Novel Insights into the Role of Copper in Critical Life Stages of Oysters Revealed by High-Resolution NanoSIMS Imaging

Copper redox state in cells and aquatic organisms: Implication for toxicity

Copper (Cu) redox state has been an important issue in biology and toxicology research, but many research gaps remain to be explored due to the limitations in the detecting techniques. Herein, the regulation of Cu homeostasis, including absorption, translocation, utilization, storage, and elimination behavior is discussed. Cuproptosis, a newly identified type of cell death caused by excessive Cu accumulation, which results in the aggregation of DLAT protein or the loss of Fe-S cluster and finally proteotoxic stress, is reviewed. Several longstanding mysteries of diseases such as Wilson disease and toxic effects, may be attributed to cuproptosis. Furthermore, we review the advanced detection methods and application of Cu(I) and Cu(II), especially the in-situ imaging techniques such as XANES, and chemosensors. Most of the existing studies using these detection techniques focus on the bioaccumulation and toxicity of Cu(I) and Cu(II) in cells and aquatic organisms. Finally, it will be important to identify the roles of Cu(I) and Cu(II) in the growth, development, and diseases of organisms, as well as the relationship between bioaccumulation and toxicity of Cu(I) and Cu(II) in cellular and aquatic toxicology.

Understanding the variable metal concentrations in estuarine oysters Crassostrea hongkongensis: A biokinetic analysis

Understanding the metal concentrations in oysters is important because of its relevance to human health and biomonitoring. However, metal concentrations in oysters are highly variable in nature and not well explained by metal exposure. This study examined the metal contamination in farm oysters Crassostrea hongkongensis grown in Qinzhou Bay, south China. Cadmium (Cd), zinc (Zn), nickel (Ni), and copper (Cu) concentrations in the oysters varied between 7.9 and 72.2, 282-17003, 0.37-47.7 and 37-4012 μg g-1, respectively, showing large metal variability among different individuals. Oyster metal concentrations decreased with increasing body size and significantly higher levels were observed in wet season. Low salinity and slower oyster growth due to inferior growth conditions could be responsible for the elevated metal concentrations in the wet season. Biokinetic modeling showed that the coupling of ingestion rate and growth can cause 2.8-4.2 folds differences in the oyster Cd and Zn concentrations, respectively, suggesting the significant role of oyster bioenergetics in contributing to the metal variability. Modeling data revealed that Cd and Zn concentrations in oyster tissues reach maximum levels when oysters have their lowest growth efficiency. This suggests that any factors influencing the energy budget in oysters could simultaneously alter their metal concentrations, which might be the reason why oyster metal concentrations are so variable in the natural environment.

Cytosolic distribution of copper in the gills of field-collected oysters with different copper bioaccumulation

Oysters can hyper-accumulate copper (Cu) without apparent toxicity, but the mechanism of sequestering excessive cytosolic Cu in oysters remains unclear. We here investigated the Cu distribution in the cytosolic proteins (CPs) in the gills of oysters (Crassostrea hongkongensis) through size-exclusion chromatography coupled to inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (SEC-ICP-MS). Oysters collected from the southern coast of China contained a gradient of gill Cu concentrations ranging from 132 to 3540 μg g-1 (dry weight), with 7-41 % of Cu distributed in the CPs fraction. The CPs-Cu concentrations were 8.6 times higher in oysters with high Cu concentrations compared to low concentrations. In the CPs, Cu was dispersed with a broad range of molecular weight, suggesting the involvement of various cytosolic proteins in Cu binding. Among the 10 major Cu peaks, peaks 2 (>600 kDa) and peak 8 (18 kDa) contained substantial Cu and showed obvious differences in response to the variation of CPs-Cu levels. Peak 8 contained metallothionein-like proteins that decreased their role in Cu binding as CPs-Cu concentrations increased. LC-MS/MS analysis revealed that peak 2 contained macromolecular protein complexes (MPCs), which played a critical role in binding excess Cu. The comparison with other bivalve species further suggested that sequestering excess CPs-Cu in MPCs was a special strategy employed by oysters in response to high Cu accumulation. This study provides valuable insights into the mechanism of hyper-accumulation and sequestration of Cu in oysters and helps to better understand Cu biomonitoring by oysters.

Quantitative imaging approaches to understanding biological processing of metal ions

Faster, more sensitive, and higher resolution quantitative instrumentation are aiding a deeper understanding of how inorganic chemistry regulates key biological processes. Researchers can now image and quantify metals with subcellular resolution, leading to a vast array of new discoveries in organismal development, pathology, and disease. Metals have recently been implicated in several diseases such as Parkinson's, Alzheimers, ischemic stroke, and colorectal cancer that would not be possible without these advancements. In this review, instead of focusing on instrumentation we focus on recent applications of label-free elemental imaging and quantification and how these tools can lead to a broader understanding of metals role in systems biology and human pathology.

Intracellular Biotransformation of Cu(II)/Cu(I) Explained High Cu Toxicity to Phytoplankton Chlamydomonas reinhardtii

The toxicity of Cu is related to its redox species, but the differential toxicity of Cu(II) and Cu(I) remains unknown. In the present study, we developed a novel protocol to simultaneously detect the biologically produced extracellular Cu(I) and internalized Cu(II) in a freshwater phytoplankton Chlamydomonas reinhardtii. The intracellular Cu(I) was further imaged using a fluorometric probe. Combining these pieces of evidence, we demonstrated that Cu(I) dominated the Cu toxicity in algal cells under Fe-deficient conditions. Our results showed that the labile Cu(I) content increased significantly in the low Fe quota cells. Intracellular biotransformation from Cu(II) to Cu(I) rather than the direct uptake of Cu(I) was responsible for the high Cu toxicity. The abnormal biotransformation from Cu(II) to Cu(I) under Fe deficiency was not resulted from the increase of overall Cu bioaccumulation but was likely due to the change of Cu(II) metabolism. High contents of Cu(II) were accumulated in the normal cells and the low Zn quota cells upon Cu exposure but did not induce cell death, further suggesting that Cu(I) dominated the Cu toxicity to the algae. This is the first study to simultaneously consider the effect of Cu(I) and Cu(II) during Cu exposure in phytoplankton. The results uncovered the underlying mechanisms of high Cu toxicity under Fe deficiency and highlighted the critical role of modulation of Cu metabolism in phytoplankton.

Copper promoting oyster larval growth and settlement: Molecular insights from RNA-seq

As a cofactor of key enzymes, Cu is required in living organisms, although Cu levels in the natural environment are typically low. In this study, the promotion of growth and settlement on the larvae of oyster Crassostrea angulata was observed at an environmentally relevant concentration (10 μg/L Cu). Interestingly, Cu accumulation in the soft tissue of oyster larvae increased during the larval development and exhibited a sharp increase at the late pelagic stage. With the help of RNA-seq, we constructed a high-quality transcriptional database of the oyster C. angulata larvae (24,257 genes with an average length of 1594 bp) via de novo assembly, which provided the basic molecular changes during the larval development. Network analysis of five early developmental stages and differential expression under Cu exposure were integrated to examine the roles of Cu in oyster larvae. Our molecular analysis demonstrated that both ion channels and organic transporters contributed to Cu internalization from the external environment, including zinc transporters and amino acid transporters. The followed distribution of Cu across cells was achieved by ATP7A, the circulatory system, and the Cu transporters (CTRs). Cu exposure enhanced the ribosome and the calcium binding proteins with a higher rate of translation and shell formation, giving rise to faster growth of oyster larvae. Furthermore, Cu facilitated the settling process by upregulating the chitin binding genes and then promoting the formation of the proteinaceous matrix between larvae and substrate. Our study presents the molecular basis for Cu promotion (i.e., hormesis) effects on oyster larval growth and settlement.

NanoSIMS Imaging of Bioaccumulation and Subcellular Distribution of Manganese During Oyster Gametogenesis

Many bivalve mollusks display remarkable sex differentiation of gonadal accumulation of manganese (Mn), but the underlying processes responsible for such differences have seldom been explored. In this study, the accumulation of Mn in male and female gonads during the reproductive cycle of oysters was first examined, and the distributions of Mn in oocytes and sperm cells at different developmental stages were imaged by the nanoscale secondary ion mass spectrometry (NanoSIMS) at the subcellular level. We found that the distribution and accumulation of Mn during oogenesis were closely associated with the formation and translocation of cortical granules. This is the first time that the enrichment of Mn was directly visualized in cortical granules, which was identified as the major storage site of Mn in oocytes of oysters. Yolk granules were revealed as another storage pool of Mn in oyster oocytes with lower accumulation. In contrast, Mn was mainly distributed in the nucleus of sperm cells with accumulation levels much lower than those in cortical and yolk granules of oocytes. These results demonstrated great differences of the subcellular localization and accumulation capacity of Mn between oocytes and sperm cells in oysters, implying the sex differentiation in susceptibility of reproductive response to Mn stress. Our study also highlights the importance of gender difference in future biomonitoring and ecotoxicological studies of Mn in marine bivalves.

Zn Induces Lipophagy via the Deacetylation of Beclin1 and Alleviates Cu-Induced Lipotoxicity at Their Environmentally Relevant Concentrations

In this study, the mechanisms of environmentally relevant doses of Cu and Zn mixtures influencing lipid deposition and metabolism were investigated in freshwater teleost yellow catfish Pelteobagrus fulvidraco (2 months old, 4.95 (t0.01 g, mean ± SEM). Our study indicated that waterborne Cu exposure increased lipid content, while Zn activated lipophagic flux and alleviated Cu-induced lipid accumulation. Yellow catfish hepatocytes treated with Zn or Zn + Cu activated autophagy-specific lipophagy, decreased lipid storage, and increased nonesterified fatty acid (NEFA) release, suggesting a causal relationship between lipophagy and lipid droplet (LD) breakdown under Zn and Zn + Cu conditions. Our further investigation found that Beclin1 deacetylation by sirtuin 1 (SIRT1) was required for Zn- and Zn + Cu-induced lipophagy and lipolysis, and lysine residues 427 and 434 were key sites for Beclin1 deacetylation. Taken together, these findings show that the Zn-induced deacetylation of Beclin1 promotes lipophagy as an important pathway to alleviate Cu-induced lipid accumulation in fish, which reveals a previously unidentified mechanism for understanding the antagonistic effects of Cu and Zn on metabolism at their environmentally relevant concentrations. Our results highlight the importance of combined exposure when the biological effects of heavy metals are evaluated during environmental risk assessments.

Imaging inorganic nanomaterial fate down to the organelle level

Nanotoxicology remains an important and emerging field since only recent years have seen the improvement of biological models and exposure setups toward real-life scenarios. The appropriate analysis of nanomaterial fate in these conditions also required methodological developments in imaging to become sensitive enough and element specific. In the last 2-4 years, impressive breakthroughs have been achieved using electron microscopy, nanoscale secondary ion mass spectrometry, X-ray fluorescence microscopy, or fluorescent sensors. In this review, basics of the approaches and application examples in the study of nanomaterial fate in biological systems will be described to highlight recent successes in the field.

Intra- and Intercellular Silver Nanoparticle Translocation and Transformation in Oyster Gill Filaments: Coupling Nanoscale Secondary Ion Mass Spectrometry and Dual Stable Isotope Tracing Study

The extensive application of silver nanoparticles (AgNPs) requires a full examination of their biological impacts, especially in aquatic systems where AgNPs are likely to end up. Despite numerous toxicity studies from molecular to individual levels, it is still a daunting challenge to achieve in situ subcellular imaging of Ag and to determine the sites of AgNP interaction with organelles or macromolecules simultaneously. Here, by coupling high-resolution nanoscale secondary ion mass spectrometry elemental mapping with scanning electron microscopy ultrastructural characterization, we successfully visualized the subcellular localization and the potential toxicity effects of AgNPs in the oyster gill filaments. The stable isotope tracing method was also adopted to investigate the respective uptake and transport mechanisms of differently labeled ¹⁰⁹AgNPs and ¹⁰⁷Ag⁺ ions. ¹⁰⁹Ag hotspots were colocalized with endosomes or lysosomes, proving an endocytosis-based entry of AgNPs which passed through the barrier of oyster gill epithelium. These ¹⁰⁹Ag hotspots showed a strong colocalization with ³²S^-. For the first time, we provided visualized evidence of AgNP-induced autophagy in the oyster gill cells. We further identified two categories of hemocytes (blood cells) and illustrated their roles in AgNP transport and sequestration. The integration of morphological and functional aspects of Ag subcellular distribution in different target cells suggested that oysters were equipped with a specialized endolysosomal (epithelial cells) or phagolysosomal system (hemocytes) in regulating the cellular process of AgNPs, during which the lysosome was the most involved organelle and sulfur was the most relevant macronutrient element. This study highlighted not only the intracellular but also the intercellular AgNP translocation and transformation, providing important subcellular imaging of silver and reliable methodology regarding bio-nano interactions in natural environments.

Influence of Size and Phase on the Biodegradation, Excretion, and Phytotoxicity Persistence of Single-Layer Molybdenum Disulfide

The increasing applications of single-layer molybdenum disulfide (SLMoS₂) pose great potential risks associated with environmental exposure. This study found that metallic-phase SLMoS₂ with nanoscale (N-1T-SLMoS₂, ∼400 nm) and microscale (M-1T-SLMoS₂, ∼3.6 μm) diameters at 10-25 mg/L induced significant algal growth inhibition (maximum 72.7 and 74.6%, respectively), plasmolysis, and oxidative damage, but these alterations were recoverable. Nevertheless, membrane permeability, chloroplast damage, and chlorophyll biosynthesis reduction were persistent. By contrast, the growth inhibition (maximum 55.3%) and adverse effects of nano-sized semiconductive-phase SLMoS₂ (N-2H-SLMoS₂, ∼400 nm) were weak and easily alleviated after 96 h of recovery. N-1T-SLMoS₂ (0.011 μg/h) and N-2H-SLMoS₂ (0.008 μg/h) were quickly biodegraded to soluble Mo compared with M-1T-SLMoS₂ (0.004 μg/h) and excreted by algae. Incomplete biodegradation of SLMoS₂ (26.8-43.9%) did not significantly mitigate its toxicity. Proteomics and metabolomics indicated that the downregulation of proteins (50.7-99.2%) related to antioxidants and photosynthesis and inhibition of carbon fixation and carbohydrate metabolism contributed to the persistent phytotoxicity. These findings highlight the roles and mechanisms of the size and phase in the persistent phytotoxicity of SLMoS₂, which has potential implications for risk assessment and environmental applications of nanomaterials.

Subcellular Imaging of Localization and Transformation of Silver Nanoparticles in the Oyster Larvae

To accurately assess the behavior and toxicity of silver nanoparticles (AgNPs), it is essential to understand their subcellular distribution and biotransformation. We combined both nanoscale secondary ion mass spectrometry (NanoSIMS) and electron microscopy to investigate the subcellular localization of Ag and in situ chemical distribution in the oyster larvae Crassostrea angulata after exposure to isotopically enriched ¹⁰⁹AgNPs. Oyster larvae directly ingested particulate Ag, and in vivo dissolution of AgNPs occurred. The results collectively showed that AgNPs were much less bioavailable than Ag⁺, and the intracellular Ag was mainly originated from the soluble Ag, especially those dissolved from the ingested AgNPs. AgNPs absorbed on the cell membranes continued to release Ag ions, forming inorganic Ag-S complexes extracellularly, while Ag-organosulfur complexes were predominantly formed intracellularly. The internalized Ag could bind to the sulfur-rich molecules (S-donors) in the cytosol and/or be sequestered in the lysosomes of velum, esophagus, and stomach cells, as well as in the digestive vacuoles of digestive cells, which could act as a detoxification pathway for the oyster larvae. Ag was also occasionally incorporated into the phosphate granules, rough endoplasmic reticulum, and mitochondria. Our work provided definite evidence for the partial sulfidation of AgNPs after interaction with oyster larvae and shed new light on the bioavailability and fate of nanoparticles in marine environment.