Cooperative Effects of Heterodinuclear IrIII-MII Complexes on Catalytic H2 Evolution from Formic Acid Dehydrogenation in Water

Stronger Together! Mechanistic Investigation into Synergistic Effects during Homogeneous Carbon Dioxide Hydrogenation Using a Heterobimetallic Catalyst

A series of group 6 heterobimetallic complexes [M0;IrIII] (M = Cr, Mo, W) were synthesized and fully characterized, and the catalytic behavior was studied. The heterobimetallic complex [Mo0;IrIII] (C1) was by far the most active and has shown a considerable synergistic effect, with both metals actively participating in homogeneous carbon dioxide hydrogenation, leading to formate salts. Based on theoretical calculations, the synergistic interaction is due to Pauli repulsion, lowering the transition state and thus enabling higher catalytic activity. The mechanism of both the hydrogenation itself and the synergistic interaction was studied by NMR spectroscopy, kinetic measurements, and theoretical calculations. The homogeneous nature of the reaction was proven using in situ high-pressure (HP) NMR experiments. The same experiments also showed that the octahedral Mo(CO)3P3 moiety of the complex is stable under the reaction conditions. The hydride complex is the resting state because the hydride transfer is the rate-determining step. This is supported by kinetic measurements, in situ HP NMR experiments, and theoretical calculations and is in contrast to the monometallic IrIII counterpart of C1.

Added Complexity!-Mechanistic Aspects of Heterobimetallic Complexes for Application in Homogeneous Catalysis

Inspired by multimetallic assemblies and their role in enzyme catalysis, chemists have developed a plethora of heterobimetallic complexes for application in homogeneous catalysis. Starting with small heterobimetallic complexes with σ-donating and π-accepting ligands, such as N-heterocyclic carbene and carbonyl ligands, more and more complex systems have been developed over the past two decades. These systems can show a significant increase in catalytic activity compared with their monometallic counterparts. This increase can be attributed to new reaction pathways enabled by the presence of a second metal center in the active catalyst. This review focuses on mechanistic aspects of heterobimetallic complexes in homogeneous catalysis. Depending on the type of interaction of the second metal with the substrates, heterobimetallic complexes can be subdivided into four classes. Each of these classes is illustrated with multiple examples, showcasing the versatility of both, the types of interactions possible, and the reactions accessible.

Diruthenium Catalyst for Hydrogen Production from Aqueous Formic Acid

Diruthenium complexes [{(η⁶-arene)RuCl}₂(μ-κ²:κ²-benztetraimd)]²⁺ containing the bridging bis-imidazole methane-based ligand {1,4-bis(bis(2-ethyl-5-methyl-1H-imidazol-4-yl)methyl)benzene} (benztetraimd) are synthesized for catalytic formic acid dehydrogenation in water at 90 °C. Catalyst [{(η⁶-p-cymene)RuCl}₂(μ-κ²:κ²-benztetraimd)]²⁺ [1-Cl₂] exhibited a remarkably high turnover frequency (1993 h^-1 per Ru atom) and long-term stability over 60 days for formic acid dehydrogenation, while the analogous (η⁶-benzene)diruthenium and mononuclear catalysts displayed low activity with poor long-term stability. Notably, catalyst [1-Cl₂] also displayed an appreciably high turnover number of 93 200 for the bulk-scale reaction. In addition, the in-depth mass and nuclear magnetic resonance investigations under the catalytic and control experimental conditions revealed the active involvement of several crucial catalytic intermediate species, such as Ru-aqua species [{(η⁶-p-cymene)Ru(H₂O)}₂(μ-L)]²⁺ [1-(OH₂)₂], Ru-formato species [{(η⁶-p-cymene)Ru(HCOO)}₂(μ-L)] [1-(HCOO)₂], and Ru-hydrido species [{(η⁶-p-cymene)Ru(H)}₂(μ-L)] [1-(H)₂], in the catalytic formic acid dehydrogenation reaction.

Synergistic Catalysis in Heterobimetallic Complexes for Homogeneous Carbon Dioxide Hydrogenation

Two heterobimetallic Mo,M’ complexes (M’ = IrIII, RhIII) were synthesized and fully characterized. Their catalytic activity in homogeneous carbon dioxide hydrogenation to formate was studied. A pronounced synergistic effect between the two metals was found, most notably between Mo and Ir, leading to a fourfold increase in activity compared with a binary mixture of the two monometallic counterparts. This synergism can be attributed to spatial proximity of the two metals rather than electronic interactions. To further understand the nature of this interaction, the mechanism of the CO2 hydrogenation to formate by a monometallic IrIII catalyst was studied using computational and spectroscopic methods. The resting state of the reaction was found to be the metal-base adduct, whereas the rate-determining step is the inner-sphere hydride transfer to CO2. Based on these findings, the synergism in the heterobimetallic complex is beneficial in this key step, most likely by further activating the CO2.

High-Throughput Approach for Facile Access to Hetero-Dinuclear Synergistic Metal Complex for H2O2 Activation and Its Implications

Hetero-dinuclear synergic catalysis is a promising approach for improving catalytic performance. However, employing it is challenging because the design principles for the metal complex are still not well understood. Further, these complexes have a broader set of possibilities than mononuclear or homometallic systems, increasing the time and effort required to understand them. In this study, we explored a high-throughput approach to obtain a new hetero-dinuclear synergistic metal complex for H₂O₂ activation. From the 1152 combinations of metal complex candidates obtained by changing three variables (metal ions, unsymmetrical dinucleating ligands, and pH), the lead complex (L3-(Ni, Co)), which has the highest peroxidase activity, was derived using colorimetric parallel analysis. A series of control experiments revealed that L3 plays a crucial role in the formation of active L3-(Ni, Co) complexes, Co²⁺ acts as a catalytic center, and Ni²⁺ serves as an assistant catalytic site within L3-(Ni, Co). In addition, the catalytic efficiency of L3-(Ni, Co), which was 125 times that of the homo-bimetallic complex (L3-(Co, Co)), revealed clear hetero-bimetallic synergism in the buffer. The ultraviolet-visible study and electron paramagnetic resonance-based spin-trap experiment provided mechanistic insight into H₂O₂ activation by the intermediate, which was found to be induced by the reaction of L3-(Ni, Co) and H₂O₂. Moreover, the intermediate could act as a donor of the hydroperoxyl radical (^•OOH) in the buffer. Furthermore, L3-(Ni, Co) demonstrated potential for application as a signal transducer for H₂O₂ in an enzyme-coupled cascade assay that can be used for the colorimetric detection of glucose.

Laser Ablation Nanoarchitectonics of Au-Cu Alloys Deposited on TiO2 Photocatalyst Films for Switchable Hydrogen Evolution from Formic Acid Dehydrogenation

The regulation of H₂ evolution from formic acid dehydrogenation using recyclable photocatalyst films is an essential approach for on-demand H₂ production. We have successfully generated Au-Cu nanoalloys using a laser ablation method and deposited them on TiO₂ photocatalyst films (Au _x Cu_100-x /TiO₂). The Au-Cu/TiO₂ films were employed as photocatalysts for H₂ production from formic acid dehydrogenation under light-emitting diode (LED) irradiation (365 nm). The highest H₂ evolution rate for Au₂₀Cu₈₀/TiO₂ is archived to 62,500 μmol h^-1 g^-1 per photocatalyst weight. The remarkable performance of Au₂₀Cu₈₀/TiO₂ may account for the formation of Au-rich surfaces and the effect of Au alloying that enables Cu to sustain the metallic form on its surface. The metallic Au-Cu surface on TiO₂ is vital to supply the photoexcited electrons of TiO₂ to its surface for H₂ evolution. The rate-determining step (RDS) is identified as the reaction of a surface-active species with protons. The results establish a practical preparation of metal alloy deposited on photocatalyst films using laser ablation to develop efficient photocatalysts.

Photochemical hydrogen production based on the HCOOH/CO2 cycle promoted by a pentanuclear cobalt complex

The first catalytic cycle for hydrogen production based on the photochemical two-electron reduction of carbon dioxide (CO₂) and the dehydrogenation of formic acid at ambient temperature was demonstrated using a pentanuclear cobalt complex (Co5). A series of mechanistic studies were performed to elucidate the mechanism responsible for the promotion of the photocatalytic cycle by Co5.

Cooperative approaches in catalytic hydrogenation and dehydrogenation

Metal-ligand cooperativity (MLC) is an established strategy for developing effective hydrogenation and dehydrogenation catalysts. Metal-metal cooperativity (MMC) in bimetallic complexes is not as well understood, and to date has had limited implementation in (de)hydrogenation. Herein we use (de)hydrogenation processes as a platform to examine modes of cooperativity, with a particular focus on catalytic mechanisms. We investigate how lessons learnt from the extensive development of metal-ligand cooperative catalysts can aid the ongoing development of metal-metal cooperative catalysts.

Advances in Nonprecious Metal Homogeneously Catalyzed Formic Acid Dehydrogenation

Formic acid (FA) possesses a high volumetric concentration of H2 (53 g L−1). Moreover, it can be easily prepared, stored, and transported. Therefore, FA stands out as a potential liquid organic hydrogen carrier (LOHC), which allows storage and transportation of hydrogen in a safe way. The dehydrogenation to produce H2 and CO2 competes with its dehydration to give CO and H2O. For this reason, research on selective catalytic FA dehydrogenation has gained attention in recent years. Several examples of highly active homogenous catalysts based on precious metals effective for the selective dehydrogenation of FA have been reported. Among them are the binuclear iridium-bipyridine catalysts described by Fujita and Himeda et al. (TOF = 228,000 h−1) and the cationic species [IrClCp*(2,2′-bi-2-imidazoline)]Cl (TOF = 487,500 h−1). However, examples of catalytic systems effective for the solventless dehydrogenation of FA, which is of great interest since it allows to reduce the reaction volume and avoids the use of organic solvents that could damage the fuel cell, are scarce. In this context, the development of transition metal catalysts based on cheap and easily available nonprecious metals is a subject of great interest. This work contains a summary on the state of the art of catalytic dehydrogenation of FA in homogeneous phase, together with an account of the catalytic systems based on non-precious metals so far reported.

Hydrogen peroxide production from oxygen and formic acid by homogeneous Ir-Ni catalyst

Hydrogen peroxide was directly produced from oxygen and formic acid, catalysed by a hetero-dinuclear Ir-Ni complex with two adjacent sites, at ambient temperature. Synergistic catalysis derived from the hetero-dinuclear Ir and Ni centres was demonstrated by comparing its activity to those of the component mononuclear Ir and Ni complexes. A reaction intermediate of Ir-hydrido was detected by UV-vis, ESI-TOF-MS, and 1H NMR spectroscopies. It was revealed that the Ir moiety serves as an active species of Ir-hydrido, reacting with oxygen to afford an Ir-hydroperoxide species through O2 insertion, which is the rate-determining step for H2O2 production. Meanwhile, the Ni moiety promotes H2O2 formation by activating solvents as proton sources. We also found that H2O2 production is strongly affected by the solvent dielectric constants (DE); the highest H2O2 concentration was obtained in ethylene glycol with a moderate DE. The catalytic mechanism of H2O2 production by the Ir-Ni complex was discussed, based on kinetic analysis, isotope labelling experiments, and theoretical DFT calculations.

Multiwavelets applied to metal-ligand interactions: Energies free from basis set errors

Transition metal-catalyzed reactions invariably include steps where ligands associate or dissociate. In order to obtain reliable energies for such reactions, sufficiently large basis sets need to be employed. In this paper, we have used high-precision multiwavelet calculations to compute the metal-ligand association energies for 27 transition metal complexes with common ligands, such as H₂, CO, olefins, and solvent molecules. By comparing our multiwavelet results to a variety of frequently used Gaussian-type basis sets, we show that counterpoise corrections, which are widely employed to correct for basis set superposition errors, often lead to underbinding. Additionally, counterpoise corrections are difficult to employ when the association step also involves a chemical transformation. Multiwavelets, which can be conveniently applied to all types of reactions, provide a promising alternative for computing electronic interaction energies free from any basis set errors.

Insights into Formate Oxidation by a Series of Cobalt Piano-Stool Complexes Supported by Bis(phosphino)amine Ligands

A series of (cyclopentadienyl)cobalt(III) half-sandwich complexes (1-4) supported by bidentate bis(phosphino)amine ligands was synthesized and characterized by NMR spectroscopy, X-ray crystallography, and cyclic voltammetry. The Co^III-hydride complex 4-H bearing the bis(cyclohexylphosphine) ligand derivative was successfully isolated via protonation of the neutral reduced Co^I complex 5 with a weak acid. Experimental and computational methods were used to determine the thermodynamic hydride accepting ability of these Co^III centers and to evaluate their reactivity toward the oxidation of formate. We find that the hydride accepting ability of 1-4 ranges from 71 to 74 kcal/mol in acetonitrile, which should favor a highly exergonic reaction with formate through direct hydride transfer. Formate oxidation was demonstrated at elevated temperatures in the presence of stoichiometric quantities of 4, generating carbon dioxide and the Co^III-hydride complex 4-H in 72% yield.

Formate-driven catalysis and mechanism of an iridium-copper complex for selective aerobic oxidation of aromatic olefins in water

A hetero-dinuclear IrIII-CuII complex with two adjacent sites was employed as a catalyst for the aerobic oxidation of aromatic olefins driven by formate in water. An IrIII-H intermediate, generated through formate dehydrogenation, was revealed to activate terminal aromatic olefins to afford an Ir-alkyl species, and the process was promoted by a hydrophobic [IrIII-H]-[substrate aromatic ring] interaction in water. The Ir-alkyl species subsequently reacted with dioxygen to yield corresponding methyl ketones and was promoted by the presence of the CuII moiety under acidic conditions. The IrIII-CuII complex exhibited cooperative catalysis in the selective aerobic oxidation of olefins to corresponding methyl ketones, as evidenced by no reactivities observed from the corresponding mononuclear IrIII and CuII complexes, as the individual components of the IrIII-CuII complex. The reaction mechanism afforded by the IrIII-CuII complex in the aerobic oxidation was disclosed by a combination of spectroscopic detection of reaction intermediates, kinetic analysis, and theoretical calculations.