Antimony(V) Incorporation into Schwertmannite: Critical Insights on Antimony Retention in Acidic Environments

Antimony sorption to schwertmannite in acid sulfate environments

Schwertmannite is a poorly-crystalline Fe(III) oxyhydroxysulfate mineral that may control Sb(V) mobility in acid sulfate environments, including acid mine drainage and acid sulfate soils. However, the mechanisms that govern uptake of aqueous Sb(V) by schwertmannite in such environments are poorly understood. To address this issue, we examined Sb(V) sorption to schwertmannite across a range of environmentally-relevant Sb(V) loadings at pH 3 in sulfate-rich solutions. Antimony K-edge extended X-ray absorption fine structure (EXAFS) spectroscopy revealed that Sb(V) sorption (at all loadings) involved edge and double-corner sharing linkages between SbVO6 and FeIIIO6 octahedra. The coordination numbers for these linkages indicate that sorption occurred by Sb(V) incorporation into the schwertmannite structure via heterovalent Sb(V)-for-Fe(III) substitution. As such, Sb(V) sorption to schwertmannite was not limited by the abundance of surface complexation sites and was strongly resistant to desorption when exposed to 0.1 M PO43-. Sorption of Sb(V) also conferred increased stability to schwertmannite, based on changes in the schwertmannite dissolution rate during extraction with an acidic ammonium oxalate solution. This study provides new insights into Sb(V) sorption to schwertmannite in acid sulfate environments, and highlights the role that schwertmannite can play in immobilizing Sb(V) within its crystal structure.

Detecting antimony(III) on-site using novel gel-based techniques: Colorimetric diffusive equilibrium in thin films for two-dimensional imaging and surface-enhanced Raman scattering for sensitive quantification

Antimony (Sb) pollution has raised increasing public concerns and its rapid on-site screening is central for the risk assessment. Herein, we proposed two gel-based methods based on colorimetric diffusive equilibrium in thin films (DET) and surface-enhanced Raman scattering (SERS), for two-dimensional imaging and sensitive detection of Sb(III) by revisiting the phenylfluorone (PhF) complexation reaction. PhF was well dispersed in the polyvinyl alcohol (PVA) hydrogel and reacted with Sb(III) in the DET gel to form a strong PhF-Sb(III) complex. The distribution of Sb(III) was easily visualized at a submillimeter resolution using computer imaging densitometry, with a detection limit (LOD) of ∼100 nmol L-1. Field application in the Sb mine area reveals limited dissolved Sb(III) penetrating the redox barrier below the sediment-water interface by 20 mm in rivers and tailing pond sediments. To improve the detection sensitivity and apply the principle to trace Sb quantification, a SERS platform was established by anchoring PhF on the hydrogel-stabilized Ag nanoparticles via C-O-Ag bonding to specifically detect Raman-inactive Sb(III). Benefiting from the high SERS activity of PhF and enrichment ability of hydrogel, Sb(III) was quantified with a LOD of 1.2-10.7 nmol L-1 depending on the sample volume. The coexisting ions at a 100-fold higher concentration than Sb(III) resulted in only 3.3-10.4 % variation in SERS intensity, indicating a negligible interference on the SERS platform. The platform exhibited a RSD of 6.6-13.1 % and acceptable recoveries for various environmental matrices, highlighting its promise in on-site application.

Sulfidation-reoxidation enhances heavy metal immobilization by vivianite

Iron minerals in nature are pivotal hosts for heavy metals, significantly influencing their geochemical cycling and eventual fate. It is generally accepted that, vivianite, a prevalent iron phosphate mineral in aquatic and terrestrial environments, exhibits a limited capacity for adsorbing cationic heavy metals. However, our study unveils a remarkable phenomenon that the synergistic interaction between sulfide (S2-) and vivianite triggers an unexpected sulfidation-reoxidation process, enhancing the immobilization of heavy metals such as cadmium (Cd), copper (Cu), and zinc (Zn). For instance, the combination of vivianite and S2- boosted the removal of Cd2+ from the aqueous phase under anaerobic conditions, and ensured the retention of Cd stabilized in the solid phase when shifted to aerobic conditions. It is intriguing to note that no discrete FeS formation was detected in the sulfidation phase, and the primary crystal structure of vivianite largely retained its integrity throughout the whole process. Detailed molecular-level investigations indicate that sulfidation predominantly targets the Fe(II) sites at the corners of the PO4 tetrahedron in vivianite. With the transition to aerobic conditions, the exothermic oxidation of CdS and the S sites in vivianite initiates, rendering it thermodynamically favorable for Cd to form multidentate coordination structures, predominantly through the Cd-O-P and Cd-O-Fe bonds. This mechanism elucidates how Cd is incorporated into the vivianite structure, highlighting a novel pathway for heavy metal immobilization via the sulfidation-reoxidation dynamics in iron phosphate minerals.

Effects of Fe(II) bio-oxidation rate and alkali control on schwertmannite microstructure and adsorption of oxyanions: Characteristics, performance and mechanism

Schwertmannite has attracted increasing interest for its excellent sorption of oxyanions such as AsO43-, CrO42-, and Sb(OH)6-. Controlling biomineralization by adjusting the Fe(II) oxidation rate and implementing alkali control can enhance the yield and adsorption performance of schwertmannite. However, the adsorption improvement mechanism is still unclear. The morphology, crystallinity, specific surface area (SSA) and oxyanion adsorption of schwertmannite synthesized with alkali control of solution pH and different Fe(II) oxidation rates were analyzed in this study. The differences in the adsorption mechanisms of As(V), Cr(VI) and Sb(V) on schwertmannite obtained under different synthesis conditions were also studied. Reducing the Fe(II) oxidation rate or maintaining the solution pH through alkali control significantly increased the SSA of schwertmannite and the proportion of outer-sphere sulfate. Alkali-controlled schwertmannite (Sch-C) exhibited superior As(V) and Sb(V) adsorption performance and slightly greater Cr(VI) adsorption than non-alkali-controlled schwertmannite. The As(V) and Sb(V) adsorption capacities of Sch-C greatly improved because the ultra-high SSA increased the surface hydroxyl content and reduced the passivation effect of amorphous precipitates on the mineral surface, allowing continuous sulfate exchange at inner mineral sites. An increased surface hydroxyl content had little effect on Cr(VI) adsorption, but an increased proportion of outer-sphere sulfate caused a slight increase in Cr(VI) adsorption. Sb(V) has a stronger hydroxyl exchange ability than As(V), but due to its octahedral structure, it exchanges only with outer-sphere sulfate on schwertmannite and hardly exchanges with inner-sphere sulfate.

The influence of Mn(II) on transformation of Cr-absorbed Schwertmannite: Mineral phase transition and elemental fate

Schwertmannite (Sch) is considered as an effective remover of Chromium (Cr) due to its strong affinity for toxic Cr species. Since the instability of Sch, the environmental fate of Cr deserves attention during the transformation of Sch into a more stable crystalline phase. The ubiquitous manganese(II) (Mn(II)) probably affects the transformation of Sch and thus the environmental fate of Cr. Therefore, this study investigated the impact of Mn(II) on the transformation of Cr-absorbed Sch (Cr-Sch) and the associated behavior of SO42- and Cr. We revealed that the transformation products of Cr-Sch at pH 3.0 and 7.0 were goethite and Sch, respectively. The presence of Mn(II) weakened the crystallinity of the transformation products, and the trend was positively correlated with the concentration of Mn(II). However, Mn(II) changed the transformation products of Cr-Sch from hematite to goethite at pH 10.0. Mn(II) replaced Fe(III) in the mineral structures or formed Mn-O complexes with surface hydroxyl groups (-OH), thereby affecting the transformation pathways of Sch. The presence of Mn(II) enhanced the immobilization of Cr on minerals at pH 3.0 and 7.0. Sch is likely to provide an channel for electron transfer between Mn(II) and Cr(VI), which promotes the reduction of Cr(VI). Meanwhile, Mn(Ⅱ) induced more -OH production on the surface of secondary minerals, which played an important role in increasing the Cr fixation. In addition, part of the Mn(Ⅱ) was oxidized to Mn(Ⅲ)/Mn(Ⅳ) at pH 3.0 and pH 7.0. This study helps to predict the role of Mn(II) in the transformations of Cr-Sch in environments and design remediation strategies for Cr contamination.

Antimony mobility in soil near historical waste rock at the world's largest Sb mine, Central China

Soil near waste rock often contains high concentrations of antimony (Sb), but the mechanisms that mobilize Sb in a soil closely impacted by the waste rock piles are not well understood. We investigated these mobility mechanisms in soils near historical waste rock at the world's largest Sb mine. The sequential extraction (BCR) of soil reveal that over 95 % Sb is present in the residual fraction. The leached Sb concentration is related to the surface protonation and deprotonation of soil minerals. SEM-EDS shows Sb in the soil is associated with Fe and Ca. Moreover, X-ray absorption spectroscopy (XAS) results show Sb is predominantly present as Sb(V) and is associated with Fe in the form of tripuhyite (FeSbO4) as well as edge- and corner-sharing complexes on ferrihydrite and goethite. Thus, Fe in soils is important in controlling the mobility of Sb via surface complexation and co-precipitation of Sb by Fe oxides. The initially surface-adsorbed Sb(V) or co-precipitation is likely to undergo a phase transformation as the Fe oxides age. In addition, Sb mobility may be controlled by small amounts of calcium antimonate. These results further the understanding of the effect of secondary minerals in soils on the fate of Sb from waste rock weathering and inform source treatment for Sb-contaminated soils.

Investigation of the migration of natural organic matter-iron-antimony nano-colloids in acid mine drainage

Colloids can potentially affect the efficacy of traditional acid mine drainage (AMD) treatment methods such as precipitation and filtration. However, it is unclear how colloids affect antimony (Sb) migration in AMD, especially when natural organic matter (NOM) is present. To conduct an in-depth investigation on the formation and migration behavior of NOM, iron (Fe), Sb and NOM-Fe-Sb colloids in AMD, experiments were performed under simulated AMD conditions. The results demonstrate significant variations in the formation of NOM-Fe-Sb colloids (1-3-450 nm) as the molar ratio of carbon to iron (C/Fe) increases within acidic conditions (pH = 3). Increasing the C/Fe molar ratio from 0.1 to 1.2 resulted in a decrease in colloid formation but an increase in particulate fraction. The distribution of colloidal Sb, Sb(III), and Fe(III) within the NOM-Fe-Sb colloids decreased from 68 % to 55 %, 72 % to 57 %, and 68 % to 55 %, respectively. Their distribution in the particulate fraction increased from 28 % to 42 %, 21 % to 34 %, and 8 % to 27 %. XRD, FTIR, and SEM-EDS analyses demonstrated that NOM facilitates the formation and crystallization of Fe3O4 and FeSbO4 crystalline phases. The formation of the colloids depended on pH. Our results indicate that NOM-Fe-Sb colloids can form when the pH ≤ 4, and the proportion of colloidal Sb fraction within the NOM-Fe-Sb colloids increased from 9 % to a maximum of 73 %. Column experiments show that the concentration of NOM-Fe-Sb colloids reaches its peak and remains stable at approximately 3.5 pore volumes (PVs), facilitating the migration of Sb in the porous media. At pH ≥ 5, stable NOM-Fe-Sb colloids do not form, and the proportion of colloidal Sb fraction decreases from 7 % to 0 %. This implies that as pH increases, the electrostatic repulsion between colloidal particles weakens, resulting in a reduction in the colloidal fraction and an increase in the particulate fraction. At higher pH values (pH ≥ 5), the repulsive forces between colloidal particles nearly disappear, promoting particle aggregation. The findings of this study provide important scientific evidence for understanding the migration behavior of NOM-Fe-Sb colloids in AMD. As the pH gradually shifts from acidic to near-neutral pH during the remediation process of AMD, these results could be applied to develop new strategies for this purpose.

Antimony(V) behavior during the Fe(II)-induced transformation of Sb(V)-bearing natural multicomponent secondary iron mineral under acidic conditions

Fe(II)-induced phase transformations of secondary iron minerals have attracted considerable attention due to their influence on antimony (Sb) mobility. However, Fe(II)-induced natural multicomponent secondary iron mineral (nmSIM) transformations and the corresponding repartitioning of Sb on nmSIM under acidic conditions upon Fe(II) exposure have not been systematically examined. Herein, we investigated the effect of Fe(II) on nmSIM mineralogy and Sb mobility in Sb(V)-bearing nmSIM at pH 3.8 and 5.6 at various Fe(II) concentrations over 15 d. The Sb(V)-bearing nmSIM phase transformation occurred under both strongly and weakly acidic conditions without Fe(II) exposure, while the presence of Fe(II) significantly intensified the transformation, and substantial amounts of intermediary minerals, including jarosite, ferrihydrite, lepidocrocite and fougerite, formed during the initial reaction stage, especially at pH 5.6. X-ray diffraction (XRD) analyses confirmed that goethite and hematite were the primary final-stage transformation products of Sb(V)-bearing nmSIM, regardless of Fe(II) exposure. Throughout the Sb(V)-bearing nmSIM transformation at pH 3.8, Sb release was inversely related to the Fe(II) concentration in the initial stage, and after maximum release was achieved, Sb was gradually repartitioned onto the nmSIM. No Sb repartitioning occurred in the absence of Fe(II) at pH 5.6, but the introduction of Fe(II) suppressed Sb release and improved Sb repartitioning on nmSIM. This transformation was conducive to Sb reimmobilization on Sb(V)-bearing nmSIM due to the structural incorporation of Sb into the highly crystalline goethite and hematite generated by the Sb(V)-bearing nmSIM transformation, and no reduction of Sb(V) occurred. These results imply that Fe(II) can trigger mineralogical changes in Sb(V)-bearing nmSIM and have important impacts on Sb partitioning under acidic conditions. These new insights are essential for assessing the mobility and availability of Sb in acid mine drainage areas.

Unveiling the crucial role of iron mineral phase transformation in antimony(V) elimination from natural water

Antimony (Sb) in natural water has long-term effects on both the ecological environment and human health. Iron mineral phase transformation (IMPT) is a prominent process for removing Sb(V) from natural water. However, the importance of IMPT in eliminating Sb remains uncertain. This study examined the various Sb-Fe binding mechanisms found in different IMPT pathways in natural water, shedding light on the underlying mechanisms. The study revealed that the presence of goethite (Goe), hematite (Hem), and magnetite (Mag) significantly affected the concentration of Sb(V) in natural water. Elevated pH levels facilitated higher Fe content in iron solids but impeded the process of removing Sb(V). To further our understanding, polluted natural water samples were collected from various locations surrounding Sb smelter sites. Results confirmed that converting ferrihydrite (Fhy) to Goe significantly reduced Sb levels (<5 μg/L) in natural water. The emergence of secondary iron phases resulted in greater electrostatic attraction and stabilized surface complexes, which was the most likely cause of the decline of Sb concentration in natural water. The comprehensive findings offer new insights into the factors governing IMPT as well as the Sb(V) behavior control.

Antimony Isotope Fractionation Revealed from EXAFS during Adsorption on Fe (Oxyhydr)oxides

A lack of knowledge about antimony (Sb) isotope fractionation mechanisms in key geochemical processes has limited its environmental applications as a tracer. Naturally widespread iron (Fe) (oxyhydr)oxides play a key role in Sb migration due to strong adsorption, but the behavior and mechanisms of Sb isotopic fractionation on Fe (oxyhydr)oxides are still unclear. Here, we investigate the adsorption mechanisms of Sb on ferrihydrite (Fh), goethite (Goe), and hematite (Hem) using extended X-ray absorption fine structure (EXAFS) and show that inner-sphere complexation of Sb species with Fe (oxyhydr)oxides occurs independent of pH and surface coverage. Lighter Sb isotopes are preferentially enriched on Fe (oxyhydr)oxides due to isotopic equilibrium fractionation, with neither surface coverage nor pH influencing the degree of fractionation (Δ¹²³Sb_{aqueous-adsorbed}). Limited Fe atoms are present in the second shell of Hem and Goe, resulting in weaker surface complexes and leading to greater Sb isotopic fractionation than with Fh (Δ¹²³Sb_{aqueous-adsorbed} of 0.49 ± 0.004, 1.12 ± 0.006, and 1.14 ± 0.05‰ for Fh, Hem, and Goe, respectively). These results improve the understanding of the mechanism of Sb adsorption by Fe (oxyhydr)oxides and further clarify the Sb isotope fractionation mechanism, providing an essential basis for future application of Sb isotopes in source and process tracing.