Extended Gas-Phase Trapping Followed by Surface-Induced Dissociation of Noncovalent Protein Complexes

Symmetry of 4-Oxalocrotonate Tautomerase Trimers Influences Unfolding and Fragmentation in the Gas Phase

The recent discovery of asymmetric arrangements of trimers in the tautomerase superfamily (TSF) adds structural diversity to this already mechanistically diverse superfamily. Classification of asymmetric trimers has previously been determined using X-ray crystallography. Here, native mass spectrometry (MS) and ultraviolet photodissociation (UVPD) are employed as an integrated strategy for more rapid and sensitive differentiation of symmetric and asymmetric trimers. Specifically, the unfolding of symmetric and asymmetric trimers initiated by collisional heating was probed using UVPD, which revealed unique gas-phase unfolding pathways. Variations in UVPD patterns from native-like, compact trimeric structures to unfolded, extended conformations indicate a rearrangement of higher-order structure in the asymmetric trimers that are believed to be stabilized by salt-bridge triads, which are absent from the symmetric trimers. Consequently, the symmetric trimers were found to be less stable in the gas phase, resulting in enhanced UVPD fragmentation overall and a notable difference in higher-order re-structuring based on the extent of hydrogen migration of protein fragments. The increased stability of the asymmetric trimers may justify their evolution and concomitant diversification of the TSF. Facilitating the classification of TSF members as symmetric or asymmetric trimers assists in delineating the evolutionary history of the TSF.

Surface-induced Dissociation Mass Spectrometry as a Structural Biology Tool

Native mass spectrometry (nMS) is evolving into a workhorse for structural biology. The plethora of online and offline preparation, separation, and purification methods as well as numerous ionization techniques combined with powerful new hybrid ion mobility and mass spectrometry systems has illustrated the great potential of nMS for structural biology. Fundamental to the progression of nMS has been the development of novel activation methods for dissociating proteins and protein complexes to deduce primary, secondary, tertiary, and quaternary structure through the combined use of multiple MS/MS technologies. This review highlights the key features and advantages of surface collisions (surface-induced dissociation, SID) for probing the connectivity of subunits within protein and nucleoprotein complexes and, in particular, for solving protein structure in conjunction with complementary techniques such as cryo-EM and computational modeling. Several case studies highlight the significant role SID, and more generally nMS, will play in structural elucidation of biological assemblies in the future as the technology becomes more widely adopted. Cases are presented where SID agrees with solved crystal or cryoEM structures or provides connectivity maps that are otherwise inaccessible by "gold standard" structural biology techniques.

Surface-Induced Dissociation of Anionic vs Cationic Native-Like Protein Complexes

Characterizing protein-protein interactions, stoichiometries, and subunit connectivity is key to understanding how subunits assemble into biologically relevant, multisubunit protein complexes. Native mass spectrometry (nMS) has emerged as a powerful tool to study protein complexes due to its low sample consumption and tolerance for heterogeneity. In nMS, positive mode ionization is routinely used and charge reduction, through the addition of solution additives, is often used, as the resulting lower charge states are often considered more native-like. When fragmented by surface-induced dissociation (SID), charge reduced complexes often give increased structural information over their "normal-charged" counterparts. A disadvantage of solution phase charge reduction is that increased adduction, and hence peak broadening, is often observed. Previous studies have shown that protein complexes ionized using negative mode generally form lower charge states relative to positive mode. Here we demonstrate that the lower charged protein complex anions activated by surface collisions fragment in a manner consistent with their solved structures, hence providing substructural information. Negative mode ionization in ammonium acetate offers the advantage of charge reduction without the peak broadening associated with solution phase charge reduction additives and provides direct structural information when coupled with SID. SID of 20S human proteasome (a 28-mer comprised of four stacked heptamer rings in an αββα formation), for example, provides information on both substructure (e.g., splitting into a 7α ring and the corresponding ββα 21-mer, and into α dimers and trimers to provide connectivity around the 7 α ring) and proteoform information on monomers.

Prediction of Protein Complex Structure Using Surface-Induced Dissociation and Cryo-Electron Microscopy

A variety of techniques involving the use of mass spectrometry (MS) have been developed to obtain structural information on proteins and protein complexes. One example of these techniques, surface-induced dissociation (SID), has been used to study the oligomeric state and connectivity of protein complexes. Recently, we demonstrated that appearance energies (AE) could be extracted from SID experiments and that they correlate with structural features of specific protein-protein interfaces. While SID AE provides some structural information, the AE data alone are not sufficient to determine the structures of the complexes. For this reason, we sought to supplement the data with computational modeling, through protein-protein docking. In a previous study, we demonstrated that the scoring of structures generated from protein-protein docking could be improved with the inclusion of SID data; however, this work relied on knowledge of the correct tertiary structure and only built full complexes for a few cases. Here, we performed docking using input structures that require less prior knowledge, using homology models, unbound crystal structures, and bound+perturbed crystal structures. Using flexible ensemble docking (to build primarily subcomplexes from an ensemble of backbone structures), the RMSD₁₀₀ of all (15/15) predicted structures using the combined Rosetta, cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM), and SID score was less than 4 Å, compared to only 7/15 without SID and cryo-EM. Symmetric docking (which used symmetry to build full complexes) resulted in predicted structures with RMSD₁₀₀ less than 4 Å for 14/15 cases with experimental data, compared to only 5/15 without SID and cryo-EM. Finally, we also developed a confidence metric for which all (26/26) proteins flagged as high confidence were accurately predicted.

Surface-Induced Dissociation of Protein Complexes Selected by Trapped Ion Mobility Spectrometry

Native mass spectrometry (nMS), particularly in conjunction with gas-phase ion mobility spectrometry measurements, has proven useful as a structural biology tool for evaluating the stoichiometry, conformation, and topology of protein complexes. Here, we demonstrate the combination of trapped ion mobility spectrometry (TIMS) and surface-induced dissociation (SID) on a Bruker SolariX XR 15 T FT-ICR mass spectrometer for the structural analysis of protein complexes. We successfully performed SID on mobility-selected protein complexes, including the streptavidin tetramer and cholera toxin B with bound ligands. Additionally, TIMS-SID was employed on a mixture of the peptides desArg1 and desArg9 bradykinin to mobility-separate and identify the individual peptides. Importantly, results show that native-like conformations can be maintained throughout the TIMS analysis. The TIMS-SID spectra are analogous to SID spectra acquired using quadrupole mass selection, indicating little measurable, if any, structural rearrangement during mobility selection. Mobility parking was used on the ion or mobility of interest and 50-200 SID mass spectra were averaged. High-quality TIMS-SID spectra were acquired over a period of 2-10 min, comparable to or slightly longer than SID coupled with ion mobility on various instrument platforms in our laboratory. The ultrahigh resolving power of the 15 T FT-ICR allowed for the identification and relative quantification of overlapping SID fragments with the same nominal m/z based on isotope patterns, and it shows promise as a platform to probe small mass differences, such as protein/ligand binding or post-translational modifications. These results represent the potential of TIMS-SID-MS for the analysis of both protein complexes and peptides.

Hybrid methods for combined experimental and computational determination of protein structure

Knowledge of protein structure is paramount to the understanding of biological function, developing new therapeutics, and making detailed mechanistic hypotheses. Therefore, methods to accurately elucidate three-dimensional structures of proteins are in high demand. While there are a few experimental techniques that can routinely provide high-resolution structures, such as x-ray crystallography, nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR), and cryo-EM, which have been developed to determine the structures of proteins, these techniques each have shortcomings and thus cannot be used in all cases. However, additionally, a large number of experimental techniques that provide some structural information, but not enough to assign atomic positions with high certainty have been developed. These methods offer sparse experimental data, which can also be noisy and inaccurate in some instances. In cases where it is not possible to determine the structure of a protein experimentally, computational structure prediction methods can be used as an alternative. Although computational methods can be performed without any experimental data in a large number of studies, inclusion of sparse experimental data into these prediction methods has yielded significant improvement. In this Perspective, we cover many of the successes of integrative modeling, computational modeling with experimental data, specifically for protein folding, protein-protein docking, and molecular dynamics simulations. We describe methods that incorporate sparse data from cryo-EM, NMR, mass spectrometry, electron paramagnetic resonance, small-angle x-ray scattering, Förster resonance energy transfer, and genetic sequence covariation. Finally, we highlight some of the major challenges in the field as well as possible future directions.

Ultraviolet Photodissociation Mass Spectrometry for Analysis of Biological Molecules

The development of new ion-activation/dissociation methods continues to be one of the most active areas of mass spectrometry owing to the broad applications of tandem mass spectrometry in the identification and structural characterization of molecules. This Review will showcase the impact of ultraviolet photodissociation (UVPD) as a frontier strategy for generating informative fragmentation patterns of ions, especially for biological molecules whose complicated structures, subtle modifications, and large sizes often impede molecular characterization. UVPD energizes ions via absorption of high-energy photons, which allows access to new dissociation pathways relative to more conventional ion-activation methods. Applications of UVPD for the analysis of peptides, proteins, lipids, and other classes of biologically relevant molecules are emphasized in this Review.

Top-Down Characterization of Denatured Proteins and Native Protein Complexes Using Electron Capture Dissociation Implemented within a Modified Ion Mobility-Mass Spectrometer

Electron-based fragmentation methods have revolutionized biomolecular mass spectrometry, in particular native and top-down protein analysis. Here, we report the use of a new electromagnetostatic cell to perform electron capture dissociation (ECD) within a quadrupole/ion mobility/time-of-flight mass spectrometer. This cell was installed between the ion mobility and time-of-flight regions of the instrument, and fragmentation was fast enough to be compatible with mobility separation. The instrument was already fitted with electron transfer dissociation (ETD) between the quadrupole and mobility regions prior to modification. We show excellent fragmentation efficiency for denatured peptides and proteins without the need to trap ions in the gas phase. Additionally, we demonstrate native top-down backbone fragmentation of noncovalent protein complexes, leading to comparable sequence coverage to what was achieved using the instrument's existing ETD capabilities. Limited collisional ion activation of the hemoglobin tetramer before ECD was reflected in the observed fragmentation pattern, and complementary ion mobility measurements prior to ECD provided orthogonal evidence of monomer unfolding within this complex. The approach demonstrated here provides a powerful platform for both top-down proteomics and mass spectrometry-based structural biology studies.

Ion Mobility and Surface Collisions: Submicrometer Capillaries Can Produce Native-like Protein Complexes

The use of submicrometer capillaries for nanoelectrospray ionization of native proteins and protein complexes effectively reduces the number of nonspecific salt adducts to biological molecules, therefore increasing the apparent resolution of a mass spectrometer without any further instrument modifications or increased ion activation. However, the increased interaction between proteins and the surface of the capillary has been shown to promote protein expansion and therefore loss of native structure. Here, we compare the effect of micrometer and submicrometer sized capillaries on the native structures of the protein complexes streptavidin, concanavalin A, and C-reactive protein under charge reducing conditions. We observe that the use of submicrometer capillaries did not result in a significantly higher charge state distribution, indicative of expansion, when compared to micrometer sized capillaries for complexes in 100 mM ammonium acetate and 100 mM triethylammonium acetate and for streptavidin in 200 mM ammonium acetate with no charge reduction. Additionally, no significant differences in collision cross sections were observed using ion mobility mass spectrometry. Finally, the dissociation behaviors of protein complexes ionized using micrometer and submicrometer capillaries were compared to determine if any structural perturbation occurred during ionization. Protein complexes from both capillary sizes displayed similar surface-induced dissociation patterns at similar activation energies. The results suggest that submicrometer capillaries do not result in significant changes to protein complex structure under charge reducing conditions and may be used for native mass spectrometry experiments. Submicrometer capillaries can be used to resolve small mass differences of biological systems on a QTOF platform; however, a laser tip puller is required for pulling reproducible submicrometer capillaries, and disruption in spray due to clogging was observed for larger protein complexes.

Impact of charge state on 193 nm ultraviolet photodissociation of protein complexes

As applications in mass spectrometry continue to expand into the field of structural biology, there have been an increasing number of studies on noncovalent biological assemblies. Ensuring that protein complexes maintain native-like conformations and architectures during the transition from solution to the gas phase is a key aim. Probing composition and arrangement of subunits of multi-charged complexes via tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) may lead to protein unfolding and the redistribution of charges on the constituent subunits, leading to asymmetric charge partitioning and ejection of a high-charged monomer. Additionally, the overall dissociation efficiency of many ion activation methods is often suppressed for low charge states, hindering the effectiveness of MS/MS for complexes that have low charge density. Ultraviolet photodissociation (UVPD) of proteins using 193 nm photons is a high-energy alternative to collisional activation and demonstrates little to no charge state dependence. Here the symmetry of charge partitioning upon UVPD is evaluated for an array of multimeric protein complexes as a function of initial charge state. The results demonstrate that high laser energies (3 mJ) for UVPD induces more symmetric charge partitioning and ejection of low-charged, presumably compact monomers than higher-energy collisional dissociation (HCD).

Tandem trapped ion mobility spectrometry

Design, characteristics, and application of tandem trapped ion mobility spectrometry (TIMS-TIMS).

Mass spectrometry beyond the native state

Native mass spectrometry allows the study of proteins by probing in vacuum the interactions they form in solution. It is a uniquely useful approach for structural biology and biophysics due to the high resolution of separation it affords, allowing the concomitant interrogation of multiple protein components with high mass accuracy. At its most basic, native mass spectrometry reports the mass of intact proteins and the assemblies they form in solution. However, the opportunities for more detailed characterisation are extensive, enabled by the exquisite control of ion motion that is possible in vacuum. Here we describe recent developments in mass spectrometry approaches to the structural interrogation of proteins both in, and beyond, their native state.

Apparent activation energies of protein-protein complex dissociation in the gas-phase determined by electrospray mass spectrometry

We have developed a method to determine apparent activation energies of dissociation for ionized protein-protein complexes in the gas phase using electrospray ionization mass spectrometry following the Rice-Ramsperger-Kassel-Marcus quasi-equilibrium theory. Protein-protein complexes were formed in solution, transferred into the gas phase, and separated from excess free protein by ion mobility filtering. Afterwards, complex disassembly was initiated by collision-induced dissociation with step-wise increasing energies. Relative intensities of ion signals were used to calculate apparent activation energies of dissociation in the gas phase by applying linear free energy relations. The method was developed using streptavidin tetramers. Experimentally determined apparent gas-phase activation energies for dissociation ([Formula: see text]) of complexes consisting of Fc parts from immunoglobulins (IgG-Fc) and three closely related protein G' variants (IgG-Fc•protein G'e, IgG-Fc•protein G'f, and IgG-Fc•protein G'g) show the same order of stabilities as can be inferred from their in-solution binding constants. Differences in stabilities between the protein-protein complexes correspond to single amino acid residue exchanges in the IgG-binding regions of the protein G' variants. Graphical abstract Electrospray mass spectrometry and collision-induced dissociation delivers apparent activation energies and supramolecular bond force constants of protein-protein complexes in the gas phase.

Intact Transition Epitope Mapping (ITEM)

Intact transition epitope mapping (ITEM) enables rapid and accurate determination of protein antigen-derived epitopes by either epitope extraction or epitope excision. Upon formation of the antigen peptide-containing immune complex in solution, the entire mixture is electrosprayed to translate all constituents as protonated ions into the gas phase. There, ions from antibody-peptide complexes are separated from unbound peptide ions according to their masses, charges, and shapes either by ion mobility drift or by quadrupole ion filtering. Subsequently, immune complexes are dissociated by collision induced fragmentation and the ion signals of the "complex-released peptides," which in effect are the epitope peptides, are recorded in the time-of-flight analyzer of the mass spectrometer. Mixing of an antibody solution with a solution in which antigens or antigen-derived peptides are dissolved is, together with antigen proteolysis, the only required in-solution handling step. Simplicity of sample handling and speed of analysis together with very low sample consumption makes ITEM faster and easier to perform than other experimental epitope mapping methods. Graphical Abstract ᅟ.

Structural Dynamics of Native-Like Ions in the Gas Phase: Results from Tandem Ion Mobility of Cytochrome c

Ion mobility (IM) is a gas-phase separation technique that is used to determine the collision cross sections of native-like ions of proteins and protein complexes, which are in turn used as restraints for modeling the structures of those analytes in solution. Here, we evaluate the stability of native-like ions using tandem IM experiments implemented using structures for lossless ion manipulations (SLIM). In this implementation of tandem IM, ions undergo a first dimension of IM up to a switch that is used to selectively transmit ions of a desired mobility. Selected ions are accumulated in a trap and then released after a delay to initiate the second dimension of IM. For delays ranging from 16 to 33 231 ms, the collision cross sections of native-like, 7+ cytochrome c ions increase monotonically from 15.1 to 17.1 nm². The largest products formed in these experiments at near-ambient temperature are still far smaller than those formed in energy-dependent experiments (∼21 nm²). However, the collision cross section increases by ∼2% between delay times of 16 and 211 ms, which may have implications for other IM experiments on these time scales. Finally, two subpopulations from the full population were each mobility selected and analyzed as a function of delay time, showing that the three populations can be differentiated for at least 1 s. Together, these results suggest that elements of native-like structure can have long lifetimes at near-ambient temperature in the gas phase but that gas-phase dynamics should be considered when interpreting results from IM.

Dynamics of Protonated Peptide Ion Collisions with Organic Surfaces: Consonance of Simulation and Experiment

In this Perspective, mass spectrometry experiments and chemical dynamics simulations are described that have explored the atomistic dynamics of protonated peptide ions, peptide-H(+), colliding with organic surfaces. These studies have investigated the energy transfer and fragmentation dynamics for peptide-H(+) surface-induced dissociation (SID), peptide-H(+) physisorption on the surface, soft landing (SL), and peptide-H(+) reaction with the surface, reactive landing (RL). SID provides primary structures of biological ions and information regarding their fragmentation pathways and energetics. Two SID mechanisms are found for peptide-H(+) fragmentation. A traditional mechanism in which peptide-H(+) is vibrationally excited by its collision with the surface, rebounds off the surface and then dissociates in accord with the statistical, RRKM unimolecular rate theory. The other, shattering, is a nonstatistical mechanism in which peptide-H(+) fragments as it collides with the surface, dissociating via many pathways and forming many product ions. Shattering is important for collisions with diamond and perfluorinated self-assembled monolayer (F-SAM) surfaces, increasing in importance with the peptide-H(+) collision energy. Chemical dynamics simulations also provide important mechanistic insights on SL and RL of biological ions on surfaces. The simulations indicate that SL occurs via multiple mechanisms consisting of sequences of peptide-H(+) physisorption on and penetration in the surface. SL and RL have a broad range of important applications including preparation of protein or peptide microarrays, development of biocompatible substrates and biosensors, and preparation of novel synthetic materials, including nanomaterials. An important RL mechanism is intact deposition of peptide-H(+) on the surface.