks old) had either a two-stage subtotal nephrectomy by removing five-sixths of the renal mass, or a sham operation. Except for a uraemic control group, all uraemic rats then had an enterocystoplasty using stomach, ileum or colon (20 animals per group). An additional group with colic augmentation received the bisphosphonate ibandronate. After 12 weeks, the left tibia was assessed using peripheral quantitative computed tomography and bone histomorphometry.

RESULTS

After subtotal nephrectomy all groups had approximately 30% less endogenous creatinine clearance. Renal failure alone or in association with gastric or colic augmentation induced only negligible changes in the mass and structure of cortical and cancellous tibial bone. In contrast, rats after ileal augmentation and renal failure had a significant reduction in cancellous bone mineral density (P < 0.05) whereas the reduction in trabecular bone area and volume was not statistically significant. Furthermore, ileocystoplasty caused a decrease in trabecular number and perimeter, increased trabecular separation and enlarged bone marrow space, whereas ileocystoplasty had no effect on cortical bone. The changes were not associated with alterations in serum pH. Ibandronate treatment in the colonic cystoplasty group increased trabecular bone mass and structural variables over the untreated colonic cystoplasty group.

CONCLUSIONS

These results suggest that cystoplasty using an ileal segment causes a decrease in bone mass and architecture in growing rats with mild uraemia. It remains open to question whether the results obtained from experimental animals can be directly extrapolated to the clinical situation.

Bladder, bowel and bones--skeletal changes after intestinal urinary diversion

Impaired bone metabolism following urinary diversion through intestinal segments has always been a controversial subject of unclear clinical relevance. Whereas the perpetuated pathophysiological considerations seem conclusive in theory, the role of acidosis and malabsorption is less clear in animal experimentation and, even more so, in the clinical reality of modern continent diversion. In hardly any of the available contemporary case series was overt derangement of the acid-base balance, rickets or osteomalacia encountered. No consistent changes in osteotropic serum parameters could be found with normal calcium and phosphate in all patients. The assumption that colonic reservoirs have a higher risk of developing metabolic bone disease could not be confirmed by clinical data. As early correction of base excess is easy and probably a common policy in patients with intestinal urinary reservoirs, it will be virtually impossible to further study the natural history of bone metabolism after urinary diversion. While there is no need for a bone specific follow-up in asymptomatic adults with a normal acid-base balance, particular attention should be paid to children and to all patients with impaired renal function.