Coitus-induced ovulation and its implications for estimates of some reproductive parameters

Sex ratio, coital rate, hormones and time of fertilization within the cycle

In this paper I shall consider the relationships between coital rates, timing of fertilization within the cycle, and sex ratios of the resulting offspring. It will be suggested that there is: (1) Analytic (mathematical) evidence for a correlation between coital rate and time of fertilization. (2) Empirical evidence for a correlation between time of fertilization and sex ratio of offspring. Whence there arises: (3) A correlation between coital rate and sex ratio secondary to correlations of both with time of fertilization. These variables will be considered in these pairs in order. Section 4 will be devoted to the magnitude of the correlation between coital rate and sex ratio. Lastly it will be noted that the data on these two variables cohere not only with that on timing of insemination, but with the overall hypothesis that parental hormone levels at conception are causally associated with sex ratios at birth.

Behavioral and biological determinants of fecundability

Our discussion has focused on a set of behavioral and physiological factors which influence fecundability. Some potentially important determinants are notable primarily because of their absence. Foremost among these determinants (as a group) are the male attributes. We have, by and large, ignored the links between male sexual behavior and hormonal profiles and the effects of hormones (or other factors) on sperm function. The fact that we have not reviewed them here does not imply that we believe that they are unimportant. Indeed, the effects of male factors may be particularly important because in some settings men are the predominant, if not the sole, decision-makers regarding reproductive behaviors including initiation of sexual intercourse and use of contraception. Also conspicuous by their absence are the effects of nutrition, consumption of alcohol, exercise, smoking, and behavioral and hormonal correlates of stress, all of which may affect fecundability. We have, though, reviewed a wide range of factors which contribute to fecundability and identified several points of potential interaction between the behavioral and biological determinants. We expect that our future understanding of these processes will be enhanced by empirical work and modeling efforts which also interact to draw upon the insights provided by each.

The incidence of superfecundation and of double paternity in the general population

It is estimated that at least one dizygotic (DZ) twin maternity in twelve is preceded by superfecundation (the fertilization of two ova by sperm from different coitions). Presumably this parameter varies from population to population eg. with coital rates and rates of double ovulation. Sometimes superfecundation occurs by two different men. The frequency with which this occurs must depend on rates of infidelity (promiscuity). It is suggested that among DZ twins born to married white women in the U.S., about one pair in 400 is bipaternal. The incidence may be substantially higher in small selected groups of dizygotic twin maternities, eg. those of women engaged in prostitution.

The current status of Weinberg's differential rule

A reanalysis of the data presented in a recent large twin study suggests that opposite-sexed (OS) pairs may be not as exhaustively tested as same-sexed (SS) pairs on genetic markers. This is contrary to an assumption I made in estimating that there are about 8 SS dizygotic pairs to every 7 OS pairs (thus impugning Weinberg's differential rule). If this assumption is false also in regard to the samples I discussed, then that estimate is unsound and Weinberg's rule is unscathed by empirical data. However, regardless of such considerations, there are strong theoretical reasons for questioning the status of Weinberg's rule. It is based on two assumptions, namely that p (the probability that a dizygotic twin zygote is male) is equal and independent for all dizygotic twin zygotes. Data are adduced here to suggest that both assumptions are false. The upshot is that, at present, without testing, we cannot know, of any given population, whether the rule holds or not. Otherwise, though Weinberg's rule may be useful (like Hellin's law) as a rule-of-thumb, it cannot be assumed as a basis for serious scientific argument.

Twinning and the r/K reproductive strategy: a critique of Rushton's theory

The theory of r selection, favoring population growth, as opposed to K selection, favoring more efficient utilization of resources, has in recent years been applied by Rushton to contrast human ethnic groups in terms of their r/K reproductive strategies, suggesting the existence of a continuum from r groups, producing many offspring but providing little parental care, to K groups, producing few offspring but providing much parental care. Rushton's theory, which is largely based on ethnic differences in twinning rates, is here critically examined. It is pointed out that twinning rate differences are not necessarily genetic in origin since various environmental factors clearly play a role, and also that twinning, as a mode of reproduction, is not necessarily an r strategy, considering the high prenatal and perinatal selection to which it has been, and still is, associated. Moreover, Rushton misinterprets a number of relevant aspects related to the biology of twinning. The claim that ethnic differences in twinning rates provide evidence for an r/K typology in human populations with respect to reproductive strategies does not appear to be warranted.

How frequent is heteropaternal superfecundation?

A newly discovered case of heteropaternal superfecundation (HS) is reported. Three HS cases were found in a parentage test database of 39,000 records. The frequency of HS among dizygotic twins whose parents were involved in paternity suits is 2.4%. Although the study population appears similar to the general population with respect to twinning data, inferences about the frequency of HS in other populations should be drawn with caution.

Coital frequency and twinning

In a comparative study to enquire whether parents of twins, especially of dizygotic twins, have a higher frequency of sexual intercourse than parents of singleton infants, data on sociodemographic status, coital frequency and other variables were collected using a postal questionnaire. Parents of all twins born alive in Denmark in 1984 or 1985 were included as cases and a random sample of parents of singleton infants born in the same period were controls. No evidence of any difference in coital frequency was found between parents of twins (neither dizygotic twins nor monozygotic) and parents of singleton infants.

Seasonality in twin birth rates, Denmark, 1936-84

A study was made of seasonality in twin birth rate in Denmark between 1977 and 1984. We studied all twin births (N = 45,550) in all deliveries (N = 3,679,932) during that period. Statistical analysis using a simple harmonic sinusoidal model provided no evidence for seasonality. However, sequential polynomial analysis disclosed a significant fit to a fifth order polynomial curve with peaks in twin birth rates in May-June and December, along with troughs in February and September. A falling trend in twinning rate broke off in Denmark around 1970, and from 1970 to 1984 an increasing trend was found. The results are discussed in terms of possible environmental influences on twinning.

Toward a theory of human multiple birthing: sociobiology and r/K reproductive strategies

Using symbols from population biology, a continuum of reproductive strategies can be distinguished ranging from r, the production of large numbers of offspring provided with minimal care, to K, the production of few offspring nurtured intensively. While all humans are at the K end of the continuum, some are proposed to be more so than others. If multiple egg production is part of an r-reproductive strategy, certain facts may be ordered. Compared to mothers of singletons, for example, mothers of DZ twins have a lower age of menarche, a shorter menstrual cycle, a higher number of marriages, a higher rate of coitus, more illegitimate children, a closer spacing of births, a greater fecundity, more wasted pregnancies, a larger family, an earlier menopause, and an earlier mortality. Further, all twins have a shorter gestation period, a lower birth weight, and a greater incidence of infant mortality, with DZ twins having a greater frequency of health disorders, a higher mortality rate, and a lower rate of enrollment in volunteer registries. Multiple birthing also occurs more frequently in families of lower than of higher social status, and in those of African than of European and especially than of Oriental descent.