Pulse EPR Spectroscopic Characterization of the S3 State of the Oxygen-Evolving Complex of Photosystem II Isolated from Synechocystis

Independent Mutation of Two Bridging Carboxylate Ligands Stabilizes Alternate Conformers of the Photosynthetic O2-Evolving Mn4CaO5 Cluster in Photosystem II

The O2-evolving Mn4CaO5 cluster in photosystem II is ligated by six carboxylate residues. One of these is D170 of the D1 subunit. This carboxylate bridges between one Mn ion (Mn4) and the Ca ion. A second carboxylate ligand is D342 of the D1 subunit. This carboxylate bridges between two Mn ions (Mn1 and Mn2). D170 and D342 are located on opposite sides of the Mn4CaO5 cluster. Recently, it was shown that the D170E mutation perturbs both the intricate networks of H-bonds that surround the Mn4CaO5 cluster and the equilibrium between different conformers of the cluster in two of its lower oxidation states, S1 and S2, while still supporting O2 evolution at approximately 50% the rate of the wild type. In this study, we show that the D342E mutation produces much the same alterations to the cluster's FTIR and EPR spectra as D170E, while still supporting O2 evolution at approximately 20% the rate of the wild type. Furthermore, the double mutation, D170E + D342E, behaves similarly to the two single mutations. We conclude that D342E alters the equilibrium between different conformers of the cluster in its S1 and S2 states in the same manner as D170E and perturbs the H-bond networks in a similar fashion. This is the second identification of a Mn4CaO5 metal ligand whose mutation influences the equilibrium between the different conformers of the S1 and S2 states without eliminating O2 evolution. This finding has implications for our understanding of the mechanism of O2 formation in terms of catalytically active/inactive conformations of the Mn4CaO5 cluster in its lower oxidation states.

Nature of S-States in the Oxygen-Evolving Complex Resolved by High-Energy Resolution Fluorescence Detected X-ray Absorption Spectroscopy

Photosystem II, the water splitting enzyme of photosynthesis, utilizes the energy of sunlight to drive the four-electron oxidation of water to dioxygen at the oxygen-evolving complex (OEC). The OEC harbors a Mn4CaO5 cluster that cycles through five oxidation states Si (i = 0-4). The S3 state is the last metastable state before the O2 evolution. Its electronic structure and nature of the S2 → S3 transition are key topics of persisting controversy. Most spectroscopic studies suggest that the S3 state consists of four Mn(IV) ions, compared to the Mn(III)Mn(IV)3 of the S2 state. However, recent crystallographic data have received conflicting interpretations, suggesting either metal- or ligand-based oxidation, the latter leading to an oxyl radical or a peroxo moiety in the S3 state. Herein, we utilize high-energy resolution fluorescence detected (HERFD) X-ray absorption spectroscopy to obtain a highly resolved description of the Mn K pre-edge region for all S-states, paying special attention to use chemically unperturbed S3 state samples. In combination with quantum chemical calculations, we achieve assignment of specific spectroscopic features to geometric and electronic structures for all S-states. These data are used to confidently discriminate between the various suggestions concerning the electronic structure and the nature of oxidation events in all observable catalytic intermediates of the OEC. Our results do not support the presence of either peroxo or oxyl in the active configuration of the S3 state. This establishes Mn-centered storage of oxidative equivalents in all observable catalytic transitions and constrains the onset of the O-O bond formation until after the final light-driven oxidation event.

Does Serial Femtosecond Crystallography Depict State-Specific Catalytic Intermediates of the Oxygen-Evolving Complex?

Recent advances in serial femtosecond crystallography (SFX) of photosystem II (PSII), enabled by X-ray free electron lasers (XFEL), provided the first geometric models of distinct intermediates in the catalytic S-state cycle of the oxygen-evolving complex (OEC). These models are obtained by flash-advancing the OEC from the dark-stable state (S₁) to more oxidized intermediates (S₂ and S₃), eventually cycling back to the most reduced S₀. However, the interpretation of these models is controversial because geometric parameters within the Mn₄CaO₅ cluster of the OEC do not exactly match those expected from coordination chemistry for the spectroscopically verified manganese oxidation states of the distinct S-state intermediates. Here we focus on the first catalytic transition, S₁ → S₂, which represents a one-electron oxidation of the OEC. Combining geometric and electronic structure criteria, including a novel effective oxidation state approach, we analyze existing 1-flash (1F) SFX-XFEL crystallographic models that should depict the S₂ state of the OEC. We show that the 1F/S₂ equivalence is not obvious, because the Mn oxidation states and total unpaired electron counts encoded in these models are not fully consistent with those of a pure S₂ state and with the nature of the S₁ → S₂ transition. Furthermore, the oxidation state definition in two-flashed (2F) structural models is practically impossible to elucidate. Our results advise caution in the extraction of electronic structure information solely from the literal interpretation of crystallographic models and call for re-evaluation of structural and mechanistic interpretations that presume exact correspondence of such models to specific catalytic intermediates of the OEC.

MnIV4O4 Model of the S3 Intermediate of the Oxygen-Evolving Complex: Effect of the Dianionic Disiloxide Ligand

Synthetic complexes provide useful models to study the interplay between the structure and spectroscopy of the different Sn-state intermediates of the oxygen-evolving complex (OEC) of photosystem II (PSII). Complexes containing the MnIV4 core corresponding to the S3 state, the last observable intermediate prior to dioxygen formation, remain very rare. Toward the development of synthetic strategies to stabilize highly oxidized tetranuclear complexes, ligands with increased anion charge were pursued. Herein, we report the synthesis, electrochemistry, SQUID magnetometry, and electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy of a stable MnIV4O4 cuboidal complex supported by a disiloxide ligand. The substitution of an anionic acetate or amidate ligand with a dianionic disiloxide ligand shifts the reduction potential of the MnIIIMnIV3/MnIV4 redox couple by up to ∼760 mV, improving stability. The S = 3 spin ground state of the siloxide-ligated MnIV4O4 complex matches the acetate and amidate variants, in corroboration with the MnIV4 assignment of the S3 state of the OEC.

Water oxidation in oxygenic photosynthesis studied by magnetic resonance techniques

The understanding of light-induced biological water oxidation in oxygenic photosynthesis is of great importance both for biology and (bio)technological applications. The chemically difficult multistep reaction takes place at a unique protein-bound tetra-manganese/calcium cluster in photosystem II whose structure has been elucidated by X-ray crystallography (Umena et al. Nature 2011, 473, 55). The cluster moves through several intermediate states in the catalytic cycle. A detailed understanding of these intermediates requires information about the spatial and electronic structure of the Mn₄ Ca complex; the latter is only available from spectroscopic techniques. Here, the important role of Electron Paramagnetic Resonance (EPR) and related double resonance techniques (ENDOR, EDNMR), complemented by quantum chemical calculations, is described. This has led to the elucidation of the cluster's redox and protonation states, the valence and spin states of the manganese ions and the interactions between them, and contributed substantially to the understanding of the role of the protein surrounding, as well as the binding and processing of the substrate water molecules, the O-O bond formation and dioxygen release. Based on these data, models for the water oxidation cycle are developed.

Magnetic and Electronic Structural Properties of the S3 State of Nature's Water Oxidizing Complex: A Combined Study in ELDOR-Detected Nuclear Magnetic Resonance Spectral Simulation and Broken-Symmetry Density Functional Theory

ELDOR-detected nuclear magnetic resonance (EDNMR) spectral simulations combined with broken-symmetry density functional theory (BS-DFT) calculations are used to obtain and to assign the ⁵⁵Mn hyperfine coupling constants (hfcs) for modified forms of the water oxidizing complex in the penultimate S₃ state of the water oxidation cycle. The study shows that an open cubane form of the core Mn₄CaO₆ cluster explains the magnetic properties of the dominant S = 3 species in all cases studied experimentally with no need to invoke a closed cubane intermediate possessing a distorted pentacoordinate Mn₄ ion as recently suggested. EDNMR simulations found that both the experimental bandwidth and multinuclear transitions may alter relative EDNMR peak intensities, potentially leading to incorrect assignment of hfcs. The implications of these findings for the water oxidation mechanism are discussed.

Mimicking the Oxygen-Evolving Center in Photosynthesis

The oxygen-evolving center (OEC) in photosystem II (PSII) of oxygenic photosynthetic organisms is a unique heterometallic-oxide Mn4CaO5-cluster that catalyzes water splitting into electrons, protons, and molecular oxygen through a five-state cycle (Sn, n = 0 ~ 4). It serves as the blueprint for the developing of the man-made water-splitting catalysts to generate solar fuel in artificial photosynthesis. Understanding the structure-function relationship of this natural catalyst is a great challenge and a long-standing issue, which is severely restricted by the lack of a precise chemical model for this heterometallic-oxide cluster. However, it is a great challenge for chemists to precisely mimic the OEC in a laboratory. Recently, significant advances have been achieved and a series of artificial Mn4XO4-clusters (X = Ca/Y/Gd) have been reported, which closely mimic both the geometric structure and the electronic structure, as well as the redox property of the OEC. These new advances provide a structurally well-defined molecular platform to study the structure-function relationship of the OEC and shed new light on the design of efficient catalysts for the water-splitting reaction in artificial photosynthesis.

Probing the proton release by Photosystem II in the S1 to S2 high-spin transition

The stoichiometry and kinetics of the proton release were investigated during each transition of the S-state cycle in Photosystem II (PSII) from Thermosynechococcus elongatus containing either a Mn₄CaO₅ (PSII/Ca) or a Mn₄SrO₅ (PSII/Sr) cluster. The measurements were done at pH 6.0 and pH 7.0 knowing that, in PSII/Ca at pH 6.0 and pH 7.0 and in PSII/Sr at pH 6.0, the flash-induced S₂-state is in a low-spin configuration (S₂^LS) whereas in PSII/Sr at pH 7.0, the S₂-state is in a high-spin configuration (S₂^HS) in half of the centers. Two measurements were done; the time-resolved flash dependent i) absorption of either bromocresol purple at pH 6.0 or neutral red at pH 7.0 and ii) electrochromism in the Soret band of P_D1 at 440 nm. The fittings of the oscillations with a period of four indicate that one proton is released in the S₁ to S₂^HS transition in PSII/Sr at pH 7.0. It has previously been suggested that the proton released in the S₂^LS to S₃ transition would be released in a S₂^LSTyr_Z^• → S₂^HSTyr_Z^• transition before the electron transfer from the cluster to Tyr_Z^• occurs. The release of a proton in the S₁Tyr_Z^• → S₂^HSTyr_Z transition would logically imply that this proton release is missing in the S₂^HSTyr_Z^• to S₃Tyr_Z transition. Instead, the proton release in the S₁ to S₂^HS transition in PSII/Sr at pH 7.0 was mainly done at the expense of the proton release in the S₃ to S₀ and S₀ to S₁ transitions. However, at pH 7.0, the electrochromism of P_D1 seems larger in PSII/Sr when compared to PSII/Ca in the S₃ state. This points to the complex link between proton movements in and immediately around the Mn₄ cluster and the mechanism leading to the release of protons into the bulk.

Alteration of the O2-Producing Mn4Ca Cluster in Photosystem II by the Mutation of a Metal Ligand

The O₂-evolving Mn₄Ca cluster in photosystem II (PSII) is arranged as a distorted Mn₃Ca cube that is linked to a fourth Mn ion (denoted as Mn4) by two oxo bridges. The Mn4 and Ca ions are bridged by residue D1-D170. This is also the only residue known to participate in the high-affinity Mn(II) site that participates in the light-driven assembly of the Mn₄Ca cluster. In this study, we use Fourier transform infrared difference spectroscopy to characterize the impact of the D1-D170E mutation. On the basis of analyses of carboxylate and carbonyl stretching modes and the O-H stretching modes of hydrogen-bonded water molecules, we show that this mutation alters the extensive network of hydrogen bonds that surrounds the Mn₄Ca cluster in the same manner as that of many other mutations. It also alters the equilibrium between conformers of the Mn₄Ca cluster in the dark-stable S₁ state so that a high-spin form of the S₂ state is produced during the S₁-to-S₂ transition instead of the low-spin form that gives rise to the S₂ state multiline electron paramagnetic resonance signal. The mutation may also change the coordination mode of the carboxylate group at position 170 to unidentate ligation of Mn4. This is the first mutation of a metal ligand in PSII that substantially impacts the spectroscopic signatures of the Mn₄Ca cluster without substantially eliminating O₂ evolution. The results have significant implications for our understanding of the roles of alternate active/inactive conformers of the Mn₄Ca cluster in the mechanism of O₂ formation.

S3 State Models of Nature's Water Oxidizing Complex: Analysis of Bonding and Magnetic Exchange Pathways, Assessment of Experimental Electron Paramagnetic Resonance Data, and Implications for the Water Oxidation Mechanism

Broken symmetry density functional theory (BS-DFT) calculations on large models of Nature's water oxidizing complex (WOC) are used to investigate the electronic structure and associated magnetic interactions of this key intermediate state. The electronic origins of the ferromagnetic and antiferromagnetic couplings between neighboring Mn ions are investigated and illustrated by using corresponding orbital transformations. Protonation of the O4 and/or O6 atoms leads to large variation in the distribution of spin around the complex with associated changes in its magnetic resonance properties. Models for Sr²⁺ exchange and methanol addition indicate minor perturbations reflected in slightly altered spin projection coefficients for the Mn₁ and Mn₂ ions. These are shown to account for the observed changes observed experimentally via electron paramagnetic resonance methods and suggest a reinterpretation of the experimental findings. By comparison with experimental determinations, we show that the spin projections and resulting calculated ⁵⁵Mn hyperfine couplings support the open cubane form of an oxo (O5)-hydroxo (O6) cluster in all cases with no need to invoke a closed cubane intermediate. The implications of these findings for the water oxidation mechanism are discussed.

Redox Isomerism in the S3 State of the Oxygen-Evolving Complex Resolved by Coupled Cluster Theory

The electronic and geometric structures of the water-oxidizing complex of photosystem II in the steps of the catalytic cycle that precede dioxygen evolution remain hotly debated. Recent structural and spectroscopic investigations support contradictory redox formulations for the active-site Mn4 CaOx cofactor in the final metastable S3 state. These range from the widely accepted MnIV 4 oxo-hydroxo model, which presumes that O-O bond formation occurs in the ultimate transient intermediate (S4 ) of the catalytic cycle, to a MnIII 2 MnIV 2 peroxo model representative of the contrasting "early-onset" O-O bond formation hypothesis. Density functional theory energetics of suggested S3 redox isomers are inconclusive because of extreme functional dependence. Here, we use the power of the domain-based local pair natural orbital approach to coupled cluster theory, DLPNO-CCSD(T), to present the first correlated wave function theory calculations of relative stabilities for distinct redox-isomeric forms of the S3 state. Our results enabled us to evaluate conflicting models for the S3 state of the oxygen-evolving complex (OEC) and to quantify the accuracy of lower-level theoretical approaches. Our assessment of the relevance of distinct redox-isomeric forms for the mechanism of biological water oxidation strongly disfavors the scenario of early-onset O-O formation advanced by literal interpretations of certain crystallographic models. This work serves as a case study in the application of modern coupled cluster implementations to redox isomerism problems in oligonuclear transition metal systems.

CaMn3 IV O4 Cubane Models of the Oxygen-Evolving Complex: Spin Ground States S<9/2 and the Effect of Oxo Protonation

We report the single crystal XRD and MicroED structure, magnetic susceptibility, and EPR data of a series of CaMn₃ ^IV O₄ and YMn₃ ^IV O₄ complexes as structural and spectroscopic models of the cuboidal subunit of the oxygen-evolving complex (OEC). The effect of changes in heterometal identity, cluster geometry, and bridging oxo protonation on the spin-state structure was investigated. In contrast to previous computational models, we show that the spin ground state of CaMn₃ ^IV O₄ complexes and variants with protonated oxo moieties need not be S=9/2. Desymmetrization of the pseudo-C₃ -symmetric Ca(Y)Mn₃ ^IV O₄ core leads to a lower S=5/2 spin ground state. The magnitude of the magnetic exchange coupling is attenuated upon oxo protonation, and an S=3/2 spin ground state is observed in CaMn₃ ^IV O₃ (OH). Our studies complement the observation that the interconversion between the low-spin and high-spin forms of the S₂ state is pH-dependent, suggesting that the (de)protonation of bridging or terminal oxygen atoms in the OEC may be connected to spin-state changes.

Orientational Jahn-Teller Isomerism in the Dark-Stable State of Nature's Water Oxidase

The tetramanganese–calcium cluster of the oxygen‐evolving complex of photosystem II adopts electronically and magnetically distinct but interconvertible valence isomeric forms in its first light‐driven oxidized catalytic state, S₂. This bistability is implicated in gating the final catalytic states preceding O−O bond formation, but it is unknown how the biological system enables its emergence and controls its effect. Here we show that the Mn₄CaO₅ cluster in the resting (dark‐stable) S₁ state adopts orientational Jahn–Teller isomeric forms arising from a directional change in electronic configuration of the “dangler” Mn^III ion. The isomers are consistent with available structural data and explain previously unresolved electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopic observations on the S₁ state. This unique isomerism in the resting state is shown to be the electronic origin of valence isomerism in the S₂ state, establishing a functional role of orientational Jahn–Teller isomerism unprecedented in biological or artificial catalysis.

Successes, challenges, and opportunities for quantum chemistry in understanding metalloenzymes for solar fuels research

Overview of the rich and diverse contributions of quantum chemistry to understanding the structure and function of the biological archetypes for solar fuel research, photosystem II and hydrogenases.