Combined mass and structural kinetic analysis of multistate antimicrobial peptide-membrane interactions

Quartz Crystal Microbalance with Dissipation Monitoring (QCM-D): Preparing Functionalized Lipid Layers for the Study of Complex Protein-Ligand Interactions

Quartz crystal microbalance with dissipation monitoring (QCM-D) is one of the most widely used techniques for the deposition of lipid layers and provides a useful tool for protein-ligand analysis. By using functionalized lipids, for example, with nitrilotriacetic acid (NTA) or biotin, one can couple a molecule to the surface to investigate ligand interactions. Using lipid layers in this way allows for the analysis of complex binding events such as conformational changes, fibrillation, and hierarchical clustering on the surface, which is difficult to interpret with conventional surface sensor techniques. Deposition of lipids and subsequent molecular interactions are easily monitored using both the frequency and the dissipation, which have distinct features in bilayer formation and make QCM-D the ideal technique to use. Here we describe the formation of biotinylated lipid bilayers using two different types of lipids and the subsequent addition of avidin, which can then be used as a basis for linking biotinylated molecules to the surface. These protocols can be adapted to use other lipid moieties and linking chemistries.

Amyloid Formation by Short Peptides in the Presence of Dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine Membranes

The aggregation of two short peptides, [RF] and [RF]₄ (where R = arginine and F = phenylalanine), at dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine (DPPC) model membranes was investigated at the air-water interface using the Langmuir technique and vesicles in aqueous solutions. The molar ratio of the peptide and lipid components was varied to provide insights into the peptide-membrane interactions, which might be related to their cytotoxicity. Both peptides exhibited affinity to the DPPC membrane interface and rapidly adopted β-sheet-rich structures upon adsorption onto the surface of the zwitterionic membrane. Results from adsorption isotherm and small-angle X-ray scattering experiments showed changes in the structural and thermodynamic parameters of the membrane with increasing peptide concentration. Using atomic force microscopy, we showed the appearance of pores through the bilayer membranes and peptide aggregation at different interfaces, suggesting that the hydrophobic residues might have an effect on both pore size and layer structure, facilitating the membrane disruption and leading to different cytotoxicity effects.

Enhanced avidin binding to lipid bilayers using PDP-PE lipids with PEG-biotin linkers

Two of the most important aspects of lipid bilayers that have increased their popularity in the field of nanotechnology and biosensors are their fluid nature, which is highly beneficial in ensuring the spatial organization of attached molecules, and the relative ease in which they can be manipulated to change the surface chemistry. Here we have used two different types of functionalized lipids to study the interaction of avidin, which is a common approach to attach further ligands for study. We have tested the commonly used Biotinyl-Cap-PE lipids at different molar percentages and reveal that avidin is not evenly distributed, but forms what looks like clusters even at low percentage occupancy which hampers the level of avidin that can be associated with the surface. We have then successfully employed the novel strategy of using PDP-PE lipids which contain a reducible disulphide to which we added maleamide-PEG-biotin spacers of different lengths. There is a more even distribution of avidin on these layers and thereby increasing the amount and efficiency of avidin association. The reduced levels of avidin that was being associated with the Biotinyl-Cap-PE layers as compared to the PDP-PE lipids could be analysed with QCM-D and interferometry approaches, but it was only with SEEC microscopy that the reason for the reduced occupancy was resolved.

The Effect of Charge on Melittin-Induced Changes in Membrane Structure and Morphology

The binding of melittin to a range of phospholipid bilayers was studied using dual polarisation interferometry and atomic force microscopy. The phospholipid model membranes included zwitterionic dimyristylphosphatidylcholine (DMPC), together with mixtures of DMPC/dimyristylphosphatidylglycerol (DMPG) and DMPC/DMPG/cholesterol. Melittin caused significant disruption on all bilayers, but differences in morphological changes during binding were different on each membrane. Overall, the results demonstrate that the process of membrane disruption follows distinct structural changes for different lipid mixtures irrespective of the strength of binding to the membrane surface.

Kinetics of interaction between antimicrobial peptide nisin and Langmuir monolayers of DPPC and DPPG molecules

We have studied the kinetics of the interaction between antimicrobial peptide nisin and Langmuir monolayers of phospholipids DPPC and DPPG at the air-water interface using the surface manometry technique. The charge on the nisin and the lipid molecules is controlled by varying the pH of the subphase, and the interactions between them are studied by measuring the surface pressure of the lipid monolayer as a function of time after injecting the nisin in the subphase. A model based on the diffusion of particles under the influence of a constant force is developed to obtain an analytical expression for surface pressure as a function of time. The expression was found to fit well with the experimental data. The average hydrodynamic radius and the translational diffusion constant of the nisin molecules are calculated from the fit parameters for the different subphase pH solutions.

Biophysical Characterization of Cationic Antibacterial Oligothioetheramides

Biophysical analysis into the mechanism of action of membrane-disrupting antibiotics such as antimicrobial peptides (AMPs) and AMP mimetics is necessary to improve our understanding of this promising but relatively untapped class of antibiotics. We evaluate the impact of cationic nature, specifically the presence of guanidine versus amine functional groups using sequence-defined oligothioetheramides (oligoTEAs). Relative to amines, guanidine groups demonstrated improved antibacterial activity against methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA). To understand the mechanism of action, we evaluated membrane interactions by performing a propidium iodide assay and fluorescence microscopy of supported MRSA mimetic bilayers treated with oligoTEAs. Both studies demonstrated membrane disruption, while fluorescence microscopy showed the formation of lipid aggregates. We further analyzed the mechanism using surface plasmon resonance with a recently developed two-state binding model with loss. Our biophysical analysis points to the importance of lipid aggregation for antibacterial activity and suggests that guanidine groups improve antibacterial activity by increasing the extent of lipid aggregation. Altogether, these results verify and rationalize the importance of guanidines for enhanced antibacterial activity of oligoTEAs, and present biophysical phenomena for the design and analysis of additional membrane-active antibiotics.

Antibacterial isoamphipathic oligomers highlight the importance of multimeric lipid aggregation for antibacterial potency

Cationic charge and hydrophobicity have long been understood to drive the potency and selectivity of antimicrobial peptides (AMPs). However, these properties alone struggle to guide broad success in vivo, where AMPs must differentiate bacterial and mammalian cells, while avoiding complex barriers. New parameters describing the biophysical processes of membrane disruption could provide new opportunities for antimicrobial optimization. In this work, we utilize oligothioetheramides (oligoTEAs) to explore the membrane-targeting mechanism of oligomers, which have the same cationic charge and hydrophobicity, yet show a unique ~ 10-fold difference in antibacterial potency. Solution-phase characterization reveals little difference in structure and dynamics. However, fluorescence microscopy of oligomer-treated Staphylococcus aureus mimetic membranes shows multimeric lipid aggregation that correlates with biological activity and helps establish a framework for the kinetic mechanism of action. Surface plasmon resonance supports the kinetic framework and supports lipid aggregation as a driver of antimicrobial function.

Joseph Brown et al. use oligothioetheramides (oligo TEAs) to show that multimeric lipid aggregation in Staphylococcus aureus mimetic membranes correlates with the biological activity of oligoTEAs. These results may explain why antimicrobial peptides with identical cationic charge and hydrophobicity show different biological activity.

Exploring Molecular-Biomembrane Interactions with Surface Plasmon Resonance and Dual Polarization Interferometry Technology: Expanding the Spotlight onto Biomembrane Structure

The molecular analysis of biomolecular-membrane interactions is central to understanding most cellular systems but has emerged as a complex technical challenge given the complexities of membrane structure and composition across all living cells. We present a review of the application of surface plasmon resonance and dual polarization interferometry-based biosensors to the study of biomembrane-based systems using both planar mono- or bilayers or liposomes. We first describe the optical principals and instrumentation of surface plasmon resonance, including both linear and extraordinary transmission modes and dual polarization interferometry. We then describe the wide range of model membrane systems that have been developed for deposition on the chips surfaces that include planar, polymer cushioned, tethered bilayers, and liposomes. This is followed by a description of the different chemical immobilization or physisorption techniques. The application of this broad range of engineered membrane surfaces to biomolecular-membrane interactions is then overviewed and how the information obtained using these techniques enhance our molecular understanding of membrane-mediated peptide and protein function. We first discuss experiments where SPR alone has been used to characterize membrane binding and describe how these studies yielded novel insight into the molecular events associated with membrane interactions and how they provided a significant impetus to more recent studies that focus on coincident membrane structure changes during binding of peptides and proteins. We then discuss the emerging limitations of not monitoring the effects on membrane structure and how SPR data can be combined with DPI to provide significant new information on how a membrane responds to the binding of peptides and proteins.

Surface mediated cooperative interactions of drugs enhance mechanical forces for antibiotic action

The alarming increase of pathogenic bacteria that are resistant to multiple antibiotics is now recognized as a major health issue fuelling demand for new drugs. Bacterial resistance is often caused by molecular changes at the bacterial surface, which alter the nature of specific drug-target interactions. Here, we identify a novel mechanism by which drug-target interactions in resistant bacteria can be enhanced. We examined the surface forces generated by four antibiotics; vancomycin, ristomycin, chloroeremomycin and oritavancin against drug-susceptible and drug-resistant targets on a cantilever and demonstrated significant differences in mechanical response when drug-resistant targets are challenged with different antibiotics although no significant differences were observed when using susceptible targets. Remarkably, the binding affinity for oritavancin against drug-resistant targets (70 nM) was found to be 11,000 times stronger than for vancomycin (800 μM), a powerful antibiotic used as the last resort treatment for streptococcal and staphylococcal bacteria including methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA). Using an exactly solvable model, which takes into account the solvent and membrane effects, we demonstrate that drug-target interactions are strengthened by pronounced polyvalent interactions catalyzed by the surface itself. These findings further enhance our understanding of antibiotic mode of action and will enable development of more effective therapies.

Two-Step Membrane Binding of NDPK-B Induces Membrane Fluidity Decrease and Changes in Lipid Lateral Organization and Protein Cluster Formation

Nucleoside diphosphate kinases (NDPKs) are crucial elements in a wide array of cellular physiological or pathophysiological processes such as apoptosis, proliferation, or metastasis formation. Among the NDPK isoenzymes, NDPK-B, a cytoplasmic protein, was reported to be associated with several biological membranes such as plasma or endoplasmic reticulum membranes. Using several membrane models (liposomes, lipid monolayers, and supported lipid bilayers) associated with biophysical approaches, we show that lipid membrane binding occurs in a two-step process: first, initiation by a strong electrostatic adsorption process and followed by shallow penetration of the protein within the membrane. The NDPK-B binding leads to a decrease in membrane fluidity and formation of protein patches. The ability of NDPK-B to form microdomains at the membrane level may be related to protein-protein interactions triggered by its association with anionic phospholipids. Such accumulation of NDPK-B would amplify its effects in functional platform formation and protein recruitment at the membrane.

The impact of cell-penetrating peptides on membrane bilayer structure during binding and insertion

We have studied the effect of penetratin and a truncated analogue on the bilayer structure using dual polarisation interferometry, to simultaneously measure changes in mass per unit area and birefringence (an optical parameter representing bilayer order) with high sensitivity during the binding and dissociation from the membrane. Specifically, we studied penetratin (RQIKIWFQNRRMKWKK), along with a shortened and biotinylated version known as R8K-biotin (RRMKWKKK(Biotin)-NH2). Overall both peptides bound only weakly to the neutral DMPC and POPC bilayers, while much higher binding was observed for the anionic DMPC/DMPG and POPC/POPG. The binding of penetratin to gel-phase DMPC/DMPG was adequately represented by a two-state model, whereas on the fluid-phase POPC/POPG it exhibited a distinctly different binding pattern, best represented by a three-state kinetic model. However, R8K-biotin did not bind well to DMPC/DMPG and showed a more transitory and superficial binding to POPC/POPG. Comparing the modelling results for both peptides binding to POPC/POPG suggests an important role for a securely bound intermediate prior to penetratin insertion and translocation. Overall these results further elucidate the mechanism of penetratin, and provide another example of the significance of the ability of DPI to measure structural changes and the use of kinetic analysis to investigate the stages of peptide-membrane interactions.

Helix 8 of the angiotensin- II type 1A receptor interacts with phosphatidylinositol phosphates and modulates membrane insertion

The carboxyl-terminus of the type 1 angiotensin II receptor (AT_1A) regulates receptor activation/deactivation and the amphipathic Helix 8 within the carboxyl-terminus is a high affinity interaction motif for plasma membrane lipids. We have used dual polarisation interferometry (DPI) to examine the role of phosphatidylinositdes in the specific recognition of Helix 8 in the AT_1A receptor. A synthetic peptide corresponding to Leu³⁰⁵ to Lys³²⁵ (Helix 8 AT_1A) discriminated between PIPs and different charges on lipid membranes. Peptide binding to PtdIns(4)P-containing bilayers caused a dramatic change in the birefringence (a measure of membrane order) of the bilayer. Kinetic modelling showed that PtdIns(4)P is held above the bilayer until the mass of bound peptide reaches a threshold, after which the peptides insert further into the bilayer. This suggests that Helix 8 can respond to the presence of PI(4)P by withdrawing from the bilayer, resulting in a functional conformational change in the receptor.

New insights into the molecular mechanisms of biomembrane structural changes and interactions by optical biosensor technology

Biomolecular-membrane interactions play a critical role in the regulation of many important biological processes such as protein trafficking, cellular signalling and ion channel formation. Peptide/protein-membrane interactions can also destabilise and damage the membrane which can lead to cell death. Characterisation of the molecular details of these binding-mediated membrane destabilisation processes is therefore central to understanding cellular events such as antimicrobial action, membrane-mediated amyloid aggregation, and apoptotic protein induced mitochondrial membrane permeabilisation. Optical biosensors have provided a unique approach to characterising membrane interactions allowing quantitation of binding events and new insight into the kinetic mechanism of these interactions. One of the most commonly used optical biosensor technologies is surface plasmon resonance (SPR) and there have been an increasing number of studies reporting the use of this technique for investigating biophysical analysis of membrane-mediated events. More recently, a number of new optical biosensors based on waveguide techniques have been developed, allowing membrane structure changes to be measured simultaneously with mass binding measurements. These techniques include dual polarisation interferometry (DPI), plasmon waveguide resonance spectroscopy (PWR) and optical waveguide light mode spectroscopy (OWLS). These techniques have expanded the application of optical biosensors to allow the analysis of membrane structure changes during peptide and protein binding. This review provides a theoretical and practical overview of the application of biosensor technology with a specific focus on DPI, PWR and OWLS to study biomembrane-mediated events and the mechanism of biomembrane disruption. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Lipid-protein interactions.

Plasmonic imaging of protein interactions with single bacterial cells

Quantifying the interactions of bacteria with external ligands is fundamental to the understanding of pathogenesis, antibiotic resistance, immune evasion, and mechanism of antimicrobial action. Due to inherent cell-to-cell heterogeneity in a microbial population, each bacterium interacts differently with its environment. This large variability is washed out in bulk assays, and there is a need of techniques that can quantify interactions of bacteria with ligands at the single bacterium level. In this work, we present a label-free and real-time plasmonic imaging technique to measure the binding kinetics of ligand interactions with single bacteria, and perform statistical analysis of the heterogeneity. Using the technique, we have studied interactions of antibodies with single Escherichia coli O157:H7 cells and demonstrated a capability of determining the binding kinetic constants of single live bacteria with ligands, and quantify heterogeneity in a microbial population.

Real-time measurement of membrane conformational states induced by antimicrobial peptides: balance between recovery and lysis

The disruption of membranes by antimicrobial peptides is a multi-state process involving significant structural changes in the phospholipid bilayer. However, direct measurement of these membrane structural changes is lacking. We used a combination of dual polarisation interferometry (DPI), surface plasmon resonance spectroscopy (SPR) and atomic force microscopy (AFM) to measure the real-time changes in membrane structure through the measurement of birefringence during the binding of magainin 2 (Mag2) and a highly potent analogue in which Ser⁸, Gly¹³ and Gly¹⁸ has been replaced with alanine (Mag-A). We show that the membrane bilayer undergoes a series of structural changes upon peptide binding before a critical threshold concentration is reached which triggers a significant membrane disturbance. We also propose a detailed model for antimicrobial peptide action as a function of the degree of bilayer disruption to provide an unprecedented in-depth understanding of the membrane lysis in terms of the interconversion of different membrane conformational states in which there is a balance between recovery and lysis.

Comparison of reversible membrane destabilisation induced by antimicrobial peptides derived from Australian frogs

The membrane destabilising properties of the antimicrobial peptides (AMP) aurein 1.2, citropin 1.1, maculatin 1.1 and caerin 1.1, have been studied by dual polarisation interferometry (DPI). The overall process of peptide induced membrane destabilisation was examined by the changes in bilayer order as a function of membrane-bound peptide mass per unit area and revealed three different modes of action. Aurein 1.2 was the only peptide that significantly destabilised the neutral membrane (DMPC), while all four peptides induced destabilisation of the negatively charged membrane (DMPC/DMPG). On DMPC, citropin 1.1, maculatin 1.1 and caerin 1.1 bound irreversibly at low concentrations but caused a reversible drop in the bilayer order. In contrast to DMPC/DMPG, these three peptides caused a mass drop at the higher concentrations, which may correspond to insertion and bilayer expansion. The critical level of bound peptide necessary to induce membrane destabilisation (peptide:lipid ratio) was determined and correlated with peptide structure. As the most lytic peptide, aurein 1.2 adsorbed strongly prior to dissolution of the bilayer. In contrast, the binding of citropin 1.1, maculatin 1.1 and caerin 1.1 needed to reach a critical level prior to insertion into the membrane and incremental expansion and disruption. Our results demonstrate that sequential events can be monitored in real-time under fluidic conditions to elucidate the complex molecular mechanism of AMP action. In particular, the analysis of birefringence in real time allows the description of a detailed mechanistic model of the impact of peptides on the membrane bilayer order. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Interfacially Active Peptides and Proteins. Guest Editors: William C. Wimley and Kalina Hristova.