Distinct Structural Elements Govern the Folding, Stability, and Catalysis in the Outer Membrane Enzyme PagP

Evolutionary selection of a 19-stranded mitochondrial β-barrel scaffold bears structural and functional significance

Transmembrane β-barrels of eukaryotic outer mitochondrial membranes (OMMs) are major channels of communication between the cytosol and mitochondria and are indispensable for cellular homeostasis. A structurally intriguing exception to all known transmembrane β-barrels is the unique odd-stranded, i.e. 19-stranded, structures found solely in the OMM. The molecular origins of this 19-stranded structure and its associated functional significance are unclear. In humans, the most abundant OMM transporter is the voltage-dependent anion channel. Here, using the human voltage-dependent anion channel as our template scaffold, we designed and engineered odd- and even-stranded structures of smaller (V2¹⁶, V2¹⁷, V2¹⁸) and larger (V2²⁰, V2²¹) barrel diameters. Determination of the structure, dynamics, and energetics of these engineered structures in bilayer membranes reveals that the 19-stranded barrel surprisingly holds modest to low stability in a lipid-dependent manner. However, we demonstrate that this structurally metastable protein possesses superior voltage-gated channel regulation, efficient mitochondrial targeting, and in vivo cell survival, with lipid-modulated stability, all of which supersede the occurrence of a metastable 19-stranded scaffold. We propose that the unique structural adaptation of these transmembrane transporters exclusively in mitochondria bears strong evolutionary basis and is functionally significant for homeostasis.

Molecular Switch between Structural Compaction and Thermodynamic Stability by the Xxx-Pro Interface in Transmembrane β-Barrels

Transmembrane β-barrel scaffolds found in outer membrane proteins are formed and stabilized by a defined pattern of interstrand intraprotein H-bonds, in hydrophobic lipid bilayers. Introducing the conformationally constrained proline in β-barrels can cause significant destabilization of these structural regions that require H-bonding, with proline additionally acting as a secondary structure breaker. Membrane protein β-barrels are therefore expected to show poor tolerance to the presence of a transmembrane proline. Here, we assign a thermodynamic measure for the extent to which a single proline can be tolerated at the C-terminal interface of the model transmembrane β-barrel PagP. We find that proline drastically destabilizes PagP by 7.0 kcal mol^-1 with respect to wild-type PagP (F¹⁶¹ → P¹⁶¹). Interestingly, strategic modulation of the preceding residue can modify the measured energetics. Placing a hydrophobic or bulky side chain as the preceding residue increases the thermodynamic stability by ≤8.0 kcal mol^-1. While polar substituents at the preceding residue decrease the PagP stability, these residues demonstrate stronger tertiary packing interactions in the barrel and retain the catalytic activity of native PagP. This biophysical interplay between enhanced thermodynamic stability and attaining a structurally compact functional β-barrel scaffold highlights the detrimental effect caused by proline incorporation. Our findings also reveal alternative mechanisms that protein sequences can employ to salvage the structural integrity of transmembrane protein structures.

Reversible folding energetics of Yersinia Ail barrel reveals a hyperfluorescent intermediate

Deducing the molecular details of membrane protein folding has lately become an important area of research in biology. Using Ail, an outer membrane protein (OMP) from Yersina pestis as our model, we explore details of β-barrel folding, stability, and unfolding. Ail displays a simple transmembrane β-barrel topology. Here, we find that Ail follows a simple two-state mechanism in its folding and unfolding thermodynamics. Interestingly, Ail displays multi-step folding kinetics. The early kinetic intermediates in the folding pathway populate near the unfolded state (β_T ≈ 0.20), and do not display detectable changes in the local environment of the two interface indoles. Interestingly, tryptophans regulate the late events of barrel rearrangement, and Ail thermodynamic stability. We show that W¹⁴⁹ → Y/F/A substitution destabilizes Ail by ~0.13-1.7 kcal mol^-1, but retains path-independent thermodynamic equilibrium of Ail. In surprising contrast, substituting W⁴² and retaining W¹⁴⁹ shifts the thermodynamic equilibrium to an apparent kinetic retardation of only the unfolding process, which gives rise to an associated increase in scaffold stability by ~0.3-1.1 kcal mol^-1. This is accompanied by the formation of an unusual hyperfluorescent state in the unfolding pathway that is more structured, and represents a conformationally dynamic unfolding intermediate with the interface W¹⁴⁹ now lipid solvated. The defined role of each tryptophan and poorer folding efficiency of Trp mutants together presents compelling evidence for the importance of interface aromatics in the unique (un)folding pathway of Ail, and offers interesting insight on alternative pathways in generalized OMP assembly and unfolding mechanisms.

Hydrophobic Characteristic Is Energetically Preferred for Cysteine in a Model Membrane Protein

The naturally occurring amino acid cysteine has often been implicated with a crucial role in maintaining protein structure and stability. An intriguing duality in the intrinsic hydrophobicity of the cysteine side chain is that it exhibits both polar as well as hydrophobic characteristics. Here, we have utilized a cysteine-scanning mutational strategy on the transmembrane β-barrel PagP to examine the membrane depth-dependent energetic contribution of the free cysteine side chain (thiolate) versus the parent residue at an experimental pH of 9.5 in phosphatidylcholine vesicles. We find that introduction of cysteine causes destabilization at several of the 26 lipid-facing sites of PagP that we mutated in this study. The destabilization is minimal (0.5-1.5 kcal/mol) when the mutation is toward the bilayer midplane, whereas it is higher in magnitude (3.0-5.0 kcal/mol) near the bilayer interface. These observations suggest that cysteine forms more favorable interactions with the hydrophobic lipid core as compared to the amphiphilic water-lipid interface. The destabilizing effect is more pronounced when cysteine replaces the interfacial aromatics, which are known to participate in tertiary interaction networks in transmembrane β-barrels. Our observations from experiments involving the introduction of cysteine at the bilayer midplane further strengthen previous views that the free cysteine side chain does possess strongly apolar characteristics. Additionally, the free energy changes observed upon cysteine incorporation show a depth-dependent correlation with the estimated energetic cost of partitioning derived from reported hydrophobicity scales. Our results and observations from the thermodynamic analysis of the PagP barrel may explain why cysteine, despite possessing a polar sulfhydryl group, tends to behave as a hydrophobic (rather than polar) residue in folded protein structures.

Transmembrane β-barrels: Evolution, folding and energetics

The biogenesis of transmembrane β-barrels (outer membrane proteins, or OMPs) is an elaborate multistep orchestration of the nascent polypeptide with translocases, barrel assembly machinery, and helper chaperone proteins. Several theories exist that describe the mechanism of chaperone-assisted OMP assembly in vivo and unassisted (spontaneous) folding in vitro. Structurally, OMPs of bacterial origin possess even-numbered strands, while mitochondrial β-barrels are even- and odd-stranded. Several underlying similarities between prokaryotic and eukaryotic β-barrels and their folding machinery are known; yet, the link in their evolutionary origin is unclear. While OMPs exhibit diversity in sequence and function, they share similar biophysical attributes and structure. Similarly, it is important to understand the intricate OMP assembly mechanism, particularly in eukaryotic β-barrels that have evolved to perform more complex functions. Here, we deliberate known facets of β-barrel evolution, folding, and stability, and attempt to highlight outstanding questions in β-barrel biogenesis and proteostasis.