Trimethylation Enhancement Using 13C-Diazomethane: Gas-Phase Charge Inversion of Modified Phospholipid Cations for Enhanced Structural Characterization

Optimized 13C-TrEnDi Enhances the Sensitivity of Plasmenyl Ether Glycerophospholipids and Demonstrates Compatibility with Other Derivatization Strategies

The identification and quantitation of plasmalogen glycerophospholipids is challenging due to their isobaric overlap with plasmanyl ether-linked glycerophospholipids, susceptibility to acid degradation, and their typically low abundance in biological samples. Trimethylation enhancement using diazomethane (TrEnDi) can be used to significantly enhance the signal of glycerophospholipids through the creation of quaternary ammonium groups producing fixed positive charges using 13C-diazomethane in complex lipid extracts. Although TrEnDi requires a strong acid for complete methylation, we report an optimized protocol using 10 mM HBF4 with the subsequent addition of a buffer solution that prevents acidic hydrolysis of plasmalogen species and enables the benefits of TrEnDi to be realized for this class of lipids. These optimized conditions were applied to aliquots of bovine liver extract (BLE) to achieve permethylation of plasmalogen lipids within a complex mixture. Treating aliquots of unmodified and TrEnDi-derivatized BLE samples with 80% formic acid and comparing their liquid chromatography mass spectrometry (LCMS) results to analogous samples not treated with formic acid, enabled the identification of 29 plasmalogen species. On average, methylated plasmalogen species from BLE demonstrated 2.81-fold and 28.1-fold sensitivity gains over unmodified counterparts for phosphatidylcholine and phosphatidylethanolamine plasmalogen species, respectively. Furthermore, the compatibility of employing 13C-TrEnDi and a previously reported iodoacetalization strategy was demonstrated to effectively identify plasmenyl-ether lipids in complex biological extracts at greater levels of sensitivity. Overall, we detail an optimized 13C-TrEnDi derivatization strategy that enables the analysis of plasmalogen glycerophospholipids with no undesired cleavage of radyl groups, boosting their sensitivity in LCMS and LCMS/MS analyses.

Expanding Lipidomic Coverage in Multisegment Injection-Nonaqueous Capillary Electrophoresis-Mass Spectrometry via a Convenient and Quantitative Methylation Strategy

Orthogonal separation techniques coupled to high-resolution mass spectrometry are required for characterizing the human lipidome, given its inherent chemical and structural complexity. However, electrophoretic separations remain largely unrecognized in contemporary lipidomics research compared to established chromatographic and ion mobility methods. Herein, we introduce a novel derivatization protocol based on 3-methyl-1-p-tolyltriazene (MTT) as a safer alternative to diazomethane for quantitative phospholipid (PL) methylation (∼90%), which enables their rapid analysis by multisegment injection-nonaqueous capillary electrophoresis-mass spectrometry (MSI-NACE-MS). Isobaric interferences and ion suppression effects were minimized by performing an initial reaction using 9-fluorenylmethyoxycarbonyl chloride prior to MTT and a subsequent back extraction in hexane. This charge-switch derivatization strategy expands lipidome coverage when using MSI-NACE-MS under positive ion mode with improved resolution, greater sensitivity, and higher throughput (∼3.5 min/sample), notably for zwitterionic PLs that are analyzed as their cationic phosphate methyl esters. Our method was validated by analyzing methyl-tert-butyl ether extracts of reference human plasma, which enabled a direct comparison of 48 phosphatidylcholine and 27 sphingomyelin species previously reported in an interlaboratory lipidomics harmonization study. The potential for plasma PL quantification by MSI-NACE-MS via a serial dilution of NIST SRM-1950 was also demonstrated based on estimation of relative response factors using their reported consensus concentrations. Moreover, lipid identification was supported by modeling predictable changes in the electrophoretic mobility for cationic PLs in conjunction with MS/MS. Overall, this work offers a practical derivatization protocol to expand lipidome coverage in CE-MS beyond the analysis of hydrophilic/polar metabolites under aqueous buffer conditions.

Recent Advances in Gas-phase Ion/Ion Chemistry for Lipid Analysis

Gas-phase ion/ion reactions can be used to alter analyte ion-types for subsequent dissociation both quickly and efficiently without the need for altering analyte ionization conditions. This capability can be particularly useful when the ion-type that is most efficiently generated by the ionization method at hand does not provide the structural information of interest using available dissociation methods. This situation often arises in the analysis of lipids, which constitute a diverse array of chemical species with many possibilities for isomers. Gas-phase ion/ion reactions have been demonstrated to be capable of enhancing the ability of tandem mass spectrometry to characterize the structures of various lipid classes. This review summarizes progress to date in the application of gas-phase ion/ion reactions to lipid structural characterization.

Options of the Main Derivatization Approaches for Analytical ESI and MALDI Mass Spectrometry

The inclusion of preliminary chemical labeling (derivatization) in the analysis process by such powerful and widespread methods as electrospray ionization (ESI) and matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization (MALDI) mass spectrometry (MS) is a popular and widely used methodological approach. This is due to the need to remove some fundamental limitations inherent in these powerful analytic methods. Although a number of special reviews has been published discussing the utilization of derivatization approaches, the purpose of the present critical review is to comprehensively summarize, characterize and evaluate most of the previously developed and practically applied, as well as recently proposed representative derivatization reagents for ESI-MS and MALDI-MS platforms in their mostly sensitive positive ion mode and frequently hyphenated with separation techniques. The review is focused on the use of preliminary chemical labeling to facilitate the detection, identification, structure elucidation, quantification, profiling or MS imaging of compounds within complex matrices. Two main derivatization approaches, namely the introduction of permanent charge-fixed or highly proton affinitive residues into analytes are critically evaluated. In situ charge-generation, charge-switch and charge-transfer derivatizations are considered separately. The potential of using reactive matrices in MALDI-MS and chemical labeling in MS-based omics sciences is given.

iTrEnDi: In Situ Trimethylation Enhancement Using Diazomethane: Improved and Expanded Glycerophospholipid and Sphingolipid Analyses via a Microscale Autonomous Derivatization Platform

Trimethylation enhancement using diazomethane (TrEnDi) is a derivatization technique that significantly enhances the signal intensity of glycerophospholipid species in mass spectrometry (MS) and tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) analyses. Here, we describe a novel apparatus that is able to conduct in situ TrEnDi (iTrEnDi) by generating and immediately reacting small amounts of gaseous diazoalkane with analyte molecules. iTrEnDi allows complete and rapid methylation of phosphatidylcholine (PC), phosphatidylethanolamine (PE), phosphatidic acid (PA), and sphingomyelin (SM) in a safe manner by removing any need for direct handling of dangerous diazoalkane solutions. iTrEnDi-modified PC ([PC^Tr]⁺) and PE ([PE^Tr]⁺) showed similar sensitivity enhancements and fragmentation patterns compared to our previously reported methodology. iTrEnDi yielded dimethylated PA ([PA^Tr]), which exhibited dramatically improved chromatographic behavior and a 14-fold increase in liquid chromatography MS (LCMS) sensitivity compared to unmodified PA. In comparison to in-solution-based TrEnDi, iTrEnDi demonstrated a modest decrease in sensitivity, likely due to analyte losses during handling. However, the enhanced safety benefits of iTrEnDi coupled with its ease of use and capacity for automation, as well as its accommodation of more-reactive diazoalkane species, vastly improve the accessibility and utility of this derivatization technique. Finally, as a proof of concept, iTrEnDi was used to produce diazoethane (DZE), a more-reactive diazoalkane than diazomethane. Reaction between DZE and PC yielded ethylated [PC^Tr]⁺, which fragmented via MS/MS to produce a high-intensity characteristic fragment ion, enabling a novel and highly sensitive precursor ion scan.

Enhancing detection and characterization of lipids using charge manipulation in electrospray ionization-tandem mass spectrometry

Heightened awareness regarding the implication of disturbances in lipid metabolism with respect to prevalent human-related pathologies demands analytical techniques that provide unambiguous structural characterization and accurate quantitation of lipids in complex biological samples. The diversity in molecular structures of lipids along with their wide range of concentrations in biological matrices present formidable analytical challenges. Modern mass spectrometry (MS) offers an unprecedented level of analytical power in lipid analysis, as many advancements in the field of lipidomics have been facilitated through novel applications of and developments in electrospray ionization tandem mass spectrometry (ESI-MS/MS). ESI allows for the formation of intact lipid ions with little to no fragmentation and has become widely used in contemporary lipidomics experiments due to its sensitivity, reproducibility, and compatibility with condensed-phase modes of separation, such as liquid chromatography (LC). Owing to variations in lipid functional groups, ESI enables partial chemical separation of the lipidome, yet the preferred ion-type is not always formed, impacting lipid detection, characterization, and quantitation. Moreover, conventional ESI-MS/MS approaches often fail to expose diverse subtle structural features like the sites of unsaturation in fatty acyl constituents or acyl chain regiochemistry along the glycerol backbone, representing a significant challenge for ESI-MS/MS. To overcome these shortcomings, various charge manipulation strategies, including charge-switching, have been developed to transform ion-type and charge state, with aims of increasing sensitivity and selectivity of ESI-MS/MS approaches. Importantly, charge manipulation approaches afford enhanced ionization efficiency, improved mixture analysis performance, and access to informative fragmentation channels. Herein, we present a critical review of the current suite of solution-based and gas-phase strategies for the manipulation of lipid ion charge and type relevant to ESI-MS/MS.

Coupling Headgroup and Alkene Specific Solution Modifications with Gas-Phase Ion/Ion Reactions for Sensitive Glycerophospholipid Identification and Characterization

Shotgun lipidomics provides sensitive and fast lipid identification without the need for chromatographic separation. Challenges faced by shotgun analysis of glycerophospholipids (GPs) include the lack of signal uniformity across GP classes and the inability to determine the carbon-carbon double bond (C═C) location within the fatty acyl chains of an unsaturated species. Two distinct derivatization strategies were employed to both enhance the ionization of GPs, via trimethylation enhancement using ¹³C-diazomethane (¹³C-TrEnDi), as well as determine location of double bonds within fatty acyl chains, employing an in-solution photochemical reaction with acetone (via the Paternò-Büchi reaction). The modified GPs were then subjected to positive ion mode ionization via electrospray ionization, producing uniform ionization efficiencies for different classes of GP species. The GPs were charge inverted via gas-phase ion/ion reactions and sequentially fragmented using ion trap collision-induced dissociation (CID). The CID of the species led to fragmentation producing diagnostic ions indicative of C═C bond location. The approach enabled enhanced ionization and the identification of phosphatidylcholine and phosphatidylethanolamine species at the C═C level in a bovine lipid extract.