Partial Opening of Cytochrome P450cam (CYP101A1) Is Driven by Allostery and Putidaredoxin Binding

3site Multisubstrate-Bound State of Cytochrome P450cam

We identified a multisubstrate-bound state, hereby referred as a 3site state, in cytochrome P450cam via integrating molecular dynamics simulation with nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) pseudocontact shift measurements. The 3site state is a result of simultaneous binding of three camphor molecules in three locations around P450cam: (a) in a well-established "catalytic" site near heme, (b) in a kink-separated "waiting" site along channel-1, and (c) in a previously reported "allosteric" site at E, F, G, and H helical junctions. These three spatially distinct binding modes in the 3site state mutually communicate with each other via homotropic allostery and act cooperatively to render P450cam functional. The 3site state shows a significantly superior fit with NMR pseudo contact shift (PCS) data with a Q-score of 0.045 than previously known bound states and consists of D251 free of salt-bridges with K178 and R186, rendering the enzyme functionally primed. To date, none of the reported cocomplex of P450cam with its redox partner putidaredoxin (pdx) has been able to match solution NMR data and controversial pdx-induced opening of P450cam's channel-1 remains a matter of recurrent discourse. In this regard, inclusion of pdx to the 3site state is able to perfectly fit the NMR PCS measurement with a Q-score of 0.08 and disfavors the pdx-induced opening of channel-1, reconciling previously unexplained remarkably fast hydroxylation kinetics with a koff of 10.2 s-1. Together, our findings hint that previous experimental observations may have inadvertently captured the 3site state as an in vitro solution state, instead of the catalytic state alone, and provided a distinct departure from the conventional understanding of cytochrome P450.

Conformational heterogeneity suggests multiple substrate binding modes in CYP106A2

CYP106A2 (cytochrome P450meg) is a bacterial enzyme originally isolated from B. megaterium, and has been shown to hydroxylate a wide variety of substrates, including steroids. The regio- and stereochemistry of CYP106A2 hydroxylation has been shown to be dependent on a variety of factors, and hydroxylation often occurs at more than one site and/or with lack of stereospecificity for some substrates. Comprehensive backbone 15N, 1H and 13C resonance assignments based on multidimensional nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) experiments performed with uniform and selective isotopically labeled CYP106A2 samples are reported herein, and broadening and splitting of resonances assigned to regions of the enzyme shown to be affected by substrate binding in other P450 enzymes indicate that substrate binding does not reduce structural heterogeneity as has been observed previously in P450 enzymes CYP101A1 and MycG. Paramagnetic relaxation enhancement (PRE) due to proximity between substrate protons and the heme iron were measured for three different substrates, and the relatively uniform nature of the PREs support the proposal that multiple substrate binding modes are occupied at saturating substrate concentrations.

Cooperative Substrate Binding Controls Catalysis in Bacterial Cytochrome P450terp (CYP108A1)

Despite being one of the most well-studied aspects of cytochrome P450 chemistry, important questions remain regarding the nature and ubiquity of allosteric regulation of catalysis. The crystal structure of a bacterial P450, P450terp, in the presence of substrate reveals two binding sites, one above the heme in position for regioselective hydroxylation and another in the substrate access channel. Unlike many bacterial P450s, P450terp does not exhibit an open to closed conformational change when substrate binds; instead, P450terp uses the second substrate molecule to hold the first substrate molecule in position for catalysis. Spectral titrations clearly show that substrate binding to P450terp is cooperative with a Hill coefficient of 1.4 and is supported by isothermal titration calorimetry. The importance of the allosteric site was explored by a series of mutations that weaken the second site and that help hold the first substrate in position for proper catalysis. We further measured the coupling efficiency of both the wild-type (WT) enzyme and the mutant enzymes. While the WT enzyme exhibits 97% efficiency, each of the variants showed lower catalytic efficiency. Additionally, the variants show decreased spin shifts upon binding of substrate. These results are the first clear example of positive homotropic allostery in a class 1 bacterial P450 with its natural substrate. Combined with our recent results from P450cam showing complex substrate allostery and conformational dynamics, our present study with P450terp indicates that bacterial P450s may not be as simple as once thought and share complex substrate binding properties usually associated with only mammalian P450s.

Hydroxylation Regiochemistry Is Robust to Active Site Mutations in Cytochrome P450cam (CYP101A1)

Cytochrome P450_cam (CYP101A1) catalyzes the hydroxylation of d-camphor by molecular oxygen. The enzyme-catalyzed hydroxylation exhibits a high degree of regioselectivity and stereoselectivity, with a single major product, d-5-exo-hydroxycamphor, suggesting that the substrate is oriented to facilitate this specificity. In previous work, we used an elastic network model and perturbation response scanning to show that normal deformation modes of the enzyme structure are highly responsive not only to the presence of a substrate but also to the substrate orientation. This work examines the effects of mutations near the active site on substrate localization and orientation. The investigated mutations were designed to promote a change in substrate orientation and/or location that might give rise to different hydroxylation products, while maintaining the same carbon and oxygen atom balances as in the wild type (WT) enzyme. Computational experiments and parallel in vitro site-directed mutations of CYP101A1 were used to examine reaction products and enzyme activity. ¹H-¹⁵N TROSY-HSQC correlation maps were used to compare the computational results with detectable perturbations in the enzyme structure and dynamics. We found that all of the mutant enzymes retained the same regio- and stereospecificity of hydroxylation as the WT enzyme, with varying degrees of efficiency, which suggests that large portions of the enzyme have been subjected to evolutionary pressure to arrive at the appropriate sequence-structure combination for efficient 5-exo hydroxylation of camphor.

Updating the Paradigm: Redox Partner Binding and Conformational Dynamics in Cytochromes P450

This Account summarizes recent findings centered on the role that redox partner binding, allostery, and conformational dynamics plays in cytochrome P450 proton coupled electron transfer. P450s are one of Nature's largest enzyme families and it is not uncommon to find a P450 wherever substrate oxidation is required in the formation of essential molecules critical to the life of the organism or in xenobiotic detoxification. P450s can operate on a remarkably large range of substrates from the very small to the very large, yet the overall P450 three-dimensional structure is conserved. Given this conservation of structure, it is generally assumed that the basic catalytic mechanism is conserved. In nearly all P450s, the O₂ O-O bond must be cleaved heterolytically enabling one oxygen atom, the distal oxygen, to depart as water and leave behind a heme iron-linked O atom as the powerful oxidant that is used to activate the nearby substrate. For this process to proceed efficiently, externally supplied electrons and protons are required. Two protons must be added to the departing O atom while an electron is transferred from a redox partner that typically contains either a Fe₂S₂ or FMN redox center. The paradigm P450 used to unravel the details of these mechanisms has been the bacterial CYP101A1 or P450cam. P450cam is specific for its own Fe₂S₂ redox partner, putidaredoxin or Pdx, and it has long been postulated that Pdx plays an effector/allosteric role by possibly switching P450cam to an active conformation. Crystal structures, spectroscopic data, and direct binding experiments of the P450cam-Pdx complex provide some answers. Pdx shifts the conformation of P450cam to a more open state, a transition that is postulated to trigger the proton relay network required for O₂ activation. An essential part of this proton relay network is a highly conserved Asp (sometimes Glu) that is known to be critical for activity in a number of P450s. How this Asp and proton delivery networks are connected to redox partner binding is quite simple. In the closed state, this Asp is tied down by salt bridges, but these salt bridges are ruptured when Pdx binds, leaving the Asp free to serve its role in proton transfer. An alternative hypothesis suggests that a specific proton relay network is not really necessary. In this scenario, the Asp plays a structural role in the open/close transition and merely opening the active site access channel is sufficient to enable solvent protons in for O₂ protonation. Experiments designed to test these various hypotheses have revealed some surprises in both P450cam and other bacterial P450s. Molecular dynamics and crystallography show that P450cam can undergo rather significant conformational gymnastics that result in a large restructuring of the active site requiring multiple cis/trans proline isomerizations. It also has been found that X-ray driven substrate hydroxylation is a useful tool for better understanding the role that the essential Asp and surrounding residues play in catalysis. Here we summarize these recent results which provide a much more dynamic picture of P450 catalysis.