The epidemiology of eating disorders

What happens to eating disorder outpatients who withdrew from therapy?

OBJECTIVE

Dropouts are frequent among eating disorder (ED) patients, but less is known about their natural history. This paper assesses the outcome of outpatients who dropped out from a therapy programme and its possible causes.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

From 1992 to 1994, we assessed 222 ED subjects. Psychiatrists expert in EDs evaluated these subjects by defining baseline parameters and diagnosis was made according to the 3rd revisioned edition of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders. One hundred and twenty-eight subjects (57%) dropped out during the treatment. In 1997, we contacted them, reassessed the same baseline parameters and asked for a self-judgment about their social and clinical condition during the previous 2-5 years. Patients were classified as "improved" and "not improved" (stationary or worse) according to their social, physical and psychological condition. The relation between baseline condition and outcome was determined statistically.

RESULTS

Seventy-one percent of subjects were "improved" and no deaths were recorded. A significant correlation was found between "duration of illness" and no treatment following a dropout.

DISCUSSION

The high percentage of improvement among dropouts was unexpected. Shorter duration of illness and lack of specific therapy in the improved patients suggest the existence of a subset of ED patients with acute onset and a spontaneous tendency to improve. This point obviously requires further investigation.

[Construction and validation of a new screnning questionnaires for eating disorders: the inventory for the screening of eating disorders/(ISED)]

OBJECTIVE

The study aims to construct and validate a new screening questionnaire for the identification of cases at risk for eating disorders.

SETTING AND SAMPLE

We assessed 218 female adolescent students recruited in a vocational school in Mestre (VE) and 88 patients consecutively referred to the Eating Disorders Unit of the University of Padova. PROCEDURE AND MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: All subjects completed the new questionnaire, the Inventory for the Screening of Eating Disorders (ISED), and the Eating Attitudes Test (EAT). Sixty-two percent of female students and all the patients underwent a structured diagnostic interview (SCID for DSM-IV) for the diagnosis of eating disorders. The reliability, validity and screening ability of the questionnaire have been assessed.

RESULTS

The reliability of the ISED, measured by Cronbach's alpha, is good (alpha = 0.87), as is the convergent validity (correlations with EAT). In order to improve the screening ability, the questionnaire has been further divided in two subscales: one for the identification of cases at risk for anorexia nervosa (ISED-AN) and the other for cases at risk for bulimia nervosa (ISED-BN). The screening ability of the two subscales is greater than that of EAT, although the difference is not statistically significant. The ISED cutoff points have greater positive predictive values than those of EAT in the screening of both anorexia nervosa and bulimia nervosa.

CONCLUSIONS

The ISED appears to be a valid and reliable questionnaire among female adolescents. Its use might improve the identification of cases at risk for eating disorders and in particular those at risk for anorexia nervosa. Other studies are needed to confirm the validity and performance of the questionnaire among samples of different ages and socio-economic status.