Photography in treatment of tympanic membrane perforations

Errors in the assessment of tympanic membrane perforations

It is commonly stated that operative closure of large perforations of the tympanic membrane is less successful than closure of small perforations. Few authors mention the exact size of the perforations studied, and fewer still give their method of measuring perforations. We describe a photographic method of assessing the size of perforations relative to the total drumhead, measuring them with a computerized digitizing pad. Thirteen temporal bones were selected at random. Perforations of different sizes, shapes and at different sites were fashioned in the tympanic membranes. These were assessed by clinicians of all grades, who were asked to draw the perforations and give estimates of the perforation size as a percentage of the total drumhead. Visual estimates and drawings were compared with a photographic objective method. Gross errors (some in excess of 100%) were apparent in both estimates and drawings. There was a highly significant statistical difference between the objective method and visual estimates and drawings (P < 0.001). Greater clinical experience was not correlated with better performance in estimating the size of perforations.

Spontaneous healing of traumatic tympanic membrane perforations in man: a century of experience

Widespread controversy exists concerning the treatment of traumatic tympanic membrane perforations. To elucidate the issue, a reference value for the rate of spontaneous tympanic membrane closure in man, to which the healing rates following different techniques of early surgical repair should be compared, was established on the basis of a review of more than 500 texts covering a century's literature on the traumatically perforated tympanic membrane. The spontaneous healing rate appeared to be close to 80 (78.7 per cent) in 760 evaluable cases of traumatic tympanic membrane perforations of all sorts diagnosed within 14 days post injury. A relative, causal-related variation of spontaneous healing could be demonstrated, and a pathogenetic classification of direct traumatic tympanic membrane perforations into ruptures induced by air-pressure changes, heat or corrosives, solids, and water pressures, is of proved clinical value and may have medico-legal validity. There is an obvious need for clinically controlled studies on the spontaneous healing of all kinds of traumatic perforations of the tympanic membrane in humans, and important elements in the design of future studies are advocated.

The mechanism of healing of tympanic membrane perforations. A two-dimensional histological study in guinea pigs

The healing of small perforations, made in 60 tympanic membranes (30 guinea pigs) with either a thermal myringotome or a needle was observed over a 10-day period using an operating microscope. Thirty-six of these were sectioned either parallel with the handle of the malleus, or at right angles to it, and the closing perforations studied by light microscopy. The epidermis closed the perforations first, in the direction of surface migration. This process began within 48 hours and was complete within 9 days. A fibrous reaction occurred, starting at 3 days, and this was seen on the side of the perforation adjacent to the malleus or bony tympanic annulus. There was no response visible in the middle ear mucosa. The conclusion of this study is that the epidermis is the first layer to close a perforation because of its migratory function, and the direction of closure is the direction of migration. Healing of the fibrous layer occurs secondarily, and the site of the response in this layer is related to the vascular distribution in the tympanic membrane.

The function of migratory epidermis in the healing of tympanic membrane perforations in guinea-pig. A photographic study

During observations on healing traumatic perforations in guinea-pig tympanic membranes, a specific appearance was seen on the surface of the epidermis as it closed the perforations. In this experiment, this pattern was identified on 15 tympanic membranes in 10 guinea pigs, and serial photography was used to record the healing process in 6 perforations over 5 days. This study shows that epidermis accumulates at the inferior margin of the perforation (the side from which it migrates) and then closes over the defect. Epidermal migration appears to be a key factor in this healing process.