Uncovering Heavy Actinide Covalency: Implications for Minor Actinide Partitioning

Understanding covalency in molecular f-block compounds from the synergy of spectroscopy and quantum chemistry

One of the most intensely studied areas of f-block chemistry is the nature of the bonds between the f-element and another species, and in particular the role played by covalency. Computational quantum chemical methods have been at the forefront of this research for decades and have a particularly valuable role, given the radioactivity of the actinide series. The very strong agreement that has recently emerged between theory and the results of a range of spectroscopic techniques not only facilitates deeper insight into the experimental data, but it also provides confidence in the conclusions from the computational studies. These synergies are shining new light on the nature of the f element-other element bond.

Alkyl Coordination in meso-(ONO)2- Supported Uranium(IV) Complexes

A series of U(IV) complexes bearing alkyl and chloride ligands in the trans configuration was synthesized and characterized. Starting with the diastereopure U(IV) trans-dichloride complex meso-( tBu2PONO)UCl2(dtbpy) (1, tBu2PONO = 2,6-bis((di-tert-butylphosphino)methanolato)pyridine), four distinct alkyl groups were employed to prepare ( tBu2PONO)U(R)Cl(dtbpy), where R = (trimethylsilyl)methyl (neosilyl), 2a, R = 2,2-dimethyl propyl (neopentyl), 2b, and R = 2-methyl-2-phenyl propyl (neophyl), 2c. Alkylation occurs with specificity but generates a predominant species and a minor species corresponding to anti/syn regioisomers relative to the tBu2P groups of the ligand. For synthesis using R = methyl, the dimethyl complex ( tBu2PONO)U(Me)2(dtbpy), 2d, was prepared; the addition of 1 equiv of MeLi produced a mixture of products. Complexes 2a-2d were characterized using single crystal X-ray diffraction (SC-XRD), UV-vis-nIR, and 1H and 31P NMR spectroscopies.

Bonding and Magnetic Trends in the [AnIII(DPA)3]3- Series Compared to the Ln(III) and An(IV) Analogues

The crystal field parameters are determined from first-principles calculations in the [AnIII(DPA)3]3- series, completing previous work on the [LnIII(DPA)3]3- and [AnIV(DPA)3]2- series. The crystal field strength parameter follows the Ln(III) < An(III) < An(IV) trend. The parameters deduced at the orbital level decrease along the series, while J-mixing strongly impacts the many-electron parameters, especially for the Pu(III) complex. We further compile the available data for the three series. In some aspects, An(III) complexes are closer to Ln(III) than to An(IV) complexes with regard to the geometrical structure and bonding descriptors. At the beginning of the series, up to Pu(III), there is a quantitative departure from the free ion, especially for the Pa(III) complex. The magnetic properties of the actinides keep the trends of the lanthanides; in particular, the axial magnetic susceptibility follows Bleaney's theory qualitatively.

Theoretical Study on the Coordination and Separation Capacity of Macrocyclic N-Donor Extractants for Am(III)/Eu(III)

Designing ligands that can effectively separate actinide An(III)/lanthanide Ln(III) in the solvent extraction process remains one of the key issues in the treatment of accumulated spent nuclear fuel. Nitrogen donor ligands are considered as promising extractants for the separation of An(III) and Ln(III) due to their environmental friendliness. Four new macrocyclic N-donor hexadentate extractants were designed and their coordination with Am(III) and Eu(III), as well as their extraction selectivity and separation performance for Am(III) and Eu(III), were investigated by scalar relativistic density functional theory. A variety of theoretical methods have been used to evaluate the properties of the four ligands and the coordination structures, bonding properties, and thermodynamic properties of the complexes formed by the four ligands with Am(III) and Eu(III). The results of various wavefunction analysis methods including NBO analysis, quantum theory of atoms in molecules (QTAIM) analysis, and so on show that Am(III) has a stronger coordination ability with the ligands than Eu(III) due to the Am 5f orbitals more involved in bonding with the ligands than the Eu 4f orbitals, and the bonding environment of the N-donor in the ligand has a significant effect on its coordination ability of the metal ions. Thermodynamic analysis of the solvent extraction process shows that all of the four N-containing macrocyclic ligands have good extraction selectivity and separation performance for Am(III) and Eu(III). This study provides theoretical support for designing potential nitrogen-containing macrocyclic extractants with excellent separation performance.

Insight into the Structural and Emissive Behavior of a Three-Dimensional Americium(III) Formate Coordination Polymer

We report the structural, vibrational, and optical properties of americium formate (Am(CHO2 )3 ) crystals synthesized via the in situ hydrolysis of dimethylformamide (DMF). The coordination polymer features Am3+ ions linked by formate ligands into a three-dimensional network that is isomorphous to several lanthanide analogs, (e. g., Eu3+ , Nd3+ , Tb3+ ). Structure determination revealed a nine-coordinate Am3+ metal center that features a unique local C3v symmetry. The metal-ligand bonding interactions were investigated by vibrational spectroscopy, natural localized molecular orbital calculations, and the quantum theory of atoms in molecules. The results paint a predominantly ionic bond picture and suggest the metal-oxygen bonds increase in strength from Nd-O Collapse

Key Words

• americium
• coordination polymers
• metal-organic frameworks
• photoluminescence
• transuranic

Collapse

MESH Headings Collapse

Grants

• S10 OD024973 NIH HHS
• 2018/07308-4 Fundação de Amparo à Pesquisa do Estado de São Paulo
• 306844/2020-6 CnPq
• FWP 73200, DE-SC0001136 Basic Energy Sciences

Collapse

Affiliation(s)

Aaron D Nicholas Pacific Northwest National Laboratory, 902 Battelle Boulevard, Richland, WA, 99354, USA
Ana Arteaga Pacific Northwest National Laboratory, 902 Battelle Boulevard, Richland, WA, 99354, USA
Lucas C Ducati Department of Fundamental Chemistry Institute of Chemistry, University of São Paulo, Av. Prof. Lineu Prestes 748, São Paulo, 05508-000, Brazil
Edgar C Buck Pacific Northwest National Laboratory, 902 Battelle Boulevard, Richland, WA, 99354, USA
Jochen Autschbach Department of Chemistry, University at Buffalo State University of New York, Buffalo, NY, 14260-3000, USA
Robert G Surbella Pacific Northwest National Laboratory, 902 Battelle Boulevard, Richland, WA, 99354, USA

Collapse

Theoretical Study of Complexes of Tetravalent Actinides with DOTA

1,4,7,10-Tetraazacyclododecane-N,N′,N″,N‴-tetraacetic acid (H4DOTA) is a prominent chelating ligand with potential applications in various fields, from radiotherapy to the separation of fission products. The present study explores the stability, structure, and bonding properties of its complexes with tetravalent actinides (An = Th, U, Np, Pu) using density functional theory and relativistic multireference calculations. Neutral complexes prefer to form symmetric (C4) structures with DOTA. The first coordination sphere of the actinide ions is readily saturated by a weakly bonded H2O ligand. The latter ligand reduces the molecular symmetry while exerting only marginal effects on the properties of the parent complex. An-ligand bonding is mainly electrostatic, but there are also significant charge-transfer contributions from DOTA to the An 6d/5f orbitals. The charge-transfer interactions and the covalent character of bonding increase gradually in the order of Th < U < Np < Pu, as indicated by analysis of the electron density distribution using the Quantum Theory of Atoms in Molecules.

Transuranium Sulfide via the Boron Chalcogen Mixture Method and Reversible Water Uptake in the NaCuTS3 Family

The behavior of 5f electrons in soft ligand environments makes actinides, and especially transuranium chalcogenides, an intriguing class of materials for fundamental studies. Due to the affinity of actinides for oxygen, however, it is a challenge to synthesize actinide chalcogenides using non-metallic reagents. Using the boron chalcogen mixture method, we achieved the synthesis of the transuranium sulfide NaCuNpS₃ starting from the oxide reagent, NpO₂. Via the same synthetic route, the isostructural composition of NaCuUS₃ was synthesized and the material contrasted with NaCuNpS₃. Single crystals of the U-analogue, NaCuUS₃, were found to undergo an unexpected reversible hydration process to form NaCuUS₃·xH₂O (x ≈ 1.5). A large combination of techniques was used to fully characterize the structure, hydration process, and electronic structures, specifically a combination of single crystal, powder, high temperature powder X-ray diffraction, extended X-ray absorption fine structure, infrared, and inductively coupled plasma spectroscopies, thermogravimetric analysis, and density functional theory calculations. The outcome of these analyses enabled us to determine the composition of NaCuUS₃·xH₂O and obtain a structural model that demonstrated the retention of the local structure within the [CuUS₃]^- layers throughout the hydration-dehydration process. Band structure, density of states, and Bader charge calculations for NaCuUS₃, NaCuUS₃·xH₂O, and NaCuNpS₃ along with X-ray absorption near edge structure, UV-vis-NIR, and work function measurements on ACuUS₃ (A = Na, K, and Rb) and NaCuUS₃·xH₂O samples were carried out to demonstrate that electronic properties arise from the [CuTS₃]^- layers and show surprisingly little dependence on the interlayer distance.

Ligand-Induced U Mobilization from Chemogenic Uraninite and Biogenic Noncrystalline U(IV) under Anoxic Conditions

Microbial reduction of soluble hexavalent uranium (U(VI)) to sparingly soluble tetravalent uranium (U(IV)) has been explored as an in situ strategy to immobilize U. Organic ligands might pose a potential hindrance to the success of such remediation efforts. In the current study, a set of structurally diverse organic ligands were shown to enhance the dissolution of crystalline uraninite (UO₂) for a wide range of ligand concentrations under anoxic conditions at pH 7.0. Comparisons were made to ligand-induced U mobilization from noncrystalline U(IV). For both U phases, aqueous U concentrations remained low in the absence of organic ligands (<25 nM for UO₂; 300 nM for noncrystalline U(IV)). The tested organic ligands (2,6-pyridinedicarboxylic acid (DPA), desferrioxamine B (DFOB), N,N'-di(2-hydroxybenzyl)ethylene-diamine-N,N'-diacetic acid (HBED), and citrate) enhanced U mobilization to varying extents. Over 45 days, the ligands mobilized only up to 0.3% of the 370 μM UO₂, while a much larger extent of the 300 μM of biomass-bound noncrystalline U(IV) was mobilized (up to 57%) within only 2 days (>500 times more U mobilization). This work shows the potential of numerous organic ligands present in the environment to mobilize both recalcitrant and labile U forms under anoxic conditions to hazardous levels and, in doing so, undermine the stability of immobilized U(IV) sources.

Theoretical Insights into the Selective Separation of Am(III)/Eu(III) Using Hydrophilic Triazolyl-Based Ligands

Designing ligands with efficient actinide (An(III))/lanthanide (Ln(III)) separation performance is still one of the key issues for the disposal of accumulated radioactive waste and the recovery of minor actinides. Recently, the hydrophilic ligands as promising extractants in the innovative Selective ActiNide Extraction (i-SANEX) process show excellent selectivity for Am(III) over Eu(III), such as hydroxylated-based ligands. In this work, we investigated the selective back-extraction toward Am(III) over Eu(III) with three hydrophilic hydroxylated triazolyl-based ligands (the skeleton of pyridine L^a, bipyridine L^b, and phenanthroline L^c) using scalar-relativistic density functional theory. The properties of three hydrophilic hydroxylated ligands and the coordination structures, bonding nature, and thermodynamic properties of the Am(III) and Eu(III) complexes with three ligands have been evaluated using multiple theoretical methods. The results of molecular orbitals (MOs), quantum theory of atoms in molecules (QTAIMs), and natural bond orbital (NBO) reveal that Am-N bonds possess more covalent character compared to Eu-N bonds. The thermodynamic results indicate that the complexing ability of L^b and L^c with metal ions is almost the same, which is stronger than that of L^a. However, L^a has the best Am(III)/Eu(III) selectivity among three ligands, which is attributed to the largest difference in covalency between Am-N_trzl and Eu-N_trzl bonds in ML^a(NO₃)₃. This work provides an in-depth understanding of the preferential selectivity of the hydrophilic hydroxylated ligands with An(III) over Ln(III) and also provides theoretical support for designing potential hydrophilic ligands with excellent separation performance of Am(III)/Eu(III).

Selective Separation of Am(III)/Eu(III) by the QL-DAPhen Ligand under High Acidity: Extraction, Spectroscopy, and Theoretical Calculations

Although 1,10-phenanthroline-based ligands have recently shown vast opportunities for the separation of trivalent actinides (Ans(III)) from lanthanides (Lns(III)), the optimization and design of the extractant structure based on the phenanthroline framework remain hotspots for further improving the separation. Following the strategy of hard and soft donor atom combination, for the first time, the quinoline group was attached to the 1,10-phenanthroline skeleton, giving a lipophilic ligand, 2,9-diacyl-bis((3,4-dihydroquinoline-1((2H)-yl)-1),10-phenanthroline (QL-DAPhen)), for Am(III)/Eu(III) separation. In the presence of sodium nitrate, the ligand can effectively extract Am(III) over Eu(III) in HNO₃ solution, with the separation factor (SF_Am/Eu) ranging from 29 to 44. The coordination chemistry of Eu(III) with QL-DAPhen was investigated by slope analysis, NMR titration, UV-vis titration, Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy, electrospray ionization-mass spectrometry, and theoretical calculations. The experimental results unanimously confirm that the ligand forms both 1:1 and 1:2 complexes with Eu(III), and the stability constants (log β) of each of the two complexes were obtained. Density functional theory calculations show that the Am-N bonds have more covalent characteristics than the Eu-N bonds in the complexes, which reveals the reason why the ligand preferentially bonds with Am(III). Meanwhile, the thermodynamic analysis reveals that the 1:1 complex is more thermodynamically stable than the 1:2 complex. The findings of this work have laid a solid theoretical foundation for the application of phenanthroline-based ligands in the separation of An(III) from practical systems.

Covalency of Trivalent Actinide Ions with Different Donor Ligands: Do Density Functional and Multiconfigurational Wavefunction Calculations Corroborate the Observed "Breaks"?

A comprehensive ab initio study of periodic actinide-ligand bonding trends for trivalent actinides is performed. Relativistic density functional theory (DFT) and complete active-space (CAS) self-consistent field wavefunction calculations are used to dissect the chemical bonding in the [AnCl₆]^3-, [An(CN)₆]^3-, [An(NCS)₆]^3-, [An(S₂PMe₂)₃], [An(DPA)₃]^3-, and [An(HOPO)]^- series of actinide (An = U-Es) complexes. Except for some differences for the early actinide complexes with DPA, bond orders and excess 5f-shell populations from donation bonding show qualitatively similar trends in 5f ⁿ active-space CAS vs DFT calculations. The influence of spin-orbit coupling on donation bonding is small for the tested systems. Along the actinide series, chemically soft vs chemically harder ligands exhibit clear differences in bonding trends. There are pronounced changes in the 5f populations when moving from Pu to Am or Cm, which correlate with previously noted "breaks" in chemical trends. Bonding involving 5f becomes very weak beyond Cm/Bk. We propose that Cm(III) is a borderline case among the trivalent actinides that can be meaningfully considered to be involved in ground-state 5f covalent bonding.

Improving the theoretical description of Ln(III)/An(III) separation with phosphinic acid ligands: a benchmarking study of structure and selectivity

The efficient separation of trivalent lanthanides from minor actinides with soft-donor ligands, while showing experimental promise, has theorists continuing to search for suitable approaches for describing and interpreting selectivity. To remedy this, we employ several computational methods in describing the structure of model M(H₂PX₂)₃ complexes, with M = Eu and Am, and X = O, S, Se, and Te, and predicting the selectivity of model phosphinic acid ligands in Eu(III)/Am(III) separation. After first establishing a set of MP2 and CCSD(T)-DKH3 results as benchmarks, we evaluate several density functionals and descriptions of valence shells for their accuracy with respect to metal-ligand bonding and selectivity. We find that commonly employed functionals with a 0-27% range of exact exchange used with small-core effective core potentials or with an explicit treatment of the relativistic effects (DKH2) incorrectly predict a decrease in the metal-ligand bond distance in going from Eu(III) to Am(III) and completely fail to track a selectivity trend, even giving a wrong sign for some or all ligands. Surprisingly, when these functionals are used in conjunction with an f-in-core description of metal ions, the correct trend in selectivity is recovered, though Am-X distances are overestimated in relation to Eu-X. Functionals with high components of exact exchange (50%) and double-hybrid functionals are reasonably aligned with benchmark results, pointing to the problems of DFT with small exact exchange fractions to handle f-electrons. Natural bond orbital analyses reveal that these poorly performing functionals disproportionately overpopulate outer f orbitals in the model complexes. We anticipate that recommendations resulting from this work will lead to more accurate theoretical descriptions of lanthanide/actinide selectivity with soft-donor chalcogen-based ligands in the future.

Theoretical Study of Actinide(III)-DOTA Complexes

1,4,7,10-Tetraazacyclododecane-N,N',N″,N‴-tetraacetic acid (DOTA) is a prominent chelating ligand used in imaging contrast agents and radiopharmaceuticals. The present study explores the stabilities, structures, and bonding properties of its complexes with trivalent actinides (Ac, U, Np, Pu, Am, Cm, Cf) using density functional theory and relativistic multireference calculations. For reference purposes, the La- and Lu-DOTA complexes are also included. Similar to La3+, the large An3+ ions prefer the TSAP conformer of the ligand. The An-ligand bonding is mainly electrostatic, with minor charge transfer contributions to the An 6d orbitals. For the assessment of the thermodynamic stabilities in aqueous solution, PCM radii to use in conjunction with the SMD solvation model were developed. Basically, the thermodynamic stability of the DOTA complexes increases along the An row but with notable counteracting of spin-orbit coupling.

Hydrophilic Sulfonated 2,9-Diamide-1,10-phenanthroline Endowed with a Highly Effective Ligand for Separation of Americium(III) from Europium(III): Extraction, Spectroscopy, and Density Functional Theory Calculations

The design and development of a water-soluble heterocyclic ligand are believed to be an alternative way for improving the separation efficiency of actinides from lanthanides. Herein, we designed and synthesized a novel hydrophilic multidentate ligand: disulfonated N,N'-diphenyl-2,9-diamide-1,10-phenanthroline (DS-Ph-DAPhen) with soft and hard donor atoms, as a masking agent in aqueous solutions for Am(III) separation. The combination of N,N,N',N'-tetraoctyldiglycolamide in kerosene and DS-Ph-DAPhen in aqueous phases could separate Am(III) from Eu(III) across a range of nitric acid concentrations with very high selectivity. The coordination behaviors of Eu(III) with DS-Ph-DAPhen in aqueous solutions were studied by UV-vis titration, electrospray ionization mass spectrometry, and Fourier transform infrared spectra. The results indicated that Eu(III) ions could form both 1:1 and 1:2 complexes with the DS-Ph-DAPhen ligand in aqueous solution. Density functional theory calculation suggests that there are more covalent characters for Am-N bonds than that for Eu-N bonds in the complexes, which supports the better selectivity of the DS-Ph-DAPhen ligand toward Am(III) over Eu(III). This work demonstrates a feasible alternative approach to separating trivalent actinides from lanthanides with high selectivity.

Theoretical Study of Actinide Complexes with Macropa

The complex formation of actinium (Ac³⁺) and californium (Cf³⁺) ions with macropa (a promising ligand for medical applications, e.g., in targeted α therapy) has been studied by means of density functional theory (DFT) calculations. This work is focused on the structural and bonding properties, the latter on the basis of charge transfer data and topological properties of the electron density distribution. The effect of water solvent on the energetics has been investigated using the SMD model. A comparative analysis with the related properties of two representative lanthanide (La, Lu) complexes has been performed.

Theoretical Prediction of the Potential Applications of Phenanthroline Derivatives in Separation of Transplutonium Elements

Recovery of transplutonium elements from adjacent actinides is extremely complicated in spent fuel reprocessing. Uncovering the electronic structures of transplutonium compounds is essential for designing robust ligands for in-group separation of transplutonium actinides. Here, we demonstrate the in-group transplutonium actinides separation ability of the recent developed phenanthroline ligand Et-Tol-DAPhen (N²,N⁹-diethyl-N²,N⁹-di-p-tolyl-1,10-phenanthroline-2,9-dicarboxamide, L_a) and its derivatives (5-bromo-(N²,N⁹-diethyl-N²,N⁹-di-p-tolyl-1,10-phenanthroline-2,9-dicarboxamide, L_b), and 5-(4-(λ¹-oxidaneyl)phenyl)-(N²,N⁹-diethyl-N²,N⁹-di-p-tolyl-1,10-phenanthroline-2,9- dicarboxamide, L_c) through quasi-relativistic density functional theory (DFT). Both electrostatic potential and molecular orbital analyses of the ligands indicate that the electron-donating group substituted ligand L_c is a better electron donor to actinides than L_a and L_b. The possible extracted complexes AnL(NO₃)₃ and [AnL₂(NO₃)]²⁺ (L = L_a, L_b, L_c; An = Am, Cm, Bk, Cf) possess similar structures. Bonding nature analysis validates that the covalent interactions of the metal-ligand bonds are enhanced across actinide series from Am to Cf, which stem from the energy degeneracy of the 5f orbitals of actinides and the 2p orbitals of the ligand coordinating atoms. The L_c ligand displays slightly stronger covalent bonding compared to the other two ligands. Simultaneously, thermodynamic analysis confirms the stronger metal-ligand bonding of the Cf³⁺ complexes and the higher stability of the extraction species with L_c. Consequently, the covalency between the DAPhen derivatives and transplutonium actinides seems to be positively correlated with the extraction ability of these ligands. Nevertheless, these ligands exhibit diverse separation abilities to in-group actinide recovery. Therefore, the enhancement of covalency does not necessarily lead to the improvement of separation ability due to different extraction capabilities. We hope that these results will provide some inspiration for designing novel ligands for in-group transplutonium separation.

Lanthanide and actinide doped B12H122- and Al12H122- clusters: new magnetic superatoms with f-block elements

In recent years, actinide containing clusters have attracted immense attention because of the distinctive bonding properties of their 5f and 6d electrons. In this context, in the present work, we have studied the isoelectronic series of actinide (An = Np⁺, Pu²⁺, Am³⁺) doped B₁₂H₁₂^2- and Al₁₂H₁₂^2- clusters using density functional theory (DFT). Similarly, corresponding isoelectronic lanthanide (Ln = Pm⁺, Sm²⁺, Eu³⁺) doped clusters are also investigated using DFT for comparison. Both exohedral and endohedral metal doped Al₁₂H₁₂^2- clusters are investigated in various possible spin states, whereas for B₁₂H₁₂^2- only exohedral metal doped clusters are studied due to its smaller cage diameter. Among all the metal doped clusters, the exohedral metal doped B₁₂H₁₂^2- and Al₁₂H₁₂^2- clusters in a septet spin state with retained high spin population on the doped actinide ion, are the most stable, indicating that all these doped clusters are magnetic in nature. The high stability of exohedral clusters is due to small steric repulsion as compared to that in the corresponding endohedral clusters. A prominent charge transfer from cage to metal ion is responsible for the strong interaction of the doped metal ion with the cage atoms. The studied Ln@B₁₂H₁₂^2- (Ln@Al₁₂H₁₂^2-) and An@B₁₂H₁₂^2- (An@Al₁₂H₁₂^2-) clusters are not only thermodynamically stable, but also kinetically stable. Metal ion encapsulated endohedral Al₁₂H₁₂^2- clusters are found to satisfy the 32-electron principle corresponding to the completely filled s, p, d and f shells of the central f-block atom. Theoretical predictions of these lanthanide and actinide doped stable B₁₂H₁₂^2- and Al₁₂H₁₂^2- clusters could encourage experimentalists for the preparation of these metal-doped clusters. Thus, the present work offers borane and alane clusters as new hosts for encapsulating radioactive actinides. Furthermore, various functional derivatives of these actinide doped B₁₂H₁₂^2- clusters may find applications in the field of radiation medicine.

Sequestration of trivalent americium and lanthanide nitrates with bis-lactam-1,10-phenanthroline ligand in a hydrocarbon solvent

Efficient separation of minor actinides and lanthanides from used nuclear fuel could potentially lead to the development of sustainable nuclear fuel cycles. Herein, we report an in-depth study on selectivity and speciation in the extraction of the trivalent minor actinide Am and rare earth metal ions with a pre-organized phenanthroline-based ligand in a hydrocarbon solvent system relevant to nuclear fuel reprocessing. The 1 : 1 and 2 : 1 ligand-to-metal complexes dominate the speciation in the organic solvent over a range of ligand-to-metal concentrations, as evidenced by experimental data and supported by modeling.

Efficient separation of trivalent americium and light lanthanides from aqueous acidic medium into hydrocarbon solvent using BLPhen extractant.