Separation of Isotopologues in Ultra-High-Resolution Ion Mobility Spectrometry

A modular, isolated high-voltage switch for application in ion mobility spectrometry

Ion mobility spectrometry is an emerging technology in trace gas analysis that has moved from typical safety and security applications to many other fields ranging from environmental and food quality monitoring to medicine and life sciences. Nevertheless, further dissemination, including the development of new instruments and the expansion into new fields of application requires the availability of the fundamental components of ion mobility spectrometers. For example, the electronics is essential for the analytical performance, but is only provided by specialized manufacturers due to specific requirements. In this paper, we present a modular, isolated high-voltage switch that can be operated at an isolated potential. The modular design enables tailoring its configuration to the required application. Each module can switch a voltage of up to 3 kV, and can be operated with an offset voltage of up to 7 kV. The switch has rise and fall times of less than 25 ns, making it suitable for a wide range of applications, e.g., in ion mobility spectrometry. Finally, the presented modular, isolated high-voltage switch was used in a push-pull configuration to generate the injection pulse of the ion gate. The new modular, isolated high-voltage switch shows similar performance compared to a commercially available high-voltage switch.

Enhancing the Performance of Tyndall-Powell Gate Ion Mobility Spectrometry by Combining Ion Enrichment, Discrimination Reduction, and Temporal Compression into a Single Gating Process

The broad applications of ion mobility spectrometry (IMS) demand good sensitivity and resolving power for ion species with different reduced mobilities (K0). In this work, a new Tyndall-Powell gate (TPG) gating method for combining ion enrichment, mobility discrimination reduction, and temporal compression into a single gating process is proposed to improve IMS analysis performance. The two-parallel-grid structure and well-confined gate region of the TPG make it convenient to spatiotemporally vary the electric fields within and around the gate region. Under the new gating method, a potential wave is applied on TPG grid 1 to enrich ions within the ionization region adjacent to the TPG during the gate-closed state; meanwhile, a potential wave is applied on TPG grid 2 to enhance mobility discrimination reduction and temporal compression simultaneously during the gate-open state. For triethyl phosphate (TEP) and dimethyl methylphosphonate mixtures, product ion peaks within K0 of 1.9 to 1.1 cm2/V·s exhibit a 19-fold increase in ion current compared to the traditional TPG gating method, while maintaining a resolving power of 85. The estimated limit of detection for the TEP dimer is lowered from 8 ppb to 135 ppt. The new gating method can be applied to other TPG-based IMS systems to enhance their performance in analyzing complex samples.

SLIM-Based High-Resolution Ion Mobility Reveals New Structural Insights into Isomeric Vitamin D Metabolites and their Isotopologues

Testing for vitamin D deficiency remains a high-volume clinical assay, much of which is done using mass spectrometry-based methods to alleviate challenges in selectivity associated with immunoassays. Ion mobility-mass spectrometry (IM-MS) has been proposed as a rapid alternative to traditional LC-MS/MS methods, but understanding the structural ensemble that contributes to the ion mobility behavior of this molecular class is critical. Herein we demonstrate the first application of high-resolution Structures for Lossless Ion Manipulations (SLIM) IM separations of several groups of isomeric vitamin D metabolites. Despite previous IM studies of these molecules, the high resolving power of SLIM (Rp ∼ 200) has revealed additional conformations for several of the compounds. The highly similar collision cross sections (CCS), some differing by as little as 0.7%, precluded adequate characterization with low-resolution IM techniques where, in some cases, wider than expected peak widths and/or subtle shoulders may have hinted at their presence. Importantly, these newly resolved peaks often provided a unique mobility that could be used to separate isomers and provides potential for their use in quantification. Lastly, the contribution of isotopic labeling to arrival time distribution for commonly used 13C- and deuterium-labeled internal standards was explored. Minor shifts of ∼0.2-0.3% were observed, and in some instances these shifts were specific to the conformer being measured (i.e., "closed" vs "open"). Accounting for these shifts is important during raw data extraction to ensure reproducible peak area integration, which will be a critical consideration in future quantitative applications.

Isolating the Contributions from Moments of Inertia in Isotopic Shifts Measured by High-Resolution Cyclic Ion Mobility Separations

The unexpected finding that isotopomers (i.e., isotopic isomers) can be separated with high-resolution ion mobility spectrometry-mass spectrometry (IMS-MS) has raised new structural considerations affecting an ion's mobility, namely its center of mass (CoM) and moments of inertia (MoI). Unfortunately, thus far, no studies have attempted to experimentally isolate either CoM or MoI, as they are intrinsically linked by their definitions, where MoI is calculated in relation to CoM. In this study, we designed and synthesized four isotopically labeled tetrapropylammonium (TAA3) ions, each with a unique mass distribution. Three of the synthesized TAA3 ions were labeled symmetrically, thus having identical CoM but differing MoI, which we verified using density functional theory (DFT) calculations. Consequently, we were able to isolate the effect of MoI changes in high-resolution IMS-MS separations. Cyclic ion mobility spectrometry-mass spectrometry (cIMS-MS) separations of the isotopically labeled TAA3 variants revealed isotopic mobility shifts attributable solely to changes in MoI. A 60-m cIMS-MS separation demonstrated that two nominally isobaric TAA3 pseudoisotopomers could be partially resolved, showcasing potential feasibility for isotopomer separations on commercially available IMS-MS platforms. With our previously established collision cross section (CCS) calibration protocol, we also quantified the relationship between MoI and CCS. Our results represent the first demonstration of IMS-MS separations based solely on MoI differences. We believe these findings will contribute important evidence to the growing body of literature on the physical nature of isotopic shifts in IMS-MS separations and work toward more accurate CCS predictions.

Altering Conformational States of Dynamic Ion Populations using Traveling Wave Structures for Lossless Ion Manipulations

With its capacity to store and translate ions across considerable distances and times, traveling wave structures for lossless ion manipulations (TW-SLIM) provide the foundation to expand the scope of ion mobility spectrometry (IMS) experiments. While promising, the dynamic electric fields and consequential ion-neutral collisions used to realize extensive degrees of separation have a considerable impact on the empirical results and the fundamental interpretation of observed arrival time distributions. Using a custom-designed set of TW-SLIM boards (∼9 m) coupled with a time-of-flight mass spectrometer (SLIM-ToF), we detail the capacity to systematically alter the gas-phase distribution of select peptide conformers. In addition to discussing the role charge-transfer may play in TW-SLIM experiments that occur at extended time scales, the ability of the SLIM-ToF to perform tandem IMS was leveraged to confirm that both the compact and elongated conformers of bradykinin2+ undergo interconversion within the SLIM. Storage experiments in which ions are confined within SLIM using static potential wells suggest that factors aside from TW-induced ion motion contribute to interconversion. Further investigation into this matter suggests that the use of radio frequency (RF) fields to confine ions within SLIM may play a role in ion heating. Aside from interconversion, storage experiments also provide insight into charge transfer behavior over the course of extended periods. The results of the presented experiments suggest that considerations should be taken when analyzing labile species and inform strategies for the TW-SLIM design and method development.

SLIM Tricks: Tools, Concepts, and Strategies for the Development of Planar Ion Guides

Traveling wave ion mobility experiments using planar electrode structures (e.g., structures for lossless ion manipulation, TW-SLIM) leverage the mature manufacturing capabilities of printed circuit boards (PCBs). With routine levels of mechanical precision below 150 μm, the conceptual flexibility afforded by PCBs for use as planar ion guides is expansive. To date, the design and construction of TW-SLIM platforms require considerable legacy expertise, especially with respect to simulation and circuit layout strategies. To lower the barrier of TW-SLIM implementation, we introduce Python-based interactive tools that assist in graphical layout of the core electrode footprints for planar ion guides with minimal user inputs. These scripts also export the exact component locations and assignments for direct integration into KiCad and SIMION for PCB finalization and ion flight simulations. The design concepts embodied in the set of scripts comprising SLIM Pickins (PCB CAD generation) and pigsim (SIMION workspace generation) build upon the lessons learned in the independent development of the research-grade TW-SLIM platforms in operation at WSU. Due to the inherent flexibility of the PCB manufacturing process and the time devoted to board layouts prior to manufacturing, both scripts serve to enable rapid, iterative design considerations. Because only a few predefined parameters are necessary (i.e., the TW-SLIM monomer width, x position following a TW Turn, and y position following a TW Turn) it is possible to design the exact component layouts and accompanying simulation space in a manner of minutes. There is no known limitation to the board layout capacities of the scripts, and the size of a designed layout is ultimately constrained by the abilities of the final PCB design and simulation tools, KiCad and SIMION, to accommodate the thousands of electrodes comprising the final design (i.e., RAM and software overhead). Toward removing the barriers to exploring new SLIM tracks and the likelihood of layout errors that require considerable revision and engineering time, the SLIM Pickins and pigsim tools (included as Supporting Information) allow the user to quickly design a length of planar ion guide, simulate its abilities to confine and transmit ions, compare hypothetical board outlines to given vacuum chamber dimensions, and generate a near-production ready PCB CAD file. In addition to these tools, this report outlines a series of cost-saving strategies with respect to vacuum feedthroughs and vacuum chamber design for TW ion mobility experiments using planar ion guides.

Electrospray Ion Mobility Spectrometer Based on Flexible Printed-Circuit Board Electrodes with Improved Resolving Power

An easily built drift tube instrument with ring electrodes made of rolled-up flexible printed circuit boards is reported. Its resolving power was maximized by careful attention to the drift tube geometry and the response time of the detector amplifier and by employing a high separation field strength. The separation of singly charged aliphatic quaternary ammonium ions introduced by electrospray was performed, and the measured resolving power was between 86 and 97% of the theoretical limit for three different drift tube lengths investigated. For the longest drift length of 30 cm, a resolving power of up to 228 was obtained. Three benzalkonium chlorides were also separated with resolving powers of over 210. The tristate injection scheme can also be used, with only a small loss of the separation performance compared to the two-state injection.

High-Definition Differential Ion Mobility Spectrometry with Structural Isotopic Shifts for Anionic Compounds

Differential ion mobility spectrometry (FAIMS) had emerged in the 2000s as a novel tool for postionization separations in conjunction with mass spectrometry (MS). High-definition FAIMS introduced a decade ago has enabled resolution of peptide, lipid, and other molecular isomers with minute structural variations and recently the isotopic shift analyses where the spectral pattern for stable isotopes fingerprints the ion geometry. Those studies, including all isotopic shift analyses, were in the positive mode. Here, we achieve the same high resolution for anions exemplified by phthalic acid isomers. The resolving power and magnitude of isotopic shifts are in line with the metrics for analogous haloaniline cations, establishing high-definition negative-mode FAIMS with structurally specific isotopic shifts. Different shifts (including the new ¹⁸O) remain additive and mutually orthogonal, demonstrating the generality of those properties across the elements and charge states. Expanding to common (not halogenated) organic compounds is a key step toward the broad use of FAIMS isotopic shift methodology.

Hydrogen-Deuterium-Exchange-Based Mass Distribution Shifts in High-Resolution Cyclic Ion Mobility Separations

The mass distribution of ions influences separations in ion mobility spectrometry-mass spectrometry (IMS-MS). Herein, we introduce a method to induce mass distribution shifts for various analytes using hydrogen-deuterium exchange (HDX) immediately prior to ionization using a dual syringe approach. By replacing labile hydrogens on analytes with deuteriums, we were able to differentiate isomers using separations of isotopologues. For each analyte studied, every possible level of deuteration (from undeuterated to fully deuterated) was generated and then separated using cyclic ion mobility spectrometry-mass spectrometry (cIMS-MS). The information gained from such separations (relative arrival times; t_Rel. values) was found to be orthogonal to conventional IMS-MS separations. Additionally, the observed shifts were linearly additive with increasing deuteration, suggesting that this methodology could be extended to analytes with a larger number of labile hydrogens. For one isomer pair, as few as two deuteriums were able to produce a large enough mass distribution shift to differentiate isomers. In another experiment, we found that the mass distribution shift was large enough to overcome the reduced mass contribution, resulting in a "flipped" arrival time where the heavier deuterated isotopologue arrived before the lighter one. In this work, we present a proof-of-concept demonstration that mass-distribution-based shifts, t_Rel. values, could potentially act as an added dimension to characterize molecules in IMS-MS. We anticipate, along with future work in this area, that mass-distribution-based shifts could enable the identification of unknown molecules through a database-driven approach in an analogous fashion to collision cross section (CCS) measurements.

Highly Efficient Ion Manipulator for Tandem Ion Mobility Spectrometry: Exploring a Versatile Technique by a Study of Primary Alcohols

In this work, we present a tandem ion mobility spectrometer (IMS) utilizing a highly efficient ion manipulator allowing to store, manipulate, and analyze ions under high electric field strengths and controlled ion-neutral reactions at ambient conditions. The arrangement of tandem drift regions and an ion manipulator in a single drift tube allows a sequence of mobility selection of precursor ions, followed by storage and analysis, mobility separation, and detection of the resulting product ions. In this article, we present a journey exploring the capabilities of the present instrument by a study of eight different primary alcohols characterized at reduced electric field strengths E/N of up to 120 Td with a water vapor concentration ranging from 40 to 540 ppb. Under these conditions, protonated alcohol monomers up to a carbon number of nine could be dissociated, resulting in 18 different fragmented product ions in total. The fragmentation patterns revealed regularities, which can be used for assignment to the chemical class and improved classification of unknown substances. Furthermore, both the time spent in high electrical field strengths and the reaction time with water vapor can be tuned precisely, allowing the fragment distribution to be influenced. Thus, further information regarding the relations of the product ions can be gathered in a standalone drift tube IMS for the first time.

Easy to assemble dielectric barrier discharge plasma ionization source based on printed circuit boards

Here, we present a new and an easy to assemble dielectric barrier discharge plasma ionization source based on printed circuit boards with two parallel isolated electrodes for generating a plasma inside an inert fused silica capillary. For demonstration, this plasma source is coupled to an ion mobility spectrometer. With two different sample gas feeds the analytes can either pass through the plasma or bypass the plasma before entering the reaction region of the ion mobility spectrometer, allowing for different ionization pathways, e.g. electron impact ionization, ionization by excited species, e.g. helium metastables, or chemical ionization via reactant ions generated inside or downstream of the plasma. The plasma source, in particular, the electrode geometry and the capillary diameter were designed with the help of electric field simulations. A rectangular electrode with a height of at least twice the outer diameter of the capillary turned out to be ideal, in both the simulation and the experiment. Furthermore, a simple control electronics has been developed, which can be easily applied to other plasma sources. With the plasma source presented here, detection limits in the mid ppt_v range have been reached.

Isomer and Conformer-Specific Mass Distribution-Based Isotopic Shifts in High-Resolution Cyclic Ion Mobility Separations

Herein, we present the use of mass distribution-based isotopic shifts in high-resolution cyclic ion mobility spectrometry-mass spectrometry (cIMS-MS)-based separations to characterize various isomeric species as well as conformers. Specifically, by using the observed relative arrival time values for the isotopologues found in the isotopic envelope after long pathlength cIMS-MS separations, we were able to distinguish dibromoaniline, dichloroaniline, and quaternary ammonium salt isomers, as well as a pair of 25-hydroxyvitamin D3 conformers based on their respective mass distribution-based shifts. Our observed shifts were highly reproducible and broadly applied to the isotopologues of various atoms (i.e., Cl, Br, and C). Additionally, through a control experiment, we determined that such shifts are indeed pathlength-independent, thus demonstrating that our presented methodology could be readily extended to other high-resolution IMS-MS platforms. These results are the first characterization of conformers using mass distribution-based IMS-MS shifts, as well as the first use of a commercial cIMS-MS platform to characterize isomers via their mass distribution-based shifts. We anticipate that our methodology will have broad applicability for biological analytes and that mass distribution-based shifts could potentially act as an added dimension of analysis in existing IMS-MS workflows in omics-based research. Specifically, we envision that the development of a database of these mass distribution-based shifts could, for example, enable the identification of unknown metabolites in complex matrices.

Modeling the modulation characteristics of the Bradbury-Nielsen gate in ion mobility spectrometers

The Bradbury-Nelson gate (BNG) is a common device used for ion control in time-of-flight mass spectrometry and ion mobility spectrometry (IMS). A dual-location control model was employed in order to better understand the behavior of ions around a modulated BNG. This model illustrated that the ions are released from the starting location and truncated at the cutoff location. The shapes of the starting and cutoff locations are both curved with similar curvature, and the cutoff location is situated further back. Therefore, the distance between the two locations is a key parameter leading to the ion loss during modulation and is influenced by the gating voltage difference. Through simulations and experiments, the ion loss is verified to increase with the increase in the gating voltage difference. Taking a Fourier transform IMS as an example, by reducing the gating voltage difference from 150 to 50 V, the signal-to-noise ratio of the time domain result was improved from 91.7 to 386.5 and the resolving power was improved from 40.9 to 63.6. In addition, the superposition effect of multicycle modulation is shown and explained by the model. When the modulated frequency is too rapid and the closing time is insufficient for all the ions to be consumed, some ions continue to exist between the two locations, and the residual ions then enter the drift region during the next few cycles. This phenomenon needs to be avoided because the total number of ions entering the drift region will then increase uncontrollably.

Field-Switching Repeller Flowing Atmospheric-Pressure Afterglow Drift Tube Ion Mobility Spectrometry

In this work, a field-switching (FS) technique is employed with a flowing atmospheric pressure afterglow (FAPA) source in drift tube ion mobility spectrometry (DTIMS). The premise is to incorporate a tip-repeller electrode as a substitute for the Bradbury-Nielsen gate (BNG) so as to overcome corresponding disadvantages of the BNG, including the gate depletion effect (GDE). The DTIMS spectra were optimized in terms of peak shape and full width by inserting an aperture at the DTIMS inlet that was used to control the neutral molecules' penetration into the separation region, thus preventing neutral-ion reactions inside. The FAPA and repeller's experimental operating conditions including drift and plasma gas flow rates, pulse injection times, repeller positioning and voltage, FAPA current, and effluent angle were optimized. Ion mobility spectra of selected compounds were captured, and the corresponding reduced mobility values were calculated and compared with the literature. The 6-fold improvements in limit of detection (LOD) compared with previous work were obtained for 2,6-DTBP and acetaminophen. The enhanced performance of the FS-FAPA-DTIMS was also investigated as a function of the GDE when compared with FAPA-DTIMS containing BNG.

Combining Isotopologue Workflows and Simultaneous Multidimensional Separations to Detect, Identify, and Validate Metabolites in Untargeted Analyses

While the combination of liquid chromatography and tandem mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS) is commonly used for feature annotation in untargeted omics experiments, ensuring these prioritized features originate from endogenous metabolism remains challenging. Isotopologue workflows, such as isotopic ratio outlier analysis (IROA), mass isotopomer ratio analysis of U-¹³C labeled extracts (MIRACLE), and credentialing incorporate isotopic labels directly into metabolic precursors, guaranteeing that all features of interest are unequivocal byproducts of cellular metabolism. Furthermore, comprehensive separation and annotation of small molecules continue to challenge the metabolomics field, particularly for isomeric systems. In this paper, we evaluate the analytical utility of incorporating ion mobility spectrometry (IMS) as an additional separation mechanism into standard LC-MS/MS isotopologue workflows. Since isotopically labeled molecules codrift in the IMS dimension with their ¹²C versions, LC-IMS-CID-MS provides four dimensions (LC, IMS, MS, and MS/MS) to directly investigate the metabolic activity of prioritized untargeted features. Here, we demonstrate this additional selectivity by showcasing how a preliminary data set of 30 endogeneous metabolites are putatively annotated from isotopically labeled Escherichia coli cultures when analyzed by LC-IMS-CID-MS. Metabolite annotations were based on several molecular descriptors, including accurate mass measurement, carbon number, annotated fragmentation spectra, and collision cross section (CCS), collectively illustrating the importance of incorporating IMS into isotopologue workflows. Overall, our results highlight the enhanced separation space and increased annotation confidence afforded by IMS for metabolic characterization and provide a unique perspective for future developments in isotopically labeled MS experiments.

Experimental Measurements of Relative Mobility Shifts Resulting from Isotopic Substitutions with High-Resolution Cyclic Ion Mobility Separations

Herein, we report on the experimental measurements for estimated relative mobility shifts caused by changes in mass distribution from isotopic substitutions in isotopologues and isotopomers with high-resolution cyclic ion mobility separations. By utilizing unlabeled and fully labeled isotopologues with the same isotopic substitutions (i.e., ²H or ¹³C), we created a highly precise mobility scale for each set analyzed to determine the magnitude of such mass distribution shifts and thus calculate estimated deviations from expected, theoretical reduced mass contributions. We observed relative mobility shifts in various isotopologues (e.g., hexadecyltrimethylammonium, sucrose, and palmitic acid species) that deviated from reduced mass theory, according to the Mason-Schamp relationship, ranging in estimated magnitude from ∼0.007% up to ∼0.1% in relative mobility. More interestingly, it was found that two deuterated palmitic acid isotopomers also differed by ∼0.03% from one another in their respective relative mobility shifts. Our results are the first report of isotopologue and isotopomer separations on a commercially available cyclic ion mobility spectrometry-mass spectrometry platform. We envision that our presented mobility scale methodology will have broad applicability in studying the effect of mass distribution changes from isotopic substitutions in other biomolecules and help pave the way for the improvement of ion mobility theory and collision cross section calculators.

Measurement and Theory of Gas-Phase Ion Mobility Shifts Resulting from Isotopomer Mass Distribution Changes

The unanticipated discovery of recent ultra-high-resolution ion mobility spectrometry (IMS) measurements revealing that isotopomers─compounds that differ only in the isotopic substitution sites─can be separated has raised questions as to the physical basis for their separation. A study comparing IMS separations for two isotopomer sets in conjunction with theory and simulations accounting for ion rotational effects provides the first-ever prediction of rotation-mediated shifts. The simulations produce observable mobility shifts due to differences in gas-ion collision frequency and translational-to-rotational energy transfer. These differences can be attributed to distinct changes in the moment of inertia and center of mass between isotopomers. The simulations are in broad agreement with the observed experiments and consistent with relative mobility differences between isotopomers. These results provide a basis for refining IMS theory and a new foundation to obtain additional structural insights through IMS.

Study of atmospheric pressure chemical ionization of phthalates in air by ion mobility spectrometry/mass spectrometry

RATIONALE

Phthalates are widely used in consumer products in the chemical industries. Due to their abundance in the milieu, their potentially harmful effect on the environment, human and animal health there is a need for sensitive and fast methods for their detection.

METHODS

Positive polarity Corona Discharge Atmospheric Pressure Chemical Ionization (CD-APCI) in the air was applied for ionization of phthalates. The ionization method for the phthalates was studied by atmospheric pressure Ion Mobility Spectrometry (IMS) and hybrid IMS/orthogonal acceleration Time-of-Flight Mass spectrometry (IMS-oaTOF-MS).

RESULTS

CD-APCI IMS and MS spectra of selected phthalates (dimethyl phthalate, diethyl phthalate, diethyl isophthalate, diethyl terephthalate, dipropyl phthalate, diisopropyl phthalate, dibutyl phthalate, diisobutyl phthalate, and dibutyl terephthalate) were recorded. In the case of the ortho- and "iso"-isomers exclusively the protonated molecular ions [M + H]⁺ were detected. In the case of the para- and meta-isomers and regioisomers, APCI resulted in the appearance of hydrated protonated molecular ions [M + H]⁺ ·(H₂ O)_0,1,2 . The ion mobilities, collision cross-sections of these ions in air, as well as the limits of detection (LODs) for the phthalate vapors, were determined. In the case of isomeric phthalates, we have demonstrated the potential of the IMS technique for their separation.

CONCLUSIONS

The results show that CD-APCI in combination with IMS and IMS-oaTOF-MS is a suitable method for the fast and sensitive detection of phthalates with the potential to separate some isomers.

Plate-height model of ion mobility-mass spectrometry: Part 2-Peak-to-peak resolution and peak capacity

In a previous work, we explored zone broadening and the achievable plate numbers in linear drift tube ion mobility-mass spectrometry through developing a plate-height model [1]. On the basis of these findings, the present theoretical study extends the model by exploring peak-to-peak resolution and peak capacity in ion mobility separations. The first part provides a critical overview of chromatography-influenced resolution equations, including refinement of existing formulae. Furthermore, we present exact resolution equations for drift tube ion mobility spectrometry based on first principles. Upon implementing simple modifications, these exact formulae could be readily extended to traveling wave ion mobility separations and to cases when ion mobility spectrometry is coupled to mass spectrometry. The second part focuses on peak capacity. The well-known assumptions of constant plate number and constant peak width form the basis of existing approximate solutions. To overcome their limitations, an exact peak capacity equation is derived for drift tube ion mobility spectrometry. This exact solution is rooted in a suitable physical model of peak broadening, accounting for the finite injection pulse and subsequent diffusional spreading. By borrowing concepts from the theoretical toolbox of chromatography, we believe that the present study will help in integrating ion mobility spectrometry into the unified language of separation science.

Recent applications of ion mobility spectrometry in natural product research

Ion mobility spectrometry (IMS) is a rapid separation technique capable of extracting complementary structural information to chromatography and mass spectrometry (MS). IMS, especially in combination with MS, has experienced inordinate growth in recent years as an analytical technique, and elicited intense interest in many research fields. In natural product analysis, IMS shows promise as an additional tool to enhance the performance of analytical methods used to identify promising drug candidates. Potential benefits of the incorporation of IMS into analytical workflows currently used in natural product analysis include the discrimination of structurally similar secondary metabolites, improving the quality of mass spectral data, and the use of mobility-derived collision cross-section (CCS) values as an additional identification criterion in targeted and untargeted analyses. This review aims to provide an overview of the application of IMS to natural product analysis over the last six years. Instrumental aspects and the fundamental background of IMS will be briefly covered, and recent applications of the technique for natural product analysis will be discussed to demonstrate the utility of the technique in this field.

On-Line Coupling of Chip-Electrochromatography and Ion Mobility Spectrometry

We report the first hyphenation of chip-electrochromatography (ChEC) with ion mobility spectrometry (IMS). This approach combines the separation power of two electrokinetically driven separation techniques, the first in liquid phase and the second in gas phase, with a label-free detection of the analytes. For achieving this, a microfluidic glass chip incorporating a monolithic separation column, a nanofluidic liquid junction for providing post-column electrical contact, and a monolithically integrated electrospray emitter was developed. This device was successfully coupled to a custom-built high-resolution drift tube IMS with shifted potentials. After proof-of-concept studies in which a mixture of five model compounds was analyzed in less than 80 s, this first ChEC-IMS system was applied to a more complex sample, the analysis of herbicides spiked in the wine matrix. The use of ChEC before IMS detection not only facilitated the peak allocation and increased the peak capacity but also enabled analyte quantification. As both, ChEC and IMS work at ambient conditions and are driven by high voltages, no bulky pumping systems are needed, neither for the hydrodynamic pumping of the mobile phase as in high-performance liquid chromatography nor for generating a vacuum system as in mass spectrometry. Accordingly, the approach has great potential as a portable analytical system for field analysis of complex mixtures.

Field-Dependent Reduced Ion Mobilities of Positive and Negative Ions in Air and Nitrogen in High Kinetic Energy Ion Mobility Spectrometry (HiKE-IMS)

In High Kinetic Energy Ion Mobility Spectrometry (HiKE-IMS), ions are formed in a reaction region and separated in a drift region, which is similar to classical drift tube ion mobility spectrometers (IMS) operated at ambient pressure. However, in contrast to the latter, the HiKE-IMS is operated at a decreased background pressure of 10-40 mbar and achieves high reduced electric field strengths of up to 120 Td in both the reaction and the drift region. Thus, the HiKE-IMS allows insights into the chemical kinetics of ion-bound water cluster systems at effective ion temperatures exceeding 1000 K, although it is operated at the low absolute temperature of 45 °C. In this work, a HiKE-IMS with a high resolving power of R_P = 140 is used to study the dependence of reduced ion mobilities on the drift gas humidity and the effective ion temperature for the positive reactant ions H₃O⁺(H₂O)_n, O₂⁺(H₂O)_n, NO⁺(H₂O)_n, NO₂⁺(H₂O)_n, and NH₄⁺(H₂O)_n, as well as the negative reactant ions O₂^-(H₂O)_n, O₃^-(H₂O)_n, CO₃^-(H₂O)_n, HCO₃^-(H₂O)_n, and NO₂^-(H₂O)_n. By varying the reduced electric field strength in the drift region, cluster transitions are observed in the ion mobility spectra. This is demonstrated for the cluster systems H₃O⁺(H₂O)_n and NO⁺(H₂O)_n.

Ion Mobility Shift of Isotopologues in a High Kinetic Energy Ion Mobility Spectrometer (HiKE-IMS) at Elevated Effective Temperatures

Ion mobility spectrometers (IMS) separate ions mainly by ion-neutral collision cross section and to a lesser extent by ion mass and effective temperature. When investigating isotopologues, the difference in collision cross section can be assumed negligible. Since the mobility shift of isotopologues is thus mainly caused by their difference in mass and effective temperature, the investigation of isotopologues can provide important insights into the theory of ion mobility. However, in classical IMS operated at ambient pressure, cluster formation with neutral molecules occurs, which significantly influences the mobility shift of isotopologues and thus makes a sound investigation of the effect of ion mass and effective temperature on the ion mobility difficult. In this work, the relative ion mobility of several organic compounds and their ¹³C-labeled isotopologues is studied in a High Kinetic Energy Ion Mobility Spectrometer (HiKE-IMS) at high reduced electric fields up to 120 Td, which allows the investigation of nonclustered ion species and thus enables a sound investigation of the mobility shift of isotopologues. The results show that the measured relative ion mobilities of isotopologues having the same effective temperature and, thus, their ion mass dominating the relative ion mobility agree well with theoretical relative ion mobilities predicted by the theory of ion mobility.

The use of UHPLC, IMS, and HRMS in multiresidue analytical methods: A critical review

Residue chemists who analyse pesticides in vegetables or veterinary drugs in animal-based food are currently facing a situation where there is a requirement to detect more and more compounds at lower and lower concentrations. Conventional tandem quadrupole instruments provide sufficient sensitivity, but speed and selectivity appear as future limitations. This will become an even larger issue when there is a need to not only detect active compounds but also their degradation products and metabolites. This will likely lead to a situation in which the conventional targeted approach must be expanded or augmented by a certain non-targeted strategy. High-resolution mass spectrometry provides such capabilities, but it frequently requires an additional degree of selectivity for the unequivocal confirmation of analytes present at trace levels in highly complex and variable food matrices. The hyphenation of ultrahigh performance liquid chromatography with ion mobility and high-resolution mass spectrometry provides analytical chemists with a new tool for performing such a demanding multiresidue analysis. The objective of this paper is to investigate the benefits of the added ion mobility dimension as well as to critically discuss the current limitations of this commercially available technology.

Flexible Drift Tube for High Resolution Ion Mobility Spectrometry (Flex-DT-IMS)

This paper describes, in detail, the development of a novel, low-cost, and flexible drift tube (DT) along with an associated ion mobility spectrometer system. The DT is constructed from a flexible printed circuit board (PCB), with a bespoke “dog-leg” track design, that can be rolled up for ease of assembly. This approach incorporates a shielding layer, as part of the flexible PCB design, and represents the minimum dimensional footprint conceivable for a DT. The low thermal mass of the polyimide substrate and overlapping electrodes, as afforded by the dog-leg design, allow for efficient heat management and high field linearity within the tube–achieved from a single PCB. This is further enhanced by a novel double-glazing configuration which provides a simple and effective means for gas management, minimizing thermal variation within the assembly. Herein, we provide a full experimental characterization of the flexible DT ion mobility spectrometer (Flex-DT-IMS) with corresponding electrodynamic (Simion 8.1) and fluid dynamic (SolidWorks) simulations. The Flex-DT-IMS is shown to have a resolution >80 and a detection limit of low nanograms for the analysis of common explosives (RDX, PETN, HMX, and TNT).

Analyzing Positive Reactant Ions in High Kinetic Energy Ion Mobility Spectrometry (HiKE-IMS) by HiKE-IMS-MS

In contrast to classical ion mobility spectrometers (IMS) operating at ambient pressure, the high kinetic energy ion mobility spectrometer (HiKE-IMS) is operated at reduced pressures between 10-40 mbar. In HiKE-IMS, ions are generated in a reaction region before they are separated in a drift region. Due to the operation at reduced pressure, it is possible to reach high reduced electric field strengths up to 120 Td in both the reaction as well as drift region, resulting in a pronounced decrease in chemical cross sensitivities and a significant enhancement of the dynamic range. Until now though, only limited knowledge about the ionization pathways in HiKE-IMS is available. Typically, proton bound water clusters, H⁺(H₂O)_n, are the most abundant positive reactant ion species in classical IMS with atmospheric chemical ionization sources. However, at reduced pressure and increased effective ion temperature, the reactant ion population significantly changes. As the ionization efficiency of analyte molecules in HiKE-IMS strongly depends on the reactant ion population, a detailed knowledge of the reactant ion population generated in HiKE-IMS is essential. Here, we present a coupling stage of the HiKE-IMS to a mass spectrometer enabling the identification of ion species and the investigation of ion molecule reactions prevailing in HiKE-IMS. In the present study, the HiKE-IMS-MS is used to identify positive reactant ion populations in both, purified air and nitrogen, respectively. The experimental data suggest the generation of systems of clustered primary ions (H⁺(H₂O)_n, NO⁺(H₂O)_m, and O₂⁺(H₂O)_p), which most probably serve as reactant ions. Their relative abundances highly depend on the reduced electric field strength in the reaction region. Furthermore, their effective mobilities are studied as a function of the reduced electric field strength in the drift region.

Structurally Informative Isotopic Shifts in Ion Mobility Spectra for Heavier Species

The isotopic molecular envelopes due to stable isotopes for most elements were a staple of mass spectrometry since its origins, often leveraged to identify and quantify compounds. However, all isomers share one MS envelope. As the molecular motion in media also depends on the isotopic composition, separations such as liquid chromatography (LC) and ion mobility spectrometry (IMS) must also feature isotopic envelopes. These were largely not observed because of limited resolution, except for the (structurally uninformative) shifts in LC upon H/D exchange. We recently found the isotopic shifts in FAIMS for small haloanilines (∼130-170 Da) to hinge on the halogen position, opening a novel route to isomer characterization. Here, we extend the capability to heavier species: dibromoanilines (DBAs, ∼250 Da) and tribromoanilines (TBAs, ∼330 Da). The ¹³C shifts for DBAs and TBAs vary across isomers, some changing sign. While ⁸¹Br shifts are less specific, the 2-D ¹³C/⁸¹Br shifts unequivocally differentiate all isomers. The trends for DBAs track those for dichloroanilines, with the ¹³C shift order preserved for most isomers. The peak broadening due to merged isotopomers is also isomer-specific. The absolute shifts for TBAs are smaller than those for lighter haloanilines, but differentiate isomers as well because of compressed uncertainties. These results showcase the feasibility of broadly distinguishing isomers in the more topical ∼200-300 Da range using the isotopic shifts in IMS spectra.

Plate-height model of ion mobility-mass spectrometry

In analogy to chromatography, a plate-height model of drift tube ion mobility-mass spectrometry is presented that describes zone broadening and resolving power in ion mobility separations.

Increased ion throughput using tristate ion-gate multiplexing

For time dispersive ion mobility experiments detail control over the mechanism of ion beam modulation is necessary to establish optimum performance as this parameter greatly influences the temporal width of the ion beam arriving at the detector. When sampling continuous ion sources the temporal sampling or the incoming ion beam is often achieved by the electronic modulation of a grid or electric field. Not surprisingly, the rate at which a given ion population traverses this gating region is directly proportional to an ion's population and the applied electric field. This scenario establishes conditions where discrimination of the incoming ion beam may occur when the ion gate modulation rate is minimized. Recent developments in the mechanical construction of ion gates and their subsequent operation suggest that the mobility discrimination during ion gating may be minimized, however, it is remains unclear how this behavior will translate to ion beam multiplexing approaches. In this present work, we compare the performance levels of the tri-state ion shutter (3S-IS) to the two-state ion shutter (2S-IS) using a series of Fourier transform ion mobility mass spectrometry (FT-IMMS) experiments. The performance of the two different shutter operating principles were evaluated using ion multiplexing using tetraalkylammonium salts (TXA ions; T5-T8, T10, T12) bradykinin, and a set of reversed sequence isomeric pentapeptides using a variety of different ion gate frequency sweeps. Noticeable increases in ion throughput were observed for the 3S-IS with 95% and 45% increases in ion counts for the T5 and T12 ions respectively compared to the 2S-IS. Similarly, a 27% and 55% increase in ion counts was observed for the [M + 2H]2+ and [M + H]+ ions of bradykinin, respectively. In addition, a 10% increase in resolving power was also observed for the 3S-IS compared to the 2S-IS. Overall, utilization of the 3S-IS effectively minimizes both discrimination of slower ions and the impact of gate depletion effect common to traditional ion gating techniques.

Ion Mobility Spectrometry: Fundamental Concepts, Instrumentation, Applications, and the Road Ahead

Ion mobility spectrometry (IMS) is a rapid separation technique that has experienced exponential growth as a field of study. Interfacing IMS with mass spectrometry (IMS-MS) provides additional analytical power as complementary separations from each technique enable multidimensional characterization of detected analytes. IMS separations occur on a millisecond timescale, and therefore can be readily nested into traditional GC and LC/MS workflows. However, the continual development of novel IMS methods has generated some level of confusion regarding the advantages and disadvantages of each. In this critical insight, we aim to clarify some common misconceptions for new users in the community pertaining to the fundamental concepts of the various IMS instrumental platforms (i.e., DTIMS, TWIMS, TIMS, FAIMS, and DMA), while addressing the strengths and shortcomings associated with each. Common IMS-MS applications are also discussed in this review, such as separating isomeric species, performing signal filtering for MS, and incorporating collision cross-section (CCS) values into both targeted and untargeted omics-based workflows as additional ion descriptors for chemical annotation. Although many challenges must be addressed by the IMS community before mobility information is collected in a routine fashion, the future is bright with possibilities.

SLIM Ultrahigh Resolution Ion Mobility Spectrometry Separations of Isotopologues and Isotopomers Reveal Mobility Shifts due to Mass Distribution Changes

We report on separations of ion isotopologues and isotopomers using ultrahigh-resolution traveling wave-based Structures for Lossless Ion Manipulations with serpentine ultralong path and extended routing ion mobility spectrometry coupled to mass spectrometry (SLIM SUPER IMS-MS). Mobility separations of ions from the naturally occurring ion isotopic envelopes (e.g., [M], [M+1], [M+2], ... ions) showed the first and second isotopic peaks (i.e., [M+1] and [M+2]) for various tetraalkylammonium ions could be resolved from their respective monoisotopic ion peak ([M]) after SLIM SUPER IMS with resolving powers of ∼400-600. Similar separations were obtained for other compounds (e.g., tetrapeptide ions). Greater separation was obtained using argon versus helium drift gas, as expected from the greater reduced mass contribution to ion mobility described by the Mason-Schamp relationship. To more directly explore the role of isotopic substitutions, we studied a mixture of specific isotopically substituted (15N, 13C, and 2H) protonated arginine isotopologues. While the separations in nitrogen were primarily due to their reduced mass differences, similar to the naturally occurring isotopologues, their separations in helium, where higher resolving powers could also be achieved, revealed distinct additional relative mobility shifts. These shifts appeared correlated, after correction for the reduced mass contribution, with changes in the ion center of mass due to the different locations of heavy atom substitutions. The origin of these apparent mass distribution-induced mobility shifts was then further explored using a mixture of Iodoacetyl Tandem Mass Tag (iodoTMT) isotopomers (i.e., each having the same exact mass, but with different isotopic substitution sites). Again, the observed mobility shifts appeared correlated with changes in the ion center of mass leading to multiple monoisotopic mobilities being observed for some isotopomers (up to a ∼0.04% difference in mobility). These mobility shifts thus appear to reflect details of the ion structure, derived from the changes due to ion rotation impacting collision frequency or momentum transfer, and highlight the potential for new approaches for ion structural characterization.

Recommendations for reporting ion mobility Mass Spectrometry measurements

Here we present a guide to ion mobility mass spectrometry experiments, which covers both linear and nonlinear methods: what is measured, how the measurements are done, and how to report the results, including the uncertainties of mobility and collision cross section values. The guide aims to clarify some possibly confusing concepts, and the reporting recommendations should help researchers, authors and reviewers to contribute comprehensive reports, so that the ion mobility data can be reused more confidently. Starting from the concept of the definition of the measurand, we emphasize that (i) mobility values (K0 ) depend intrinsically on ion structure, the nature of the bath gas, temperature, and E/N; (ii) ion mobility does not measure molecular surfaces directly, but collision cross section (CCS) values are derived from mobility values using a physical model; (iii) methods relying on calibration are empirical (and thus may provide method-dependent results) only if the gas nature, temperature or E/N cannot match those of the primary method. Our analysis highlights the urgency of a community effort toward establishing primary standards and reference materials for ion mobility, and provides recommendations to do so. © 2019 The Authors. Mass Spectrometry Reviews Published by Wiley Periodicals, Inc.

Ultra-high-resolution ion mobility spectrometry-current instrumentation, limitations, and future developments

With recent advances in ionization sources and instrumentation, ion mobility spectrometers (IMS) have transformed from a detector for chemical warfare agents and explosives to a widely used tool in analytical and bioanalytical applications. This increasing measurement task complexity requires higher and higher analytical performance and especially ultra-high resolution. In this review, we will discuss the currently used ion mobility spectrometers able to reach such ultra-high resolution, defined here as a resolving power greater than 200. These instruments are drift tube IMS, traveling wave IMS, trapped IMS, and field asymmetric or differential IMS. The basic operating principles and the resulting effects of experimental parameters on resolving power are explained and compared between the different instruments. This allows understanding the current limitations of resolving power and how ion mobility spectrometers may progress in the future. Graphical abstract.

Achieving high gating performance for ion mobility spectrometry by manipulating ion swarm spatiotemporal behaviors in the vicinity of ion shutter

Ion shutter is one of the key components of the drift-tube types of ion mobility spectrometer, which affects both the resolving power and sensitivity of an ion mobility spectrometer. In this work, a spatiotemporal model was built to understand the behaviors of the ion swarms around the ion shutter. For simplicity, a Tyndall-Powell gate (TPG) was chosen as the gating disturbance to the field on the two sides of ion shutter could be separated. It can be inferred from the spatiotemporal model that the ion swarm could be diluted in front of the TPG when the gate closing voltage (GCV) was superposed on the grid facing the ionization region, while it could be compressed behind the TPG when the GCV was superposed on the other grid. These inferences conformed to the narrower and higher ion peaks obtained at GCV superposed on the latter grid and were further verified by the ion distribution profiles obtained at a wide gate opening pulse width. Finally, the product of the resolving power and the gating efficiency was proposed to evaluate the gating performance of an ion shutter. At GCV superposed on the grid facing the drift region, the best gating performance of 42 was obtained with peak height of 1.63 nA and resolving power of 57.2, and was almost twice as high as the optimal gating performance at GCV superposed on the other grid.

Coupling of a High-Resolution Ambient Pressure Drift Tube Ion Mobility Spectrometer to a Commercial Time-of-flight Mass Spectrometer

Ion mobility spectrometry provides information about molecular structures of ions. Hence, high resolving power allows separation of isomers which is of major interest in several applications. In this work, we couple our high-resolution ion mobility spectrometer (IMS) with a resolving power of R_p = 100 to a time-of-flight mass spectrometer (TOF-MS). Besides, the benefit of an increased resolving power such an IMS-MS also helps analyzing and understanding the ionization processes in IMS. Usually, the coupling between IMS and TOF-MS is realized by synchronizing data acquisition of the IMS and MS resulting in two-dimensional data containing ion mobility and mass spectra. However, due to peak widths of less than 100 μs in our high-resolution IMS, this technique is not practicable due to significant peak broadening during the ion transfer into the MS and an insufficient data acquisition rate of the MS. Thus, a novel but simple interface between the IMS and MS has been designed which minimizes ion losses, allows recording of ion mobility at full IMS resolving power, and enables a shuttered transmission of ions into the MS. The interface is realized by replacing the Faraday plate used in IMS by a Faraday grid that is shielded by two additional aperture grids. For demonstration, positive product ions of benzene, toluene, and m-xylene in air are investigated. The IMS is equipped with a radioactive ³H source. Besides the well-known product ions M⁺ and M·NO⁺, a dimer ion is also observed for benzene and toluene, consisting of two molecules and three further hydrogen atoms. Graphical Abstract ᅟ.

Fast Orthogonal Separation by Superposition of Time of Flight and Field Asymmetric Ion Mobility Spectrometry

Ion mobility spectrometry is a powerful and low-cost technique for the identification of chemical warfare agents, toxic chemicals, or explosives in air. Drift tube ion mobility spectrometers (DT-IMS) separate ions by the absolute value of their low field ion mobility, while field asymmetric ion mobility spectrometers (FAIMS) separate them by the change of their ion mobility at high fields. However, using one of these devices alone, some common and harmless substances show the same response as the hazardous target substances. In order to increase the selectivity, orthogonal data are required. Thus, in this work, we present for the first time an ambient pressure ion mobility spectrometer which is able to separate ions both by their differential and low field mobility, providing additional information for selectivity enhancement. This novel field asymmetric time of flight ion mobility spectrometer (FAT-IMS) allows high repetition rates and reaches limits of detection in the low ppb range common for DT-IMS. The device consists of a compact 44 mm drift tube with a tritium ionization source and a resolving power of 70. An increased separation of four substances with similar low field ion mobility is shown: phosgene (K₀ = 2.33 cm²/(V s)), 1,1,2-trichlorethane (K₀ = 2.31 cm²/(V s)), chlorine (K₀ = 2.24 cm²/(V s)), and nitrogen dioxide (K₀ = 2.25 cm²/(V s)). Furthermore, the behavior and limits of detection for acetonitrile, dimethyl methylphosphonate, diisopropyl methyl phosphonate in positive polarity and carbon dioxide, sulfur dioxide, hydrochloric acid, cyanogen chloride, and hydrogen cyanide in negative polarity are investigated.