An Approach to More Accurate Model Systems for Purple Acid Phosphatases (PAPs)

Exploring second coordination sphere effects in flavodiiron nitric oxide reductase model complexes

Flavodiiron nitric oxide reductases (FNORs) equip pathogens with resistance to nitric oxide (NO), an important immune defense agent in mammals, allowing these pathogens to proliferate in the human body, potentially causing chronic infections. Understanding the mechanism of how FNORs mediate the reduction of NO contributes to the greater goal of developing new therapeutic approaches against drug-resistant strains. Recent density functional theory calculations suggest that a second coordination sphere (SCS) tyrosine residue provides a hydrogen bond that is critical for the reduction of NO to N2O at the active site of FNORs [J. Lu, B. Bi, W. Lai and H. Chen, Origin of Nitric Oxide Reduction Activity in Flavo-Diiron NO Reductase: Key Roles of the Second Coordination Sphere, Angew. Chem., Int. Ed., 2019, 58, 3795-3799]. Specifically, this H-bond stabilizes the hyponitrite intermediate and reduces the energetic barrier for the N-N coupling step. At the same time, the role of the Fe⋯Fe distance and its effect on the N-N coupling step has not been fully investigated. In this study, we equipped the H[BPMP] (= 2,6-bis[[bis(2-pyridylmethyl)amino]methyl]-4-methylphenol) ligand with SCS amide groups and investigated the corresponding diiron complexes with 0-2 bridging acetate ligands. These amide groups can form hydrogen bonds with the bridging acetate ligand(s) and potentially the coordinated NO groups in these model complexes. At the same time, by changing the number of bridging acetate ligands, we can systematically vary the Fe⋯Fe distance. The reactivity of these complexes with NO was then investigated, and the formation of stable iron(II)-NO complexes was observed. Upon one-electron reduction, these NO complexes form Dinitrosyl Iron Complexes (DNICs), which were further characterized using IR and EPR spectroscopy.

Distinct chemical factors in hydrolytic reactions catalyzed by metalloenzymes and metal complexes

The selective hydrolysis of the extremely stable phosphoester, peptide and ester bonds of molecules by bio-inspired metal-based catalysts (metallohydrolases) is required in a wide range of biological, biotechnological and industrial applications. Despite the impressive advances made in the field, the ultimate goal of designing efficient enzyme mimics for these reactions is still elusive. Its realization will require a deeper understanding of the diverse chemical factors that influence the activities of both natural and synthetic catalysts. They include catalyst-substrate complexation, non-covalent interactions and the electronic nature of the metal ion, ligand environment and nucleophile. Based on our computational studies, their roles are discussed for several mono- and binuclear metallohydrolases and their synthetic analogues. Hydrolysis by natural metallohydrolases is found to be promoted by a ligand environment with low basicity, a metal bound water and a heterobinuclear metal center (in binuclear enzymes). Additionally, peptide and phosphoester hydrolysis is dominated by two competing effects, i.e. nucleophilicity and Lewis acid activation, respectively. In synthetic analogues, hydrolysis is facilitated by the inclusion of a second metal center, hydrophobic effects, a biological metal (Zn, Cu and Co) and a terminal hydroxyl nucleophile. Due to the absence of the protein environment, hydrolysis by these small molecules is exclusively influenced by nucleophile activation. The results gleaned from these studies will enhance the understanding of fundamental principles of multiple hydrolytic reactions. They will also advance the development of computational methods as a predictive tool to design more efficient catalysts for hydrolysis, Diels-Alder reaction, Michael addition, epoxide opening and aldol condensation.

Controlled Hydrolysis of Phosphate Esters: A Route to Calixarene-Supported Rare-Earth Clusters

Phosphate ester bonds are widely present in nature (e. g. DNA/RNA) and can be extremely stable against hydrolysis without the help of catalysts. Previously, we showed how the combination of phosphoryl and calix[4]arene moieties in the same organic framework (L_PO ) allows isolation of single lanthanide (Ln) metal ions as [Ln^III (L_PO )₂ ](O₃ SCF₃ )₃ . Here we report how by controlling the reaction conditions a new hydrolyzed phosphoryl-calix[4]arene ligand (H₃ L_HPO ) is formed as a result of Ln^III -mediated P-OEt bond cleavage in three out of the eight possible sites in L_PO . The chelating nature of H₃ L_HPO traps the Ln^III species in the form of [Ln^III (L_HPO )((EtO)₂ P(O)OH)]₂ dimers (Ln=La, Dy, Tb, Gd), where the Dy derivative shows slow magnetization relaxation. The strategy presented herein could be extended to access a broader library of hydrolyzed platforms (H_x L_HPO ; x=1-8) that may represent mimics of nuclease enzymes.

Synthesis, characterization and computational investigation of the phosphatase activity of a dinuclear Zinc(II) complex containing a new heptadentate asymmetric ligand

We report the synthesis of a new asymmetric heptadentate ligand based on the 1,3-diaminopropan-2-ol backbone. The ligand 3-[[3-(bis-pyridin-2-ylmethyl-amino)-2-hydroxy-propyl]-(2-carbamoyl-ethyl)-amino]-propionamide (HL1) contains two amide and two pyridine groups attached to the 1,3-diaminopropan-2-ol core. Reaction between HL1 and Zn(ClO₄)₂.6H₂O resulted in the formation of the dinuclear [Zn₂(L1)(μ-OAc)](ClO₄)₂ complex, characterized by single crystal X-ray diffraction, ¹H, ¹³C and ¹⁵N NMR, ESI-(+)-MS, CHN elemental analysis as well as infrared spectroscopy. The phosphatase activity of the complex was studied in the pH range 6-11 employing pyridinium bis(2,4-dinitrophenyl)phosphate (py(BDNPP)) as substrate. The complex exhibited activity dependent on the pH, presenting an asymmetric bell shape profile with the highest activity at pH 9; at high pH ligand exchange is rate-limiting. The hydrolysis of BDNPP^- at pH 9 displayed behavior characteristic of Michaelis-Menten kinetics, with k_cat = 5.06 × 10^-3 min^-1 and K_m = 5.7 ± 1.0 mM. DFT calculations map out plausible reaction pathways and identify a terminal, Zn(II)-bound hydroxide as likely nucleophile.

Biomimetics for purple acid phosphatases: A historical perspective

Biomimetics hold potential for varied applications in biotechnology and medicine but have also attracted particular interest as benchmarks for the functional study of their more complex biological counterparts, e.g. metalloenzymes. While many of the synthetic systems adequately mimic some structural and functional aspects of their biological counterparts the catalytic efficiencies displayed are mostly far inferior due to the smaller size and the associated lower complexity. Nonetheless they play an important role in bioinorganic chemistry. Numerous examples of biologically inspired and informed artificial catalysts have been reported, designed to mimic a plethora of chemical transformations, and relevant examples are highlighted in reviews and scientific reports. Herein, we discuss biomimetics of the metallohydrolase purple acid phosphatase (PAP), examples of which have been used to showcase synergistic research advances for both the biological and synthetic systems. In particular, we focus on the seminal contribution of our colleague Prof. Ademir Neves, and his group, pioneers in the design and optimization of suitable ligands that mimic the active site of PAP.

Air oxidation-induced single-crystal-to-single-crystal transformation of mixed-valence tetranuclear Fe(II)-Fe(III) complexes

A mixed valence tetranuclear iron complex [(Hpmide)Fe^II(NCSe)₂Fe^III(pmide)]₂·5CH₃OH (1) underwent oxidation and ligand exchange in the solid state (H₂pmide = N-(2-pyridylmethyl)iminodiethanol). Upon air oxidation, 1 was converted into [(pmide)Fe^III(NCSe)Fe^III(pmide)]₂(NCSe)₂·2H₂O (2), which was accompanied by deprotonation and ligand exchange through a single crystal-to-single-crystal transformation.

Proton controlled synthesis of two dicopper(II) complexes and their magnetic and biomimetic catalytic studies together with probing the binding mode of the substrate to the metal center

This paper describes the synthesis, and structural and spectroscopic characterizations of two doubly bridged dicopper(II) complexes, [Cu₂(μ-H₂L)(μ-OMe)](ClO₄)₄·2H₂O (1) and [Cu₂(μ-L)(μ-OH)](ClO₄)₂ (2), with a binucleating ligand (HL) derived from the Schiff base condensation of DFMP and N,N-dimethyldipropylenetriamine, and their biomimetic catalytic activities were related to CAO and phenoxazinone synthase using 3,5-di-tert-butylcatechol and o-aminophenol (OAPH), respectively, as model substrates. Structural studies reveal that the major differences in these structures appear to be from the distinct roles of the tertiary amine groups of the ligands, which are protonated in 1, whereas it coordinates the metal centers in 2. Magnetic studies disclose that two copper(II) centers are strongly antiferromagnetically coupled with slightly different J values, which is further interpreted and discussed. They exhibited very different biomimetic catalytic activities; whereas 2 is an efficient catalyst, complex 1 showed somewhat lower substrate oxidation. The higher reactivity in 2 is rationalized by the strong involvement of the tertiary amine group of the Schiff base ligand, where the substrate oxidation is favored because of the transfer of protons from the substrate to the tertiary amine group, showing the importance of the functional groups in proximity to the bimetallic active site. Emphasis was also given to probing the binding mode of the substrate using an electronically deficient tetrabromomocatechol (Br₄CatH₂) and the isolated compound [Cu₆(μ-HL)₂(μ-OH)₂(Br₄Cat)₄](NO₃)₂·4H₂O (3) which suggests that monodentate asymmetric binding of 3,5-di-tert-butylcatechol and OAPH occurs during the course of the catalytic reaction.

Mixed Valence (μ-Phenoxido) FeII FeIII et FeIII FeIV Compounds: Electron and Proton Transfers

Mixed-valence non-heme diiron centers are present at the active sites of a few enzymes and confer them interesting reactivities with the two ions acting in concert. Related (μ-phenoxido)diiron complexes have been developed as enzyme mimics. They exhibit very rich spectroscopic properties enabling independent monitoring of each individual ion, which proved useful for mechanistic studies of catalytic hydrolysis and oxidation reactions. In our studies of such complexes, we observed that these compounds give rise to a wide variety of electron transfers (intervalence charge transfer), proton transfers (tautomerism), coupled electron and proton transfers (H^. abstraction and PCET). In this minireview, we present and analyze the main results illustrating the latter aspects.

A novel triple aqua-, phenoxo- and carboxylato-bridged dinickel(ii) complex, its magnetic properties, and comparative biomimetic catalytic studies with analogous dinickel(ii) complexes

A unique triply bridged dinickel(ii) complex and two doubly bridged dinickel(ii) complexes are reported, and their magnetic properties and comparative biomimetic catalytic performances are studied.

Electronic Effect on Bimetallic Catalysts: Cleavage of Phosphodiester Mediated by Fe(III)-Zn(II) Purple Acid Phosphatase Mimics

The bimetallic system is an important strategy for the catalytic hydrolysis of phosphodiester. The purple acid phosphatase (PAPs) enzyme is a typical bimetallic catalyst in this field. Mechanistic details for the hydrolysis cleavage of the DNA dinucleotide analogue BNPP^- (BNPP^- = bis(p-nitrophenyl) phosphate) by hetero-binuclear [Fe^III(μ-OH)Zn^IIL]²⁺ complexes (L = 2-[N-bis(2-pyridylmethyl)-aminomethyl]-4-methyl-6-[N'-(2-pyridylmethyl)(2-hydroxybenzyl) aminomethyl] phenol) were investigated using density functional theory calculations. The catalysts with single-bridged hydroxyl and double-bridged hydroxyl groups were compared. The calculation results show that the doubly hydroxide-bridged complex could better bind to substrates. For the BNPP^- hydrolysis, the doubly hydroxide-bridged reactant isomerizes into a single hydroxide-bridged complex, and then the attack is initiated by the hydroxyl group on the iron center. In addition, the catalyst with the electron-donating group (Me) was determined to take precedence over electron-withdrawing groups (Br and NO₂ groups) in the hydrolysis reaction. This is because the substituents affect the high-lying occupied molecular orbitals, tuning the Lewis acidity of iron and pK_a values of the metal-bonded water. These factors influence the hydroxyl nucleophilicity, leading to changes in catalytic activity. To further examine substituent effects, the occupied orbital energies were calculated with several different substituent groups (-CF₃, -OMe, -OH, -NH₂, and -N(Me)₂). It was found that the HOMO or HOMO-1 energy decreases with the increase of the σ_p value. Further, the catalyst activity of the [Fe^III(μ-OH)Zn^IIL]²⁺ complexes was found to be mainly affected by the phenolate ligand (B) coordinated to the iron and zinc centers. These fundamental aspects of the hydrolysis reactions of BNPP^- catalyzed by [Fe^III(μ-OH)Zn^IIL]²⁺ complexes should contribute to improved understanding of the mechanism and to catalyst design involving hetero-binuclear metals complexes.

Polynuclear zinc(II) complexes of thiosemicarbazone: Synthesis, X-ray structure and biological evaluation

Two new dimeric Zn(II) ([{ZnL¹(DMSO₂)}₂]·DMSO (1), [{ZnL²Cl}₂] (2)) and a novel tetrameric Zn(II) complex ([(Zn₂L³)₂(μ-OAc)₂(μ₃-O)₂] (3)), where H₂L¹ = 4-(p-methoxyphenyl) thiosemicarbazone of o-hydroxynapthaldehyde, HL² = 4-(p-methoxyphenyl)thiosemicarbazone of benzoyl pyridine and H₂L³ = 4-(p-chlorophenyl)thiosemicarbazone of o-vanillin are reported. Ligands and their complexes were characterized by spectroscopic and single crystal X-ray diffraction techniques. In addition, the complexes exhibited good binding affinity towards HSA (10¹² M^-1), which is supported by their ability to quench the tryptophan fluorescence emission spectra of HSA. The complexes were also screened for their DNA binding propensity through UV-vis absorption titration, circular dichroism and fluorescence spectral studies. Results show that they effectively interact with CT-DNA through an intercalative mode of binding, with binding constants ranging from 10³ to 10⁴ M^-1. Among the three complexes 1 has the highest binding affinity towards CT-DNA. Further, the phosphatase activity was evaluated using bis(2,4-dinitrophenyl)phosphate (BDNPP) as substrate, however, the complexes did not yield any measurable catalytic activity. Nevertheless the complexes showed significant cytotoxic potential against HeLa and HT-29 cancer cell lines that was assessed through MTT assay and DAPI staining. Remarkably, complex 1 showed better activity than cisplatin against HT-29 cell line.

Synthesis, Magnetic Properties, and Catalytic Properties of a Nickel(II)-Dependent Biomimetic of Metallohydrolases

A dinickel(II) complex of the ligand 1,3-bis(bis(pyridin-2-ylmethyl)amino)propan-2-ol (HL1) has been prepared and characterized to generate a functional model for nickel(II) phosphoesterase enzymes. The complex, [Ni2(L1)(μ-OAc)(H2O)2](ClO4)2·H2O, was characterized by microanalysis, X-ray crystallography, UV-visible, and IR absorption spectroscopy and solid state magnetic susceptibility measurements. Susceptibility studies show that the complex is antiferromagnetically coupled with the best fit parameters J = -27.4 cm-1, g = 2.29, D = 28.4 cm-1, comparable to corresponding values measured for the analogous dicobalt(II) complex [Co2(L1)(μ-OAc)](ClO4)2·0.5 H2O (J = -14.9 cm-1 and g = 2.16). Catalytic measurements with the diNi(II) complex using the substrate bis(2,4-dinitrophenyl)phosphate (BDNPP) demonstrated activity toward hydrolysis of the phosphoester substrate with K m ~10 mM, and k cat ~0.025 s-1. The combination of structural and catalytic studies suggests that the likely mechanism involves a nucleophilic attack on the substrate by a terminal nucleophilic hydroxido moiety.

Dinuclear metal(ii)-acetato complexes based on bicompartmental 4-chlorophenolate: syntheses, structures, magnetic properties, DNA interactions and phosphodiester hydrolysis

A series of dinuclear metal(ii)-acetato complexes: [Ni2(μ-L(Cl)O)(μ2-OAc)2](PF6)·3H2O (1), [Ni2(μ-L(Cl)O)(μ2-OAc)2](ClO4)·CH3COCH3 (2), [Cu2(μ-L(Cl)O)(μ2-OAc)(ClO4)](ClO4) (3), [Cu2(μ-L(Cl)O)(OAc)2](PF6)·H2O (4), [Zn2(μ-L(Cl)O)(μ2-OAc)2](PF6) (5) and [Mn2(L(Cl)-O)(μ2-OAc)2](ClO4)·H2O (6), where L(Cl)O(-) = 2,6-bis[bis(2-pyridylmethyl)aminomethyl]-4-chlorophenolate, were synthesized. The complexes were structurally characterized by spectroscopic techniques and single crystal X-ray crystallography. Six-coordinate geometries with doubly bridged acetato ligands were found in Ni(ii), Zn(ii) and Mn(ii) complexes 1, 2, 5 and 6, whereas with Cu(ii) complexes a five-coordinate species was obtained with 4, and mixed five- and six-coordinate geometries with a doubly bridged dimetal core were observed in 3. The magnetic properties of complexes 1-4 and 6 were studied at variable temperatures and revealed weak to very weak antiferromagnetic interactions in 1, 2, 4 and 6 (J = -0.55 to -9.4 cm(-1)) and ferromagnetic coupling in 3 (J = 15.4 cm(-1)). These results are consistent with DFT calculations performed at the B3LYP/def2-TZVP(-f) level of theory. Under physiological conditions, the interaction of the dinculear complexes 1-5 with supercoiled plasmid ds-DNA did not show any pronounced nuclease activity, but Ni(ii) complexes 1 and 2 revealed a strong ability to unwind the supercoiled conformation of ds-DNA. The mechanistic studies performed on the interaction of the Ni(ii) complexes with DNA demonstrated the important impact of the nickel(ii) ion in the unwinding process. In combination with the DNA study, the phosphatase activity of complexes 1, 3, and 5 was examined by the phosphodiester hydrolysis of bis(2,4-dinitrophenol)phosphate (BDNPP) in the pH range of 5.5-10.5 at 25 °C. The Michaelis-Menten kinetics performed at pH 7 and 10.7 showed that catalytic efficiencies kcat/KM (kcat = catalytic rate constant, KM = substrate binding constant) decrease in the order: Ni(ii), 1 > Zn(ii), 5 > Cu(ii), 3. A similar trend was also observed with the turnover numbers at pH = 7. The results are discussed in relation to the coordination geometry and nature of the metal center as well as the steric environment imposed by the compartmental phenoxido ligand.

Modeling the Active Site of the Purple Acid Phosphatase Enzyme with Hetero-Dinuclear Mixed Valence M(II)-Fe(III) [M = Zn, Ni, Co, and Cu] Complexes Supported over a [N6O] Unsymmetrical Ligand

The active site of the purple acid phosphatase enzyme has been successfully modeled by a series of hetero-dinuclear M(II)-Fe(III) [M = Zn, Ni, Co, and Cu] type complexes of an unsymmetrical [N₆O] ligand that contained a bridging phenoxide moiety and one imidazoyl and three pyridyl moieties as the terminal N-binding sites. In particular, the hetero-dinuclear complexes, {L[M^II(μ-OAc)₂Fe^III]}(ClO₄)₂ [M = Zn (3a), Ni (3b), Co (4a), and Cu (4b)], were obtained directly from the phenoxy-bridged ligand (HL), namely 2-{[bis(2-methylpyridyl)amino]methyl}-6-{[((1-methylimidazol-2-yl)methyl)(2-pyridylmethyl)amino]methyl}-4-t-butylphenol (2), upon sequential addition of Fe(ClO₄)₃·XH₂O and M(ClO₄)₂·6H₂O (M = Zn and Ni) or M(OAc)₂·XH₂O (M = Co and Cu), in a low-to-moderate (ca. 32-53%) yield. The temperature-dependent magnetic susceptibility measurements indicated weak antiferromagnetic coupling interactions occurring between the two metal centers in their high-spin states. All of the 3(a-b) and 4(a-b) complexes successfully carried out the hydrolysis of the bis(2,4-dinitrophenyl)phosphate (2,4-BDNPP) substrate in a mixed CH₃CN/H₂O (v/v 1:1) medium in the pH range of 5.5-10.5 at room temperature, thereby mimicking the functional activity of the native enzyme. The spectrophotometric titration suggested a monoaquated and dihydroxo species of the type {L[(H₂O)M^II(μ-OH)Fe^III(OH)]}²⁺ to be the catalytically active species for the phosphodiester hydrolysis reaction within the pH range of ca. 5.80-7.15. Last, the kinetic studies on the hydrolysis of the model substrate, 2,4-BDNPP, divulge a Michaelis-Menten-type behavior for all complexes.

Synthesis and characterization of FeIII(μ-OH)ZnII complexes: effects of a second coordination sphere and increase in the chelate ring size on the hydrolysis of a phosphate diester and DNA

Effects of a second coordination sphere and of the chelate ring size in Fe^III(μ-OH)Zn^II complexes properties and catalysis.

Metallohydrolase biomimetics with catalytic and structural flexibility

The phosphatase activity of zinc complexes containing six- and seven-dentate ligands was evaluated through kinetic and³¹P NMR studies.

Role of para-substitution in controlling phosphatase activity of dinuclear NiII complexes of Mannich-base ligands: experimental and DFT studies

Five dinuclear Ni^II complexes synthesized by Mannich reaction portray remarkable phosphatase activity where the tert-butyl complex exhibits the maximum reactivity.