Maximizing mismatch discrimination by surface-tethered locked nucleic acid probes via ionic tuning

Melting temperature measurement and mesoscopic evaluation of single, double and triple DNA mismatches

Unlike the canonical base pairs AT and GC, the molecular properties of mismatches such as hydrogen bonding and stacking interactions are strongly dependent on the identity of the neighbouring base pairs. As a result, due to the sheer number of possible combinations of mismatches and flanking base pairs, only a fraction of these have been studied in varying experiments or theoretical models. Here, we report on the melting temperature measurement and mesoscopic analysis of contiguous DNA mismatches in nearest-neighbours and next-nearest neighbour contexts. A total of 4032 different mismatch combinations, including single, double and triple mismatches were covered. These were compared with 64 sequences containing all combinations of canonical base pairs in the same location under the same conditions. For a substantial number of single mismatch configurations, 15%, the measured melting temperatures were higher than the least stable AT base pair. The mesoscopic calculation, using the Peyrard-Bishop model, was performed on the set of 4096 sequences, and resulted in estimates of on-site and nearest-neighbour interactions that can be correlated to hydrogen bonding and base stacking. Our results confirm many of the known properties of mismatches, including the peculiar sheared stacking of tandem GA mismatches. More intriguingly, it also reveals that a number of mismatches present strong hydrogen bonding when flanked on both sites by other mismatches. To highlight the applicability of our results, we discuss a number of practical situations such as enzyme binding affinities, thymine DNA glycosylase repair activity, and trinucleotide repeat expansions.

Free-Energy-Based Gene Mutation Detection Using LNA Probes

We have developed a label-free approach for direct detection of gene mutations using free-energy values that are derived from single-molecule force spectroscopy (SMFS)-based nucleic acid unbinding experiments. From the duplex unbinding force values acquired by SMFS, the force-loading-rate-independent Gibbs free-energy values were derived using Jarzinsky's equality treatment. Because it provides molecule-by-molecule information, this approach is a major shift compared to the earlier reports on label-free detection of DNA sequences, which are mostly based on ensemble level data. We tested our approach in the disease model framework of multiple drug-resistant tuberculosis using the nuclease-resistant and conformationally rigid locked nucleic acid probes that are a robust and efficient alternative to the DNA probes. All of the major mutations in Mycobacterium tuberculosis (MTB), as relevant to MTB's resistance to the first-line anti-TB drugs rifampicin and isoniazid, could be identified, and the wild type could be discriminated from the most prevalent mutation and the most prevalent mutation from the less occurring ones. Our approach could also identify DNA sequences (45 mer), having overhang stretches at different positions with respect to the complementary stretch. Probably for the first time, the findings show that free-energy-based detection of gene mutations is possible at molecular resolution.

Nanoscale Nucleic Acid Recognition at the Solid-Liquid Interface Using Xeno Nucleic Acid Probes

Challenges in reliable nucleic acid detection are manifold. The major ones are related to false positive or negative signals due to a lack of target specificity in detection and to low sensitivity, especially when a plethora of background sequences are present that can mask the specific recognition signal. Utilizing designed synthetic nucleic acids that are commonly called xeno nucleic acids could offer potential routes to meeting such challenges. In this article, we present the general framework of nucleic acid detection, especially for nanoscale applications, and discuss how and why the xeno nucleic acids could be truly an alternative to the DNA probes. Two specific cases, locked nucleic acid (LNA) and peptide nucleic acid (PNA), which are nuclease-resistant and can form thermally stable duplexes with DNA, are addressed. It is shown that the relative ease of the conformationally rigid LNA probe to be oriented upright on the substrate surface and of the nonionic PNA probe to result into high probe density assists in their use in nanoscale nucleic acid recognition. It is anticipated that success with these probes may lead to important developments such as PCR-independent approaches where the major aim is to detect a small number of target sequences present in the analyte medium.

Direct Quantification of Trace Amounts of a Chronic Myeloid Leukemia Biomarker Using Locked Nucleic Acid Capture Probes

Molecular monitoring is indispensable for the clinical management of chronic myeloid leukemia (CML) patients. Real-time quantitative polymerase chain reaction (RT-qPCR) is the gold standard for the quantitative assessment of BCR-ABL transcript levels, which are critical in clinical decision-making. However, the frequent recurrence of the disease after drug discontinuation for 60% of patients has necessitated more sensitive and specific techniques to detect residual BCR-ABL transcripts. Here, we describe a quantification method for the detection of BCR-ABL targets at very low concentrations (<10 copies/sample) in the presence of a million copies of normal BCR and ABL genes. In this method, a fully modified locked nucleic acid (LNA) and a LNA/DNA chimera were used as capture probes, and the quantitative imaging mode of atomic force microscopy (AFM) was employed. Targets with one of the major breakpoints (found in more than 95% of CML patients), b3a2 and b2a2, were quantified. The BCR-ABL target captured on a miniaturized LNA-probe spot was scanned at nanometric resolution, and the samples containing one to ten copies of the BCR-ABL genes were examined. It was observed that the highest sensitivity, i.e., the detection of a single copy of the target gene, could be achieved through multiple runs, and the observed cluster number was well correlative (adjusted R² = 0.999) to the target copy number in the sample solution. This observation clearly demonstrates that the LNA-based platform is effective in quantifying BCR-ABL targets with extremely low copy numbers, highlighting the potential applicability of AFM for use in the direct quantification of such targets without amplification or labeling.

Ionic strength-controlled hybridization and stability of hybrids of KRAS DNA single-nucleotides: A surface plasmon resonance study

The discrimination of a fully matched, unlabeled KRAS wild-type (WT) (C-G) target sample with respect to three of the most frequent KRAS codon mutations (G12 S (C-A), G12 R (C-C), G12C (C-T)) was investigated using an optimized detection strategy involving surface plasmon resonance (SPR), based on optimized probe-surface density and ionic strength control. The changes observed in the SPR signal were always larger for WT compared with the single-mismatch target DNA oligonucleotides, and were aligned with the theoretical energy differences between the base pair C-G, C-T, C-A, C-C. Hybridization rates of ∼10⁶M^-1s^-1 were detected without the introduction of high temperature and labels, usually needed in conventional hybridization methods. One hundred percent mutation discrimination of the matched KRAS wild-type (C-G) sequence with respect to three mismatched G12C (C-T), G12 S (C-A), G12 R (C-C) target sequences was achieved.

SPR Detection and Discrimination of the Oligonucleotides Related to the Normal and the Hybrid bcr-abl Genes by Two Stringency Control Strategies

In this study, we applied two stringency control strategies for surface plasmon resonance (SPR) detection of DNA hybridization and discrimination of completely and partially complementary 24-mer sequences. These sequences are specific to the human normal bcr and the hybrid bcr-abl genes, protein products of which are responsible for some leukemia. SPR sensors based on resonance phenomena in nanoscale gold films are well suited for label-free, real-time investigations of the macromolecule interactions. Thermodynamic parameters obtained using the web server DINAMelt allowed supposing the possibility for realization (a) stringency control based on the ionic strength of the hybridization buffer and (b) stringency control based on the temperature elevation. The first one resulted in that the discrimination index of completely complementary and partially complementary oligonucleotides depending on the target concentration varied from 1.3 to 1.8 in 2 × SSC and from 2.0 to 2.9 in 0.5 × SSC. For implementation of the second stringency control strategy, SPR spectrometer measuring flow cell with built-in high-precision temperature control and regulation as well as corresponding software was created. It is shown that the duplexes formed by the immobilized probes mod-Ph and completely complementary oligonucleotides P1 remained without significant changes until ~50 °C, while the duplexes formed with partially complementary oligonucleotide Bcrex14 almost entirely disrupted at 40 °C. Thus, the absolutely effective thermodiscrimination of this pair of oligonucleotides was achieved in this temperature range (40-50 °C).

Molecularly resolved label-free sensing of single nucleobase mismatches by interfacial LNA probes

So far, there has been no report on molecularly resolved discrimination of single nucleobase mismatches using surface-confined single stranded locked nucleic acid (ssLNA) probes. Herein, it is exemplified using a label-independent force-sensing approach that an optimal coverage of 12-mer ssLNA sensor probes formed onto gold(111) surface allows recognition of ssDNA targets with twice stronger force sensitivity than 12-mer ssDNA sensor probes. The force distributions are reproducible and the molecule-by-molecule force measurements are largely in agreement with ensemble on-surface melting temperature data. Importantly, the molecularly resolved detection is responsive to the presence of single nucleobase mismatches in target sequences. Since the labelling steps can be eliminated from protocol, and each force-based detection event occurs within milliseconds' time scale, the force-sensing assay is potentially capable of rapid detection. The LNA probe performance is indicative of versatility in terms of substrate choice - be it gold (for basic research and array-based applications) or silicon (for ‘lab-on-a-chip’ type devices). The nucleic acid microarray technologies could therefore be generally benefited by adopting the LNA films, in place of DNA. Since LNA is nuclease-resistant, unlike DNA, and the LNA-based assay is sensitive to single nucleobase mismatches, the possibilities for label-free in vitro rapid diagnostics based on the LNA probes may be explored.

Discriminating unalike single nucleobase mismatches using a molecularly resolved, label-free, interfacial LNA-based assay

Molecularly resolved, label-free discrimination of different types of single nucleobase mismatches by LNA probes.

Regulating the on-surface LNA probe density for the highest target recognition efficiency

The recent emergence of on-surface LNA-based assays as potentially better alternatives over DNA-based approaches, due to enhanced sensitivity and target specificity, raises the need for the precise identification of the factors that control the performance of these assays. In this work, we investigated whether the probe density of fully modified ssLNA probes on the gold(111) surface could influence the target recognition capacity of the LNA sensing layer and illustrated simple means to control it, primarily by adjusting the salt concentration, nature of the cation, and pH of the immobilization buffer. It was observed that monovalent Na(+) could more effectively control the sensor probe density compared to bivalent Mg(2+), leading to better target recognition. Interestingly, unlike in the case of ssDNA sensor probes, the target recognition efficiency of the LNA layer at the optimum probe density was found to be almost spacer-independent, probably due to the rigidity of the LNA backbone. The optimized LNA sensor layer could discriminate single base mismatches, detect a minimum target DNA concentration of 5 nM, and sense a significant level of hybridization within a time scale of a few minutes. To our knowledge, for the first time, we identify the factors that control the on-surface LNA probe density for maximizing the performance of the LNA sensing layer.

Enhancing on-surface mismatch discrimination capability of PNA probes by AuNP modification of gold(111) surface

Unambiguous identification of single base mismatches in nucleic acid sequences is of great importance in nucleic acid detection assays. However, ambiguities are often encountered with, and therefore, a strategy for attaining substantially large enhancement of mismatch discrimination has been worked upon in this study. Short single-stranded peptide nucleic acid (PNA) and deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) sensor probes that are immobilized onto gold nanoparticle (AuNP) modified Au(111) surface have been applied for target DNA detection. It will be shown that while both PNA and the analogous DNA probes exhibit generally better target detection abilities on the AuNP-modified Au(111) surface (elicited from fluorescence-based measurement of on-surface Tm values), compared to the bare Au(111) surface, PNA supersedes DNA, for all sizes of AuNPs (10, 50, and 90 nm) applied, with the difference being quite drastic in the case of the smallest 10 nm AuNP. It is found that while the AuNP curvature plays a pivotal role in target detection abilities of the PNA probes, the changes in the surface roughness caused by AuNP treatment do not exert any significant influence. This study also presents a means for preparing PNA-AuNP hybrids without altering PNA functionality and without AuNP aggregation by working with the surface-affixed AuNPs.